Apparently Leeds Minster has displayed a "tapestry", which is simply a length of cloth on which has been embroidered in English the names of a large number of people killed in Gaza. The Jewish community claims to
have identified 18 of the names as belonging to Hamas fighters and on
that basis Leeds has removed the exhibition and apologised.
Hamas is a deeply unpleasant organisation and some of its members are undoubtedly terrorists. But it is also the government of Gaza and every official there is more or less obliged to be a paid-up member of Hamas.
Do you want to be a librarian? Belong to Hamas. Do you want to be a
hospital administrator? Belong to Hamas. Do you want to distribute
social welfare to widows and orphans? Belong to Hamas.
It's as bad as the situation in Iraq when the Americans were determined
to get rid of the Ba'ath party and all its members. Anyone whose name
was on the membership list was promptly sacked and life in Iraq came to
an end because if you wanted a job - teacher, nurse, street sweeper -
you had to belong to the Ba'ath party. It didn't matter whether you were
a confirmed Ba'athist or detested it, if you wanted to work you had to
have a membership card.
Plus, of course, there is the problem that the terms "terrorist" and "freedom fighter" are pretty well interchangeable and which is used
depends on which side you are on. The life histories of Menachim Begin
or Ariel Sharon do not bear undue scrutiny - one a terrorist and the
other a war criminal, or one a freedom fighter and the other a
successful general.
I don't know how many names were displayed on this "tapestry", but I
wonder who the unpleasant individual was who spent hours in Leeds
Minster, not to worship God but to copy them all down and then go home
and spend more hours poring over his list and comparing it with a list
of deceased Hamas members and (one trusts) making sure he wasn't
confusing them with someone of the same name and triumphantly coming up
with 18. What a nasty-minded little man he must be!
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
I know nothing about this, but could you clarify one point. In your
first paragraph you referred to 18 Hamas fighters. In your second
paragraph, they have become Hamas librarians and hospital administrators.
I agree with your final paragraph that this was small mindedness on theThe saying about people who live in glass houses springs to mind.
part of the person(s) who went through the lists of names.
On 19/09/2026 13:02, GB wrote:
I know nothing about this, but could you clarify one point. In your
first paragraph you referred to 18 Hamas fighters. In your second
paragraph, they have become Hamas librarians and hospital administrators.
No, I was making the point that because Hamas was the government, if you wanted a government job, you had to formally belong to Hamas. (I
clarified that by comparing it with the situation in Iraq with the
Ba'ath party.) I have no idea whether the 18 identified as Hamas members were active terrorists or merely formal members in order to have a
paying job and nothing in the news report leads me to think that the
Jewish group (or individual) who identified the 18 has any idea either.
I agree with your final paragraph that this was small mindedness on
the part of the person(s) who went through the lists of names.
The saying about people who live in glass houses springs to mind.
Hamas could, with equal (or even greater) justification point out that
in view of universal conscription in Israel, every young person
attending that ill-fated pop concert either was or would soon be a
member of the Israeli armed forces and therefore a legitimate target!
Please note that I am not in any way condoning what Hamas did. I am
merely pointing that, as usual, there is more than one side to the
story. Neither side is served by simplistic "All Jews good, all Arabs
bad" (or v.v.) which is served up by both sides.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
You have no evidence for that, of course.
Hamas also killed and kidnapped foreign farm workers.
Would you say they were legitimate targets?-a And, even if, in the heat
of the moment Hamas killed some of them, how do you justify taking
others hostage?
It may just have been a matter of clicking a single picture andIt may, but it still involved time and trouble. I don't know how many
uploading it to some site where it would be OCR'd and the data
automatically searched against some azure cloud database on all
palestinians
On 20/09/2026 11:03, GB wrote:
You have no evidence for that, of course.
No evidence for what? That I have no idea whether the 18 were terrorists
or merely government officials? You think that I do have some idea?
Or no evidence that the person who identified them had no idea? My
statement was "nothing in the news report leads me to think that the
Jewish group (or individual) who identified the 18 has any idea either."
Hamas also killed and kidnapped foreign farm workers.
I am sure that they did. Remember, I am not in any way attempting to
glorify Hamas or justify what they did.
Would you say they were legitimate targets?-a And, even if, in the heat
of the moment Hamas killed some of them, how do you justify taking
others hostage?
I don't. I condemn both actions utterly. But then, to be fair, I expect
you to be equally robust in condemning the Israeli army for shooting
dead doctors from Medicines sans Frontiers and a number of news reporters.
You come across as a reasonable person, so I am sure you will make plain your condemnation of the IDF. The unfortunate fact is that there are no
good guys in this whole affair. Both sides are fighting in what they
believe to be a just cause. Both sides are guilty of killing civilians.
Both sides ...
I wish it was otherwise.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
On 20/09/2026 05:59, Madhu wrote:
It may just have been a matter of clicking a single picture andIt may, but it still involved time and trouble. I don't know how many
uploading it to some site where it would be OCR'd and the data
automatically searched against some azure cloud database on all
palestinians
names featured on the display, but given the huge number of civilians
killed in Gaza, to have a mere 18 identifiable as belonging to Hamas is laughable.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
I don't condemn the IDF, because they were given an impossible job to
do. They were supposed to fight a guerilla enemy in prepared defensive positions, whilst minimising civilian casualties.
My own view before the battle in Gaza commenced was quite clear, namelyHow widely did you make your sensible ideas known? Mind you, I can
that any attempt to free the hostages taken by Hamas was going to be far
too costly in lives - both Israeli lives and Gazan lives.-a Any victory would be Pyrrhic. I think it was obvious. But, nobody listened to me.
Why does the Church of England not have a tapestry commemorating theIndeed - and the photo of that silly woman who is now the archbishopess
tens of thousands of Christians slaughtered in the ongoing religious conflict in Nigeria? It's bonkers that they are so obsessed with Israel
that they ignore the plight of their co-religionists.
On 22/09/2026 11:19, GB wrote:
I don't condemn the IDF, because they were given an impossible job to
do. They were supposed to fight a guerilla enemy in prepared defensive
positions, whilst minimising civilian casualties.
I presume that on the same basis you refrain from condemning the German forces that battled against the Warsaw Ghetto?
My own view before the battle in Gaza commenced was quite clear,How widely did you make your sensible ideas known? Mind you, I can understand the "do not negotiate with kidnappers" point of view.
namely that any attempt to free the hostages taken by Hamas was going
to be far too costly in lives - both Israeli lives and Gazan lives.
Any victory would be Pyrrhic. I think it was obvious. But, nobody
listened to me.
Just as I pointed out that nearly all the Israeli young people either
were or would soon be conscripted into the IDF and were therefore
legitimate military targets, I have little doubt that the people of Gaza were almost universally in favour of Hamas and supported their attack on Israel - and were therefore legitimate military targets.
Were they supposed to minimise civilian casualties?
The trouble with that argument is that implies all the young Gazans are
also legitimate targets, for the same reasons. Essentially, you're
saying there are no civilians.
On 22/09/2026 05:55, Kendall K. Down wrote:
On 20/09/2026 05:59, Madhu wrote:This was reported in The
Times. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/religion/article/leeds-minster-tapestry-hamas-pro-palestine-fighters-vh0nx0vxp
One of the comments was as follows:
K Albery
10 September, 2026
Why does the Church of England not have a tapestry commemorating the
tens of thousands of Christians slaughtered in the ongoing religious
conflict in Nigeria? It's bonkers that they are so obsessed with
Israel that they ignore the plight of their co-religionists.
Hamas is a deeply unpleasant organisation and some of its members are undoubtedly terrorists. But it is also the government of Gaza and every official there is more or less obliged to be a paid-up member of Hamas.
Do you want to be a librarian? Belong to Hamas. Do you want to be a
hospital administrator? Belong to Hamas. Do you want to distribute
social welfare to widows and orphans? Belong to Hamas.
Were they supposed to minimise civilian casualties?
No, of course not. But I remain to be convinced that the IDF was
concerned about civilian casualties either. Dropping high explosives
into such a crowded place as Gaza is not compatible with concern for civilians and the shooting of two escaped hostages is further
demonstration that the IDF was "trigger happy" as far as civilians were
On 22/09/2026 11:43, GB wrote:Ah bless you Ken, once again showing how closely you follow and copy the teachings of your Saviour!! Was Jesus unfit for office when He dealt
Why does the Church of England not have a tapestry commemorating the
tens of thousands of Christians slaughtered in the ongoing religious
conflict in Nigeria? It's bonkers that they are so obsessed with
Israel that they ignore the plight of their co-religionists.
Indeed - and the photo of that silly woman who is now the archbishopess
of Canterbury, standing smiling inanely beside a figure entirely covered
in cloth apart from a slit for her eyes, reveals just how unfit she is
for high office in the church. Or, in fact, any office at all.
Ah bless you Ken, once again showing how closely you follow and copy the teachings of your Saviour!! Was Jesus unfit for office when He dealt
with the Samaritan woman at the well and the Caananite woman desperate
for crumbs?
On 25/09/2026 12:20, John wrote:What is an Archbishopess, is this a new word you've invented?
Ah bless you Ken, once again showing how closely you follow and copy
the teachings of your Saviour!! Was Jesus unfit for office when He
dealt with the Samaritan woman at the well and the Caananite woman
desperate for crumbs?
If the archbishopess had been seeking to lead the woman with a bag on
her head to Christ, I would, of course, have applauded her. Such, I
think, was not the case but in fact the very opposite.
What is an Archbishopess, is this a new word you've invented?
I'm not sure you're aware, but love thy neighbour doesn't mean you shun someone because you disagree with their attire.But love thy neighbour does not oblige you to celebrate their attire, particularly when it is an expression of misogyny which, I would have
On 25/09/2026 21:58, John wrote:
What is an Archbishopess, is this a new word you've invented?
Actor-actress, prince-princess. We never needed the word archbishopess before because the idea of a female archbishop never crossed our minds.
Considering the way this woman is acting, I hope it will never again
cross our minds.
What was she meant to do, whip off the head covering and call her aI'm not sure you're aware, but love thy neighbour doesn't mean you
shun someone because you disagree with their attire.
But love thy neighbour does not oblige you to celebrate their attire, particularly when it is an expression of misogyny which, I would have thought, an archbichopess would deplore.
Female bishops have been around for decades, and are referred to as
bishops, not bishopesses, but I do take your point on actresses and princesses, although the word actress is slowly disappearing.
Wow, I had no idea you were misogynistic. Are you saying a woman
shouldn't be head of a church, if so, why not?
But let's take an example straight from the Gospels. A sinful woman goes
to Jesus and washes His feet with her tears and perfume, using her hair.
Back in t'olden days it was considered against Jewish tradition for
women to have their hair loose in the presence of other men, yet Jesus celebrated the fact, and didn't rebuke her.
As a general point, though, I see no reason to reject the notion that
men and women are more suited to different roles.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:49:17 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |