BBC News
How lamp-posts could help fix bad phone signal
Cambridgeshire
-a-a-a Published
-a-a-a 7 minutes ago
In a time when we rely so much on our mobile phones, it can be
frustrating when you cannot find good signal. In some towns and cities
with so-called notspots - areas with patchy, slow, or missing network coverage - a type of technology involving lamp-posts could help
eradicate the issue.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
On 02/09/2026 06:11, JMB99 wrote:
BBC News
How lamp-posts could help fix bad phone signal
Cambridgeshire
-a-a-a-a Published
-a-a-a-a 7 minutes ago
In a time when we rely so much on our mobile phones, it can be
frustrating when you cannot find good signal. In some towns and cities
with so-called notspots - areas with patchy, slow, or missing network
coverage - a type of technology involving lamp-posts could help
eradicate the issue.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
I am not sure how this is "news" but its reassuring to know that they
have a grip of the problem, as demonstrated by the dazzling observation that: -
"One way to improve mobile signal is to install more masts"
Its the same in France. If the signal is poor* then go sit outside the Mairie's (mayor's) office or outside the Tourist Information bureau.
Both of those usually have free wifi around the building. The only catch
is that the Mairie's office signal is likely on Orange France and is
limited to port 80 - i.e. browser surfing. You cannot even check your emails. The TI systems are usually wide open.
*You will rarely have a problem with lack of signal in Europe as your
phone will use whichever system it can find.
Its the same in France. If the signal is poor* then go sit outside the
Mairie's (mayor's) office or outside the Tourist Information bureau.
Both of those usually have free wifi around the building. The only catch
is that the Mairie's office signal is likely on Orange France and is
limited to port 80 - i.e. browser surfing. You cannot even check your
emails. The TI systems are usually wide open.
I cant see you doing a lot of browser surfing on port 80 in the land of https
*You will rarely have a problem with lack of signal in Europe as your
phone will use whichever system it can find.
the brutal truth is ... that the lack of mobile phone coverage in
almost any spot in any town in the UK is simply because the potential revenue generated from it will not cover the costs - although I will
admit that pompous. arrogant power mad planning "officers" have their
part to play in this pantomime
I suspect that this problem is only going to get worse
The "technology" to provide it has been available for more than 25 years
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 06:11:20 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
[snip]
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremoWhat about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
How do you calculate the revenue generated by a cell? Revenue is largely
via contract income (pre or post pay). Operating a cell site is a cost. In the limit, providing no sites will mean no paying customers. But will
having poor coverage in the middle of Ely really impact revenue? In other words, what is the incentive for the three operators to fix the problem?
How do you calculate the revenue generated by a cell? Revenue is largely
via contract income (pre or post pay). Operating a cell site is a cost. In >> the limit, providing no sites will mean no paying customers. But will
having poor coverage in the middle of Ely really impact revenue? In other
words, what is the incentive for the three operators to fix the problem?
Well ... long ago and far away, people used to pay for every call they
made, so it was a lot easier
You can get some clues from the number of calls / connections which are dropped by adjacent cells
Back to the bit where I said "I suspect that this problem is only going
to get worse" ... :-\
Few people realise that if the general signal coverage in a town centre is
a problem, the shop of each of the service providers will likely have a picocell inside it to ensure that prospective phone buyers can test their phone before purchase.
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 06:11:20 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote: [snip]
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being irradiated
by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a thing of the past?
In message <p1qf9ltsoveeg61mq01boo1avddkvujfs5@4ax.com>
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 06:11:20 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote: [snip]
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremoWhat about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being irradiated
by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a thing of the past?
It damned well should have become a thing of the past, because it was
never a fact.
Not helpful if you live in a village (as many of us do) that doesn't have
any such shop.
Few people realise that if the general signal coverage in a town centre
is a problem, the shop of each of the service providers will likely have
a picocell inside it to ensure that prospective phone buyers can test
their phone before purchase.
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
On 02/09/2026 10:13, Scott wrote:
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
Whilst the pedestrians are holding a radio transmitter to the side of
the head producing higher RF levels there than there is from the mobile >phone transmitters!
On 02/09/2026 15:26, David Higton wrote:
Not helpful if you live in a village (as many of us do) that doesn't have any such shop.
How many villages with no shops?
Obviously there are some but not going to be many pedestrians (and mobile phone owning dogs) around.
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 19:49:48 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 02/09/2026 10:13, Scott wrote:Have handsets not generally moved away from the side of the head?
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
Whilst the pedestrians are holding a radio transmitter to the side of
the head producing higher RF levels there than there is from the mobile
phone transmitters!
Equally annoying though is people who walk around with BT earbuds and in conversation. It only needs one not to hear an approaching bus behind them....................
Equally annoying though is people who walk around with BT earbuds
and in conversation. It only needs one not to hear an approaching
bus behind them....................
Darwin Award contestants ?
BBC News
How lamp-posts could help fix bad phone signal
Cambridgeshire
Published 7 minutes ago
In a time when we rely so much on our mobile phones, it can be
frustrating when you cannot find good signal. In some towns and cities
with so-called notspots - areas with patchy, slow, or missing network coverage - a type of technology involving lamp-posts could help
eradicate the issue.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> writes:
BBC News
How lamp-posts could help fix bad phone signal
Cambridgeshire
Published 7 minutes ago
In a time when we rely so much on our mobile phones, it can be
frustrating when you cannot find good signal. In some towns and cities
with so-called notspots - areas with patchy, slow, or missing network
coverage - a type of technology involving lamp-posts could help
eradicate the issue.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm2rne4gremo
My mobile phone coverage at home is kindly provided by me via my
wi-fi. This allows me to pay two different companies for the same thing.
On 02/09/2026 15:26, David Higton wrote:
Not helpful if you live in a village (as many of us do) that doesn't have any such shop.
How many villages with no shops?
Equally annoying though is people who walk around with BT earbuds and in conversation. It only needs one not to hear an approaching bus behind them....................
On 03/09/2026 04:24, Woody wrote:
Equally annoying though is people who walk around with BT earbuds and in
conversation. It only needs one not to hear an approaching bus behind
them....................
I believe getting out a notebook and writing down everything they say, can be a good deterrent.
*You will rarely have a problem with lack of signal in Europe as your
phone will use whichever system it can find.
Few people realise that if the general signal coverage in a town centre
is a problem, the shop of each of the service providers will likely have
a picocell inside it to ensure that prospective phone buyers can test
their phone before purchase.
Aren't there companies that earn their living by providing mobile phone coverage inside large stores and malls?
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
mostly ..... yes
Yes. Agreed. But...
Let's say there is a tower, and then high tension lines, and a tower.
CELLTOWER ....... perpendicular high tension lines...... CELLTOWER
I wonder if there's a measurable re-radiation loss of signal dBm
due to the huge passive omni antenna in the middle of the two towers?
1. Scattering/re-radiation
2. Multi-path interference
REFERENCES:
Scattering Characteristics of VHF/UHF Television Broadcasting Waves
by Overhead Power Transmission Conductors
<https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1871146593101257984>
Abandoned Trolley wrote:
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
mostly ..... yes
Yes. Agreed. But...
Let's say there is a tower, and then high tension lines, and a tower.
CELLTOWER ....... perpendicular high tension lines...... CELLTOWER
I wonder if there's a measurable re-radiation loss of signal dBm
due to the huge passive omni antenna in the middle of the two towers?
1. Scattering/re-radiation
2. Multi-path interference
REFERENCES:
Scattering Characteristics of VHF/UHF Television Broadcasting Waves
by Overhead Power Transmission Conductors <https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1871146593101257984>
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 19:49:48 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 02/09/2026 10:13, Scott wrote:Have handsets not generally moved away from the side of the head?
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
Whilst the pedestrians are holding a radio transmitter to the side of
the head producing higher RF levels there than there is from the mobile >>phone transmitters!
On Wed 02/09/2026 19:55, Scott wrote:
On Wed, 2 Sep 2026 19:49:48 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 02/09/2026 10:13, Scott wrote:Have handsets not generally moved away from the side of the head?
What about all the complaints about pedestrians and dogs being
irradiated by electro magnetic radiation, or has this now become a
thing of the past?
Whilst the pedestrians are holding a radio transmitter to the side of
the head producing higher RF levels there than there is from the mobile
phone transmitters!
Given the number of people you see holding their phone horizontally in
front of them and loudspeaker on, there's no wonder that phone theft is >through the roof. If they think that holding the phone at the side of
their head is dangerous then they should not use a mobile phone at all.
Equally annoying though is people who walk around with BT earbuds and in >conversation. It only needs one not to hear an approaching bus behind >them....................
Abandoned Trolley <that.bloke@microsoft.com> wrote:
How do you calculate the revenue generated by a cell? Revenue is largely >>> via contract income (pre or post pay). Operating a cell site is a cost. In >>> the limit, providing no sites will mean no paying customers. But will
having poor coverage in the middle of Ely really impact revenue? In other >>> words, what is the incentive for the three operators to fix the problem? >>>
Well ... long ago and far away, people used to pay for every call they
made, so it was a lot easier
You can get some clues from the number of calls / connections which are
dropped by adjacent cells
Back to the bit where I said "I suspect that this problem is only going
to get worse" ... :-\
Presumably EE are going to have to provide coverage for the Emergency Services Network? So will that see an improvement for commercial customers
as a side effect?
On 2 Sep 2026 09:51, Tweed wrote:
Abandoned Trolley <that.bloke@microsoft.com> wrote:
How do you calculate the revenue generated by a cell? Revenue is largely >>>> via contract income (pre or post pay). Operating a cell site is a cost. In >>>> the limit, providing no sites will mean no paying customers. But will
having poor coverage in the middle of Ely really impact revenue? In other >>>> words, what is the incentive for the three operators to fix the problem? >>>>
Well ... long ago and far away, people used to pay for every call they
made, so it was a lot easier
You can get some clues from the number of calls / connections which are
dropped by adjacent cells
Back to the bit where I said "I suspect that this problem is only going
to get worse" ... :-\
Presumably EE are going to have to provide coverage for the Emergency
Services Network? So will that see an improvement for commercial customers >> as a side effect?
I don't think you will always get APNs beyond the ESN APN. This might
be because of limited backhaul or landlord issues.
Maybe not everywhere, but the ESN rollout seems to be behind EE signal becoming available in the Clyde Tunnel and the Glasgow Subway. Vodafone arenrCOt there yet. Likewise the HS1 tunnels coming out of St Pancras. The London Tube is, of course, provided with a multi operator signal.
because of limited backhaul or landlord issues.
Maybe not everywhere, but the ESN rollout seems to be behind EE signal
becoming available in the Clyde Tunnel and the Glasgow Subway. Vodafone
arenrCOt there yet. Likewise the HS1 tunnels coming out of St Pancras. The >> London Tube is, of course, provided with a multi operator signal.
More than 50 years ago, part of the London tube was equipped with
driver/ controller comms using Storno VHF walkie talkie kit. It was OK
in the tunnels but there was quite a bit of interference from unlicensed taxis out on the overground sections.
Coverage in the tunnels was provided by a continuous leaky feeder from
the base station, so its quite surprising that it took so long to get
phone coverage down there
Coverage in the tunnels was provided by a continuous leaky feeder from
the base station, so its quite surprising that it took so long to get
phone coverage down there
I donrCOt think the antenna system is what holds them back. ItrCOs finding room
for all the associated equipment and getting that plumbed in. IrCOve been on a few Hidden London tours where you get to go down some of the disused bits of stations. You see new racks squeezed in amongst all the other stuff. ThererCOs an awful lot of cables, old and new down there. ItrCOs not like a shiny data centre.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 58:18:23 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,959 |