I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is complicated)
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
If you use a VoIP phone dialling from a memory will connect instantly,
it often works more like using a mobile than an analogue phone so
typically you enter or recall a number and press a GO or green or a tick (reU) button. Calling via an ATA usually takes a few seconds more than the time it takes the analogue phone to send the DTMF, because there is a usually a timeout to detect that you've stopped adding more digits to
the number.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also how
to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is complicated)
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
If you use a VoIP phone dialling from a memory will connect instantly,
it often works more like using a mobile than an analogue phone so
typically you enter or recall a number and press a GO or green or a tick (reU) button. Calling via an ATA usually takes a few seconds more than the time it takes the analogue phone to send the DTMF, because there is a usually a timeout to detect that you've stopped adding more digits to
the number.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also how
to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
On Thu 15/10/2026 23:03, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one. Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is complicated)
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by using a VoIP phone.
If you use a VoIP phone dialling from a memory will connect instantly,
it often works more like using a mobile than an analogue phone so typically you enter or recall a number and press a GO or green or a tick (reU) button. Calling via an ATA usually takes a few seconds more than the time it takes the analogue phone to send the DTMF, because there is a usually a timeout to detect that you've stopped adding more digits to
the number.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
I have a Panasonic desktop VoIP phone which works a treat - or rather it
did when I installed it for my late f-in-l. I also have a couple of
Linksys PAP2T or SPA2102 ATA's with which I have had no problem - save
that whilst we were away earlier this year the PSU expired and something
it did faulted the ATA - I could receive calls but if I wanted to make a call I only got a single tone instead of a proper dial tome.
Other VoIP phones are such as Yealink/YeaStar, Grandstream (who also do ATAs) and D-Link. For set-up parameters just look at a few VoIP service providers and if necessary ring them and ask if they will supply
operating parameters so you can used your own ATA - IME many will.
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Am 16.10.26 um 11:05 schrieb Richmond:
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Of course. There are different codecs and your ISP might convert them if needed.
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the lowest standard will define the speech quality.
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
The Natural Philosopher wrote:
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
I think you're right to assume that most ISPs outsource the VoIP, but
not all do (e.g. AAISP)
On 16/10/2026 10:05, Richmond wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
IME with first Cisco and then Draytek routers with VOIP ports, the only >degradation below 'better than POTS by a large margin' was packet loss >causing breakup and distortion when my (now ex) wife was watching a
video
On 15/10/2026 23:03, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
If you mean a device plugs into the local LAN and talks VOIP yes these >exist. However they can't be used with EE ot BT routers as these are
locked down.
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is
complicated)
You might want to look at a used Fritz!Box router with VOIP as they can
act as a SIP server and mini PABX. You can of course also run Asterisk
on a PI or similar.
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog TelephoneIt depends on the router and VOIP service. So if its a BT or EE router
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
If you use a VoIP phone dialling from a memory will connect instantly,
it often works more like using a mobile than an analogue phone so
typically you enter or recall a number and press a GO or green or a tick
(?) button. Calling via an ATA usually takes a few seconds more than the
time it takes the analogue phone to send the DTMF, because there is a
usually a timeout to detect that you've stopped adding more digits to
the number.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also how
to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
you are locked into BT devices and can't add a "corded" SIP phone.
If its a Fritz!box from ZEN that can act as a SIP server and mini PABX.
So by having multiple SIP phones connected by Ethernet you can have your
own internal phone system with extension dialing. As its also a DECT
base station you can do the same with DECT
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Or shuffling packet queues based on whether there is a VoIP packet in them(typos in above line corrected)
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the lowest
standard will define the speech quality.
That is ALL that is relevant, that and the bandwidth, packet loss-a and latency between the devices
None of which is necessaruly ISP specific
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 09:26:04 +0100, David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid>
wrote:
On 15/10/2026 23:03, Brian Gregory wrote:As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
If you mean a device plugs into the local LAN and talks VOIP yes these
exist. However they can't be used with EE ot BT routers as these are
locked down.
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is
complicated)
You might want to look at a used Fritz!Box router with VOIP as they can
act as a SIP server and mini PABX. You can of course also run Asterisk
on a PI or similar.
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog TelephoneIt depends on the router and VOIP service. So if its a BT or EE router
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
If you use a VoIP phone dialling from a memory will connect instantly,
it often works more like using a mobile than an analogue phone so
typically you enter or recall a number and press a GO or green or a tick >>> (?) button. Calling via an ATA usually takes a few seconds more than the >>> time it takes the analogue phone to send the DTMF, because there is a
usually a timeout to detect that you've stopped adding more digits to
the number.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also how >>> to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
you are locked into BT devices and can't add a "corded" SIP phone.
If its a Fritz!box from ZEN that can act as a SIP server and mini PABX.
So by having multiple SIP phones connected by Ethernet you can have your
own internal phone system with extension dialing. As its also a DECT
base station you can do the same with DECT
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
The Natural Philosopher wrote:More likely the router separates off the VoIP traffic, and sends it to
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are runningtheir own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Which obviously they are, since his analogue phone was plugged into his router.
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
I'm with Zen.
But I'm not using the Fritzbox. I couldn't cope with the weird names
they call things that are presumably simplistic translations of their
German names. But now I suspect my setup is also more complicated than
the Fritzbox is capable of.
Zen's, rather limited, information on setting up your own VoIP device is >here:
https://www.zen.co.uk/help-support/general-sip-settings/
I set mine up using info in a blog I found before I knew about that page
and I used UDP ports 10000-20000 for RTP while Zen says "Media Call
Audio Addresses Ports - 20000 to 30000 UDP" so I guess you can actually
use whatever you want in that case. Also it did seem to be easy enough
to get it to work without port forwarding those ports, but I chose to
port forward, but only UDP from Zen's VoIP servers (62.3.88.0/27).
Also note that the Fritzbox provides some of the service like the
answering machine which you won't get on Zen with most VoIP phones.
Brian Gregory wrote:
The Natural Philosopher wrote:More likely the router separates off the VoIP traffic, and sends it to servers operated by (guessing) BT or Magrathea
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are runningtheir own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Which obviously they are, since his analogue phone was plugged into
his router.
On 16/10/2026 16:31, Andy Burns wrote:
Brian Gregory wrote:
The Natural Philosopher wrote:More likely the router separates off the VoIP traffic, and sends it to
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are runningtheir own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Which obviously they are, since his analogue phone was plugged into
his router.
servers operated by (guessing) BT or Magrathea
The reverse lookups of the IPs used are Zen names even if I don't use
Zen's DNS, which I don't.
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the traditional phone I am using.
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard >rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 16:04:02 +0100, Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
I'm with Zen.
But I'm not using the Fritzbox. I couldn't cope with the weird names
they call things that are presumably simplistic translations of their
German names. But now I suspect my setup is also more complicated than
the Fritzbox is capable of.
Zen's, rather limited, information on setting up your own VoIP device is
here:
https://www.zen.co.uk/help-support/general-sip-settings/
I set mine up using info in a blog I found before I knew about that page
and I used UDP ports 10000-20000 for RTP while Zen says "Media Call
Audio Addresses Ports - 20000 to 30000 UDP" so I guess you can actually
use whatever you want in that case. Also it did seem to be easy enough
to get it to work without port forwarding those ports, but I chose to
port forward, but only UDP from Zen's VoIP servers (62.3.88.0/27).
Also note that the Fritzbox provides some of the service like the
answering machine which you won't get on Zen with most VoIP phones.
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the traditional phone I am using.
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 16:04:02 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box? >>>> Does SIP phone require a power supply?
I'm with Zen.
But I'm not using the Fritzbox. I couldn't cope with the weird names
they call things that are presumably simplistic translations of their
German names. But now I suspect my setup is also more complicated than
the Fritzbox is capable of.
Zen's, rather limited, information on setting up your own VoIP device is >>> here:
https://www.zen.co.uk/help-support/general-sip-settings/
I set mine up using info in a blog I found before I knew about that page >>> and I used UDP ports 10000-20000 for RTP while Zen says "Media Call
Audio Addresses Ports - 20000 to 30000 UDP" so I guess you can actually
use whatever you want in that case. Also it did seem to be easy enough
to get it to work without port forwarding those ports, but I chose to
port forward, but only UDP from Zen's VoIP servers (62.3.88.0/27).
Also note that the Fritzbox provides some of the service like the
answering machine which you won't get on Zen with most VoIP phones.
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
Personally I would try a DECT phone linked to the Fritz!box DECT Base. I >have a Panasonic linked direct to my FritzBox and I think the call
quality is better than the IP Phone I tried. You can do some tweaking of
the audio in the Fritz...
Dave
p.s. this model
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/237126660958
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:59:35 +0100, David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid>
wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:Why would a DECT phone linked to the FRITZ!Box be better that a corded
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 16:04:02 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I >>>>> can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box? >>>>> Does SIP phone require a power supply?
I'm with Zen.
But I'm not using the Fritzbox. I couldn't cope with the weird names
they call things that are presumably simplistic translations of their
German names. But now I suspect my setup is also more complicated than >>>> the Fritzbox is capable of.
Zen's, rather limited, information on setting up your own VoIP device is >>>> here:
https://www.zen.co.uk/help-support/general-sip-settings/
I set mine up using info in a blog I found before I knew about that page >>>> and I used UDP ports 10000-20000 for RTP while Zen says "Media Call
Audio Addresses Ports - 20000 to 30000 UDP" so I guess you can actually >>>> use whatever you want in that case. Also it did seem to be easy enough >>>> to get it to work without port forwarding those ports, but I chose to
port forward, but only UDP from Zen's VoIP servers (62.3.88.0/27).
Also note that the Fritzbox provides some of the service like the
answering machine which you won't get on Zen with most VoIP phones.
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
Personally I would try a DECT phone linked to the Fritz!box DECT Base. I
have a Panasonic linked direct to my FritzBox and I think the call
quality is better than the IP Phone I tried. You can do some tweaking of
the audio in the Fritz...
Dave
p.s. this model
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/237126660958
phone linked to the FRITZ!Box?
On 16/10/2026 18:41, Scott wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:59:35 +0100, David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid>
wrote:
Why would a DECT phone linked to the FRITZ!Box be better that a corded
phone linked to the FRITZ!Box?
Because many corded phones are pretty naff.
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard
rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
On 16/10/2026 10:49, Marco Moock wrote:
Am 16.10.26 um 11:05 schrieb Richmond:The ISP is not involved in inspeccting packets passing through it or changing their protocols.
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Of course. There are different codecs and your ISP might convert them
if needed.
The codecs in use are a function of the endpoints, which are other VOIP phones
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Or shuffling packet queus based on whether there is a viOPp packet in them
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the lowest
standard will define the speech quality.
That is ALL that is relevant, that and the bandwidth, packet loss-a and latency between the devices
Brian Gregory wrote:
The Natural Philosopher wrote:More likely the router separates off the VoIP traffic, and sends it to servers operated by (guessing) BT or Magrathea
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are runningtheir own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Which obviously they are, since his analogue phone was plugged into
his router.
No it needs to be configured both in the Fritz!Box and in the phone.
Just check if you go to Telephony-> Devices in the Fritz you can add a device and add a network telephone.
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 11:58:33 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 10:05, Richmond wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:
Sometimes using an analogue phone with any ATA (Analog Telephone
Adapter) that allows an ordinary analogue phone to connect to VoIP
results in poor sound and/or some echo which can mostly be avoided by
using a VoIP phone.
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
IME with first Cisco and then Draytek routers with VOIP ports, the only
degradation below 'better than POTS by a large margin' was packet loss
causing breakup and distortion when my (now ex) wife was watching a
video
A situation you obviously dealt with decisively :-)
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> writes:Not really. ISP is technically someone who provides access to the
The Natural Philosopher wrote:
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
I think you're right to assume that most ISPs outsource the VoIP, but
not all do (e.g. AAISP)
I am with AAISP. But I see Voipfone is also an ISP. And anyone who runs
a SIP registrar/proxy to handle registration and call routing is
technically an ISP.
Brian Gregory wrote:
The Natural Philosopher wrote:More likely the router separates off the VoIP traffic, and sends it to servers operated by (guessing) BT or Magrathea
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are runningtheir own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
Which obviously they are, since his analogue phone was plugged into
his router.
Scott wrote:AIUI the sip server simply registers your phone number IP address and
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
Basically yes ... SIP is the signalling protocol and RTP is used for the actual audio/video.
On 16/10/2026 18:41, Scott wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:59:35 +0100, David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid>
wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:Why would a DECT phone linked to the FRITZ!Box be better that a corded
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 16:04:02 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I >>>>>> can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the >>>>>> box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
I'm with Zen.
But I'm not using the Fritzbox. I couldn't cope with the weird names >>>>> they call things that are presumably simplistic translations of their >>>>> German names. But now I suspect my setup is also more complicated than >>>>> the Fritzbox is capable of.
Zen's, rather limited, information on setting up your own VoIP
device is
here:
https://www.zen.co.uk/help-support/general-sip-settings/
I set mine up using info in a blog I found before I knew about that >>>>> page
and I used UDP ports 10000-20000 for RTP while Zen says "Media Call
Audio Addresses Ports - 20000 to 30000 UDP" so I guess you can
actually
use whatever you want in that case. Also it did seem to be easy enough >>>>> to get it to work without port forwarding those ports, but I chose to >>>>> port forward, but only UDP from Zen's VoIP servers (62.3.88.0/27).
Also note that the Fritzbox provides some of the service like the
answering machine which you won't get on Zen with most VoIP phones.
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
Personally I would try a DECT phone linked to the Fritz!box DECT Base. I >>> have a Panasonic linked direct to my FritzBox and I think the call
quality is better than the IP Phone I tried. You can do some tweaking of >>> the audio in the Fritz...
Dave
p.s. this model
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/237126660958
phone linked to the FRITZ!Box?
Because many corded phones are pretty naff.
Dave--
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard
rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Am 16.10.26 um 13:03 schrieb The Natural Philosopher:
On 16/10/2026 10:49, Marco Moock wrote:
Am 16.10.26 um 11:05 schrieb Richmond:The ISP is not involved in inspeccting packets passing through it or
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Of course. There are different codecs and your ISP might convert them
if needed.
changing their protocols.
As many people use the VoIP service from their ISP, I used that term. In case they use something else, that service will do the VoIP stuff. How
is such a service provider properly called?
The codecs in use are a function of the endpoints, which are other
VOIP phones
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
They do that and most users use such a service. Direct VOIP calling is possible, but no normal users uses that. There was an idea to use DNS to
get the remote's IP, but the telephone companies didn't like that.
Or shuffling packet queus based on whether there is a viOPp packet in
them
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the lowest
standard will define the speech quality.
That is ALL that is relevant, that and the bandwidth, packet loss-a and
latency between the devices
In case there is a mismatch, a conversion needs to be done. Depending on
how the telephone companies route the phone traffic, they might need to change to a lower codec.
Am 16.10.26 um 16:44 schrieb David Wade:
No it needs to be configured both in the Fritz!Box and in the phone.
Just check if you go to Telephony-> Devices in the Fritz you can add a
device and add a network telephone.
You can also let the VoIP phone register at the SIP server.
Although, the router's firewall needs to be configured to let the
SIP/RTP packets through. Not very model supports such rulesets.
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard >>>> rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Am 16.10.26 um 11:05 schrieb Richmond:
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Of course. There are different codecs and your ISP might convert them if needed.
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the lowest standard will define the speech quality.
Yaeh. Now I have no wife and fibre to the premises.
Good upgrade
On 15/10/2026 23:03, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
If you mean a device plugs into the local LAN and talks VOIP yes these exist. However they can't be used with EE ot BT routers as these are
locked down.
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is
complicated)
You might want to look at a used Fritz!Box router with VOIP as they can
act as a SIP server and mini PABX. You can of course also run Asterisk
on a PI or similar.
It depends on the router and VOIP service. So if its a BT or EE router
you are locked into BT devices and can't add a "corded" SIP phone.
If its a Fritz!box from ZEN that can act as a SIP server and mini PABX.
So by having multiple SIP phones connected by Ethernet you can have your
own internal phone system with extension dialing. As its also a DECT
base station you can do the same with DECT
Dave
If its being mapped to a land line it needs a special gateway, but since everyone is going VOIP I expect less use of that. More likely a gateway
to mobile.
That is what costs money. Voip to Voip should be free
In some discussion on this matter a while back (external ATAs were the
main consideration at that point), some people in the discussion said
that some ATAs could handle a variety of compression/encoding protocols,
and some said you could choose the one you wanted to use.
(That
discussion started out by comaparing the quality of VoIP to normal POTS,
with some [people with hearing impairments] saying they couldn't get on
with e. g. whatever mobile 'phones use, only normal 'phones; others
pointed out that normal 'phones use an encoding/compression standard
anyway, and even named it [I think it was a 5 or 6 character string of letters and numbers].)
On 2026/10/16 21:19:25, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
[]
If its being mapped to a land line it needs a special gateway, but sinceInteresting point - but, initially at least, they've managed to arrange
everyone is going VOIP I expect less use of that. More likely a gateway
to mobile.
That is what costs money. Voip to Voip should be free
that it's _not_ free (though cheap), other than anytime contracts (which
cost more so aren't free either).
_Hopefully_, it'll be like broadband eventually: I remember when many,
if not most, broadband contracts had usage caps; I doubt there are many,
if any, such remaining now (for fibre or copper connections I mean,
rather than over the mobile network where I think they mostly still are).
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless >>>>> VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume >>>>> the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the >>>>> traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a >>>> VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard >>>> rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the >>> same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
On 2026/10/16 9:26:4, David Wade wrote:
On 15/10/2026 23:03, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 15/10/2026 21:19, Scott wrote:
I have a router beside my desk with a standard phone plugged into it.
Do corded VOIP phones exist and would they offer any benefit?
If you mean a device plugs into the local LAN and talks VOIP yes these
exist. However they can't be used with EE ot BT routers as these are
locked down.
Thanks for the warning. Probably not a problem to me initially, as I'll almost certainly be using such (and will be with such routers), since I
will otherwise have redundant 'phones I can't sell and have no desire to scrap.
(Interesting side-thought: both EE and BT offer "adapters" for use "if
your router is in an awkward place" - there are devices that just plug
into a mains socket, and you plug your [analogue] 'phone into them, and
they link to the router. Do they contain ATA hardware, or is that all in
the router and their connection to the router is by some yet other
protocol, possibly even analogue?)
Also: when I first looked into VoIP, one of the options - cost-free, as opposed to having to buy either an ATA or a VoIP-enabled 'phone - was
the entirely-software method, where you used your (e. g.) laptop's
speaker and microphone, somewhat like a Skype/Zoom/whatever call (sound
only, of course), I suppose. I've seen no mention of this lately - is it considerably inferior and just a get-started system while you're waiting
for your ATA to be delivered, or ...? Also, can it be used with the
BT/EE routers or do they block that too?
Yes they do.
I have two Snom D120 (wired) phones. (At present I only use one.
Connecting more than one to a VoIP service designed for a single ATA is
complicated)
You might want to look at a used Fritz!Box router with VOIP as they can
act as a SIP server and mini PABX. You can of course also run Asterisk
on a PI or similar.
So it's the router, not the ISP contract/whatever, that is the block/lock?
[]
It depends on the router and VOIP service. So if its a BT or EE router
you are locked into BT devices and can't add a "corded" SIP phone.
Or, presumably, an external ATA (not that I can see why you'd want to as there's in effect one in the router), as that would in effect be a VoIP 'phone.
If its a Fritz!box from ZEN that can act as a SIP server and mini PABX.
So by having multiple SIP phones connected by Ethernet you can have your
own internal phone system with extension dialing. As its also a DECT
base station you can do the same with DECT
Dave
They certainly - whether deliberately or not, and I think it's probably not-deliberately-but-they-don't-want-too-expend-any-effort-explaining -
seem to be concealing what does what. Much like - especially in the
early days - mobile companies confused the public about the difference between the hardware and the service.
On 17/10/2026 02:57, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
On 2026/10/16 21:19:25, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
[]
If its being mapped to a land line it needs a special gateway, but since >>> everyone is going VOIP I expect less use of that. More likely a gatewayInteresting point - but, initially at least, they've managed to arrange
to mobile.
That is what costs money. Voip to Voip should be free
that it's _not_ free (though cheap), other than anytime contracts (which
cost more so aren't free either).
_Hopefully_, it'll be like broadband eventually: I remember when many,
if not most, broadband contracts had usage caps; I doubt there are many,
if any, such remaining now (for fibre or copper connections I mean,
rather than over the mobile network where I think they mostly still are).
TBH I am not sure how long VOIP phones will last anyway. WE have [essentially] free whatsapp or skype messaging, and mobile phones with
data connections.
VOIP is replacing a technology that is already passing out of use.
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:But DECT and VOIP are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless
VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume
the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >> >>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the
traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard >> >>>> rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the >> >>> same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
to have a VOIP system that uses DECT handsets. It's also possible to
have both a DECT/VOIP system and a separate VOIP phone using the same
router (I've done it!). The router doesn't really know or care if a
device that's connected to it is VOIP or any other protocol.
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
The Fritzbox should have enough power to drive a basic analogue phone
If it is compatible with the SIP service it just needs a connection to
your LAN, and some power.
Mobile is not VOIP. There is - or was - no IP involved.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 09:08:09 +0100, Chris Green <cl@isbd.net> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:But DECT and VOIP are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless >> >>>>> VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume >> >>>>> the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >> >>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the >> >>>>> traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a >> >>>> VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard
rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the >> >>> same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
to have a VOIP system that uses DECT handsets. It's also possible to
have both a DECT/VOIP system and a separate VOIP phone using the same >router (I've done it!). The router doesn't really know or care if a
device that's connected to it is VOIP or any other protocol.
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
On 17/10/2026 02:23, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
In some discussion on this matter a while back (external ATAs were the
main consideration at that point), some people in the discussion said
that some ATAs could handle a variety of compression/encoding protocols,
and some said you could choose the one you wanted to use.
I THINK that is correct. My router has tunable options for VOIP, AIUI
the endpoint VOIP units (whatever they are ) negotiate a common
standard, or at least acceptable ones in both direction. Mine is
currently set to 'prefer' an 8kbps codec. This gives excellent results
but faster options are avialable
(That
discussion started out by comaparing the quality of VoIP to normal POTS,
with some [people with hearing impairments] saying they couldn't get on
with e. g. whatever mobile 'phones use, only normal 'phones; others
pointed out that normal 'phones use an encoding/compression standard
anyway, and even named it [I think it was a 5 or 6 character string of
letters and numbers].)
'Normal' phones use a 64kbps fixed TDM . Crude by today's standards but >very advanced when it first came out. I am fairly sure that conversion
to and from analogue happens at the exchange.
That is why modems could only ever reach 56Kbps or thereabouts and ISDN >lines were 64kbps digital
UK backbone is/was built of links that are multiples of this speed,
Then I think it moved to frame relay, but the basic encoding didn't change >VOIP phones use 'intelligent' codecs that can get te same or bvetter
quality into e.g an 8kbps channel
Mobile data rates are much much lower. Hundreds of calls need to be
squeezed into a very limited RF spectrum. 8kbps is luxury. 1kbps is
normal and in congested areas even less. To the point where it becomes >unintelligible.
Mobile is not VOIP. There is - or was - no IP involved. Different
standards to meet different limitations. Mobiles are massively bandwidth >limited, but even an ADSL links is way way faster than a mobile link
*used* to be. I cant answer for 4G/5G
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
Yes. essentially the fritzbox or the pure voiphone need to connect to a
SIP server which as a record of their 'phone number' and registers an IP
and port address ion it.
The router has to allow incoming traffic to reach that port. Sometimes
NAT will do it but mostly the router needs to map the frirzbox/voip
phone-a ip address and port to a public ip address and port.
My router contains the equoivalent of two fritz boxes as well as its
normal fiunctions
In use, to dial out, you contact the server with the number you want to contact, and that either tells you how to contact it directly via IP address/port, ifs its VOIP or directs you to a gateway to POTS or mobile services or proxies the connection to a remote number itself
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a
VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard rather than to connect directly to Zen.
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 21:09:30 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
The Fritzbox should have enough power to drive a basic analogue phone
Yes it can but the audio quality is not very good (not as good at the cordless) and there is a loud buzzing noise.
If it is compatible with the SIP service it just needs a connection to
your LAN, and some power.
I can do that with the cordless but I wondered about a corded phone
for my desk (with the option of headphones) given that the router is
only 1 metre away.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 09:08:09 +0100, Chris Green <cl@isbd.net> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:But DECT and VOIP are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless >>>>>>>>> VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume >>>>>>>>> the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >>>>>>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the >>>>>>>>> traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a >>>>>>>> VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard >>>>>>>> rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the >>>>>>> same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured?
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
to have a VOIP system that uses DECT handsets. It's also possible to
have both a DECT/VOIP system and a separate VOIP phone using the same
router (I've done it!). The router doesn't really know or care if a
device that's connected to it is VOIP or any other protocol.
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
I think you understand correctly. The VOIP handset just requires a way to communicate with the internet which it gets by using WiFi to the router.
As I said the router doesn't care really what's connected, it just
provides a link between the VOIP handset and the internet.
The FON port on the router is (I think) a built in VOIP 'endpoint' that allows you to connect an old POTS phone to it.
I think some FRITZ routers may **also** be DECT base stations so they
provide a way for DECT handsets to connect, through the VOIP
'endpoint' in the router to the internet.
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 21:09:30 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
The Fritzbox should have enough power to drive a basic analogue phone
Yes it can but the audio quality is not very good (not as good at the cordless) and there is a loud buzzing noise.
If it is compatible with the SIP service it just needs a connection to
your LAN, and some power.
I can do that with the cordless but I wondered about a corded phone
for my desk (with the option of headphones) given that the router is
only 1 metre away.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also
how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP through to your VoIP phone.
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
If it is compatible with the SIP service it just needs a connection to >your LAN, and some power.
I can do that with the cordless but I wondered about a corded phone
for my desk (with the option of headphones) given that the router is
only 1 metre away.
The Natural Philosopher wrote:
Mobile is not VOIP. There is - or was - no IP involved.
The only mobile that *isn't* VoIP is 2G.
3G is gone.
4G and 5G are pure IP networks, VoLTE is SIP/RTP over IP, VoNR is the equivalent for 5G.
Granted, phones can for the short term choose to drop to 2G to do voice.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also
how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP through to your VoIP phone.
Presumably you could have a different number on the VOIP phone, and the router should route calls to the appropriate port, phone port 1 or 2, or
the Ethernet port.
Or if all phones had the same number, then the router would route
traffic to the one which made the call.
What would happen for incoming calls? Would all the phones rings?
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:If it's a VOIP phone then the router isn't involved at all except to the extent of sending and receiving the VOIP data packets.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also
how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
Presumably you could have a different number on the VOIP phone, and the
router should route calls to the appropriate port, phone port 1 or 2, or
the Ethernet port.
Or if all phones had the same number, then the router would routeSee above, the router isn't involved. This is one of the difficulties
traffic to the one which made the call.
when using VOIP phones via a typical home router that does NAT. There
isn't a simple way for the packets of data coming 'back' to find the VOIP handset. The A&A website has a better explanation of this problem than I will ever manage, and A&A dislike NAT for this very reason.
What would happen for incoming calls? Would all the phones rings?
If there's more than one VOIP phone registered to a VOIP number then all
of them will ring (or receive the call anyway). They don't have to be connected via the same router or even be in the same country. I have a
VOIP phone on my boat in France which receives calls at the same time as
our VOIP phones at home in the UK as it's registered with the same number
at the same VOIP provider.
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:If it's a VOIP phone then the router isn't involved at all except to the extent of sending and receiving the VOIP data packets.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also
how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
Presumably you could have a different number on the VOIP phone, and the
router should route calls to the appropriate port, phone port 1 or 2, or
the Ethernet port.
Or if all phones had the same number, then the router would routeSee above, the router isn't involved. This is one of the difficulties
traffic to the one which made the call.
when using VOIP phones via a typical home router that does NAT. There
isn't a simple way for the packets of data coming 'back' to find the VOIP handset. The A&A website has a better explanation of this problem than I will ever manage, and A&A dislike NAT for this very reason.
What would happen for incoming calls? Would all the phones rings?
If there's more than one VOIP phone registered to a VOIP number then all
of them will ring (or receive the call anyway). They don't have to be connected via the same router or even be in the same country. I have a
VOIP phone on my boat in France which receives calls at the same time as
our VOIP phones at home in the UK as it's registered with the same number
at the same VOIP provider.
On 17/10/2026 10:06, Chris Green wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:The ones Zen supplies are....
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 09:08:09 +0100, Chris Green <cl@isbd.net> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:But DECT and VOIP are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless >>>>>>>>>> VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume >>>>>>>>>> the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP >>>>>>>>>> (SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the >>>>>>>>>> traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a >>>>>>>>> VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard
rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the >>>>>>>> same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured? >>>>>>>
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
to have a VOIP system that uses DECT handsets. It's also possible to
have both a DECT/VOIP system and a separate VOIP phone using the same
router (I've done it!). The router doesn't really know or care if a
device that's connected to it is VOIP or any other protocol.
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
I think you understand correctly. The VOIP handset just requires a way to
communicate with the internet which it gets by using WiFi to the router.
As I said the router doesn't care really what's connected, it just
provides a link between the VOIP handset and the internet.
The FON port on the router is (I think) a built in VOIP 'endpoint' that
allows you to connect an old POTS phone to it.
I think some FRITZ routers may **also** be DECT base stations so they
provide a way for DECT handsets to connect, through the VOIP
'endpoint' in the router to the internet.
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 11:50:50 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
It was serious because I am puzzled. When I visited Droitwich I was
told the polarisation was vertical. Is MW different in this respect?
That is very odd. I have my old house wiring and a DECT base station
plugged into the analogue phone port on one of my Fritz routers and
don't get any buzzing.
On 16/10/2026 17:41, Andy Burns wrote:
Scott wrote:AIUI the sip server simply registers your phone number-a IP address and
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
Basically yes ... SIP is the signalling protocol and RTP is used for
the actual audio/video.
port number, so when someone wants to connect to your phone they know
which port to access on which IP address
It may act as a proxy too,
But ideally it takes no part in sending voice packets
Its more like a DNS server than a router.
So e.g if you want to phone someone it says 'contact 176.4.35.1 on port 9900' and so you do, and the other end says 'hi im a voip line' and you
talk direct
If its being mapped to a land line it needs a special gateway, but since everyone is going VOIP I expect less use of that. More likely a gateway
to mobile.
That is what costs money. Voip to Voip should be free
On 17/10/2026 12:56, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 11:50:50 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
It was serious because I am puzzled. When I visited Droitwich I was
told the polarisation was vertical. Is MW different in this respect?
I dunno to be honest. I thought it was
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 10:56:11 +0100, David Wade <g4ugm@dave.invalid>
wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:06, Chris Green wrote:Does this mean my FRITZ!Fon is DECT and not WiFi?
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:The ones Zen supplies are....
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 09:08:09 +0100, Chris Green <cl@isbd.net> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 21:37, The Natural Philosopher wrote:But DECT and VOIP are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible >>>>> to have a VOIP system that uses DECT handsets. It's also possible to >>>>> have both a DECT/VOIP system and a separate VOIP phone using the same >>>>> router (I've done it!). The router doesn't really know or care if a >>>>> device that's connected to it is VOIP or any other protocol.
On 16/10/2026 19:30, Brian Gregory wrote:
On 16/10/2026 17:37, Scott wrote:I expect most have a web interface
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 17:16:52 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 16/10/2026 16:40, Scott wrote:
I don't know if this helps or hinders but I already have a cordless >>>>>>>>>>> VOIP phone (FRITZ!Fon) that links direct to the router (so I assume >>>>>>>>>>> the basic set-up is in place). Now I am thinking about a corded VOIP
(SIP) phone for my desk as the audio quality is not too good on the >>>>>>>>>>> traditional phone I am using.
You will need Fritzbox documentation to find out about configuring a >>>>>>>>>> VoIP phone to connect to and use the Fritzbox as a kind of switchboard
rather than to connect directly to Zen.
Why can't it be connected in the same way as the FRITZ!Fon? Is SIP the
same as VOIP?
Oh! Is the FRITZ!Fon not DECT? Most are.
If not and it's VoIP then do you know how its VoIP is configured? >>>>>>>>
Google thinks all FRITZ!Fon are DECT, not VoIP.
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
I think you understand correctly. The VOIP handset just requires a way to >>> communicate with the internet which it gets by using WiFi to the router. >>> As I said the router doesn't care really what's connected, it just
provides a link between the VOIP handset and the internet.
The FON port on the router is (I think) a built in VOIP 'endpoint' that >>> allows you to connect an old POTS phone to it.
I think some FRITZ routers may **also** be DECT base stations so they
provide a way for DECT handsets to connect, through the VOIP
'endpoint' in the router to the internet.
Does this improve or
worsen its range?
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
On 17/10/2026 13:32, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 12:56, Scott wrote:I did a bit more research. It is indeed vertical. So whip antennae work. Well you will just have to bottom load as tall a bit of metal as you can erect :-)
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 11:50:50 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:It was serious because I am puzzled. When I visited Droitwich I was
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS >>>>>> NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial >>>>> be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line >>>
told the polarisation was vertical. Is MW different in this respect?
I dunno to be honest. I thought it was
If there's more than one VOIP phone registered to a VOIP number then all
of them will ring (or receive the call anyway). They don't have to be connected via the same router or even be in the same country. I have a> VOIP phone on my boat in France which receives calls at the same time as
our VOIP phones at home in the UK as it's registered with the same number
at the same VOIP provider.
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a
full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
On 2026/10/17 12:15:25, Chris Green wrote:
[]
If there's more than one VOIP phone registered to a VOIP number then allIf I VoIP-call your number, presumably my VoIP packets are not sent to
of them will ring (or receive the call anyway). They don't have to be
connected via the same router or even be in the same country. I have a
VOIP phone on my boat in France which receives calls at the same time as
our VOIP phones at home in the UK as it's registered with the same number
at the same VOIP provider.
every VoIP 'phone in the country; so how does the network arrange that
they _are_ sent to both your 'phone(s) at home, and to your boat in France?
Presumably it's via some systen similar to normal internet use - if I'm accessing mail or a web server, the packets therefrom are routed only to
me (I've never actually given much thought to how _that_ works, but it
does). But in those cases, they're only going to one of me, in/at one location.
I found Voipfone did not necessarily ring on the mobile app (softphone)
but this is probably due to the configuration needing to keep it alive.
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32 +0100, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
The bastard - my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
End-fed long wires (e.g. 'inverted L' with an ATU) work quite well for receiving but they're not recommended for transmitting because the
end of the antenna is a high impedance point and feeding there results
in lots of RF in the shack. It is possible to mitigate this somewhat by
the use of a counterpoise and tuning against that rather than against
earth.
The centre point of a half-wave antenna, where current is greatest
and most radiation occurs, should ideally be as high as possible.
To achieve this, centre-fed 'inverted-V' antennas are popular.
On 17/10/2026 12:56, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 11:50:50 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
It was serious because I am puzzled. When I visited Droitwich I was
told the polarisation was vertical. Is MW different in this respect?
I dunno to be honest. I thought it was
I understood this (cordless) VOIP handset runs off the WiFi with
nothing connected to the 'FON' port on the router - or are you saying
the router may have DECT as well as WiFi built in?
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32 +0100, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS
NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line
The bastard - my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
Sn!pe <snipeco.2@gmail.com> wrote:
End-fed long wires (e.g. 'inverted L' with an ATU) work quite well for receiving but they're not recommended for transmitting because the
end of the antenna is a high impedance point and feeding there results
in lots of RF in the shack. It is possible to mitigate this somewhat by the use of a counterpoise and tuning against that rather than against earth.
I think that is misleading. Inverted-L antennas are popular on the 160m and 80m Amateur bands, obviously for transmitting and receiving, and there is
no reason why they cannot be used for MW reception.
An ATU is necessary for transmitting and highly recommended for receiving. Its function is to transform the low impedance (50 ohm) of the feeder to
the complex impedance of the antenna, and a properly designed system won't bring RF back into the shack.
As these antennas tend to electrically short, they need to work against a ground system, such as surface radials, but a good connection to Earth (ground rod, etc) is necessary to bleed off static.
The centre point of a half-wave antenna, where current is greatest
and most radiation occurs, should ideally be as high as possible.
To achieve this, centre-fed 'inverted-V' antennas are popular.
Inverted-V antennas tend to be used when resonant.
On 16/10/2026 19:34, Marco Moock wrote:
Am 16.10.26 um 13:03 schrieb The Natural Philosopher:The end points negotiate that. And most voip to voip does not involve
On 16/10/2026 10:49, Marco Moock wrote:
Am 16.10.26 um 11:05 schrieb Richmond:The ISP is not involved in inspeccting packets passing through it or
Does the sound quality of VOIP depend on the ISPs network and the
compression protocol it accepts? and also the recipients network.
Of course. There are different codecs and your ISP might convert
them if needed.
changing their protocols.
As many people use the VoIP service from their ISP, I used that term.
In case they use something else, that service will do the VoIP stuff.
How is such a service provider properly called?
The codecs in use are a function of the endpoints, which are other
VOIP phones
VOIP has NOTHING to do with the ISP at all. Unless they are running
their own SIP server and/or POTS gateway
They do that and most users use such a service. Direct VOIP calling is
possible, but no normal users uses that. There was an idea to use DNS
to get the remote's IP, but the telephone companies didn't like that.
Or shuffling packet queus based on whether there is a viOPp packet in
them
The recipient's device and used codec is also relevant, as the
lowest standard will define the speech quality.
That is ALL that is relevant, that and the bandwidth, packet loss
and latency between the devices
In case there is a mismatch, a conversion needs to be done. Depending
on how the telephone companies route the phone traffic, they might
need to change to a lower codec.
the SIP server
VOIPto other shit involves and expensive VOIP gateway.
On 18/10/2026 10:21, Scott wrote:
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32 +0100, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS >>>>>> NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial >>>>> be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line >>>>
The bastard - my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
This would be silly. To work well it would need to be so far above the >ground that it'd be ridiculously impractical.
Do what everyone else does and use the earth as one half and a wire as
the other half. Or use a vertical loop aerial with one side aimed at the >transmitter so the direction of the signal is in the plane of the loop.
On 16/10/2026 13:03, Scott wrote:
As it happens, it is a FRITZ!Box and Zen is my ISP. Does this mean I
can plug it into a LAN port (not FON) and will it work out of the box?
Does SIP phone require a power supply?
The Fritzbox should have enough power to drive a basic analogue phone
...Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial
be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 14:23:47 +0100, Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 18/10/2026 10:21, Scott wrote:
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32 +0100, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS >>>>>> NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial >>>>> be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line >>>>
The bastard - my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
This would be silly. To work well it would need to be so far above the >ground that it'd be ridiculously impractical.
Do what everyone else does and use the earth as one half and a wire as
the other half. Or use a vertical loop aerial with one side aimed at the >transmitter so the direction of the signal is in the plane of the loop.
It's academic now as I have no plans to create a similar installation.
I ran the cable from an attic window to a tree at the bottom of the
garden. Does this mean I should have installed an earth spike at the
far end? Too late now.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 14:23:47 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 18/10/2026 10:21, Scott wrote:
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32 +0100, "J. P. Gilliver"
<G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote:
On 2026/10/17 11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 17/10/2026 10:28, Scott wrote:With the feed point in the middle, not at one end.
On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
So mobile is like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS >> >>>>>> NOTHING like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >> >>>>>> full power VHF radio signal
True. Reception of 648 kHz is not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial >> >>>>> be half the wavelength: 232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-)
Seriously yes. Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line >> >>>>
The bastard - my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
This would be silly. To work well it would need to be so far above the
ground that it'd be ridiculously impractical.
Do what everyone else does and use the earth as one half and a wire as
the other half. Or use a vertical loop aerial with one side aimed at the
transmitter so the direction of the signal is in the plane of the loop.
It's academic now as I have no plans to create a similar installation.
I ran the cable from an attic window to a tree at the bottom of the
garden. Does this mean I should have installed an earth spike at the
far end? Too late now.
It depend on whether you were listening in the tree or the attic. The >receiver needs to be connected between the aerial and earth.
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 18:22:13 +0100, liz@poppyrecords.invalid.invalid
(Liz Tuddenham) wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 14:23:47 +0100, Brian Gregory
<void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> wrote:
On 18/10/2026 10:21, Scott wrote: > On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:43:32
+0100, "J. P. Gilliver" > <G6JPG@255soft.uk> wrote: > >> On 2026/10/17
11:50:50, The Natural Philosopher wrote: >>> On 17/10/2026 10:28,
Scott wrote: >>>> On Sat, 17 Oct 2026 08:47:20 +0100, The Natural
Philosopher >>>> <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote: >>> >>>>> So mobile is
like VOIP is a completely false statement, Qualitry IS >>>>> NOTHING
like VOIP. Its like comparing Radio Caroline on the MW with a >>>>>
full power VHF radio signal >>>> >>>> True. Reception of 648 kHz is
not great in Glasgow. Should the aerial >>>> be half the wavelength:
232 metres? Vertical or horizontal :-) >>> >>> Seriously yes.
Horizontally, strung between poles like a telephone line >>> >>> >>
With the feed point in the middle, not at one end. > > The bastard -
my dad never told me that when I was a teenager.
This would be silly. To work well it would need to be so far above the
ground that it'd be ridiculously impractical.
Do what everyone else does and use the earth as one half and a wire as
the other half. Or use a vertical loop aerial with one side aimed at
the transmitter so the direction of the signal is in the plane of the
loop.
It's academic now as I have no plans to create a similar installation.
I ran the cable from an attic window to a tree at the bottom of the
garden. Does this mean I should have installed an earth spike at the
far end? Too late now.
It depend on whether you were listening in the tree or the attic. The >receiver needs to be connected between the aerial and earth.
It's all coming back to me now. The radio had an earth point which my
dad told me to connect to the central heating. Was this right enough?
They do that and most users use such a service. Direct VOIP calling is possible, but no normal users uses that. There was an idea to use DNS to
get the remote's IP, but the telephone companies didn't like that.
Richmond <dnomhcir@gmx.com> wrote:
Brian Gregory <void-invalid-dead-dontuse@email.invalid> writes:If it's a VOIP phone then the router isn't involved at all except to the extent of sending and receiving the VOIP data packets.
However if you want to use a VoIP phone instead of an ISP provided ATA
you'll need to find out the required settings for the phone and also
how to disable the ATA in the router and configure it to pass the VoIP
through to your VoIP phone.
Presumably you could have a different number on the VOIP phone, and the
router should route calls to the appropriate port, phone port 1 or 2, or
the Ethernet port.
Or if all phones had the same number, then the router would routeSee above, the router isn't involved. This is one of the difficulties
traffic to the one which made the call.
when using VOIP phones via a typical home router that does NAT. There
isn't a simple way for the packets of data coming 'back' to find the VOIP handset. The A&A website has a better explanation of this problem than I will ever manage, and A&A dislike NAT for this very reason.
What would happen for incoming calls? Would all the phones rings?
If there's more than one VOIP phone registered to a VOIP number then all
of them will ring (or receive the call anyway). They don't have to be connected via the same router or even be in the same country. I have a
VOIP phone on my boat in France which receives calls at the same time as
our VOIP phones at home in the UK as it's registered with the same number
at the same VOIP provider.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 56:54:51 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,828 |