I see we currently have:
uk.telecom
uk.telecom.broadband
uk.telecom.voip
It occurs to me to wonder, especially after POTS switchoff, what will
be on the three 'groups. The VoIP one is fairly obvious; I can't think
of anything else we discuss here that wouldn't be applicable to
_either_ of the other two. (Discussion of POTS being appropriate to
only uk.telecom, but will cease?)
Maybe we should think of retiring one of the first two? I've nothing
against either of them, it's just wearing deciding which of them to
post in - and always crossposting to both would indeed suggest that
they aren't both needed.
What do others think? no hurry - there's justification for all three
at the moment.
What do others think?
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
What do others think?
Going as far as deleting groups is never worthwhile IMHO.
Because I use thunderbird, cross-posts are inconvenient and just mean
I see every message multiple times. Maybe we could generally agree to
not use uk.telecom, then use uk.telecom.broadband for actual internet connectivity and uk.telecom.voip for speech, with crossposts
discouraged?
Did you forget about uk.telecom.mobile?
I see we currently have:
uk.telecom
uk.telecom.broadband
uk.telecom.voip
It occurs to me to wonder, especially after POTS switchoff, what will be
on the three 'groups. The VoIP one is fairly obvious; I can't think of anything else we discuss here that wouldn't be applicable to _either_ of
the other two. (Discussion of POTS being appropriate to only uk.telecom,
but will cease?)
Maybe we should think of retiring one of the first two? I've nothing
against either of them, it's just wearing deciding which of them to post
in - and always crossposting to both would indeed suggest that they
aren't both needed.
What do others think? no hurry - there's justification for all three at
the moment.
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
What do others think?
Going as far as deleting groups is never worthwhile IMHO.
Because I use thunderbird, cross-posts are inconvenient and just mean I
see every message multiple times. Maybe we could generally agree to not
use uk.telecom, then use uk.telecom.broadband for actual internet connectivity and uk.telecom.voip for speech, with crossposts discouraged?
Did you forget about uk.telecom.mobile?
I see we currently have:
uk.telecom
uk.telecom.broadband
uk.telecom.voip
It occurs to me to wonder, especially after POTS switchoff, what will be
on the three 'groups. The VoIP one is fairly obvious; I can't think of anything else we discuss here that wouldn't be applicable to _either_ of
the other two. (Discussion of POTS being appropriate to only uk.telecom,
but will cease?)
Maybe we should think of retiring one of the first two? I've nothing
against either of them, it's just wearing deciding which of them to post
in - and always crossposting to both would indeed suggest that they
aren't both needed.
What do others think? no hurry - there's justification for all three at
the moment.
I know actually closing 'groups is a slow and complicated process
news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that, news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the
impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that, news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
I know actually closing 'groups is a slow and complicated process
And tends to make archives less accessible ...
Roger Mills <mills37.fslife@gmail.com> wrote
[rCa]
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that, news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
<https://www.newsdemon.com/usenet-access>
rCais currently offering 50GB of Usenet access for a massive -u2:40 for a one-off payment; other options are available.
That amount of data in text-only groups will last essentially forever.
It claims:
256-Bit SSL Encryption
? 3 Server Regions: US East -+ US West -+ EU
?? Zero Logging
? 4.6/5 Customer Rating
? 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
What's not to like?
We cannot let Usenet die. We can't let Zuckerberg and co. take over the internet.
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that, news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
Am 18.10.26 um 12:50 schrieb Roger Mills:
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the
impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that,
news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
Various other servers exist - some free to use.
PS: Technical newsgroups are a really interesting place, I started in
2021 and never experienced how it was in the 90s.
The social media sites are just a huge junkjard. I do not use them.
The best 'forums' are those that are frequented by industry insiders, no Usenet groups are now, so they end up with circular echo-chamber style moaning about impending switch offs etc. The best forum for Telecom
related stuff these days is inside Mark Jackson's ISP Review site
Some Reddit groups are worthwhile, because they contain really niche
groups. I find the Octopus, UKSolar and UK-EV groups really good of
Billing and EV Smart charging issues (there are plenty) but threads
don't last longer than a day or so, so there are multiple threads on the same topic. Easy to attach photos and screen-shots though
Roger Mills <mills37.fslife@gmail.com> wrote
[rCa]
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get the impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others
use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that, news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
<https://www.newsdemon.com/usenet-access>
rCais currently offering 50GB of Usenet access for a massive -u2:40 for a one-off payment; other options are available.
That amount of data in text-only groups will last essentially forever.
It claims:
256-Bit SSL Encryption
EfiE 3 Server Regions: US East -+ US West -+ EU
EfciN+A Zero Logging
r!E 4.6/5 Customer Rating
EfA# 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
WhatrCOs not to like?
I don't think it's worth worrying about. Any groups which are no longer relevant simply won't get used.The difficulty is knowing _which_ to use - in this case, for anything
Usenet itself is close to the end of its shelf life anyway. I get theSadly that _may_ be true - but it has been being said for some decades,
impression that it's only old codgers like me who still use it. Others > use various types of social, media instead. Besides all that,I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
news.individual.net - which many of use as our usenet server - is
shortly going to stop operation, and I predict that many of its users
will say that they can't be arsed to find an alternative.
<https://www.newsdemon.com/usenet-access>
rCais currently offering 50GB of Usenet access for a massive -u2:40 for a one-off payment; other options are available.
That amount of data in text-only groups will last essentially forever.
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
On 18/10/2026 in message <11b3c9r$1ghaa$1@dont-email.me> J. P. Gilliver wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
I would be happy to pay for a NIN replacement, don't know if that is
worth a separate thread?
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
You're probably into your second free year of NIN as they wind-down,
nothing stopping us from donating the re410 to Ray already ...
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small >donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small
donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small
donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when >>>> NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small
donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details. You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card >> and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >> The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full >> consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But
thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
Yes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >>> The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>> thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I even heard some suggestion that if you use it without storing money in
it - i. e. when you use it, it takes the money immediately from your
card - that the protection may still apply.
I think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I wasYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
details of either your card or bank. (I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy
things from don't.)
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >>> The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>> thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I even heard some suggestion that if you use it without storing money in
it - i. e. when you use it, it takes the money immediately from your
card - that the protection may still apply.
I think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I wasYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
details of either your card or bank.
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy
things from don't.)
Am 20.10.26 um 13:40 schrieb AnthonyL:
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I do not see how PayPal transfers your address to E-S if you use PayPal >friends. You do not need buyer protection here.
AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when >>>> NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small
donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card >and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details. >You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full >consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
On Tue, 20 Oct 2026 20:26:54 +0200, Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de> wrote:
Am 20.10.26 um 13:40 schrieb AnthonyL:
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I do not see how PayPal transfers your address to E-S if you use PayPal
friends. You do not need buyer protection here.
That's not what I said; I said if I paid by Credit card I need to
enter my home (ie credit card) address.
On Tue, 20 Oct 2026 11:47:02 -0000 (UTC), Tweed
<usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when >>>>> NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it. >>>>>
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small >>>> donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card >> and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >> The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full >> consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But
thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I have recollections of the major issues in its early days.
But if you pay by paypal they automatically give that out anyway. How
else do they know where to send goods?
On Tue, 20 Oct 2026 20:26:54 +0200, Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de> wrote:
Am 20.10.26 um 13:40 schrieb AnthonyL:
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I do not see how PayPal transfers your address to E-S if you use PayPal
friends. You do not need buyer protection here.
That's not what I said; I said if I paid by Credit card I need to
enter my home (ie credit card) address.
On 20/10/2026 20:46, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
What|ore4raos wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesn|ore4raot get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps.
The only real downside is you don|ore4raot, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>>> that|ore4raos only relevant for amounts over |e-u100.
I even heard some suggestion that if you use it without storing money in
it - i. e. when you use it, it takes the money immediately from your
card - that the protection may still apply.
I think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I wasYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
details of either your card or bank.
no, paypal has those. but people i buy from don't
(I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy
things from don't.)
exactly.
On 21/10/2026 15:04, Ian wrote:
On 2026-10-21, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:Exactly, If the customer complains the vendor loses out with no question
On 21/10/2026 11:39, AnthonyL wrote:
On Tue, 20 Oct 2026 11:47:02 -0000 (UTC), TweedBiggest issues I have had with paypal is its refusal to investigate
<usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote: >>>>>>
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when
NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN >>>>>>>> charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it. >>>>>>>>
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at >>>>>>> the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small >>>>>>> donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers. >>>>>>>
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've >>>>>> avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S >>>>>> (and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I >>>>>> buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up >>>>>> putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing >>>>>> a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps.
The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>>>> thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I have recollections of the major issues in its early days.
fraud by customers.
On the few occasions I've had to dispute a transaction I've always had a full
refund, and it was much easier than going through the CC chargeback route. >> Another payment handler that I've had to use had no such dispute mechanism, >> and the only option would be via the funding CC provider, which could be
complicated by using an intermediary.
And if te cutsomer is a scabby tea leaf, he gets paid out for nothing
AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
On Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:31:46 +0100, snipeco.2@gmail.com (Sn!pe) wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I do fear for eternal-september - will it be able to take the load when >>>> NIN closes? I hope so; I'd also gladly pay Ray something like NIN
charges (or even 150-200% as much), should he choose to implement it.
There is a PayPal donation button on the Eternal-September website at
the bottom left of each page. IMO every E-S user ought to make a small
donation to help pay for bandwidth and the remotely-hosted servers.
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I am finding of course this makes small donations a pain and I end up
putting the thought into the roundtuit tray.
So how best to create a PayPal a/c, keep myself secure whilst allowing
a coffee or two to be bought for the hardworking souls who try to
respect the original ethos of the internet?
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card >and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details. >You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps. >The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full >consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
On 20/10/2026 20:46, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps.
The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>>> thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I even heard some suggestion that if you use it without storing money in
it - i. e. when you use it, it takes the money immediately from your
card - that the protection may still apply.
I think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I wasYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
details of either your card or bank.
no, paypal has those. but people i buy from don't
(I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy
things from don't.)
exactly.
For those who weren't around when Paypal started up do a search for,
or ask your favourite AI: "what were the early concerns about paypal"
eg: In its early days around 2000, PayPal faced severe existential
concerns, including rampant financial fraud causing millions in
monthly losses, high customer acquisition and credit card processing
costs, a lack of sustainable revenue, and aggressive competition from
eBay
It was to be avoided. I've not kept abreast of its development but my
brain still has those memories embedded.
On 2026/10/21 11:4:10, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 20:46, J. P. Gilliver wrote:So why /do/ you "keep it in credit"? I never put any money into my
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 12:47, Tweed wrote:[]
WhatrCOs wrong with PayPal? It provides a firebreak between your credit card
and the retailer, in as much as the retailer doesnrCOt get your card details.
You can secure your PayPal account login via one of the authenticator apps.
The only real downside is you donrCOt, if I remember correctly, get the full
consumer protection that paying directly by a credit card gives you. But >>>>> thatrCOs only relevant for amounts over -u100.
I even heard some suggestion that if you use it without storing money in >>> it - i. e. when you use it, it takes the money immediately from your
card - that the protection may still apply.
I think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I wasYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
details of either your card or bank.
no, paypal has those. but people i buy from don't
(I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy
things from don't.)
exactly.
PayPal account (if I even have one); when I pay for something with
PayPal, a charge for that amount appears on my CC statement.
On 21/10/2026 21:31, J. P. Gilliver wrote:[]
On 2026/10/21 11:4:10, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 20:46, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
I THINK there is a charge for thatSo why /do/ you "keep it in credit"? I never put any money into myYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: II think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I was >>>> going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get
transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in credit
details of either your card or bank.
no, paypal has those. but people i buy from don't
(I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy >>>> things from don't.)
exactly.
PayPal account (if I even have one); when I pay for something with
PayPal, a charge for that amount appears on my CC statement.
On 2026/10/22 8:49:43, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 21/10/2026 21:31, J. P. Gilliver wrote:[]
On 2026/10/21 11:4:10, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 20/10/2026 20:46, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/20 15:24:36, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
Not for me; I buy something on ebay, pay with PayPal, and a chargeI THINK there is a charge for thatSo why /do/ you "keep it in credit"? I never put any money into myYes. I run a paypal account because its very handy for some uses: I >>>>>> transfer some moolah in from my bank account to keep it in creditI think _that_ might remove the protection, if it applies anyway. I was >>>>> going to ask why you do that, but presumably so that PayPal don't get >>>>> details of either your card or bank.
no, paypal has those. but people i buy from don't
(I have my card with PayPal - OK,
they have my card details, but at least the odd little retailers I buy >>>>> things from don't.)
exactly.
PayPal account (if I even have one); when I pay for something with
PayPal, a charge for that amount appears on my CC statement.
appears on my CC bill for the amount I saw as the price of the item on ebay.
Is is /possible/ I paid a one-time charge to PayPal, but if I did it
would have been many years ago, and I don't /think/ I ever did.
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
in the same way that credit card companies charge the vendor ?
On 2026/10/22 22:59:18, Abandoned Trolley wrote:
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
... with its
encouragement not to use cash - even contactless where possible - to
reduce the spread.
We have a similar situation with direct debit: for many things (this is actually now back on-topic for at least telecom!)
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/22 22:59:18, Abandoned Trolley wrote:
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
[snip]
... with its
encouragement not to use cash - even contactless where possible - to
reduce the spread.
We have a similar situation with direct debit: for many things (this is
actually now back on-topic for at least telecom!)
[snip]
Recent statements on the news tell us all to carry some cash for when banking systems crash. But the problem these days is that many vendors (small businesses in Scotland especially) will only accept card
payments. Not surprising really, when it may ba a 200km round trip to
the nearest bank. We could see the return of barter systems.
I think direct debits should be disallowed on principle. The bank is my servant, not the servant of the electricity/phone/gas/tax people who all make mistakes. It's all very well to say that there is a guarantee to
allow you to recover money taken in error, but that's a bit like saying murder is illegal and we will guarantee to bring the victim back to life
if he was killed in error!
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/22 22:59:18, Abandoned Trolley wrote:
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
[snip]
... with its
encouragement not to use cash - even contactless where possible - to
reduce the spread.
We have a similar situation with direct debit: for many things (this is
actually now back on-topic for at least telecom!)
[snip]
Recent statements on the news tell us all to carry some cash for when banking systems crash.-a But the problem these days is that many vendors (small businesses in Scotland especially) will only accept card
payments.-a Not surprising really, when it may ba a 200km round trip to
the nearest bank.-a We could see the return of barter systems.
I think direct debits should be disallowed on principle.-a The bank is my servant, not the servant of the electricity/phone/gas/tax people who all make mistakes.-a It's all very well to say that there is a guarantee to allow you to recover money taken in error, but that's a bit like saying murder is illegal and we will guarantee to bring the victim back to life
if he was killed in error!
On 2026/10/22 22:59:18, Abandoned Trolley wrote:
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
in the same way that credit card companies charge the vendor ?
Who absorbs it, presumably, since they don't show different prices.
On 21/10/2026 11:34, AnthonyL wrote:
On Tue, 20 Oct 2026 20:26:54 +0200, Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de> wrote:But if you pay by paypal they automatically give that out anyway. How
Am 20.10.26 um 13:40 schrieb AnthonyL:
A little off-topic but related to the donation issue. Thus far I've
avoided PayPal, possible paranoia. But if I pay by Credit card E-S
(and others) require my address which I don't mind for major sites I
buy from but do mind for others, including E-S.
I do not see how PayPal transfers your address to E-S if you use PayPal
friends. You do not need buyer protection here.
That's not what I said; I said if I paid by Credit card I need to
enter my home (ie credit card) address.
else do they know where to send goods?
Graham J <nobody@nowhere.co.uk> wrote:[]
I think direct debits should be disallowed on principle. The bank is my
servant, not the servant of the electricity/phone/gas/tax people who all
make mistakes. It's all very well to say that there is a guarantee to
allow you to recover money taken in error, but that's a bit like saying
murder is illegal and we will guarantee to bring the victim back to life
if he was killed in error!
Does any organisation of significance *force* you to use direct debits? IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.
On 23/10/2026 07:33, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/22 22:59:18, Abandoned Trolley wrote:I am not sure if it still applies, but at one time retailers agreements
Oh, I think you are right. PayPal charges the VENDOR
in the same way that credit card companies charge the vendor ?
Who absorbs it, presumably, since they don't show different prices.
with card companies required them to offer identical prices
Some of the commission rates are quite high, which explains a large
number of shop not accepting AmEx cards any more
On 2026/10/23 8:36:0, Tweed wrote:
Graham J <nobody@nowhere.co.uk> wrote:[]
I think direct debits should be disallowed on principle. The bank is my
Certainly for anything involving a regular payment of a fixed amount.
I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utilityservant, not the servant of the electricity/phone/gas/tax people who all >>> make mistakes. It's all very well to say that there is a guarantee to
allow you to recover money taken in error, but that's a bit like saying >>> murder is illegal and we will guarantee to bring the victim back to life >>> if he was killed in error!
Does any organisation of significance *force* you to use direct debits?
IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.
companies if you want their best tariffs.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/23 8:36:0, Tweed wrote:
Graham J <nobody@nowhere.co.uk> wrote:[]
Certainly for anything involving a regular payment of a fixed amount.I think direct debits should be disallowed on principle. The bank is my >>
I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utilityservant, not the servant of the electricity/phone/gas/tax people who all >>>> make mistakes. It's all very well to say that there is a guarantee to >>>> allow you to recover money taken in error, but that's a bit like saying >>>> murder is illegal and we will guarantee to bring the victim back to life >>>> if he was killed in error!
Does any organisation of significance *force* you to use direct debits?
IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.
companies if you want their best tariffs.
IrCOve checked a couple of major ISPs and they reluctantly allow payment via credit/debit cards as well as direct debit. As to getting the best fuel
tariffs, as others have stated not using direct debit imposes costs on the supplier. So if you wish to impose those costs donrCOt be surprised if you are expected to pay them. My ISP charges my credit card. TheyrCOve never asked for a direct debit.
On 2026/10/25 6:6:57, Tweed wrote:
IrCOve checked a couple of major ISPs and they reluctantly allow payment via >> credit/debit cards as well as direct debit. As to getting the best fuel
If they do, it'll be by CCA (continuous credit authorisation) - i. e.
you have to authorise them to take unspecified payments from your credit
Does any organisation of significance*force* you to use direct debits?I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utility
IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.
companies if you want their best tariffs.
On 24/10/2026 22:08, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Does any organisation of significance*force* you to use direct debits?I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utility
IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.
companies if you want their best tariffs.
It simplifies accounting and means less people need to be employed: It
is a saving that is passed on.
You can cancel at any time
On 2026/10/25 9:48:18, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 24/10/2026 22:08, J. P. Gilliver wrote:You can instruct your bank to stop paying a DD, and they will. You
Does any organisation of significance*force* you to use direct debits? >>>> IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utility
companies if you want their best tariffs.
It simplifies accounting and means less people need to be employed: It
is a saving that is passed on.
You can cancel at any time
cannot necessarily cancel the contract with the supplier you have agreed
to, which may specify DD as the only payment they will accept; if you
try to, they may well impose an early termination charge, which in the
case of ISPs, is usually the monthly charge times the number of months remaining, i. e. the entire cost you'd have paid if you _didn't_ cancel.
On 2026/10/25 9:48:18, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 24/10/2026 22:08, J. P. Gilliver wrote:You can instruct your bank to stop paying a DD, and they will. You
Does any organisation of significance*force* you to use direct debits? >>>> IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utility
companies if you want their best tariffs.
It simplifies accounting and means less people need to be employed: It
is a saving that is passed on.
You can cancel at any time
cannot necessarily cancel the contract with the supplier you have agreed
to, which may specify DD as the only payment they will accept; if you
try to, they may well impose an early termination charge, which in the
case of ISPs, is usually the monthly charge times the number of months remaining, i. e. the entire cost you'd have paid if you _didn't_ cancel.
I think you are going to have to come up with a list of major ISPs that wonrCOt accept any other payment method. Even the customer hostile Virgin Media accepts a wide range of payments.
On 26/10/2026 06:59, Tweed wrote:
I think you are going to have to come up with a list of major ISPs thatI certainly get a notional discount fore DD electricity with the company holding a load of my funds permanently in presumably interest bearing accounts
wonrCOt accept any other payment method. Even the customer hostile Virgin
Media accepts a wide range of payments.
On 26/10/2026 06:59, Tweed wrote:
I think you are going to have to come up with a list of major ISPs thatI certainly get a notional discount fore DD electricity with the company holding a load of my funds permanently in presumably interest bearing accounts
wonrCOt accept any other payment method. Even the customer hostile Virgin
Media accepts a wide range of payments.
On 26/10/2026 00:49, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/25 9:48:18, The Natural Philosopher wrote:Which you can refuse to pay.
On 24/10/2026 22:08, J. P. Gilliver wrote:You can instruct your bank to stop paying a DD, and they will. You
Does any organisation of significance*force* you to use direct debits? >>>>> IrCOve used them for very many years and have never had an issue.I believe most internet service providers do, yes. And most utility
companies if you want their best tariffs.
It simplifies accounting and means less people need to be employed: It
is a saving that is passed on.
You can cancel at any time
cannot necessarily cancel the contract with the supplier you have agreed
to, which may specify DD as the only payment they will accept; if you
try to, they may well impose an early termination charge, which in the
case of ISPs, is usually the monthly charge times the number of months
remaining, i. e. the entire cost you'd have paid if you _didn't_ cancel.
But if you signed up to a long term contract to get a cheaper rate,
caveat emptor.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:01:15 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,989 |