• Stupid question are BT still going toi be charginh line rentalm after Jan 31st ?

    From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Oct 26 21:58:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.


    bb



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Oct 26 22:23:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 26/10/2026 21:58, billy bookcase wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?


    If you have phone service from BT then you pay a line rental.

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Well that has being going on for a while, as folks ditch land lines.
    If you retain a copper service the rental actually rises.
    Some of the income is replaced as they sell the copper for scrap.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.


    Yes those who take a phone package pay a "line rental"


    bb


    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Theo@theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Oct 26 23:07:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of
    the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no
    matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or
    will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    If you took phone service and DSL from different providers, the phone part might have been called 'line rental' but it was simply the part of the
    monthly payment you made to the phone provider. If you had no phone
    service, it was just part of your broadband bill instead.

    Theo
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 27 08:17:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    billy bookcase wrote:

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Not for a "phone line" the rental will be hidden within your broadband cost.

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.
    You got it ...

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tweed@usenet.tweed@gmail.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 27 09:20:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    billy bookcase wrote:

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Not for a "phone line" the rental will be hidden within your broadband cost.

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.
    You got it ...

    Whichever way you look at it, after introductory discounts have expired,
    you will be paying at least -u30/month.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 09:43:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message news:U8s*iD-TA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or
    will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    So I am still going to have to pay BT u31 a month line rental
    no matter what VOIP provider I go with ?

    That was my question.

    If I go with Phonely they will charge around u10 a month for
    "digital line rental".

    So unles I'm still having to pay BT u31 a month on top
    then no matter what Phonely pay them that's a big loss
    of u20 a month to BT.

    The point I'm making is either this is going to cost me
    u10 a month extra to Phonely (my broadband cost will remain
    around the same) or I'm goibg to save u20 a month by not
    having to pay BT.


    bb





    If you took phone service and DSL from different providers, the phone part might have been called 'line rental' but it was simply the part of the monthly payment you made to the phone provider. If you had no phone
    service, it was just part of your broadband bill instead.

    Theo


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 09:44:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Tweed" <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote in message news:11bpqd4$1cbjh$1@dont-email.me...
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    billy bookcase wrote:

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Not for a "phone line" the rental will be hidden within your broadband cost. >>
    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.
    You got it ...

    Whichever way you look at it, after introductory discounts have expired,
    you will be paying at least u30/month.

    I'm sorry I don't follow.

    At present I'm paying u24 a month for broadband and u31 a month BT line
    rental before calls

    That's u55 a month

    I can get a broadband for around u27 a month and pay Phoneley u10 a
    month for a digital landline

    So that's u37 a month which u18 less.

    A big difference.


    bb








    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Richmond@dnomhcir@gmx.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 10:19:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    "billy bookcase" <billy@anon.com> writes:

    "Tweed" <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote in message news:11bpqd4$1cbjh$1@dont-email.me...
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    billy bookcase wrote:

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Not for a "phone line" the rental will be hidden within your broadband cost.

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.
    You got it ...

    Whichever way you look at it, after introductory discounts have expired,
    you will be paying at least -u30/month.

    I'm sorry I don't follow.

    At present I'm paying -u24 a month for broadband and -u31 a month BT line rental before calls

    That's -u55 a month

    I can get a broadband for around -u27 a month and pay Phoneley -u10 a
    month for a digital landline

    So that's -u37 a month which -u18 less.

    A big difference.


    bb






    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around -u3 to rent a telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 10:44:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Richmond wrote:

    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around -u3 to rent a telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.

    I currently pay plusnet -u28/month for part-fibre broadband and pay
    voipfone -u6/month for my original BT number and bundle of 100 minutes.

    Broadband is up for renewal next month, I'll stay with plusnet,
    depending on contract length it should go down to -u23/month (but with
    annual increases).

    I ought to swap to voipfone's "flex" option without the bundle because I hardly make any calls on the landline now ... would save about -u4/month.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Theo@theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 10:51:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:

    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message news:U8s*iD-TA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    So I am still going to have to pay BT -u31 a month line rental
    no matter what VOIP provider I go with ?

    That was my question.

    If I go with Phonely they will charge around -u10 a month for
    "digital line rental".

    So unles I'm still having to pay BT -u31 a month on top
    then no matter what Phonely pay them that's a big loss
    of -u20 a month to BT.

    The point I'm making is either this is going to cost me
    -u10 a month extra to Phonely (my broadband cost will remain
    around the same) or I'm goibg to save -u20 a month by not
    having to pay BT.

    BT are taking you for a ride. Most people are paying ~-u30 for broadband and some kind of landline phone, now implemented via VOIP over the broadband instead of analogue over the copper wires. They're not paying 'line rental'
    to BT or anyone. They might be paying an extra few pounds for some kind of monthly calls bundle, rather than the default tariff of ~20p/min + setup
    fees.

    I'm paying -u25pm for broadband (Truespeed 300Mbps FTTP) and -u1.80pm for a VOIP phone number with Andrews & Arnold. Calls are 1.5p/min landlines and 4p/min mobiles (+VAT); I don't make enough calls to make a bundle
    worthwhile (A&A don't offer bundles but Voipfone do).

    When I was on FTTC with Sky I think it was about -u26pm for broadband and phone. I didn't pay line rental to BT or anyone: Sky paid part of that -u26
    to Openreach to maintain the line (the OR wholesale pricing table is public
    if I wanted to look up how much).

    Theo
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris Green@cl@isbd.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 10:58:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    Richmond wrote:

    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around -u3 to rent a telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.

    I currently pay plusnet -u28/month for part-fibre broadband and pay
    voipfone -u6/month for my original BT number and bundle of 100 minutes.

    Yes, that's the basic mix for having a 'home phone' in the modern world
    without a 'landline'. You pay an ISP for an internet connection and, if
    you want a 'home phone' you pay a VOIP provider for that.

    If you want the 'home phone' to work during a power cut then your router
    and the phone itself need battery back-up.

    The VOIP phone can come in several different guises.
    --
    Chris Green
    -+
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Graham J@nobody@nowhere.co.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 11:36:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Chris Green wrote:
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    Richmond wrote:

    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around -u3 to rent a >>> telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.

    I currently pay plusnet -u28/month for part-fibre broadband and pay
    voipfone -u6/month for my original BT number and bundle of 100 minutes.

    Yes, that's the basic mix for having a 'home phone' in the modern world without a 'landline'. You pay an ISP for an internet connection and, if
    you want a 'home phone' you pay a VOIP provider for that.

    If you want the 'home phone' to work during a power cut then your router
    and the phone itself need battery back-up.

    The VOIP phone can come in several different guises.

    The problem - as has been discussed on the news recently - is that in
    rural areas there is no fibre, and broadband is delivered over the
    copper pair in the form of either ADSL or VDSL (aka FTTC). Your voice
    service is then carried over the broadband connection.

    However, rural areas are exactly the locations where the copper pair is
    not very good at carrying the broadband service. Both speed and
    reliability can be affected, and people's experiences vary widely from
    "never have a problem" to "virtually never works".

    Rural areas are also exactly the locations where mobile signals are weak
    or non-existent.

    By contrast, if you are lucky enough to get Fibre To The Premises
    reliability is much better, and speed is limited by the backhaul (i.e.
    your supplier) and not by the fibre itself. It does fail, and can be
    out for several days if the infrastructure has been damaged. This infrastructure includes overhead and underground "cables" as well as
    equipment failure somewhere in the network.

    I have FTTP and so far I've suffered a single outage of about 36 hours
    since it was installed in March 2023, and a handful of breaks lasting a
    few tens of seconds over the same period. These short breaks are inconsequential because the connection is restored almost immediately,
    without the need for the modem to train as was the case with ADSL and
    VDSL.

    I've experienced at least three power cuts over the same period, lasting
    from tens of minutes up to several hours. The last major power failure
    was about 6 days because of the storm in October 1987.
    --
    Graham J
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From JMB99@mb@nospam.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 14:14:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 28/10/2026 11:36, Graham J wrote:
    However, rural areas are exactly the locations where the copper pair is
    not very good at carrying the broadband service.



    Some years ago I had a BT engineer for a fault, he told me that they are prioritising places where the broadband connection is poor i.e. rural
    areas, before starting on the town.

    Probably a risky policy because other companies might do the easy areas
    first and leave the more difficult, i.e. rural areas, for BT. But they
    will be familiar with that as it is how many other companies operate.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 14:29:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 28/10/2026 14:14, JMB99 wrote:
    On 28/10/2026 11:36, Graham J wrote:
    However, rural areas are exactly the locations where the copper pair
    is not very good at carrying the broadband service.



    Some years ago I had a BT engineer for a fault, he told me that they are prioritising places where the broadband connection is poor i.e. rural
    areas, before starting on the town.


    I think thats changed...

    Probably a risky policy because other companies might do the easy areas first and leave the more difficult, i.e. rural areas, for BT.-a But they will be familiar with that as it is how many other companies operate.




    There are now schemes to help e.g.

    https://www.openreach.com/fibre-broadband/fibre-community-partnership/connect-my-community

    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris Green@cl@isbd.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 28 16:41:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Graham J <nobody@nowhere.co.uk> wrote:
    Chris Green wrote:
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    Richmond wrote:

    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around -u3 to rent a >>> telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.

    I currently pay plusnet -u28/month for part-fibre broadband and pay
    voipfone -u6/month for my original BT number and bundle of 100 minutes.

    Yes, that's the basic mix for having a 'home phone' in the modern world without a 'landline'. You pay an ISP for an internet connection and, if you want a 'home phone' you pay a VOIP provider for that.

    If you want the 'home phone' to work during a power cut then your router and the phone itself need battery back-up.

    The VOIP phone can come in several different guises.

    The problem - as has been discussed on the news recently - is that in
    rural areas there is no fibre, and broadband is delivered over the
    copper pair in the form of either ADSL or VDSL (aka FTTC). Your voice service is then carried over the broadband connection.

    We're very rural, though actually not far from BT Adastral Park so maybe
    that had/has an effect! We have **very** reliable FTTC for many years.


    However, rural areas are exactly the locations where the copper pair is
    not very good at carrying the broadband service. Both speed and
    reliability can be affected, and people's experiences vary widely from "never have a problem" to "virtually never works".

    We have CityFibre FTTP (well they call it FTTH) now, they came and laid
    fibre through the whole village about a year ago, maybe thumbing their
    noses at BT!

    Rural areas are also exactly the locations where mobile signals are weak
    or non-existent.

    Yes, our mobile signal is crap throughout the village. It's just not a
    serious contender for making phone calls hereabouts.
    --
    Chris Green
    -+
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Thu Oct 29 08:13:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message news:aUy*WthUA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:

    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message
    news:U8s*iD-TA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of >> > the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no
    matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or >> > will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    So I am still going to have to pay BT u31 a month line rental
    no matter what VOIP provider I go with ?

    That was my question.

    If I go with Phonely they will charge around u10 a month for
    "digital line rental".

    So unles I'm still having to pay BT u31 a month on top
    then no matter what Phonely pay them that's a big loss
    of u20 a month to BT.

    The point I'm making is either this is going to cost me
    u10 a month extra to Phonely (my broadband cost will remain
    around the same) or I'm goibg to save u20 a month by not
    having to pay BT.

    BT are taking you for a ride.

    I'm still on ADSL. Simply because it provides all the speed I need
    ot will prbably ever need as I don't play online games or watch
    much streamng other than the odd fiv minute Youtube clip

    That coupled with simple inertia. If it ain't broke don't fix it even
    if it does cost an extra few bob.

    However as I understand it, from an angry lady at Plusnet all this
    is about to change


    bb


    Most people are paying ~u30 for broadband and
    some kind of landline phone, now implemented via VOIP over the broadband instead of analogue over the copper wires. They're not paying 'line rental' to BT or anyone. They might be paying an extra few pounds for some kind of monthly calls bundle, rather than the default tariff of ~20p/min + setup fees.

    I'm paying u25pm for broadband (Truespeed 300Mbps FTTP) and u1.80pm for a VOIP phone number with Andrews & Arnold. Calls are 1.5p/min landlines and 4p/min mobiles (+VAT); I don't make enough calls to make a bundle
    worthwhile (A&A don't offer bundles but Voipfone do).

    When I was on FTTC with Sky I think it was about u26pm for broadband and phone. I didn't pay line rental to BT or anyone: Sky paid part of that u26 to Openreach to maintain the line (the OR wholesale pricing table is public if I wanted to look up how much).

    Theo


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Thu Oct 29 08:19:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Richmond" <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote in message news:82cxsum8jk.fsf@example.com...
    "billy bookcase" <billy@anon.com> writes:

    "Tweed" <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote in message
    news:11bpqd4$1cbjh$1@dont-email.me...
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    billy bookcase wrote:

    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Not for a "phone line" the rental will be hidden within your broadband >>>> cost.

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.
    You got it ...

    Whichever way you look at it, after introductory discounts have expired, >>> you will be paying at least u30/month.

    I'm sorry I don't follow.

    At present I'm paying u24 a month for broadband and u31 a month BT line
    rental before calls

    That's u55 a month

    I can get a broadband for around u27 a month and pay Phoneley u10 a
    month for a digital landline

    So that's u37 a month which u18 less.

    A big difference.


    bb






    Why have you chosen Phoneley? Voipfone charges only around u3 to rent a telephone number. I use it with an 056 number without paying any rent.

    Sorry my mistake. I wasn't clear. That cost includes a calls bundle.

    I'm not really up top speed with any of this.


    bb


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Thu Oct 29 10:41:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 29/10/2026 08:13, billy bookcase wrote:
    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message news:aUy*WthUA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:

    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message
    news:U8s*iD-TA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of >>>> the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no >>>> matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or >>>> will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    So I am still going to have to pay BT +U31 a month line rental
    no matter what VOIP provider I go with ?

    That was my question.

    If I go with Phonely they will charge around +U10 a month for
    "digital line rental".

    So unles I'm still having to pay BT +U31 a month on top
    then no matter what Phonely pay them that's a big loss
    of +U20 a month to BT.

    The point I'm making is either this is going to cost me
    +U10 a month extra to Phonely (my broadband cost will remain
    around the same) or I'm goibg to save +U20 a month by not
    having to pay BT.

    BT are taking you for a ride.

    I'm still on ADSL. Simply because it provides all the speed I need
    ot will prbably ever need as I don't play online games or watch
    much streamng other than the odd fiv minute Youtube clip

    That coupled with simple inertia. If it ain't broke don't fix it even
    if it does cost an extra few bob.

    However as I understand it, from an angry lady at Plusnet all this
    is about to change


    I wonder why she was angry? She is just a poor under trained minion
    only doing her job..

    so:-

    1. PlusNet are stopping supplying a phone service, your telephone line
    will go. There is nothing she could do about this.

    2. This change counts as a new contract and if you live in an area where
    any alternative to ADSL is available they can't sell you a new ADSL
    contract. Again nothing she can do OpenReach won't sell ADSL to any ISP
    and that includes PlusNet due to OFCOM rules to ensure a level playing
    field.

    3. If you just want internet and no phone then you can stay with Plusnet
    but this will be a new contract and you will get FTTP if possible, if no
    FTTP then FTTC.

    4. If you want a phone service then in general folks are being moved to
    EE at which point they get an new router with a phone socket..


    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Thu Oct 29 13:27:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "David Wade" <g4ugm@dave.invalid> wrote in message news:11bv7t2$376v0$1@dont-email.me...
    On 29/10/2026 08:13, billy bookcase wrote:
    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message
    news:aUy*WthUA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:

    "Theo" <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote in message
    news:U8s*iD-TA@news.chiark.greenend.org.uk...
    billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
    Are BT still going to be charging line rental after Jan 31st ?

    Presumably not;or if so how. But surely that will represent
    a big loss of income.

    Or will that simply be incorporated into whatever broadband phone
    packages people take up.

    Line rental is, and always has been, a pricing fiction. It's just part of
    the monthly standing charge for your service. The cost won't change no >>>>> matter what arrangement of copper/fibre or PSTN/VOIP/no-voice you had or >>>>> will have - your existing contract will continue as before.

    So I am still going to have to pay BT L31 a month line rental
    no matter what VOIP provider I go with ?

    That was my question.

    If I go with Phonely they will charge around L10 a month for
    "digital line rental".

    So unles I'm still having to pay BT L31 a month on top
    then no matter what Phonely pay them that's a big loss
    of L20 a month to BT.

    The point I'm making is either this is going to cost me
    L10 a month extra to Phonely (my broadband cost will remain
    around the same) or I'm goibg to save L20 a month by not
    having to pay BT.

    BT are taking you for a ride.

    I'm still on ADSL. Simply because it provides all the speed I need
    ot will prbably ever need as I don't play online games or watch
    much streamng other than the odd fiv minute Youtube clip

    That coupled with simple inertia. If it ain't broke don't fix it even
    if it does cost an extra few bob.

    However as I understand it, from an angry lady at Plusnet all this
    is about to change


    I wonder why she was angry?


    I received a letter on Saturday dated 10 days earlier FULL OF RED
    INK saying that they had been vainly trying to contact me by email,
    letters and phone but had failed.

    This is a total and absolute lie,. They've made no attempt to contact
    me on this topic at all. But having left it with three months
    to go, they've flown into a panic

    The letter went on

    That if I don't contact them immediately, my Internet connection
    would be closed for seven days.

    I simply pointed out that the letter was based on total lies; that
    this was the first I'd ever heard of this issue and that I don't
    respond kindly to threats. I also mentioned the Kray twins.

    Subsequent research on Plusnet forums and elsewhere suggests
    that this approach - intimidation based on lies which originates
    with BT - is quite common.

    She is just a poor under trained minion only doing her job..

    On the contrary she was totally indoctrinated into the need for me
    switch broadband suppliers as soon as possible.. Rather than
    research all the options in my own time.

    As to her being a poorly paid minion. I'm usually sympathetic
    to the plight of poorly paid minions, in supermarkets and the
    like. But not to those attempting to justify the issuing of threats.

    Basically by employing sufficient poorly paid minions, managements
    can get away with all sorts; with no accountability at all.


    so:-

    1. PlusNet are stopping supplying a phone service, your telephone line will go. There is nothing she could do about this.

    2. This change counts as a new contract and if you live in an area where any alternative to ADSL is available they can't sell you a new ADSL contract. Again nothing she can do OpenReach won't sell ADSL to any ISP and that includes PlusNet due to OFCOM rules to ensure a level playing field.

    3. If you just want internet and no phone then you can stay with Plusnet but this will be a new contract and you will get FTTP if possible, if no FTTP then
    FTTC.

    4. If you want a phone service then in general folks are being moved to EE at which point they get an new router with a phone socket..

    These being the "folks" who having being threatened with seven days disconnection, solely as a result of Plusnet/BT's somnolence, are
    now being bumped into EE/BT


    bb


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Thu Oct 29 17:02:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/29 13:27:59, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    I received a letter on Saturday dated 10 days earlier FULL OF RED
    INK saying that they had been vainly trying to contact me by email,
    letters and phone but had failed.

    This is a total and absolute lie,. They've made no attempt to contact
    me on this topic at all. But having left it with three months
    to go, they've flown into a panic

    You aren't a POP user (using Thunderbird or a similar client), are you?
    I _did_ receive the original letter (dated 2 Sept. and received 9th),
    but the email containing more or less the same information, and also
    apparently sent on the 2nd, had gone into the spam bin which Greenby had
    set up, and set to maximum aggressiveness, unknown to me (until I looked
    on 29 September), when I was transferred to Greenby; if you _are_ a POP
    user, it might be worth logging in to web mail
    (https://webmail.greenby.com/) to see if you have a spam bin (I found
    other moderately important stuff in there too, and it explained why I
    hadn't been receiving things like one-time codes), and turn off the spam filter. (The fact that it had captured this important email - from
    Plusnet/EE - struck me as pretty incompetent.)


    The letter went on

    That if I don't contact them immediately, my Internet connection
    would be closed for seven days.

    Interesting; although I _did_ receive the first letter, I've not
    actually done anything, since it implied that if I was willing to accept
    the transfer to EE (which I am, for now), I didn't _have_ to do
    anything. So am I going to get a letter full of red too?


    I simply pointed out that the letter was based on total lies; that
    this was the first I'd ever heard of this issue and that I don't
    respond kindly to threats. I also mentioned the Kray twins.

    That probably didn't help :-)

    Subsequent research on Plusnet forums and elsewhere suggests
    that this approach - intimidation based on lies which originates
    with BT - is quite common.

    [rest deleted as I'm not in a position to comment]>>
    4. If you want a phone service then in general folks are being moved to EE at
    which point they get an new router with a phone socket..

    These being the "folks" who having being threatened with seven days disconnection, solely as a result of Plusnet/BT's somnolence, are
    now being bumped into EE/BT

    Well, the original letter which I did get, and I think the email of the
    same date, told me my EE contract would have the same cost and end date,
    so I didn't see any urgency to do anything.

    bb


    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Of course some of it [television] is bad. But some of everything is bad
    - books, music, family ... - Melvyn Bragg, RT 2017/7/1-7
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Fri Oct 30 10:10:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message news:11bvu6m$3hjub$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/10/29 13:27:59, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    I received a letter on Saturday dated 10 days earlier FULL OF RED
    INK saying that they had been vainly trying to contact me by email,
    letters and phone but had failed.

    This is a total and absolute lie,. They've made no attempt to contact
    me on this topic at all. But having left it with three months
    to go, they've flown into a panic

    You aren't a POP user (using Thunderbird or a similar client), are you?
    I _did_ receive the original letter (dated 2 Sept. and received 9th),
    but the email containing more or less the same information, and also apparently sent on the 2nd, had gone into the spam bin which Greenby had
    set up, and set to maximum aggressiveness, unknown to me (until I looked
    on 29 September), when I was transferred to Greenby; if you _are_ a POP
    user, it might be worth logging in to web mail
    (https://webmail.greenby.com/) to see if you have a spam bin (I found
    other moderately important stuff in there too, and it explained why I
    hadn't been receiving things like one-time codes), and turn off the spam filter. (The fact that it had captured this important email - from
    Plusnet/EE - struck me as pretty incompetent.)

    Having just checked I got three identical "Welcome to Greenby" messages on 29/01/2026. Which because it explained that I'd been migrated, but that otherwise
    nothing had changed, except I would have to pay u15 after two years, I subsequently ignored .

    But having just tried to log in to webmail for the first time, I find my Plusnet
    user name and password as used for ordinary mail is not recognised.

    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet, confirming DD
    deductions



    The letter went on

    That if I don't contact them immediately, my Internet connection
    would be closed for seven days.

    Interesting; although I _did_ receive the first letter, I've not
    actually done anything, since it implied that if I was willing to accept
    the transfer to EE (which I am, for now), I didn't _have_ to do
    anything. So am I going to get a letter full of red too?


    I simply pointed out that the letter was based on total lies; that
    this was the first I'd ever heard of this issue and that I don't
    respond kindly to threats. I also mentioned the Kray twins.

    That probably didn't help :-)

    More especially perhaps, as their only claim to a major criminal, is the Yorkshire Ripper,



    Subsequent research on Plusnet forums and elsewhere suggests
    that this approach - intimidation based on lies which originates
    with BT - is quite common.

    [rest deleted as I'm not in a position to comment]>>
    4. If you want a phone service then in general folks are being moved to EE >>> at
    which point they get an new router with a phone socket..

    These being the "folks" who having being threatened with seven days
    disconnection, solely as a result of Plusnet/BT's somnolence, are
    now being bumped into EE/BT

    Well, the original letter which I did get, and I think the email of the
    same date, told me my EE contract would have the same cost and end date,
    so I didn't see any urgency to do anything.

    I live in the London suburbs; and so this area was possibly regarded as
    being less of a priority; maybe based on the assumption that more people
    would already be "fibred up". So it would just be a case of swapping
    routers. Or maybe not even that, if they chose their own VOIP providers.

    But as I mentioned elsewhere, on the evidence of Plusnet forums at least,
    I am not alone in this.



    bb




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Fri Oct 30 21:04:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/30 10:10:20, billy bookcase wrote:
    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message news:11bvu6m$3hjub$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/10/29 13:27:59, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    I received a letter on Saturday dated 10 days earlier FULL OF RED
    INK saying that they had been vainly trying to contact me by email,
    letters and phone but had failed.

    This is a total and absolute lie,. They've made no attempt to contact
    me on this topic at all. But having left it with three months
    to go, they've flown into a panic

    You aren't a POP user (using Thunderbird or a similar client), are you?
    I _did_ receive the original letter (dated 2 Sept. and received 9th),
    but the email containing more or less the same information, and also
    []
    Having just checked I got three identical "Welcome to Greenby" messages on 29/01/2026. Which because it explained that I'd been migrated, but that otherwise
    nothing had changed, except I would have to pay +U15 after two years, I subsequently ignored .

    I did much the same; I gather it wasn't as seamless as they claimed
    because their server assumed some sort of encrypted sign-in, which under PlusNet it hadn't; this didn't bother me as I am using Thunderbird which
    does that sort of sign-in, but I gather some people using older clients
    had to do something (such as use stunnel). I think I _did_ have some
    problems but they got sorted. (More recently to do with domain in From:,
    but I'm unusual in that respect.)

    But having just tried to log in to webmail for the first time, I find my Plusnet
    user name and password as used for ordinary mail is not recognised.

    Hmm. if you _are_ a POP user, I'd get onto them; for me, when I was
    moved onto Greenby, they set up a spam bin, and a spam trap set to
    maximum aggressiveness, both of those unknown to me (POP only collects
    from the "Inbox", not the spam or any other bin). You may well be
    missing some important emails. (And I think any that have been in the
    spam box over about a month get deleted altogether, too; I was missing
    utility emails [from Octopus], and only found one of them when I learnt
    about the spam box.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet, confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)


    The letter went on

    That if I don't contact them immediately, my Internet connection
    would be closed for seven days.

    Interesting; although I _did_ receive the first letter, I've not
    actually done anything, since it implied that if I was willing to accept
    the transfer to EE (which I am, for now), I didn't _have_ to do
    anything. So am I going to get a letter full of red too?
    []
    These being the "folks" who having being threatened with seven days
    disconnection, solely as a result of Plusnet/BT's somnolence, are
    now being bumped into EE/BT

    As I say, it may be Greenby's incompetence rather than PlusNet's, though
    since PlusNet chose them, I'm not letting them off.

    Well, the original letter which I did get, and I think the email of the
    same date, told me my EE contract would have the same cost and end date,
    so I didn't see any urgency to do anything.

    I live in the London suburbs; and so this area was possibly regarded as
    being less of a priority; maybe based on the assumption that more people would already be "fibred up". So it would just be a case of swapping
    routers. Or maybe not even that, if they chose their own VOIP providers.

    If you want to stop 'phone (or transfer it to some other VoIP provider)
    but stay with PN for BB, I think you have to tell them - otherwise
    they'll move you (both services) to EE.

    But as I mentioned elsewhere, on the evidence of Plusnet forums at least,
    I am not alone in this.

    So far, I've not had threats, just incompetence over the years.


    bb




    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "Galbraith's Law of Human Nature: Faced with the choice between
    changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everybody gets busy on the proof." - John Kenneth Galbraith
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 09:28:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message news:11c30oi$jrd4$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/10/30 10:10:20, billy bookcase wrote:
    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message
    news:11bvu6m$3hjub$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/10/29 13:27:59, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    I received a letter on Saturday dated 10 days earlier FULL OF RED
    INK saying that they had been vainly trying to contact me by email,
    letters and phone but had failed.

    This is a total and absolute lie,. They've made no attempt to contact
    me on this topic at all. But having left it with three months
    to go, they've flown into a panic

    You aren't a POP user (using Thunderbird or a similar client), are you?
    I _did_ receive the original letter (dated 2 Sept. and received 9th),
    but the email containing more or less the same information, and also
    []
    Having just checked I got three identical "Welcome to Greenby" messages on >> 29/01/2026. Which because it explained that I'd been migrated, but that
    otherwise
    nothing had changed, except I would have to pay L15 after two years, I
    subsequently ignored .

    I did much the same; I gather it wasn't as seamless as they claimed
    because their server assumed some sort of encrypted sign-in, which under PlusNet it hadn't; this didn't bother me as I am using Thunderbird which
    does that sort of sign-in, but I gather some people using older clients
    had to do something (such as use stunnel). I think I _did_ have some
    problems but they got sorted. (More recently to do with domain in From:,
    but I'm unusual in that respect.)

    Thank you for this tip about Webmail, BTW.


    But having just tried to log in to webmail for the first time, I find my
    Plusnet
    user name and password as used for ordinary mail is not recognised.

    Hmm. if you _are_ a POP user, I'd get onto them; for me, when I was
    moved onto Greenby, they set up a spam bin, and a spam trap set to
    maximum aggressiveness, both of those unknown to me (POP only collects
    from the "Inbox", not the spam or any other bin). You may well be
    missing some important emails. (And I think any that have been in the
    spam box over about a month get deleted altogether, too; I was missing utility emails [from Octopus], and only found one of them when I learnt
    about the spam box.)

    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details, address etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine. Then after that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of
    accessing it. All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining nevertheless.



    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)


    The letter went on

    That if I don't contact them immediately, my Internet connection
    would be closed for seven days.

    Interesting; although I _did_ receive the first letter, I've not
    actually done anything, since it implied that if I was willing to accept >>> the transfer to EE (which I am, for now), I didn't _have_ to do
    anything. So am I going to get a letter full of red too?
    []
    These being the "folks" who having being threatened with seven days
    disconnection, solely as a result of Plusnet/BT's somnolence, are
    now being bumped into EE/BT

    As I say, it may be Greenby's incompetence rather than PlusNet's, though since PlusNet chose them, I'm not letting them off.

    Well, the original letter which I did get, and I think the email of the
    same date, told me my EE contract would have the same cost and end date, >>> so I didn't see any urgency to do anything.

    I live in the London suburbs; and so this area was possibly regarded as
    being less of a priority; maybe based on the assumption that more people
    would already be "fibred up". So it would just be a case of swapping
    routers. Or maybe not even that, if they chose their own VOIP providers.

    If you want to stop 'phone (or transfer it to some other VoIP provider)
    but stay with PN for BB, I think you have to tell them - otherwise
    they'll move you (both services) to EE.

    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded
    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in addition
    to the router and an extra available plug socket


    bb



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Finnigan@nix@genie.co.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 10:17:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 01/11/2026 09:28, billy bookcase wrote:


    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their supplied router.

    Their fibre minimum is 74 Mbps, -u28 a month + -u18 for unlimited UK
    minutes on a home phone, free ATA (for a nearby postcode, YMMV).

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 13:53:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Nick Finnigan" <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote in message news:11c73j3$1q3q3$2@dont-email.me...
    On 01/11/2026 09:28, billy bookcase wrote:


    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded
    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    Their fibre minimum is 74 Mbps, u28 a month + u18 for unlimited UK
    minutes on a home phone, free ATA (for a nearby postcode, YMMV).

    Thanks. I think I saw a 700 minutes phone option somewhere on one of
    their sites; but was unable to retrieve it subsequently. Dunno what
    ATA means. but there was an extra u30? for the first month.
    Presumably for the router.

    If they hadn't sent the threatening letter replete with the red ink
    but had asked nicely, I would most probably have arrannged all
    this already.


    bb





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 14:13:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 01/11/2026 13:53, billy bookcase wrote:
    "Nick Finnigan" <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote in message news:11c73j3$1q3q3$2@dont-email.me...
    On 01/11/2026 09:28, billy bookcase wrote:


    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded
    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter >>> along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    Their fibre minimum is 74 Mbps, +U28 a month + +U18 for unlimited UK
    minutes on a home phone, free ATA (for a nearby postcode, YMMV).

    Thanks. I think I saw a 700 minutes phone option somewhere on one of
    their sites; but was unable to retrieve it subsequently. Dunno what
    ATA means. but there was an extra +U30? for the first month.
    Presumably for the router.


    Analogue Telephone Adaptor - Lets you connect a "normal" phone to a VOIP service. EE, BT and ZEN provide routers with a built-in ATA but BT and
    EE lock theirs into their "Digital Voice" service, so if you want to use
    an alternative you need a VOIP phone, VOIP application or an ATA.


    If they hadn't sent the threatening letter replete with the red ink
    but had asked nicely, I would most probably have arrannged all
    this already.


    They may have sent one earlier but it may be sat somewhere within
    RoyalMail and if you dind't act you would be left with no service.


    bb





    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 15:34:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/1 9:28:45, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details, address etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine. Then after
    that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    Yes, I think I had to do something advanced to get into it.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of accessing it. All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    When I go to https://webmail.greenby.com/ and log in ...
    Oh. I was going to describe what I see, but it's currently showing
    "Login failed." (Two browsers.) (Of course, https://status.greenby.com/
    says "All Systems Operational".) So I'll try to describe from memory: I
    saw a list of - I don't know what you'd call them, folders or inboxes -
    with inbox at the top; I think one of the others was called spam or
    junk. With a number next to each showing how many messages were in each
    (Inbox having 0, as that's what Thunderbird - or, I guess, any other POP
    client - fetches from.)

    Ah - I've found another way in: I had
    https://greenby.com/support/tickets bookmarked; from there I clicked on
    the three lines top left, then Email, then view webmail: hmm, you're
    right, I can only see Inbox. Ah, found it - this is like getting blood
    out of a stone! Clicking on Settings on the left gives a menu including Folders; clicking on /that/ gives me the list - Inbox, Drafts, Sent,
    Junk, Trash, INBOX Drafts, INBOX Sent, INBOX Spam, and INBOX Trash. No
    numbers are against any of those, but the first time I got to this
    screen one of them did (ninetysomething I think).

    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)
    []
    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.

    Ditto - I won't be any _worse_ off until current contract end, so that's
    least effort.

    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded

    Same here (no "smart" TV), and I presume my YouTube viewing uses mostly
    no more resolution than my screen, mostly less as I tend to view in the
    little window.

    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum

    I think I'm on FTTC.

    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their supplied router.

    The EE one, yes. But if you think you might _not_ need a 'phone at all
    (e. g. you're willing to use a mobile entirely), then get onto PlusNet
    who - at least that's what they imply - will be happy for you to stay
    with them, and that should be for less.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in addition
    to the router and an extra available plug socket

    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).

    bb



    John
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    * SLMR 2.1a #113 * Tits like watermelons, sparrows like bacon rind.
    - 03-22-97 Dave Beecham <dave.beecham@pandbox.demon.co.uk> (quoted by
    Gene Wirchenko, in alt.windows7.general, 2012-10-16.)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 15:59:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/1 15:34:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    [Greenby]
    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)
    []
    I forgot to say - turn off the spam filter /before/ you try moving
    emails from the spam (or whatever) box to your inbox, or it might move
    them back before your POP client can fetch them.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Sometimes I believe we made up god just to have someone to blame for our mistakes - "Sarah Sidle" (Jorja Fox), CSI
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Woody@harrogate3@ntlworld.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 19:22:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On Sun 01/11/2026 15:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/1 9:28:45, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details, address
    etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine. Then after
    that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    Yes, I think I had to do something advanced to get into it.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of
    accessing it. All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    When I go to https://webmail.greenby.com/ and log in ...
    Oh. I was going to describe what I see, but it's currently showing
    "Login failed." (Two browsers.) (Of course, https://status.greenby.com/
    says "All Systems Operational".) So I'll try to describe from memory: I
    saw a list of - I don't know what you'd call them, folders or inboxes -
    with inbox at the top; I think one of the others was called spam or
    junk. With a number next to each showing how many messages were in each (Inbox having 0, as that's what Thunderbird - or, I guess, any other POP client - fetches from.)

    Ah - I've found another way in: I had
    https://greenby.com/support/tickets bookmarked; from there I clicked on
    the three lines top left, then Email, then view webmail: hmm, you're
    right, I can only see Inbox. Ah, found it - this is like getting blood
    out of a stone! Clicking on Settings on the left gives a menu including Folders; clicking on /that/ gives me the list - Inbox, Drafts, Sent,
    Junk, Trash, INBOX Drafts, INBOX Sent, INBOX Spam, and INBOX Trash. No numbers are against any of those, but the first time I got to this
    screen one of them did (ninetysomething I think).

    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more >> rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining
    nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)
    []
    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.

    Ditto - I won't be any _worse_ off until current contract end, so that's least effort.

    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded

    Same here (no "smart" TV), and I presume my YouTube viewing uses mostly
    no more resolution than my screen, mostly less as I tend to view in the little window.

    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum

    I think I'm on FTTC.

    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    The EE one, yes. But if you think you might _not_ need a 'phone at all
    (e. g. you're willing to use a mobile entirely), then get onto PlusNet
    who - at least that's what they imply - will be happy for you to stay
    with them, and that should be for less.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in addition
    to the router and an extra available plug socket

    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).



    I thought Skype was no more?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From MikeS@MikeS@fred.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 19:36:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 01/11/2026 15:59, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/1 15:34:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    [Greenby]
    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)
    []
    I forgot to say - turn off the spam filter /before/ you try moving
    emails from the spam (or whatever) box to your inbox, or it might move
    them back before your POP client can fetch them.

    Most systems have a option to mark items in the spam folder as "not
    junk". They are then automatically moved back to the Inbox where they
    stay. Depending on the system this may also help to train the filter.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 20:13:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 01/11/2026 19:22, Woody wrote:
    On Sun 01/11/2026 15:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/1 9:28:45, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details,
    address
    etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine.
    Then after
    that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    Yes, I think I had to do something advanced to get into it.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of
    accessing it.-a All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    When I go to https://webmail.greenby.com/ and log in ...
    Oh. I was going to describe what I see, but it's currently showing
    "Login failed." (Two browsers.) (Of course, https://status.greenby.com/
    says "All Systems Operational".) So I'll try to describe from memory: I
    saw a list of - I don't know what you'd call them, folders or inboxes -
    with inbox at the top; I think one of the others was called spam or
    junk. With a number next to each showing how many messages were in each
    (Inbox having 0, as that's what Thunderbird - or, I guess, any other POP
    client - fetches from.)

    Ah - I've found another way in: I had
    https://greenby.com/support/tickets bookmarked; from there I clicked on
    the three lines top left, then Email, then view webmail: hmm, you're
    right, I can only see Inbox. Ah, found it - this is like getting blood
    out of a stone! Clicking on Settings on the left gives a menu including
    Folders; clicking on /that/ gives me the list - Inbox, Drafts, Sent,
    Junk, Trash, INBOX Drafts, INBOX Sent, INBOX Spam, and INBOX Trash. No
    numbers are against any of those, but the first time I got to this
    screen one of them did (ninetysomething I think).

    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it
    means more
    rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining
    nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)
    []
    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.

    Ditto - I won't be any _worse_ off until current contract end, so that's
    least effort.

    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded

    Same here (no "smart" TV), and I presume my YouTube viewing uses mostly
    no more resolution than my screen, mostly less as I tend to view in the
    little window.

    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to
    potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for-a much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum

    I think I'm on FTTC.

    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    The EE one, yes. But if you think you might _not_ need a 'phone at all
    (e. g. you're willing to use a mobile entirely), then get onto PlusNet
    who - at least that's what they imply - will be happy for you to stay
    with them, and that should be for less.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in
    addition
    to the router and an extra available plug socket

    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).



    I thought Skype was no more?

    Replaced by Teams which does not allow "real" calls for domestic/home
    users..

    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 22:58:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "David Wade" <g4ugm@dave.invalid> wrote in message news:11c7he2$1r30i$1@dont-email.me...
    On 01/11/2026 13:53, billy bookcase wrote:
    "Nick Finnigan" <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote in message
    news:11c73j3$1q3q3$2@dont-email.me...
    On 01/11/2026 09:28, billy bookcase wrote:


    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded >>>> British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter >>>> along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    Their fibre minimum is 74 Mbps, L28 a month + L18 for unlimited UK
    minutes on a home phone, free ATA (for a nearby postcode, YMMV).

    Thanks. I think I saw a 700 minutes phone option somewhere on one of
    their sites; but was unable to retrieve it subsequently. Dunno what
    ATA means. but there was an extra L30? for the first month.
    Presumably for the router.


    Analogue Telephone Adaptor - Lets you connect a "normal" phone to a VOIP service. EE, BT and ZEN provide routers with a built-in ATA but BT and EE lock
    theirs into their "Digital Voice" service, so if you want to use an alternative you need a VOIP phone, VOIP application or an ATA.

    Thanks

    bb


    If they hadn't sent the threatening letter replete with the red ink
    but had asked nicely, I would most probably have arrannged all
    this already.


    They may have sent one earlier but it may be sat somewhere within RoyalMail and if you dind't act you would be left with no service.


    bb





    Dave


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 22:58:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "Nick Finnigan" <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote in message news:11c73j3$1q3q3$2@dont-email.me...
    On 01/11/2026 09:28, billy bookcase wrote:


    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.
    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded
    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum
    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    Their fibre minimum is 74 Mbps, u28 a month + u18 for unlimited UK minutes on
    a home phone, free ATA (for a nearby postcode, YMMV).

    Thanks


    bb



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Sun Nov 1 23:38:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message news:11c7m6c$232dk$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/11/1 9:28:45, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details, address
    etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine. Then
    after
    that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    Yes, I think I had to do something advanced to get into it.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of
    accessing it. All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    When I go to https://webmail.greenby.com/ and log in ...
    Oh. I was going to describe what I see, but it's currently showing
    "Login failed." (Two browsers.) (Of course, https://status.greenby.com/
    says "All Systems Operational".) So I'll try to describe from memory: I
    saw a list of - I don't know what you'd call them, folders or inboxes -
    with inbox at the top; I think one of the others was called spam or
    junk. With a number next to each showing how many messages were in each (Inbox having 0, as that's what Thunderbird - or, I guess, any other POP client - fetches from.)



    Ah - I've found another way in: I had
    https://greenby.com/support/tickets bookmarked; from there I clicked on
    the three lines top left, then Email, then view webmail: hmm, you're
    right, I can only see Inbox. Ah, found it - this is like getting blood
    out of a stone! Clicking on Settings on the left gives a menu including Folders; clicking on /that/ gives me the list - Inbox, Drafts, Sent,
    Junk, Trash, INBOX Drafts, INBOX Sent, INBOX Spam, and INBOX Trash. No numbers are against any of those, but the first time I got to this
    screen one of them did (ninetysomething I think).

    Much of their "website" appears to consist of isolated pages which
    seemingly are unaware of the other pages existence. So that when forced
    to bring up the log-in page (yet again) it skips this, as it I'm
    already logged in. I can only ever a mention of "mailbox" and only
    then to the inbox, Clicking on "folders" simply brings up settings
    preferences for these folders. But as I've never seen any folders,
    only my inbox, this all seems a bit pointless.

    Like a lot of "websites" nowadays, my local free newspapers group is
    going the same way, with icons on a panel at the left, these sites
    seem to start with a pre-existing template which requires creators
    to try to find appropriate actions, to make use of the template's
    pre-exiting "features".

    Rather than working out what visitors to their site will want and
    need to do; and designing the site around that.


    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more >> rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining
    nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    As you don't seem to have suffered any dire consequences as a result of
    having done so, I'll try that too. Thanks


    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)
    []
    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.

    Ditto - I won't be any _worse_ off until current contract end, so that's least effort.

    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded

    Same here (no "smart" TV), and I presume my YouTube viewing uses mostly
    no more resolution than my screen, mostly less as I tend to view in the little window.

    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter
    along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum

    I think I'm on FTTC.

    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    The EE one, yes. But if you think you might _not_ need a 'phone at all
    (e. g. you're willing to use a mobile entirely), then get onto PlusNet
    who - at least that's what they imply - will be happy for you to stay
    with them, and that should be for less.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in addition
    to the router and an extra available plug socket

    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).

    Thanks.

    Isn't modern life wonderful ? Presenting us with all these options,
    concerning which very few ordinary people are in any real position
    to evaluate.


    bb

    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-tyranny-of-choice/


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 09:13:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/1 19:36:52, MikeS wrote:
    On 01/11/2026 15:59, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/1 15:34:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    [Greenby]
    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)
    []
    I forgot to say - turn off the spam filter /before/ you try moving
    emails from the spam (or whatever) box to your inbox, or it might move
    them back before your POP client can fetch them.

    Most systems have a option to mark items in the spam folder as "not
    junk". They are then automatically moved back to the Inbox where they
    stay. Depending on the system this may also help to train the filter.

    Ah - it didn't even occur to me to look for anything like that in PlusNet/Greenby's webmail spam box; I just wanted everything that was in
    it back in my Inbox, and nothing to go there in future, so turned off
    the spam filter altogether once I learnt of its existence. I don't get
    enough spam for it to be worth any risk of missing emails; I think on
    average less than one (spam or phishing) a week, and I don't think ever
    (in decades) more than three or four in a day/ten in a week, usually
    nearer none.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "Bother," said Pooh, as he tasted the bacon in his sandwich.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 09:22:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/1 20:13:34, David Wade wrote:
    On 01/11/2026 19:22, Woody wrote:
    On Sun 01/11/2026 15:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    []
    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).



    I thought Skype was no more?

    That's why I added the "/Zoom/whatever"; I just meant, a software VoIP
    "phone" uses your computer's own microphone and speaker, like one of
    those calling systems (but audio-only). Last time I really looked at the voipfone website, they had one of the software 'phones available for
    download - I think another VoIP supplier had the same one.


    Replaced by Teams which does not allow "real" calls for domestic/home users..

    Is Zoom still about? Or there may be another such, or several?

    Dave

    John
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "Bother," said Pooh, as he tasted the bacon in his sandwich.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 09:48:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/1 23:38:23, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Much of their "website" appears to consist of isolated pages which
    seemingly are unaware of the other pages existence. So that when forced
    to bring up the log-in page (yet again) it skips this, as it I'm
    already logged in. I can only ever a mention of "mailbox" and only

    Yes, I found if I clicked Logout (if I could find it - not in the same
    position on every page, e. g. top right under something or bottom left!) frequently just to get back to a known start position.

    then to the inbox, Clicking on "folders" simply brings up settings preferences for these folders. But as I've never seen any folders,
    only my inbox, this all seems a bit pointless.

    Hmm. I suppose you could always raise a ticket (as that's the only way
    to communicate with them - no 'phone number) asking them to transfer any remaining emails in the spam bin (or any other) you can't find, to your
    Inbox.

    (I presume you _are_ a POP user, not IMAP?)


    Like a lot of "websites" nowadays, my local free newspapers group is
    going the same way, with icons on a panel at the left, these sites
    seem to start with a pre-existing template which requires creators
    to try to find appropriate actions, to make use of the template's
    pre-exiting "features".

    And nearly all of these templates seem to use three lines - sometimes
    referred to as a hamburger, if they're horizontal - as a shortcut for "settings" (or even just "menu"); I've never liked that!

    Rather than working out what visitors to their site will want and
    need to do; and designing the site around that.

    :-)

    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more >>> rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining
    nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    As you don't seem to have suffered any dire consequences as a result of having done so, I'll try that too. Thanks

    Well, I get very little spam, and so far have recognised the odd
    phishing one. If you get a lot, YMMV - although you presumably can train
    your own spam filter in Thunderbird or whatever.
    []
    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).

    Thanks.

    When a separate item, it's (IIRR) about four inches square; you plug
    your old 'phone into it (probably via an adapter, hopefully supplied, as
    I think it has US 'phone sockets), and connect it to the router with an ethernet cable. When I first started to look into VoIP, they were quite expensive - I think nearly 60; later they seemed to be cheaper (under 30 maybe?); it wouldn't surprise me if they've gone up again. The default
    model - with a 1 somewhere in its model number - works with one "SIP";
    the model with a 2 in the model number, which didn't cost much more, can
    use two SIPs, which means you can have e. g. a different VoIP provider
    for incoming and outgoing calls. This is all academic if you use a
    router with a built-in ATA so you just plug your old 'phone into the
    router anyway.

    (What's particularly irritating is that the PlusNet router _does_ have
    the ATA hardware in it - it's just not enabled by the firmware!)

    Isn't modern life wonderful ? Presenting us with all these options, concerning which very few ordinary people are in any real position
    to evaluate.

    :-(

    bb

    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-tyranny-of-choice/


    I am reminded of a sketch - I think it was Not The Nine O'Clock News; I
    think it was the time of the mass privatisations, when we were offered
    lots of "choice". A man in a caf|- asked for something to stir his
    coffee; someone tipped near him a huge bin-bag-full of those little
    plastic stirrers, all identical. "But look at how much /choice/ you have!"
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "Bother," said Pooh, as he tasted the bacon in his sandwich.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 09:57:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 01/11/2026 23:38, billy bookcase wrote:
    "J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote in message news:11c7m6c$232dk$1@dont-email.me...
    On 2026/11/1 9:28:45, billy bookcase wrote:
    []
    Sorry my mistake. To first log on and enter all the relevent details, address
    etc. it was first necessary to use my grown up, Windows 10 machine. Then >>> after
    that I can access my inbox on an XP machine.

    Yes, I think I had to do something advanced to get into it.

    However on neither, can I identify my junk folder nor find any way of
    accessing it. All I seem to be able to access, is my inbox.

    When I go to https://webmail.greenby.com/ and log in ...
    Oh. I was going to describe what I see, but it's currently showing
    "Login failed." (Two browsers.) (Of course, https://status.greenby.com/
    says "All Systems Operational".) So I'll try to describe from memory: I
    saw a list of - I don't know what you'd call them, folders or inboxes -
    with inbox at the top; I think one of the others was called spam or
    junk. With a number next to each showing how many messages were in each
    (Inbox having 0, as that's what Thunderbird - or, I guess, any other POP
    client - fetches from.)



    Ah - I've found another way in: I had
    https://greenby.com/support/tickets bookmarked; from there I clicked on
    the three lines top left, then Email, then view webmail: hmm, you're
    right, I can only see Inbox. Ah, found it - this is like getting blood
    out of a stone! Clicking on Settings on the left gives a menu including
    Folders; clicking on /that/ gives me the list - Inbox, Drafts, Sent,
    Junk, Trash, INBOX Drafts, INBOX Sent, INBOX Spam, and INBOX Trash. No
    numbers are against any of those, but the first time I got to this
    screen one of them did (ninetysomething I think).

    Much of their "website" appears to consist of isolated pages which
    seemingly are unaware of the other pages existence. So that when forced
    to bring up the log-in page (yet again) it skips this, as it I'm
    already logged in. I can only ever a mention of "mailbox" and only
    then to the inbox, Clicking on "folders" simply brings up settings preferences for these folders. But as I've never seen any folders,
    only my inbox, this all seems a bit pointless.

    Like a lot of "websites" nowadays, my local free newspapers group is
    going the same way, with icons on a panel at the left, these sites
    seem to start with a pre-existing template which requires creators
    to try to find appropriate actions, to make use of the template's
    pre-exiting "features".

    Rather than working out what visitors to their site will want and
    need to do; and designing the site around that.


    I have set the spam filter up to 8 which may be a mistake; as it means more >>> rubbish should get through; some of which might prove entertaining
    nevertheless.

    Rather than setting it to anything, I just turned it off altogether. How
    to get to it - right. From initial login: under products, click Manage
    by Email, then Settings: upper right, under Anti Spam, where you have
    the slider from More Agressive to Less Agressive, you will see above it
    a green switch saying ON; I clicked that and it turned red and OFF (and
    the slider disappeared). [Phew, that was hard work!]

    As you don't seem to have suffered any dire consequences as a result of having done so, I'll try that too. Thanks


    If you move your emails from the spam (or wherever) box to Inbox, your
    POP client will get them. (Can't remember _how_ I did that move - might
    have had to do it one at a time.)


    However .......I already regularly get monthly emails from Plusnet,
    confirming
    DD
    deductions

    Those _were_ still getting through to me too; presumably they didn't
    trigger Greenby's spam trap. (But the one about the EE transfer did!)
    []
    All depending on prices it looks as though I will be going with EE,.

    Ditto - I won't be any _worse_ off until current contract end, so that's
    least effort.

    The point being that as I don't play online games or use streaming
    except for brief Youtube clips - all mainly in the past now, downloaded

    Same here (no "smart" TV), and I presume my YouTube viewing uses mostly
    no more resolution than my screen, mostly less as I tend to view in the
    little window.

    British Pathe and historic street scenes etc. I was quite happy to potter >>> along on ADSL offering around 10-12 Mps. But seemingly I'll have to
    pay for much a higher speed, rather than even their fibre minimum

    I think I'm on FTTC.

    if I want to use a phone which I assume will plug directly into their
    supplied router.

    The EE one, yes. But if you think you might _not_ need a 'phone at all
    (e. g. you're willing to use a mobile entirely), then get onto PlusNet
    who - at least that's what they imply - will be happy for you to stay
    with them, and that should be for less.

    Rather than go with Phonely; which will require an extra box, in addition >>> to the router and an extra available plug socket

    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).

    Thanks.

    Isn't modern life wonderful ? Presenting us with all these options, concerning which very few ordinary people are in any real position
    to evaluate.


    You are not presented with any options! You really have to dig to find
    them BT/EE just give you the take it or leave it option. PlusNet tell
    you to move to EE or no service. I suspect many just move without
    checking. None of the comparison sites allow separate VOIP and Broadband packages. As far as I can tell only the major ISPs so BT/EE , Sky and
    Virgin plus ZEN offer a phone service.

    When I go to uSwitch I get offered 81 packages of which only 9 include a
    phone service but as I am a ZEN customer they are not there. I think
    TalkTalk also offer VOIP to their own customers, but they are being
    bought by BT.

    I really don't see there is any profit in home VOIP. SipGate pulled out
    of offering a single number 4 years ago. Voipfone don't make it obvious
    you can have a single number and not pay anything. A&A seems to be to be
    the only



    bb

    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-tyranny-of-choice/



    Dave
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 10:12:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 02/11/2026 09:22, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/1 20:13:34, David Wade wrote:
    On 01/11/2026 19:22, Woody wrote:
    On Sun 01/11/2026 15:34, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    []
    Yes, an ATA (analogue telephone adapter - built into the EE router).
    That or a VoIP 'phone, or a software one (like Skype/Zoom/whatever).



    I thought Skype was no more?

    That's why I added the "/Zoom/whatever"; I just meant, a software VoIP "phone" uses your computer's own microphone and speaker, like one of
    those calling systems (but audio-only). Last time I really looked at the voipfone website, they had one of the software 'phones available for
    download - I think another VoIP supplier had the same one.


    There are a couple of free apps which simulate a SIP protocol phone and
    so work with most of the "voip only" suppliers.


    Replaced by Teams which does not allow "real" calls for domestic/home
    users..

    Is Zoom still about? Or there may be another such, or several?

    Yes, zoom is still about, and whilst mainly a conferencing system it
    does offer a VOIP service in the UK. I didn't realise this before. There
    is also WebEx a similar video meetings product from CISCO which allows
    calls for businesses and may have a personal calling feature but I
    didn't check further

    Both need a subscription. In the US google has a similar feature in its services, but these are only for US calls ...


    Dave

    John

    Dave

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris Green@cl@isbd.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 10:47:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> wrote:
    Thanks.

    Isn't modern life wonderful ? Presenting us with all these options, concerning which very few ordinary people are in any real position
    to evaluate.


    You are not presented with any options! You really have to dig to find
    them BT/EE just give you the take it or leave it option. PlusNet tell
    you to move to EE or no service. I suspect many just move without
    checking. None of the comparison sites allow separate VOIP and Broadband packages. As far as I can tell only the major ISPs so BT/EE , Sky and
    Virgin plus ZEN offer a phone service.

    IDNet offer VOIP, though it's rather slanted towards business use. It's
    quite reasonably priced.
    --
    Chris Green
    -+
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,uk.telecom.voip,uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 12:11:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/2 10:12:5, David Wade wrote:
    On 02/11/2026 09:22, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    []
    That's why I added the "/Zoom/whatever"; I just meant, a software VoIP
    "phone" uses your computer's own microphone and speaker, like one of
    those calling systems (but audio-only). Last time I really looked at the
    voipfone website, they had one of the software 'phones available for
    download - I think another VoIP supplier had the same one.


    There are a couple of free apps which simulate a SIP protocol phone and
    so work with most of the "voip only" suppliers.

    Good to know. Anyone got any experience using either?

    Replaced by Teams which does not allow "real" calls for domestic/home
    users..

    Is Zoom still about? Or there may be another such, or several?

    Yes, zoom is still about, and whilst mainly a conferencing system it
    does offer a VOIP service in the UK. I didn't realise this before. There

    I didn't realise Zoom did VoIP; I just cited it as a conferencing-type
    thing.

    is also WebEx a similar video meetings product from CISCO which allows
    calls for businesses and may have a personal calling feature but I
    didn't check further

    Yes, I used that when I was a member of the parish council; I had the impression that it was exactly identical to one of the others (Zoom I
    think), other than the borders of parts of the window were a different
    colour!

    Both need a subscription. In the US google has a similar feature in its services, but these are only for US calls ...

    I take it you mean for VoIP; from what I remember, the normal Zoom
    function was free, though a bit fiddly to set up (I usually let the
    other party do that, then invite me).

    Dave

    John

    Dave

    John
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    I still say a church steeple with a lightning rod on top shows a lack
    of confidence. D McLeod
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 14:27:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband


    "David Wade" <g4ugm@dave.invalid> wrote in message news:11c9mpi$2m48d$1@dont-email.me...

    You are not presented with any options! You really have to dig to find them BT/EE just give you the take it or leave it option. PlusNet tell you to move to EE or no service.

    Since signing up with EE an hour ago I am receiving automated spam
    phone calls from Plusnet regarding SMS messages, I answered the
    first one which says "we heard you're leaving Plusnet"



    I suspect many just move without checking.

    I must confess I just have done just that. Due to a paucity of
    information online

    Basically I only phoned up Plusnet - after giving my user name and
    pass word, to be then passed to BT who asked loads of security
    questions before they would quote me a price which is all I was
    after for combined EE and phone and Broadband; which was exactly
    the same as Nick Finnegan quoted on this forum.

    * Anyway as it saved me abour u200 p.a as compared with what I'm paying
    now, I signed up for that.*

    At first the conversation was fraught, as I was being asked loads of unnecessary (to any sensible person) security and credit rating
    questions. I've been paying a BT bill on time in my own name
    for over 50 years now. So why the need for a credit check ?

    However after I correctly guessed the young (27) lady's accent, "Are you
    from Bolton" mainly due to Fred Dibnah, and Diane Morgan (Philomena
    Cunk) and knowing people from Chorley, yonks ago the
    atmosphere lightened immediately. Nevertheless it was really a hard
    slog; as the young lady had to go through her script come what may.

    What is also disconcerting is that they insist on using you Christian
    name all the time.;just to make it "personal"and "friendly" when
    in reality it's just a business transaction.

    Although as I'd already pointed out in the "pre Bolton" phase, given their
    job is supposed to be selling *me* something. its surprising how difficult they're making it for me to actually buy it.

    But what a load of palaver ! And that's even before Openreach get involved


    bb



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,uk.telecom.voip,uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 15:21:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    J. P. Gilliver wrote:

    David Wade wrote:

    In the US google has a similar feature in its
    services, but these are only for US calls ...

    I take it you mean for VoIP; from what I remember, the normal Zoom
    function was free, though a bit fiddly to set up (I usually let the
    other party do that, then invite me).
    You're talking about "Google Voice" I presume?
    I don't think it's ever been available in the UK ...


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Woody@harrogate3@ntlworld.com to uk.telecom.broadband,uk.telecom.voip,uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 20:42:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On Mon 02/11/2026 12:11, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/11/2 10:12:5, David Wade wrote:
    On 02/11/2026 09:22, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    []
    That's why I added the "/Zoom/whatever"; I just meant, a software VoIP
    "phone" uses your computer's own microphone and speaker, like one of
    those calling systems (but audio-only). Last time I really looked at the >>> voipfone website, they had one of the software 'phones available for
    download - I think another VoIP supplier had the same one.


    There are a couple of free apps which simulate a SIP protocol phone and
    so work with most of the "voip only" suppliers.

    Good to know. Anyone got any experience using either?

    Replaced by Teams which does not allow "real" calls for domestic/home
    users..

    Is Zoom still about? Or there may be another such, or several?

    Yes, zoom is still about, and whilst mainly a conferencing system it
    does offer a VOIP service in the UK. I didn't realise this before. There

    I didn't realise Zoom did VoIP; I just cited it as a conferencing-type
    thing.

    is also WebEx a similar video meetings product from CISCO which allows
    calls for businesses and may have a personal calling feature but I
    didn't check further

    Yes, I used that when I was a member of the parish council; I had the impression that it was exactly identical to one of the others (Zoom I
    think), other than the borders of parts of the window were a different colour!

    Both need a subscription. In the US google has a similar feature in its
    services, but these are only for US calls ...

    I take it you mean for VoIP; from what I remember, the normal Zoom
    function was free, though a bit fiddly to set up (I usually let the
    other party do that, then invite me).


    For software VoIP phone there is Linfone, Zoiper. and the one I have
    used most, Phonerlite, all of which work on any Windows machine as far
    back as XPSP2. Phonerlite is a doddle to set up and if you have one it
    will work easily with a USB telephone handset or a headset.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,uk.telecom.voip,uk.telecom.broadband on Mon Nov 2 22:22:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/11/2 15:21:15, Andy Burns wrote:
    J. P. Gilliver wrote:

    David Wade wrote:

    In the US google has a similar feature in its
    services, but these are only for US calls ...

    I take it you mean for VoIP; from what I remember, the normal Zoom
    function was free, though a bit fiddly to set up (I usually let the
    other party do that, then invite me).
    You're talking about "Google Voice" I presume?
    I don't think it's ever been available in the UK ...


    No, I meant a video call system (which I think can involve several people/sites). but I haven't been involved in one of them for a few
    years, so it may have changed.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Sometimes I believe we made up god just to have someone to blame for our mistakes - "Sarah Sidle" (Jorja Fox), CSI
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2