• Re: Is Socialism the answer?

    From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Jul 27 22:34:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 18:44, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 12:49, John wrote:

    Gary Linekar fought a tax battle in court and won. The court ruled
    that he had legitimately used a Ltd Company to pay less tax, whilst
    HMRC had argued he shouldn't have used the Ltd Company.

    Which is at odds with his apparent claim that rich people should pay
    more tax. He should have rejoiced at the opportunity to pay more instead
    of dragging HMRC through expensive litigation.

    I've mixed feelings. In one sense I agree but in another I don't.
    You used to pay less tax through a Ltd Company, but it's perfectly
    legitimate for shareholders to do so. HMRC deemed him to be a sole
    trader but they were wrong, so in that sense Gary paid the right ammount
    of tax. HMRC has won some of these cases, so maybe they thought they
    would win with GL, but a lot depends on the contract between the
    parties, and GL's was sufficiently strong enough.

    Now if GL was using a loophole to avoid paying extra tax, lets say by funelling money through shell companies and offshore accounts then I'd
    say close the loophole and make him pay the right amount of tax. Or say
    a certain coffee company were shifting profits abroad by using licencing
    fees and intellectual rights I would say it's wrong (whilst being
    perfectly legal in my latter example, and borderline in my first.

    HMRC have more or less levelled up the playing field since then on Ltd
    Co v Sole Trader but I wouldn't be averse to it making no difference
    either way, allowing for the fact that if you do take dividends the
    Company pays Corporation Tax on top.








    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Jul 27 22:49:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 18:43, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 11:18, John wrote:

    We're talking about the personal wealth of people, not successful
    businesses, but is it right that the Government has to top up the ages
    of some because some of these wealthy businesses pay minimum wage
    wilst personally extracting millions from their businesses?

    Personal wealth doesn't just fall off the magic money tree. Someone, somewhere, has worked hard to amass that money.

    I agree with you entirely, that people who amass wealth by mistreating
    and underpaying their workers, should be penalised to the maximum.


    And that's not all successful businesses of course. We've previously
    discussed Tesco, who do plough some of their profits back into worker
    investment

    Other model firms are, I believe, Cadburys and Sunlight soap. I think
    that at least the former has links to the Quaker movement.

    It does, and the Cadburys were great philanthropists.

    As I said, I haven't advocated bleeding him dry, but on a slightly
    different note (and I hasten to add I'm not a commie) do you not like
    the idea of everyone being equal, having exactly the same status, and
    no one having more than anyone else.-a Just think, if there were no
    poverty, no greed, no jealousy, how joyous that would be.

    Indeed, very joyous. Tell that to the young bludgers who are getting
    -u100 a week more than a worker on minimum wage just by claiming that
    they suffer from anxiety. If someone works hard, I see no justification
    for not rewarding him for his work.

    It's actually -u47 a week for new claimants, but the -u100 a week is extra
    if you *can't* work full stop, and only if you're on universal credit.
    I'm not conviced that anxiety on it's own would trigger that benefit.
    It's called LCWR, and isn't an easy benefit to get.







    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Jul 27 22:55:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 19:04, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 07:52, Timreason wrote:

    Some sort of community work perhaps.

    You seem to be arguing for "work-fare" as opposed to "wel-fare". You
    will not find me disagreeing.

    Yes of course it's not that simple. Mental health patients,for
    example, need to feel secure in the knowledge that they will continue
    to get support. But most people could do something, even if it was
    just attendance at a community mental health centre or something.
    Tying in some sort of commitment to their receipt of income would help
    maintain the notion of doing something in order to receive, which is
    after all how the world of employment functions.

    Indeed. There are people who are physically unable to work - I'm not
    sure that mental health is an obstacle to all work - but other than that suitable employment should be found for all.

    We agree, with the priviso that acute anxiety is a debillitating illness.


    One thing, the populace is for ever pressing governments to provide
    for more and more things. More services, but the same populace keep
    pressing for ever lower taxes! They want great services, but they
    don't want to pay for them. Maybe governments need to 'sell' taxation
    better?



    What services do you have in mind? The only services I would press for
    are essentials like rubbish collection, road maintenance, and so on.


    SEND provision is the biggest expenditure of most councils nowadays,
    would you do away with that?



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Mon Jul 27 23:15:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 19:11, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 10:20, John wrote:

    I do sometimes wonder if we're paying enough income tax, even at the
    lower end. Or is the solution simply to cut public spending?-a We
    collect approximately 1.4 trillion in tax, but some services have
    already been cut to the bone, particularly in local Government.-a That
    said, tax has been brought in using stealth taxes, so maybe not.

    The biggest drain on our taxes is unnecessary welfare payments. If we weren't paying to house illegal immigrants, employ equality officers, sponsor Pride events, cossett young people with imagined mental
    illnesses, provide luxury homes for druggies and the work-shy, and on
    and on and on, we could probably halve our tax burden.

    Oh, I doubt it. Perhaps we should do away with the state pension, given
    it makes up 44% of the welfare budget!

    On a serious note, what "unecessary" welfare payments would you do away
    with?

    Whether you like it or not, we have no choice to house "illegal
    immigrants", given it's a legal duty. I'm not aware of luxury homes
    being provided for druggies and the work-shy, perhaps you could
    enlighten me. I'm wondering though, isn't rejecting the foreigner in
    your land going against biblical principles?

    To pick up on an earlier point, which I forgot to reply to. Under the
    Dublin agreement we could insist the asylum seeker did have to stop in
    the first safe country. Also Germany and France both take in more than
    we do.


    I do know that we (in general) better off paying 30% tax back in the
    early 80's.

    Back in those days there wasn't an equality office in the land! And I
    don't recall any problem with illegal immigrants either.

    Blame Brexit for the boat people.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 05:22:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 22:34, John wrote:

    I've mixed feelings. In one sense I agree but in another I don't.

    I have no objection to someone taking HMRC down a peg or two if the
    latter are being greedy - but it is a bit rich to immediately turn round
    and declare that he is willing to pay more tax. Quite obviously he is
    *not* willing to pay more tax!

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 05:24:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 22:49, John wrote:

    It's actually -u47 a week for new claimants, but the -u100 a week is extra if you *can't* work full stop, and only if you're on universal credit.
    I'm not conviced that anxiety on it's own would trigger that benefit.
    It's called LCWR, and isn't an easy benefit to get.

    I don't know the details of the situation, but apparently questions have
    been asked in parliament about it, so it cannot be as rare or as hard to exploit as you appear to claim.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 05:39:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 23:15, John wrote:

    Oh, I doubt it.-a Perhaps we should do away with the state pension, given
    it makes up 44% of the welfare budget!

    Only if you refund all the pension contributions that workers have made
    over the years.

    On a serious note, what "unecessary" welfare payments would you do away with?

    I would restore the two child limit, abolish payments for anxiety and
    similar fashionable afflictions, and I would follow your suggestion (was
    it you or Tim?) and institute workfare. Those who want money from the
    state should work for it.

    Whether you like it or not, we have no choice to house "illegal
    immigrants", given it's a legal duty.

    Change the law. Some countries tell illegal immigrants to hand over all valuables to pay for their accommodation.

    I'm not aware of luxury homes
    being provided for druggies and the work-shy, perhaps you could
    enlighten me.

    Rhyl is plagued by big houses being turned into HMOs, where greedy
    landlords are cashing in on the money doled out by the welfare
    authorities for rent on behalf of druggies and alcoholics - and, of
    course, the people who come here claiming to be looking for work but
    really wanting a holiday by the seaside.

    I'm wondering though, isn't rejecting the foreigner in
    your land going against biblical principles?

    The Bible certainly instructs us not to discriminate against "the
    stranger within thy gates", but mass migration for economic benefit by
    people who refuse to assimilate is not, I think, the situation for which
    the Bible was written.

    To pick up on an earlier point, which I forgot to reply to.-a Under the Dublin agreement we could insist the asylum seeker did have to stop in
    the first safe country.-a Also Germany and France both take in more than
    we do.

    We *should* insist on that, as should Germany and France.

    Blame Brexit for the boat people.
    Really? I thought Brexit was responsible for the current heat wave and drought?

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 05:41:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 27/07/2026 22:55, John wrote:

    We agree, with the priviso that acute anxiety is a debillitating illness.

    And exactly how does lavishing money on people and allowing them to hide
    away at home at tax-payer expense, help them overcome their anxiety?

    SEND provision is the biggest expenditure of most councils nowadays,
    would you do away with that?
    As I don't know what SEND is, I can't comment.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 22:02:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 28/07/2026 05:39, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 23:15, John wrote:

    Oh, I doubt it.-a Perhaps we should do away with the state pension,
    given it makes up 44% of the welfare budget!

    Only if you refund all the pension contributions that workers have made
    over the years.

    On a serious note, what "unecessary" welfare payments would you do
    away with?

    I would restore the two child limit, abolish payments for anxiety and similar fashionable afflictions, and I would follow your suggestion (was
    it you or Tim?) and institute workfare. Those who want money from the
    state should work for it.

    Why would you restore the 2 child cap. Can you feed 3 mouths on the
    payment you get for 2 mouths?

    As I've previously said, you only get the universal credit payment if
    you can't work. PIP has an anxiety depictor but it isn't enough to
    receive PIP on it's own.

    It was Tim, but it's not something I would object to. Those who can work should work, I agree with you there. Some people lose their job through
    no fult of their own, so maybe a breathing space of 3 to 6 months to
    give them time to look for another job.


    Whether you like it or not, we have no choice to house "illegal
    immigrants", given it's a legal duty.

    Change the law. Some countries tell illegal immigrants to hand over all valuables to pay for their accommodation.

    To change the law you would need to abolish the EHCR and the 1953
    Refugee Convention.


    I'm not aware of luxury homes being provided for druggies and the
    work-shy, perhaps you could enlighten me.

    Rhyl is plagued by big houses being turned into HMOs, where greedy
    landlords are cashing in on the money doled out by the welfare
    authorities for rent on behalf of druggies and alcoholics - and, of
    course, the people who come here claiming to be looking for work but
    really wanting a holiday by the seaside.

    So bedsits then, not luxury housing. I've just looked up the housing
    benefit for Rhyl bedsits and it's -u78.80 a week. I'm guessing the actual
    rent will be more, so hardly greedy landlords cashing in. They could
    easily let those same rooms to single working people (or couples in a
    double bedsits).

    I'm wondering though, isn't rejecting the foreigner in your land going
    against biblical principles?

    The Bible certainly instructs us not to discriminate against "the
    stranger within thy gates", but mass migration for economic benefit by people who refuse to assimilate is not, I think, the situation for which
    the Bible was written.

    Leviticus 19:33-34 instructs, rCLWhen a foreigner resides among you in
    your land, do not mistreat them. The foreigner residing among you must
    be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were
    foreigners in Egypt. I am the Lord your God.rCY Similarly, Deuteronomy 10:18-19 states, rCLHe defends the cause of the fatherless and the widow,
    and loves the foreigner residing among you, giving them food and
    clothing. And you are to love those who are foreigners, for you
    yourselves were foreigners in Egypt. I am the LORD your God.rCY

    Seems pretty clear to me, there don't appear to be any get out clauses.


    To pick up on an earlier point, which I forgot to reply to.-a Under the
    Dublin agreement we could insist the asylum seeker did have to stop in
    the first safe country.-a Also Germany and France both take in more
    than we do.

    We *should* insist on that, as should Germany and France.

    But we can't, as the Dublin Agreement no longer applies. France won't
    want them back.

    Blame Brexit for the boat people.

    Really? I thought Brexit was responsible for the current heat wave and drought?

    hehe



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Tue Jul 28 22:07:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 28/07/2026 05:41, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 27/07/2026 22:55, John wrote:

    We agree, with the priviso that acute anxiety is a debillitating illness.

    And exactly how does lavishing money on people and allowing them to hide away at home at tax-payer expense, help them overcome their anxiety?

    I think you'll find acute anxiety is a heck of a lot more than someone strssing out every now and then.


    SEND provision is the biggest expenditure of most councils nowadays,
    would you do away with that?

    As I don't know what SEND is, I can't comment.

    Special Educational Needs and Disabilities. Children with autism and
    ADHD, amonst other things.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Jul 29 06:42:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 28/07/2026 22:07, John wrote:

    I think you'll find acute anxiety is a heck of a lot more than someone strssing out every now and then.

    Could well be - but not a million of them!

    Special Educational Needs and Disabilities. Children with autism and
    ADHD, amonst other things.
    Thank you. I am highly sceptical about ADHD, which in my opinion is
    actually a combination of poor diet and poor parenting.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Jul 29 06:40:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 28/07/2026 22:02, John wrote:

    Why would you restore the 2 child cap. Can you feed 3 mouths on the
    payment you get for 2 mouths?

    It is not a perfect solution - as you say, three can't live as cheaply
    as two - but it is *a* solution to those (and I have met some) who deliberately have lots of children with the sole purpose of getting lots
    of child benefit payments.

    As I've previously said, you only get the universal credit payment if
    you can't work. PIP has an anxiety depictor but it isn't enough to
    receive PIP on it's own.

    The figure I saw quoted yesterday was that there are a million young
    people claiming to be unable to work because of anxiety. I simply do not believe that so many young people are so inadequate that they cannot work.

    It was Tim, but it's not something I would object to. Those who can work should work, I agree with you there. Some people lose their job through
    no fult of their own, so maybe a breathing space of 3 to 6 months to
    give them time to look for another job.

    We agree - except that I wouldn't limit it to six months. It can be
    virtually impossible for an older person to find work.

    To change the law you would need to abolish the EHCR and the 1953
    Refugee Convention.

    I am all for abolishing the EHCR, which is a good idea in theory but
    whose judgements have caused me to lose all confidence in it. And no,
    you would not need to abolish the Refugee Convention, just apply it more vigorously and evenly. Someone who passes through a dozen safe countries
    to arrive in Britian is not a refugee.

    So bedsits then, not luxury housing.

    The houses were large and potentially luxurious before the landlord
    realised he could make more money out of splitting them into fifteen
    bedsits (or whatever the number is).

    I've just looked up the housing
    benefit for Rhyl bedsits and it's -u78.80 a week. I'm guessing the actual rent will be more, so hardly greedy landlords cashing in. They could
    easily let those same rooms to single working people (or couples in a
    double bedsits).

    Single working people are in short supply in Rhyl, particularly single
    working people prepared to live next door to alcoholics and drug
    addicts. In addition - though I'll agree that it is less of a problem
    now - most jobs in Rhyl were highly seasonal, so your single working
    person would be there from Easter to September and then either leave or
    cause problems by being unable to pay the rent. Letting to the DHSS,
    however, ensures a steady income for the landlord.

    Seems pretty clear to me, there don't appear to be any get out clauses.

    I'm all for treating foreigners the same as we treat natives. Do you
    know of many native Brits who get free housing and dole without limit?

    But we can't, as the Dublin Agreement no longer applies. France won't
    want them back.

    Smart French.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.religion.christian on Wed Jul 29 20:45:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 29/07/2026 06:40, Kendall K. Down wrote:
    On 28/07/2026 22:02, John wrote:

    Why would you restore the 2 child cap. Can you feed 3 mouths on the
    payment you get for 2 mouths?

    It is not a perfect solution - as you say, three can't live as cheaply
    as two - but it is *a* solution to those (and I have met some) who deliberately have lots of children with the sole purpose of getting lots
    of child benefit payments.

    I'm not against 3 as a limit, as long as there was a safety gap for a
    larger family who suddenly find the breadwinner unemployed through no
    fault of their own.

    An old friend's daughter and her partner had 5 children in about 6/7
    years whilst being unemployed, so I do know where you're coming from in
    that respect.

    As I've previously said, you only get the universal credit payment if
    you can't work. PIP has an anxiety depictor but it isn't enough to
    receive PIP on it's own.

    The figure I saw quoted yesterday was that there are a million young
    people claiming to be unable to work because of anxiety. I simply do not believe that so many young people are so inadequate that they cannot work.

    According to the Telegraph about 430,000 18-24 year olds claim sickness benefit, not all will be for anxiety, but let's assume most are. Not all
    of those will be unable to work and Andy Burnham is right to shift the
    focus onto helping young people to work. The link is behind a paywall so
    you might be able to quickly scan it before its blocked, or quickly
    press ctrl+p to bring the print version up which you can then read or
    print off.

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/07/26/andy-burnham-to-crack-down-on-youth-sickness-benefits/


    It was Tim, but it's not something I would object to. Those who can
    work should work, I agree with you there. Some people lose their job
    through no fult of their own, so maybe a breathing space of 3 to 6
    months to give them time to look for another job.

    We agree - except that I wouldn't limit it to six months. It can be virtually impossible for an older person to find work.

    Fair enough, so mostly younger people would come under workfare?

    To change the law you would need to abolish the EHCR and the 1953
    Refugee Convention.

    I am all for abolishing the EHCR, which is a good idea in theory but
    whose judgements have caused me to lose all confidence in it. And no,
    you would not need to abolish the Refugee Convention, just apply it more vigorously and evenly. Someone who passes through a dozen safe countries
    to arrive in Britian is not a refugee.

    The ECHR is not just about asylum seekers, so unless we have a bill of
    human rights that matches closely what else EHCR covers we're going to
    be worse off as a nation.

    Seems pretty clear to me, there don't appear to be any get out clauses.

    I'm all for treating foreigners the same as we treat natives. Do you
    know of many native Brits who get free housing and dole without limit?

    I keep hearing that foreigners get preferential treatment in respect of housing, I think both claims you make are untrue, but obviously those
    with larger families are going to be a higher priority than us brits who
    tend to have smaller families nowadays. It should, and as far as I know
    does, depend on priority need.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kendall K. Down@kendallkdown@googlemail.com to uk.religion.christian on Thu Jul 30 17:39:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    On 29/07/2026 20:45, John wrote:

    I'm not against 3 as a limit, as long as there was a safety gap for a
    larger family who suddenly find the breadwinner unemployed through no
    fault of their own.

    So we are agreed on a limit, just apparently disagreeing on what that
    limit should be.

    An old-a friend's daughter and her partner had 5 children in about 6/7
    years whilst being unemployed, so I do know where you're coming from in
    that respect.

    Alas that human greed can use children simply for economic benefit.

    According to the Telegraph about 430,000 18-24 year olds claim sickness benefit, not all will be for anxiety, but let's assume most are. Not all
    of those will be unable to work and Andy Burnham is right to shift the
    focus onto helping young people to work.

    I can't find the figure I quoted, but I fully agree on the need to get
    people back to work.

    Fair enough, so mostly younger people would come under workfare?

    I can't see why not. Actually, I would have not objection to older
    people getting workfare; the problem is not their unwillingness to work,
    it is the unwillingness of employers to take them on.

    The ECHR is not just about asylum seekers, so unless we have a bill of
    human rights that matches closely what else EHCR covers we're going to
    be worse off as a nation.

    We had all the rights we needed long before we joined the ECHR.

    I keep hearing that foreigners get preferential treatment in respect of housing, I think both claims you make are untrue, but obviously those
    with larger families are going to be a higher priority than us brits who tend to have smaller families nowadays.-a It should, and as far as I know does, depend on priority need.

    I don't see why people who come here illegally, bringing 17 children and
    3 wives, should be given priority at public expense. Nobody asked them
    to have so many children or even to come here. Better still, back to the workhouse conditions. Keep men and women separate, stop them having even
    more children and give them incentives to come off benefits.

    God bless,
    Kendall K. Down
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Stuart@Stuart.winsor@orpheusinternet.co.uk to uk.religion.christian on Tue Aug 18 12:30:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.religion.christian

    In article <114dl85$14vvt$1@dont-email.me>,
    John <megane.06@gmail.com> wrote:
    The ECHR is not just about asylum seekers, so unless we have a bill of
    human rights that matches closely what else EHCR covers we're going to
    be worse off as a nation.

    How did we manage before the EHCR existed?
    How do ther countries such as Australia or New Zealand manage without the
    EHCR?
    --
    Stuart Winsor

    Tools With A Mission
    sending tools across the world
    http://www.twam.co.uk/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2