• "Reply-to" vs. "From".

    From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Sun Oct 11 18:47:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Is "Reply-to" often ignored, including by companies/organisations?

    I've recently changed my "From" address (in emails, not news posts), to
    keep Greenby happy, as they've recently tightened their outgoing-email checking. At the same time, I introduced a Reply-to to all outgoing emails.

    I ask because I'm getting lots of replies to the From address, including
    from official bodies (such as the ASA).

    Thunderbird 'group included in case there's anything I can do in the TB settings to make the Reply-to address more prominent than the From one,
    but I suspect there isn't.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    1974: not one member of the British jury gave the Swedish band a single
    point.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Sun Oct 11 20:46:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Am 11.10.26 um 19:47 schrieb J. P. Gilliver:
    Is "Reply-to" often ignored, including by companies/organisations?

    Some software ignores this header, most likely automatic replies or
    certain mail apps people use.

    Do not rely on it.
    --
    Gru|f
    Marco

    Spam bitte an abfalleimer2001@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From dillinger@dillinger@not.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Sun Oct 11 23:44:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Op 11/10/2026 om 19:47 schreef J. P. Gilliver:
    Is "Reply-to" often ignored, including by companies/organisations?

    I've recently changed my "From" address (in emails, not news posts), to
    keep Greenby happy, as they've recently tightened their outgoing-email checking. At the same time, I introduced a Reply-to to all outgoing emails.

    I ask because I'm getting lots of replies to the From address, including
    from official bodies (such as the ASA).

    Thunderbird 'group included in case there's anything I can do in the TB settings to make the Reply-to address more prominent than the From one,
    but I suspect there isn't.

    Reply-to can and will be ignored, I do sometimes.

    Assuming this is about a 255soft address, why are you not using the
    servers there?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Sun Oct 11 23:22:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/11 22:44:40, dillinger wrote:
    Op 11/10/2026 om 19:47 schreef J. P. Gilliver:
    Is "Reply-to" often ignored, including by companies/organisations?

    I've recently changed my "From" address (in emails, not news posts), to
    keep Greenby happy, as they've recently tightened their outgoing-email
    checking. At the same time, I introduced a Reply-to to all outgoing emails. >>
    I ask because I'm getting lots of replies to the From address, including
    from official bodies (such as the ASA).

    Thunderbird 'group included in case there's anything I can do in the TB
    settings to make the Reply-to address more prominent than the From one,
    but I suspect there isn't.

    Reply-to can and will be ignored, I do sometimes.

    When you say you do, does that mean your client does and you have to
    manually do something if you get an email with a Reply-to, or do you
    mean your client obeys it and you override it?


    Assuming this is about a 255soft address, why are you not using the
    servers there?

    Not sure! Lethargy, mainly, plus something I can't quite put my finger on.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    what - recession? Up north? What we gonna have - more nowt?
    (News Quiz 2013-7-26)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From dillinger@dillinger@not.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 00:58:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Op 12/10/2026 om 00:22 schreef J. P. Gilliver:
    Reply-to can and will be ignored, I do sometimes.
    When you say you do, does that mean your client does and you have to
    manually do something if you get an email with a Reply-to, or do you
    mean your client obeys it and you override it?


    In TB you can always see if reply-to is set in a message, my TB selects
    it automatically, if I want to use the from: address I have to choose
    that manually.

    Assuming this is about a 255soft address, why are you not using the
    servers there?
    Not sure! Lethargy, mainly, plus something I can't quite put my finger on.

    Have a look at it, it doesn't look too complicated to me and it would
    save you all of this reply-to and send as trouble.
    If you could ditch Greenby it might even save you some money.

    https://help.krystal.io/email/adding-a-new-c-panel-email-account https://help.krystal.io/mail-clients/setting-up-mozilla-thunderbird
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 07:05:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/11 23:58:29, dillinger wrote:
    Op 12/10/2026 om 00:22 schreef J. P. Gilliver:
    Reply-to can and will be ignored, I do sometimes.
    When you say you do, does that mean your client does and you have to
    manually do something if you get an email with a Reply-to, or do you
    mean your client obeys it and you override it?


    In TB you can always see if reply-to is set in a message, my TB selects
    it automatically, if I want to use the from: address I have to choose
    that manually.

    Yes; I assumed that was the case for most clients - however, the person (attribution lines have been lost) saying "I sometimes ignore it"
    suggested that maybe there are clients that don't automatically use it.


    Assuming this is about a 255soft address, why are you not using the
    servers there?
    Not sure! Lethargy, mainly, plus something I can't quite put my finger on.

    Have a look at it, it doesn't look too complicated to me and it would
    save you all of this reply-to and send as trouble.

    Thanks, I will ...

    If you could ditch Greenby it might even save you some money.

    ... certainly when my free time with Greenby runs out.


    https://help.krystal.io/email/adding-a-new-c-panel-email-account https://help.krystal.io/mail-clients/setting-up-mozilla-thunderbird
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Veni, Vidi, Video (I came, I saw, I'll watch it again later)
    - Mik from S+AS Limited (mik@saslimited.demon.co.uk), 1998
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 06:57:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:

    Is "Reply-to" often ignored, including by companies/organisations?

    I've recently changed my "From" address (in emails, not news posts), to
    keep Greenby happy, as they've recently tightened their outgoing-email >checking.

    I suggest that you send messages through the SMTP server associated with
    the domain. I'm guessing that's what's being blocked.

    At the same time, I introduced a Reply-to to all outgoing emails.

    Can't you use this address on From and use its associated SMTP server?

    I ask because I'm getting lots of replies to the From address, including
    from official bodies (such as the ASA).

    You cannot force the user to correspond with you at Reply-To in reply.

    Also, if you established contact information with ASA, they may use it
    by policy (or sometimes by statute) in correspondence depending on the
    nature of the message.

    Thunderbird 'group included in case there's anything I can do in the TB >settings to make the Reply-to address more prominent than the From one,
    but I suspect there isn't.

    It's not an issue at your client but your correspondent's policy.

    In any event, I woukdn't use Reply-To for every message.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 07:11:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:

    . . .

    When you say you do, does that mean your client does and you have to
    manually do something if you get an email with a Reply-to, or do you
    mean your client obeys it and you override it?

    In alpine, the user replying to a meaasage with Reply-To is presented
    with the Reply-To address on To in the composer, but he can delete it
    and enter another address.

    There is a feature that I enabled to confirm use of Reply-To or use From instead.

    Every client has a different implementation method.

    . . .
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Stan Brown@someone@example.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 13:25:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:05:39 +0100, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/10/11 23:58:29, dillinger wrote:
    [quoted text muted]

    In TB you can always see if reply-to is set in a message, my TB selects
    it automatically, if I want to use the from: address I have to choose
    that manually.

    Yes; I assumed that was the case for most clients - however, the person (attribution lines have been lost) saying "I sometimes ignore it"
    suggested that maybe there are clients that don't automatically use it.

    Of course there are. I would consider that a bug, but bugs don't
    always get fixed, even if people take the trouble to report them.

    Lord knows, people don't always speak or write precisely. That other
    poster might have meant "_I_ ignore the suggested Reply-to: address
    even though my mail client honors it. I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to." (I [Stan]
    have never heard of a mail client that wouldn't let you change a To:
    address, and I'd be surprised to learn that one exists.)

    Or that other poster may have meant something different.
    --
    Trolls wouldn't be trolling if nobody would take the flamebait.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From knuttle@keith_nuttle@yahoo.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Mon Oct 12 17:55:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 10/12/2026 4:25 PM, Stan Brown wrote:
    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:05:39 +0100, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
    On 2026/10/11 23:58:29, dillinger wrote:
    [quoted text muted]

    In TB you can always see if reply-to is set in a message, my TB selects
    it automatically, if I want to use the from: address I have to choose
    that manually.

    Yes; I assumed that was the case for most clients - however, the person
    (attribution lines have been lost) saying "I sometimes ignore it"
    suggested that maybe there are clients that don't automatically use it.

    Of course there are. I would consider that a bug, but bugs don't
    always get fixed, even if people take the trouble to report them.

    Lord knows, people don't always speak or write precisely. That other
    poster might have meant "_I_ ignore the suggested Reply-to: address
    even though my mail client honors it. I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to." (I [Stan]
    have never heard of a mail client that wouldn't let you change a To:
    address, and I'd be surprised to learn that one exists.)

    Or that other poster may have meant something different.

    I find it best to put the reply to address in the body of the message,
    as it is sure to be seen in the message. If I had it in most messages,
    I would put it in the Account Signature.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 01:17:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/12 22:55:51, knuttle wrote:
    On 10/12/2026 4:25 PM, Stan Brown wrote:
    []
    Lord knows, people don't always speak or write precisely. That other
    poster might have meant "_I_ ignore the suggested Reply-to: address
    even though my mail client honors it. I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to." (I [Stan]
    have never heard of a mail client that wouldn't let you change a To:
    address, and I'd be surprised to learn that one exists.)

    Or that other poster may have meant something different.

    Not sure if it was that poster or a different one, but someone has said
    his client has an option to override Reply-to.


    I find it best to put the reply to address in the body of the message,
    as it is sure to be seen in the message. If I had it in most messages,
    I would put it in the Account Signature.

    I have, in effect, now done that - but the line is above the "-- " line,
    since otherwise people might not see it in their reply editor.

    And before everyone jumps in and says switch anyway: I may well do so;
    I've just checked and my free time with Greenby doesn't actually run out
    until December 2027, and I (and my correspondents) may well get fed up
    before then.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    aibohphobia, n., The fear of palindromes.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@invalid@invalid.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 02:04:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 12/10/2026 21:25, Stan Brown wrote:
    I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to.


    If in doubt, why not send the email to both addresses? They both belong
    to the same person, so send replies to both addresses unless they
    specifically request otherwise.
    --
    *Newsgroup Post *


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 02:51:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/13 2:4:28, John wrote:
    On 12/10/2026 21:25, Stan Brown wrote:
    I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to.


    If in doubt, why not send the email to both addresses? They both belong
    to the same person, so send replies to both addresses unless they specifically request otherwise.



    Agreed, will do no harm, though the recipient will receive two copies.

    But it _could_ be argued that _by using a Reply-to_, the person _has_
    requested its use. though whether "specifically" I'm not sure.
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    By most scientific estimates sustained, useful fusion is ten years in
    the future - and will be ten years in the future for the next fifty
    years or more. - "Hamadryad", ~2016-4-4
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 03:00:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    John <invalid@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    On 12/10/2026 21:25, Stan Brown wrote:

    I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to.

    If in doubt, why not send the email to both addresses? They both belong
    to the same person, so send replies to both addresses unless they >specifically request otherwise.

    t could be a phishing attempt. The miscreant's address won't be
    recognized, so it's on Reply-To, hoping the potential victim won't
    notice.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From s|b@me@privacy.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 13:45:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On Sun, 11 Oct 2026 23:44:40 +0200, dillinger wrote:

    Reply-to can and will be ignored, I do sometimes.

    If you ignore it in my case you'll get a bounce as response.

    But I can understand why companies/organisations would ignore it.
    --
    Horum omnium fortissimi sunt Belgae.
    - Julius Caesar
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Andy Burns@usenet@andyburns.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 13:42:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    J. P. Gilliver wrote:

    Is "Reply-to" often ignored

    I would swear that i just saw someone claim that TB creates an
    "unsendable" message when it sees reply-to: and that the to: address
    needs to be manually added?

    I just tested it and it works fine for me ... but I seem to have lost
    all trace of the message from whoever said that.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Carlos E.R.@robin_listas@es.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 17:53:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026-10-13 05:00, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
    John <invalid@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    On 12/10/2026 21:25, Stan Brown wrote:

    I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to.

    If in doubt, why not send the email to both addresses? They both belong
    to the same person, so send replies to both addresses unless they
    specifically request otherwise.

    t could be a phishing attempt. The miscreant's address won't be
    recognized, so it's on Reply-To, hoping the potential victim won't
    notice.

    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    It can be an email in a compromised server that was used to post
    thousands of mails, and an email sent to it probably doesn't reach the spammers.
    --
    Cheers, Carlos.
    ESEfc-Efc+, EUEfc-Efc|;
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 16:23:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
    On 2026-10-13 05:00, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
    John <invalid@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    On 12/10/2026 21:25, Stan Brown wrote:

    I change the To: on the new
    message to match the From: of the one I'm replying to.

    If in doubt, why not send the email to both addresses? They both belong >>>to the same person, so send replies to both addresses unless they >>>specifically request otherwise.

    It could be a phishing attempt. The miscreant's address won't be >>recognized, so it's on Reply-To, hoping the potential victim won't
    notice.

    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    Phishing works best if the address on From is in use and recognizeable
    to the recipient. Phishing certainly uses foreries of email addresses
    currently in use.

    I agree that spam isn't necessarily a forgery of an email address in
    use.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@invalid@invalid.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 19:09:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 13/10/2026 16:53, Carlos E.R. wrote:
    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    It can be an email in a compromised server that was used to post
    thousands of mails, and an email sent to it probably doesn't reach the spammers.


    Sound judgement is always required when responding to emails. It's no
    wonder that banks and credit card companies require a mobile phone
    number for verification purposes, given that the likelihood of someone spoofing a phone number is very low, whereas the likelihood of someone spoofing an email address is very high.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Theo@theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 19:48:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Adam H. Kerman <ahk@chinet.com> wrote:
    Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:

    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    Phishing works best if the address on From is in use and recognizeable
    to the recipient. Phishing certainly uses foreries of email addresses currently in use.

    I agree that spam isn't necessarily a forgery of an email address in
    use.

    Due to SPF it's harder to spoof email addresses, so what's spoofed is the
    user name instead:

    From: National Bank <compromised-user@isp.example.net>

    A lot of mail clients, especially on mobile, hide the underlying address and just say the message is from 'National Bank'. So the chance to spot the discrepancy is lost.

    Theo
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Carlos E.R.@robin_listas@es.invalid to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 21:14:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026-10-13 20:48, Theo wrote:
    Adam H. Kerman <ahk@chinet.com> wrote:
    Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:

    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    Phishing works best if the address on From is in use and recognizeable
    to the recipient. Phishing certainly uses foreries of email addresses
    currently in use.

    I agree that spam isn't necessarily a forgery of an email address in
    use.

    Due to SPF it's harder to spoof email addresses, so what's spoofed is the user name instead:

    From: National Bank <compromised-user@isp.example.net>

    I was going to say that.


    A lot of mail clients, especially on mobile, hide the underlying address and just say the message is from 'National Bank'. So the chance to spot the discrepancy is lost.

    Exactly.



    Theo
    --
    Cheers, Carlos.
    ESEfc-Efc+, EUEfc-Efc|;
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 20:36:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/13 19:48:20, Theo wrote:
    []
    Due to SPF it's harder to spoof email addresses, so what's spoofed is the user name instead:

    From: National Bank <compromised-user@isp.example.net>

    A lot of mail clients, especially on mobile, hide the underlying address and just say the message is from 'National Bank'. So the chance to spot the discrepancy is lost.

    Theo

    A lot of clients - including Thunderbird - let you choose what is
    displayed on incoming messages. (I have it set to show both "name" and
    email address; I think that's the default.)
    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "English doesn't borrow from other languages. It follows them down
    dark alleys, clubs them on the head, and rifles through their pockets
    for loose grammar."
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 20:39:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    On 2026/10/13 19:9:4, John wrote:
    []
    Sound judgement is always required when responding to emails. It's no
    wonder that banks and credit card companies require a mobile phone
    number for verification purposes, given that the likelihood of someone spoofing a phone number is very low, whereas the likelihood of someone spoofing an email address is very high.


    It's a pain when they only accept a _mobile_ number, though.>


    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    "English doesn't borrow from other languages. It follows them down
    dark alleys, clubs them on the head, and rifles through their pockets
    for loose grammar."
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to uk.telecom.broadband,alt.comp.software.thunderbird on Tue Oct 13 21:12:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.telecom.broadband

    Theo <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
    Adam H. Kerman <ahk@chinet.com> wrote:
    Carlos E.R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:

    In phishing or spam, the address in the from field is burned.

    Phishing works best if the address on From is in use and recognizeable
    to the recipient. Phishing certainly uses foreries of email addresses
    currently in use.

    I agree that spam isn't necessarily a forgery of an email address in
    use.

    Due to SPF it's harder to spoof email addresses, so what's spoofed is the >user name instead:

    From: National Bank <compromised-user@isp.example.net>

    A lot of mail clients, especially on mobile, hide the underlying address and >just say the message is from 'National Bank'. So the chance to spot the >discrepancy is lost.

    Generally, spam and phishing I receive has DKIM and SPF, sometimes
    DMARC. It's all authenticated.

    Never was a countermeasure to spam.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2