Landline switchover could cut people off in emergency, minister warned
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29g1nlr51o
People have been trying to tell them for ages!
Landline switchover could cut people off in emergency, minister warned
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29g1nlr51o
People have been trying to tell them for ages!
What really irritates me is lines like "The government and
operators say the move to digital landlines will offer a more
reliable service." I can't _imagine_ something more reliable than
the old system, with which I can only remember one outage, and that
- at my previous address - was when the buried cable finally worked
its way to the surface until it met a lawnmower. (And I was able to temporarily repair that myself.)
The reliability of the connection from an exchange to the premises is dramatically improved by going fibre not least because fibre doesn't
die on contact with H2O. It's actually no longer economically viable
or engineering wise viable not to do so.
Your experience I assure you, is not typical.
Landline switchover could cut people off in emergency, minister warned
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29g1nlr51o
People have been trying to tell them for ages!
I did actually call one of the numbers in the EE leaflet, to enquire
about the battery, and the person I spoke to seemed to have little
knowledge of me - and also seemed not to have any urgency.
I worked for Post office telephones then BT for 20 years. My time
ended just before broadband arrived. My experience or rather those of
my external colleagues was that copper cables were extremely prone to
damage by water. Water in ducts, water in DPs, water everywhere. Most
common faults in the parlance of the period...
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went.
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many
who had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service
because they only had DECT phones and the base station died when
the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those? Even if you do, many people don't
(or do, but in a box in the loft somewhere, not ready for an
emergency).
Theo
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those?
But who still has one of those? Even if you do, many people don't (or do, but in a box in the loft somewhere, not ready for an emergency).
At the end of the day, any emergency system is only good if you test it regularly, so any kinks can be ironed out when it isn't an emergency. If
you don't even have all the pieces plugged in you aren't doing that.
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those? Even if you do, many people don't (or do, but in a box in the loft somewhere, not ready for an emergency).
At the end of the day, any emergency system is only good if you test it regularly, so any kinks can be ironed out when it isn't an emergency. If
you don't even have all the pieces plugged in you aren't doing that.
Theo
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those? Even if you do, many people don't (or do, but in a box in the loft somewhere, not ready for an emergency).
At the end of the day, any emergency system is only good if you test it regularly, so any kinks can be ironed out when it isn't an emergency. If
you don't even have all the pieces plugged in you aren't doing that.
Theo
Landline switchover could cut people off in emergency, minister warned
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29g1nlr51o
People have been trying to tell them for ages!
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote:
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are
POTS linecards on the street cabinets
On 28/10/2026 06:17, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
I did actually call one of the numbers in the EE leaflet, to enquire
about the battery, and the person I spoke to seemed to have little
knowledge of me - and also seemed not to have any urgency.
I have been surprised that the big chains have not been stocking /
promoting UPS's or just backup for routers.
Theo <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> writes:Answerphone that works without power? (Plausible, if non-volatile-memory based.)
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who >>>> had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those?
I do. I have two connected to the router, one with a built in
answerphone. And I have a few in the cupboard. (Obviously I am not
entirely normal.)
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote:
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who >>>>> had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because >>>>> they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>>>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
Where does the router get power from in a power cut?
Marco Moock wrote:
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are
POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that.
On 2026/10/28 10:49:7, JMB99 wrote:
On 28/10/2026 06:17, J. P. Gilliver wrote:Good point!
I did actually call one of the numbers in the EE leaflet, to enquire
about the battery, and the person I spoke to seemed to have little
knowledge of me - and also seemed not to have any urgency.
I have been surprised that the big chains have not been stocking /
promoting UPS's or just backup for routers.
Possibly because, to actually give any useful backup, they'd have to be
quite expensive (and possibly large), and they don't think there'd be
enough market for economies of scale to work.
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are
POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that. >>
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS.
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS.
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from the exchange.
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the
cabinet is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and have
already in many - most? - cases).
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote:
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who >>>>> had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because >>>>> they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>>>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
Where does the router get power from in a power cut?
On 2026/10/28 14:48:33, Richmond wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones (which I suspect a large proportion of the less technically-savvy will
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote:
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who >>>>>> had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because >>>>>> they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went. >>>>>
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
be on).
Where does the router get power from in a power cut?
There's that too!
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are
POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that. >>
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS.
On 2026/10/28 17:36:46, Andy Burns wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS. >>
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from the exchange.
cabinet is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and have
already in many - most? - cases).
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from the
exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from the
exchange.
If you are on FTTC you get VOIP.
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the
cabinet is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and have
already in many - most? - cases).
They are. These solutions are all being sold as "short term" solutions
which will cease 2030...
.. they are also priced in such a way to discourage continued use...
Dave
On 28/10/2026 17:29, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS.
Its in the Exchange, but the rental shoots up, and you still have to
dial the full STD Number.
Dave
For vulnerable people, who only have (as far as they know - whether
served from the exchange, or from an ATA in the cabinet), it would seem logical to give them a "router", even if they onlyuse it for VoIP.
But - except in the early part of this debate, not now - I've not heard
this option being discussed.
On 2026/10/28 18:57:54, David Wade wrote:
On 28/10/2026 17:29, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:Its in the Exchange, but the rental shoots up, and you still have to
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view) POTS. >>
dial the full STD Number.
Dave
So those customers - who definitely include vulnerable ones - are, in
effect, being told "get broadband, or else stay on something that will actually cost you _more_"?
On 2026/10/28 18:2:5, Andy Burns wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will beDepends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ... >>>
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from the
exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with no
broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
He has copper to the house, but that could be, surely, from a cabinet
with an (in effect) ATA in it, rather than copper all the way to the exchange? I don't think there's any way for him (or you without
specialised equipment) to know.
[]
Landline switchover could cut people off in emergency, minister warned
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29g1nlr51o
People have been trying to tell them for ages!
On 2026/10/28 14:48:33, Richmond wrote:
From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones (which I suspect a large proportion of the less technically-savvy will
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
be on).
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many who
had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service because
they only had DECT phones and the base station died when the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
fibre to the premises but that is a long way off for most of us.
On 28 Oct 2026 11:16:36 +0000 (GMT)
Theo <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote:
Yes, but most when this issue was first raised it turned out many
who had lost their service were still on POTS. They lost service
because they only had DECT phones and the base station died when
the power went.
But at least at that time you could still plug a good old fashioned
phone into the master socket and bypass the DECT.
But who still has one of those? Even if you do, many people don't
(or do, but in a box in the loft somewhere, not ready for an
emergency).
Theo
Mine is still on the shelf where it was located in case of need.
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
to actually give any useful backup, they'd have to be
quite expensive (and possibly large), and they don't think there'd be
enough market for economies of scale to work.
On 28/10/2026 17:29, J. P. Gilliver wrote:What exchange?
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange
does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view)
POTS.
Its in the Exchange, but the rental shoots up, and you still have to
dial the full STD Number.
Dave
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
For vulnerable people, who only have (as far as they know - whether
served from the exchange, or from an ATA in the cabinet), it would seem
logical to give them a "router", even if they onlyuse it for VoIP.
But - except in the early part of this debate, not now - I've not heard
this option being discussed.
I remember it being discussed very early regarding the switch-off, if
you were a voice-only user, you'd get a DSL connection with "free"
256kbps bandwidth for use by VoIP or anything else you can squeeze out
of it (BT's ADSL started at 512kbps back in the early 2000s).
He has copper to the house, but that could be, surely, from a cabinet
with an (in effect) ATA in it, rather than copper all the way to the exchange? I don't think there's any way for him (or you without
specialised equipment) to know.
being Exchange Based means the only changes needed are in the Exchange,
no cabinets need to be updated, no batteries for backup up are required
in the street cabinets. The batteries have been a problem for BT as they
age or are stolen.
Putting them in the FTTC cabinets could also have slowed their removal
as IP services are moved to FTTP.
On 28/10/2026 18:57, David Wade wrote:
On 28/10/2026 17:29, J. P. Gilliver wrote:What exchange?
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange
does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view)
POTS.
Its in the Exchange, but the rental shoots up, and you still have to
dial the full STD Number.
Dave
On 28/10/2026 17:17, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
to actually give any useful backup, they'd have to be
quite expensive (and possibly large), and they don't think there'd be
enough market for economies of scale to work.
That depends on whether we persist in this renewable nonsense past the > next election, and power cuts become routine
On 28/10/2026 17:27, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:33, Richmond wrote:
From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
(which I suspect a large proportion of the less technically-savvy will
be on).
BT phones or routers? The routers certainly have DECT.
On 28/10/2026 20:30, David Wade wrote:
being Exchange Based means the only changes needed are in theThis does not gybe with their avowed intention to get rid of exchanges
Exchange, no cabinets need to be updated, no batteries for backup up
are required in the street cabinets. The batteries have been a problem
for BT as they age or are stolen.
and copper altogether
Putting them in the FTTC cabinets could also have slowed their removal
as IP services are moved to FTTP.
Nope. They then provide them on premises
On 28/10/2026 19:43, Andy Burns wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
For vulnerable people, who only have (as far as they know - whether
served from the exchange, or from an ATA in the cabinet), it would seem
logical to give them a "router", even if they onlyuse it for VoIP.
But - except in the early part of this debate, not now - I've not heard
this option being discussed.
I remember it being discussed very early regarding the switch-off, if
you were a voice-only user, you'd get a DSL connection with "free"
256kbps bandwidth for use by VoIP or anything else you can squeeze out
of it (BT's ADSL started at 512kbps back in the early 2000s).
IIRC it was 128k and 256k as well. I had something like that and then my
ISP on a support call asked why OI was still on it...
... Suddenly 5Mbps
On 28/10/2026 18:57, David Wade wrote:
On 28/10/2026 17:29, J. P. Gilliver wrote:What exchange?
On 2026/10/28 14:48:55, Andy Burns wrote:
Marco Moock wrote:Though there is some suggestion that either temporary or vulnerable may
Dunno how POTS is currently implemented, but here in Germany there are >>>>> POTS linecards on the street cabinets
Not in the UK, the cabinets don't provide POTS, only the exchange
does that.
have an ATA in the cabinet, making it (from the user's point of view)
POTS.
Its in the Exchange, but the rental shoots up, and you still have to
dial the full STD Number.
Dave
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Are DECT handsets being marketed as "compatible with VoIP" (or
"digital", or whatever) now? I haven't looked as such boxes lately.
There's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
_something_ will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these
fibres must go somewhere!
David Wade wrote:I think the transitional product has a hard stop date of 2030, the
being Exchange Based means the only changes needed are in theExchange, no cabinets need to be updated, no batteries for backup up
are required in the street cabinets. The batteries have been a problem
for BT as they age or are stolen.
This does not gybe with their avowed intention to get rid of exchanges
and copper altogether
Putting them in the FTTC cabinets could also have slowed their removal
as IP services are moved to FTTP.
Nope. They then provide them on premises
There's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
something will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these fibres
must go somewhere!
Granted, technology means they won't need something
as big as a building (especially without all those big batteries), but
some sort of a cabinet will be needed?
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Are DECT handsets being marketed as "compatible with VoIP" (or
"digital", or whatever) now? I haven't looked as such boxes lately.
I visited an elderly couple over the weekend, they'd been given a new router, battery pack and cordless phones, not sure if they're DECT or WiFi based ...
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Bob.
On 29/10/2026 08:50, Andy Burns wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Are DECT handsets being marketed as "compatible with VoIP" (or
"digital", or whatever) now? I haven't looked as such boxes lately.
I visited an elderly couple over the weekend, they'd been given a new
router, battery pack and cordless phones, not sure if they're DECT or WiFi >> based ...
The BT 'emergency hybrid phone' is wired, analogue; BT digital phones are DECT. https://www.bt.com/help/home-phone/digital-voice-handsets (etc).
On 2026/10/28 22:40:26, The Natural Philosopher wrote:1. The reach of unpowered fibre is tens of kilometres.
What exchange?There's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
_something_ will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these fibres
must go somewhere! Granted, technology means they won't need something
as big as a building (especially without all those big batteries), but
_some_ sort of a cabinet will be needed?
On 28/10/2026 17:27, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:33, Richmond wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones (which I suspect a large proportion of the less technically-savvy will
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote: > JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote: >> On >>>28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote: >>> Yes, but most when this issue >>>was first raised it turned out many who >>> had lost their service were >>>still on POTS. They lost service because >>> they only had DECT phones >>>and the base station died when the power went. >> >> >> But at least at >>>that time you could still plug a good old fashioned >> phone into the >>>master socket and bypass the DECT. >
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets
last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
be on).
For vunerable BT connect an existing handset to the router
Where does the router get power from in a power cut?
There's that too!
BT can provide battery backup but this is expensive for any decent period.
if the
power goes off the emergency phone switches over to 4G and presents an
07xx number instead of her geographic number. This means that during a
power cut, people need to know to try the mobile number rather than the landline number.
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> wrote:
On 28/10/2026 17:27, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/28 14:48:33, Richmond wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:From what I've heard/read here, that's unlikely to include BT or EE ones >>> (which I suspect a large proportion of the less technically-savvy will
On 28/10/2026 11:16, Theo wrote: > JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote: >> On >>>>> 28/10/2026 09:48, David Wade wrote: >>> Yes, but most when this issue >>>>> was first raised it turned out many who >>> had lost their service were >>>>> still on POTS. They lost service because >>> they only had DECT phones >>>>> and the base station died when the power went. >> >> >> But at least at >>>>> that time you could still plug a good old fashioned >> phone into the >>>>> master socket and bypass the DECT. >
These days, most routers can act as a DECT base and my DECT handsets >>>>> last nearly a week without any power, so I have one linked to the
router.
be on).
For vunerable BT connect an existing handset to the router
Where does the router get power from in a power cut?
There's that too!
BT can provide battery backup but this is expensive for any decent period.
They claimed they could provide me with battery back-up for a week. I
didn't ask them where they thought they were going to park the lorry.
Nick Finnigan <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote:
On 29/10/2026 08:50, Andy Burns wrote:
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Are DECT handsets being marketed as "compatible with VoIP" (or
"digital", or whatever) now? I haven't looked as such boxes lately.
I visited an elderly couple over the weekend, they'd been given a new
router, battery pack and cordless phones, not sure if they're DECT or WiFi >>> based ...
The BT 'emergency hybrid phone' is wired, analogue; BT digital phones are >> DECT. https://www.bt.com/help/home-phone/digital-voice-handsets (etc).
On the Emergency Hybrid phone, BT are a bit coy about how many minutes are available in mobile (rCyline faultrCO) mode, mentioning at the same time that there up to 1hr talk time or 8hr standby time - and they keep saying rCykeep it for emergency calls onlyrCO.
Andy Burns wrote:
I visited an elderly couple over the weekend, they'd been given a new
router, battery pack and cordless phones, not sure if they're DECT or WiFi >> based ...
When you say they were given a "new" router, was that to replace an
existing one (i. e. they had broadband), or they were given a router
where they didn't have one at all before (i. e. they just had a landline)?
Well, a simple mobile can last over a week connected but unused; if its electronics are running a second receiver to check whether the router
has come back on, I guess that'd reduce the time, though by how much I
don't know.
Well, a simple mobile can last over a week connected but unused; if its electronics are running a second receiver to check whether the routerI can just plug the mobile into the car to recharge it
has come back on, I guess that'd reduce the time, though by how much I
don't know.
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product
designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or
lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
There's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
_something_ will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these
fibres must go somewhere!
BT currently has about 5,500 exchange locations, about 4,500 will close and about 1,000 will remain effectively as data centres full of routers and fibre switches. And maybe servers.
Fibre can be terminated up to 30km away, and already often bypasses local exchanges.
But all the historic telephone switching kit will powered down in a few months
time and removed over 10 years, with all copper cabling.
Angus
I can just plug the mobile into the car to recharge it
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
There's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
something will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these fibres
must go somewhere!
They plan to cut the number of exchanges from 5,600 to 1,000
Granted, technology means they won't need something
as big as a building (especially without all those big batteries), but
some sort of a cabinet will be needed?
Eventually they'll want the cabinets gone too, both ye olde cast-iron
PDPs and the bent steel FTTC DSLAMs.
FTTP splitters and connection points will all be up poles, or down
holes, no power required.
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
I visited an elderly couple over the weekend, they'd been given a new
router, battery pack and cordless phones, not sure if they're DECT or WiFi >>> based ...
When you say they were given a "new" router, was that to replace an
existing one (i. e. they had broadband), or they were given a router
where they didn't have one at all before (i. e. they just had a landline)?
They were already on broadband (actually she does all the online stuff
like grocery shopping and ordering heating oil, he won't touch it, he
should probably learn).
Well, a simple mobile can last over a week connected but unused; if its
electronics are running a second receiver to check whether the router
has come back on, I guess that'd reduce the time, though by how much I
don't know.
Whenever they phone me, they use their landline, "number witheld" is
usually a good sign it's from them.
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product
designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or
lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
On 29/10/2026 16:23, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product
designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no
broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or
lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having
reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
I think horses and carts need special lanes and number plates
NY <me@privacy.net> wrote:
if the
power goes off the emergency phone switches over to 4G and presents an
07xx number instead of her geographic number. This means that during a
power cut, people need to know to try the mobile number rather than the
landline number.
Three hours later, the batteries at the mobile 'phone masts run out and
she will have no 'phone at all.
Andy Burns wrote:
Eventually they'll want the cabinets gone too, both ye olde cast-iron
PDPs and the bent steel FTTC DSLAMs.
FTTP splitters and connection points will all be up poles, or downIf by "splitter" you mean something that combines two or more
holes, no power required.
subscribers into fewer lines
then that _will_ involve electronics that need power, though granted
a constantly reducing amount as technology improves, but not zero.
On 2026/10/29 8:51:0, Angus Robertson - Magenta Systems Ltd wrote:
Ah, so it's not "all exchanges will be closed", it's "most exchangesThere's all this talk of exchanges coming to an end. But surely,
_something_ will be needed as a concentrator/switch: all these
fibres must go somewhere!
BT currently has about 5,500 exchange locations, about 4,500 will close and >> about 1,000 will remain effectively as data centres full of routers and fibre
switches. And maybe servers.
Fibre can be terminated up to 30km away, and already often bypasses local
exchanges.
But all the historic telephone switching kit will powered down in a few months
time and removed over 10 years, with all copper cabling.
Angus
will be closed, and the remaining ones won't be called that any more".
If by "splitter" you mean something that combines two or more
subscribers into fewer lines, then that_will_ involve electronics that
need power, though granted a constantly reducing amount as technology improves, but not zero.
I think horses and carts need special lanes and number platesYes, the shaming/scorning campaign ...
No. its "all exchanges will be closed and regional concentration
centres built in different locations"
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product
designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or
lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
On 29/10/2026 16:23, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:only a landline 'phone (however it is actually technically
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of
reliability and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty
to former days and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial
full length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line
is quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots
was coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing
exchanges but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional
product designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have
implemented), no broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have
declined to zero, but I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up
of the public shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be
told, like it or lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile
(coverage by then having reached them?) and change their number; or,
if they are a really tiny number, they'll be given a router (and
maybe "general" broadband too); or, perhaps, it'll be possible by
then to give them a mobile but with their old number.
My personal thoughts are this service is being deployed to divert
criticism over vulnerable users being inappropriately transferred to
VOIP when they have CareCall etc.
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will
be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the
latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from
the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with
no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability
and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days
and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet
is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full
length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges
but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product
designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no
broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or
lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having
reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
What is the public shaming scorning campain in place?
On 2026/10/29 16:42:32, Richmond wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will >>>>>>>> be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the >>>>>>>> latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from >>>>>>> the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only, with >>>>>> no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of reliability >>>>> and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty to former days >>>>> and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet >>>>>>> is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial full >>>>> length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line is
quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots was
coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing exchanges >>>>> but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional product >>>> designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no
broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero, but
I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like it or >>> lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by then having
reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are a really tiny
number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" broadband too);
or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them a mobile but with
their old number.
What is the public shaming scorning campain in place?
Anyone who does not accept with enthusiasm, new things, is made to feel
at least a burden, if not a dinosaur/old-fashioned. For example, "The
Natural Philosopher" clearly doesn't "give a fuck" about vulnerable
people who might want to stay on just a landline;
I may be overstating--
the case slightly in his case, but that attitude is definitely not rare.
(Not just among indivuduals, but companies - for example, the assumption
that everyone has, carries, and uses, a smartphone, and has a
permanently-on data contract for it, so they can use an "app" anywhere
and at any time.)
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
Eventually they'll want the cabinets gone too, both ye olde cast-iron
PDPs and the bent steel FTTC DSLAMs.
Oops that should have read PCPs (primary connection points)
FTTP splitters and connection points will all be up poles, or downIf by "splitter" you mean something that combines two or more
holes, no power required.
subscribers into fewer lines
fibre optic splitters for FTTP (also work as combiners for the upstream).
then that _will_ involve electronics that need power, though granted
a constantly reducing amount as technology improves, but not zero.
All passive optics, e.g.
<https://ebay.co.uk/itm/128135254353>
On 2026/10/29 16:52:34, Andy Burns wrote:
I see no mention of _filtering_ there (or in the device TNP details). [I
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
Eventually they'll want the cabinets gone too, both ye olde cast-iron
PDPs and the bent steel FTTC DSLAMs.
Oops that should have read PCPs (primary connection points)
FTTP splitters and connection points will all be up poles, or downIf by "splitter" you mean something that combines two or more
holes, no power required.
subscribers into fewer lines
fibre optic splitters for FTTP (also work as combiners for the upstream).
then that _will_ involve electronics that need power, though granted
a constantly reducing amount as technology improves, but not zero.
All passive optics, e.g.
<https://ebay.co.uk/itm/128135254353>
had wondered if some high/low wavelength filtering might be involved,
but there seems to be no mention of anything like that.) So does that
mean two customers (subscribers, whatever you call them) both receive
the same feed,
not?
On 2026/10/29 16:42:32, Richmond wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will >>>>>>>> be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the >>>>>>>> latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of
concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from >>>>>>> the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only,
with no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of
reliability and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty
to former days and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet >>>>>>> is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I
thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and
have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial
full length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line
is quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots
was coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing
exchanges but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional
product designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no
broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero,
but I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like
it or lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by
then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are
a really tiny number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general"
broadband too); or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them
a mobile but with their old number.
What is the public shaming scorning campain in place?
Anyone who does not accept with enthusiasm, new things, is made to
feel at least a burden, if not a dinosaur/old-fashioned. For example,
"The Natural Philosopher" clearly doesn't "give a fuck" about
vulnerable people who might want to stay on just a landline; I may be overstating the case slightly in his case, but that attitude is
definitely not rare. (Not just among indivuduals, but companies - for example, the assumption that everyone has, carries, and uses, a
smartphone, and has a permanently-on data contract for it, so they can
use an "app" anywhere and at any time.)
On 2026/10/28 10:49:7, JMB99 wrote:
On 28/10/2026 06:17, J. P. Gilliver wrote:Good point!
I did actually call one of the numbers in the EE leaflet, to enquire
about the battery, and the person I spoke to seemed to have little
knowledge of me - and also seemed not to have any urgency.
I have been surprised that the big chains have not been stocking /
promoting UPS's or just backup for routers.
Possibly because, to actually give any useful backup, they'd have to be
quite expensive (and possibly large), and they don't think there'd be
enough market for economies of scale to work.
I wonder if satellite phones might be the next big thing? No issues with broadband availability or local mast power supply.
I mean, a lot of modern mobile phones are already capable of sending an emergency SMS via satellite.
Tim
Three hours later, the batteries at the mobile 'phone masts run out and
she will have no 'phone at all.
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 16:42:32, Richmond wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will >>>>>>>>> be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the >>>>>>>>> latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of >>>>>>>> concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from >>>>>>>> the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only,
with no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of
reliability and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty >>>>>> to former days and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet >>>>>>>> is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I >>>>>>>> thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and >>>>>>>> have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial
full length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line >>>>>> is quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots >>>>>> was coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing
exchanges but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional
product designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no
broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero,
but I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like
it or lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by
then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are
a really tiny number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general"
broadband too); or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them
a mobile but with their old number.
What is the public shaming scorning campain in place?
Anyone who does not accept with enthusiasm, new things, is made to
feel at least a burden, if not a dinosaur/old-fashioned. For example,
"The Natural Philosopher" clearly doesn't "give a fuck" about
vulnerable people who might want to stay on just a landline; I may be
overstating the case slightly in his case, but that attitude is
definitely not rare. (Not just among indivuduals, but companies - for
example, the assumption that everyone has, carries, and uses, a
smartphone, and has a permanently-on data contract for it, so they can
use an "app" anywhere and at any time.)
I don't think usenet is public, it is more a backwater of wierdos and
trolls.
It seems to me what we are seeing is bad implementations of good
technology. VOIP has been around for a long time, and anyone who wanted
to use it with their broadband could have done but they didn't because
it was fiddly to configure and they didn't understand it when it didn't
work. If they wanted to force this thing on the general public then they should have made it as seamless as possible. Instead they dumped a
router and said get on with it. The underlying motivation is increased profits for shareholders as always.
Quite so! For comparison, how long did the batteries at an analogue telephone exchange used to last?
When we had a power cut the other year, we lost Vodafone signal
immediately and it did not return until our power came back. That seems
to suggest that our local mast has no battery backup and is driven from
the same HV feed as the domestic mains in the village.
Whenever we have power cuts, it's always the HV feed - branches touching
the 33 kV which trips a line protector that then retries (usually successfully) - but 1-second power cut is long enough for all the
computer equipment in the house to reboot. We may get a sequence of
several such drop-outs (the record was 15 over a 30-minite period) but longer power cuts (30 minutes to several hours) are thankfully rare.
I wonder if satellite phones might be the next big thing? No issues with broadband availability or local mast power supply.
On 2026/10/29 16:52:34, Andy Burns wrote:
I see no mention of _filtering_ there (or in the device TNP details). [I
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
Eventually they'll want the cabinets gone too, both ye olde cast-iron
PDPs and the bent steel FTTC DSLAMs.
Oops that should have read PCPs (primary connection points)
FTTP splitters and connection points will all be up poles, or downIf by "splitter" you mean something that combines two or more
holes, no power required.
subscribers into fewer lines
fibre optic splitters for FTTP (also work as combiners for the upstream).
then that _will_ involve electronics that need power, though granted
a constantly reducing amount as technology improves, but not zero.
All passive optics, e.g.
<https://ebay.co.uk/itm/128135254353>
had wondered if some high/low wavelength filtering might be involved,
but there seems to be no mention of anything like that.) So does that
mean two customers (subscribers, whatever you call them) both receive
the same feed, i. e. might be able to see each other's data? If not, how
not?
It seems to me what we are seeing is bad implementations of good
technology. VOIP has been around for a long time, and anyone who wanted
to use it with their broadband could have done but they didn't because
it was fiddly to configure and they didn't understand it when it didn't
work. If they wanted to force this thing on the general public then they
should have made it as seamless as possible. Instead they dumped a
router and said get on with it. The underlying motivation is increased
profits for shareholders as always.
On the contrary both the BT and EE routers are pretty much plug and
play. You get a router with a socket into which you plug you existing
phone. For the vast majority with a DECT base station its pretty much "seamless". They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain
to some. If you are one of the few with extension wiring you need to
order a patch lead from Amazon.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/28 10:49:7, JMB99 wrote:
On 28/10/2026 06:17, J. P. Gilliver wrote:Good point!
I did actually call one of the numbers in the EE leaflet, to enquire
about the battery, and the person I spoke to seemed to have little
knowledge of me - and also seemed not to have any urgency.
I have been surprised that the big chains have not been stocking /
promoting UPS's or just backup for routers.
Possibly because, to actually give any useful backup, they'd have to be
quite expensive (and possibly large), and they don't think there'd be
enough market for economies of scale to work.
I wonder if satellite phones might be the next big thing? No issues with broadband availability or local mast power supply.
I mean, a lot of modern mobile phones are already capable of sending an emergency SMS via satellite.
Tim
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:
It seems to me what we are seeing is bad implementations of good
technology. VOIP has been around for a long time, and anyone who wanted
to use it with their broadband could have done but they didn't because
it was fiddly to configure and they didn't understand it when it didn't
work. If they wanted to force this thing on the general public then they >>> should have made it as seamless as possible. Instead they dumped a
router and said get on with it. The underlying motivation is increased
profits for shareholders as always.
On the contrary both the BT and EE routers are pretty much plug and
play. You get a router with a socket into which you plug you existing
phone. For the vast majority with a DECT base station its pretty much
"seamless". They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a
pain to some. If you are one of the few with extension wiring you need
to order a patch lead from Amazon.
I simply got a SIPGATE contract and plugged my PABX into my VOIP
equipped router and set it up and it Just Worked
That was 2005 or thereabouts
I suspect it will be the same with A & A, except it will cost me money
Andy Burns wrote:
All passive optics, e.g.
<https://ebay.co.uk/itm/128135254353>
I see no mention of _filtering_ there (or in the device TNP details). [I
had wondered if some high/low wavelength filtering might be involved,
but there seems to be no mention of anything like that.) So does that
mean two customers (subscribers, whatever you call them) both receive
the same feed, i. e. might be able to see each other's data? If not, how
not?
I had wondered if some high/low wavelength filtering might be involvedAnother use for different "colours" of light is for future enhancement,
I think horses and carts need special lanes and number plates
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I think horses and carts need special lanes and number plates
I can sort-of understand the plea for special lanes but surely you
don't need a special number place to distinguish a horse and cart
from a car?
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:25:23 +0000
liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid (Liz Tuddenham) wrote:
The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
[...]
I think horses and carts need special lanes and number plates
I can sort-of understand the plea for special lanes but surely you
don't need a special number place to distinguish a horse and cart
from a car?
The emissions are certainly different.
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
All passive optics, e.g.
<https://ebay.co.uk/itm/128135254353>
I see no mention of _filtering_ there (or in the device TNP details). [I
had wondered if some high/low wavelength filtering might be involved,
There are separate wavelengths of light for upstream and downstream.
but there seems to be no mention of anything like that.) So does that
mean two customers (subscribers, whatever you call them) both receive
the same feed, i. e. might be able to see each other's data? If not, how
not?
Every ONT sees all light sent by the exchange-end (OLT) but it only
decrypts packets intended for itself and filters out the rest.
The devices have IDs that are checked at startup, during which they negotiate timeslots. Only one subscriber can "talk" at the same time,
only the OLT sees what the ONTs transmit.
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.
The emissions are certainly different.
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.
I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router. I have
never liked Voicemail.
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.
I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I have never liked Voicemail.
On 29/10/2026 19:31, Richmond wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 16:42:32, Richmond wrote:I don't think usenet is public, it is more a backwater of wierdos
"J. P. Gilliver" <G6JPG@255soft.uk> writes:
On 2026/10/29 10:57:41, David Wade wrote:
On 29/10/2026 07:23, Bob Latham wrote:
In article <nkerkvF6qq9U1@mid.individual.net>,
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
"J. P. Gilliver" wrote:
Andy Burns wrote:
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will >>>>>>>>>> be installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the >>>>>>>>>> latter ...
Depends: if either it is FTTC, or the cabinet does any sort of >>>>>>>>> concentration, then _powering_ the (in effect) ATA can't be from >>>>>>>>> the exchange.
But SoTAP is for people who currently have copper voice only,
with no broadband (that describes one of my uncles).
It also describes me. I have my BB from Virgin because of
reliability and speed but for some sort of warped sense of loyalty >>>>>>> to former days and my pension, my landline phone is still BT.
Thats is now a very expensive option...
Where it's still copper from exchange to home, i. e. the cabinet >>>>>>>>> is just a junction box, then it could be at the exchange, but I >>>>>>>>> thought that was one of the cases they're trying to reduce (and >>>>>>>>> have already in many - most? - cases).
Mine got changed over about 12 months ago and I now have to dial >>>>>>> full length numbers no locals any more. On the plus side, the line >>>>>>> is quieter than it has ever been in 40 years. I "assumed" the pots >>>>>>> was coming from a unit in the cab with the intention of closing
exchanges but I certainly have no confirmation of that.
Nope it comes from the Exchange, and so is only a transitional
product designed to go in by 2030..
Bob.
Dave
So what will happen, in 2030/2031, to those who _still_ have only a
landline 'phone (however it is actually technically implemented), no >>>>> broadband? I can see they're hoping it will have declined to zero,
but I'd be surprised. I _suspect_ - with ramping up of the public
shaming/scorning campaign already in place - they'll be told, like
it or lump it, that they'll have to switch to mobile (coverage by
then having reached them?) and change their number; or, if they are
a really tiny number, they'll be given a router (and maybe "general" >>>>> broadband too); or, perhaps, it'll be possible by then to give them
a mobile but with their old number.
What is the public shaming scorning campain in place?
Anyone who does not accept with enthusiasm, new things, is made to
feel at least a burden, if not a dinosaur/old-fashioned. For example,
"The Natural Philosopher" clearly doesn't "give a fuck" about
vulnerable people who might want to stay on just a landline; I may be
overstating the case slightly in his case, but that attitude is
definitely not rare. (Not just among indivuduals, but companies - for
example, the assumption that everyone has, carries, and uses, a
smartphone, and has a permanently-on data contract for it, so they can
use an "app" anywhere and at any time.)
and
trolls.
It seems to me what we are seeing is bad implementations of good
technology. VOIP has been around for a long time, and anyone who wanted
to use it with their broadband could have done but they didn't because
it was fiddly to configure and they didn't understand it when it didn't
work. If they wanted to force this thing on the general public then they
should have made it as seamless as possible. Instead they dumped a
router and said get on with it. The underlying motivation is increased
profits for shareholders as always.
On the contrary both the BT and EE routers are pretty much plug and
play. You get a router with a socket into which you plug you existing
phone. For the vast majority with a DECT base station its pretty much "seamless". They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a
pain to some. If you are one of the few with extension wiring you need
to order a patch lead from Amazon.
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote:
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone does
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I have
never liked Voicemail.
not get time to pick the call up.
On 30/10/2026 12:11, Davey wrote:
The emissions are certainly different.
We had a driving course at work, part of which was a series of slides
where we had to identify the hazard.
One was of a rural road with some horse manure in the road. The
'correct' reply was that it indicated a horse ahead but I pointed out
that it was not 'steaming' so must have been there for some time.
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote:
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain toI have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it
some.
will work using the telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I
have never liked Voicemail.
does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and digits.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:15:18 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote: > On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade
wrote: >> They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a
pain to >> some. > I have been tempted to dig out an old
answerphone and see if it > will work using the telephone socket on
the back of the router.-a I > have never liked Voicemail.
The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone
does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and digits.
As I would always say at work when trying to solve a mechanical or
electrical puzzle: "There is always a solution, the hard part is
finding it".
Davey <davey@example.invalid> writes:With the usual caveats of the difficulty of finding that if you don't
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:15:18 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote: > On 29/10/2026 22:26, David
Wade
wrote: >> They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a
pain to >> some. > I have been tempted to dig out an old
answerphone and see if it > will work using the telephone socket
on the back of the router.-a I > have never liked Voicemail.
The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone
does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and
digits.
As I would always say at work when trying to solve a mechanical or electrical puzzle: "There is always a solution, the hard part is
finding it".
I found this from 2022 which says 'solved'.
https://community.bt.com/t5/Home-phone-including-Digital/Digital-Voice-How-to-disable-voicemail-function/m-p/2214809#M82169
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:01:23 +0000
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 30/10/2026 12:11, Davey wrote:
The emissions are certainly different.
We had a driving course at work, part of which was a series of slides
where we had to identify the hazard.
One was of a rural road with some horse manure in the road. The
'correct' reply was that it indicated a horse ahead but I pointed out
that it was not 'steaming' so must have been there for some time.
There you go, applying common sense again.
I always wonder why you have to bag and remove your dog's faeces, but
the considerably large horses' ones can just be left in the road.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 13:10:28 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
Davey <davey@example.invalid> writes:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:15:18 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote: > On 29/10/2026 22:26, David
Wade wrote: >> They do want you to use their answerphone so that
is a pain to >> some. > I have been tempted to dig out an old
answerphone and see if it > will work using the telephone socket
on the back of the router.-a I > have never liked Voicemail.
The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own
answerphone does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and
digits.
As I would always say at work when trying to solve a mechanical or
electrical puzzle: "There is always a solution, the hard part is
finding it".
I found this from 2022 which says 'solved'.
https://community.bt.com/t5/Home-phone-including-Digital/Digital-Voice-How-to-disable-voicemail-function/m-p/2214809#M82169
With the usual caveats of the difficulty of finding that if you don't
happen to use as the internet.
I'm so glad I ditched BT many years ago.
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote:
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone does
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I have
never liked Voicemail.
not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and digits.
Davey <davey@example.invalid> writes:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:15:18 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote: > On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade
wrote: >> They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a
pain to >> some. > I have been tempted to dig out an old
answerphone and see if it > will work using the telephone socket on
the back of the router.-a I > have never liked Voicemail.
The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone
does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and digits.
As I would always say at work when trying to solve a mechanical or
electrical puzzle: "There is always a solution, the hard part is
finding it".
I found this from 2022 which says 'solved'.
https://community.bt.com/t5/Home-phone-including-Digital/Digital-Voice-How-to-disable-voicemail-function/m-p/2214809#M82169
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:01:23 +0000
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 30/10/2026 12:11, Davey wrote:
The emissions are certainly different.
We had a driving course at work, part of which was a series of slides
where we had to identify the hazard.
One was of a rural road with some horse manure in the road. The
'correct' reply was that it indicated a horse ahead but I pointed out
that it was not 'steaming' so must have been there for some time.
There you go, applying common sense again.
I always wonder why you have to bag and remove your dog's faeces, but
the considerably large horses' ones can just be left in the road.
Davey <davey@example.invalid> writes:I got tired of trying to decode their Three Card Trick bills: think of
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 13:10:28 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
Davey <davey@example.invalid> writes:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:15:18 +0000
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote: > On 29/10/2026 22:26, David
Wade wrote: >> They do want you to use their answerphone so
that is a pain to >> some. > I have been tempted to dig out
an old answerphone and see if it > will work using the
telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I > have never
liked Voicemail.
The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own
answerphone does not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and
digits.
As I would always say at work when trying to solve a mechanical
or electrical puzzle: "There is always a solution, the hard part
is finding it".
I found this from 2022 which says 'solved'.
https://community.bt.com/t5/Home-phone-including-Digital/Digital-Voice-How-to-disable-voicemail-function/m-p/2214809#M82169
With the usual caveats of the difficulty of finding that if you
don't happen to use as the internet.
I'm so glad I ditched BT many years ago.
I ditched BT about 20 years ago when they raised their call prices by
90% in the evenings and negleted to tell me except buried away several
pages into a lengthy pamphlet. I still had to use a BT line but I
didn't ever have to communicate with them and I was glad of that.
I still have a 'free' Sipgate service which runs over VM without problem.
(That's what my mum called it!)
On 2026/10/31 12:18:6, Davey wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:01:23 +0000
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 30/10/2026 12:11, Davey wrote:
The emissions are certainly different.
We had a driving course at work, part of which was a series of slides
where we had to identify the hazard.
One was of a rural road with some horse manure in the road. The
'correct' reply was that it indicated a horse ahead but I pointed out
that it was not 'steaming' so must have been there for some time.
There you go, applying common sense again.
I always wonder why you have to bag and remove your dog's faeces, but
the considerably large horses' ones can just be left in the road.
The nature of the hazard is different - horsh is fibrous, and also as
you say large and hard to miss (and in theory useful); dogsh is small
(and thus can be missed until too late), and unpleasant both in texture
and smell. (At least my mind tells me the latter - I can't say I've ever checked that.)
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.
I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router. I have never liked Voicemail.
David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid> writes:
On 31/10/2026 11:54, JMB99 wrote:
On 29/10/2026 22:26, David Wade wrote:The BT/EE voicemail kicks in very quickly so your own answerphone does
They do want you to use their answerphone so that is a pain to some.I have been tempted to dig out an old answerphone and see if it will
work using the telephone socket on the back of the router.-a I have
never liked Voicemail.
not get time to pick the call up.
You should be able to disable it with some sequence of # and digits.
I always wonder why you have to bag and remove your dog's faeces, but
the considerably large horses' ones can just be left in the road.
J. P. Gilliver <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:So is fox's. We do not pick that up. Not having vet sessions. fox is far
(That's what my mum called it!)
On 2026/10/31 12:18:6, Davey wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 12:01:23 +0000The nature of the hazard is different - horsh is fibrous, and also as
JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 30/10/2026 12:11, Davey wrote:
The emissions are certainly different.
We had a driving course at work, part of which was a series of slides
where we had to identify the hazard.
One was of a rural road with some horse manure in the road. The
'correct' reply was that it indicated a horse ahead but I pointed out
that it was not 'steaming' so must have been there for some time.
There you go, applying common sense again.
I always wonder why you have to bag and remove your dog's faeces, but
the considerably large horses' ones can just be left in the road.
you say large and hard to miss (and in theory useful); dogsh is small
(and thus can be missed until too late), and unpleasant both in texture
and smell. (At least my mind tells me the latter - I can't say I've ever
checked that.)
Dog excrement may be toxic and is most undesirable if dropped on
e.g. sports or childrens' recreation grounds. Chat GPT says:
----
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 14:08:28 +0000[]
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
[]I ditched BT about 20 years ago when they raised their call prices by
I got tired of trying to decode their Three Card Trick bills: think of
a number, reduce it because the monthly cost increased halfway through,
then multiply the removed cost by another factor to charge at the new
rate. Or something like that. It was almost impossible to follow the
thinking (and that was before AI came along).
After I switched to Zen, there were no price increases. Bliss.
On 28/10/2026 17:36, Andy Burns wrote:
The exchange will cease to exist, so noshing will be installed in it
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
On Wed, 28 Oct 2026 22:32:45 +0000, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 28/10/2026 17:36, Andy Burns wrote:Yes, but not just yet.
The exchange will cease to exist, so noshing will be installed in it
It's never been clear (to me) whether the "box" for SoTAP will be
installedm], in the cabinet or exchange, I tend to think the latter ...
Currently there's no hard end date for:
Pre-digital phone line - analogue voice from an ATA in the exchange
SOTAP - VoIP over ADSL, from a DSLAM in the exchange
MPF - phone lines from Sky or TalkTalk equipment in the exchange
Some exchanges will close sooner than others, which means all these
services will go away. But it may take a while, and some will be hanging
on for many years.
Mike
Mike Humphrey wrote:With that in mind, BT seem somewhat relaxed on timescale, just over 100 exchanges have a scheduled evacuation by 2030, the rest over the next
Some exchanges will close sooner than others, which means all these
services will go away. But it may take a while, and some will be hanging
on for many years.
There might not be a "Hard Date" but apart from MPF these are clearly marketed as transitional products with a TARGETTED end date of 2030.
They are not available for new supply.
The leases on the Exchanges ends in 2030 so there is a big incentive to remove the buildings as the rent will rise considerably on Exchanges retained beyond this date.
David Wade wrote:
Mike Humphrey wrote:With that in mind, BT seem somewhat relaxed on timescale, just over 100 exchanges have a scheduled evacuation by 2030, the rest over the next decade.
Some exchanges will close sooner than others, which means all these
services will go away. But it may take a while, and some will be hanging >>> on for many years.
There might not be a "Hard Date" but apart from MPF these are clearly
marketed as transitional products with a TARGETTED end date of 2030.
They are not available for new supply.
The leases on the Exchanges ends in 2030 so there is a big incentive
to remove the buildings as the rent will rise considerably on
Exchanges retained beyond this date.
Andy Burns wrote:
I thought that too. I wasn't quite accurate, apparently the leasesBT seem somewhat relaxed on timescale, just over100 exchanges have a scheduled evacuation by 2030, the rest over the
next decade.
continue until 2031 but I can't see an exact date in 2031.
The next break-point in the lease would I believe be 2041 so perhapsApparently BT have the option to buy the buildings back, wonder if
that explains the 10 year plan.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:57:17 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,718 |