They propose annual emissions checks on nearly all vehicles
(including bikes) and that they must never emit more nasty stuff than
they did when new.
They propose annual emissions checks on nearly all vehicles
(including bikes) and that they must never emit more nasty stuff
than they did when new.
"As vehicles particularly historic vehicles age it is unrealistic to
expect them to match the manufacturers stated performances at new."
I filled in the form mostly saying it was a good idea but that
historic (pre-Euro 1) vehicles should be exempted.
smoky engine
which is burning oil would not be covered (bad piston rings etc
probably aren't covered by 'normal servicing').
The only thing that you can be absolutely certain of any powers
granted will be overreached and misused because they always are.
Simon Wilson wrote:
They propose annual emissions checks on nearly all vehicles
(including bikes) and that they must never emit more nasty stuff than
they did when new.
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuring vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions (Euro 3)?
I get the point of solving congestion problems but it is possible to do
both - ensure that vehicles are maintained and, importantly, not
modified, to continue to comply as well as encourage a shift away from
cars.
Simon Wilson wrote:
They propose annual emissions checks on nearly all vehicles
(including bikes) and that they must never emit more nasty stuff than
they did when new.
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuring vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions (Euro 3)?
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuring
vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions
(Euro 3)?
It's the retrospective nature of it.
The current owner of a vehicle may not realise it was modified twenty
years and numerous owners previously, and the parts to un-modify it
may not be available.
As someone that used to be involved in atmospheric pollution control,
I'm far more concerned about NOx and particulates than CO2.
"...encourage a shift away from cars." Aha, the other item on the
agenda for alternative motives perhaps?
I quite like travelling by train. I shall use one to get to the NEC
to ogle at model ones next month, but only because I my old gimmers
Centro pass will get me to Birmingham International gratis.
If the
new way of running things means they arrive and depart with some
resemblance to the timetable I might use them more.
Sqirrel99 wrote:
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuring
vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions
(Euro 3)?
It's the retrospective nature of it.
The current owner of a vehicle may not realise it was modified twenty
years and numerous owners previously, and the parts to un-modify it
may not be available.
...and what about the, significantly more likely, larger number of
people who know they've unlawfully modified their vehicle?
If we're not going to enforce the rules what's the point of having them?
Sqirrel99 wrote:I don't disagree with this statement, but...
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuringIt's the retrospective nature of it.
vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions
(Euro 3)?
The current owner of a vehicle may not realise it was modified twenty
years and numerous owners previously, and the parts to un-modify it
may not be available.
...and what about the, significantly more likely, larger number of
people who know they've unlawfully modified their vehicle?
If we're not going to enforce the rules what's the point of having them?
It is unclear to me that there are any regulations that say that
motorcyles must be maintained such that emissions do not increase
over the lifetime of the vehicle (prior to Euro5+ which makes this
explicit).
The proposal also acknowledges that there is no 'evidence specific to
in-use emissions from motorcycle', but that they will include them in
the legislation anyway.
So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating new ones
that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
Sqirrel99 wrote:
So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating new ones
that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
I disagree - it's that the vehicle needs to meet the Euro standard it
was registered with. It's not a retrospective change in the standard
that the vehicle needs to meet - it's just that it is now going to
enforced.
Sqirrel99 wrote:
It is unclear to me that there are any regulations that say that
motorcyles must be maintained such that emissions do not increase
over the lifetime of the vehicle (prior to Euro5+ which makes this
explicit).
My guess would be the Construction and Use regs - which make it an
offence to modify the emissions systems so that they are less effective
than at first registration - so removing, Cats, adding Power Commanders
etc. would probably contravene this long standing regulation.
The proposal also acknowledges that there is no 'evidence specific to
in-use emissions from motorcycle', but that they will include them in
the legislation anyway.
They were already covered by C&U regs.
So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating new ones
that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
I disagree - it's that the vehicle needs to meet the Euro standard it
was registered with.
It's not a retrospective change in the standard
that the vehicle needs to meet - it's just that it is now going to
enforced.
They were already covered by C&U regs.
I'm not sure this is the case.
Section 61A of the Construction and Use regs is the bit that deals
with emissions and removing cats etc. and this doesn't apply to
motorcycles (something that is noted in the DfT proposal).
So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating new
ones that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
I disagree - it's that the vehicle needs to meet the Euro standard
it was registered with.
This is the part that I can't find legislation for.
Do the Euro regulations say anything about ongoing emissions, or only
those at the time of manufacture ?
Sqirrel99 wrote:
They were already covered by C&U regs.
I'm not sure this is the case.
Section 61A of the Construction and Use regs is the bit that deals
with emissions and removing cats etc. and this doesn't apply to
motorcycles (something that is noted in the DfT proposal).
Reg 61 applies to bikes because key parts are expressed in terms
ofrCLevery vehiclerCY andrCLany motor vehicle" - rather than specifically "car" "light commercial"
This is the part that I can't find legislation for.So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating newI disagree - it's that the vehicle needs to meet the Euro standard
ones that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
it was registered with.
Do the Euro regulations say anything about ongoing emissions, or only
those at the time of manufacture ?
The durability/type-approval requirement is for 100,000 miles/5 years(referenced in the Gov't consultation)
"Emissions standards are regulated in accordance with this broad
framework and manufacturers must also demonstrate that their emissions technology performs as expected for 100,000 km or 5 years, whichever
occurs sooner. This applies to properly maintained and used vehicles. A durability requirement also applies to separate pollution control
devices, such as catalytic converters, which must last for 160,000 km."
sweller wrote:
Sqirrel99 wrote:
They were already covered by C&U regs.
I'm not sure this is the case.
Section 61A of the Construction and Use regs is the bit that deals
with emissions and removing cats etc. and this doesn't apply to
motorcycles (something that is noted in the DfT proposal).
Reg 61 applies to bikes because key parts are expressed in terms
ofrCLevery vehiclerCY andrCLany motor vehicle" - rather than specifically
"car" "light commercial"
Isn't that the problem though ?
Reg 61 binds all vehicles to emissions standards set in 1996.
Reg 61a extends this for vehicles built after 2001, binding them to the
Euro regs at the time of construction, but has not been updated beyond
2009 and does not apply to motorcycles at all.
This is the part that I can't find legislation for.So this is not about enforcing existing rules, but creating newI disagree - it's that the vehicle needs to meet the Euro standard
ones that apply retrospectively (which is always problematic).
it was registered with.
Do the Euro regulations say anything about ongoing emissions, or only
those at the time of manufacture ?
The durability/type-approval requirement is for 100,000 miles/5
years(referenced in the Gov't consultation)
"Emissions standards are regulated in accordance with this broad
framework and manufacturers must also demonstrate that their emissions
technology performs as expected for 100,000 km or 5 years, whichever
occurs sooner. This applies to properly maintained and used vehicles. A
durability requirement also applies to separate pollution control
devices, such as catalytic converters, which must last for 160,000 km."
Simon Wilson wrote:
They propose annual emissions checks on nearly all vehicles
(including bikes) and that they must never emit more nasty stuff than
they did when new.
A bit late to this party but what's the problem with ensuring vehicles registered after 2001 maintain their stated emissions (Euro 3)?
I get the point of solving congestion problems but it is possible to do
both - ensure that vehicles are maintained and, importantly, not
modified, to continue to comply as well as encourage a shift away from
cars.
Place bets now.
On 30 Oct 2026 at 08:45:17 GMT, ""sweller"" <sweller@mztech.fsnet.co.uk> wrote:
Place bets now.
/ [UKRM Pedantry: ITYM "Prace bets now?"] /
On 01/11/2026 19:59, Another John wrote:
On 30 Oct 2026 at 08:45:17 GMT, ""sweller"" <sweller@mztech.fsnet.co.uk>
wrote:
Place bets now.
/ [UKRM Pedantry: ITYM "Prace bets now?"] /
racist
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:05:20 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,220 |