On 07/11/2026 16:28, boltar@caprica.universe wrote:
On Sat, 07 Nov 2026 14:47:57 +0100
Marc Van Dyck <marc.gr.vandyck@invalid.skynet.be> gabbled:
Bob has brought this to us :
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:catenery,
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember >>>> a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below >>>> the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound
with a second support wire between the main support wire and thewired
contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC
because the much
lower voltage meant a much higher current and consequently a
significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the switch to 25 kV,
the thickness of wire
needed was much reduced, and consequently the weight did not require
the added support of the secondary support wire. When the routes
originally
for 1500 V DC were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25wires
kV, then the 6.25 being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the >>> old 1500 V
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of >>> the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago,
eliminating the old compound catenery.
Robin
Compound catenary today is only used on DC 1500 and 3000 V territory
in Belgium and France. Other countries using DC (Netherlands, Spain,
Italy) do not use it.
Perhaps I'm being thick but how does it work? Unless you have offset pantographs how can you have 2 voltage wires without risking a train getting
the wrong voltage?
You don't have both at the same time, it's either/or. Also a 3kV train
can operate on 1.5kV but not the other way round.
Graeme Wall <rail@greywall.demon.co.uk> posted:
You don't have both at the same time, it's either/or. Also a 3kV train
can operate on 1.5kV but not the other way round.
You could see that at Modane station with Italian locos.
Recent ones need to be told half of the voltage is still okay to operate.
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 08:38:55 GMT
Ulf Kutzner <user2991@newsgrouper.org.invalid> gabbled:
Graeme Wall <rail@greywall.demon.co.uk> posted:
You don't have both at the same time, it's either/or. Also a 3kV train
can operate on 1.5kV but not the other way round.
You could see that at Modane station with Italian locos.
Recent ones need to be told half of the voltage is still okay to operate.
I'm not an electrical expert, but sometimes if you lower a voltage the current draw goes up and this can cause stuff to burn out. Is this not a
risk with a 3KV loco running on 1.5KV?
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 08:38:55 GMT
Ulf Kutzner <user2991@newsgrouper.org.invalid> gabbled:
Graeme Wall <rail@greywall.demon.co.uk> posted:
You don't have both at the same time, it's either/or. Also a 3kV train
can operate on 1.5kV but not the other way round.
You could see that at Modane station with Italian locos.
Recent ones need to be told half of the voltage is still okay to operate.
I'm not an electrical expert, but sometimes if you lower a voltage the >current draw goes up and this can cause stuff to burn out. Is this not a
risk with a 3KV loco running on 1.5KV?
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember
a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below
the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound >catenery, with a second support wire between the main support wire and
the contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC >because the much lower voltage meant a much higher current and
consequently a significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the
switch to 25 kV, the thickness of wire needed was much reduced, and >consequently the weight did not require the added support of the
secondary support wire. When the routes originally wired for 1500 V DC
were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25 kV, then the 6.25
being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the old 1500 V wires
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of
the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago, eliminating
the old compound catenery.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 21:49:54 +0100, Bob <nospam@gmail.com> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:I thought compound catenary was used on the WCML (25 kV AC) at the
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember
a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below
the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound
catenery, with a second support wire between the main support wire and
the contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC
because the much lower voltage meant a much higher current and
consequently a significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the
switch to 25 kV, the thickness of wire needed was much reduced, and
consequently the weight did not require the added support of the
secondary support wire. When the routes originally wired for 1500 V DC
were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25 kV, then the 6.25
being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the old 1500 V wires
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of
the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago, eliminating
the old compound catenery.
start of electrification. I thought, but could be wrong, that standard catenary was employed in the Glasgow suburban area then compound for
higher speeds. I am wondering why they did this at all when it seems
to be unnecessary. Maybe it was similar to dropping the voltage in
tunnels, which has also subsequently turned out to be unnecessary.
On 09/11/2026 10:29, Scott wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 21:49:54 +0100, Bob <nospam@gmail.com> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:I thought compound catenary was used on the WCML (25 kV AC) at the
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember >>>> a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below >>>> the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound
catenery, with a second support wire between the main support wire and
the contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC
because the much lower voltage meant a much higher current and
consequently a significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the
switch to 25 kV, the thickness of wire needed was much reduced, and
consequently the weight did not require the added support of the
secondary support wire. When the routes originally wired for 1500 V DC
were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25 kV, then the 6.25
being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the old 1500 V wires
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of
the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago, eliminating
the old compound catenery.
start of electrification. I thought, but could be wrong, that standard
catenary was employed in the Glasgow suburban area then compound for
higher speeds. I am wondering why they did this at all when it seems
to be unnecessary. Maybe it was similar to dropping the voltage in
tunnels, which has also subsequently turned out to be unnecessary.
10 years may be a long time, but the Blackpool electrification seems to
have a compound catenary (e.g. level crossing in Carleton).
Bob has brought this to us :
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember
a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below
the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound catenery,
with a second support wire between the main support wire and the contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC because the much
lower voltage meant a much higher current and consequently a significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the switch to 25 kV, the thickness of wire
needed was much reduced, and consequently the weight did not require the added support of the secondary support wire. When the routes originally wired
for 1500 V DC were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25 kV, then
the 6.25 being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the old 1500 V wires
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago, eliminating the old
compound catenery.
Compound catenary today is only used on DC 1500 and 3000 V territory
in Belgium and France. Other countries using DC (Netherlands, Spain,
Italy) do not use it.
On 09/11/2026 10:29, Scott wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 21:49:54 +0100, Bob <nospam@gmail.com> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 18:26, Scott wrote:I thought compound catenary was used on the WCML (25 kV AC) at the
Returning from London last week, I ran out of scenery to watch so
started looking at the overhead line equipment instead. I can remember >>>> a long time ago there being two horizontal cables, one suspended below >>>> the other. What was the point of this and why was it discontinued?
On some installations, notably on the GE routes, there was compound
catenery, with a second support wire between the main support wire and
the contact wire. This was used on lines originally wired for 1500 V DC
because the much lower voltage meant a much higher current and
consequently a significantly larger/heavier contact wire. With the
switch to 25 kV, the thickness of wire needed was much reduced, and
consequently the weight did not require the added support of the
secondary support wire. When the routes originally wired for 1500 V DC
were converted, initially to a mix of 25 kV and 6.25 kV, then the 6.25
being eliminated for a uniform 25 kV, initially the old 1500 V wires
were retained with larger insulators. The originally 1500 V wiring of
the Shenfield scheme was entirely replaced a few years ago, eliminating
the old compound catenery.
start of electrification. I thought, but could be wrong, that standard
catenary was employed in the Glasgow suburban area then compound for
higher speeds. I am wondering why they did this at all when it seems
to be unnecessary. Maybe it was similar to dropping the voltage in
tunnels, which has also subsequently turned out to be unnecessary.
10 years may be a long time, but the Blackpool electrification seems to have a compound catenary (e.g. level crossing in Carleton).
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:29:49 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |