• well that's pants

    From Simon Wilson@siwilson@nodamnspamn.hotmail.com to uk.rec.motorcycles on Fri Nov 13 22:12:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    Daughter hit a deer a few days ago, managed to drive home ok.

    I looked at the damage, concluded that there was quite a lot of plastic
    bits busted and that she really should claim.

    Insurance say deer doesn't cause loss of no claims so that was the good
    news.

    Yesterday we got the report from the garage, they say not economical to repair. Bumper, headlight, air con + main radiator pushed back, yada yada.

    We reckon the car was worth about -u8K going by listings on Autotrader.

    Seems crazy.
    --
    /Simon
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From bp@bp@www.zefox.net to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 02:24:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    Simon Wilson <siwilson@nodamnspamn.hotmail.com> wrote:
    Daughter hit a deer a few days ago, managed to drive home ok.

    I looked at the damage, concluded that there was quite a lot of plastic
    bits busted and that she really should claim.

    Insurance say deer doesn't cause loss of no claims so that was the good news.

    Yesterday we got the report from the garage, they say not economical to repair. Bumper, headlight, air con + main radiator pushed back, yada yada.

    We reckon the car was worth about -u8K going by listings on Autotrader.

    Seems crazy.

    Maybe the shop just doesn't need the work. I'd look for a second
    (and maybe third) estimate, assuming the car was satisfactory
    prior to hitting the deer. The numbers that matter are the cost
    of repair versus the cost of a satisfactory replacement, which
    might have little to do with the car's book value.

    On the other hand, if a new car is wanted anyway, here's
    your ticket, no trade-in haggling required.

    bob prohaska

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Peter Fisher@spam@nospam.net to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 07:32:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    On 13/11/2026 22:12, Simon Wilson wrote:
    Daughter hit a deer a few days ago, managed to drive home ok.

    I looked at the damage, concluded that there was quite a lot of plastic
    bits busted and that she really should claim.

    Insurance say deer doesn't cause loss of no claims so that was the good news.

    Yesterday we got the report from the garage, they say not economical to repair. Bumper, headlight, air con + main radiator pushed back, yada yada.

    We reckon the car was worth about -u8K going by listings on Autotrader.

    Seems crazy.


    Is that an insurers recommended garage?

    You need an old fashioned body basher prepared to use second hand parts. Having said that, my usual one couldn't save the lad's Hyundai Getz.
    Mind you that was only worth -u1000.

    What have the Insco offered?
    --
    Moto Morini 2C/375 Gilera 175 Sport Honda CB250RS (Not Waynetta!) *2026
    Moto Morini 350 Sport* "Do not adjust your mind, there is a fault in the reality"
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From sweller@sweller@mztech.fsnet.co.uk to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 07:46:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    Peter Fisher wrote:

    Seems crazy.


    Is that an insurers recommended garage?

    You need an old fashioned body basher prepared to use second hand
    parts. Having said that, my usual one couldn't save the lad's Hyundai
    Getz. Mind you that was only worth -u1000.


    I think you can normally buy the car back as scrap - Simon may be able
    to get it fixed at a lower cost himself. Get a payout and keep the car
    (which will be pretty much unsellable though).

    I know the Jag insurance has a "buy back" clause.


    What have the Insco offered?

    My recent dealings with Ageas have been a little trying - the initially
    offered -u5,750 for the four year old Husqvarna. After a suitable reply
    they offered the somewhat precise -u8,147

    I'm still out of pocket but not as badly - I feel a Chinese motorcycle
    in my future.

    Meanwhile the 2003 BMW GSA has been dragged out of the shed and
    resurrected (new fuel pump, strainer, filter and some pipework, rebuilt
    front calipers). The list of MOT advisories is something to behold.

    I'll probably use that for the rest of the winter - it's got 173K miles
    on it so isn't worth anything.

    The Guzzi put in some miles while the BMW was being fixed - although
    I'm not prepared to leave that at the station overnight in the way I
    used to!
    --
    Simon
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Simon Wilson@siwilson@nodamnspamn.hotmail.com to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 11:38:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    On 14/11/2026 07:46, sweller wrote:
    Peter Fisher wrote:

    Seems crazy.


    Is that an insurers recommended garage?

    It's actually owned by Aviva now I believe. Used to do Directline
    before, possibly exclusive. Very reputable repairer, we have used them
    before.


    You need an old fashioned body basher prepared to use second hand
    parts. Having said that, my usual one couldn't save the lad's Hyundai
    Getz. Mind you that was only worth -u1000.


    Yeah some of the plastic parts could be repaired but you end up with a
    car that's recorded and difficult to move on.


    I think you can normally buy the car back as scrap - Simon may be able
    to get it fixed at a lower cost himself. Get a payout and keep the car (which will be pretty much unsellable though).

    I know the Jag insurance has a "buy back" clause.


    Have done this several times but in the end I'm not sure it's a good
    idea for a new-ish car.


    What have the Insco offered?

    Nothing yet as they were uncontactable the other day due to microsoft
    outage.


    My recent dealings with Ageas have been a little trying - the initially offered -u5,750 for the four year old Husqvarna. After a suitable reply
    they offered the somewhat precise -u8,147

    That's quite some difference. We have found an almost identical mileage
    and model car for sale so hoping to replace it. She really likes the
    car, Citroen C4. I quite like it too.


    I'm still out of pocket but not as badly - I feel a Chinese motorcycle
    in my future.

    Meanwhile the 2003 BMW GSA has been dragged out of the shed and
    resurrected (new fuel pump, strainer, filter and some pipework, rebuilt
    front calipers). The list of MOT advisories is something to behold.

    I'll probably use that for the rest of the winter - it's got 173K miles
    on it so isn't worth anything.

    I think you might be surprised.


    The Guzzi put in some miles while the BMW was being fixed - although
    I'm not prepared to leave that at the station overnight in the way I
    used to!

    --
    /Simon
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Peter Fisher@spam@nospam.net to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 11:54:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    On 14/11/2026 11:38, Simon Wilson wrote:
    On 14/11/2026 07:46, sweller wrote:
    Peter Fisher wrote:

    Seems crazy.


    Is that an insurers recommended garage?

    It's actually owned by Aviva now I believe. Used to do Directline
    before, possibly exclusive. Very reputable repairer, we have used them before.


    You need an old fashioned body basher prepared to use second hand
    parts. Having said that, my usual one couldn't save the lad's Hyundai
    Getz. Mind you that was only worth -u1000.


    Yeah some of the plastic parts could be repaired but you end up with a
    car that's recorded and difficult to move on.


    I think you can normally buy the car back as scrap - Simon may be able
    to get it fixed at a lower cost himself.-a Get a payout and keep the car
    (which will be pretty much unsellable though).

    I know the Jag insurance has a "buy back" clause.


    Have done this several times but in the end I'm not sure it's a good
    idea for a new-ish car.


    Quite. In the case of the Granvia it was to keep it out of the clutches
    of the Insco who would probably have written it off. Had it repaired, so
    not written off, and the no fault solicitor and their estimator did the business arguing about the cost. The bikes that had been on the trailer
    were 'write-offs', but that's another story.
    --
    Moto Morini 2C/375 Gilera 175 Sport Honda CB250RS (Not Waynetta!) *2026
    Moto Morini 350 Sport* "Do not adjust your mind, there is a fault in the reality"
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Theo@theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 12:54:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    Simon Wilson <siwilson@nodamnspamn.hotmail.com> wrote:
    On 14/11/2026 07:46, sweller wrote:
    Peter Fisher wrote:

    Seems crazy.


    Is that an insurers recommended garage?

    It's actually owned by Aviva now I believe. Used to do Directline
    before, possibly exclusive. Very reputable repairer, we have used them before.


    You need an old fashioned body basher prepared to use second hand
    parts. Having said that, my usual one couldn't save the lad's Hyundai
    Getz. Mind you that was only worth -u1000.


    Yeah some of the plastic parts could be repaired but you end up with a
    car that's recorded and difficult to move on.

    Has it been categorised yet?

    They've changed the categorisation system now... used to be based on
    economic repairability (cat C = beyond economic repair) but now it's based
    on structural damage. If it's bent the chassis legs it'll likely be a cat S implying structural damage. If it's a cat N (non-structural) then you'll
    have a better chance of selling it on.

    Insurance inspectors are sometimes overzealous in terms of categorising
    things as a cat S when there isn't structural damage, perhaps from photos having never seen the car. Something to watch for.

    That's quite some difference. We have found an almost identical mileage
    and model car for sale so hoping to replace it. She really likes the
    car, Citroen C4. I quite like it too.

    Really depends on what kind of payout they're offering. If you want to keep driving the car for years and are happy to drive a cat car knowing it's been professionally repaired, then the numbers could stack up towards keeping it. If you turn over cars regularly you might be more fussy about the hit to the resale value.

    I would be tempted to ask independent body shops for quotes asap before you make an insurance claim. eg if you don't claim you could avoid it being categorised. If an independent fix was say -u2k you could decide it's
    cheaper to pay that than make a claim, devalue the car with a cat marker,
    and have to pay elevated insurance policies for ~5 years having claimed.

    I don't know Citroen parts but it's not a rare car, so I suspect scrapyard
    bits are buttons compared with getting them from the main dealer.

    Theo
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From boots@news@millhouse-communications.co.uk to uk.rec.motorcycles on Sat Nov 14 13:33:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    On 14/11/2026 12:54 Theo penned these words:
    I would be tempted to ask independent body shops for quotes asap before you make an insurance claim. eg if you don't claim you could avoid it being categorised. If an independent fix was say -u2k you could decide it's cheaper to pay that than make a claim, devalue the car with a cat marker,
    and have to pay elevated insurance policies for ~5 years having claimed.
    The insurance quote for my shite old Vauxhall was -u5k+, they valued the car at -u3K, reluctantly they sold it back to me for -u10 as I recall so I got the car and almost all the money. Local garage had it back on the road for -u700. My daughter's Micra and the old Sierra my ex was driving we under -u100 for parts from the scrappy. In not one case did they mark them as write off on the V5C. --
    Ian

    "Man will never be free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest"
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Champ@neal@champ.org.uk to uk.rec.motorcycles on Mon Nov 16 14:59:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.motorcycles

    On 14 Nov 2026 07:46:17 GMT, "sweller" <sweller@mztech.fsnet.co.uk>
    wrote:

    Meanwhile the 2003 BMW GSA has been dragged out of the shed and
    resurrected (new fuel pump, strainer, filter and some pipework, rebuilt
    front calipers). The list of MOT advisories is something to behold.

    Post the list! Post the list!
    --
    Champ
    neal at champ dot org dot uk

    I don't know, but I been told
    You never slow down, you never grow old
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2