• Class 175

    From Scott@newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 14:28:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ulf Kutzner@user2991@newsgrouper.org.invalid to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 14:45:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> posted:

    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Is it a graffity or other matter?

    To prevent non-graffity problems like corrosion and mold,
    I read trains should run maybe once per week.

    Regards, ULF
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Theo@theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 14:46:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    I'm no expert, but AIUI leased trains have to be returned to the lessor in working condition. The lessor doesn't have their own workshops, so they can only issue contracts to third parties. They contract somebody to store
    them. Then somebody else comes along and wants to lease them. The lessor
    is responsible for paying for the work to bring them up to usable condition again but they don't have anywhere to do this work themselves. GWR does
    have a workshop. So I'd not be surprised if the lease deal either includes
    a payment for remedial work or a discount on the leasing costs if they do
    it.

    Not much different from handing back a rented house at the end of the
    tenancy. If it's empty for a while the agent might redecorate during the
    void period, but if the new tenant wants to do it themselves maybe they can negotiate some amount off the rent.

    Theo
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 14:57:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is between the DfT and TfW.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Anna Noyd-Dryver@anna@noyd-dryver.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 15:21:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?


    I doubt it's anything to do with TfW or the Welsh Government - IIRC the
    175s went through a programme of repairs before being returned to the
    leasing company.

    Their period in storage will be the responsibility of the ROSCO, and also
    the DfT's rolling stock strategy (or lack thereof).

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Scott@newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 16:06:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See: https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tweed@usenet.tweed@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 16:11:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >> between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See: https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.


    Yes, we need to differentiate between defacto nationalisation and dejura nationalisation.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 16:18:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    In message <11csrcf$1d222$1@dont-email.me>, at 16:11:59 on Mon, 9 Nov
    2026, Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> remarked:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.


    Yes, we need to differentiate between defacto nationalisation and dejura >nationalisation.

    More importantly, who is paying for this extra refurbishment? Is it FirstGroup's shareholders, or someone else.
    --
    Roland Perry
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 16:37:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >> between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See: https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
    the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
    managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator
    on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 17:11:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    In message <WEmIS.61$%12.56@fx11.ams1>, at 16:37:10 on Mon, 9 Nov 2026, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> remarked:

    FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are almost certainly smarter than
    their DfT counterparts.

    I have a testimonial from a senior Civil Servant, which says [in code of course] "Roland is a great asset to the community, not least because he
    runs rings around our department's in-house lawyers, which I find quite
    fun to watch".
    --
    Roland Perry
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 17:41:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator
    on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.



    Just to add some financial figures:

    GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
    management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.


    I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such
    as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
    FirstGroup?

    With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
    transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail interests.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tweed@usenet.tweed@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 17:48:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
    damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
    just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
    between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
    franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
    managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >> refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and
    costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock
    (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting
    certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure >> that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its >> fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.



    Just to add some financial figures:

    GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
    management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
    fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.


    I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
    FirstGroup?

    With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail interests.


    DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bevan Price@bevanprice666@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 19:13:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    On 09/11/2026 14:57, Recliner wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.

    That is only partly true. They had prolonged teething problems when new,
    but after a few years they seemed just as reliable as most other UK
    dmus... But recent open storage for a few years saw them deteriorate,
    and it is taking rather long for them to be sorted out. Meantime, their
    TfW successors, Class 197, are also having prolonged teething problems.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Scott@newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 19:57:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:37:10 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
    outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
    wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnAt want to admit to nationalising the >franchises, but thatAs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
    the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donAt think anyone >refers to LO as being in the private sector!

    I think the argument is that legal ownership transfers from First
    Greater Western Limited (owned by First) Greater Western Railway
    Limited (owned by HM Government) on 13 December; and this is the
    definition of 'nationalisation'. Would you argue that the companies
    running London's buses are nationalised because they are part of a
    network specified by TfL?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 22:02:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>> wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
    damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
    work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
    just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
    between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
    franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >>> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
    managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >>> refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >>> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >>> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >>> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
    that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
    fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >>> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.



    Just to add some financial figures:

    GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
    management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m >> available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
    fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.


    I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such >> as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any
    senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
    FirstGroup?

    With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
    transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail >> interests.


    DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?

    No, of course not. The 802s were procured through a conventional ROSCO (Eversholt, now Beacon), rather than being supplied by Agility Trains. I
    assume the ROSCO-supplied trains are much cheaper.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Mon Nov 9 22:03:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:37:10 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
    Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
    acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
    Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
    leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
    condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
    properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
    electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
    damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
    just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
    between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didn-At want to admit to nationalising the >> franchises, but that-As exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
    have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
    managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I don-At think anyone
    refers to LO as being in the private sector!

    I think the argument is that legal ownership transfers from First
    Greater Western Limited (owned by First) Greater Western Railway
    Limited (owned by HM Government) on 13 December; and this is the
    definition of 'nationalisation'.

    IrCOd say it was *LabourrCOs* definition of nationalisation. Another way of describing it would be taking the concession in-house.

    The question now is whether moving the concession to DFTO reduces or
    increases costs compared to that 1% payment to a concession holder.

    But the evidence suggests that performance (ie, passenger service quality) falls as the concessions are taken in-house. It seems that those small performance incentives paid to the private concession holders did indeed improve performance.


    Would you argue that the companies
    running London's buses are nationalised because they are part of a
    network specified by TfL?

    IrCOd describe London buses as a concession, but one difference is that the buses (apart from the Boris buses) are supplied (ie, normally leased) by
    the bus companies, not TfL. When a concession changes, so do the buses. ThatrCOs not the case with the rail concessions. TfL is now experimenting
    with an in-house bus concession, to compare the business models.

    In the past, rail franchises sometimes acquired/provided some of their own trains, such as some GWR HSTs, the Chiltern bubble cars and the Chiltern Mk
    3 stock (plus the 67s were supplied by DB, ChilternrCOs owner). I assume
    these parent company trains were leased by the TOC, with the permission of
    the DfT.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tweed@usenet.tweed@gmail.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 06:04:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>>> wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being >>>>>>> acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for >>>>>>> Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the >>>>>>> leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable >>>>>>> condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets >>>>>>> properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
    damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
    work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the >>>>>>> Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
    just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
    between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
    franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
    the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They >>>> have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >>>> managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >>>> refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
    have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >>>> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >>>> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >>>> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
    that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
    fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >>>> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.



    Just to add some financial figures:

    GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
    management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m >>> available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
    fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.


    I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such >>> as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any >>> senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
    FirstGroup?

    With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
    transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail >>> interests.


    DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT
    indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?

    No, of course not. The 802s were procured through a conventional ROSCO (Eversholt, now Beacon), rather than being supplied by Agility Trains. I assume the ROSCO-supplied trains are much cheaper.


    But is the lease of those trains indemnified by DfT?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 11:08:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>>>> wrote:

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
    I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being >>>>>>>> acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for >>>>>>>> Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the >>>>>>>> leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable >>>>>>>> condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets >>>>>>>> properly?

    Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
    damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
    work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the >>>>>>>> Welsh Government?

    Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
    just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
    between the DfT and TfW.

    I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
    https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership

    The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
    franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
    the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They >>>>> have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >>>>> managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone
    refers to LO as being in the private sector!


    I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not >>>>>> have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
    nationalisation has not yet taken place.

    As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>>>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>>>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being
    re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).

    FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator
    on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>>>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be
    impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
    that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
    fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are
    almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.



    Just to add some financial figures:

    GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
    management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m
    available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
    fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.


    I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such
    as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any >>>> senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
    FirstGroup?

    With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
    transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail
    interests.


    DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT
    indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?

    No, of course not. The 802s were procured through a conventional ROSCO
    (Eversholt, now Beacon), rather than being supplied by Agility Trains. I
    assume the ROSCO-supplied trains are much cheaper.


    But is the lease of those trains indemnified by DfT?

    Trains have a much longer life than the old franchise lengths, so the DfT always had to guarantee lease continuity using section 54 agreements.
    However, this arrangement came to an end in 2014, so the GWR 802s might
    have been acquired without that particular guarantee. However, as the DfT wanted to ensure that GWR ordered IETs very similar to the 800s, and not
    some other lower cost design it might have preferred and which might be
    more attractive to another franchise in the future, I think the DfT must
    have provided Eversholt with some sort of guarantee of a minimum lease
    period.

    Incidentally, most of the early section 54 agreements have now expired, so
    GBR will not be locked into retaining most of its inherited stock that was originally covered by section 54 agreements. ItrCOs up to the ROSCOs to keep those fleets refurbished and cheaper to lease than new builds. The only exceptions are the class 800 and 801 fleets, which have unusually long guarantees of 27.5 years after the acceptance date of the first set in each fleet, and the class 700s, which have another guaranteed decade. It looks
    like the ROSCOs wouldnrCOt touch the DfTrCOs own, poor train designs without unusually long lease guarantees.

    Of course, the lack of section 54 guarantees will simply mean that lease
    costs of new fleets are higher, as they have to, in effect, include an insurance premium against early lease termination. Or maybe GBR will simply have to guarantee, say, 25-30 year leases.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Anna Noyd-Dryver@anna@noyd-dryver.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 14:56:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?


    I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a
    result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
    time in a year or so.

    I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
    months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Recliner@recliner.usenet@gmail.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 15:55:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?


    I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
    time in a year or so.

    I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
    months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.


    Why the climb in share price? Has there been some good news thatrCOs not
    been widely reported?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Anna Noyd-Dryver@anna@noyd-dryver.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 16:55:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?


    I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a
    result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
    time in a year or so.

    I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed >> relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
    months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.


    Why the climb in share price? Has there been some good news thatrCOs not been widely reported?



    No idea!

    But I'm not complaining

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tweed@usenet.tweed@gmail.com to uk.railway on Tue Nov 10 17:52:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.railway

    Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
    Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
    Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
    Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:


    Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
    FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
    Welsh Government?


    I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a
    result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
    time in a year or so.

    I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed >>> relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
    months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.


    Why the climb in share price? Has there been some good news thatrCOs not
    been widely reported?



    No idea!

    But I'm not complaining



    This gives an explanation

    https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/firstgroup-shares-hit-52-week-094233024.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2