• Re: ICC made current relay catching rule more complicated for Umpires

    From Daniel70@daniel47@nomail.afraid.org to uk.sport.cricket on Fri Oct 9 21:04:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.sport.cricket

    On 22/06/2025 2:49 pm, David North wrote:
    On 20/06/2025 09:40, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    On 6/20/2025 12:15 AM, David North wrote:

    <Snip>


    Once the fielder outside the boundary relays the catch to a fielder
    inside the boundary, it SHOULDN'T MATTER that the fielder landed
    outside the boundary because he DIDN'T take the catch.

    But he has fielded the ball after jumping from outside the boundary, so
    I go back to my original question about whether there is any good reason
    why he should be allowed to do that. He could be several metres outside
    the boundary at that stage. The change at least means that he would have
    to be close to the boundary and about to move back within it.

    This is similar to the law change where a batter running or diving
    towards their ground and beyond, and having made their ground, is no
    longer considered to be out of their ground if they are subsequently off
    the ground.

    If a Ball hits the fence (which is outside the field of play) on the
    full, can a player, in the air, then flick the ball (before it hits the ground) back to a team mate (who is still with-in the field of play) to
    effect the catch??

    I mean neither the ball nor anyone who touches the Ball is also in
    contact with the ground .... except the Player who takes the "catch"!!
    --
    Daniel70
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From David North@nospam@lane-farm.fsnet.co.uk to uk.sport.cricket on Sat Oct 10 04:56:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.sport.cricket

    On 09/10/2026 11:04, Daniel70 wrote:
    On 22/06/2025 2:49 pm, David North wrote:
    On 20/06/2025 09:40, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    On 6/20/2025 12:15 AM, David North wrote:

    <Snip>


    Once the fielder outside the boundary relays the catch to a fielder
    inside the boundary, it SHOULDN'T MATTER that the fielder landed
    outside the boundary because he DIDN'T take the catch.

    But he has fielded the ball after jumping from outside the boundary,
    so I go back to my original question about whether there is any good
    reason why he should be allowed to do that. He could be several metres
    outside the boundary at that stage. The change at least means that he
    would have to be close to the boundary and about to move back within it.

    This is similar to the law change where a batter running or diving
    towards their ground and beyond, and having made their ground, is no
    longer considered to be out of their ground if they are subsequently
    off the ground.

    If a Ball hits the fence (which is outside the field of play) on the
    full, can a player, in the air, then flick the ball (before it hits the ground) back to a team mate (who is still with-in the field of play) to effect the catch??

    I mean neither the ball nor anyone who touches the Ball is also in
    contact with the ground .... except the Player who takes the "catch"!!

    No.

    "19.4.1 The ball in play is grounded beyond the boundary if it touches

    - the boundary or any part of an object used to mark the boundary
    - the ground beyond the boundary
    - any object that is grounded beyond the boundary."

    https://lawsofcricket.lords.org/laws-of-cricket/the-over-scoring-runs-dead-ball-and-extras/boundaries
    --
    David North
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Daniel70@daniel47@nomail.afraid.org to uk.sport.cricket on Sat Oct 10 21:50:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.sport.cricket

    On 10/10/2026 2:56 pm, David North wrote:
    On 09/10/2026 11:04, Daniel70 wrote:
    On 22/06/2025 2:49 pm, David North wrote:
    On 20/06/2025 09:40, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    On 6/20/2025 12:15 AM, David North wrote:

    <Snip>


    Once the fielder outside the boundary relays the catch to a fielder
    inside the boundary, it SHOULDN'T MATTER that the fielder landed
    outside the boundary because he DIDN'T take the catch.

    But he has fielded the ball after jumping from outside the boundary,
    so I go back to my original question about whether there is any good
    reason why he should be allowed to do that. He could be several
    metres outside the boundary at that stage. The change at least means
    that he would have to be close to the boundary and about to move back
    within it.

    This is similar to the law change where a batter running or diving
    towards their ground and beyond, and having made their ground, is no
    longer considered to be out of their ground if they are subsequently
    off the ground.

    If a Ball hits the fence (which is outside the field of play) on the
    full, can a player, in the air, then flick the ball (before it hits
    the ground) back to a team mate (who is still with-in the field of
    play) to effect the catch??

    I mean neither the ball nor anyone who touches the Ball is also in
    contact with the ground .... except the Player who takes the "catch"!!

    No.

    "19.4.1 The ball in play is grounded beyond the boundary if it touches

    - the boundary or any part of an object used to mark the boundary
    - the ground beyond the boundary
    - any object that is grounded beyond the boundary."

    https://lawsofcricket.lords.org/laws-of-cricket/the-over-scoring-runs-dead-ball-and-extras/boundaries


    Thank you. I thought it would have been to weird .... but you never
    know!! ;-)
    --
    Daniel70
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2