• It wasn't him

    From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Fri Aug 21 07:45:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    Headlines in the Daily Mail today claim that a new discovery in Egypt
    may prove the Biblical story of the Exodus. Rubbish.

    The article shows that all they have discovered is an inscription
    mentioning the name of Rameses II. RII was one of the longest lived
    pharaohs of ancient Egypt, he was a compulsive builder and equally unscrupulous about nicking other people's work and attaching his name to
    it. The discovery of an inscription bearing his name is very much a
    ho-hum moment!

    As for the alleged links to the Exodus, Biblical chronology states that
    the Exodus happened 480 years before Solomon's temple. Solomon began to
    reign in 970 BC, his fourth year would be 965 BC (assuming an accession
    year before his official first year), which would place the Exodus at
    1445 BC. RII reigned around 1280 BC.

    The only reason he is picked is because the Bible records that the
    Israelites built "treasure cities" Pithom and Rameses and the not
    unnatural assumption that the pharaoh who commissioned the work would
    name the city after himself. Yet he didn't name Pithom after himself ...
    And in any case, names including the god "Ra" were not unusual in Egypt.

    However the biggest reason against RII is not the conflict with Biblical chronology but the fact that there is no evidence for the Exodus in
    either Egypt or Palestine. Rameses did not die in the Red Sea, Egypt was
    not devastated by plagues, Jericho was an uninhabited ruin, life in
    Palestine continued on without any major changes.

    It is no wonder that those who perversely insist on putting the Exodus
    in the wrong place in time end up concluding that the whole thing was a
    myth. It would be like me insisting that Sir Francis Drake was a myth
    because I find no record of him in newspaper from the time of Queen
    Elizabeth - Elizabeth II, that is.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Madhu@enometh@meer.net to uk.religion.christian on Sun Aug 23 20:08:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian


    * "Kendall K. Down" <1168s73$3f6s$1@dont-email.me> :
    Wrote on Fri, 21 Aug 2026 07:45:56 +0100:

    Headlines in the Daily Mail today claim that a new discovery in Egypt
    may prove the Biblical story of the Exodus. Rubbish.

    The article shows that all they have discovered is an inscription
    mentioning the name of Rameses II. RII was one of the longest lived
    pharaohs of ancient Egypt, he was a compulsive builder and equally unscrupulous about nicking other people's work and attaching his name
    to it. The discovery of an inscription bearing his name is very much a
    ho-hum moment!

    https://www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16067379/biblical-discovery-ramses-egypt-mesen.html

    (They don't serve under dailymail.co.uk or dailyfail.co.uk anymore and
    looking at any content has to pass through an akamai browser
    fingerpinting challenge)

    As for the alleged links to the Exodus, Biblical chronology states
    that the Exodus happened 480 years before Solomon's temple. Solomon
    began to reign in 970 BC, his fourth year would be 965 BC (assuming an accession year before his official first year), which would place the
    Exodus at 1445 BC. RII reigned around 1280 BC.

    The only reason he is picked is because the Bible records that the
    Israelites built "treasure cities" Pithom and Rameses and the not
    unnatural assumption that the pharaoh who commissioned the work would
    name the city after himself. Yet he didn't name Pithom after himself
    ... And in any case, names including the god "Ra" were not unusual in
    Egypt.

    The local pastor maintains that Moses was an accomplished architect and
    was the principal architect of the "Rameses" city. By itself would
    claim not be consistent with the biblical record, even assuming a 15th
    century of Exodus, since "the Pharaoh" is unnamed.

    The rabbinic sages have their own debates on this, but the point they
    emphasize for some is that is it was same (unnamed) P. who installed
    Joseph who also enslaved his descendants.

    However the biggest reason against RII is not the conflict with
    Biblical chronology but the fact that there is no evidence for the
    Exodus in either Egypt or Palestine. Rameses did not die in the Red
    Sea, Egypt was not devastated by plagues, Jericho was an uninhabited
    ruin, life in Palestine continued on without any major changes.

    the "Absence of evidence" argument



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Sun Aug 23 18:19:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 23/08/2026 15:38, Madhu wrote:

    The local pastor maintains that Moses was an accomplished architect and
    was the principal architect of the "Rameses" city. By itself would
    claim not be consistent with the biblical record, even assuming a 15th century of Exodus, since "the Pharaoh" is unnamed.

    I know of nothing to support your pastor's claim. Legend attributes
    military prowess to Moses (including Josephus), but says nothing about architecture.

    The rabbinic sages have their own debates on this, but the point they emphasize for some is that is it was same (unnamed) P. who installed
    Joseph who also enslaved his descendants.

    Which just shows what rubbish they talk. The Bible specifically says
    that slavery came under a pharaoh "who knew not Joseph".

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2