• That woman!

    From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Sep 16 19:33:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    Recently it was the feast of the Assumption of the Virgin (another
    subject altogether) and I had to attend mass as chairman of Rhyl Cytun (Churches Together). We got the usual rubbish about the woman of
    Revelation 12 being the Virgin Mary.

    It does annoy me, as the interpretation is so facile - and so wrong.

    Yes, the woman does give birth to a son who would rule all nations -
    clearly Jesus. But no, the Virgin Mary never fled into any wilderness.
    No, she was never given wings like an eagle. No, Mary was never in
    danger from a flood. Catholic tradition - which I admit is slightly contradictory - claims that she lived out her life in Ephesus being
    cared for by John the Beloved Disciple.

    Even if we take the ridiculously low age for her of 12 when Jesus was
    born, by the time He began His public ministry she would be 42.
    Christianity first came to Ephesus about twenty years later, so she
    would be 62, and we don't know at what point either John or Mary arrived
    in Ephesus. By the time John was exiled, Mary - if still alive - would
    have been 96.

    There are several apocryphal "Assumption of the Virgin" MSS and at least
    one of them has Paul being miraculously brought from Ephesus to be
    present at the death and subsequent assumption. Such legends are,
    obviously, not at all trustworthy, but if we did believe them, then Mary
    would have died at around 62, which seems believable given life
    expectancy at the time.

    In other words, Catholic tradition (and the assumption is infallible doctrine!) rules out Mary being the woman of Revelation 12.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Sep 17 11:45:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 16/09/2026 19:33, Kendall K. Down wrote:

    Recently it was the feast of the Assumption of the Virgin (another
    subject altogether) and I had to attend mass as chairman of Rhyl Cytun (Churches Together). We got the usual rubbish about the woman of
    Revelation 12 being the Virgin Mary.

    It does annoy me, as the interpretation is so facile - and so wrong.

    Yes, the woman does give birth to a son who would rule all nations -
    clearly Jesus. But no, the Virgin Mary never fled into any wilderness.
    No, she was never given wings like an eagle. No, Mary was never in
    danger from a flood. Catholic tradition - which I admit is slightly contradictory - claims that she lived out her life in Ephesus being
    cared for by John the Beloved Disciple.

    Who would you say the woman is? The obvious link is Mary, but could also represent Eve, but more likely Israel or the Church. (I would opt for
    the latter, bearing in mind the Christian church will have more or less severed it's connection with Judaism by the time John wrote it)


    Even if we take the ridiculously low age for her of 12 when Jesus was
    born,
    Why ridiculously low? Through our modern lens it is, but back then
    young maidens married at that age, so would have been quite normal.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Sep 17 20:55:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 17/09/2026 11:45, John wrote:

    Who would you say the woman is? The obvious link is Mary, but could also represent Eve, but more likely Israel or the Church. (I would opt for
    the latter, bearing in mind the Christian church will have more or less severed it's connection with Judaism by the time John wrote it)

    In several prophets (Ezekiel the most notable) a woman is used to
    represent God's people, usually an adulterous woman. Rev 17 depicts just
    such a woman. The symbolism is of an unfaithful wife standing for God's
    people when they are unfaithful to Him.

    On the other hand a pure and faithful woman would stand for God's people
    who are faithful to Him. You would expect that Jesus would be born among
    such people and also that the devil would persecute God's true people.
    In fact, this interpretation is more or less explained by the part of
    Rev 12 that talks about the devil being the "accuser of the brethren"
    and coming down in great wrath.
    Why ridiculously low?-a Through our modern lens it is, but back then
    young maidens married at that age, so would have been quite normal.

    I decline to think that God would impose pregnancy on a 12-year old,
    with all the inherent risks to life and health. Furthermore, although
    the rabbis declared that if a girl had two pubic hairs she was mature
    enough for marriage, I'm not convinced that such was the norm. It was
    just dirty-minded rabbis being pervs.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2