Howls of outrage over Ed Milliband's decision to take action on Israel's illegal settlements just before Rosh Hashana. I share the outrage: it'sI agree with you, and Israel have used the October 2023 catastrophe as
a policy that should have been implemented several decades ago.
That's not to condone the attack, Hamas are a terrorist organisation and
it was absolutely right for Israel to retaliate, but they went way too
far in that retaliation.
Also I note that Andy Burnham has been at pains to point out that this
in no way condones attacks on Jewish people, and such will be treated as anti-Semitism, and rightly so.
On 09/09/2026 06:54, Kendall K. Down wrote:
Howls of outrage over Ed Milliband's decision to take action onI agree with you, and Israel have used the October 2023 catastrophe as
Israel's illegal settlements just before Rosh Hashana. I share the
outrage: it's a policy that should have been implemented several
decades ago.
an excuse (1) to bomb the **** out of Gaza then follow up with the
illegal settlements.
That's not to condone the attack, Hamas are a terrorist organisation and
it was absolutely right for Israel to retaliate, but they went way too
far in that retaliation.
Also I note that Andy Burnham has been at pains to point out that this
in no way condones attacks on Jewish people, and such will be treated as anti-Semitism, and rightly so.
There's not too many British Jews who oppose this move, except on purely practical grounds:
a) The timing is daft. There's an election in Israel in October.
Netanyahu feeds on xenophobia, so an action like this bolsters
Netanyahu's election prospects. This should have been left until November.
b) The Foreign Office has repeatedly told ministers that it's impossible
to separate goods and services from Jewish settlements from those of the Palestinians nearby.
c) It's purely symbolic. The amount of trade with the settlements is miniscule. The upper estimate is -u38m, but it might be as low as -u6m.But I think the symbolism is important - that is why Netanyahu's
So, this is really just virtue signalling. It's not going to affect the settlements economically, and there's likely to be some collateral
damage on the Palestinians.
But I think the symbolism is important - that is why Netanyahu's
government has reacted as violently as it has, closing the embassy,
banning MPs (also symbolic as I doubt many MPs are clamouring to visit Israel), and so on.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
But I think the symbolism is important - that is why Netanyahu's
government has reacted as violently as it has, closing the embassy,
banning MPs (also symbolic as I doubt many MPs are clamouring to visit Israel), and so on.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
I love the reaction from Natanyahu's son, who has suggested that Israel should recognise Argentina's claim to the Falkland Islands. As a bit of trolling, it's first class. More telling would be recognising theOr the Welsh to govern London.
ancestral right of the Irish Republic to govern Belfast. That would
really set the cat amongst the pigeons!
Incidentally, the idea of a two state solution is great, but it runs
into a major difficulty for religious Jews. The West Bank comprises
Judea and Samaria, the heartland of ancient Israel.
There are numerous references in the bible to this land being given to
the Jews forever, as I don't need to remind you. Hence, some settlers consider it is their duty to live there, specifically to stop the land
being given away to the Palestinians!
That doesn't excuse violence though.Violence or injustice. One would have hoped that, having been on the
I know. I'm sure you realise that Christians believe that those promises were negated when the Jews rejected Jesus.
On 10/09/2026 13:03, GB wrote:
Incidentally, the idea of a two state solution is great, but it runs
into a major difficulty for religious Jews. The West Bank comprises
Judea and Samaria, the heartland of ancient Israel.
I know. The solution, I suppose, would be to remove the Palestinians
from the West Bank and give them the coastal areas of Philistia. I'm not sure that the farmers of the West Bank would be entirely happy with Tel Aviv, but at least history would be on their side.
There are numerous references in the bible to this land being given to
the Jews forever, as I don't need to remind you. Hence, some settlers
consider it is their duty to live there, specifically to stop the land
being given away to the Palestinians!
I know. I'm sure you realise that Christians believe that those promises were negated when the Jews rejected Jesus.
Unfortunately there are those
who believe that Israel must be re-established before Jesus returns, but even a superficial reading of the prophecies shows that not only is
Israel's territory to be restored, but Israel's righteousness.
Given
that a large number of Jews in Israel are avowed atheists and that the country has one of the highest percentages of illegitimate births in the world (as reported by Qol Israel), I don't see that second but necessary condition having been fulfilled.
That doesn't excuse violence though.
Violence or injustice. One would have hoped that, having been on the receiving end of the Holocaust, Jews would be extra sensitive about
imposing a Holocaust on others. Alas, many seem to regard what Jews
suffered as an example to be followed in their dealings with the Arabs.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
That cannot be compatible with a literal interpretation of the bible.
For example, Genesis 13:14u18:
"all the land which you see I will give to you and your descendants forever.o
There's no caveat there about rescinding the promise. It's unconditional.
That cannot be compatible with a literal interpretation of the bible.
For example, Genesis 13:14rCo18:
"all the land which you see I will give to you and your descendants forever.rCY
There's no caveat there about rescinding the promise. It's unconditional.
So, being confused, I read a (very) little about this, and I came across Supersessionism, which requires a non-literal interpretation of the bible.
I agree. We could do with more righteousness. Well, all of us, really.
From here, it is hard to understand how attitudes have become so
hardened on both sides.
We have a friend who lives in Ashkelon, which is a couple of miles awayYes, it is not widely reported (it has been, but anything which goes on
from the border with Gaza. A while ago, he complained that, pretty much
on a nightly basis, people in Gaza were launching rockets in the
direction of Ashkelon. These were not guided missiles, but they could
hit a target the size of a town, and they had warheads capable of
destroying a flat and killing/injuring the occupants. Air raid sirens
were going off most nights.
You don't hear much about this sort of thing on the UK news, but it is obviously a real issue if you're under fire.
On 11/09/2026 12:47, GB wrote:
That cannot be compatible with a literal interpretation of the bible.
For example, Genesis 13:14rCo18:
"all the land which you see I will give to you and your descendants
forever.rCY
There's no caveat there about rescinding the promise. It's unconditional.
I suggest you have a look at Jeremiah 18:6-11 where God is very clear, speaking to Israel, that His promises are indeed conditional (as are His threats).
I agree. We could do with more righteousness. Well, all of us, really.
Agreed - and I certainly don't want to claim that Christians are
exclusively righteous. In fact, I strongly suspect that some - at least
- of modern Christians may be in danger of falling into the condition
given by Jeremiah.
From here, it is hard to understand how attitudes have become so
hardened on both sides.
I remember when the Oslo accord was signed and Palestinians were given certain rights. We were touring Jericho that day and there were
Palestinian police in uniforms and with guns. The atmosphere of goodwill
was incredible, everyone was smiling and a bus load of Jews could have rolled in and been welcomed.
Then, of course, Rabin was assassinated and Bebe got in and promptly did everything he could to undermine Oslo and eventually repudiate it. All
that goodwill rebuffed. Such a tragedy.
We have a friend who lives in Ashkelon, which is a couple of milesYes, it is not widely reported (it has been, but anything which goes on
away from the border with Gaza. A while ago, he complained that,
pretty much on a nightly basis, people in Gaza were launching rockets
in the direction of Ashkelon. These were not guided missiles, but they
could hit a target the size of a town, and they had warheads capable
of destroying a flat and killing/injuring the occupants. Air raid
sirens were going off most nights.
You don't hear much about this sort of thing on the UK news, but it is
obviously a real issue if you're under fire.
for a long time tends to slip down and out of the news) but it is very
real. Hamas are idiots but I fear they get their strength from Israeli oppression. If Gaza had been allowed to prosper and everyone had jobs, I don't believe that Hamas would have anything like the influence it does have.
I can understand the actions by the Israeli government and army, which
are an exasperated reaction to the sort of terrorism you describe. But
do you really think that bombing and shooting and killing the wife and children of some man is going to make him well-disposed towards Israel?
Or will it give him a burning desire to join Hamas and kill a few
Israelis in revenge for his own wife and children?
It may go against the grain - and at this late stage it may not work -
but I firmly believe that Israel needs to give back the land it has illegally occupied in the West Bank and Gaza, encourage trade and
enterprise so that the Palestinians become wealthy. There will,
inevitably, be a few who will misuse their wealth, but there will be a
far greater number who will suddenly have a different attitude.
It's one thing to risk the Jews demolishing your house when all you have
is a single-room hovel with no electricity or water; it's quite another
when you have a large and comfortable house with all mod-cons. You may
be willing to risk even that, but I'll bet your wife will be adamant
that you should not be such a fool!
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
Oh, I agree that his promises are, indeed, conditional. But, that's not compatible with a literal interpretation of Genesis.
It's clearly both wrong and wrong-headed.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:22:02 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,374 |