J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I think there are certain parallels between IMAP and things like
OneDrive; some of us are uneasy about both, and don't really want to say
why :-)
I use Windows because there are a few business-critical programs that
don't have a Linux alternative. I use Linux where it's the better
option.
That being said, there is no analogy. OneDriive will happily delete
files at your storage capacity; the user is not being protected. All Microsoft account-based service force themselves on the user.
Installation tries to force accounr set up. An update changes settings
back to default, back to account-based services.
Under no circumstances am I forced to use IMAP and I've never had
settings changed with an update.
I'll bite: What dis-ease is there about IMAP? Note that I don't
syncronize. If I archive a message, it's always forwarded, then stored, deleting it from the inbox. If I don't want to archive a message, I
delete it from the inbox. I like IMAP because the inbox can be on one
host and the archive folder on another.
In the fetchmail documentation, developers recommended using imap over
pop3 for multiple reasons, one of them being safer and easier to handle.
IMAP could do the same things as PO3, and then more.
...
On 2026/10/2 21:13:38, Carlos E. R. wrote:
[]
In the fetchmail documentation, developers recommended using imap over
pop3 for multiple reasons, one of them being safer and easier to handle.
In what way safer?
--IMAP could do the same things as PO3, and then more.I think the main fear among we dinosaurs is that not only _can_ IMAP do
...
more, it _will_, even if we don't want it to (especially if we're only faintly aware of what they are).
On 2026-10-02 19:45, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I think there are certain parallels between IMAP and things like >>>OneDrive; some of us are uneasy about both, and don't really want to say >>>why :-)
I use Windows because there are a few business-critical programs that
don't have a Linux alternative. I use Linux where it's the better
option.
In Linux it was traditional to use "fetchmail" to get mail using POP3.
The thing is, when IMAP came, I simply changed some words in the
fetchmail config file, and mail continued to be downloaded to my local >storage. My mail was not in the cloud and I was using imap.
In the fetchmail documentation, developers recommended using imap over
pop3 for multiple reasons, one of them being safer and easier to handle. >IMAP could do the same things as PO3, and then more.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I meant in the way they work. AIUI (I've never actually used IMAP), if
you create a folder one one device, it gets created on the remote one
and all others involved with that account - and something similar for
files and folders.
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol.
It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
On 2026/10/2 21:30:3, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I meant in the way they work. AIUI (I've never actually used IMAP), if >>>you create a folder one one device, it gets created on the remote one
and all others involved with that account - and something similar for >>>files and folders.
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol.
It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_
sync, what is its advantage?
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/2 21:30:3, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I meant in the way they work. AIUI (I've never actually used IMAP), if >>>> you create a folder one one device, it gets created on the remote one
and all others involved with that account - and something similar for
files and folders.
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol.
It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_
sync, what is its advantage?
I have my message archive folders on one host, with inboxes on a variet
of different hopes. IMAP allows me to check, save, or delete messages
between folders on different hosts. POP3 can ceck an inbox only.
OK, so it's a multi-host file (or email) manager. As I only have one
host, it's not for me - I can see it is for some.
I meant in the way they work. AIUI (I've never actually used IMAP), if
you create a folder one one device, it gets created on the remote one
and all others involved with that account - and something similar for
files and folders.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
I think there are certain parallels between IMAP and things like
OneDrive; some of us are uneasy about both, and don't really want to say
why :-)
I use Windows because there are a few business-critical programs that
don't have a Linux alternative. I use Linux where it's the better
option.
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol. >>>It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_ >>sync, what is its advantage?
Most IMAP users will choose to sync the inbox, sent items, and perhaps
spam and drafts folders, with most servers you can create any other
folders you like to organise the mailbox, they won't automatically sync,
but most clients will let you choose ...
Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol.
It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_
sync, what is its advantage?
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol. >>>> It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_
sync, what is its advantage?
Most IMAP users will choose to sync the inbox, sent items, and perhaps
spam and drafts folders, with most servers you can create any other
folders you like to organise the mailbox, they won't automatically sync,
but most clients will let you choose ...
I would not phrase it like that.
Like pine/alpine, IMAP was written at UWash to support its own students
who used email, perhaps for the first time at college.
pine and alpine don't sync.
The protocol supports syncing but it's a Mail client feature. The user
must both desire syncing and choose a Mail client like Thunderbird that syncs. There may be Mail clients invoked from the Unix or linux shell
that both support IMAP and syncing, but someone else will have to tell
us. In my opinion, syncing increases the chance of an unwanted handling
of a message because there is more than one host affected.
Syncing is undesireable. Other users want syncing despite this increased
risk of mishandling.
On 2026-10-03 20:29, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol. >>>>>It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_ >>>>sync, what is its advantage?
Most IMAP users will choose to sync the inbox, sent items, and perhaps >>>spam and drafts folders, with most servers you can create any other >>>folders you like to organise the mailbox, they won't automatically sync, >>>but most clients will let you choose ...
I would not phrase it like that.
Like pine/alpine, IMAP was written at UWash to support its own students
who used email, perhaps for the first time at college.
pine and alpine don't sync.
Fetchmail downloads. I have used pop3 or imap with fetchmail to download >from remote servers to local machine, to then read with Pine.
The protocol supports syncing but it's a Mail client feature. The user
must both desire syncing and choose a Mail client like Thunderbird that >>syncs. There may be Mail clients invoked from the Unix or linux shell
that both support IMAP and syncing, but someone else will have to tell
us. In my opinion, syncing increases the chance of an unwanted handling
of a message because there is more than one host affected.
Syncing is undesireable. Other users want syncing despite this increased >>risk of mishandling.
As we have the Thunderbird group in these posts, TB syncs just fine. I
never noticed a problem, using more than one computer.
Unless you are working offline, then the local version might differ from
the remote version.
I swear I'll get to the backlong in my inbox some day.
Seriously, IMAP works so nicely with multiple hosts, syncing gives me no added advantage.
On 2026/10/4 17:2:56, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Seriously, IMAP works so nicely with multiple hosts, syncing gives me no >>added advantage.
I thought syncing was the main advantage of IMAP?!? (Even the _point_?)
pine and IMAP were developed together at UWash. pine/alpine doesn't
sync. IMAP supports syncing but syncing is not an IMAP feature. It's a >feature of the Mail client.
Carlos E. R. <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:
On 2026-10-03 20:29, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Whether the client keeps folders in sync is supported by the protocol. >>>>>> It's not a requirement. I don't sync.
I'll freely admit I know nearly nothing about IMAP, but if you _don't_ >>>>> sync, what is its advantage?
Most IMAP users will choose to sync the inbox, sent items, and perhaps >>>> spam and drafts folders, with most servers you can create any other
folders you like to organise the mailbox, they won't automatically sync, >>>> but most clients will let you choose ...
I would not phrase it like that.
Like pine/alpine, IMAP was written at UWash to support its own students
who used email, perhaps for the first time at college.
pine and alpine don't sync.
Fetchmail downloads. I have used pop3 or imap with fetchmail to download >>from remote servers to local machine, to then read with Pine.
alpine has a fetchmail-equivalent feature (or may call fetchmail)
called Maildrop, which downloads messages from an inbox on a remote
host. I don't use it myself. I believe the host receiving the messages
may also be remote. I suppose the inbox could be on a local host! That's
the wonderful thing about handling messages, as the client and the inbox
or folder of archived messages may be on different hosts, without caring about remote versus local.
The protocol supports syncing but it's a Mail client feature. The user
must both desire syncing and choose a Mail client like Thunderbird that
syncs. There may be Mail clients invoked from the Unix or linux shell
that both support IMAP and syncing, but someone else will have to tell
us. In my opinion, syncing increases the chance of an unwanted handling
of a message because there is more than one host affected.
Syncing is undesireable. Other users want syncing despite this increased >>> risk of mishandling.
As we have the Thunderbird group in these posts, TB syncs just fine. I
never noticed a problem, using more than one computer.
I didn't say that syncing failed. I'm saying that the user may
misunderstand that the user may delete the message on one host without understanding that it will also get deleted at the other host upon
syncing, and that he needed to move it from the inbox into an archive
message folder immediately upon first reading it in the inbox.
--Unless you are working offline, then the local version might differ from
the remote version.
But I'm not supposed to store messages in the inbox in the first place!
I should be archiving them in folders as I check the inbox!
I swear I'll get to the backlong in my inbox some day.
Seriously, IMAP works so nicely with multiple hosts, syncing gives me no added advantage.
Unlike POP, IMAP allows messages in any folder, remote or local, inbox
or message archive, to be read or manipulated.
No, syncing is not the main point, not at all. The main point is
superiority to POP in everywhere, especially in the era in which POP was notorious for message transfer failure due to noisy dialup connections.
I've explained all this.
On 2026/10/4 17:46:37, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
[]
Unlike POP, IMAP allows messages in any folder, remote or local, inbox
or message archive, to be read or manipulated.
AIUI, remote folders have no meaning in POP.>
On 2026-10-05 00:32, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/4 17:46:37, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
[]
Unlike POP, IMAP allows messages in any folder, remote or local, inbox
or message archive, to be read or manipulated.
AIUI, remote folders have no meaning in POP.>
Spam was in a remote folder that you could not see.
On 2026-10-05 00:32, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/4 17:46:37, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
[]
Unlike POP, IMAP allows messages in any folder, remote or local, inbox
or message archive, to be read or manipulated.
AIUI, remote folders have no meaning in POP.
Spam was in a remote folder that you could not see.
On 2026/10/4 17:46:37, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
[]
Unlike POP, IMAP allows messages in any folder, remote or local, inbox
or message archive, to be read or manipulated.
AIUI, remote folders have no meaning in POP.
No, syncing is not the main point, not at all. The main point is >>superiority to POP in everywhere, especially in the era in which POP was >>notorious for message transfer failure due to noisy dialup connections.
I've explained all this.
Now that we are past that area (and I think you said PO3 was superior to
POP in that respect), is _that_ difference as relevant these days?
After some mail problems I ended up using IMAP but find that the mailbox keeps filling up despite me having autoarchive running every day.
After some mail problems I ended up using IMAP but find that the mailbox keeps filling up despite me having autoarchive running every day.
JMB99 wrote:
After some mail problems I ended up using IMAP but find that the
mailbox keeps filling up despite me having autoarchive running every day.
Depends how autoarchive is configured.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:33:23 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |