Anyone else in the group had any experience of this hobby?Not hands-on as you are doing - and well done. But change-ringing has fascinated me for years and we used to love listening to "Bells on
... we used to love listening to "Bells onEarly and late on Sundays - 05:43 and 00:45 Monday morning, just before
Sunday" - the different bells and the different changes that featured.
Alas, as part of its anti-Christianity drive, the BBC pushed it to a different slot and I don't even know if it still exists.
Early and late on Sundays - 05:43 and 00:45 Monday morning, just before Sailing By and the shipping forecast.Thanks for that information. I'm glad to know that it continues. Change-ringing is a peculiarly English phenomenon that we should
On 2026-09-22 05:53, Kendall K. Down wrote:
... we used to love listening to "Bells onEarly and late on Sundays - 05:43 and 00:45 Monday morning, just before Sailing By and the shipping forecast.
Sunday" - the different bells and the different changes that featured.
Alas, as part of its anti-Christianity drive, the BBC pushed it to a
different slot and I don't even know if it still exists.
Last Sunday's recording, from St Bartholomew the Great, Smithfield in London,
is available here (registration may be required):
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0031spd
The Radio 4 schedule is available online at:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/schedules/bbc_radio_fourfm/2026-09-20
On 22/09/2026 21:39, Graham Nye wrote:
On 2026-09-22 05:53, Kendall K. Down wrote:
... we used to love listening to "Bells onEarly and late on Sundays - 05:43 and 00:45 Monday morning, just before
Sunday" - the different bells and the different changes that featured.
Alas, as part of its anti-Christianity drive, the BBC pushed it to a
different slot and I don't even know if it still exists.
Sailing By and the shipping forecast.
Last Sunday's recording, from St Bartholomew the Great, Smithfield
in London,
is available here (registration may be required):
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0031spd
The Radio 4 schedule is available online at:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/schedules/bbc_radio_fourfm/2026-09-20
That's the great thing these days, that we can "Hear what you like,
when you like" as it used to say on the old vintage Rex record
labels. (As my late mother pointed out, in those days you could only
do so if you had the record!)
But BBC sounds makes it more possible today.
Although I get up early on Sundays to be ready in time to get to 8am
Mass at Guildford Cathedral every Sunday, the 'Bells on Sunday'
usually goes out about half an hour before I get up. It's only a two
minute slot. I have rung a couple of the bells at the Cathedral, but
usually I ring the bells with our team at a church local to me two
Sundays a month.
like many others I was introduced to change-ringing by Dorothy Sayers'
1934 novel "The Nine Tailors".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nine_Tailors#Literary_significance_and_criticism
with some technical information here https://belladvocate.wordpress.com/2015/07/31/the-nine-tailors-nine-hour-bell-performance/
What also struck me in her works was her descriptions of
"Southern-English Country-Christianity" if I may call it that.
Although I get up early on Sundays to be ready in time to get to 8amYou should be able to go back to that time on BBC Sounds and listen to
Mass at Guildford Cathedral every Sunday, the 'Bells on Sunday' usually
goes out about half an hour before I get up. It's only a two minute
slot. I have rung a couple of the bells at the Cathedral, but usually I
ring the bells with our team at a church local to me two Sundays a month.
On 23/09/2026 21:48, Timreason wrote:
Although I get up early on Sundays to be ready in time to get to 8amYou should be able to go back to that time on BBC Sounds and listen to
Mass at Guildford Cathedral every Sunday, the 'Bells on Sunday'
usually goes out about half an hour before I get up. It's only a two
minute slot. I have rung a couple of the bells at the Cathedral, but
usually I ring the bells with our team at a church local to me two
Sundays a month.
it at a time convenient to you.
like many others I was introduced to change-ringing by Dorothy Sayers'
1934 novel "The Nine Tailors".
What also struck me in her works was her descriptions ofYes. And Wales has a similar depth of Christianity. People have
"Southern-English Country-Christianity" if I may call it that.
You should be able to go back to that time on BBC Sounds and listen to
it at a time convenient to you.
On 25/09/2026 10:23, John wrote:
You should be able to go back to that time on BBC Sounds and listen to
it at a time convenient to you.
You have to be signed in to listen to it. I don't know whether that
involves being a licence fee payer or not.
In the UK you need an account on the BBC UK website (bbc.co.uk) to use
BBC Sounds or BBC iPlayer. (Overseas users get pointed to bbc.com .)
You don't need a TV licence to listen to BBC Sounds. You do need a TV
licence to legally watch iPlayer. It periodically asks you to confirm
you have one but doesn't, as far as I'm aware, verify your assertion.
You don't need a TV licence to listen to BBC Sounds. You do need a TVIt is mooted that the Government might replace the TV licence with a
licence to legally watch iPlayer. It periodically asks you to confirm
you have one but doesn't, as far as I'm aware, verify your assertion.
On 25/09/2026 17:22, Graham Nye wrote:Songs of Praise certainly has a lot to answer for!!
In the UK you need an account on the BBC UK website (bbc.co.uk) to use
BBC Sounds or BBC iPlayer. (Overseas users get pointed to bbc.com .)
Thanks for the clarification, Graham.
You don't need a TV licence to listen to BBC Sounds. You do need a TV
licence to legally watch iPlayer. It periodically asks you to confirm
you have one but doesn't, as far as I'm aware, verify your assertion.
Yes, I was aware of the situation with iPlayer. When I first came to
Britain 50+ years ago I listened to nothing but the BBC, which was world famous for its truthfulness and impartiality. Since then it has become nothing but a propaganda mouthpiece for homosexuality and all things left-wing and woke. It is years since I listened to it or even visited
its website.
But seriously, what an absolutely bigoted view to have on an
organisation.-a The BBC isn't perfect, and in recent years it has had
more than it's fair share of controversy, but to completely dismiss it's output because you think it's all about homosexuality, left wing bias
and wokeness is a ridiculous stance imo.
There's thousands of BBC programmes that don't fit your narrative.
On 26/09/2026 12:48, John wrote:
We live in a world where it has become VERY clear that the greatest
But seriously, what an absolutely bigoted view to have on an
organisation.-a The BBC isn't perfect, and in recent years it has had
more than it's fair share of controversy, but to completely dismiss
it's output because you think it's all about homosexuality, left wing
bias and wokeness is a ridiculous stance imo.
There's thousands of BBC programmes that don't fit your narrative.
threat to the world comes from the far-right and their aim to dismantle
the checks and balances of society to carry out their selfish aims unchecked.
We're seeing what happened in the USA when such groups get control, and
we need to be on our guard to ensure that similar criminal elements do
not gain control here.
The BBC and other media are the natural enemies of such groups.The area to watch is Christian Nationalism, again feeding on the notion
The problems are political rather than theological and are perhaps
therefore beyond the remit of this newsgroup, but that said, I think it
is reasonable to take the Gospels, read them, and then see how they
measure up to the far-right agenda. To me, they seem to be opposites.
I have been involved with this for about two and a half years now, and
can ring a bell reasonably reliably and change speed and set the bell OK
most of the time. But I still struggle a bit with ringing a bell up, and ringing down at the end. As for 'Changes' and 'Methods', that is,
ringing the bells in changing order, I've still got a LOT to learn!
Anyone else in the group had any experience of this hobby?
Tim.
On 27/09/2026 07:12, Timreason wrote:
We live in a world where it has become VERY clear that the greatest
threat to the world comes from the far-right and their aim to
dismantle the checks and balances of society to carry out their
selfish aims unchecked.
Unfortunately, they are feeding into a genuine concern about unfettered illegal immigration, fuelled by the propaganda peddled by Restore,
Reform and the likes of Tommy Robinson and new kid on the block Danny
Tommo, that its an invasion and we will become a Muslim country.
We're seeing what happened in the USA when such groups get control,
and we need to be on our guard to ensure that similar criminal
elements do not gain control here.
It was largely the evangelical wing (1) which enabled Trump to be
President. I fear the US is heading towards a dictatorship but the
testing stage will be the mid term elections. I think some MAGA
supporters are seeing sense, but whether that will be enough to see a
swing against Trump, I don't know.
The BBC and other media are the natural enemies of such groups.The area to watch is Christian Nationalism, again feeding on the notion
The problems are political rather than theological and are perhaps
therefore beyond the remit of this newsgroup, but that said, I think
it is reasonable to take the Gospels, read them, and then see how they
measure up to the far-right agenda. To me, they seem to be opposites.
this is (or more correctly was) a Christian nation. Both TR and DT are professed Christians but I see little fruit that convinces me of genuine conversion.
(1) I am not against evangelist wing per se, but Christian Nationalism
is a greater danger to society, and certainly to those who practice
other faiths, the Muslims in particular.
But seriously, what an absolutely bigoted view to have on an
organisation.-a The BBC isn't perfect, and in recent years it has had
more than it's fair share of controversy, but to completely dismiss it's output because you think it's all about homosexuality, left wing bias
and wokeness is a ridiculous stance imo.
There's thousands of BBC programmes that don't fit your narrative.
I would suggest homosexuality is treated no more differently by the BBC
than other TV channels.
As an aside, one wonders why you read the gospels, it contains way more
left wing bias and wokeness than any TV programme does.
We live in a world where it has become VERY clear that the greatest
threat to the world comes from the far-right and their aim to dismantle
the checks and balances of society to carry out their selfish aims unchecked.
We're seeing what happened in the USA when such groups get control, and
we need to be on our guard to ensure that similar criminal elements do
not gain control here.
The BBC and other media are the natural enemies of such groups.
The problems are political rather than theological and are perhapsI doubt that any political party will measure up to the teachings of the gospel.
therefore beyond the remit of this newsgroup, but that said, I think it
is reasonable to take the Gospels, read them, and then see how they
measure up to the far-right agenda. To me, they seem to be opposites.
It is mooted that the Government might replace the TV licence with a broadband tax. I'm in favour, as streaming is very much the way forward,
and people but a charge of -u11 a month (again mooted) seems to me to be
too high.
(1) I am not against evangelist wing per se, but Christian Nationalism
is a greater danger to society, and certainly to those who practice
other faiths, the Muslims in particular.
On 26/09/2026 12:25, John wrote:
It is mooted that the Government might replace the TV licence with a
broadband tax. I'm in favour, as streaming is very much the way
forward, and people but a charge of -u11 a month (again mooted) seems
to me to be too high.
Yes, I saw that proposal too. I really see no reason why I should have
to pay for propaganda and entertainment that I do not support or use.
The government already takes taxes on what we pay for our broadband (VAT).
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
On 27/09/2026 16:39, John wrote:
(1) I am not against evangelist wing per se, but Christian Nationalism
is a greater danger to society, and certainly to those who practice
other faiths, the Muslims in particular.
Like you, I have the gravest doubts regarding any union of church and
state.
On the other hand, knowing that Muslims would not hesitate to impose
their beliefs and practises on us if they got the chance, I view a
threat to Muslims in Britain with a degree of equanimity.
God bless,I've found the town you refer to, Hamtramck, near Michigan. whilst pride
Kendall K. Down
P.S. A few weeks back there was a report (on YouTube, I think) about
some very woke town in America that happily elected a wholly Muslim town council. Almost the first thing the council did was order the removal of
all rainbow flags and symbols followed by separate toilets for men and
women and started to encourage certain dress standards for women when
the report went out.
On 27/09/2026 07:12, Timreason wrote:
We live in a world where it has become VERY clear that the greatest
threat to the world comes from the far-right and their aim to
dismantle the checks and balances of society to carry out their
selfish aims unchecked.
That is certainly the case in America, though whether it is the
Republicans who want that or merely Donald Trump I am not sure. Here in Britain I see no signs that Kemi has any such aims and am much more
worried about Burnham and his thought police.
We're seeing what happened in the USA when such groups get control,
and we need to be on our guard to ensure that similar criminal
elements do not gain control here.
I agree.
The BBC and other media are the natural enemies of such groups.
They are the enemies of such groups so long as they are on the right. I haven't seen overmuch condemnation of Burnham's thought police.
Fair point, but would such a thing work anyway? I read a book onceThe problems are political rather than theological and are perhaps
therefore beyond the remit of this newsgroup, but that said, I think
it is reasonable to take the Gospels, read them, and then see how they
measure up to the far-right agenda. To me, they seem to be opposites.
I doubt that any political party will measure up to the teachings of the gospel.
On 26/09/2026 12:48, John wrote:
But seriously, what an absolutely bigoted view to have on an
organisation.-a The BBC isn't perfect, and in recent years it has had
more than it's fair share of controversy, but to completely dismiss
it's output because you think it's all about homosexuality, left wing
bias and wokeness is a ridiculous stance imo.
You may not have noticed it, but I stopped listening when every single
news programme included at least one story about homosexuals, either praising them in some way or deploring prejudice against them. Every programme on TV featured homosexuals sooner or later. There was a comedy about Indians that I enjoyed (when iPlayer was free) but in its second season it introduced a homosexual imam - entirely unrealistic and not
even terribly funny, but homosexual propaganda aimed at the Muslim
audience.
There's thousands of BBC programmes that don't fit your narrative.
I remember reading a statement by some BBC reporter that when he was
working it was almost de rigeur to be a homosexual if you wanted to be employed. He was, he averred, one of the exceptions.
Haha, Quelle surprise that Jesus loves even "them". Maybe you should too?I would suggest homosexuality is treated no more differently by the
BBC than other TV channels.
That is entirely possible - makes me thankful that I eschew all such media.
As an aside, one wonders why you read the gospels, it contains way
more left wing bias and wokeness than any TV programme does.
Really? I must have missed the bit where Jesus said "For God so love the world that He gave His only begotten Child, that whosoever believeth in
Them might have eternal life".
I wouldn't class Kemi or the Conservatives as far right in the way Tim outlines above, but certainly Reform and Restore would fit in that
category.
Really? You must be living in a bubble, there is a great deal of
animosity towards Muslims on social media, fuelled by far right activists.
As for your other claim, there's not a shred of evidence to suggest this is/could be true.-a I've met several Muslims over the years, not one has tried to impose their beliefs on me. Whilst I disagree with their
ideology, the ones I've met have been decent people.-a Their charitable deeds are also noteworthy.
I've found the town you refer to, Hamtramck, near Michigan. whilst pride flags are banned, along with ethnic and political flags, I can't find
any reference to your other two claims.
I note your first paragraph above, but am surprised you find it objectionable.-a As for the pride flags, Reform have done exactly theYou are correct that I don't find it objectionable, whether done by
same over here in councils they run.
I wouldn't class Kemi or the Conservatives as far right in the way Tim outlines above, but certainly Reform and Restore would fit in that
category.
The second time you've mentioned Burnham's thought police. Is this
something you've dreamt up or do you have credible evidence that you can
be arrested for what you think?-a Obviously if you carry acts out based
on your thinking that may well lead to your arrest.
Fair point, but would such a thing work anyway?-a I read a book once
called In the Tomorrow by Michael Stamp, about a community where only Christians lived.-a A sound principle, but unfortunately, with the best
will in the world, couldn't be achieved.
The danger is that the Conservative Party may be tempted to form a
coalition with one of those two extremist groups. That would be both a disaster for the Conservative Party and the country as a whole, IMO.
As far as the Left goes, the Greens are more extreme than many people realise, and they are Republicans which I don't think many of their supporters realise, they keep that bit very low-key.As someone who reads the news, I am aware of just how obnoxious the
I think you're referring to Goodness Gracious Me, but it was a gay son,
not an Imam.
No doubt you also watched Goodnight Sweetheart, then
stopped watching when Noel Coward was introduced as a character.
And you believed it?-a The gay population is roughly 4%. Are you
suggesting that the BBC employs 90% or more of them?
Haha, Quelle surprise that Jesus loves even "them". Maybe you should too?
The BBC isn't just about propaganda and you can pick and choose what you want to watch.-a More pertinent to you-a would be documentaries and the like.-a BBC 4 in particular I find can be really good in that respect.
True, but we pay VAT on most things, so not a tax on broadband per seI know, but why should broadband be singled out for a special tax?
Really? You must be living in a bubble, there is a great deal of
animosity towards Muslims on social media, fuelled by far right activists.
As for your other claim, there's not a shred of evidence to suggest this is/could be true. I've met several Muslims over the years, not one has tried to impose their beliefs on me. Whilst I disagree with their
ideology, the ones I've met have been decent people. Their charitable
deeds are also noteworthy.
On 29/09/2026 11:41, John wrote:
I wouldn't class Kemi or the Conservatives as far right in the way Tim
outlines above, but certainly Reform and Restore would fit in that
category.
I note that in his maiden speech as prime minister to the Labour
conference, Burnham gave "electoral reform" as one of his aims. That, of course, is Labour-speak for proportional representation and giving the
vote to 5-year olds (or whatever the proposal is).
The second time you've mentioned Burnham's thought police. Is this
something you've dreamt up or do you have credible evidence that you
can be arrested for what you think?-a Obviously if you carry acts out
based on your thinking that may well lead to your arrest.
You know very well that a number of people have been arrested and
imprisoned for exercising their right to free speech.
On 29/09/2026 11:58, John wrote:
I think you're referring to Goodness Gracious Me, but it was a gay
son, not an Imam.
You could be right on both points.
No doubt you also watched Goodnight Sweetheart, then stopped watching
when Noel Coward was introduced as a character.
No, I don't usually watch TV dramas, but very likely I would have
reacted as you suggest.
So, if someone describes themselves as them, rather than he or she, theyHaha, Quelle surprise that Jesus loves even "them". Maybe you should too?
You clearly are not as familiar with John 3:16 as you ought to be.
On 29/09/2026 11:26, John wrote:
Really? You must be living in a bubble, there is a great deal of
animosity towards Muslims on social media, fuelled by far right
activists.
Not all animosity towards Muslims is unreasonable.
As for your other claim, there's not a shred of evidence to suggest
this is/could be true.-a I've met several Muslims over the years, not
one has tried to impose their beliefs on me. Whilst I disagree with
their ideology, the ones I've met have been decent people.-a Their
charitable deeds are also noteworthy.
You obviously have not been keeping up to date with the news, which
several times has featured Muslims forming "sharia patrols" to order
women in their suburb to "cover up" or protesting against the sale of alcohol, and other manifestations of Muslim law. In fact, there was
comment on this newsgroup about a policewoman who, for once, did not
favour Muslims over Christians but defended the right of a street
preacher to preach in a Muslim part of town.
I've found the town you refer to, Hamtramck, near Michigan. whilst
pride flags are banned, along with ethnic and political flags, I can't
find any reference to your other two claims.
Given the assiduity with which you follow the news (as evidenced above)
your failure to find something that contradicts your prejudices is not surprising.
There are a minority of Muslims who take their religion to extremes, but unlike you I don't tar all of them with the same brush. I'm sure youI note your first paragraph above, but am surprised you find it
objectionable.-a As for the pride flags, Reform have done exactly the
same over here in councils they run.
You are correct that I don't find it objectionable, whether done by
Muslims or by Reform. I merely cite it to show that your pro-Muslim enthusiasm is rather misplaced.
On 29/09/2026 16:48, Timreason wrote:
The danger is that the Conservative Party may be tempted to form a
coalition with one of those two extremist groups. That would be both a
disaster for the Conservative Party and the country as a whole, IMO.
Would it be more of a disaster than a continued Labour government? A
very moot point. Mind you, it is hardly likely to be more of a disaster
than the alliance with the Liberal Party a few years back.
On what grounds would it be reasonable?
You make it sound like this is a common occurrence on British streets,
it is a rarity.
There are a minority of Muslims who take their religion to extremes, but unlike you I don't tar all of them with the same brush.-a I'm sure you wouldn't like me calling you a Paedo simply there are more Paedo
Christians than the national average.
It was certainly a disaster for the liberal party, they were decimated
in the 2015 elections, and rightly so (and I say that as someone who
chooses between the Libdems and Labour at each General Election)
The main damage was done between 2010 and 2019. We had austerity for the first 5 years, and the slogan was we're all in it together. It baffles
me that the Conservatives went from an -u800 billion deficit in 2010, to
a -u1.7 trillion by 2019.
Genuine question, was there anything you liked in the speech?
You can't be locked up for free speech, you can be locked up for sayingYour argument might be acceptable were it not for the two-tier policing
or doing something that breaks the law. A typical example would be
holding up a placard saying I support Palestinian ******. which is a proscribed group.-a With free speech comes a responsibility not to cross
the boundary.
It was a comedy. The main character was a man who went back in time to
1940. He cheated on his present day wife with a woman from the war, had
a son out of wedlock and became a bigamist.-a If you are true to your Christian morals one would hope you would have stopped watching when he cheated on his wife.-a Brilliant comedy never the less.
So, if someone describes themselves as them, rather than he or she, they
are excluded from the Kingdom?-a What a lovely God you worship!!
So, if someone describes themselves as them, rather than he or she, they
are excluded from the Kingdom?-a What a lovely God you worship!!
The austerity was because the Conservatives were trying to overcome the damage done by Labour (who famously left a note saying, "There's no
money" for their Conservative successors). I am surprised at the figures
you quote.
On 30/09/2026 00:43, John wrote:You didn't answer the question but God so loved the world that *whoever* believes shall not perish etc
So, if someone describes themselves as them, rather than he or she,
they are excluded from the Kingdom?-a What a lovely God you worship!!
As I said, you display your ignorance of John 3:16 every time you open
your mouth.
On 30/09/2026 00:43, John wrote:I've just replied to Ken before seeing this. Great minds think alike :)
So, if someone describes themselves as them, rather than he or she,
they are excluded from the Kingdom?-a What a lovely God you worship!!
Indeed, a better pronoun for God might well be 'They'.
On 29/09/2026 23:59, John wrote:
On what grounds would it be reasonable?
Bombs on the underground?
You make it sound like this is a common occurrence on British streets,
it is a rarity.
It may be a rarity now, but 1. it is an indication that at least some Muslims do want to change our Western way of life; 2. unless it is
nipped in the bud, it could quickly become widespread.
There are a minority of Muslims who take their religion to extremes,
but unlike you I don't tar all of them with the same brush.-a I'm sure
you wouldn't like me calling you a Paedo simply there are more Paedo
Christians than the national average.
What is "extremes"? Obviously planting bombs in synagogues is extreme,
but what about insisting that your wife and daughters wear a hijab? What about insisting that your daughter accept an arranged marriage to her Pakistani cousin she has never met? What about going around in the
clothes that were suitable for your backward village in the Punjab
instead of shirt and trousers like everyone else in town?
You may wish to claim that such things are not "extreme" but at the very least they show that you refuse to assimilate to this country.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
On 29/09/2026 23:59, John wrote:
On what grounds would it be reasonable?
Bombs on the underground?
You make it sound like this is a common occurrence on British streets,
it is a rarity.
It may be a rarity now, but 1. it is an indication that at least some Muslims do want to change our Western way of life; 2. unless it is
nipped in the bud, it could quickly become widespread.
There are a minority of Muslims who take their religion to extremes,
but unlike you I don't tar all of them with the same brush.-a I'm sure
you wouldn't like me calling you a Paedo simply there are more Paedo
Christians than the national average.
What is "extremes"? Obviously planting bombs in synagogues is extreme,
but what about insisting that your wife and daughters wear a hijab?
What about insisting that your daughter accept an arranged marriage to her Pakistani cousin she has never met? What about going around in theIf clothing makes you extreme then I feel sorry for you.
clothes that were suitable for your backward village in the Punjab
instead of shirt and trousers like everyone else in town?
You may wish to claim that such things are not "extreme" but at the very least they show that you refuse to assimilate to this country.
On 30/09/2026 00:17, John wrote:That old chestnut. The crash of 2008 was caused by lenders dishing out mortgages willy nilly to those who couldn't really afford it, mainly in America. Look up sub prime lending.
It was certainly a disaster for the liberal party, they were decimated
in the 2015 elections, and rightly so (and I say that as someone who
chooses between the Libdems and Labour at each General Election)
Indeed.
The main damage was done between 2010 and 2019. We had austerity for
the first 5 years, and the slogan was we're all in it together. It
baffles me that the Conservatives went from an -u800 billion deficit in
2010, to a -u1.7 trillion by 2019.
The austerity was because the Conservatives were trying to overcome the damage done by Labour (who famously left a note saying, "There's no
money" for their Conservative successors). I am surprised at the figures
you quote.
On 30/09/2026 00:28, John wrote:
Genuine question, was there anything you liked in the speech?
I didn't listen to it, just saw a summary somewhere. There was mention
of leasehold reform, which may be a step in the right direction.
Personally I think that leasehold should be abolished, at least where it requires the payment of annual fees.
Lucy Connolly and Ricky Jones by any chance?You can't be locked up for free speech, you can be locked up for
saying or doing something that breaks the law. A typical example would
be holding up a placard saying I support Palestinian ******. which is
a proscribed group.-a With free speech comes a responsibility not to
cross the boundary.
Your argument might be acceptable were it not for the two-tier policing
and enforcement. A white person sent to prison for saying something that could be interpreted as incitement, a black person ignored for saying
almost exactly the same thing (but in reverse).
My wife generally wears 'modest' clothing. (We have a Christian friend
who does the same.)
The most orthodox Jews try to get the kids married off in their late
teens, and quite often through arranged introductions. We do tend to
avoid cousins, even distant ones, though. As to clothing, I suggest you
go to Stamford Hill on a Saturday morning.
I hardly ever wear long trousers. You might think me eccentric, but I
don't think you'd feel threatened by my wearing shorts.
You don't drink beer, Ken, so you're resisting assimilation?He he! Nonsense, I'm just anticipating Generation Z, which has turned
You said "Not all animosity towards Muslims is unreasonable"-a that was
four of them, add in maybe another 15-20 and you have the total
terrorism carried out by Muslims in this country in almost 20 years.
These Muslims have been radicalised, yet you want to paint a picture
that Muslims are dangerous, based on a teeny weeny majority.
Muslims represent about 8% of our society, which is about 6 million. I
doubt even 1% pose the dangers you are fearful of.
Head coverings were required of Christian wives, still is if you take a literalist view of the bible.-a For Muslims, I think it's more cultural,
and is a choice from what I understand (ICBW) If you had said the Niqab
I may have agreed with you, but that is extremely rare and only by by
those from more strict Islamic countries.
If clothing makes you extreme then I feel sorry for you.
That old chestnut. The crash of 2008 was caused by lenders dishing out mortgages willy nilly to those who couldn't really afford it, mainly in America.-a Look up sub prime lending.The sub-prime scandal exacerbated things.
I agree, and I think that's the eventual aim, but we will see a drastic reduction to a a couple of hundred a year in the meantime.
If so, firstly the police prosecuted in both cases, so I'm not quite
sure why you're blaming them.
Secondly, the white person admitted they were guilty of incitement and jailed accordingly, the brown person pleaded not guilty and was
acquitted by a jury of 12 people good and true.-a It was explained to you when you last grumbled about it why the brown person said what he said.
If the skin colour had been reversed I'm fairly sure you would have said
the brown person got their just desserts and it was right for the white person to be acquitted.
Any other examples Ken?
You didn't answer the question but God so loved the world that *whoever* believes shall not perish etc
Believing you are non binary, even if wrong, would hardly exclude
someone receiving eternal life if they believe in Jesus and follow His teachings.
But remind me, what gender is God, and is "He" wrong for identifying as male.
Indeed, a better pronoun for God might well be 'They'.Or "It". Nevertheless, God chose to reveal Himself as male and I don't
Yes. :)I hardly ever wear long trousers. You might think me eccentric, but I
don't think you'd feel threatened by my wearing shorts.
Definitely eccentric in Britain! You wear shorts in winter?
On 30/09/2026 19:03, Kendall K. Down wrote:
I hardly ever wear long trousers. You might think me eccentric, but I
don't think you'd feel threatened by my wearing shorts.
Definitely eccentric in Britain! You wear shorts in winter?Yes. :)
On 30/09/2026 17:10, John wrote:
You said "Not all animosity towards Muslims is unreasonable"-a that was
four of them, add in maybe another 15-20 and you have the total
terrorism carried out by Muslims in this country in almost 20 years.
These Muslims have been radicalised, yet you want to paint a picture
that Muslims are dangerous, based on a teeny weeny majority.
Well, I would agree with you about the majority and thank you for acknowledging it.
Muslims represent about 8% of our society, which is about 6 million. I
doubt even 1% pose the dangers you are fearful of.
For a group that is only 8% of the nation, they make an awful lot of noise.
a literalist view of the bible.-a For Muslims, I think it's more
cultural, and is a choice from what I understand (ICBW) If you had
said the Niqab I may have agreed with you, but that is extremely rare
and only by by those from more strict Islamic countries.
Just because it is cultural does not mean that it is acceptable.
Actually, I agree what women should have the right to wear a niqab or
even a burkha if they want to, but that is the catch. Do they want to,
or is some man forcing them to wear it? Perhaps some recent arrival in
her forties is so conditioned that she wants to cover up - but then the daughters go to school, see white girls free as birds and want to dress
like them and father and brothers murder them in consequence.
Well yes, although it's not a Nazi uniform, I think its meant toIf clothing makes you extreme then I feel sorry for you.
Silly man. What about people on the far right wearing nazi uniforms? If
you can't see that clothing is the outworking of an inner state of mind
then I have small regard for your intellect.
On 30/09/2026 12:39, John wrote:
You didn't answer the question but God so loved the world that
*whoever* believes shall not perish etc
But that was not the word I changed to "them" in my parody version.
Believing you are non binary, even if wrong, would hardly exclude
someone receiving eternal life if they believe in Jesus and follow His
teachings.
Believing that you are non-binary might not, but such a belief usually
leads to immoral actions - and they very well might exclude.
Fair point. As an aside, I have a question I was musing on today, areBut remind me, what gender is God, and is "He" wrong for identifying
as male.
God has chosen to reveal Himself as male and I see no reason why we
should pretend to know better and use either "she" or "them" for God.
Oooops, you knew I meant minority.
Far from it Ken, the vast majority just want to live in peace.
Honour killings, certainly in this country, are extremely rare.
Well yes, although it's not a Nazi uniform,-a I think its meant to
represent the blackshirts of the 1930's.-a So would you also say the
armed services are extreme, the Salvation Army, security guards, heck
even the Asda staff?-a In other words, it's the intent. A woman wearing a Niqab or a burka is no threat to you in the slightest.
"Really? I must have missed the bit where Jesus said "For God so love
the world that He gave His only begotten Child, that whosoever believeth
in Them might have eternal life""
No dishonesty on my part, I picked up on your altered text. If I misunderstood what you meant please explain.
Even those who choose a partner of the opposite sex can be celibate.
Strangely we don't see you raging against people living together,who probably are sexually sinning, or those who are in adultery, who
definitely are sinning sexually.-a Of course, the bible also says what
the world gets up to is none of your business, so stop judging when
you're not supposed to.
The angels who had sex with the daughters of men weren't sexless were they?-a Still, it was merely a musing, sorry I spoke.
in my present world view Politics and Theology operate in a frameworkCertainly I do not share your belief that all evils in the world are due
only to serve a third abstract structure, which to troll Kendall I can characterise as "banking". since it supports both.
* Timreason <119ac3l$13i0l$1@dont-email.me> :
Wrote on Sun, 27 Sep 2026 07:12:04 +0100:
We live in a world where it has become VERY clear that the greatest>> threat to the world comes from the far-right and their aim to
dismantle the checks and balances of society to carry out their
selfish aims unchecked.
I think the fact that you are being nudged into taking this position is
a result of targetted propaganda investments, I can say this with
confidence because I see that the same propaganda investents produce
your counterpart who hold the "liburels" and accuse them of the same
category of intent and agenda.
I know it wasn't, you changed the word Him to them, which was a dig at
the non binary community.
Is a non binary person more in danger of sinning than the rest of us?
Besides of which, doesn't Christian doctrine teach that you are only excluded if you've not believed in God's only Son?-a Take it as read that this will include a changed attitude to sinning.
Fair point.-a As an aside, I have a question I was musing on today, are there female Angels in Heaven or is it a completely male hierarchy?
On 01/10/2026 20:43, John wrote:
I know it wasn't, you changed the word Him to them, which was a dig at
the non binary community.
In which case all your fussing over words that I did not change implies
a degree of dishonesty in your arguments.
Is a non binary person more in danger of sinning than the rest of us?
It would appear so. "Let every man have his own wife," St Paul advised,
but if you are busy trying to find out whether you want a male or female partner you are hardly likely to be living a celibate or moral lifestyle.
Besides of which, doesn't Christian doctrine teach that you are only
excluded if you've not believed in God's only Son?-a Take it as read
that this will include a changed attitude to sinning.
Belief which does not lead to actions is a bit of empty posing. Jesus
was quite scathing about those who loudly say "Lord! Lord!" but who do
not do God's will.
Fair point.-a As an aside, I have a question I was musing on today, are
there female Angels in Heaven or is it a completely male hierarchy?
Or, more likely, a society in which sex and gender has no role.
Do you worry about the sex of the robots that weld your car together? Or
the sex of your robot vacuum cleaner? The questions are ridiculous. Sex
or gender simply do not enter into the matter. In the same way, it is possible that the angels are entirely sexless, just like cars or
bicycles or automatic vacuum cleaners.
On 01/10/2026 20:20, John wrote:
Oooops, you knew I meant minority.
But that minority is a real problem. Look at the idiot who stabbed the
pilot and attempted to crash a plane the day before yesterday. It's not
just that the fellow had a brain storm; it's part of his Muslim ideology.
Far from it Ken, the vast majority just want to live in peace.
Given the current wave of incidents resulting from the war in Gaza, I suspect the majority is smaller than you appear to think. And their definition of "live in peace" may not be exactly the same as yours.
Honour killings, certainly in this country, are extremely rare.
You mean, about 8%?
Well yes, although it's not a Nazi uniform,-a I think its meant to
represent the blackshirts of the 1930's.-a So would you also say the
armed services are extreme, the Salvation Army, security guards, heck
even the Asda staff?-a In other words, it's the intent. A woman wearing
a Niqab or a burka is no threat to you in the slightest.
No, but the fact that she has been forced to wear it under pain of death
is a threat to our society, if not to me personally.
On 02/10/2026 12:38, John wrote:
"Really? I must have missed the bit where Jesus said "For God so love
the world that He gave His only begotten Child, that whosoever
believeth in Them might have eternal life""
Indeed - and you'll notice that I only altered one single word.
No dishonesty on my part, I picked up on your altered text. If I
misunderstood what you meant please explain.
You then criticised me for a variety of reasons, but never for the word "Them" instead of "Him" for the Son of God.
Even those who choose a partner of the opposite sex can be celibate.
Yes. So?
Strangely we don't see you raging against people living together,who
probably are sexually sinning, or those who are in adultery, who
definitely are sinning sexually.-a Of course, the bible also says what
the world gets up to is none of your business, so stop judging when
you're not supposed to.
As I always say when this subject comes up, as soon as we get people defending adulterers or any of the other things you mention, and
insisting that adulterers should be allowed become priests or bishops or
to be given full acceptance in church while continuing their adultery,
you will find me condemning them just as strongly.
The fact is that everyone is happy to condemn adulterers or paedophiles
or any of the others, but active homosexuals must be taken in and loved
and given every right they may dream of.
The angels who had sex with the daughters of men weren't sexless were
they?-a Still, it was merely a musing, sorry I spoke.
Where does it say that angels had sex with the daughters of men?
But even if it was angels, angels are ministering spirits with noYikes, I thought you believed Genesis was literal? If it wasn't a
natural physical shape, but at times they are allowed to adopt a
physical shape so as to appear to men. Seeing as we are speculating, is there any reason why that manifestation should be male rather than
female? Is this, perhaps, the origin of the incubus and succubus mythology?
On 29/09/2026 16:42, Madhu wrote:
What he has written elsewhere, not only on another newsgroup, but also
on here.
Repeat something often enough...
Oooops, you knew I meant minority.
But that minority is a real problem. Look at the idiot who stabbed the pilot and attempted to crash a plane the day before yesterday. It's
not just that the fellow had a brain storm; it's part of his Muslim ideology.
It may well be part of *his* ideology, but it certainly isn't what Islam teaches.
In article <119qup7$31an1$1@dont-email.me>,
John <megane.06@gmail.com> wrote:
Oooops, you knew I meant minority.
But that minority is a real problem. Look at the idiot who stabbed
the pilot and attempted to crash a plane the day before yesterday.
It's not just that the fellow had a brain storm; it's part of his
Muslim ideology.
It may well be part of *his* ideology, but it certainly isn't what
Islam teaches.
John, you really need to read the Quar'an and the Hadiths.
I will post some quotes for you when I have time later.
It may well be part of *his* ideology, but it certainly isn't what Islam teaches.
You will always have extremists. What's the percentage of Muslims
engaging in terrorism?
Estimated between 12 and 15 a year in this country and 5000 world wide.
How is it a threat to our society?-a Whilst I disagree that women should
be forced to wear either, I don't think it's enforced by any other
Muslim country other than Afghanistan.
Repeat something often enough...Even so, I think it would have to be far more persuasive than Madhu has
I answered this in another newsgroup. I know the history of my own life,That is a rather extreme statement! Unless you are counting Putin's
you OTOH do not. I don't know how old you are, but I remember how things were in the 70s and the rampant racism and groups like the National
Front and the racist 'skinheads'. In my parents' time, Germany had
Nazism and the rise of Hitler, and here in Britain there was Oswald
Mosley and his 'Blackshirts', the "British Union of Fascists".
Fortunately the British people rejected them. But such beliefs have not
gone away. The greatest threat to world peace is the Far Right.
Two actually, and added a third.-a Child should be Son, them should be
Him, and you added might.
Your memory is short, it was precisely the word change to Them that I
picked up on, hence why I replied "Haha, Quelle surprise that Jesus
loves even "them". Maybe you should too?"
You're the one bringing up transgenderism and homosexuality, every
single time, without any prompting from others on this forum! When you
do raise it, it is rare it's regarding those inside the church.
It is accepted by society.
Regarding homosexuality, I think if you were to do a honest study of the contentious verses, you would find it's more to do with temple worship
and men regarding young males as fair game, than same sex people falling
in love with each other.
Who do you think the Sons of God were?
Yikes, I thought you believed Genesis was literal?-a If it wasn't a
physical union, I doubt they would be able to have offspring.
On 03/10/2026 07:54, Timreason wrote:
I answered this in another newsgroup. I know the history of my own life,
you OTOH do not. I don't know how old you are, but I remember how things
were in the 70s and the rampant racism and groups like the National
Front and the racist 'skinheads'. In my parents' time, Germany had
Nazism and the rise of Hitler, and here in Britain there was Oswald
Mosley and his 'Blackshirts', the "British Union of Fascists".
Fortunately the British people rejected them. But such beliefs have not
gone away. The greatest threat to world peace is the Far Right.
That is a rather extreme statement! Unless you are counting Putin's
Russia as "far right"?
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far >right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under >Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a >demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.
On Tue, 6 Oct 2026 06:41:37 +0100, "Kendall K. Down" <kendallkdown@googlemail.com> wrote:
On 03/10/2026 07:54, Timreason wrote:
I answered this in another newsgroup. I know the history of my own life, >>> you OTOH do not. I don't know how old you are, but I remember how things >>> were in the 70s and the rampant racism and groups like the National
Front and the racist 'skinheads'. In my parents' time, Germany had
Nazism and the rise of Hitler, and here in Britain there was Oswald
Mosley and his 'Blackshirts', the "British Union of Fascists".
Fortunately the British people rejected them. But such beliefs have not
gone away. The greatest threat to world peace is the Far Right.
That is a rather extreme statement! Unless you are counting Putin's
Russia as "far right"?
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.
Mark
On 03/10/2026 15:10, John wrote:
Two actually, and added a third.-a Child should be Son, them should be
Him, and you added might.
You are right about "child"; "might" was in place of the whole phrase
about "should not perish".
Your memory is short, it was precisely the word change to Them that I
picked up on, hence why I replied "Haha, Quelle surprise that Jesus
loves even "them". Maybe you should too?"
Which was an extremely silly comment seeing as "them" was referring to
Jesus Himself.
You're the one bringing up transgenderism and homosexuality, every
single time, without any prompting from others on this forum! When you
do raise it, it is rare it's regarding those inside the church.
No? I have encountered both inside churches and am certainly aware of efforts to make both acceptable, even in church leaders.
It is accepted by society.
Just because something is accepted by society does not make it right. Society is sinful according to what the Bible teaches.
Regarding homosexuality, I think if you were to do a honest study of
the contentious verses, you would find it's more to do with temple
worship and men regarding young males as fair game, than same sex
people falling in love with each other.
What a load of rubbish. It is true that sex was part of heathen worship
and reforming kings did away with male prostitutes and destroyed the
places where heterosexual activities were conducted (the groves and high places) but that does not mean that heterosexual adultery or promiscuity
or homosexual sex are therefore allowed.
Who do you think the Sons of God were?
Christians? (Or their equivalent back then.)
They were certainly physical on Earth. Heck, one of them even wrestledYikes, I thought you believed Genesis was literal?-a If it wasn't a
physical union, I doubt they would be able to have offspring.
Certainly the union described in Genesis was physical, I merely disagree that it involved non-physical creatures.
On 03/10/2026 14:08, John wrote:
It may well be part of *his* ideology, but it certainly isn't what
Islam teaches.
Have you read the Qur'an? Islam was founded on violence against non- Muslims, all through history it has promoted violence against non-
Muslims (jihad) and it continues to promote violence against non-
Muslims. It is encouraging that *some* modern Muslims are attempting to change the meaning of "jihad" to mean some sort of internal struggle
against sin or something, and perhaps one day they will succeed in the
same way as we have turned the word "crusade" into some innocuous, but
they are still a minority.
would, > in fact, deplore such an action.)You will always have extremists. What's the percentage of Muslims
engaging in terrorism?
It depends where you are. In Gaza it is probably close to 100% - did you
see the report where parents in Gaza are lamenting that Hamas has turned
a generation of school children into anti-Israel fanatics? In Somalia or northern Nigeria the percentage is high. In Britain probably small -
though potentially large. Try burning a Bible outside any church and
then try burning a Qur'an outside any mosque. The response may surprise
you, it would not surprise me.
(Note: I am not recommending that anyone burn any holy books. I
Estimated between 12 and 15 a year in this country and 5000 world wide.
So that's 12-15 innocent young women murdered every year, not by random violence by someone out of his head on drink or drugs, but by institutionalised misogyny. And you are not horrified?
Incorrect matey. I did double check this before posting. The hijab is enforced in Iran, and no doubt the other countries you mention, but notHow is it a threat to our society?-a Whilst I disagree that women
should be forced to wear either, I don't think it's enforced by any
other Muslim country other than Afghanistan.
Iran. Saudi Arabia. Somalia. Syria. And enforced in parts of just about every other Muslim country. Interestingly, there are a very few Muslim majority countries which have banned the hijab or niqab because they can
see how it is a threat to their society, while sweet liberal John closes
his eyes tight and (probably) votes Green.
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 09:42:20 +0100, I <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:Mark, did you get the email I sent you a couple of weeks ago (17th
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far
right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under
Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a
demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.
I meant "horseshoe", obviously. Meh.
On 06/10/2026 06:36, Kendall K. Down wrote:
On 03/10/2026 14:08, John wrote:
It may well be part of *his* ideology, but it certainly isn't what
Islam teaches.
Have you read the Qur'an? Islam was founded on violence against non-
Muslims, all through history it has promoted violence against non-
Muslims (jihad) and it continues to promote violence against non-
Muslims. It is encouraging that *some* modern Muslims are attempting
to change the meaning of "jihad" to mean some sort of internal
struggle against sin or something, and perhaps one day they will
succeed in the same way as we have turned the word "crusade" into some
innocuous, but they are still a minority.
Violence in the Qur'an was in connection with the wards (sorry, that should have been wars)
Even so, I think it would have to be far more persuasive than Madhu
has so far managed. Banks and bankers certainly wield great power and
I am glad that they are regulated, but I doubt they are the malign
forces he (or she) imagines.
Violence in the Qur'an was in connection with the wards at that time. Of course the bible can also be taken out of context.-a If what you say is true, why do 90% of Muslims just want to serve their God and live in peace?-a Again I ask, do we disparage Christianity because some don't
live up to it's ideals?
They seem to be more respectful to their holy book than Christians are.
Both are offensive of course, and like you, I don't condone either.
75 people are killed by domestic violence each year, not by random
violence by someone out of his head on drink or drugs, but by institutionalised misogyny or misandry. And you are not horrified?
All murder is wrong, and is committed by all race and creed, and all is abhorrent.-a What point were you trying to make by singling out one type
of murder to the exclusion of other types.
Incorrect matey.-a I did double check this before posting. The hijab is enforced in Iran, and no doubt the other countries you mention, but not
the Niqab or Burkha, which is what I was referring to.
Thanks for the compliment by the way, although I don't have much inReally? Jesus seemed pretty extreme about sexual morality, which is
common with the Greens. I do think Jesus would be closer to my ideology
than yours, and I'm not even a Christian!-a You can't get more sweet
liberal than the Sermon on The Mount.
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.Hmmm. If so, there is not so much difference between far left and far
Please tell me why you changed Him to Them?
It is indeed, would you like to point out the verse where you are called
to rail against non Christians LGBT's
If a heterosexual decided they wanted to go with someone of the same
sex, I would say that is changing the natural to unnatural as described
in Romans 1.-a If you've always been a homosexual with no interest in the opposite sex then you haven't.-a In fact the opposite, you are suggesting they change their (to them) natural homosexuality to something unnatual
(to them) unnatural.
So they were all the same humans?-a Why then is there a distinction, and their offspring giants?
They were certainly physical on Earth. Heck, one of them even wrestled
with Jacob.
My pronouns are Him/He.
The point I repeatedly make (to Tim's annoyance) is that the forces of international banking that are shaping the direction that our present
world is converging (to the global kingdom of the antichrist) get their
power from Satan and his money Laundering Angels.
Now you can misrepresent this in any number of ways and state that I'm talking about Jews or I'm calling bankers evil or that I'm calling jews
evil, or whatever other toolbox trope you have been equipped with by
Israeli Propaganda my testimony doesn't change even if you have
succeeded in misrepresenting it to the world.
On 06/10/2026 12:37, Mark Goodge wrote:
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 09:42:20 +0100, I <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>Mark, did you get the email I sent you a couple of weeks ago (17th >September) to good stuff? Nothing to do with ukrc, it was just
wrote:
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far >>> right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under
Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a
demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.
I meant "horseshoe", obviously. Meh.
something I wanted to draw your attention to if you weren't aware.
My pronouns are Him/He.
The point I repeatedly make (to Tim's annoyance)
is that the forces of
international banking that are shaping the direction that our present
world is converging (to the global kingdom of the antichrist) get their
power from Satan and his money Laundering Angels.
Now you can misrepresent this in any number of ways and state that I'm talking about Jews or I'm calling bankers evil or that I'm calling jews
evil, or whatever other toolbox trope you have been equipped with by
Israeli Propaganda my testimony doesn't change even if you have
succeeded in misrepresenting it to the world.
On Tue, 6 Oct 2026 13:47:49 +0100, John <megane.06@gmail.com> wrote:Cheers Mark, I've resent it.
On 06/10/2026 12:37, Mark Goodge wrote:
On Tue, 06 Oct 2026 09:42:20 +0100, I <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> >>> wrote:Mark, did you get the email I sent you a couple of weeks ago (17th
I think most people would consider Russia's current government to be "far >>>> right". The fact that Russia has transitioned from being far left under >>>> Soviet communism to far right under Putin's nationalism is merely a
demonstration of the horsehoe political theory in practice.
I meant "horseshoe", obviously. Meh.
September) to good stuff? Nothing to do with ukrc, it was just
something I wanted to draw your attention to if you weren't aware.
I don't recall seeing it, no. And I can't find it now when looking back. So I'd suggest re-sending it.
Bear in mind that my real email address is mark{at}good-stuff.co.uk rather than the one at the head of this post.
On 06/10/2026 13:15, John wrote:
Please tell me why you changed Him to Them?
Because that's the sort of stupid change you find in the latest gender- neutral NIV.
It is indeed, would you like to point out the verse where you are
called to rail against non Christians LGBT's
Why do non-Christians get a get out of gaol free card? Sin is sin,
whether the perpetrator is Christian or not.
If a heterosexual decided they wanted to go with someone of the same
sex, I would say that is changing the natural to unnatural as
described in Romans 1.-a If you've always been a homosexual with no
interest in the opposite sex then you haven't.-a In fact the opposite,
you are suggesting they change their (to them) natural homosexuality
to something unnatual (to them) unnatural.
Another stupid argument. I presume you oppose artificial legs for those
born without legs, because for them getting around on their bottoms is natural. Similarly you would oppose blocking paedophiles from accessing children because for them, sex with children is natural.
Why you just regurgitate these fatuous arguments put out by homosexuals without thinking them through, I don't know. Does your brain switch off
when homosexuality is mentioned?
So they were all the same humans?-a Why then is there a distinction,
and their offspring giants?
A distinction because one lot were serving God and the other not?
Obviously you haven't read your bible properly (Genesis 18 and 19 for reference)They were certainly physical on Earth. Heck, one of them even wrestled
with Jacob.
Given that every other encounter of humans with angels the angels
refused to even eat human food, the idea that they might engage in human
sex does seem a tad unlikely.
Are you familiar with 1 Corinthians 5:12-13 by any chance.
Because that is the reality. Homosexuals don't harm anyone, unlike the paedophiles you mention.
That guy was never heterosexual, and I've read of other similar tales,
so no, I don't believe my arguments are fatuous, if God be true He would have taken away this man's desire.
It doesn't sound like they were serving God very well, does it?-a Still doesn't explain the giants but hey.
Obviously you haven't read your bible properly (Genesis 18 and 19 for reference)
Here's what I believe: Whether the establishment of the state of Israel
was morally right or wrong in the first place is now a moot point.
Israel has existed for 10 more years than I have, and I'm quite old now.
So the existence of the state of Israel is now a 'Done Deal'. The clock cannot be wound back. Israel now has a right to exist, and nearly every citizen there was born since the founding of the state.
I believe that Israel has the right to defend itself, and to make *proportionate* responses to any attacks. Israel does NOT have the right
to make hugely disproportionate responses of the sort it has made
lately, neither does it have the right to expand its borders.
Palestine should be recognised as a state, and also has a right to exist
and defend itself.
Only a two state solution might work, and Israel needs to accept that,
as well as accepting that expansion is NOT permissible, either by
military force or by illegal settlement.
Palestine will also have to fully accept Israel's right to exist.Unfortunately, although the PEO, which rules in the West Bank, is
On 06/10/2026 23:34, John wrote:
Are you familiar with 1 Corinthians 5:12-13 by any chance.
You mean the passage which calls non-Christians fornicators,
extortioners, drunkards, idolators and so on?
Because that is the reality. Homosexuals don't harm anyone, unlike the
paedophiles you mention.
Leading people to sin and damnation doesn't count as harm? But having
sex with a girl a day before her 18th birthday does?
That guy was never heterosexual, and I've read of other similar tales,
so no, I don't believe my arguments are fatuous, if God be true He
would have taken away this man's desire.
Hmmmm. Your argument is superficially persuasive, but actually wrong. Putting the onus on God to remove something while we cling to it
mentally is never going to work. And giving up what may be a life-long battle is also not God's fault. What did this guy's wife think about him walking out after 40 years of marriage?
No, but their offspring were, how did that happen?It doesn't sound like they were serving God very well, does it?-a Still
doesn't explain the giants but hey.
I think you are getting a bit muddled. "Mighty men ... men of renown"
are not necessarily giants.
Flip me, you don't read the bible properly do you? I sort of understand because you didn't read what I wrote either. SHE LEFT HIM and I never
said it was after 40 years.
Cling to it mentally, are you for real? The guy prayed every day for 40 flipping years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"Whatever you ask in prayer it will be given to you". I accept that this should be in alignment with God's will but don't you think praying away homosexuality if it's a sin IS within God's will?
If God was a true Father would he not take away that desire?-a Luke 11:11 springs to mind.
Hmmm, an interesting observation, maybe Paul should have taken his own advice in my quoted verses when it came to writing Chapter 6?-a Or maybe you've misunderstood Chapter 6. Your God is a bit of a sadist though if
Paul is right. I mean, people can't help being effeminate, can they? I
met one once, lovely guy called Kevin, came across camp but wasn't a homosexual, he just couldn't help his mannerisms.-a Yet, according to
YOUR understanding of 1 Corinthians 6, God wants to send him to hell for being so.
How does having sex with a 17 year old cause harm? (assuming she is a consensual partner? (I guess you meant under the age of 16) and if you
think paedophilia includes having sex with a 15 year old then there must have been a hell of a lot of paedophiles back in t'olden days, because
up until a couple of centuries ago they could be married at 12 (I'm not saying that's right, but they were different times. The age of consent
is 16 in the UK and I agree with that)
Flip me, you don't read the bible properly do you? I sort of understand because you didn't read what I wrote either. SHE LEFT HIM and I never
said it was after 40 years.
Cling to it mentally, are you for real? The guy prayed every day for 40 flipping years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The alternative is you are born either homosexual, and lets not pretend, this affects 4% of people, yet to hear the likes of you and your cronies (not meaning anyone else on the ng) its the biggest sin of all time.
No, but their offspring were, how did that happen?Oh no they weren't.
On 07/10/2026 11:39, John wrote:
Hmmm, an interesting observation, maybe Paul should have taken his own
advice in my quoted verses when it came to writing Chapter 6?-a Or
maybe you've misunderstood Chapter 6. Your God is a bit of a sadist
though if Paul is right. I mean, people can't help being effeminate,
can they? I met one once, lovely guy called Kevin, came across camp
but wasn't a homosexual, he just couldn't help his mannerisms.-a Yet,
according to YOUR understanding of 1 Corinthians 6, God wants to send
him to hell for being so.
I doubt that your understanding of "effeminate" is what Paul meant by
the word "malakos".
How does having sex with a 17 year old cause harm? (assuming she is a
consensual partner? (I guess you meant under the age of 16) and if you
think paedophilia includes having sex with a 15 year old then there
must have been a hell of a lot of paedophiles back in t'olden days,
because up until a couple of centuries ago they could be married at 12
(I'm not saying that's right, but they were different times. The age
of consent is 16 in the UK and I agree with that)
I think that is my point; everyone is down on paedophiles, yet if you
have consensual sex with a girl below the age of consent, you are a paedophile. So "does no harm" is not a valid argument.
Flip me, you don't read the bible properly do you? I sort of
understand because you didn't read what I wrote either. SHE LEFT HIM
and I never said it was after 40 years.
Sorry, I misunderstood what you wrote.
Cling to it mentally, are you for real? The guy prayed every day for
40 flipping years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Like I said, I don't know this guy or anything about him, but as a
general comment, there are people who pray and pray, but do nothing to
help themselves. Someone I knew prayed that God would deliver him from
his smoking habit, but every couple of days went out and bought more cigarettes and was always too busy for smoking cessation programmes. He wanted to wake up some morning with no desire for a cigarette but was
not willing to so anything difficult to achieve the end he professed to desire.
The alternative is you are born either homosexual, and lets not
pretend, this affects 4% of people, yet to hear the likes of you and
your cronies (not meaning anyone else on the ng) its the biggest sin
of all time.
I don't deny that some are born homosexual; some are born bad tempered,
some with a tendency to steal, and so on.
Is it panto season already :-)No, but their offspring were, how did that happen?
Oh no they weren't.
Of course not, but some bibles say that, same as some bibles say
homosexual when that's not what the Greek means.
I'll ask again, what harm does a homosexual do?-a You've said that it
could prevent them attaining eternal life and I get that you regard it
as sin, but if it is, it's the only sin I'm aware of that doesn't harm
his fellow man. (although possibly that could be extended to those
living together or having children out of wedlock)
Well yes, and had my example given in to his desires during that period, whilst still praying earnestly to be released from them, I would wholeheartedly agree with you.
I'm not sure that you are born bad tempered or with a tendency to steal.
To me that's learned behaviour.-a Obviously there are exceptions to the rule.
Oh no they weren't.Is it panto season already :-)
The Nephilim were on the earth in those days, and also afterward, when
the sons of God came in to the daughters of man and they bore children
to them. These were the mighty men who were of old, the men of renown. Genesis 6:4 ESV.
If you think there's a bit of wiggle room there to say these offspring weren't the Nephilim, also have a look at the KJV, which is more explicit."There were giants in the earth in those days; and also after that, when
The greatest threat to world peace is the Far Right.Record number of terrorists now locked up in Britain - the majority
Oh well, if you will use strange translations instead of the divinely inspired KJV
On 08/10/2026 11:44, John wrote:
Of course not, but some bibles say that, same as some bibles say
homosexual when that's not what the Greek means.
Really?
I'll ask again, what harm does a homosexual do?-a You've said that it
could prevent them attaining eternal life and I get that you regard it
as sin, but if it is, it's the only sin I'm aware of that doesn't harm
his fellow man. (although possibly that could be extended to those
living together or having children out of wedlock)
But you are ensuring that your fellow man ends up damned.
Well yes, and had my example given in to his desires during that
period, whilst still praying earnestly to be released from them, I
would wholeheartedly agree with you.
So are you saying that he stopped praying and after that got into a homosexual relationship? If so, then his prayers were being answered!
I'm not sure that you are born bad tempered or with a tendency to
steal. To me that's learned behaviour.-a Obviously there are exceptions
to the rule.
You haven't had much to do with children, then.
"There were giants in the earth in those days; and also after that, whenwhen is the keyword there.
the sons of God came in unto the daughters of men, and they bare
children to them, the same became mighty men which were of old, men of renown."
It is indeed; the children born to the sons of God and daughters of men
were not the giants.
Yes, arsenokoitai means literally male bed
Homosexual has a much wider
meaning to those who are, or want to be, in a relationship with someone exclusively of the same sex. You can be a homosexual without bedding someone.
Arsenokoitai relates to bedding someone of the same sex, which can be
done by a heterosexual person as a means of dominance. The fact that the word malakoi is also there suggests that one plays the dominant role and
one plays the submissive role.
I think this is particularly pertinent to Leviticus, and makes "as with
a woman" more meaningful.
How so?
After 40 years he realised God wasn't going to take his orientation away
so began a relationship with a man. They are still together after 5
years.-a In what way were his prayers answered?
I'm mild mannered (most of the time, so is my son. My wife has a short fuse.-a Are these hard wired from birth?
"There were giants in the earth in those days; and also after that,
when the sons of God came in unto the daughters of men, and they bare
children to them, the same became mighty men which were of old, men of
renown."
It is indeed; the children born to the sons of God and daughters of
men were not the giants.
when is the keyword there.
On 11/10/2026 22:46, John wrote:
Yes, arsenokoitai means literally male bed
No it doesn't - and stop just regurgitating homosexual propaganda that
you have found somewhere.
I agree that the word is "made up", but not in the way you and your
sources appear to think. St Paul used the LXX version of the Old
Testament. Leviticus 20:13 says, "If a man lies with a man, as he lies
with a woman, both have committed an abomination." In the LXX Greek, the phrase "as he lies with a woman" is +++|-a+# +#-U-a+|++++-a +|+++|-a++++ +|-a+++#+|+|++-e
I don't know how competent your Greek is, but +++|-a+# is "like" or "as" and +|-a+++#+|+|++-e is "woman". The remaining two words correspond to "lying with".
-a+#-U-a+|++++-a means "male" but +|+++|-a++ can mean "bed, litter, deposit" so
assuming that +|+++|-a++++ is a verb form, it would be "to bed". So the expression is literally "as a man bedding a woman". So Paul's "made-up"
word is a) a combination of two words from the laws of God which would
be immediately recognised by anyone familiar with the LXX; b) it has a directly sexual connotation (bedding someone); c) a literal translation would be "male bedders".
Homosexual has a much wider meaning to those who are, or want to be,
in a relationship with someone exclusively of the same sex. You can be
a homosexual without bedding someone.
Indeed, but if you are an arsenokoitai you are definitely bedding someone.
Arsenokoitai relates to bedding someone of the same sex, which can be
done by a heterosexual person as a means of dominance. The fact that
the word malakoi is also there suggests that one plays the dominant
role and one plays the submissive role.
I make no comment about your own home life, but even in the good old missionary position, one is dominant (on top!) and one is sub. But
whether it is an expression of dominance or not, it is sexual.
How so?
By leading them into sin.
After 40 years he realised God wasn't going to take his orientation
away so began a relationship with a man. They are still together after
5 years.-a In what way were his prayers answered?
While he was praying I presume he remained faithful to his wife. That, I think, was an answer to his prayers and also to his wife's prayers.
I disagree with your interpretation of the verses, but if we assume"There were giants in the earth in those days; and also after that,
when the sons of God came in unto the daughters of men, and they bare
children to them, the same became mighty men which were of old, men
of renown."
It is indeed; the children born to the sons of God and daughters of
men were not the giants.
when is the keyword there.
Indeed, but "when" refers to "men of renown" not giants.
You've agreed with me, although I should have maybe said male+bed. I
have no issue with you using the term male bedders. That's my point
though, being an arsenokoitai doesn't make you an homosexual.
Going back to those days the women were regarded as property, so I
highly doubt they would assume a dominant role, they were probably told
to shut their eyes and think of Israel!!-a And that's my other point, if
a man lay with a man as if he were a woman, that is treating the malokai
as property, when in them days it was considered taboo.
I'm not telling anyone they should be a homosexual, they either are or
they aren't. it isn't my cup of tea to be fair but by the same token I
don't tell someone they're destined to hell if they are, because I don't believe even you should be doing that, as you accept it's something
they're born with.
As far as I understand he was faithful (he remarried) whilst praying for
God to take away his orientation.-a But if God didn't take away his orientation please tell me how is prayer was answered?
I disagree with your interpretation of the verses,
but if we assumeBecause they were wicked? You can be wicked no matter what your physical height and no matter how clever you are. Being famous (renown) is no
you're right, why did God consider them wicked and destroy them in the flood? Only Noah and his family were considered righteous.
On 12/10/2026 22:42, John wrote:
You've agreed with me, although I should have maybe said male+bed. IApart from some hugely artificial situation that you might dream up, no
have no issue with you using the term male bedders. That's my point
though, being an arsenokoitai doesn't make you an homosexual.
one but a homosexual would be an arseokoite. Are you trying to pretend
that beds can be classified as male or female? You haven't addressed the fact that Paul's word comes directly from the Biblical prohibition on homosexual sex
Going back to those days the women were regarded as property, so I
highly doubt they would assume a dominant role, they were probably
told to shut their eyes and think of Israel!!-a And that's my other
point, if a man lay with a man as if he were a woman, that is treating
the malokai as property, when in them days it was considered taboo.
You're talking rubbish again. Go to Pompeii and you will see pictures of
sex with the woman on top. Read history and you will discover that Roman women could be just as much sexual predators as the men. And who was the dominant partner in Samson and Delilah?
Wow, what a guy!! I know, I'll create some humans to have a desire forI'm not telling anyone they should be a homosexual, they either are or
they aren't. it isn't my cup of tea to be fair but by the same token I
don't tell someone they're destined to hell if they are, because I
don't believe even you should be doing that, as you accept it's
something they're born with.
You can't help what you are born with, but you can help what you do with
it. I was born with a short temper; I can either indulge it and make everyone's life miserable, or I can struggle against it. Which course
would you recommend for a Christian? What do you think would be the
eternal fate of someone who makes no effort to control his/her temper?
As far as I understand he was faithful (he remarried) whilst praying
for God to take away his orientation.-a But if God didn't take away his
orientation please tell me how is prayer was answered?
By helping him to remain faithful to his wife.
On 13/10/2026 06:40, Kendall K. Down wrote:
Go to Pompeii and you will see pictures of
sex with the woman on top. ...
I'm obviously not as familiar as you are with Roman porn mags!
A cheap shot. The pictures in Pompeii are on the walls of the
brothel or have been moved to the national archeological museum
in Naples.
(I've been to both though I can't recall those specific pictures.)I'd post one or two if this newsgroup accepted pictures!
So, if a prisoner beds his fellow cellmate because he's frustrated, but under normal circumstances, he@ heterosexual, does that make him a homosexual?-a No it doesn't, but it does make him an arsenokoite.
I'm obviously not as familiar as you are with Roman porn mags!-a For the Jews, was this the norm though or the exception to the rule?-a That's a
bit like saying because Deborah was a warrior, all Jewish women were warriors.
Wow, what a guy!!-a I know, I'll create some humans to have a desire for
the same sex, but tell them it's a sin to do anything about it.-a What a sadistic God you worship!!
I don't believe God is like that and I don't believe it's a sin for two people of the same sex to be in love and have a physical relationship, despite what you've interpreted 2000+ year old scriptures to say. I
daresay you would have defended slavery and women not having the same
rights as men in church back when it was the norm.
Why not just admit the prayer wasn't answered? God didn't help him to
remain faithful, he chose to remain faithful because he believed it was sinful to go with another man, yet he still had that desire to do so.
If God is the almighty supreme being you claim him to be why didn't He simply take that desire away, was God not capable of doing so? That
would have solved the issue, and I dare say him and his wife would still
be together.
What you're basically saying is that God let this man suffer for 40
years rather than taking away his desire for other men.
I can't for the life of me think why you would want to worship such aBecause I am grateful that He gives me freewill and respects it. After
being, but you do you.
By helping him to remain faithful to his wife.
Why not just admit the prayer wasn't answered? God didn't help him to
remain faithful, he chose to remain faithful because he believed it was sinful to go with another man, yet he still had that desire to do so.
If God is the almighty supreme being you claim him to be why didn't He simply take that desire away, was God not capable of doing so?
On 13/10/2026 15:03, John wrote:
So, if a prisoner beds his fellow cellmate because he's frustrated,
but under normal circumstances, he@ heterosexual, does that make him a
homosexual?-a No it doesn't, but it does make him an arsenokoite.
Hmmm. I can't imagine any circumstances under which I would engage in
sex with another man.
I'm obviously not as familiar as you are with Roman porn mags!
Wow, what a guy!!-a I know, I'll create some humans to have a desire
for the same sex, but tell them it's a sin to do anything about it.
What a sadistic God you worship!!
You have heard of the devil, I presume?
I don't believe God is like that and I don't believe it's a sin for
two people of the same sex to be in love and have a physical
relationship, despite what you've interpreted 2000+ year old
scriptures to say. I daresay you would have defended slavery and women
not having the same rights as men in church back when it was the norm.
If there was something in the Bible commanding slavery and depriving
women of rights, then I might have. As the Bible condemns slavery and encourages women's rights, the answer is No. If you choose to ignore the very clear prohibition of homosexual sex in Scripture, that is something
for which you will have to answer. I suggest you start thinking now;
relying on making it up when face-to-face with the Author of those laws,
may not be sufficient.
Why not just admit the prayer wasn't answered? God didn't help him to
remain faithful, he chose to remain faithful because he believed it
was sinful to go with another man, yet he still had that desire to do so.
Of course God helped him to remain faithful, but God does not commonly change our personalities overnight.
If God is the almighty supreme being you claim him to be why didn't He
simply take that desire away, was God not capable of doing so? That
would have solved the issue, and I dare say him and his wife would
still be together.
Because then you would be demanding that God miraculously stop every
single sin, every sinful desire - and then you would be complaining that
God had removed your freewill.
What you're basically saying is that God let this man suffer for 40
years rather than taking away his desire for other men.
Of course, as I have previously remarked, I know nothing about this man.
I can't help but wonder about this "suffering" you allege and how much
was due to him indulging his desires instead of resolutely suppressing
them every time they cropped up.
One of the people I most admire is the late Kenneth Williams, who also
was a homosexual and also faced temptation throughout his life - but he found that God's grace was enough to keep him free from sin.
I don't doubt that, but f you were banged up for 10 years with a high libido, you might think differently of course.
I was merely using the example as to why a heterosexual would consider
it.-a It can also be a form of exercising power, as in Sodom.
Apparently this was a cheap shot. It was a tongue in cheek reply but if
it caused offence I apologise.
So where does the devil fit in to the scenario. Who made a person gay,
God or the devil?
It's not my fault if you've misinterpreted the handful of scriptures
which mention it.-a As for women's rights only Jesus, and to a lesser
extent Paul, allowed women to have rights, and Paul then in two books
tells women they should be quiet in church, and not permitted to teach.
The old testament is even worse, a woman could end up having to marry
her rapist, or a virgin being raped by a consenting God.
Slavery isn't condemned in the bible at all. It was an accepted part of
life in both old and new. Even Jesus didn't condemn it.
If you're struggling with a particular desire, and you ask God to help
you overcome it, how is that going against your free will? Asking for a
fish springs to mind, which is supposedly a biblical promise
That's the point, he didn't indulge, he fought against it every step of
the way, until he reached breaking point.
From what I've read Kenneth was constantly battling the issue, and
often talked about suicide.
On 14/10/2026 18:48, John wrote:
I was merely using the example as to why a heterosexual would consider
it.-a It can also be a form of exercising power, as in Sodom.
So can heterosexual rape.
The devil is the source of all imperfection, directly or indirectly. Who
is responsible for spina bifida or Downs Syndrome? Are you going to
argue that those things are part of God's perfect plan and it would be
wrong to try and "convert" such people by curing their problem?
The old testament is even worse, a woman could end up having to marry
her rapist, or a virgin being raped by a consenting God.
Rapist or seducer? God raped virgins? Tell me more!
If you're struggling with a particular desire, and you ask God to help
you overcome it, how is that going against your free will? Asking for
a fish springs to mind, which is supposedly a biblical promise
And God will and does work with you to help you overcome the problem.
That's the point, he didn't indulge, he fought against it every step
of the way, until he reached breaking point.
Breaking point? Really?
Both the cases you mention above are genetic faults. If God deliberately made them that way then He's not a God to be worshipped. ... So I blame neither God or the devil.
Seducer????-a I think when you've seized someone and had sex with them
it's rape rather than seduction.
Ooops, extremely bad wording on my part, sorry. What I meant was that
God said they could have the Midianite virgin women and girls in Numbers 31:17-18. In effect God consented to the rapes.
Sigh, obviously not.-a Both this man and the lesbian I have previously mentioned both seriously contemplated suicide.-a In the end both decided
to accept their situations rather than continue living in anguish.
I think when someone seriously contemplates suicide I would call that breaking point yes.I am glad to say that my brother had too much sense to contemplate
On 15/10/2026 14:20, John wrote:
Both the cases you mention above are genetic faults. If God
deliberately made them that way then He's not a God to be
worshipped. ... So I blame
neither God or the devil.
I'm glad you don't blame God, but curious as to why you exonerate the
devil?
If God were to over-rule every act of evil done by the devil, the devil could justly claim that he was the victim of interference, his evil and
its consequences would never be revealed, and heaven would be nothing
for than a dictatorship, with no room for freewill.
Seducer????-a I think when you've seized someone and had sex with them
it's rape rather than seduction.
Indeed - and in such a case the girl's father could refuse to give his daughter to the rapist. However what was the girl doing outside the
safety of her home, alone in a field? Was it a case of seduction and she cries "rape" when caught?
Ooops, extremely bad wording on my part, sorry. What I meant was that
God said they could have the Midianite virgin women and girls in
Numbers 31:17-18. In effect God consented to the rapes.
1. You are assuming that these women were raped by the men who captured them. The law of God specifically forbade that. If you were attracted to
one of these captives, you had to properly marry her and you had to
allow her a month in which to mourn. Meanwhile I imagine your parents
and family - and your earlier wives if you were contemplating polygamy - would have a lot to say on the subject.
2. I think it more likely that the majority of these women were put to
work at home or in the fields. Think of the Israelite girl captured by Naaman.
3. As for this "forced marriage", in those days marriage was a contract
and neither party had much say in the matter. Both bride and groom were marrying the partner picked for them by their parents! So being married
to someone without your wishes being consulted, was the expected thing.
Sigh, obviously not.-a Both this man and the lesbian I have previously
mentioned both seriously contemplated suicide.-a In the end both
decided to accept their situations rather than continue living in
anguish.
Not at all "obviously not". They had unrealistic expectations (or
demands) of what God should do and when those were not met, they turned
away from God and right.
My own brother was in love with a particular girl and when she turned
him down he more or less demanded that God force the girl to marry him.
When that did not happen, he claimed that there was no God and turned
his back on religion. Please note that despite his earnest pleas, God
did not force the girl to marry him, and despite the earnest pleas of my parents and the other members of my family, God has not forced him to
turn back to God!
I'm glad that was the case.I think when someone seriously contemplates suicide I would call that
breaking point yes.
I am glad to say that my brother had too much sense to contemplate
suicide over God's failure to answer his prayers.
The answer is to completely remove the devil from the equation. I'm astonished that God still allows him to roam, dissuading the world of
God. I would have thought that would have happened at the cross, but apparently not.
Do you believe that if someone is born with a genetic fault, whether
that be spina bifida, downs syndrome, or less serious like homosexual,
this is because the devil has willed it for that particular person?
The answer is to completely remove the devil from the equation. I'm astonished that God still allows him to roam, dissuading the world of
God. I would have thought that would have happened at the cross, but apparently not.
Wow, just wow. You have a history of defending rape as seduction, or
it's the girls fault for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, or
she was half naked so she was asking for it. Rape is rape, absolutely no excuses. If a guy is in a strip club, and gets to see her naked body,
then attacks her on her way home, he is the rapist, there are no
excuses, none whatsoever.
You're not very hot on biblical promises are you? I've heard it said
that if God doesn't answer prayer it's because it's not His will to do
so.-a Ergo, if God chose not to take their gay away, He had absolutely no problem with them being gay.-a-a Sorted, cheers Ken, and just to add icing to the cake, I know one definitely remained a Christian, as he talks
about it on his social media, and as far as I'm aware the lady is too.
I think there's a difference between someone praying for their own affliction to be removed and someone praying to change another persons
mind.
On 16/10/2026 11:18, John wrote:
Wow, just wow. You have a history of defending rape as seduction, or
it's the girls fault for being in the wrong place at the wrong time,
or she was half naked so she was asking for it. Rape is rape,
absolutely no excuses. If a guy is in a strip club, and gets to see
her naked body, then attacks her on her way home, he is the rapist,
there are no excuses, none whatsoever.
I'm not denying that; I'm merely pointing out that for a woman to cry
rape when there was no rape is not at all an unknown phenomenon.
You're not very hot on biblical promises are you? I've heard it said
that if God doesn't answer prayer it's because it's not His will to do
so.-a Ergo, if God chose not to take their gay away, He had absolutely
no problem with them being gay.-a-a Sorted, cheers Ken, and just to add
icing to the cake, I know one definitely remained a Christian, as he
talks about it on his social media, and as far as I'm aware the lady
is too.
The same argument could be used to claim that God has no problem with alcoholism or paedophilia or kleptomania. Why does God instantly remove
the desire to smoke from one person but leave another to battle his addiction for years if not life-long? I cannot give a reason in any
specific case, but in general I believe that a person who struggles
develops stronger "spiritual muscles" than one who is carried without
effort on his part.
I think there's a difference between someone praying for their own
affliction to be removed and someone praying to change another persons
mind.
Indeed, I was merely giving an instance of where it is unreasonable to expect God to answer a particular prayer.
Now imagine someone with a disability or recovering from a broken leg, praying and asking God to give the physio a kind heart and carry himMind over matter eh Ken?
from chair to table - but the physio forces him to make the effort and
walk because that is the only way to build up his mobility. God didn't answer the person's prayer because He sees that it is in the person's long-term interest to be forced to struggle.
You're right it isn't, but it's rare. But that isn't what you stated,
First of all you questioned the biblical narrative about a woman being seized, playing it down as seduction rather than rape.-a Then you
questioned why the woman was alone in a field, outside the safety of her
own home. Why the heck shouldn't she be?
Ah, so it isn't God who removes the affliction. What you're saying is
that some have greater willpower (although you dressed it up as
"spiritual muscles") Do you not believe in a God of miracles who can, if
He wills, immediately relieve a person of their affliction, whether that
be any of the things you mention?
Do you think it 0unreasonable for a homosexual, or indeed a kleptomaniac
or paedophile, to pray to be removed of their affliction?
Mind over matter eh Ken?
On 17/10/2026 13:15, John wrote:
Ah, so it isn't God who removes the affliction. What you're saying is
that some have greater willpower (although you dressed it up as
"spiritual muscles") Do you not believe in a God of miracles who can,
if He wills, immediately relieve a person of their affliction, whether
that be any of the things you mention?
Of course. But I also believe in a God Who doesn't treat everyone alike. Everyone is different, everyone has a different journey, so God will let
one person struggle while delivering someone else. I suspect, however,
that that other person will have his own struggles that God does not miraculously resolve.
We're back to asking for a fish and receiving a serpent, so that's one biblical promise broken. (based on your understanding of the bible)Do you think it 0unreasonable for a homosexual, or indeed a
kleptomaniac or paedophile, to pray to be removed of their affliction?
Of course not. But it is unreasonable to demand that God do our will.
"Thy will be done" is right at the beginning of the Lord's Prayer.
But why would he allow someone to struggle at all?-a If there were some future enlightenment that made the person a better Christian, I could
maybe understand. Matthew 11:28-30 springs to mind.
I remember a man at church and house group, who lost his mojo with God
and was deeply unhappy.
Would you avoid speaking to one of your sons for a long period simply to help him grow in stature? I doubt it and I certainly wouldn't to my son.
We're back to asking for a fish and receiving a serpent, so that's one biblical promise broken. (based on your understanding of the bible)
The second is God saying Christians will not be tempted beyond what they
can bear.-a Again, adopting your understanding, God did indeed allow this man to succumb to sin, thus losing one of his children.
On 18/10/2026 21:46, John wrote:I must have missed that in the bible, which version was it in?
We're back to asking for a fish and receiving a serpent, so that's one
biblical promise broken. (based on your understanding of the bible)
Rubbish. We are back to asking for a fish and being given a fishing rod
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:00:08 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |