• Totally OT - Advertising Techniques

    From Martin Harran@martinharran@gmail.com to uk.net.news.moderation on Mon Oct 12 14:53:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.net.news.moderation on Mon Oct 12 14:14:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    On 2026-10-12, Martin Harran <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    My favourite is: suppose you're watching an episode of Peppa Pig on
    YouTube. It gets interrupted by adverts from time to time. Sometimes,
    the advert is... another full episode of Peppa Pig. So you start out
    watching an episode, for which you are indirectly paying the creators
    by watching adverts, but then they decide they don't like money and
    would prefer to pay to decide a different episode of the same program
    for you to watch instead.

    I cannot work out any way on god's green earth that the above is
    a sensible use of anyone's money.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.net.news.moderation on Mon Oct 12 14:23:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    On 12 Oct 2026 at 14:53:08 BST, "Martin Harran" <martinharran@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    I think there are two factors at play here. The first is to get the audience really hooked on reading the human interest story. The second is that AI has made it very easy to generate a long and discursive story from a fairly simple prompt. And also to automate the whole process of writing the story and formatting and publishing it without much human intervention.

    Whether it works to interest people in the product I have no idea. But I suppose if it is a monetised video on Youtube or whatever they may actually make money just from people reading it.
    --

    Roger Hayter
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.net.news.moderation on Mon Oct 12 18:49:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation


    "Martin Harran" <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote in message news:egppcl9eg2vip2ilu09g6m913tsv4vhvci@4ax.com...
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    They won't be concerned at all if they put most people off.

    Depending on the potential reach of the advert they're probably
    hoping that it succeeds in selling the product to maybe .01% of
    the people who watch it; otherwise as a small supplier they would
    be overwhelmed by the demand, and unable to cope.

    As to the boredom factor; Freeview is awash with shopping
    channels which presumably must cost more to transmit than
    Youtube videos, These go on, for hour after hour, selling
    exactly the same item or succession of items. Hour after hour
    day after day. And so presumably these must be effective to
    some degree.

    While according to John Wannamaker a US department store pioneer

    "Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is
    I don't know which half" -

    A standby for the advertising executives ever since.


    bb





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Martin Harran@martinharran@gmail.com to uk.net.news.moderation on Tue Oct 13 12:08:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 18:49:46 +0100, "billy bookcase" <billy@anon.com>
    wrote:


    "Martin Harran" <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote in message >news:egppcl9eg2vip2ilu09g6m913tsv4vhvci@4ax.com...
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    They won't be concerned at all if they put most people off.

    Depending on the potential reach of the advert they're probably
    hoping that it succeeds in selling the product to maybe .01% of
    the people who watch it; otherwise as a small supplier they would
    be overwhelmed by the demand, and unable to cope.

    That logic certainly applies to email spam where the difference in
    cost of sending a million emails compared to sending a hundred is
    negligible but I'm not sure that it applies to social media where
    advertising costs apply. I have no idea what it costs to advertise on
    Facebook for example but I doubt if it comes cheap.


    As to the boredom factor; Freeview is awash with shopping
    channels which presumably must cost more to transmit than
    Youtube videos, These go on, for hour after hour, selling
    exactly the same item or succession of items. Hour after hour
    day after day. And so presumably these must be effective to
    some degree.

    While according to John Wannamaker a US department store pioneer

    "Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is
    I don't know which half" -

    A standby for the advertising executives ever since.


    bb




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Martin Harran@martinharran@gmail.com to uk.net.news.moderation on Tue Oct 13 12:35:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 14:14:02 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-10-12, Martin Harran <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    My favourite is: suppose you're watching an episode of Peppa Pig on
    YouTube. It gets interrupted by adverts from time to time. Sometimes,
    the advert is... another full episode of Peppa Pig. So you start out
    watching an episode, for which you are indirectly paying the creators
    by watching adverts, but then they decide they don't like money and
    would prefer to pay to decide a different episode of the same program
    for you to watch instead.

    I don't really get your logic there, if you are already watching Peppa
    Pig then you are a prime candidate for another episode. A bit like a
    trailer in the cinema.

    In fairness to YouTube compared to what I was talking about above,
    their adverts generally last seconds, not minutes, you can usually
    grasp right away what they are trying to sell you and there is often a
    'skip' button if you aren't interested. The BBC and some other
    mainstream media piss me off in that regard; I see a link on their
    main news page to what looks like an interesting video and I get
    presented with several minutes of advertising in which I have zero
    interest with no option to skip or fast forward; I quite often just
    abandon the video.


    I cannot work out any way on god's green earth that the above is
    a sensible use of anyone's money.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.net.news.moderation on Tue Oct 13 11:54:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation

    On 2026-10-13, Martin Harran <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 14:14:02 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
    <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
    On 2026-10-12, Martin Harran <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    My favourite is: suppose you're watching an episode of Peppa Pig on >>YouTube. It gets interrupted by adverts from time to time. Sometimes,
    the advert is... another full episode of Peppa Pig. So you start out >>watching an episode, for which you are indirectly paying the creators
    by watching adverts, but then they decide they don't like money and
    would prefer to pay to decide a different episode of the same program
    for you to watch instead.

    I don't really get your logic there, if you are already watching Peppa
    Pig then you are a prime candidate for another episode. A bit like a
    trailer in the cinema.

    Perhaps I didn't explain it well enough. The advert is not an advert
    for another episode of Peppa Pig. The advert *is* an episode of Peppa
    Pig. So you're happily watching Peppa Pig, causing the creators of it
    to receive (a tiny amount of) money, and they interrupt you in order
    to instead *pay* (a larger amount of) money in order to get you to
    watch a different episode of the same programme.

    In fairness to YouTube compared to what I was talking about above,
    their adverts generally last seconds, not minutes, you can usually
    grasp right away what they are trying to sell you and there is often a
    'skip' button if you aren't interested.

    I've seen YouTube adverts that last hours. But yes you can skip after
    the first 20 seconds or so.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From billy bookcase@billy@anon.com to uk.net.news.moderation on Tue Oct 13 13:53:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.net.news.moderation


    "Martin Harran" <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote in message news:pk3scldlelvuc8ts03k3d3iton2uib6v89@4ax.com...
    On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 18:49:46 +0100, "billy bookcase" <billy@anon.com>
    wrote:


    "Martin Harran" <martinharran@gmail.com> wrote in message >>news:egppcl9eg2vip2ilu09g6m913tsv4vhvci@4ax.com...
    Totally off topic but people here seem to know a lot of stuff about a
    lot of things so maybe somebody can enlighten me :)

    I see regular ads on the Net that seem to go on and on for ever.
    Videos about fitness programmes seem particularly common. I don't mind
    people advertising but I can't see many people bothering with a video
    that takes something like 10 minutes to tell me what it is trying to
    sell me. On social media, long drawn-out stories seem a favourite
    ploy, Today, for example, one has popped up on my social media, a
    woman telling a long, drawn-out story about how her 5-year-old
    granddaughter left in her care for a night nearly died of cold. Out of
    idle curiosity, I copied and pasted the story into my word processor
    to get a word count and it came out at 3,700. At the end of it, the
    poster reveals that it was some kind of body warming armour developed
    by the military and on a really special offer at the moment!

    Again, I am not questioning the products being sold on such stories
    (though most of them are total rubbish), it's the adoption of an
    advertising technique that I think will put most people off before
    they get anywhere near the punchline.

    Can anyone explain the logic?

    They won't be concerned at all if they put most people off.

    Depending on the potential reach of the advert they're probably
    hoping that it succeeds in selling the product to maybe .01% of
    the people who watch it; otherwise as a small supplier they would
    be overwhelmed by the demand, and unable to cope.

    That logic certainly applies to email spam where the difference in
    cost of sending a million emails compared to sending a hundred is
    negligible but I'm not sure that it applies to social media where
    advertising costs apply. I have no idea what it costs to advertise on Facebook for example but I doubt if it comes cheap.

    But would it cost as much if viewers don't watch all the way to
    the end, as you're suggesting many won't ?

    I must also admit I'm a bit confused as to how you obtained a word
    count of 3,700 as a result of watching a video. Possibly I've
    misunderstood,

    Of necessity I'm currently watching youtube videos produced by
    helpful people on how to do specific car repairs; where they
    spend the first five minutes showing you how they got the new
    parts out of the box, which they often hold up to the camera.
    And then ten minutes later film a close-up of the back of their
    head, or the peak of their cap, as they lean forward to make the
    crucial moves well out of sight.


    bb




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2