Sometimes the prayer God answers is not the one we speak aloud, but the deeper one beneath it rCo the prayer for acceptance, peace, wholeness, and love.What you have said is all true and good, but I think you - and perhaps
Considering some of the recent discussions here, maybe we should think
about unanswered prayers.
We have JesusrCO promise: rCLWhatever you ask in my Name, I will do it.rCY (John 14:13)
And we have his teaching on persistent prayer: rCLWhat father among you,
if his son asks for a fish, will give him a serpent?rCY (Luke 11:5rCo13)
These passages emphasise GodrCOs goodness, generosity, and
trustworthiness. They assume that God does not trick us, harm us, or withhold what is truly good.
Yet some prayers rCo prayers that seem like rCLright things to ask forrCY rCo do
not appear to be answered. Or if they are, then only very rarely. And
this is true even when such prayers are offered sincerely, repeatedly,
and by many different people over many years.
Some people conclude from this that God must not be there, or does not
hear them, or worse, is vindictive or uncaring.
But is the nonrCaanswer actually a kind of answer?
Perhaps sometimes we pray for rCLfixesrCY for things that God does not consider broken.
Sometimes the prayer God answers is not the one we speak aloud, but the deeper one beneath it rCo the prayer for acceptance, peace, wholeness, and love.Nails and heads spring to mind
On 15/10/2026 09:04, Timreason wrote:
Considering some of the recent discussions here, maybe we should think
about unanswered prayers.
We have JesusrCO promise: rCLWhatever you ask in my Name, I will do it.rCY >> (John 14:13)
And we have his teaching on persistent prayer: rCLWhat father among you,
if his son asks for a fish, will give him a serpent?rCY (Luke 11:5rCo13)
These passages emphasise GodrCOs goodness, generosity, and
trustworthiness. They assume that God does not trick us, harm us, or
withhold what is truly good.
Yet some prayers rCo prayers that seem like rCLright things to ask forrCY rCo
do not appear to be answered. Or if they are, then only very rarely.
And this is true even when such prayers are offered sincerely,
repeatedly, and by many different people over many years.
Some people conclude from this that God must not be there, or does not
hear them, or worse, is vindictive or uncaring.
But is the nonrCaanswer actually a kind of answer?
Perhaps sometimes we pray for rCLfixesrCY for things that God does not
consider broken.
------
Sometimes the prayer God answers is not the one we speak aloud, butNails and heads spring to mind
the deeper one beneath it rCo the prayer for acceptance, peace,
wholeness, and love.
In the case of the person who I've been discussing with Ken, when he
finally gave in after 40 years of prayer, he experienced exactly what
you describe. He lost his marriage, his church, and numerous "friends"
but has never been more happy and at peace, both with his now partner
and his renewed faith in God and Jesus.
What you have said is all true and good, but I think you - and perhaps
others - have overlooked another reason, and that is that we are
asking for something which God cannot give and remain good.
How many parents have prayed that a straying son or daughter will
repent and come back to God - but God cannot answer that prayer and
still respect the freewill of the son or daughter! God will and does
give the rebellious child opportunities and pleadings that perhaps He
would not have given without those prayers, but in the ultimate
resort, God has given us freewill and wherever possible He allows us
to use or misuse that gift.
And there are times when God allows or even sends illness or
misfortune either to make us better or for His own purposes (think of
Job). If we pray that the illness will be healed, God will not defeat
His good purpose. Indeed, we might suggest that if we could know the
reasons behind everything, we would not have made such prayers in the
first place.
Yet in this real world there are "prayers", whether they addressed to
God or to the devil, are being answered, and in being answered, limit
the freewill of yet others, and these are answered all the time.
Making this about "freewill" just introduces a spurious catch-all
debating point that is orthogonal and extraneous to the mechanism of
prayer and answering of prayer
This imposes a belief in "God's good purpose" and a consistent
fucntioning of his goodness in this world, by the debator, on the "perplexed". which in turn imposes a dissoncance on the "perplexed"
between his reality and conflicts with the world view of the debator. eventually this dissonance ends up being turned around and used against
the "perplexed" without addressing the merits of his prayer.
Structrually it is a blanket argument eventually only upholdsThere speaks a Hindu, whose gods are not always good. (One thinks of
and defends the unjustices and evils of the present world by sweeping
them under "God is always good" carpet
In the case of the person who I've been discussing with Ken, when heIn which case I would say that his "faith" is a delusion.
finally gave in after 40 years of prayer, he experienced exactly what
you describe. He lost his marriage, his church, and numerous "friends"
but has never been more happy and at peace, both with his now partner
and his renewed faith in God and Jesus.
Spot on. The world is too full of people eager to tell other people howOh indeed. Just look at how happy that drunk is now he has decided to
to live their lives. Such people are never willing to accept any advice themselves, or to accept that they could be wrong, or even to consider
often overwhelming evidence against their stance.
This imposes a belief in "God's good purpose" and a consistent
fucntioning of his goodness in this world, by the debator, on the "perplexed". which in turn imposes a dissoncance on the "perplexed"
between his reality and conflicts with the world view of the debator.
eventually this dissonance ends up being turned around and used against
the "perplexed" without addressing the merits of his
prayer. Structrually it is a blanket argument eventually only upholds
and defends the unjustices and evils of the present world by sweeping
them under "God is always good" carpet
On 16/10/2026 11:32, John wrote:
In the case of the person who I've been discussing with Ken, when he
finally gave in after 40 years of prayer, he experienced exactly what
you describe. He lost his marriage, his church, and numerous "friends"
but has never been more happy and at peace, both with his now partner
and his renewed faith in God and Jesus.
In which case I would say that his "faith" is a delusion.
He lost his marriage - the words roll glibly off the tongue, hiding the heartbreak of his wife and his children (assuming he had some).
He lost his church - more glib words, but how many had their faith
shattered by his careless falling into sin?
He may think he's happy, but in the Day of Judgement he will have toIf only God had answered his prayer hey, none of that collateral damage
face all the damage he has done to other people.
On 16/10/2026 08:15, Madhu wrote:
Yet in this real world there are "prayers", whether they addressed to
God or to the devil, are being answered, and in being answered, limit
the freewill of yet others, and these are answered all the time.
Can you give an example of what you have in mind?
Making this about "freewill" just introduces a spurious catch-all
debating point that is orthogonal and extraneous to the mechanism of
prayer and answering of prayer
No, I don't believe it is extraneous at all. However I do not claim to
know the reason why any particular prayer has not been answered. I'm
merely putting forward a general principle.
This imposes a belief in "God's good purpose" and a consistent
fucntioning of his goodness in this world, by the debator, on the
"perplexed". which in turn imposes a dissoncance on the "perplexed"
between his reality and conflicts with the world view of the debator.
eventually this dissonance ends up being turned around and used against
the "perplexed" without addressing the merits of his prayer.
Rather than talking about the merits of a particular prayer, we should
talk about the merits of God's reasons for answering or not
answering. For example, a martyr may reasonably pray to be delivered
from the lions, but God sees that his death will result in the
conversion of x number of others. I suppose you might say it is the
old runaway train dilemma: should one allow the train to carry on down
its original pathway and kill a dozen people or divert it onto another
line where it will kill only one?
Structrually it is a blanket argument eventually only upholdsThere speaks a Hindu, whose gods are not always good. (One thinks of
and defends the unjustices and evils of the present world by sweeping
them under "God is always good" carpet
Kali, for instance). It is a given that the Christian God is always
good - He would not be God if He were not always good.
sure, rationalizations are always possible, but I'm not sure applying a standard rationalization to some unique believer's specific problem is
going to benefit the believer even if goes away satisified for the time being.
No space for Hindu apologetics, but my sect defines God to be entirely
Good in exactly the same sense as [most] christian theology, without redefining God to some impersonal Supreme Brahaman.
However to reconcile that with the world it also has to resort to meta theories (karma etc.) and to actually make it work it has to inculcate internalised hypocricy -- as with western christianity.So you run into the same problem with generalisations and particular
The OT shows humanity learning to understand God.
The NT shows God stepping into humanity to reveal Himself more fully.
We are told not to be judgemental and condemning, we are told to beYou are forgetting, though, that the Old Testament and the New are
caring and compassionate.
Careless?-a Are you for real? I only lasted 5 years before I gave up on a God who didn't keep His biblical promises. This guy managed 40 years - that's half a lifetime.
But thank God you're not sat on the Judgement seat. I've no idea whatOf course I am not his judge, just the same as I am not the judge when
will happen to him, just as I have no idea what will happen to you.-a If
it is as he believes, then he and plenty of other LGBT+ Christians will
be joining him in eternity.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:49:59 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |