John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was this a new thing or
was baptism also in the OT?-a If a new thing why the sudden change?
I've been reading up a bit on the Council of Nicea and it appears Constantine became a Christian some time before this but I've also
learnt he wasn't baptised until he was on his deathbed.-a My
understanding is that new converts were baptised as soon as possible
after conversion, it certainly seems to be a feature of Acts.
And on a slightly different note reegarding baptism of the Holy Spirit.It is obviously a good thing to be immersed in the Holy Spirit and I
As a charismatic I certainly believed it was an essential part of being
a Christian, but I know other sectors of Christianity don't regard it as important.
John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was this a new thing or
was baptism also in the OT?-a If a new thing why the sudden change?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MikvehI'm not sure why you provided that URL. The question was whether John
There is no suggestion that if, for example, you have robbed someone,
you need a ritual bath in order to be forgiven. John the Baptist's
call for people to repent and then to immerse themselves does appear
to be something new.
On 25/08/2026 11:39, GB wrote:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MikvehI'm not sure why you provided that URL.
On 19/08/2026 09:03, John wrote:Thanks, I hadn't heard of that before.
John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was this a new thing
or was baptism also in the OT?-a If a new thing why the sudden change?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikveh
On 19/08/2026 09:03, John wrote:
John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was this a new thing
or was baptism also in the OT?-a If a new thing why the sudden change?
Baptism - that is, immersing oneself completely - was standard Jewish practice, possibly carried to extremes by the Essenes of Qumran (and I believe John the Baptist was an Essene). John's innovation seems to have been a) immersion for sin rather than the standard causes of
uncleanness, and b) anyone at all could join in the ceremony rather than just the members of an exclusive community.
Among the scrolls found at Qumran was "The War of the Sons of Light
against the Sons of Darkness", predicting and describing a coming
apocalypic war against thinly diguised Romans. The document indicates
that the Sons of Light were the Essenes of Qumran; John may have felt
that all Israel should have a chance at being on the right side.
I've been reading up a bit on the Council of Nicea and it appears
Constantine became a Christian some time before this but I've also
learnt he wasn't baptised until he was on his deathbed.-a My
understanding is that new converts were baptised as soon as possible
after conversion, it certainly seems to be a feature of Acts.
By the time of Constantine the idea had come in that baptism cleansed
you from all your sins, but as it was unrepeatable, it made sense to put
it off as long as possible so as to have the maximum number of sins
washed away and the minimum possible on your record when you met your
Maker. Unfortunately more than one person waited too long and died
before baptism, therefore totally without hope of salvation (according
to the theory) so the practice was gradually discouraged.
Even as a Christian, I never believed tongues were essential as a signAnd on a slightly different note regarding baptism of the Holy Spirit.
As a charismatic I certainly believed it was an essential part of
being a Christian, but I know other sectors of Christianity don't
regard it as important.
It is obviously a good thing to be immersed in the Holy Spirit and I
don't know of any Christians who would disagree. Where disagreement
arises is in the notion that unless you spout gibberish you are not
filled with the Holy Spirit. In 1 Corinthians 14:22 St Paul tells us
that tongues are not a sign for believers, so the charismatic teaching
is directly contrary to St Paul. You have my sympathy for having fallen
prey to this false teaching.
You snipped away the question I was partially answering, which was "wasThe question was: "John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was
this a new thing or was baptism also in the OT?"
However the idea that conversion to christianity is confirmed by aIndeed - but John the Baptist was not converting people to Christianity.
ritual act of water baptism recapitualates the traditional use of the
Mikveh in Jewish conversion and culture.
It's interesting that Paul mentions baptism for the dead, and doesn't
appear to discourage this.
As I said, I had aI don't believe that it "just came to" you. You heard other people
tongue, which just came to me, I didn't receive the laying on of hands
or anything.-a Whether it was gibberish I have no way of knowing, it may well have been.
Would you-a say the baptisms carried out by John and Jesus's disciples (possibly Jesus himself) were Mikveh, or was this a new practice?
Having read your link, it would appear the NT practice was forExactly - and that was the innovation inspired by John the Baptist.
repentance rather than purification.
As I said, I had a tongue, which just came to me, I didn't receive
the laying on of hands or anything. Whether it was gibberish I have
no way of knowing, it may well have been.
I don't believe that it "just came to" you. You heard other people
speaking gibberish, you heard it being praised as a desirable thing,
then you started doing it yourself.
On 26/08/2026 06:58, Madhu wrote:
However the idea that conversion to christianity is confirmed by aIndeed - but John the Baptist was not converting people to Christianity.
ritual act of water baptism recapitualates the traditional use of the
Mikveh in Jewish conversion and culture.
The practice contined even when the baptisms weren't automatically accompanied with the reception of the Holy spirit -- (the power that AntiPeter so coveted). so it wasn't a new thing, but an adaptedYes, I rather regret that in my tradition we don't lay hands on people
"cultural appropriation" that eventually served the same ritual purpose
of "tribal marker", as from the culture where it was adopted.
Yes, I rather regret that in my tradition we don't lay hands on people
to receive the Holy Spirit after baptism. I can understand why - too
much like claiming that the ministrant has the power to dispense the
Holy Spirit - but still a shame.
On 26/08/2026 11:45, GB wrote:
You snipped away the question I was partially answering, which wasThe question was: "John introduced baptism as a sign of repentance, was
"was this a new thing or was baptism also in the OT?"
this a new thing or was baptism also in the OT?-a If a new thing why the sudden change?", so John was not asking whether immersion was a new
thing, but whether immersion as a sign of repentance was new."
You might
as well have snipped even more and just answered the question "was this
a new thing" and posted a URL about rocket travel or genetic engineering.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
I think if you believed that you could have easily found a congregation
where it was done.
Certainly there is power given through these sort of anointations, you
can see it in the guru-discipleship of various institutions in india,
and it is centered around power influence control and icrease of of
community assets, but is it the power of the holy spirit or the power of
the money laundering angels that gets trasmitted
when traveling on a pilgrimage decades ago some sadhus told me i wasI trust you avoided it.
weak and powerless because i had not really served any guru "in the
body", and by doing bodily service to the guru and receiving "shaktipat"
(the laying of hands) i would find out about it
Baptism is a sign of purification, surely? So, are you making a very
fine distinction there?
Or, is it a major distinction that's gone whoosh past me because of my
lack of knowledge?
On 28/08/2026 13:29, GB wrote:
Baptism is a sign of purification, surely? So, are you making a very
fine distinction there?
I don't think so. For example, you might be walking past a butchers and somehow accidentally come into contact with a dead pig or part thereof.
That would require cleansing but not repentance - you did not
intentionally touch the pig.
On 28/08/2026 13:29, GB wrote:
Baptism is a sign of purification, surely? So, are you making a very
fine distinction there?
I don't think so. For example, you might be walking past a butchers and somehow accidentally come into contact with a dead pig or part thereof.
That would require cleansing but not repentance - you did not
intentionally touch the pig.
Or, is it a major distinction that's gone whoosh past me because of my
lack of knowledge?
I'm not sure. Surely Judaism has the concept of repentance when you have done something wrong?
Suppose you, in a moment of temptation, stole some money from your
employer - put it in your pocket instead of into the till. Later God convicts you that you have done wrong. You restore the money, you
determine never to do such a thing again, (possibly you apologise to the employer). Those are steps of repentance and necessary if you want to be right with God again.
However I do not know of any Old Testament law which would require you
to visit the mikveh for such an offence. Perhaps you can enlighten me?
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
You must have strange butchers in Rhyl!-a Where I live it's not possibleI must admit I was thinking primarily of the East, where you see skinned carcasses hanging outside butcher's shops. However even here in Britain
to walk past a butchers and make contact with a dead pig.
We have repentance for moral sins.Exactly - and you would hardly repent of handling - laying-out - the
We also have the concept of cleansing, through washing, for ritual
impurity. Ritual impurity could include handling a corpse, for example.
On 30/08/2026 11:21, John wrote:Fair comments, although I would imagine a Jew would give such a butchers
You must have strange butchers in Rhyl!-a Where I live it's not
possible to walk past a butchers and make contact with a dead pig.
I must admit I was thinking primarily of the East, where you see skinned carcasses hanging outside butcher's shops. However even here in Britain
I've seen whole animals being carried from the truck into the shop and
it is conceivable that you might accidentally come into contact with the carcass.
However that is just an illustration of how you might require cleansing
but not repentance. Another example might be an ambulance worker who has
to handle a dead body; cleansing required, but hardly repentance.
On 30/08/2026 19:40, GB wrote:
We have repentance for moral sins.Exactly - and you would hardly repent of handling - laying-out - the
We also have the concept of cleansing, through washing, for ritual
impurity. Ritual impurity could include handling a corpse, for example.
corpse of a loved one. John the Baptist, however, seems to have urged baptism (cleansing in water) to mark repentance, implying that moral
sins were also defiling.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
Fair comments, although I would imagine a Jew would give such a butchersI'm sure, but if he was deep in conversation he might not notice someone suddenly emerging from behind a delivery truck.
a wide berth if they saw a dead pig being carried from the street to the shop.
Yes, thanks for explaining the difference.At present I'm wading through the different blessings to be said over
On 31/08/2026 11:37, GB wrote:
Yes, thanks for explaining the difference.At present I'm wading through the different blessings to be said over
food. Before and after? Or only before or only after?
How much food do
you need to eat to make a blessing necessary?
All very complicated apart
from barley; you don't need to say any blessing over barley.
The most recent bit is who should say the blessing. If there are two men eating together, one can invite the other to say the blessing, but if
there are three men an invitation is not possible - reason not explained
but I think it has to do with precedence. A group of women or a group of slaves can also invite someone to say the blessing, but a mixed group of women, slaves and children cannot - no indication of what they should
do. However you'll be pleased to know that 100 women are not worth two
men when it comes to blessings (that is explicitly stated).
If there are three men eating and one leaves before the final blessing,
does the rule for two apply or the rule for three? That depends on
whether you call him back - if you do, the rule for three applies,
though the rabbis appear divided on whether it is the calling back that
is important or the man actually coming back.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
Say a blessing before partaking.
You need to eat at least a kezayit (an olive size portion - quite a
large olive) before needing to recite the grace after meals.
All very complicated apart from barley; you don't need to say any
blessing over barley.
Incorrect, I'm afraid.
I'm impressed by your thirst for knowledge. But, why this? :)It makes me glad to be a Christian, who can talk to his Heavenly Father without worrying about the exact form of words that are required.
On 31/08/2026 19:55, GB wrote:
Say a blessing before partaking.
And another afterwards (under certain circumstances).
You need to eat at least a kezayit (an olive size portion - quite a
large olive) before needing to recite the grace after meals.
Ah, but what if the olive has been stoned? (I kid you not.)
All very complicated apart from barley; you don't need to say any
blessing over barley.
Incorrect, I'm afraid.
"Are the two cakes alike? In the case of olive oil the article does not admit of further improvement, in this case it does admit of further improvement, by being made into bread, and when it is still capable of further improvement we do not say over it the blessing 'that createst
the fruit of the ground;', but 'by whose word all things exist'! But has
not R. Zera said in the name of R. Mattena reporting Samuel: Over raw cabbage and barley-flour we say the blessing 'by whose word all things exist', and may we not infer from this that over wheat-flour we say 'who createst the fruit of the ground'? No, over wheat-flour also we say 'by whose word all things exist'. Then let him state the rule for wheat-
flour and it will apply to barley-flour as a matter of course? If he had stated the rule as applying to wheat-flour, I might have said, That is
the rule for wheat-flour, but over barley-flour we need say no blessing
at all. There we are told that this is not so. But is barley-flour of
less account than salt or brine, of which was we learned: Over salt and brine one said 'by whose word all things exist'? It was necessary to lay down the rule for barley-flour. You might argue that man often puts a
dash of salt or-a brine into his mouth without harm, but barley-flour is harmful in creating tapeworms and therefore we need say no blessing over
it. We are therefore told that since one has some enjoyment from it he
must say a blessing over it."
Tractate Berakoth 36a Soncino edition
Hmmm. It appears to be a disputed point,
especially as barley-flour
breeds tapeworms, a detail that, I think, is not recognised by
veterinary or medical authorities these days.
I'm impressed by your thirst for knowledge. But, why this? :)It makes me glad to be a Christian, who can talk to his Heavenly Father without worrying about the exact form of words that are required.
My Christian readers may like to note the string of authorities quoted, which gives point to the astonishment of those who listened to Jesus,
"for He taught them as one having authority and not as the scribes" -
"ye have heard ... but *I* say unto you ..."
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
If you're interested, there's a straightforward article about it here: https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/7226278/jewish/What-is-a- Kezayit.htm
My father managed to get a tapeworm when he was a young man in the
1920s. No great problem, as he took a poison that killed the tapeworm
but not him. Before the time of modern medicine, I don't know whether catching a tapeworm was a death sentence, but it must have been really debilitating. So, even a tiny chance of getting one was a risk you'd definitely want to avoid?
This is an entirely valid point, but it reminds me of my mother arguingShe was, of course, absolutely right. And from having discussed the same
with Jehovah's Witnesses. She would tell them that their religion was "wrong" because it banned blood transfusions. This was a point that made perfect sense to her, but made no sense to the JWs.
On 01/09/2026 16:42, GB wrote:
If you're interested, there's a straightforward article about it here:
https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/7226278/jewish/What-is-
a- Kezayit.htm
I think the expression "nit-picking" is applicable.
My father managed to get a tapeworm when he was a young man in the
1920s. No great problem, as he took a poison that killed the tapeworm
but not him. Before the time of modern medicine, I don't know whether
catching a tapeworm was a death sentence, but it must have been really
debilitating. So, even a tiny chance of getting one was a risk you'd
definitely want to avoid?
Certainly - but you get tapeworm from eating uncooked meat, not from
barley flour!
This is an entirely valid point, but it reminds me of my motherShe was, of course, absolutely right. And from having discussed the same issue with JWs myself, I don't think it is correct to say that it makes
arguing with Jehovah's Witnesses. She would tell them that their
religion was "wrong" because it banned blood transfusions. This was a
point that made perfect sense to her, but made no sense to the JWs.
no sense to them. They have taken God's prohibition on eating blood -
which is reasonable - and turned transfusing into eating. Mad.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
It's not completely impossible that something about barley makes it more likely than other grains that tapeworm eggs get swept up in the harvest.
On 02/09/2026 12:49, GB wrote:
It's not completely impossible that something about barley makes it
more likely than other grains that tapeworm eggs get swept up in the
harvest.
I think it is up to you to demonstrate that. I suppose it is conceivable that barley might be contaminated by animal faeces and therefore with tapeworm eggs, but as no one eats raw flour, the chances of the eggs surviving being baked into bread or scones or whatever are zero.
Certainly it would not be a major cause of tapeworm infestation, as the Talmud appears to claim.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
This is where you're going wrong. It's not "the Talmud" claimingYour comments would be correct were it not for one thing. To this day
anything. The Talmud is a record of past discussions. So, what you're referring to is some rabbi in distant times thinking that Barley was
more likely to harbour tapeworm eggs. I have no reason to doubt that
that was his honestly held belief. But, whether what he believed was
correct matters not a jot.
The Talmud is a record of past discussions. So, what you're
referring to is some rabbi in distant times thinking that Barley was
more likely to harbour tapeworm eggs.
On 03/09/2026 11:04, GB wrote:
This is where you're going wrong. It's not "the Talmud" claimingYour comments would be correct were it not for one thing. To this day
anything. The Talmud is a record of past discussions. So, what you're
referring to is some rabbi in distant times thinking that Barley was
more likely to harbour tapeworm eggs. I have no reason to doubt that
that was his honestly held belief. But, whether what he believed was
correct matters not a jot.
Jews study the Talmud with almost as much diligence as if it were Holy
Writ. The opinions of the rabbis are treated with reverence, no matter
how ridiculous.
As a counter example, we have Martin Luther's "Table Talk", the record
of the reformer's conversations around his table. Some of the things he
said were controversial, a few were abhorrent, a lot were interesting or even profitable (I've read it). However no one earnestly studies it to discover the path to heaven, there are no "Table Talk" scholars - but
there are Talmudic scholars.
Of course, their views on interpretation of the bible are treated with reverence. Their obiter dicta on medicine are largely irrelevant.
You sound like you think everybody should simply sit down and read the bible, interpreting it from scratch for themselves. Yet, I'm pretty sure you've been to Bible College, and you've clearly read extensively aroundOf course I cannot deny that some authors have had an influence on my
the bible, taking into account the views of others. I think that's absolutely the right thing to do, by the way. There's no point in
everybody reinventing the wheel, so to speak.
On 08/09/2026 11:39, GB wrote:
Of course, their views on interpretation of the bible are treated with
reverence. Their obiter dicta on medicine are largely irrelevant.
Yet their ideas about medicine are advanced as reasons for their
Biblical interpretations. The two go together. I assure you I would be similarly dismissive of a Christian theologian who - for example -
believed in a flat earth.
You sound like you think everybody should simply sit down and read theOf course I cannot deny that some authors have had an influence on my
bible, interpreting it from scratch for themselves. Yet, I'm pretty
sure you've been to Bible College, and you've clearly read extensively
around the bible, taking into account the views of others. I think
that's absolutely the right thing to do, by the way. There's no point
in everybody reinventing the wheel, so to speak.
views, but consciously I am not aware of it. I read source documents
around the Bible, but theology I deliberately skip. Why read someone
else's opinions when I can form my own?
So, for example, I have read just about all the apocrypha, both Old and
New Testament, and reached my own conclusion about them. I don't need to have some theologian to tell me that Tobit is a load of rubbish but 1
and 2 Maccabees are valuable historically.
I remember arguing with a fellow student at college who was proud of his extensive theological reading and contemptuous when I was equally proud
of never having read any of his favourite German theologian. After he
had listed some of the works of theology he had read I quietly asked,
"But can you sit down now and give me a Bible study on Daniel 8?"
He floundered and flustered a bit and finally admitted that he couldn't.
"But I can," I told him.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
You're not one to shrink from confrontation, are you?Not when I know that I'm right.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (1 / 5) |
| Uptime: | 61:40:11 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |