I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly? Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >between the DfT and TfW.
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See: https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >> between the DfT and TfW.
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
Yes, we need to differentiate between defacto nationalisation and dejura >nationalisation.
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See: https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >> between the DfT and TfW.
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are almost certainly smarter than
their DfT counterparts.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone refers to LO as being in the private sector!
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).
FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator
on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >> refers to LO as being in the private sector!
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and
costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock
(unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).
FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting
certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure >> that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its >> fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.
Just to add some financial figures:
GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.
I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
FirstGroup?
With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail interests.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored
outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started
wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the >>> damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020, >>> just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is >>> between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnAt want to admit to nationalising the >franchises, but thatAs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donAt think anyone >refers to LO as being in the private sector!
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >>> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >>> refers to LO as being in the private sector!
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >>> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).
FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >>> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >>> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >>> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.
Just to add some financial figures:
GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m >> available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.
I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such >> as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any
senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
FirstGroup?
With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail >> interests.
DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:37:10 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I think the argument is that legal ownership transfers from First
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com>
wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio
Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being
acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for
Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the
leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable
condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets
properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the
electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial >>>> work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didn-At want to admit to nationalising the >> franchises, but that-As exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard >> the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They
have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are
managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I don-At think anyone
refers to LO as being in the private sector!
Greater Western Limited (owned by First) Greater Western Railway
Limited (owned by HM Government) on 13 December; and this is the
definition of 'nationalisation'.
Would you argue that the companies
running London's buses are nationalised because they are part of a
network specified by TfL?
Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>>> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being >>>>>>> acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for >>>>>>> Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the >>>>>>> leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable >>>>>>> condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets >>>>>>> properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the >>>>>>> Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They >>>> have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >>>> managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone >>>> refers to LO as being in the private sector!
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not
have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being >>>> re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).
FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator >>>> on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be >>>> impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are >>>> almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.
Just to add some financial figures:
GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m >>> available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.
I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such >>> as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any >>> senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
FirstGroup?
With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail >>> interests.
DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT
indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?
No, of course not. The 802s were procured through a conventional ROSCO (Eversholt, now Beacon), rather than being supplied by Agility Trains. I assume the ROSCO-supplied trains are much cheaper.
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Tweed <usenet.tweed@gmail.com> wrote:But is the lease of those trains indemnified by DfT?
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 14:57:35 GMT, Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> >>>>>> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:I don't think that's entirely correct. See:
I was listening to someone from GWR being interviewed on BBC Radio >>>>>>>> Devon this morning. He was saying that the Class 175 trains being >>>>>>>> acquired by GWR had suffered from neglect as a result of being stored >>>>>>>> outside for a long period by the previous operator, Transport for >>>>>>>> Wales and are now being expertly refurbised at Laira depot. I started >>>>>>>> wondering: surely the trains must have been leased so either the >>>>>>>> leasing company is responsible for restoring them to serviceable >>>>>>>> condition or TfW is responsible for not looking after the assets >>>>>>>> properly?
Storing them in the open allowed rain to penetrate, and get into the >>>>>>> electrics. The ROSCO did contract with Wolverton to refurbish them, but the
damage was worse than expected, so Laira has had to do additional remedial
work. In addition, these trains were never reliable.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the >>>>>>>> Welsh Government?
Why would it cost FirstGroup anything? GWR was nationalised in March 2020,
just like all the remaining franchises. So the dispute, if there is one, is
between the DfT and TfW.
https://www.gwr.com/public-ownership
The Tories (ie, Boris and Shapps) didnrCOt want to admit to nationalising the
franchises, but thatrCOs exactly what they did. Otherwise, would you regard
the DLR, LO, Liz and London Trams as being in the private sector? They >>>>> have exactly the same status as GWR. In fact, LO and London Trams are >>>>> managed by FIrstGroup for the state, just like GWR. I donrCOt think anyone
refers to LO as being in the private sector!
I believe GWR moved to a management contract (which may or may not >>>>>> have transferred maintenance liability to DfT) but formal
nationalisation has not yet taken place.
As the owner of the operator, the DfT is responsible for all revenues and >>>>> costs, so *of course* it pays the routine costs of maintaining the stock >>>>> (unless some of LairarCOs unexpected additional 175 repair costs are being
re-billed to Angel or Gemini (WolvertonrCOs operator).
FirstGroup gets paid a relatively small base fee for managing the operator
on behalf of the DfT, plus top-up bonus payments associated with meeting >>>>> certain targets. ItrCOs possible that some of those top-up bonuses will be
impacted by the 175 problems, but I imagine that FirstrCOs lawyers made sure
that it wouldnrCOt get penalised for problems with trains that werenrCOt its
fault (as with the cracking IETs). FirstGrouprCOs managers and lawyers are
almost certainly smarter than their DfT counterparts.
Just to add some financial figures:
GWR had a revenue of -u1.66bn in 2025. FirstGroup received a fixed
management fee of -u6.9m, with additional performance fees of up to -u17.8m
available if rCystretching performance targetsrCO were met. So, the management
fee is between 0.4% and 1.5% of turnover rCo letrCOs assume about 1% typically.
I assume FirstGroup has to pay certain external costs out of this fee, such
as the board costs, so the fee isnrCOt pure profit. I donrCOt know if any >>>> senior management or legal staff in the TOC are paid directly by
FirstGroup?
With the other TOCs transferring to DFTO, almost all the executives
transferred as well, but GWR may be different, as FirstGroup has other rail
interests.
DidnrCOt First procure some of their own IETs outside of the normal DfT
indemnified procurements? Are they on the hook for those?
No, of course not. The 802s were procured through a conventional ROSCO
(Eversholt, now Beacon), rather than being supplied by Agility Trains. I
assume the ROSCO-supplied trains are much cheaper.
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
time in a year or so.
I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.
Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a
result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
time in a year or so.
I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed >> relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.
Why the climb in share price? Has there been some good news thatrCOs not been widely reported?
Recliner <recliner.usenet@gmail.com> wrote:
Anna Noyd-Dryver <anna@noyd-dryver.com> wrote:
Scott <newsgroups@gefion.myzen.co.uk> wrote:
Declaring an interest here, I have a few shares in
FirstGroup so why am I apparently paying for damage caused by the
Welsh Government?
I'm in the process of cashing in a staff-benefit shares scheme and as a
result have actually looked at the Firstgroup share price for the first
time in a year or so.
I wouldn't worry too much about this affecting share value, they've climbed >>> relentlessly over the last two months, now around 50% higher than two
months ago! The last time they were this high was 2012.
Why the climb in share price? Has there been some good news thatrCOs not
been widely reported?
No idea!
But I'm not complaining
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 58:17:56 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,959 |