• Proclamation of the Jehobozo Witless Witchtower Society on Babies Abstaining From Blood

    From NightBulb@nospam-1975576487@nightbulb.net to uk.religion.christian on Sat Nov 7 21:31:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    == Proclamation of the Jehobozo Witless Witchtower Society
    == on Cannibal Babies Abstaining From Blood


    The bible teaches to abstain from blood. Eight-one years ago
    we proclaimed a directive prohibiting the faithful from blood
    tranfusions to comport to this Bible law.

    Since a fetus imbibes nutrients from the mother's bloodstream, we
    declare all babies sinful cannibals. This is proof that babies are born
    in original sin.

    We hereby outlaw pregnancy since a baby steals nutrients from the
    mother's bloodstream. This type of blood transfusion violates the
    earlier directive to abstain from blood. Babies are just as subject to
    the Witchtower laws as adults.

    Since the bible prohibits partaking of blood and commands to abstain
    from blood we prohibit pregnancy of any kind. Pregnancy allows the
    fetus to sin in violation of the command to abstain from blood.

    Preganant baby feeders are to be shunned to show them the gravity of
    their sin. Unborn blood-nourished babies must be shunned along with
    them to prevent their sin from spreading among the faithful.
    --
    NightBulb | https://blog.nightbulb.net | Flip the night switch.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 8 07:18:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 07/11/2026 21:31, NightBulb wrote:

    == Proclamation of the Jehobozo Witless Witchtower Society
    == on Cannibal Babies Abstaining From Blood
    I presume that this is a somewhat heavy-handed attempt at sarcasm. I
    allowed it because JWs deserve to have their stupidity highlighted.

    The individual JW is a sincere and dedicated individual, though usually
    not the brightest bulb on the Christmas tree and severely lacking in the ability to think independently or rationally. My detestation is
    primarily directed at the Watchtower organisation which exploits its
    members with teachings that it must know are false and evidence that it equally knows is false.

    I first realised this many years ago when a JW, attempting to prove
    something, quoted from a three-volume handbook produced by the
    Watchtower, a sort of JW encyclopaedia. It quoted Edwin Thiele in
    support of a particular point, the very opposite of what Thiele actually taught. I got my copy of his book down from my shelves, located the
    alleged quote, and found that they had quoted the first half of a
    sentence in which he outlined a position which he refuted in the second
    half of his sentence.

    That was not an oversight or accident. That was a deliberate twisting of
    the author and was dishonest, relying on the fact that very few people
    have read or understood Thiele.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 12:13:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 08/11/2026 07:18, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 07/11/2026 21:31, NightBulb wrote:

    == Proclamation of the Jehobozo Witless Witchtower Society
    == on Cannibal Babies Abstaining From Blood
    I presume that this is a somewhat heavy-handed attempt at sarcasm. I
    allowed it because JWs deserve to have their stupidity highlighted.

    The individual JW is a sincere and dedicated individual, though usually
    not the brightest bulb on the Christmas tree and severely lacking in the ability to think independently or rationally. My detestation is
    primarily directed at the Watchtower organisation which exploits its
    members with teachings that it must know are false and evidence that it equally knows is false.

    I'm not sure they do. They have an ideal and because they believe them
    to be Christ's representative on earth they don't look (or ignore) the evidence against.

    However, as far as the adherents go, they have been brainwashed, which I
    think is a powerful thing.

    I could level the same accusation at followers of the SDA, or in my case Charismatic Christianity. I never believed I could have been brainwashed
    but that is certainly one of my thought trains.


    I first realised this many years ago when a JW, attempting to prove something, quoted from a three-volume handbook produced by the
    Watchtower, a sort of JW encyclopaedia. It quoted Edwin Thiele in
    support of a particular point, the very opposite of what Thiele actually taught. I got my copy of his book down from my shelves, located the
    alleged quote, and found that they had quoted the first half of a
    sentence in which he outlined a position which he refuted in the second
    half of his sentence.

    That was not an oversight or accident. That was a deliberate twisting of
    the author and was dishonest, relying on the fact that very few people
    have read or understood Thiele.
    I think that happens in all sects. Jeff was a master at only accepting
    half a scripture which aligned to his deep rooted beliefs. The same
    happens in politics. You have those on the right and those on the left believing entirely opposite beliefs.

    For example, I am much against MAGA and Donald Trump. It is obvious to
    me (and no doubt yourself) that is policies are unhinged, but to those
    in MAGA he's the best thing since sliced bread.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Timreason@timreason@hotmail.co.uk to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 14:50:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 12:13, John wrote:


    They have an ideal and because they believe them
    to be Christ's representative on earth they don't look (or ignore) the evidence against.

    However, as far as the adherents go, they have been brainwashed, which I think is a powerful thing.

    I could level the same accusation at followers of the SDA, or in my case Charismatic Christianity. I never believed I could have been brainwashed
    but that is certainly one of my thought trains.

    When I was younger it was similar for me, that I believed in my local
    Baptist church and their teachings for about three years. But then the
    cracks began to show.

    The trouble is, it is all too easy to fall in totally with an ideology,
    be it either political or theological.

    People are taught that any questioning of 'authority' is a weakening of
    faith or commitment to the cause. I often heard "Lean not on your own understanding" being quoted, for example. Proverbs 3:5-6 "Trust in the
    LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding."

    What I heard in the Baptist church, and what I saw in the 'University of
    Life' (that is, real experience of real scenarios in real life) did not
    match up. But there was a culture of never questioning teachings, in
    that church.

    I therefore returned to Anglicanism, but moved away from evangelicalism towards Catholicism within Anglican tradition. I could never accept
    Roman Catholicism, for the same reasons that I couldn't accept Baptist teaching in full (there are things I agree with, such as adult baptism
    by immersion). The Roman Catholic Church believes it can lay down the
    law and insists it cannot be questioned.

    My own view is that God gave us brains and we are expected to use them.
    I will never accept the teachings of any preacher blindly, nor assume
    any interpretation of scripture is beyond question.

    I believe in God and I believe God is Love, and we are called to love
    God and love our neighbour. There it is in a nut shell.

    Tim.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 19:39:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 12:13, John wrote:

    I'm not sure they do. They have an ideal and because they believe them
    to be Christ's representative on earth they don't look (or ignore) the evidence against.

    The illustration I give towards the end of my post shows why I believe
    the organisation is dishonest.

    However, as far as the adherents go, they have been brainwashed, which I think is a powerful thing.

    Yes. It's denied recently, but for many years JWs were forbidden to read anything except literature produced by the WatchTower, which is not only
    evil in the people making the ban but incredibly stupid in those obeying it.

    I could level the same accusation at followers of the SDA, or in my case Charismatic Christianity. I never believed I could have been brainwashed
    but that is certainly one of my thought trains.

    I can't speak for your experience, but an SDA service is in two parts,
    the first is loosely based on the old Methodist "class" system. It is a Bible-based discussion in which anything goes. I'm sure there are some
    classes where the official line is promulgated exclusively, but in the majority the official line is often questioned and even rejected if
    people feel that the author of the "lesson" is wrong.

    I think that happens in all sects.-a Jeff was a master at only accepting half a scripture which aligned to his deep rooted beliefs. The same
    happens in politics.-a You have those on the right and those on the left believing entirely opposite beliefs.

    Indeed, which raises an interesting point. Are only certain personality
    types attracted to a group such as the JWs? I strongly suspect that they
    are inadequate people who deep-down want to be told what to do and think
    and believe. They would be threatened by the thought of having to think
    for themselves.

    For example, I am much against MAGA and Donald Trump.-a It is obvious to
    me (and no doubt yourself) that is policies are unhinged, but to those
    in MAGA he's the best thing since sliced bread.
    Trump's policies are based on profound ignorance, deep rooted populism,
    and utter selfishness. If it's good for Trump it must be approved and
    enacted.

    Bah.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 19:42:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 14:50, Timreason wrote:

    People are taught that any questioning of 'authority' is a weakening of faith or commitment to the cause. I often heard "Lean not on your own understanding" being quoted, for example. Proverbs 3:5-6 "Trust in the
    LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding."

    It's a good Bible verse - but the understanding you should seek is
    divine wisdom, not church dogma. Authority - and especially church
    authority - *should* be questioned, regularly.

    My own view is that God gave us brains and we are expected to use them.
    I will never accept the teachings of any preacher blindly, nor assume
    any interpretation of scripture is beyond question.
    Absolutely. That doesn't mean that you reject things just because
    someone else teaches them, but you question everything and look for
    evidence, using your God-given brain.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 20:45:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 14:50, Timreason wrote:
    On 09/11/2026 12:13, John wrote:

    What I heard in the Baptist church, and what I saw in the 'University of Life' (that is, real experience of real scenarios in real life) did not match up. But there was a culture of never questioning teachings, in
    that church.

    I remember when I first joined this newsgroup, around 2000, and coming
    across many different viewpoints to my own. I mentioned it to my house
    group leader and he said, be careful, it will lead you away from proper Christianity. That jarred with me at the time, and albeit for other
    reasons, I left the church not long after.


    I therefore returned to Anglicanism, but moved away from evangelicalism towards Catholicism within Anglican tradition. I could never accept
    Roman Catholicism, for the same reasons that I couldn't accept Baptist teaching in full (there are things I agree with, such as adult baptism
    by immersion). The Roman Catholic Church believes it can lay down the
    law and insists it cannot be questioned.

    My own view is that God gave us brains and we are expected to use them.
    I will never accept the teachings of any preacher blindly, nor assume
    any interpretation of scripture is beyond question.

    I believe in God and I believe God is Love, and we are called to love
    God and love our neighbour. There it is in a nut shell.
    Thanks Tim.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 9 21:19:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 19:39, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 09/11/2026 12:13, John wrote:

    Yes. It's denied recently, but for many years JWs were forbidden to read anything except literature produced by the WatchTower, which is not only evil in the people making the ban but incredibly stupid in those obeying
    it.
    As I said, they are brainwashed. I wouldn't say it's incredibly stupid
    they think that way, as it's a powerful force.

    I have to admit there was a time I considered joining them, and had it
    not been for my Christian beliefs at the time, I may well have done so.
    The ones I met were lovely and practised their beliefs far better than
    some Christians tend to. It doesn't make them right of course.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 06:09:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 20:45, John wrote:

    I remember when I first joined this newsgroup, around 2000, and coming across many different viewpoints to my own.-a I mentioned it to my house group leader and he said, be careful, it will lead you away from proper Christianity. That jarred with me at the time, and albeit for other
    reasons, I left the church not long after.
    One should know what the Bible teaches. Encountering different
    viewpoints is a strength - it either confirms your understanding of the
    Bible or modifies it. Locking oneself away in a doctrinal box is not
    healthy.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 06:11:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 09/11/2026 21:19, John wrote:

    As I said, they are brainwashed. I wouldn't say it's incredibly stupid
    they think that way, as it's a powerful force.

    It is stupid to allow oneself to be brainwashed. Being told that you
    mustn't read anything except WatchTower literature should be a definite
    red flag.

    I have to admit there was a time I considered joining them, and had it
    not been for my Christian beliefs at the time, I may well have done so.
    The ones I met were lovely and practised their beliefs far better than
    some Christians tend to. It doesn't make them right of course.

    Yes, I have a lot of time for individual JWs - no time at all for their beliefs. I respect their dedication and zeal but wish it was in a better cause.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 11:53:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 06:09, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 09/11/2026 20:45, John wrote:

    I remember when I first joined this newsgroup, around 2000, and coming
    across many different viewpoints to my own.-a I mentioned it to my
    house group leader and he said, be careful, it will lead you away from
    proper Christianity. That jarred with me at the time, and albeit for
    other reasons, I left the church not long after.

    One should know what the Bible teaches. Encountering different
    viewpoints is a strength - it either confirms your understanding of the Bible or modifies it. Locking oneself away in a doctrinal box is not healthy.
    I do agree, but each sector of Christianity will argue that their understanding of the bible is correct, and the sector you belong to will
    shape your understanding, and it's very hard to shake that off.
    Although you are ex-SDA, you still follow their teachings and attend SDA churches. Mainstream Christianity would claim some of those teachings
    are wrong.

    Mike Davis is* a Catholic, later becoming charismatic in his beliefs.
    There is much wrong in Catholic teaching but he still clung onto
    Catholicism, defending it to some extent, claiming that's where God
    wanted him to be.

    I think I was luckier than most charismatics, as I did read the bible
    (well the New Testament certainly) and it helped me spot the flaws in
    some off beam teaching at the time. As time went on I realised the
    bible was simply a book written by men with a flawed understanding of
    God, and contains contradictions. Most Christians will gloss over that,
    and make excuses, as you've done so in debates with me in the past.

    * Anyone know if he's still around? He left the group after
    experiencing internet issues, but we never heard from him again. I liked
    Mike, and had the pleasure of meeting him once.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 11:57:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 06:11, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 09/11/2026 21:19, John wrote:

    As I said, they are brainwashed. I wouldn't say it's incredibly stupid
    they think that way, as it's a powerful force.

    It is stupid to allow oneself to be brainwashed. Being told that you
    mustn't read anything except WatchTower literature should be a definite
    red flag.

    I used to think the same, until I realised I had been brainwashed
    myself, and I would like to consider myself fairly intelligent. It
    didn't help that I had a supernatural experience at the start of my
    Christian journey, which is why I said it's a powerful force.

    I have to admit there was a time I considered joining them, and had it
    not been for my Christian beliefs at the time, I may well have done
    so. The ones I met were lovely and practised their beliefs far better
    than some Christians tend to. It doesn't make them right of course.

    Yes, I have a lot of time for individual JWs - no time at all for their beliefs. I respect their dedication and zeal but wish it was in a better cause.
    I agree.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 19:28:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 11:53, John wrote:

    I do agree, but each sector of Christianity will argue that their understanding of the bible is correct, and the sector you belong to will shape your understanding, and it's very hard to shake that off. Although
    you are ex-SDA, you still follow their teachings and attend SDA
    churches. Mainstream Christianity would claim some of those teachings
    are wrong.

    Most of their teachings. And yes, I would expect each denomination to
    defend its beliefs. No one is going to say "We know we are wrong but
    we're sticking with it anyway."

    Mike Davis is* a Catholic, later becoming charismatic in his beliefs.
    There is much wrong in Catholic teaching but he still clung onto Catholicism, defending it to some extent, claiming that's where God
    wanted him to be.

    Yes. I respect him for his stance, even though I think it was the wrong one.

    I think I was luckier than most charismatics, as I did read the bible
    (well the New Testament certainly) and it helped me spot the flaws in
    some off beam teaching at the time.-a As time went on I realised the
    bible was simply a book written by men with a flawed understanding of
    God, and contains contradictions.-a Most Christians will gloss over that, and make excuses, as you've done so in debates with me in the past.

    You mean, I have had the temerity to explain that what you thought was a contradiction was not any such thing in fact? Shocking!

    * Anyone know if he's still around?-a He left the group after
    experiencing internet issues, but we never heard from him again. I liked Mike, and had the pleasure of meeting him once.

    He wrote to me privately once, just to say that he has personal problems
    grieving for his wife, I think. I encouraged him to come back, but so
    far he has chosen not to.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 19:31:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 11:57, John wrote:

    I used to think the same, until I realised I had been brainwashed
    myself, and I would like to consider myself fairly intelligent.

    I am glad that you recognised the problem, though your solution smacks
    very much of disposing of infants together with their sanitising liquid.

    It
    didn't help that I had a supernatural experience at the start of my Christian journey, which is why I said it's a powerful force.

    Why that should stop you continuing as a Christian is beyond me.
    Certainly I approve of you leaving the group where you felt you were
    being brain-washed, but there are other denominations where you can
    worship without that problem.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 23:34:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 19:28, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 10/11/2026 11:53, John wrote:


    I think I was luckier than most charismatics, as I did read the bible
    (well the New Testament certainly) and it helped me spot the flaws in
    some off beam teaching at the time.-a As time went on I realised the
    bible was simply a book written by men with a flawed understanding of
    God, and contains contradictions.-a Most Christians will gloss over
    that, and make excuses, as you've done so in debates with me in the past.

    You mean, I have had the temerity to explain that what you thought was a contradiction was not any such thing in fact? Shocking!

    What, like when Mary and Joseph went to Egypt for 2 years in one gospel
    but returned to Jerusalem then Galilee in another?

    * Anyone know if he's still around?-a He left the group after
    experiencing internet issues, but we never heard from him again. I
    liked Mike, and had the pleasure of meeting him once.

    He wrote to me privately once, just to say that he has personal problems
    -agrieving for his wife, I think. I encouraged him to come back, but so
    far he has chosen not to.
    Thanks for the info. I hope he is keeping well.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Nov 10 23:40:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 19:31, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 10/11/2026 11:57, John wrote:

    I used to think the same, until I realised I had been brainwashed
    myself, and I would like to consider myself fairly intelligent.

    I am glad that you recognised the problem, though your solution smacks
    very much of disposing of infants together with their sanitising liquid.

    It didn't help that I had a supernatural experience at the start of my
    Christian journey, which is why I said it's a powerful force.

    Why that should stop you continuing as a Christian is beyond me.

    It didn't. It was many years later when I realised I had been brainwashed.

    Certainly I approve of you leaving the group where you felt you were
    being brain-washed, but there are other denominations where you can
    worship without that problem.
    There were other reasons I left Christianity. I've discussed them here previously.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Nov 11 07:04:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 10/11/2026 23:34, John wrote:

    What, like when Mary and Joseph went to Egypt for 2 years in one gospel
    but returned to Jerusalem then Galilee in another?

    How is that a contradiction? It is merely an abbreviation. Now if Luke
    had said "And they didn't go to Egypt" *that* would be a contradiction.

    Thanks for the info. I hope he is keeping well.

    I hope so too. He was/is a good man and the loss of his wife was a
    terrible wrench.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Nov 11 22:23:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 11/11/2026 07:04, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 10/11/2026 23:34, John wrote:

    What, like when Mary and Joseph went to Egypt for 2 years in one
    gospel but returned to Jerusalem then Galilee in another?

    How is that a contradiction? It is merely an abbreviation. Now if Luke
    had said "And they didn't go to Egypt" *that* would be a contradiction.
    In Matthew Jesus was born in Bethlehem. We aren't told that they
    travelled there to have the birth (that story comes from Luke, but
    reading the passage it would appear that the wise men could have visited
    him up to 2 years later. Once Herod finds out the wise men have
    returned to their country Herod orders the killing of all baby boys 2
    years or under.Mary and Joseph flee to Egypt where they remain until
    Herod snuffs it.

    In Luke we are told Mary & Joseph travel to Bethlehem to have the birth.
    After the birth they go to Jerusalem to the temple (as per Leviticus
    12) From there they returned to Galilee. That would have all happened
    in the first 6 or 7 weeks.

    Please explain how that is an abbreviation.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Nov 12 05:15:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 11/11/2026 22:23, John wrote:

    In Luke we are told Mary & Joseph travel to Bethlehem to have the birth.
    -aAfter the birth they go to Jerusalem to the temple (as per Leviticus
    12) From there they returned to Galilee.-a That would have all happened
    in the first 6 or 7 weeks.

    I must have missed the verse which said it all happened in the first six
    or seven weeks. Perhaps you can give me the reference?

    Please explain how that is an abbreviation.

    The only problem is your assumed timeline. Luke simply says that when
    they had done everything the law required, they returned to Nazareth. He doesn't say how long it was between fulfilling the law and returning.
    The statement would still be true if there was a short period in Egypt
    in between.

    Now *why* Luke doesn't mention the flight into Egypt, I don't know - but
    then, Matthew doesn't record the encounters with Anna and Simeon. Each
    author selected the incidents that were germane to the story he was telling.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Nov 12 12:03:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 12/11/2026 05:15, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 22:23, John wrote:

    In Luke we are told Mary & Joseph travel to Bethlehem to have the
    birth. -a-aAfter the birth they go to Jerusalem to the temple (as per
    Leviticus 12) From there they returned to Galilee.-a That would have
    all happened in the first 6 or 7 weeks.

    I must have missed the verse which said it all happened in the first six
    or seven weeks. Perhaps you can give me the reference?

    Please explain how that is an abbreviation.

    The only problem is your assumed timeline. Luke simply says that when
    they had done everything the law required, they returned to Nazareth. He doesn't say how long it was between fulfilling the law and returning.
    The statement would still be true if there was a short period in Egypt
    in between.

    Now *why* Luke doesn't mention the flight into Egypt, I don't know - but then, Matthew doesn't record the encounters with Anna and Simeon. Each author selected the incidents that were germane to the story he was
    telling.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Nov 12 12:18:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 12/11/2026 05:15, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 22:23, John wrote:

    In Luke we are told Mary & Joseph travel to Bethlehem to have the
    birth. -a-aAfter the birth they go to Jerusalem to the temple (as per
    Leviticus 12) From there they returned to Galilee.-a That would have
    all happened in the first 6 or 7 weeks.

    I must have missed the verse which said it all happened in the first six
    or seven weeks. Perhaps you can give me the reference?

    I already gave you the reference, Leviticus 12. The woman is unclean
    for 7 days, then the boy is circumcised. Then comes 33 days of
    purification followed by a visit to the Priest. So 8 + 33 is 41, + a
    few days, maybe gives you 6 to 7 weeks.

    Please explain how that is an abbreviation.

    The only problem is your assumed timeline. Luke simply says that when
    they had done everything the law required, they returned to Nazareth. He doesn't say how long it was between fulfilling the law and returning.
    The statement would still be true if there was a short period in Egypt
    in between.

    And *when* they had performed everything according to the Law of the
    Lord, *they returned into Galilee, to their own town of Nazareth*. And
    the child grew and became strong, filled with wisdom. And the favour of
    God was upon him. Luke 2:39-40 ESV (my emphasis)

    Now *why* Luke doesn't mention the flight into Egypt, I don't know - but then, Matthew doesn't record the encounters with Anna and Simeon. Each author selected the incidents that were germane to the story he was
    telling.
    That's because Matthew doesn't have them returning to Jerusalem, he
    sends them from Bethlehem to Egypt.

    Like I said, most Christians will gloss over contradictions and make
    excuses for them.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Nov 12 16:55:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 12/11/2026 12:18, John wrote:

    I already gave you the reference, Leviticus 12.-a The woman is unclean
    for 7 days, then the boy is circumcised. Then comes 33 days of
    purification followed by a visit to the Priest.-a So 8 + 33 is 41, + a
    few days, maybe gives you 6 to 7 weeks.

    Yes, yes, but where does it say that they returned to Nazareth within
    those 7 weeks?

    And *when* they had performed everything according to the Law of the
    Lord, *they returned into Galilee, to their own town of Nazareth*. And
    the child grew and became strong, filled with wisdom. And the favour of
    God was upon him.-a Luke 2:39-40 ESV-a (my emphasis)

    Yes, I assure you I am familiar with the gospels. You forget to allow
    for the time Mary spent packing. Then Joseph had to hire another donkey
    from Hertz and his credit card was declined, and then ....

    Luke tells us that they didn't skimp on any of the required ceremonial,
    but his words do not require that the instant the priest said the last
    "Amen" they ran out of the temple and jogged all the way back to Nazareth.

    That's because Matthew doesn't have them returning to Jerusalem, he
    sends them from Bethlehem to Egypt.

    That's because he saw significance in the stay in Egypt. Luke, without
    that knowledge, omitted the trip as he omitted mention of whooping
    cough, stubbed toes, first day at school, and anything else which he
    regarded as unimportant.

    Like I said, most Christians will gloss over contradictions and make
    excuses for them.
    And most non-Christians strain gnats and swallow camels to manufacture contradictions where there are none.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 00:56:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 12/11/2026 16:55, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 12/11/2026 12:18, John wrote:

    I already gave you the reference, Leviticus 12.-a The woman is unclean
    for 7 days, then the boy is circumcised. Then comes 33 days of
    purification followed by a visit to the Priest.-a So 8 + 33 is 41, + a
    few days, maybe gives you 6 to 7 weeks.

    Yes, yes, but where does it say that they returned to Nazareth within
    those 7 weeks?

    From the birth of Jesus to Mary & Joseph leaving the temple, give me a minimum and maximum timescale.


    And *when* they had performed everything according to the Law of the
    Lord, *they returned into Galilee, to their own town of Nazareth*. And
    the child grew and became strong, filled with wisdom. And the favour
    of God was upon him.-a Luke 2:39-40 ESV-a (my emphasis)

    Yes, I assure you I am familiar with the gospels. You forget to allow
    for the time Mary spent packing. Then Joseph had to hire another donkey
    from Hertz and his credit card was declined, and then ....

    Luke tells us that they didn't skimp on any of the required ceremonial,
    but his words do not require that the instant the priest said the last "Amen" they ran out of the temple and jogged all the way back to Nazareth.

    No, but it does say when it had all been done they returned to Nazareth.
    I would suggest that would be a week max, more likely 3 to 4 days, not
    two years later.

    That's because Matthew doesn't have them returning to Jerusalem, he
    sends them from Bethlehem to Egypt.

    That's because he saw significance in the stay in Egypt. Luke, without
    that knowledge, omitted the trip as he omitted mention of whooping
    cough, stubbed toes, first day at school, and anything else which he regarded as unimportant.

    Popping over to Egypt for a couple of years is quite an important factor
    don't you think?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Madhu@enometh@meer.net to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 10:27:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    * John <11d5n7i$eggk$1@dont-email.me> :
    Wrote on Fri, 13 Nov 2026 00:56:16 +0000:
    On 12/11/2026 16:55, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    That's because he saw significance in the stay in Egypt. Luke,
    without that knowledge, omitted the trip as he omitted mention of
    whooping cough, stubbed toes, first day at school, and anything else
    which he regarded as unimportant.

    Popping over to Egypt for a couple of years is quite an important
    factor don't you think?

    It is important because Matthew adduces it a fulfil[l?]ment of a
    messianic prophecy, Hosea 11:1 (When Israel was a child, then I loved
    him, and called my son out of Egypt.) in Matt 2:15 (And was there until
    the death of Herod: that it might be fulfilled which was spoken of the
    Lord by the prophet, saying, Out of Egypt have I called my son.)

    One may claim Luke gave no importance to th Messianic Prophecies, but it
    is only this one that he omits. This is used to prove Jesus was not the Messiah. Here is a document from a detractor that gives a list of
    messianic prophecies and argues that Jesus did not fulfil any of them.
    (It may reflects some other source, the references useful even if you're
    not a denier)

    https://www.srimatham.com/uploads/5/5/4/9/5549439/why_jesus_is_not_the_messiah.pdf
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 07:10:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 00:56, John wrote:

    From the birth of Jesus to Mary & Joseph leaving the temple, give me a minimum and maximum timescale.

    No one disputes your 7 weeks for that period.

    No, but it does say when it had all been done they returned to Nazareth.
    I would suggest that would be a week max, more likely 3 to 4 days, not
    two years later.

    You suggest that because it creates the "contradiction" you desire.

    Popping over to Egypt for a couple of years is quite an important factor don't you think?

    I would think so, yes, but Luke obviously regarded it differently. After
    all, we don't know much about this trip to Egypt. Did they travel all
    the way to within sight of the pyramids? Or did they just cross the
    border and settle down in Rafah? All they needed was to be out of
    Herod's jurisdiction.

    Take a parallel example: ask an ordinary person to tell you what they
    know about Winston Churchill. Some may know he was born in Blenheim
    Palace, or that he served in the army in India, but most will just tell
    you about his war years. Very few will know about his participation in
    the war against the Mahdi or his escape from Boer captivity, yet both
    were very significant in shaping his career.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 07:21:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 04:57, Madhu wrote:

    https://www.srimatham.com/uploads/5/5/4/9/5549439/why_jesus_is_not_the_messiah.pdf

    That's an interesting document. The sad thing is that the author
    indicates that he has become a Hindu, whose gods are just as nasty as he claims the Bible God is (I'm thinking particularly of Kali, but Shiva
    comes a close second) and whose Scriptures lack any historical
    authenticity so far as I can judge. Even Krishna, so lauded by European Hindus, is known in north India (at least) as "makkan chor" - butter thief.

    As for the list of "prophecies" that Jesus did not fulfil (such as
    smiting Moab), I fear that author displays enormous historical ignorance
    as well as being unable to interpret the Bible correctly.

    I suspect that, like John, he has manufactured things to justify his
    decision to reject Christianity.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 12:02:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 07:10, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 13/11/2026 00:56, John wrote:

    -aFrom the birth of Jesus to Mary & Joseph leaving the temple, give me
    a minimum and maximum timescale.

    No one disputes your 7 weeks for that period.

    No, but it does say when it had all been done they returned to
    Nazareth. I would suggest that would be a week max, more likely 3 to 4
    days, not two years later.

    You suggest that because it creates the "contradiction" you desire.

    Some time ago Ken Down went to Evesham SDA church as guest speaker. When
    he had done all that was required he returned unto Wales, to his own
    town of Rhyl.

    If, in the same time frame another narrative says he went to
    Kidderminster for 18 months to see his family, I would say one of the narratives is wrong, wouldn't you?

    Popping over to Egypt for a couple of years is quite an important
    factor don't you think?

    I would think so, yes, but Luke obviously regarded it differently. After all, we don't know much about this trip to Egypt. Did they travel all
    the way to within sight of the pyramids? Or did they just cross the
    border and settle down in Rafah? All they needed was to be out of
    Herod's jurisdiction.

    Take a parallel example: ask an ordinary person to tell you what they
    know about Winston Churchill. Some may know he was born in Blenheim
    Palace, or that he served in the army in India, but most will just tell
    you about his war years. Very few will know about his participation in
    the war against the Mahdi or his escape from Boer captivity, yet both
    were very significant in shaping his career.
    If one says he went to x, and the other says he went to y, in the same
    time frame, I would say one of the reports is wrong, wouldn't you?

    For the avoidance of doubt, Matthew's narrative allows for them visiting Jerusalem on the way to Egypt, and may have just omitted it as not
    important, although there was a sense of urgency in the Angel's message
    for them to go straight to Egypt.

    Luke doesn't allow for them going to Egypt at all. It says they returned
    to their home town of Nazareth.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 12:03:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 04:57, Madhu wrote:
    * John <11d5n7i$eggk$1@dont-email.me> :
    Wrote on Fri, 13 Nov 2026 00:56:16 +0000:
    On 12/11/2026 16:55, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    That's because he saw significance in the stay in Egypt. Luke,
    without that knowledge, omitted the trip as he omitted mention of
    whooping cough, stubbed toes, first day at school, and anything else
    which he regarded as unimportant.

    Popping over to Egypt for a couple of years is quite an important
    factor don't you think?

    It is important because Matthew adduces it a fulfil[l?]ment of a
    messianic prophecy, Hosea 11:1 (When Israel was a child, then I loved
    him, and called my son out of Egypt.) in Matt 2:15 (And was there until
    the death of Herod: that it might be fulfilled which was spoken of the
    Lord by the prophet, saying, Out of Egypt have I called my son.)

    One may claim Luke gave no importance to th Messianic Prophecies, but it
    is only this one that he omits. This is used to prove Jesus was not the Messiah. Here is a document from a detractor that gives a list of
    messianic prophecies and argues that Jesus did not fulfil any of them.
    (It may reflects some other source, the references useful even if you're
    not a denier)

    https://www.srimatham.com/uploads/5/5/4/9/5549439/why_jesus_is_not_the_messiah.pdf

    Thanks, I'll read that when I have time. There are purportedly 300
    messianic prophecies that say Jesus is the Messiah. One of the most
    important ones is based on a mistranslation of a hebrew word.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 13:16:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 12:02, John wrote:

    For the avoidance of doubt, Matthew's narrative allows for them visiting Jerusalem on the way to Egypt, and may have just omitted it as not important, although there was a sense of urgency in the Angel's message
    for them to go straight to Egypt.

    Luke doesn't allow for them going to Egypt at all. It says they returned
    to their home town of Nazareth.
    Sorry, I'm wrong about Matthew, it doesn't allow him to stop at
    Jerusalem on the way.

    Now when they had departed, behold, an angel of the Lord appeared to
    Joseph in a dream and said, rCLRise, take the child and his mother, and
    *flee* to Egypt, and remain there until I tell you, for Herod is about
    to search for the child, to destroy him.rCY And he rose and took the child
    and his mother by night and *departed to Egypt*.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 16:16:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 12:03, John wrote:

    Thanks, I'll read that when I have time.-a There are purportedly 300 messianic prophecies that say Jesus is the Messiah. One of the most important ones is based on a mistranslation of a hebrew word.

    If you are referring to "the virgin shall conceive", I wouldn't be too
    sure. "Maid" used to refer to virginity but now no longer does so and it
    is possible that Hebrew suffered a similar change, which is why the
    Jewish translators of the LXX used "virgin".

    A more serious objection is that the context seems to place the event in
    the lifetime of King Ahaz, for whom this conception would be a sign.
    However that may be to place our modern rules of interpretation on a
    passage which was not intended for modern readers.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 16:22:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 12:02, John wrote:

    Some time ago Ken Down went to Evesham SDA church as guest speaker. When
    he had done all that was required he returned unto Wales, to his own
    town of Rhyl.
    If, in the same time frame another narrative says he went to
    Kidderminster for 18 months to see his family, I would say one of the narratives is wrong, wouldn't you?

    If it was intended to be a detailed account of my movements you might
    well be right. If, however, it was a summary, written 40 or 50 years
    after the event, then I would not say that there was a mistake.

    For the avoidance of doubt, Matthew's narrative allows for them visiting Jerusalem on the way to Egypt, and may have just omitted it as not important, although there was a sense of urgency in the Angel's message
    for them to go straight to Egypt.

    I am not the first to notice that Jesus was born in a stable, but by the
    time the wise men reached Him, the narrative talks of a house. Some have suggested, based on this and on the time line Herod gave for the
    slaughter, that Joseph and Mary settled down in Bethlehem and Joseph may
    even have found work at the temple, which was being constructed by Herod.

    So never mind the trip into Egypt, Luke omits the eighteen months to two
    years in which the Holy Family lived in Bethlehem before skipping out to Egypt.

    Luke doesn't allow for them going to Egypt at all. It says they returned
    to their home town of Nazareth.
    Neither does he preclude them going to Egypt.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 16:25:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 13:16, John wrote:

    Sorry, I'm wrong about Matthew, it doesn't allow him to stop at
    Jerusalem on the way.
    Certainly once the wise men had departed it was all get up and go and
    the Holy Family departed in a hurry that same night. But Herod's decree
    that boys two or younger should be killed indicates that 18-24 months
    must have elapsed between the birth and the wise men.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 23:17:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 16:22, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 13/11/2026 12:02, John wrote:



    For the avoidance of doubt, Matthew's narrative allows for them
    visiting Jerusalem on the way to Egypt, and may have just omitted it
    as not important, although there was a sense of urgency in the Angel's
    message for them to go straight to Egypt.

    I am not the first to notice that Jesus was born in a stable, but by the time the wise men reached Him, the narrative talks of a house. Some have suggested, based on this and on the time line Herod gave for the
    slaughter, that Joseph and Mary settled down in Bethlehem and Joseph may even have found work at the temple, which was being constructed by Herod.

    So never mind the trip into Egypt, Luke omits the eighteen months to two years in which the Holy Family lived in Bethlehem before skipping out to Egypt.
    Luke has Joseph and Mary go to Bethlehem for the birth, then to
    Jerusalem, then to Nazareth. Do you think they then went back to
    Bethlehem before going to Egypt, what would be the purpose? The only
    reason they went to Bethlehem in the first place was so Joseph could
    take part in a census.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Nov 13 23:57:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 16:16, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 13/11/2026 12:03, John wrote:

    Thanks, I'll read that when I have time.-a There are purportedly 300
    messianic prophecies that say Jesus is the Messiah. One of the most
    important ones is based on a mistranslation of a hebrew word.

    If you are referring to "the virgin shall conceive", I wouldn't be too
    sure. "Maid" used to refer to virginity but now no longer does so and it
    is possible that Hebrew suffered a similar change, which is why the
    Jewish translators of the LXX used "virgin".

    Isaiah uses the word almah, which was translated to parthenos in the
    Greek LXX. It is used in 7 places, and generally means maid or young (unmarried) woman.

    The Hebrew word generally used for virgin is betulah, also translated as parthenos in the LXX. It is interesting that Isaiah 23:4 uses beetulot
    for virgins, which is then translated as parthenous in the LXX.

    This is where I think Matthew has made a mistake, and constructed his
    account round it, but I don't expect you or any other Christian to
    accept that.


    A more serious objection is that the context seems to place the event in
    the lifetime of King Ahaz, for whom this conception would be a sign.
    However that may be to place our modern rules of interpretation on a
    passage which was not intended for modern readers.


    verse 16 wasn't fulfilled in jesus's time.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sat Nov 14 06:40:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 23:57, John wrote:

    Isaiah uses the word almah, which was translated to parthenos in the
    Greek LXX. It is used in 7 places, and generally means maid or young (unmarried) woman.

    I know.

    This is where I think Matthew has made a mistake, and constructed his account round it, but I don't expect you or any other Christian to
    accept that.

    What mistake? He used the LXX - is that his mistake?

    verse 16 wasn't fulfilled in jesus's time.

    I would say that it was fulfilled long before Jesus' day! As I pointed
    out, the original prophecy was a sign given to King Ahaz that he need
    not fear the Syrians. The passage about a virgin conceiving was taken completely out of context - but ...

    Concern for context is a relatively modern and Christian development.
    The Jews themselves cheerfully take verses that have no relevance to
    what is under discussion and advance them as "proof" for whatever it is
    that they are arguing - read the Talmud and see. So although the virgin prophecy is completely out of literary context, it is entirely in the
    cultural context of the people to whom the Old Testament was addressed.

    Did God send Isaiah to Jews of the 8th century BC or to Europeans of the
    20th century AD?

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sat Nov 14 06:42:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 13/11/2026 23:17, John wrote:

    Luke has Joseph and Mary go to Bethlehem for the birth, then to
    Jerusalem, then to Nazareth. Do you think they then went back to
    Bethlehem before going to Egypt,-a what would be the purpose?-a The only reason they went to Bethlehem in the first place was so Joseph could
    take part in a census.

    What have I said that would cause you to think I held to such a
    ridiculous idea?

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 15 11:26:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 14/11/2026 06:42, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 13/11/2026 23:17, John wrote:

    Luke has Joseph and Mary go to Bethlehem for the birth, then to
    Jerusalem, then to Nazareth. Do you think they then went back to
    Bethlehem before going to Egypt,-a what would be the purpose?-a The only
    reason they went to Bethlehem in the first place was so Joseph could
    take part in a census.

    What have I said that would cause you to think I held to such a
    ridiculous idea?
    Because you said that Joseph could have been in Bethlehem for up to 2
    years, something I actually agree with based on the narrative, and which
    I alluded to in my post of the 11th September at 10.23 pm. That
    narrative on it's own I have no quibble over, but you have a different narrative in Luke which mucks up the story somewhat.

    It's the only conclusion I can draw from your insistence that Joseph and
    Mary visited all 4 places. Perhaps if you draw your own timeline I
    could better understand?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 15 11:55:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 14/11/2026 06:40, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 13/11/2026 23:57, John wrote:

    Isaiah uses the word almah, which was translated to parthenos in the
    Greek LXX. It is used in 7 places, and generally means maid or young
    (unmarried) woman.

    I know.

    This is where I think Matthew has made a mistake, and constructed his
    account round it, but I don't expect you or any other Christian to
    accept that.

    What mistake? He used the LXX - is that his mistake?

    Indirectly yes. In my opinion, by using the LXX he saw it as a prophecy
    that the virgin shall be with child, and concocted the virgin birth
    around it. I think for the virgin birth to have more merit the Hebrew
    would have said betulah. When I learned (learnt?) about this it blew my
    mind to be fair.

    verse 16 wasn't fulfilled in Jesus's time.

    I would say that it was fulfilled long before Jesus' day! As I pointed
    out, the original prophecy was a sign given to King Ahaz that he need
    not fear the Syrians. The passage about a virgin conceiving was taken completely out of context - but ...

    Concern for context is a relatively modern and Christian development.
    The Jews themselves cheerfully take verses that have no relevance to
    what is under discussion and advance them as "proof" for whatever it is
    that they are arguing - read the Talmud and see. So although the virgin prophecy is completely out of literary context, it is entirely in the cultural context of the people to whom the Old Testament was addressed.

    Did God send Isaiah to Jews of the 8th century BC or to Europeans of the 20th century AD?
    My quibble is not with the prophecy itself, which, as you agree, was
    about a maiden giving birth to a child, but that Matthew took it as a
    prophecy about Jesus, because he used the LXX as his source. I
    understand and accept this totally goes against Christian understanding.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 15 16:46:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 15/11/2026 11:55, John wrote:

    Indirectly yes.-a In my opinion, by using the LXX he saw it as a prophecy that the virgin shall be with child, and concocted the virgin birth
    around it.-a I think for the virgin birth to have more merit the Hebrew would have said betulah. When I learned (learnt?) about this it blew my
    mind to be fair.

    I'm not sure that using the LXX was a mistake. It was cutting edge
    scholarship with a miraculous story to prove its validity. The mistake -
    if there was one - lay with the translators.

    My quibble is not with the prophecy itself, which, as you agree, was
    about a maiden giving birth to a child, but that Matthew took it as a prophecy about Jesus, because he used the LXX as his source.-a I
    understand and accept this totally goes against Christian understanding.

    1. As indicated above, the LXX was highly regarded and there is no
    reason why he should not have used it - and there is always the
    possibility that the Hebrew carried a connotation of virginity that we
    don't understand.

    2. Using the verse in the out-of-context way seems deplorable to us, but
    was entirely in harmony with Jewish hermeneutics.

    3. I like the idea that God allowed Matthew's "mistake" to enter the
    Bible because He approved of it.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 15 17:05:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 15/11/2026 11:26, John wrote:

    Because you said that Joseph could have been in Bethlehem for up to 2
    years, something I actually agree with based on the narrative, and which
    I alluded to in my post of the 11th September at 10.23 pm.-a That
    narrative on it's own I have no quibble over, but you have a different narrative in Luke which mucks up the story somewhat.

    But nothing I have said remotely suggests the ridiculous coming and
    going that you put forward.

    It's the only conclusion I can draw from your insistence that Joseph and Mary visited all 4 places.-a Perhaps if you draw your own timeline I
    could better understand?

    Given that we are not given a Biblical time-line, there must be a lot of conjecture here.

    "It was in the forty-second year of the reign of Augustus and the twenty-eighth after the subjugation of Egypt and the death of Antony and Cleopatra, with whom the dynasty of the Ptolemies in Egypt came to an
    end, that our Saviour and Lord Jesus Christ was born in Bethlehem of
    Judea." Eusebius: History of the Church V.ii

    Those dates would put the birth of Jesus in either 1 or 2 BC, but as
    Herod did not die until 4 BC, neither of the dates is possible. Assuming
    that Jesus was born 2 years before Herod died, He must have been born
    around 6 BC.

    Augustus, in his "Res Gestae", lists three censuses, 28 BC, 8 BC and AD
    14. The first and last are clearly out of the running, leaving us with 8
    BC as the year when "all the world should be taxed".

    "But there is historical proof that at this very time a census had been
    taken in Judaea by Sentius Saturninus, which might have satisfied their inquiry respecting the family and descent of Christ." Tertullian:
    Adversus Marcion IV.xix

    It is possible, however, that Herod may have delayed the census by a
    year, which would put Jesus' birth in 7 BC, however 8 BC is perhaps more likely.

    The wise men in the east see the star on the same night as Jesus' birth, debate its significance and then decide to travel to Judea to see for themselves. Lacking Thomas Cook and Sons, the whole process (including
    the journey) could easily have taken a year and possibly longer. That
    would put their visit in 7 BC.

    Joseph and Mary take their newborn son to the temple 40 days after His
    birth and Joseph discovers that carpenters (or possibly stone-masons[1])
    can earn good money working on the temple. He therefore decides to
    safe-guard his interests in Bethlehem and do his finances a bit of good
    by staying in Bethlehem and working on the temple which is only about 4
    miles away.

    Herod realises that the wise men have done a runner approximately two
    years after Jesus' birth, which would be 6 BC. An angel takes a warning
    to Joseph, who leaves immediately and is across the border into Egypt
    two days later. He stays there until Herod dies in 4 BC and sets out
    back to Israel, but on the way hears stories about Herod's son,
    Archelaeus, and decides that Bethlehem is no longer safe, so keeps to
    the coast and slips past Judea to arrive in Nazareth in 4 BC/3 BC.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Nov 15 22:49:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 15/11/2026 17:05, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 15/11/2026 11:26, John wrote:

    Because you said that Joseph could have been in Bethlehem for up to 2
    years, something I actually agree with based on the narrative, and
    which I alluded to in my post of the 11th September at 10.23 pm.-a That
    narrative on it's own I have no quibble over, but you have a different
    narrative in Luke which mucks up the story somewhat.

    But nothing I have said remotely suggests the ridiculous coming and
    going that you put forward.

    It's the only conclusion I can draw from your insistence that Joseph
    and Mary visited all 4 places.-a Perhaps if you draw your own timeline
    I could better understand?

    Given that we are not given a Biblical time-line, there must be a lot of conjecture here.

    "It was in the forty-second year of the reign of Augustus and the twenty-eighth after the subjugation of Egypt and the death of Antony and Cleopatra, with whom the dynasty of the Ptolemies in Egypt came to an
    end, that our Saviour and Lord Jesus Christ was born in Bethlehem of
    Judea." Eusebius: History of the Church V.ii

    Those dates would put the birth of Jesus in either 1 or 2 BC, but as
    Herod did not die until 4 BC, neither of the dates is possible. Assuming that Jesus was born 2 years before Herod died, He must have been born
    around 6 BC.

    Augustus, in his "Res Gestae", lists three censuses, 28 BC, 8 BC and AD
    14. The first and last are clearly out of the running, leaving us with 8
    BC as the year when "all the world should be taxed".

    "But there is historical proof that at this very time a census had been taken in Judaea by Sentius Saturninus, which might have satisfied their inquiry respecting the family and descent of Christ." Tertullian:
    Adversus Marcion IV.xix

    It is possible, however, that Herod may have delayed the census by a
    year, which would put Jesus' birth in 7 BC, however 8 BC is perhaps more likely.

    The wise men in the east see the star on the same night as Jesus' birth, debate its significance and then decide to travel to Judea to see for themselves. Lacking Thomas Cook and Sons, the whole process (including
    the journey) could easily have taken a year and possibly longer. That
    would put their visit in 7 BC.

    Joseph and Mary take their newborn son to the temple 40 days after His
    birth and Joseph discovers that carpenters (or possibly stone-masons[1])
    can earn good money working on the temple. He therefore decides to safe- guard his interests in Bethlehem and do his finances a bit of good by staying in Bethlehem and working on the temple which is only about 4
    miles away.

    Herod realises that the wise men have done a runner approximately two
    years after Jesus' birth, which would be 6 BC. An angel takes a warning
    to Joseph, who leaves immediately and is across the border into Egypt
    two days later. He stays there until Herod dies in 4 BC and sets out
    back to Israel, but on the way hears stories about Herod's son,
    Archelaeus, and decides that Bethlehem is no longer safe, so keeps to
    the coast and slips past Judea to arrive in Nazareth in 4 BC/3 BC.
    Thanks for your detailed timeline.

    So, as far as I can tell, you believe they went from Nazareth to
    Bethlehem, stayed in Bethlehem for up to 2 years, then went to Eygypt
    then back to Nazareth? That all fits with the Matthew narrative (with
    the exclusion of the visit to Jerusalem which is fair enough)

    My problem still remains with Luke's narrative. He says "When Joseph
    and Mary had done everything required by the Law of the Lord, they
    returned to Galilee to their own town of Nazareth" which according to Matthews narrative isn't true, because they didn't.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Nov 16 05:06:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 15/11/2026 22:49, John wrote:

    So, as far as I can tell, you believe they went from Nazareth to
    Bethlehem, stayed in Bethlehem for up to 2 years, then went to Eygypt
    then back to Nazareth?-a That all fits with the Matthew narrative (with
    the exclusion of the visit to Jerusalem which is fair enough)

    Luke only mentions the visit to Jerusalem so that he can tell the
    stories of Anna and Simeon.

    My problem still remains with Luke's narrative. He says-a "When Joseph
    and Mary had done everything required by the Law of the Lord, they
    returned to Galilee to their own town of Nazareth"-a which according to Matthews narrative isn't true, because they didn't.
    But they did. They just didn't do so immediately.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2