(I'm taking the lethargy route from PlusNet, so will be moved to EE - assuming they ever get round to it; The initial letter dated 2 September
said they'd do something in about 30 days. No peep heard from them so
far [landline and broadband still working fine, if three phishing calls
so far today counts as fine].)
last ISPs I would consider. I had the impression that Zen were good but
discovered that they no longer offer e-mail to new customers and their
Sales Department couldn't be contacted (in which case I wondered what
the Complaints Department must have been like?).
After recommendations from several satisfied customers, I went to
Truespeed (a small local supplier) for my broadband but they don't offer e-mail either. They were so busy that they had nearly a fortnight's
On 2026/10/30 17:3:6, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
last ISPs I would consider. I had the impression that Zen were good but
Yes, I've got that impression, though last time I looked (some years
ago) they were noticeably more expensive; I guess you get what you pay for.
discovered that they no longer offer e-mail to new customers and their Sales Department couldn't be contacted (in which case I wondered what
the Complaints Department must have been like?).
After recommendations from several satisfied customers, I went to
Truespeed (a small local supplier) for my broadband but they don't offer e-mail either. They were so busy that they had nearly a fortnight's
I think virtually no ICP (internet connection provider) now gives email
with new customers, and most of the existing ones are stopping - what
was Orange stopped two or three years ago, and PlusNet are clearly
trying to, with the Greenby fiasco. I suppose so many people are using
things like gmail, or their own, that it's quite expensive for providers
to, er, provide it. (My hosting provider provides email, as I think do
most similar. Does poppyrecords' hoster not?)
[]
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/30 17:3:6, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
last ISPs I would consider. I had the impression that Zen were good but >>Yes, I've got that impression, though last time I looked (some years
ago) they were noticeably more expensive; I guess you get what you pay for. >>
discovered that they no longer offer e-mail to new customers and their
Sales Department couldn't be contacted (in which case I wondered what
the Complaints Department must have been like?).
After recommendations from several satisfied customers, I went to
Truespeed (a small local supplier) for my broadband but they don't offer >> > e-mail either. They were so busy that they had nearly a fortnight's
I think virtually no ICP (internet connection provider) now gives email
with new customers, and most of the existing ones are stopping - what
was Orange stopped two or three years ago, and PlusNet are clearly
trying to, with the Greenby fiasco. I suppose so many people are using
things like gmail, or their own, that it's quite expensive for providers
to, er, provide it. (My hosting provider provides email, as I think do
most similar. Does poppyrecords' hoster not?)
[]
My website host accepts incoming e-mails sent to my poppyrecords address
(and will auto-divert them if requested) but strongly discourages
sending outgoing e-mails through their server, as they risk being
rejected or marked as spam. My Linux e-mail server sends outgoing
e-mails through Truespeed broadband (which will allow this) and I have
been told I must ask them to provide a fixed IP and reverse DNS record,
so my incoming e-mails are received reliably and my outgoing e-mails
are marked as trustworthy.
I am very much a beginner in this field and still feeling my way.
wrote:
On 2026-10-31, Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/30 17:3:6, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
last ISPs I would consider. I had the impression that Zen were good but >>Yes, I've got that impression, though last time I looked (some years
ago) they were noticeably more expensive; I guess you get what you pay for.
discovered that they no longer offer e-mail to new customers and their >> > Sales Department couldn't be contacted (in which case I wondered what
the Complaints Department must have been like?).
After recommendations from several satisfied customers, I went to
Truespeed (a small local supplier) for my broadband but they don't offer >> > e-mail either. They were so busy that they had nearly a fortnight's
I think virtually no ICP (internet connection provider) now gives email
with new customers, and most of the existing ones are stopping - what
was Orange stopped two or three years ago, and PlusNet are clearly
trying to, with the Greenby fiasco. I suppose so many people are using
things like gmail, or their own, that it's quite expensive for providers >> to, er, provide it. (My hosting provider provides email, as I think do
most similar. Does poppyrecords' hoster not?)
[]
My website host accepts incoming e-mails sent to my poppyrecords address (and will auto-divert them if requested) but strongly discourages
sending outgoing e-mails through their server, as they risk being
rejected or marked as spam. My Linux e-mail server sends outgoing
e-mails through Truespeed broadband (which will allow this) and I have
been told I must ask them to provide a fixed IP and reverse DNS record,
so my incoming e-mails are received reliably and my outgoing e-mails
are marked as trustworthy.
I am very much a beginner in this field and still feeling my way.
The DNS domain you send mail from (e.g. poppyrecords.xx.yy) should also
have an SPF entry entry containing the resolvable name(s) of your Linux e-mail server, that seems to help a lot, and is trivial to do (assuming
your DNS provider is decent). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sender_Policy_Framework
There's also DKIM (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DomainKeys_Identified_Mail) but that's more complex to set up (requires each outgoing email to be signed).
There's also DKIM (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DomainKeys_Identified_Mail) >> but that's more complex to set up (requires each outgoing email to be signed).I'll look into those.
On 31/10/2026 15:38, Liz Tuddenham wrote: >> There's also DKIM (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DomainKeys_Identified_Mail) >> but that's
more complex to set up (requires each outgoing email to be signed). > I'll look into those.
I assume you are using a linux based MTA to send mail: If it is behind a router that changes its IP address every so often things get tricky.
These things are hard behind a typical DHCP allocated address. I run a
very small virtual private server that runs EXIM4 and Dovecot that I configure, to resolve these issues.
Costs as low as -u1 a month exist
I consider that a small price to pay.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 31/10/2026 15:38, Liz Tuddenham wrote: >> There's also DKIM
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DomainKeys_Identified_Mail) >> but that's
more complex to set up (requires each outgoing email to be signed). > I'll >> look into those.
I assume you are using a linux based MTA to send mail: If it is behind a
router that changes its IP address every so often things get tricky.
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and
reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be
almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail
said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking
much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
[...]
These things are hard behind a typical DHCP allocated address. I run a
very small virtual private server that runs EXIM4 and Dovecot that I
configure, to resolve these issues.
Costs as low as |e-u1 a month exist
I consider that a small price to pay.
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably uses
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost around 20p per unit, this is less than -u30 per year. The router uses a similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
wrote:
On 2026-11-01, Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 31/10/2026 15:38, Liz Tuddenham wrote: >> There's also DKIM
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DomainKeys_Identified_Mail) >> but that's >> more complex to set up (requires each outgoing email to be signed). > I'll >> look into those.
I assume you are using a linux based MTA to send mail: If it is behind a >> router that changes its IP address every so often things get tricky.
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and
reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
[...]
These things are hard behind a typical DHCP allocated address. I run a
very small virtual private server that runs EXIM4 and Dovecot that I
configure, to resolve these issues.
Costs as low as |e-u1 a month exist
I consider that a small price to pay.
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably uses
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost around 20p per unit, this is less than -u30 per year. The router uses a similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
The other problem you may hit sending email from "home" is that most residential IP address ranges are on various blocklists. I use a VPS
(well, two...) to avoid that issue, but I do wonder how long it will
be before the tech. cartel blocks all email not coming from one of its members :(
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
The other problem you may hit sending email from "home" is that most residential IP address ranges are on various blocklists. I use a VPS
(well, two...) to avoid that issue, but I do wonder how long it will
be before the tech. cartel blocks all email not coming from one of its members :(
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably uses
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost around 20p per unit, this is less than -u30 per year. The router uses a similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
On 2026/11/1 9:19:30, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably uses
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost around 20p per unit, this is less than -u30 per year. The router uses a similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
Which ISP/ICP does broadband for a bit more than -u100 a year (other than
BT Basic, which you need to be vulnerable to get)? Most seem to be at
least twentysomething a month.
That does appear to be their business model. If I understand it
correctly, Gmail will unblock e-mails from smaller suppliers for a fee
of about -u30 per month.
On 2026/11/1 9:19:30, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably usesWhich ISP/ICP does broadband for a bit more than -u100 a year (other than
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost
around 20p per unit, this is less than -u30 per year. The router uses a
similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is
comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around -u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
BT Basic, which you need to be vulnerable to get)? Most seem to be at
least twentysomething a month.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/11/1 9:19:30, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably usesWhich ISP/ICP does broadband for a bit more than |e-u100 a year (other than >> BT Basic, which you need to be vulnerable to get)? Most seem to be at
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost
around 20p per unit, this is less than |e-u30 per year. The router uses a >>> similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is >>> comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around |e-u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental. >>>
least twentysomething a month.
My apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge.
Yes, -u360 per year for the ISP - so the -u100 per year for running your
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
On 01/11/2026 15:01, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/11/1 9:19:30, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
[]
I did the sums based on a Mac Mini using 15 Watts (it probably usesWhich ISP/ICP does broadband for a bit more than |e-u100 a year (other than
less), which is 132 units of electricity per year. At the present cost >>> around 20p per unit, this is less than |e-u30 per year. The router uses a
similar amount of power and the depreciation on a secondhand Mac Mini is >>> comparable.
The total cost of running your own software on your own hardware is
around |e-u100 per year, a bit less than the cost of the broadband rental.
BT Basic, which you need to be vulnerable to get)? Most seem to be at
least twentysomething a month.
My apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge.
Yes, -u360 per year for the ISP - so the -u100 per year for running your own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
Make that -u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge.Make that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running your
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge. >>> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running yourMake that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:Fasthosts are -u1.25/month for ever, not just limited to the first year.
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge. >>>>> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running yourMake that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
You can point an IPV4 address at it, I have a domain hosted at Mythic
Beasts whose IPV4 address points to my Fasthosts VPS. It all 'just
works'.
As noted above you can do it cheaper, Mythic Beasts' VPS systems aren't particularly cheap.
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge. >>> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running yourMake that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge. >>>>> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running yourMake that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
Or you could pay -u2 per month to Mythic and get them to handle your email for you. Then you don't need to maintain any email server. I do, and it's solid.
Your own server comes into its own if you're going to be storing hundreds of GB of mail (when hosting providers are more expensive), but there are ways around that - eg use Mythic as the mail sending/receiving service and download mail to your local store.
Theo--
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
I don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to haveMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly charge. >> >>> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per year for running yourMake that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more
own server doesn't seem all that excessive.
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
Or you could pay -u2 per month to Mythic and get them to handle your email for you. Then you don't need to maintain any email server. I do, and it's solid.
I made the decision to self-host* a number of years ago, and haven't regretted it, yet.
The options were to move everything to one of the heavyweights (MS/Google), move
everything to a smaller outfit (e.g. Mythic), or d-i-y. The heavyweights are only
intersted in us proles as fodder for their revenue machine. Smaller outfits come
and go - to be attriactive they need to be cheap, which make them unprofitable in
the longer term, so bust or bought out. D-i-y is a p-i-t-a, but at least I own the
whole stack, and have some extra lines on my CV. Pick your poison...
* DNS, email and webserver
On 02/11/2026 14:32, Ian wrote:
I made the decision to self-host* a number of years ago, and haven't regretted it, yet.
The options were to move everything to one of the heavyweights (MS/Google), move
everything to a smaller outfit (e.g. Mythic), or d-i-y. The heavyweights are only
intersted in us proles as fodder for their revenue machine. Smaller outfits come
and go - to be attriactive they need to be cheap, which make them unprofitable in
the longer term, so bust or bought out. D-i-y is a p-i-t-a, but at least I own the
whole stack, and have some extra lines on my CV. Pick your poison...
* DNS, email and webserver
I think its a complex situation. Mythic beasts have been around forever.
I would rely on them quite highly
Self hosting requires the ability to set up and configure a fairly bomb
and hack proof mail server and MTA. That talks nice to other MTAs.
Having done this several times it is not a trivial exercise.
It becomes more rational if you are hosting say a lot of little web sites.
wrote:
On 2026-11-02, Theo <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 01/11/2026 17:31, Liz Tuddenham wrote:
charge. >> Yes, |e-u360 per year for the ISP - so the |e-u100 per yearMy apologies, I confused the monthly charge with the quarterly
for running your >> own server doesn't seem all that excessive. >> >
Make that |e-u12...plus cost of registering a domain, which is more I
don't understand the figure (was it a missprint?) but I have to have
my own domain name(s) anyway, so there is no additional cost through
having them on my own server.
A virtual private server adequate for a mail transfer agent is as
little as -u1 a month for first year
Maybe as much as -u6.50 for a real service with IPV4 (mythic beasts)
https://www.mythic-beasts.com/order/vps
That is enough to host many peoples mail services.
Or you could pay -u2 per month to Mythic and get them to handle your email for you. Then you don't need to maintain any email server. I do, and it's solid.
Until they go bust, get bought out by the cartel, or their CEO loses his marbles:
https://www.404media.co/manifestos-fear-and-loser-thinking-inside-protons- ai-reckoning/
I made the decision to self-host* a number of years ago, and haven't regretted it, yet.
(Have they even been /doing/ broadband for a while?)
If so, what are they like - both technical competence and general
customer service?
(I'm taking the lethargy route from PlusNet, so will be moved to EE - assuming they ever get round to it; The initial letter dated 2 September
said they'd do something in about 30 days. No peep heard from them so
far [landline and broadband still working fine, if three phishing calls
so far today counts as fine].)
--
J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()ALIS-Ch++(p)Ar++T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf
"Galbraith's Law of Human Nature: Faced with the choice between
changing one's mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everybody gets busy on the proof." - John Kenneth Galbraith
On 30 Oct 2026 14:07, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
(Have they even been /doing/ broadband for a while?)
If so, what are they like - both technical competence and general
customer service?
(I'm taking the lethargy route from PlusNet, so will be moved to EE -
assuming they ever get round to it; The initial letter dated 2 September
said they'd do something in about 30 days. No peep heard from them so
far [landline and broadband still working fine, if three phishing calls
so far today counts as fine].)
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
I was actually on the BT->EE transition process.
They struggled providing a reliable VOIP service (Digital Voice) so I
use A&A for that, with my own ATA. During the period when EE struggled
they told the Ombudsman that they don't actually control the service elements. In effect they are a simple reseller.
I've had a series of "hubs" over the years. The current Wifi Pro 7 and extenders are fairly solid but not easy to manage well. The EE App, at
one point was quite feature-full but a number of things have been lost.
But, in general, the broadband works.
The STBs are ok, too.
Customer service, as always, needs some patience but that seems to be
the same for any ISP.
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and
reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be
almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail
said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking
much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and
reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
The letter has been returned marked: "addressee gone away". The address
is the one given as their Registered Office at Companies House.
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
The letter has been returned marked: "addressee gone away". The address
is the one given as their Registered Office at Companies House.
I've now discovered that there were two buildings with similar names and
the same postcode; I addressed it to the wrong one - which may have been demolished.
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
Liz Tuddenham <liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I have sent an e-mail request to my ISP for a static IP address and reverse DNS. They are overwhelmed with new customers and appear to be almost uncontactable at the moment; the 'holding' response to my e-mail said they would respond within 4 working days but I see they are taking much longer in some cases. I will follow up the e-mail with a letter to
their registered office, just to make sure the message gets through.
The letter has been returned marked: "addressee gone away". The address is the one given as their Registered Office at Companies House.
I've now discovered that there were two buildings with similar names and the same postcode; I addressed it to the wrong one - which may have been demolished.
Surely that would be "address gone away"? :-)
On 2026/11/4 20:41:43, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
On 30 Oct 2026 14:07, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
(Have they even been /doing/ broadband for a while?)
If so, what are they like - both technical competence and general
customer service?
(I'm taking the lethargy route from PlusNet, so will be moved to EE -
assuming they ever get round to it; The initial letter dated 2 September >>> said they'd do something in about 30 days. No peep heard from them so
far [landline and broadband still working fine, if three phishing calls
so far today counts as fine].)
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
Thanks for replying; my original thread got a bit sidetracked!
I was actually on the BT->EE transition process.
They struggled providing a reliable VOIP service (Digital Voice) so I
use A&A for that, with my own ATA. During the period when EE struggled
I'm _hoping_ that by now, they've got the VoIP part working - at least
for a locked-down situation with analogue 'phone plugged into router.
they told the Ombudsman that they don't actually control the service
elements. In effect they are a simple reseller.
I'm not surprised.
I've had a series of "hubs" over the years. The current Wifi Pro 7 and
extenders are fairly solid but not easy to manage well. The EE App, at
one point was quite feature-full but a number of things have been lost.
But, in general, the broadband works.
That's good to know. (Though I am pretty sure that in my location, it's
just going to be the OpenReach product, whoever is reselling it.)
The STBs are ok, too.
(Sorry - STBs? That's set-top box to me, which I'm sure it isn't here!)
Customer service, as always, needs some patience but that seems to beIndeed. But good to know they're no /worse/ than others. Any particular wrinkles that are useful to know when dealing with them?
the same for any ISP.
On 4 Nov 2026 22:50, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
On 2026/11/4 20:41:43, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
Thanks for replying; my original thread got a bit sidetracked!
I was actually on the BT->EE transition process.
They struggled providing a reliable VOIP service (Digital Voice) so I
use A&A for that, with my own ATA. During the period when EE struggled
I'm _hoping_ that by now, they've got the VoIP part working - at least
for a locked-down situation with analogue 'phone plugged into router.
My brother has Digital Voice from them and seems happy enough so
perhaps it has stabilised.
That's good to know. (Though I am pretty sure that in my location, it's
just going to be the OpenReach product, whoever is reselling it.)
Yes, the fibre is Openreach and they, of course, have to make sure that
works and it would be the same for any ISP but the service overlay is entirely EE.
Interestingly enough, last night the connection dropped three times in
the early hours. The router has a new UI with an option to try a newer
"beta" version. They seem to work.
The STBs are ok, too.
(Sorry - STBs? That's set-top box to me, which I'm sure it isn't here!)
Yes, I have "EE TV", which only works over EE broadband.
At the moment you can't have EE TV and the 1.6Gb offering.
Well, you can by using an Apple TV box instead.
Customer service, as always, needs some patience but that seems to beIndeed. But good to know they're no /worse/ than others. Any particular
the same for any ISP.
wrinkles that are useful to know when dealing with them?
I've found best service on Saturday mornings, first thing but not if
you expect to need 2nd or 3rd line technical help.
My account is a terrible mess in their database so any change causes
huge amounts of work for their "data integrity" team and, sometimes,
their OSS people as well.
I was originally customer 4251 with Orange and, as you can imagine, a
lot has happened since. I've also trialled a number of product
"journeys", some of which failed so there is probably a lot of cruft in
the databases.
I've suggested, more than once, to throw away the account and start
from scratch but no-one customer-facing has that power, not even the "Executive Office"
what comes into the home is the old copper, and I've had no
indication that that's going to change; whether it comes from a cabinet
or the actual exchange, I know not - I've been assuming cabinet.
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
what comes into the home is the old copper, and I've had no
indication that that's going to change; whether it comes from a cabinet
or the actual exchange, I know not - I've been assuming cabinet.
Yes, BT checker says currently fibre to cabinet, but that fibre to
premises is being installed in your area right now (may not necessarily apply to all homes).
On 2026/11/6 15:49:55, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:[snip]
On 4 Nov 2026 22:50, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
On 2026/11/4 20:41:43, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
I've received my EE "router" (and a couple of adapters), for use on the
17th; I haven't taken it out of its box yet. No cables (though there is
a PSU for it), so I assume it'll just replace the PlusNet one and they
know I'm on copper. Does it have a web interface like the PLusNet one?
(I'll find out for myself. Just wondering how easy - or possible - it'll
be to change the SSID.)
Indeed. But good to know they're no /worse/ than others. Any particular
wrinkles that are useful to know when dealing with them?
I've found best service on Saturday mornings, first thing but not if
you expect to need 2nd or 3rd line technical help.
Thanks a lot - that's exactly the sort of thing I was after. Do you mean there's less of a wait on Saturday mornings for billing or other administrative enquiries, but fewer technical staff?
On 6 Nov 2026 18:12, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
On 2026/11/6 15:49:55, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:[snip]
On 4 Nov 2026 22:50, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
On 2026/11/4 20:41:43, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
I've received my EE "router" (and a couple of adapters), for use on the
17th; I haven't taken it out of its box yet. No cables (though there is
a PSU for it), so I assume it'll just replace the PlusNet one and they
know I'm on copper. Does it have a web interface like the PLusNet one?
(I'll find out for myself. Just wondering how easy - or possible - it'll
be to change the SSID.)
There is a Web interface which is quite useful but, for a lot of things
you will find the EE "App" sufficient
I have dynamic DNS and also have changed the DHCP range which did
require the UI but things like SSID and standing up a guest SSID can
all be done via the app.
Indeed. But good to know they're no /worse/ than others. Any particular >>>> wrinkles that are useful to know when dealing with them?
I've found best service on Saturday mornings, first thing but not if
you expect to need 2nd or 3rd line technical help.
Thanks a lot - that's exactly the sort of thing I was after. Do you mean
there's less of a wait on Saturday mornings for billing or other
administrative enquiries, but fewer technical staff?
Correct
On 2026/11/14 18:45:6, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 18:12, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
On 2026/11/6 15:49:55, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:[snip]
On 4 Nov 2026 22:50, "J. P. Gilliver" wrote:[]
On 2026/11/4 20:41:43, Rupert Moss-Eccardt wrote:
I have been with EE broadband for several years.
I've received my EE "router" (and a couple of adapters), for use on the
17th; I haven't taken it out of its box yet. No cables (though there is
a PSU for it), so I assume it'll just replace the PlusNet one and they
know I'm on copper. Does it have a web interface like the PLusNet one?
(I'll find out for myself. Just wondering how easy - or possible - it'll >>> be to change the SSID.)
There is a Web interface which is quite useful but, for a lot of things
you will find the EE "App" sufficient
Thanks - good to know (the web interface that is). I don't have a
smartphone.
I have dynamic DNS and also have changed the DHCP range which did
require the UI but things like SSID and standing up a guest SSID can
all be done via the app.
As long as I can do it via the webUI I'm fine.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:41:45 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,687 |