predicted to be an hour late southbound.
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing theYou're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
On 2026-11-11 1:09 p.m., Roland Perry wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing theYou're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to
various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
Nobody <jock@soccer.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-11 1:09 p.m., Roland Perry wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to >>> various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
You're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
This was what was advertised, which seems perfectly accurate. But, of
course, you did need to read it before booking:
https://saphostrains.com/journey/the-cumbrian-mountaineer-11-11-2026/
On 2026-11-11 1:09 p.m., Roland Perry wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But
chatting to various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be
an hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and >>Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's >>layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
You're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
Why anyone would take a railtour scheduled to cross Ribblehead ~1705--
when local sunset for 11 Nov is ~1615?
In message <11d2vuc$3gr3f$1@dont-email.me>, at 17:06:34 on Wed, 11 Nov
2026, Nobody <jock@soccer.com> remarked:
On 2026-11-11 1:09 p.m., Roland Perry wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But
chatting to various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be
an hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
You're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
It was advertised like that, but I booked it in a hurry (did you not see
"I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip". Assuming like many others that it would at worst be twilight.
Of course it was then over an hour late.
Why anyone would take a railtour scheduled to cross Ribblehead ~1705
when local sunset for 11 Nov is ~1615?
On 2026-11-11 1:09 p.m., Roland Perry wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing theYou're saying the return route wasn't advertised that way originally?
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to
various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
Why anyone would take a railtour scheduled to cross Ribblehead ~1705
when local sunset for 11 Nov is ~1615?
I guess one has to Settle for whatever's available in Remembrance.
Why anyone would take a railtour scheduled to cross Ribblehead ~1705
when local sunset for 11 Nov is ~1615?
IrCOve been over the S&C on a rail tour and found it disappointing. Probably >better to be lineside looking at the trains rather than being on the train.
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to >various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
So-called First Class, but it's actually Standard Class in First Class >carriages. No welcome drink, snacks, place settings, free tea/coffee at
seat etc. There was never planned to be a Premier service on this train.
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 20:09:15 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk>
wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
In what way is it good that almost everyone has a mobile phone :-)
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to
various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
So-called First Class, but it's actually Standard Class in First Class
carriages. No welcome drink, snacks, place settings, free tea/coffee at
seat etc. There was never planned to be a Premier service on this train.
What makes you think a railtour has the same definition of 'First
Class' as a scheduled service? I posted a letter First Class and did
not receive free tea and coffee.
And, incidentally, IrCOm surprised he was surprised that the whole train was >turned at Carlisle. This is normal with steam charters on that route, as >itrCOs much simpler, and requires fewer shunting movements, than turning the >steam engine, tender and support coach, then swapping both locos round.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 20:09:15 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk>
wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
In what way is it good that almost everyone has a mobile phone :-)
Roland had misinterpreted SaphosrCOs request that mobile phones be only used in the vestibules, and wrongly thought they were banned entirely.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to >>> various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
So-called First Class, but it's actually Standard Class in First Class
carriages. No welcome drink, snacks, place settings, free tea/coffee at >>> seat etc. There was never planned to be a Premier service on this train.
What makes you think a railtour has the same definition of 'First
Class' as a scheduled service? I posted a letter First Class and did
not receive free tea and coffee.
Saohos makes perfectly clear what each class includes, but it appears
Roland failed to read it, and wasnrCOt aware of the dark evenings in northern England in mid-November, nor the approximate timings. That probably
explains the relative unpopularity of this winter trip, and why there was
no Pullman dining offered. The equivalent trip in brighter months does include the dining option.
He also seems not to be aware just how late the train was in to Carlisle, which explains its subsequent late departure:
In message <zjiJS.68$%12.17@fx11.ams1>, Recliner
<recliner.usenet@gmail.com> writes
And, incidentally, IrCOm surprised he was surprised that the whole train was >>turned at Carlisle. This is normal with steam charters on that route, as >>itrCOs much simpler, and requires fewer shunting movements, than turning the >>steam engine, tender and support coach, then swapping both locos round.
I'm not.
I've done several tours that stop at Carlisle, and (so far as I
remember), none of them has seen a reversal of the carriages, just the >loco(s) and support coach. The stock usually remains at the platform
whilst the loco(s) are away, and my seat remains on the same side of the >train (if it was platform side when it came in, it was platform side
when it left).
That said, I've only done tours at weekends, weekdays may be different,
if only because of platform availability.
So-called First Class, but it's actually Standard Class in First Class >>carriages. No welcome drink, snacks, place settings, free tea/coffee at >>seat etc. There was never planned to be a Premier service on this train.
What makes you think a railtour has the same definition of 'First
Class' as a scheduled service? I posted a letter First Class and did
not receive free tea and coffee.
He needs an updated version of his Pervert Glasses equipped with night >vision mode.
On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 14:41:50 +0000, Adrian <bulleid@ku.gro.lioff> wrote:
In message <zjiJS.68$%12.17@fx11.ams1>, Recliner
<recliner.usenet@gmail.com> writes
And, incidentally, IrCOm surprised he was surprised that the whole train was
turned at Carlisle. This is normal with steam charters on that route, as >>> itrCOs much simpler, and requires fewer shunting movements, than turning the
steam engine, tender and support coach, then swapping both locos round.
I'm not.
I've done several tours that stop at Carlisle, and (so far as I
remember), none of them has seen a reversal of the carriages, just the
loco(s) and support coach. The stock usually remains at the platform
whilst the loco(s) are away, and my seat remains on the same side of the
train (if it was platform side when it came in, it was platform side
when it left).
That said, I've only done tours at weekends, weekdays may be different,
if only because of platform availability.
It's certainly a lot simpler to simply turn the whole train on the triangle south of the station. No need to run the
locos round, or water the coaches on the platform.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 20:09:15 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk>
wrote:
The good bits: pristine locomotive, comfy seats, and staff doing the
best they can. No inspection for corkage, and almost everyone has a
mobile phone.
In what way is it good that almost everyone has a mobile phone :-)
Roland had misinterpreted SaphosrCOs request that mobile phones be only used >in the vestibules, and wrongly thought they were banned entirely.
What I blame myself for: not fully researching the trip. But chatting to >>> various other pax, they are in the same boat.
The not so good bits: An hour late northbound, and predicted to be an
hour late southbound. Puzzling that it's returning via Settle and
Carlise after dark, when therefore nothing to see. And why an hour's
layover in Blackburn (watering was done at Settle).
So-called First Class, but it's actually Standard Class in First Class
carriages. No welcome drink, snacks, place settings, free tea/coffee at
seat etc. There was never planned to be a Premier service on this train.
What makes you think a railtour has the same definition of 'First
Class' as a scheduled service? I posted a letter First Class and did
not receive free tea and coffee.
Saohos makes perfectly clear what each class includes, but it appears
Roland failed to read it
, and wasnrCOt aware of the dark evenings in northern England in >mid-November,
nor the approximate timings.
That probably explains the relative unpopularity of this winter trip,
and why there was no Pullman dining offered. The equivalent trip in
brighter months does include the dining option.
https://saphostrains.com/dining-hospitality/
HererCOs an equivalent itinerary for next June, when there should be ample >daylight, that does include approximate timings:
https://saphostrains.com/journey/settle-carlisle-fellsman-09-06-2027/
He also wasnrCOt aware of the class 57 on the back, which is strange,
as people on steam tours always care about whether their steam loco is
being assisted up the gradients. In this case, apparently 57302 was
working hard on the outward leg (when Roland thought it wasnrCOt even >attached),
as 6024 had problems.
https://www.railadvent.co.uk/events/the-cumbrian-mountaineer-4
He also seems not to be aware just how late the train was in to Carlisle,
which explains its subsequent late departure:
https://www.realtimetrains.co.uk/service/gb-nr:U05891/2026-11-11/detaile >d?s=5003
And, incidentally, IrCOm surprised he was surprised that the whole train was >turned at Carlisle. This is normal with steam charters on that route, as >itrCOs much simpler, and requires fewer shunting movements, than turning the >steam engine, tender and support coach, then swapping both locos round.
It is several years since I last travelled on a main-line steam
special. They often compare unfavourably with tours I used in the 1960s
in terms of timings and motive power. Also, the occasional tour from >Liverpool to Carlisle via Shap only gets steam haulage Between
Carnforth and Carlisle, then returning south via Settle via Blackburn
only as far as Preston with steam.
In message <zjiJS.68$%12.17@fx11.ams1>, Recliner
<recliner.usenet@gmail.com> writes
And, incidentally, IrCOm surprised he was surprised that the whole train was >>turned at Carlisle. This is normal with steam charters on that route, as >>itrCOs much simpler, and requires fewer shunting movements, than turning the >>steam engine, tender and support coach, then swapping both locos round.
I'm not.
I've done several tours that stop at Carlisle, and (so far as I
remember), none of them has seen a reversal of the carriages, just the >loco(s) and support coach. The stock usually remains at the platform
whilst the loco(s) are away, and my seat remains on the same side of
the train (if it was platform side when it came in, it was platform
side when it left).
That said, I've only done tours at weekends, weekdays may be different,
if only because of platform availability.
In message <11d4uf5$5jep$1@dont-email.me>, at 17:53:40 on Thu, 12 Nov
2026, Bevan Price <bevanprice666@gmail.com> remarked:
It is several years since I last travelled on a main-line steam
special. They often compare unfavourably with tours I used in the
1960s in terms of timings and motive power. Also, the occasional tour
from Liverpool to Carlisle via Shap only gets steam haulage Between
Carnforth and Carlisle, then returning south via Settle via Blackburn
only as far as Preston with steam.
The trip this week was primarily to prove the newly refurbished loco on
the main line. Hence was steam hauled throughout.
I've been on plenty of rail tours where some (especially south of Peterborough) or all of the return leg was diesel hauled.
On 13/11/2026 00:28, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11d4uf5$5jep$1@dont-email.me>, at 17:53:40 on Thu, 12 Nov >>2026, Bevan Price <bevanprice666@gmail.com> remarked:
It is several years since I last travelled on a main-line steam >>>special. They often compare unfavourably with tours I used in the
1960s in terms of timings and motive power. Also, the occasional tour >>>from Liverpool to Carlisle via Shap only gets steam haulage Between >>>Carnforth and Carlisle, then returning south via Settle via Blackburn >>>only as far as Preston with steam.
The trip this week was primarily to prove the newly refurbished loco
on the main line. Hence was steam hauled throughout.
I've been on plenty of rail tours where some (especially south of >>Peterborough) or all of the return leg was diesel hauled.
I have also been on some all-diesel railtours, but not for several
years.
There are only a few (mostly freight only) lines that I have not
covered, and timings made many tours too much like hard work. A long
drive to/from the starting point, and gettimg home around (or after) >midnight was not fun.
Also there were almost always a few passengers who made travel for
others unpleasant by consuming too many cans of beer....
In message <11d7jgt$19mbv$1@dont-email.me>, at 18:05:14 on Fri, 13 Nov
2026, Bevan Price <bevanprice666@gmail.com> remarked:
Also there were almost always a few passengers who made travel for
others unpleasant by consuming too many cans of beer....
Never encountered that, thankfully.
On 13/11/2026 00:28, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11d4uf5$5jep$1@dont-email.me>, at 17:53:40 on Thu, 12 Nov
2026, Bevan Price <bevanprice666@gmail.com> remarked:
It is several years since I last travelled on a main-line steam
special. They often compare unfavourably with tours I used in the
1960s in terms of timings and motive power. Also, the occasional tour
from Liverpool to Carlisle via Shap only gets steam haulage Between
Carnforth and Carlisle, then returning south via Settle via Blackburn
only as far as Preston with steam.
The trip this week was primarily to prove the newly refurbished loco on
the main line. Hence was steam hauled throughout.
I've been on plenty of rail tours where some (especially south of
Peterborough) or all of the return leg was diesel hauled.
I have also been on some all-diesel railtours, but not for several
years. There are only a few (mostly freight only) lines that I have not covered, and timings made many tours too much like hard work. A long
drive to/from the starting point, and gettimg home around (or after) midnight was not fun. Also there were almost always a few passengers who made travel for others unpleasant by consuming too many cans of beer....
I have also been on some all-diesel railtours, but not for several
years. There are only a few (mostly freight only) lines that I have not
covered, and timings made many tours too much like hard work. A long
drive to/from the starting point, and gettimg home around (or after)
midnight was not fun. Also there were almost always a few passengers who
made travel for others unpleasant by consuming too many cans of beer....
At one time as older diesel classes were used on tours before they
withdrawn it seemed that a good number of the participants regarded >rumbustious behaviour as being part of the tour.
Mk 1 coaches gave them plenty of opportunity to wave arms , and shout
loudly from the droplight windows the practices becoming known as
flailing and bellowing much of it fuelled by beer. The occasional moon
was not unheard of. Some of those involved justified there behaviour by >saying it was aimed at line side spotters and photographers who would
not buy a ticket for a tour but got some benefit from it but really
there were just boorish oafs misbehaving.
I would think a few people were put off such tours not wishing to be in the >company of such people.
The cost of Railtours now
and the decreasing use of MK one stock has--
probably seen the practice decline.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> posted:
In message <11d7jgt$19mbv$1@dont-email.me>, at 18:05:14 on Fri, 13 Nov
2026, Bevan Price <bevanprice666@gmail.com> remarked:
Also there were almost always a few passengers who made travel for
others unpleasant by consuming too many cans of beer....
Never encountered that, thankfully.
Because you happen to be one of them? Or too much of other booze?
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:29:05 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |