• One VOIP landline number but two different phones which ring independently

    From NY@me@privacy.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 20:27:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    My mother (age 90) has just had her landline converted from analogue to
    VOIP with EE who also provide her broadband.

    Previously she had two phone sockets, one with a DECT phone plugged in
    and another extension in another room which has a corded phone.

    When she was migrated to VOIP, she explained to the Openreach engineer
    that she wanted to be able to use both phones so she could make and
    answer calls either using one of the DECT handsets or using the corded
    phone.

    But she has noticed several times that when she is on the phone (eg to
    me) using the DECT, the landline rings with another call - which she can answer while keeping the call open to me on the DECT phone.

    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the DECT
    in one and the corded in the other, with software doing a divert-on-busy
    from the DECT phone to the corded phone? I was expecting one BT socket
    on the router to go to a two-way splitter so both DECT and analogue are identical and don't ring or allow outgoing calls independently of each
    other.

    I'm waiting for her to send me a photo of the cables going into the back
    of her router.

    I can't see much of relevance to VOIP in the EE router's admin "site" (browsing to the gateway address). I was expecting (as for my Zyxel
    router) that there would be, for example, a list of incoming/outgoing
    calls - remote number, time, duration.

    Her main concern is that she may be being charged twice for two VOIP
    landlines (with the same number) if they feed different phones.

    It would be a lot easier if I didn't live 200 miles away from her... ;-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 20:46:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    NY wrote:

    When she was migrated to VOIP, she explained to the Openreach engineer
    that she wanted to be able to use both phones so she could make and
    answer calls either using one of the DECT handsets or using the corded phone.

    But she has noticed several times that when she is on the phone (eg to
    me) using the DECT, the landline rings with another call - which she can answer while keeping the call open to me on the DECT phone.

    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the DECT
    in one and the corded in the other

    More likely the router has a built-in DECT base that the handset speak
    tp, and the corded phone is in the POTS port.

    with software doing a divert-on-busy
    from the DECT phone to the corded phone?


    No divert necessary, SIP allows multiple calls in parallel, my gigaset
    can handle four calls at once.

    I was expecting one BT socket
    on the router to go to a two-way splitter so both DECT and analogue are identical and don't ring or allow outgoing calls independently of each other.

    I bet the engineer was really pleased with his work ...

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 20:47:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    NY wrote:

    Her main concern is that she may be being charged twice for two VOIP landlines (with the same number) if they feed different phones.

    Only if she makes two chargeable outbound calls at once, no charge per
    "line" though.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From NY@me@privacy.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 21:35:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 20/10/2026 20:46, Andy Burns wrote:
    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the DECT
    in one and the corded in the other

    More likely the router has a built-in DECT base that the handset speak
    to, and the corded phone is in the POTS port.
    Curiouser and curiouser. As far as I am aware POTS has been turned off
    on the old copper pair. But... the photo she's sent me shows just one
    "Phone" socket with a BT socket, as well as all the RJ45 for 4x LAN
    Ethernet and for WAN connection to the fibre modem. And the DECT phone
    is the same one she's had all along, not a special one which speaks VOIP.

    I will be intrigued to see how it's all connected when we next visit her
    - maybe at Christmas. Teamviewer is great for remote control of a PC and
    an Android phone, but it's no substitute for being able to follow a
    rats' next of cables and see where they go and what is plugged into
    what. Somewhere she should have a UPS, provided as backup because she's classed as "vulnerable" on account of her age, but goodness knows where
    it is and what is plugged into it.

    Does the analogue output of a router's VOIP interface (the "Phone"
    socket on the router) have a ringer-equivalence number? Can it drive
    more than one phone via a splitter (eg DECT and corded phone in parallel)?

    Do you ever get a VOIP output on the fibre modem (fibre termination
    unit), bypassing the router? Because her photo of the FTU has *three*
    cables going into it: power, Cat 5 probably to the router, and a third
    cable with a small white inline box. Could that box have one of the two
    phones plugged into it?

    https://i.postimg.cc/VsDJ6gp7/Image1.png

    White is power

    Red plug on black cable is WAN to router (WAN socket on router has same
    red plug/black cable)

    Third lead to small white box - could that be a WAN-to-analogue VOIP interface? Shame the black cable obscures the writing on the FTU for
    that socket, though everything has camera-shake...
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Finnigan@nix@genie.co.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 21:55:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 20/10/2026 21:35, NY wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 20:46, Andy Burns wrote:
    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the DECT
    in one and the corded in the other

    More likely the router has a built-in DECT base that the handset speak
    to, and the corded phone is in the POTS port.
    Curiouser and curiouser. As far as I am aware POTS has been turned off on the old copper pair. But... the photo she's sent me shows just one "Phone" socket with a BT socket, as well as all the RJ45 for 4x LAN Ethernet and
    for WAN connection to the fibre modem. And the DECT phone is the same one she's had all along, not a special one which speaks VOIP.

    I will be intrigued to see how it's all connected when we next visit her - maybe at Christmas. Teamviewer is great for remote control of a PC and an Android phone, but it's no substitute for being able to follow a rats' next of cables and see where they go and what is plugged into what. Somewhere
    she should have a UPS, provided as backup because she's classed as "vulnerable" on account of her age, but goodness knows where it is and what is plugged into it.

    Does the analogue output of a router's VOIP interface (the "Phone" socket
    on the router) have a ringer-equivalence number? Can it drive more than one phone via a splitter (eg DECT and corded phone in parallel)?

    Do you ever get a VOIP output on the fibre modem (fibre termination unit), bypassing the router? Because her photo of the FTU has *three* cables going into it: power, Cat 5 probably to the router, and a third cable with a
    small white inline box. Could that box have one of the two phones plugged into it?

    https://i.postimg.cc/VsDJ6gp7/Image1.png

    White is power

    Red plug on black cable is WAN to router (WAN socket on router has same red plug/black cable)

    Third lead to small white box - could that be a WAN-to-analogue VOIP interface? Shame the black cable obscures the writing on the FTU for that socket, though everything has camera-shake...

    I have that FTU, right hand is fibre in from the external box. I think
    the white box is just a neat cover. I'd guess the engineer switched the
    DECT phone to use the router as a base, and the corded phone into the ATA.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 22:10:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 20/10/2026 21:35, NY wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 20:46, Andy Burns wrote:
    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the
    DECT in one and the corded in the other

    More likely the router has a built-in DECT base that the handset speak
    to, and the corded phone is in the POTS port.
    Curiouser and curiouser. As far as I am aware POTS has been turned off
    on the old copper pair. But... the photo she's sent me shows just one "Phone" socket with a BT socket, as well as all the RJ45 for 4x LAN
    Ethernet and for WAN connection to the fibre modem. And the DECT phone
    is the same one she's had all along, not a special one which speaks VOIP.

    The DECT does not need to be special. The EE hub will act as a DECT base station and talk to any GAP compatible DECT handset.


    I will be intrigued to see how it's all connected when we next visit her
    - maybe at Christmas. Teamviewer is great for remote control of a PC and
    an Android phone, but it's no substitute for being able to follow a
    rats' next of cables and see where they go and what is plugged into
    what.

    If the BT line is disconnected they may have left the DECT base station plugged into it but not in use.

    Somewhere she should have a UPS, provided as backup because she's
    classed as "vulnerable" on account of her age, but goodness knows where
    it is and what is plugged into it.
    They just provide a battery. Perhaps that is why they linked the DECT to
    the EE router. You then don't need to put battery backup on the original
    DECT base.


    Does the analogue output of a router's VOIP interface (the "Phone"
    socket on the router) have a ringer-equivalence number? Can it drive
    more than one phone via a splitter (eg DECT and corded phone in parallel)?


    RENs are pretty irrelevant on modern phone systems. Most modern phones
    have a fractional REN so even if the box can in theory only drive 1 REN
    in practice it will drive multiple phones. If you have multiple phones
    you can get a back-to-back patch cable to patch the router into the
    house wiring.

    Do you ever get a VOIP output on the fibre modem (fibre termination
    unit), bypassing the router? Because her photo of the FTU has *three*
    cables going into it: power, Cat 5 probably to the router, and a third
    cable with a small white inline box. Could that box have one of the two phones plugged into it?

    The white cable is the Fibre. BT started with ONTs (not FTU) that had
    phone sockets, but OFCOM said it was anticompetitive so they now all use
    the router.


    https://i.postimg.cc/VsDJ6gp7/Image1.png

    White is power

    Red plug on black cable is WAN to router (WAN socket on router has same
    red plug/black cable)

    Third lead to small white box - could that be a WAN-to-analogue VOIP interface? Shame the black cable obscures the writing on the FTU for
    that socket, though everything has camera-shake...


    That is the Fibre.

    info on ONTs here

    https://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2022/09/pictured-openreachs-future-2-5gbps-ont-for-fttp-broadband.html

    (you may have to re-join URL)

    Like I said above the EE router is a DECT base station.

    Dave


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David Wade@g4ugm@dave.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 23:00:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 20/10/2026 22:10, David Wade wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:35, NY wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 20:46, Andy Burns wrote:
    Could it be that the router has two analogue BT sockets, with the
    DECT in one and the corded in the other

    More likely the router has a built-in DECT base that the handset
    speak to, and the corded phone is in the POTS port.
    Curiouser and curiouser. As far as I am aware POTS has been turned
    off on the old copper pair. But... the photo she's sent me shows just
    one "Phone" socket with a BT socket, as well as all the RJ45 for 4x
    LAN Ethernet and for WAN connection to the fibre modem. And the DECT
    phone is the same one she's had all along, not a special one which
    speaks VOIP.

    The DECT does not need to be special. The EE hub will act as a DECT
    base station and talk to any GAP compatible DECT handset.


    oh, from a quick google search, the EE hub supports two calls at once,
    three way calling and a few other features,




    I will be intrigued to see how it's all connected when we next visit
    her - maybe at Christmas. Teamviewer is great for remote control of a
    PC and an Android phone, but it's no substitute for being able to
    follow a rats' next of cables and see where they go and what is
    plugged into what.

    If the BT line is disconnected they may have left the DECT base
    station plugged into it but not in use.

    Somewhere she should have a UPS, provided as backup because she's
    classed as "vulnerable" on account of her age, but goodness knows
    where it is and what is plugged into it.
    They just provide a battery. Perhaps that is why they linked the DECT
    to the EE router. You then don't need to put battery backup on the
    original DECT base.


    Does the analogue output of a router's VOIP interface (the "Phone"
    socket on the router) have a ringer-equivalence number? Can it drive
    more than one phone via a splitter (eg DECT and corded phone in
    parallel)?


    RENs are pretty irrelevant on modern phone systems. Most modern phones
    have a fractional REN so even if the box can in theory only drive 1
    REN in practice it will drive multiple phones. If you have multiple
    phones you can get a back-to-back patch cable to patch the router into
    the house wiring.

    Do you ever get a VOIP output on the fibre modem (fibre termination
    unit), bypassing the router? Because her photo of the FTU has *three*
    cables going into it: power, Cat 5 probably to the router, and a
    third cable with a small white inline box. Could that box have one of
    the two phones plugged into it?

    The white cable is the Fibre. BT started with ONTs (not FTU) that had
    phone sockets, but OFCOM said it was anticompetitive so they now all
    use the router.


    https://i.postimg.cc/VsDJ6gp7/Image1.png

    White is power

    Red plug on black cable is WAN to router (WAN socket on router has
    same red plug/black cable)

    Third lead to small white box - could that be a WAN-to-analogue VOIP
    interface? Shame the black cable obscures the writing on the FTU for
    that socket, though everything has camera-shake...


    That is the Fibre.

    info on ONTs here

    https://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2022/09/pictured-openreachs-future-2-5gbps-ont-for-fttp-broadband.html


    (you may have to re-join URL)

    Like I said above the EE router is a DECT base station.

    Dave



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From NY@me@privacy.net to uk.telecom.broadband on Tue Oct 20 23:03:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 20/10/2026 22:10, David Wade wrote:
    The DECT does not need to be special. The EE hub will act as a DECT base station and talk to any GAP compatible DECT handset.

    Ah. I hadn't realise that some routers included the DECT
    transmitter/receiver. However, just to complicate matters, AFAIK the answerphone in her original DECT phone is still being used: I had to
    jump though hoops to get EE to increase the number of rings on 1571
    voicemail so her answerphone still kicked-in first at her preferred 8 rings.

    The white cable is the Fibre. BT started with ONTs (not FTU) that had
    phone sockets, but OFCOM said it was anticompetitive so they now all use
    the router.

    Of course it is :-) It takes a special sort of stupid (mine) to forget
    that one of the cables going into an ONT will be the fibre...
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 21 02:03:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/20 22:10:30, David Wade wrote:
    []
    info on ONTs here

    https://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2022/09/pictured-openreachs-future-2-5gbps-ont-for-fttp-broadband.html

    (you may have to re-join URL)
    []
    If you think a URL may be split by a line-break, enclose it in <> - that
    still won't make it foolproof, but will increase the number of cases
    where any newline won't break it.
    <Like
    this.>
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband on Wed Oct 21 08:09:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    NY wrote:

    Do you ever get a VOIP output on the fibre modem

    You used to, but that type of ONT is no longer supplied.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2