Apparently there is a bill introduced in America - not sure whether it
has been passed into law yet - that obliges health insurers that pay for transgender surgery, to also pay for the damage it causes. In the case
of girls being turned into men (an impossibility, of course, but these transgender idiots will happily mutilate them in the cause of an
ideology) the reversal covers bone degradation, heart disease, loss of fertility, all the reconstructive surgery, and no doubt other on-going costs.
It's just a pity they don't unload some of the costs onto the
psychologists who encourage this nonsense and the surgeons who
transgress their Hippocratic oaths by carrying out the surgery in the
first place.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
On 04/08/2026 13:38, GB wrote:
The Hippocratic Oath is not sworn any longer. If you read it, I'm sure
you'll understand why:
Even when it was, I'm pretty sure the mention of heathen gods was
ommitted. Apart from that, it all seems like good stuff.
Your main point, I'm sure, is "I will do no harm", and that begs theIndeed, but there is no question-begging involved. There is clearly no confusion over a person's gender - just pull his or her trousers down
question entirely, ie how best to minimise the harm resulting from
gender dysphoria.
(or do a DNA test if you are squeamish)[1]. It is clear that any man thinking he is a woman (or vice versa) is suffering from a mental
problem and treatment for the mentally ill is appropriate.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
Note 1: Yes, I am aware that there are a tiny number of individuals
whose DNA does not provide a clear answer to their sex. In that tiny
number of individuals a certain amount of choice or even surgery may be required.
Your views are heavily biased by your religious observance. Fortunately, you're not involved in caring for people with gender dysphoria, so it doesn't much matter what you think.
You might care to find out abut Intersex people (with ambiguous external genitalia). It might make you realise that there's a bigger range of possibilities than you choose to imagine. Certainly, there are people
where "just pull his or her trousers down " leaves you none the wiser.
Indeed, but there is no question-begging involved. There is clearly no confusion over a person's gender - just pull his or her trousers down
(or do a DNA test if you are squeamish)[1]. It is clear that any man thinking he is a woman (or vice versa) is suffering from a mental
problem and treatment for the mentally ill is appropriate.
What treatment to you think appropriate? Attempting to cure gender
dysphoria by mental or psychological processes has been tried for a long time, and nothing has been found that works.
What does work, very well, is transition (which doesn't necessarily
involve surgery).
On 04/08/2026 21:49, Laurence Taylor wrote:
What treatment to you think appropriate? Attempting to cure gender
dysphoria by mental or psychological processes has been tried for a long
time, and nothing has been found that works.
The same could be said about attempts to cure schizophrenia or
depression. That has not caused intelligent and caring people to stop
trying to find something that works.
What does work, very well, is transition (which doesn't necessarily
involve surgery).
Apart, of course, from those who discover that they have been hoodwinked
and seek to de-transition.
God bless,
Kendall K. Down
However, there is no rational reason why people who want to dress and
live as the opposite sex should not be allowed to do so. I'll go further
and say they should be encouraged to do so if that improves their mental wellbeing.
That seems a humane and kind approach, but it runs contrary to the
bible, specifically Deuteronomy 22:5, although there's some discussion
about the meaning of that verse.
Obviously, if surgery is avoided, all your arguments about de-Partly. If someone is encouraged to cross-dress and adopt the persona of
transitioning fall away.
Yes, it does go contrary to the Bible. I don't think the Bible is
talking about pantomime dames or children dressing up for a game or a
party. My opinion is that the Biblical prohibition is directed at cross-dressing for sexual purposes.
That seems a humane and kind approach, but it runs contrary to the
bible, specifically Deuteronomy 22:5, although there's some discussion
about the meaning of that verse.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:57:53 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |