On 22/05/2026 13:52, Madhu wrote:
I don't think the last point is a fair or honest comparison: it states
the defect isn't in christianity, but in the practice of christianity
("celibacy"), but analogously the defect is in unambiguously with islam.
Christian teaching - and Jewish teaching before it - is unambiguously
in favour of marriage. In fact, there is a warning against those who
would devalue marriage. So the celibacy heresy of the Catholic church
goes completely contrary to Christianity's sacred book.
The same cannot be said about Islam and jihad, which is taught in the
Qur'an.
The issues Ken has with "islam" are the reusult of the situation solely
through the lens solely of the western banking propaganda.
Strangely, in all the time I have been banking with Lloyds, I have
never seen anything in the bank either for or against Islam.
I'd suggest Ken read the few chapters before this dealing with the role
of britain and the war and oil banking industry in the middle east in
the 20th century, and see where the source of the antagonim (that he has
faced in his travels in Iran, Iraq etc.) comes from
I didn't know that there was an industry set up to bank oil? Probably
a good idea - store oil away and hopefully earn interest on it as it self-multiplies.
Yes, I know about Britain and Iran. A bit ironic that the British
government was busy nationalising everything in sight and trampling on
the rights of private owners, but got all hoity-toity when the
Iranians did the same with their oil industry!
If you get a chance to read the article, I'd appreciate your assesemntIt's an interesting thesis. Of course, the problem is that Islam's
of the author's claim.
It's an interesting thesis. Of course, the problem is that Islam's
response to European superiority was to retreat to an imagined
original Muslim religion instead of abandoning the false religion
entirely and adopting Christianity.
Islam, shorn of its saints and djinn and shrines, is still a
misogynistic, superstitious collection of Arab traditions that may
have passed muster in AD 700 but is totally unfit for the modern
world.
If you are basing this on the text rather than the people, the OT is no
less violent, and the text highlights the same principles and
whitewashes everything else.
As the article indicated, in practice,
despite the principles you highlight in the core text, was there was no dearth of science and arts and vast periods of peace and proseperity
between the conquests.
On 05/08/2026 01:37, Madhu wrote:
If you are basing this on the text rather than the people, the OT is noThe Old Testament does not force women to cover their faces or stay
less violent, and the text highlights the same principles and
whitewashes everything else.
inside their homes or prevent them being educated. If, by "violence"
you mean the use of the death penalty, then certainly the Old
Testament was violent, but you don't find individuals being encouraged
to kill those who transgress. In fact the "cities of refuge" was a
clear attempt to prevent individual killings.
As the article indicated, in practice, despite the principles you
highlight in the core text, was there was no dearth of science and
arts and vast periods of peace and proseperity between the conquests.
Yes, after the Muslims conquored somewhere, they profited from the
educated elite, but within a short time, after that elite had died
out, the Muslims sank back into ignorance and poverty, which is the inevitable outcome of their religion.
I don't see any basis for your claim. The muslims sank into ignorance
and poverty _after_ they were defeated and their economy became part of
the western banking economy
YourSurprisingly, Scripture has very little to say about Muhammad or his
arguments against Islam are just Israeli Propaganda points at this
point, and not from a consideration of scripture.
Surprisingly, Scripture has very little to say about Muhammad or his religion, which started 500 years after the canon of Scripture closed.
I think
1. We should interpret and witness to our present condition on the basis
of scripture and not on the basis of the dominant propaganda
2. You were handling "islamic scripture" in a non-proprietary waySo in other words, no one has any idea what you are trying to say
(where "witness to" and "non-proprietary" are non standard usage)
2. You were handling "islamic scripture" in a non-proprietary waySo in other words, no one has any idea what you are trying to say
(where "witness to" and "non-proprietary" are non standard usage)
because you are giving words your own meanings.
No, that was to cover the possibility of you dismissing what I wroteNo, your meaning was not at all clear.
without trying to understand it. (c.f. your response)
But as long as my meaning was clear
YourSurprisingly, Scripture has very little to say about Muhammad or his religion, which started 500 years after the canon of Scripture closed.
arguments against Islam are just Israeli Propaganda points at this
point, and not from a consideration of scripture.
On 06/08/2026 07:00, Madhu wrote:
No, that was to cover the possibility of you dismissing what I wrote without trying to understand it. (c.f. your response)No, your meaning was not at all clear.
But as long as my meaning was clear
On 05/08/2026 01:37, Madhu wrote:
If you are basing this on the text rather than the people, the OT is no
less violent, and the text highlights the same principles and
whitewashes everything else.
The Old Testament does not force women to cover their faces or stay
inside their homes or prevent them being educated. If, by "violence" you mean the use of the death penalty, then certainly the Old Testament was violent, but you don't find individuals being encouraged to kill those
who transgress. In fact the "cities of refuge" was a clear attempt to prevent individual killings.
With Wes Streeting, who is a practicing Christian, resigning as Health Secretary and a leadership battle more than likely, could he be our next
PM?
He's done an excellent job as Health Secretary, although I personally
would like Labour to go a little bit more to the left, helping the
ordinary man (and woman) in the street to have a better quality of life.
Either Andy Burnham or Angela Rayner would get my vote.
As we know Andy Burnham became PM, but he does become the firstSo, I believe, are most Mafioso.
Christian since TM anyway, as he is a devout Catholic.
Christian women did cover their hair, as do most Muslim women.
The
burka is worn by very few and, correct me if I'm wrong, more to do with culture than any Islamic text.
Women were considered property so their
place *was* in the home and "learning" was frowned upon, an example of
which was Martha's attitude to Mary.
Other than honour killings (I may be wrong but I don't think it is based
on the Qur'an) I don't know any other "offence" that individuals will kill.-a The death penalty is usually left to the state rulers to carry out.
I see Islam as more based on OT principles.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:43:59 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |