I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamically
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as
though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps.
R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
On 02/10/2026 10:20, Scott wrote:
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamically
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main
service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as
though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps.
R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
If he wants to cut costs, then a lot of the on-line only stuff can go.
It is, after all the British *Broadcasting* corporation, not the British
Web Content Maker. Leave iPlayer running, though, as that is handy for catching up on the stuff they have broadcast. It saves buying a video recorder.
Although _I_ agree with you, we are both of an older generation that
listen to what is broadcast; regardless of the name, which is
historical, to keep up with the audience (not just "down with the kids",
but a fair proportion of young adults), they have to do the online stuff
- if we believe what we're told, a lot of the "audience" don't listen to
or watch much live at all.
On 02/10/2026 16:03, J. P. Gilliver wrote:
Although _I_ agree with you, we are both of an older generation thatWhat I was suggesting is dropping the online only content, only keeping
listen to what is broadcast; regardless of the name, which is
historical, to keep up with the audience (not just "down with the kids",
but a fair proportion of young adults), they have to do the online stuff
- if we believe what we're told, a lot of the "audience" don't listen to
or watch much live at all.
the stuff that actually gets transmitted available on line.
Timeshifting costs very little, no matter which end of the link it
happens. What costs money is creating content, not distributing it.
They could also save money by bringing a lot of production back "in
house", as the current system has to pay for all the backroom staff at dozens of creators instead of one department split between all the
programme creators.
However, the new Boss seems determined to close down all the
transmitters as soon as he can get away with it, transferring that part
of the cost from the BBC to the consumer, as we will all need a decent broadband speed to watch. In my case, as I can not get a landline connection, that will have to be Starlink. My current system is far too
slow to stream HD (Or even SD) video.
On 02/10/2026 10:20, Scott wrote:
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamicallyIf he wants to cut costs, then a lot of the on-line only stuff can go.
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main
service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as
though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps.
R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
It is, after all the British *Broadcasting* corporation, not the British
Web Content Maker. Leave iPlayer running, though, as that is handy for catching up on the stuff they have broadcast. It saves buying a video recorder.
On 2 Oct 2026 at 14:39:00 BST, "John Williamson" ><johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
On 02/10/2026 10:20, Scott wrote:
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamicallyIf he wants to cut costs, then a lot of the on-line only stuff can go.
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main
service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as
though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps.
R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
It is, after all the British *Broadcasting* corporation, not the British
Web Content Maker. Leave iPlayer running, though, as that is handy for
catching up on the stuff they have broadcast. It saves buying a video
recorder.
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live >TV.
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live >>TV.
Could they not compromise and make it free in real time and charge for
back catalogue? This would closely resemble the original concept of
the radio/TV licence. I have always thought R4 Extra could be
chargeable as there is no entitlement to watch 1960s comedy.
On Sat, 3 Oct 2026 06:29:34 -0000 (UTC), Old John
<watcombeman@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
On 2 Oct 2026 at 14:39:00 BST, "John Williamson"
<johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
On 02/10/2026 10:20, Scott wrote:
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamicallyIf he wants to cut costs, then a lot of the on-line only stuff can go.
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main
service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as
though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps.
R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
It is, after all the British *Broadcasting* corporation, not the British >>> Web Content Maker. Leave iPlayer running, though, as that is handy for
catching up on the stuff they have broadcast. It saves buying a video
recorder.
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live
TV.
Could they not compromise and make it free in real time and charge for
back catalogue? This would closely resemble the original concept of
the radio/TV licence. I have always thought R4 Extra could be
chargeable as there is no entitlement to watch 1960s comedy.
On 03/10/2026 09:29, Scott wrote:
On Sat, 3 Oct 2026 06:29:34 -0000 (UTC), Old John
<watcombeman@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
On 2 Oct 2026 at 14:39:00 BST, "John Williamson"
<johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
On 02/10/2026 10:20, Scott wrote:
The BBC seems to have stopped adjusting the DAB bitrate dynamicallyIf he wants to cut costs, then a lot of the on-line only stuff can go. >>>> It is, after all the British *Broadcasting* corporation, not the British >>>> Web Content Maker. Leave iPlayer running, though, as that is handy for >>>> catching up on the stuff they have broadcast. It saves buying a video
depending on programming. It used to be that R3 (or) R4, and R5 (main >>>>> service) had bitrates adjusted when R5L was on air. Now it looks as >>>>> though they remain static as R3 160 kbps, R4 112 kbps and R5 64 kbps. >>>>> R5L seems to be wasting 64 kbps playing a silly loop while it is
off-air. Why has the BBC done this?
I see the new DG is talking about reducing the number of services.
Will this improve DAB quality or will the BBC vacate the 'spare'
capacity as a cost-cutting measure?
recorder.
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live
TV.
Could they not compromise and make it free in real time and charge for
back catalogue? This would closely resemble the original concept of
the radio/TV licence. I have always thought R4 Extra could be
chargeable as there is no entitlement to watch 1960s comedy.
you "watch" Radio 4 ?
On Sat, 03 Oct 2026 09:29:25 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live
TV.
Could they not compromise and make it free in real time and charge for
back catalogue? This would closely resemble the original concept of
the radio/TV licence. I have always thought R4 Extra could be
chargeable as there is no entitlement to watch 1960s comedy.
They could make the whole thing subscription based, like other online >services, or maybe individual programmes available for rent or
purchase like some of the movies on Amazon. I don't care what they do
as long as they stop sending me threatening and legally misleading
letters and let me make my own choices about what I want to pay for.
They won't want to of course. Who would want to stop a five billion a
year gravy train? And the government won't want to stop it either,
because they still think that by keeping control of broadcasting they
can control what the public is told, even though an increasing number
of people now get their knowledge of the world from a variety of other >sources. I wonder how long they can keep it going?
On Sun, 04 Oct 26 07:45:04 UTC, Charles Hope <clh@candehope.me.uk>
wrote:
you "watch" Radio 4 ?
Of course, we all sit around the fireplace to watch the radio play
'Round the Horne' :-)
On 06/10/2026 18:03, Scott wrote:
Charles Hope <clh@candehope.me.uk> wrote:
you "watch" Radio 4 ?
Of course, we all sit around the fireplace to watch the radio play
'Round the Horne' :-)
Don't knock it, the pictures are a lot better on the radio. :-)
On Sun, 04 Oct 2026 08:37:22 +0100, Roderick Stewart ><rjfs@escapetime.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Sat, 03 Oct 2026 09:29:25 +0100, ScottOn your second paragraph, if it's to do with thought processes, surely
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I would be deeply distressed if iPlayer went. I tend to use it more than live
TV.
Could they not compromise and make it free in real time and charge for >>>back catalogue? This would closely resemble the original concept of
the radio/TV licence. I have always thought R4 Extra could be
chargeable as there is no entitlement to watch 1960s comedy.
They could make the whole thing subscription based, like other online >>services, or maybe individual programmes available for rent or
purchase like some of the movies on Amazon. I don't care what they do
as long as they stop sending me threatening and legally misleading
letters and let me make my own choices about what I want to pay for.
They won't want to of course. Who would want to stop a five billion a
year gravy train? And the government won't want to stop it either,
because they still think that by keeping control of broadcasting they
can control what the public is told, even though an increasing number
of people now get their knowledge of the world from a variety of other >>sources. I wonder how long they can keep it going?
the government would be even happier to fund the BBC out of general
taxation (as in Denmark and other countries) then if they are unhappy
with the output they would not need to wait for the next licence
renewal round to make their disapproval known :-)
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 18:06:24 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On your second paragraph, if it's to do with thought processes, surely
the government would be even happier to fund the BBC out of general
taxation (as in Denmark and other countries) then if they are unhappy
with the output they would not need to wait for the next licence
renewal round to make their disapproval known :-)
The government probably would like to pay for it out of taxes, because
it would mean they retain some control of it. However, if it's really supposed to be a public service, it should be the public that is in
control of it, by controlling whether we want to pay for it or not.
On 07/10/2026 10:47, Roderick Stewart wrote:
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 18:06:24 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
You mean make it a subscription or pay per view service?On your second paragraph, if it's to do with thought processes, surely
the government would be even happier to fund the BBC out of general
taxation (as in Denmark and other countries) then if they are unhappy
with the output they would not need to wait for the next licence
renewal round to make their disapproval known :-)
The government probably would like to pay for it out of taxes, because
it would mean they retain some control of it. However, if it's really
supposed to be a public service, it should be the public that is in
control of it, by controlling whether we want to pay for it or not.
The government probably would like to pay for it out of taxes,
because it would mean they retain some control of it. However, if
it's really supposed to be a public service, it should be the
public that is in control of it, by controlling whether we want to
pay for it or not.
On Wed, 7 Oct 2026 11:03:45 +0100, John Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
On 07/10/2026 10:47, Roderick Stewart wrote:
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 18:06:24 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
You mean make it a subscription or pay per view service?On your second paragraph, if it's to do with thought processes, surely >>> the government would be even happier to fund the BBC out of general
taxation (as in Denmark and other countries) then if they are unhappy
with the output they would not need to wait for the next licence
renewal round to make their disapproval known :-)
The government probably would like to pay for it out of taxes, because
it would mean they retain some control of it. However, if it's really
supposed to be a public service, it should be the public that is in
control of it, by controlling whether we want to pay for it or not.
It already works for the other broadcasters, so why not?
And they don't send me threatening letters if I'm not interested.
Not only threatening but misleading. They say things like "Buy a
licence now to avoid a fine", and the most recent one tells me to get "correctly licenced", even though I already am; I haven't got a
licence because I don't do anything that requires one, which seems
perfectly correct to me. But still they send the threats. I know
enough not to worry but I've heard that some people are so
intimidated by this nonsense that they buy TV licences anyway, even
though they don't need to, just to stop the threats. Whatever else
changes, this has got to stop.
It already works for the other broadcasters, so why not?
On 07/10/2026 16:06, Roderick Stewart wrote:
It already works for the other broadcasters, so why not?
And just look what you end up on the channels dependent on adverts or >subscriptions.
And even worse with radio.
On 07/10/2026 16:06, Roderick Stewart wrote:
It already works for the other broadcasters, so why not?
And just look what you end up on the channels dependent on adverts
or subscriptions.
And even worse with radio.
What's so terrible about adverts anyway?
On Wed, 7 Oct 2026 23:36:03 +0100, JMB99 <mb@nospam.net> wrote:
On 07/10/2026 16:06, Roderick Stewart wrote:
It already works for the other broadcasters, so why not?
And just look what you end up on the channels dependent on adverts or
subscriptions.
And even worse with radio.
I end up with a system where I can *choose* what I think is worth
paying for, and don't have to pay for what I don't want, without
being threatened with fines or prison if my choice doesn't include
what somebody else thinks I should have.
What's so terrible about adverts anyway? ITV, for example, has been
supported in this way since 1955 and seems to have survived quite
well. It now has many years worth of stored material that anyone with
an internet connection can watch totally free with adverts, or for a
small subscription without them.
The USP of the BBC is that despite the complaints here, most of the
world is of the opinion that their news is the most balanced in
the World,
It is also free to make experimental programmes and programmes for[...]
special interest groups that subscription stations could not afford to
take the risk of making.
In article <nipsu2Fnm15U1@mid.individual.net>,
John Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
The USP of the BBC is that despite the complaints here, most of the
world is of the opinion that their news is the most balanced in
the World,
If you tried some on-line news services you would learn just how much
the BBC bends and hides the news. However, if you don't regularly
look elsewhere you will be unaware and think they're honest. Main
stream news is captured by activists and is corrupt.
On Thu, 8 Oct 2026 16:58:59 +0100, John Williamson ><johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
[...]
It is also free to make experimental programmes and programmes for[...]
special interest groups that subscription stations could not afford to >>take the risk of making.
That's fine as long as they're paid for by those who want them. If
other people want the luxury of having their special interrests
catered for at no extra personal cost, then I don't see why I should
be forced to pay for them. I'm sure everybody wants what they want at
no extra cost to them, but unfortunately that's not reality.
In any case, human nature being what it is, the extra money resulting
from a single broadcaster being given lots of it and the freedom to do >whatever they like with it probably doesn't always result in better
and more balanced programmes.
I think the argument is that mainstream interests will be catered for
by the commercial sector and that the role of a public service
broadcaster is to fill the gaps (ie special interests).
On Fri, 09 Oct 2026 15:31:50 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I think the argument is that mainstream interests will be catered for
by the commercial sector and that the role of a public service
broadcaster is to fill the gaps (ie special interests).
As long as I don't have to pay for other people's special interests, I
don't care.
On Thu, 8 Oct 2026 16:58:59 +0100, John Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
[...]
It is also free to make experimental programmes and programmes for[...]
special interest groups that subscription stations could not afford to
take the risk of making.
That's fine as long as they're paid for by those who want them. If
other people want the luxury of having their special interrests
catered for at no extra personal cost, then I don't see why I should
be forced to pay for them. I'm sure everybody wants what they want at
no extra cost to them, but unfortunately that's not reality.
In any case, human nature being what it is, the extra money resulting
from a single broadcaster being given lots of it and the freedom to do whatever they like with it probably doesn't always result in better
and more balanced programmes.
Rod
On Fri, 09 Oct 2026 15:40:12 +0100, Roderick Stewart ><rjfs@escapetime.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Fri, 09 Oct 2026 15:31:50 +0100, Scott
<newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I think the argument is that mainstream interests will be catered for
by the commercial sector and that the role of a public service >>>broadcaster is to fill the gaps (ie special interests).
As long as I don't have to pay for other people's special interests, I >>don't care.
What is a special interest anyway? Is there one list of universal
interests and one list of special interests?
some things that would be considered "special interests"
actually turn out to be of widespread interest/enjoyment. Who would have thought ballroom dancing, for example?
J. P. Gilliver wrote:
some things that would be considered "special interests"
actually turn out to be of widespread interest/enjoyment. Who would have
thought ballroom dancing, for example?
Several decades before "Strictly Come Dancing" the BBC produced "Come Dancing" without the pro-celeb contestants, I seem to remember it being popular in the 70s ...
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:41:11 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,687 |