"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote in message news:O4WIakI6ehyqFAgp@perry.uk...
In message <niuak9FcuccU1@mid.individual.net>, at 09:17:12 on Sat, 10 Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
Even if he does, he's still selling a collection of badges in a biscuit tin.
He can't force the price up by imagination.
False dichotomy yet again. He can imagine what a buyer might
do with them, and value them accordingly.
Which completely misses the whole point of auctions.
Which is that it's the bidders who decide what items are worth;
not auctioneers.
Auctioneers can advise consignees on what would be a "realistic"
reserve; to prevent goods being given away at poorly attended
auctions. But fairly obviously if they advised too high a
reserve, then this would deter bidders, leaving goods unsold;
and fewer bidders at future auctions.
People only turn up in the first place in the hope of getting
what they consider bargains ; not on paying prices based on
auctioneers valuations
Here is the post in its entity without the preambleAnd there's more. Someone, it seems, and probably Mr Perry who cant
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote in message
news:O4WIakI6ehyqFAgp@perry.uk...
In message <niuak9FcuccU1@mid.individual.net>, at 09:17:12 on Sat, 10 Oct >>> 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
Even if he does, he's still selling a collection of badges in a biscuit tin.
He can't force the price up by imagination.
False dichotomy yet again. He can imagine what a buyer might
do with them, and value them accordingly.
Which completely misses the whole point of auctions.
Which is that it's the bidders who decide what items are worth;
not auctioneers.
Auctioneers can advise consignees on what would be a "realistic"
reserve; to prevent goods being given away at poorly attended
auctions. But fairly obviously if they advised too high a
reserve, then this would deter bidders, leaving goods unsold;
and fewer bidders at future auctions.
People only turn up in the first place in the hope of getting
what they consider bargains ; not on paying prices based on
auctioneers valuations
bb
Roland Perry clearly doesn't understand how auctions work, about
the role of reserves; or the function of estimates.
This is spoken as someone who has attended auctions of all kinds
since the 1970's; that's right folks for over 50 years. Rather than
posing as a wanabee dealer, based on watching reality TV programmes
and picking up estate cars full of "bargains" i.e rubbish; at
local auctions.
About which I was too polite to comment at the time; in any
case Norman Wells made most of my points for me.
All four of my paragraphs contain points which Roland Perry
is clearly unwilling to address.
As it was Roland Perry who initiated this thread, either
it is Roland Perry himself who is rejecting posts so as to
simply avoid losing face - which is a gross misuse of
his role as a moderator, or one of the other moderators
is colluding with Roland Perry; so as to preserve his
delicate ego.
valuable unsold possessions, in the longer term?
Is that not a recipe for creating a houseful of junk^h^h^h, er
It's called "buying stock". And most not stored in the house.
three years, so you can't ba selling as much as you're bringing in.You see, you have said you won't be making a profit for at least
That's true of many businesses.
Say you are a car dealer, typically you'll have fifty vehicles on theforecourt, which when you started the business at a new site, arrived
warehouses is if they've drastically under-valued it. For example aThe only way to usefully buy stock at other people's antiques
that last sentence.
I'd have thought there might be a clue to value and saleability in
Value and saleability at *their* location, and *their* originalasking price. I have a different location and a different asking price.
question posted by the presenter to the contestant-buyer was "when didOne of the items on TV yesterday was a cocktail shaker, and the
but current usefulness is not the reason. After all, the Mona Lisa has
Well, there may not be a market for cocktail shakers at the moment,
I think you'll find the Mona Lisa brings substantial number of
tourists to Paris and The Louvre. Which is useful to many local
hotels, restaurants and the museum itself.
nor ornament'. And many things frequently bought on Bargain Hunt forIt used to be said that the test for worthlessness was 'neither use
Indeed. And as it happens writing slopes are one of "yesterday'santiques" which can hardly be given away nowadays. Partly because they
those other dealers and collectors because you know better than them?What reason have they to think that if an item is that rare, it
won't already have come to the attention of collectors, not to say
other dealers, who they would then need to outbid in the saleroom,
and then charge a premium in order to make any profit ?
That's the skill of being in that line of business.
What you're saying then is that you're prepared to pay more than all
The competition is often only a handful of "other dealers andcollectors", something you keep being deliberately obtuse about.
Also they don't necessarily specialise in the same sorts of items Ido, so don't have a market to dispose of them.
built- in cassette), and even before that was in-the-shops, the DDI-1You may recall that back in the day Amstrad had the CPC464 (with
of worthlessness, but who am I to say you shouldn't try?What's the attraction ?
Being able to make a profit, or just preserving things for posterity.
For myself, I'd go back to the 'neither use nor ornament' definition
They attract quite a crowd at vintage games events, and plenty ofcollectors use them to play vintage games at home. Others even write
new games for them.
biscuit-tin-full to a dealer who will spend -u50 having them framed, anda) as a collection of badges in a biscuit tin they're possiblyOf course it is. He should be expecting to sell the
worth the auctioneer's estimate. Maybe a fiver a pop or
thereabouts in a general sale ?
b) mounted on a board with a frame they're worth a lot more
as a conversation piece
But it's not up to the auctioneer to go that extra (b) mile
biscuit tin. He can't force the price up by imagination.
That depends on the imagination of the bidders as to what they
do with them.
Given that it's his job, the auctioneer should be imagining that too.
Even if he does, he's still selling a collection of badges in a
False dichotomy yet again. He can imagine what a buyer might do withthem, and value them accordingly.
Here is the post in its entity without the preamble
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote in message
news:O4WIakI6ehyqFAgp@perry.uk...
In message <niuak9FcuccU1@mid.individual.net>, at 09:17:12 on Sat, 10 Oct >> > 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
Even if he does, he's still selling a collection of badges in a
biscuit tin.
He can't force the price up by imagination.
False dichotomy yet again. He can imagine what a buyer might
do with them, and value them accordingly.
Which completely misses the whole point of auctions.
Which is that it's the bidders who decide what items are worth;
not auctioneers.
Auctioneers can advise consignees on what would be a "realistic"
reserve; to prevent goods being given away at poorly attended
auctions. But fairly obviously if they advised too high a
reserve, then this would deter bidders, leaving goods unsold;
and fewer bidders at future auctions.
People only turn up in the first place in the hope of getting
what they consider bargains ; not on paying prices based on
auctioneers valuations
bb
Roland Perry clearly doesn't understand how auctions work, about
the role of reserves; or the function of estimates.
This is spoken as someone who has attended auctions of all kinds
since the 1970's; that's right folks for over 50 years. Rather than
posing as a wanabee dealer, based on watching reality TV programmes
and picking up estate cars full of "bargains" i.e rubbish; at
local auctions.
About which I was too polite to comment at the time; in any
case Norman Wells made most of my points for me.
All four of my paragraphs contain points which Roland Perry
is clearly unwilling to address.
As it was Roland Perry who initiated this thread, either
it is Roland Perry himself who is rejecting posts so as to
simply avoid losing face - which is a gross misuse of
his role as a moderator, or one of the other moderators
is colluding with Roland Perry; so as to preserve his
delicate ego.
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than RolandWhy are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
does.
In message <11adva1$1ve4g$1@dont-email.me>, at 19:14:24 on Sat, 10 Oct 2026, billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
Here is the post in its entity without the preamble
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote in message
news:O4WIakI6ehyqFAgp@perry.uk...
In message <niuak9FcuccU1@mid.individual.net>, at 09:17:12 on Sat, 10 Oct >>> > 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
Even if he does, he's still selling a collection of badges in a biscuit >>> >>tin.
He can't force the price up by imagination.
False dichotomy yet again. He can imagine what a buyer might
do with them, and value them accordingly.
Which completely misses the whole point of auctions.
Which is that it's the bidders who decide what items are worth;
not auctioneers.
Auctioneers can advise consignees on what would be a "realistic"
reserve; to prevent goods being given away at poorly attended
auctions. But fairly obviously if they advised too high a
reserve, then this would deter bidders, leaving goods unsold;
and fewer bidders at future auctions.
People only turn up in the first place in the hope of getting
what they consider bargains ; not on paying prices based on
auctioneers valuations
bb
Roland Perry clearly doesn't understand how auctions work, about
the role of reserves; or the function of estimates.
This is spoken as someone who has attended auctions of all kinds
since the 1970's; that's right folks for over 50 years. Rather than
posing as a wanabee dealer, based on watching reality TV programmes
and picking up estate cars full of "bargains" i.e rubbish; at
local auctions.
About which I was too polite to comment at the time; in any
case Norman Wells made most of my points for me.
All four of my paragraphs contain points which Roland Perry
is clearly unwilling to address.
As it was Roland Perry who initiated this thread, either
it is Roland Perry himself who is rejecting posts so as to
simply avoid losing face - which is a gross misuse of
his role as a moderator, or one of the other moderators
is colluding with Roland Perry; so as to preserve his
delicate ego.
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland does. But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the seventh time is
"not new".
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
Very strange.
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland does. >> But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the seventh time is
"not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri, 16
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland
does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
To make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
On 18/10/2026 08:25, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri, 16
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than
Roland does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
To make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
Do you mean who Roland is talking about?
In message <njjiroFmeubU1@mid.individual.net>, at 10:46:31 on Sun, 18
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 18/10/2026 08:25, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri, 16
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than
Roland-a does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
-aTo make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
Do you mean who Roland is talking about?
Of course. I can hardly believe you are so stupid as to have to ask.
On 18/10/2026 11:18, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <njjiroFmeubU1@mid.individual.net>, at 10:46:31 on Sun, 18
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 18/10/2026 08:25, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri,
16 Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than >>>>>>Rolanda does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
aTo make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
Do you mean who Roland is talking about?
Of course. I can hardly believe you are so stupid as to have to ask.
Do you mean Roland can hardly believe it?
On 18/10/2026 08:25, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri, 16
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>>> does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
To make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
Do you mean who Roland is talking about?
On 2026-10-18, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> wrote:
On 18/10/2026 08:25, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nje0c7Fph53U1@mid.individual.net>, at 08:00:23 on Fri, 16
Oct 2026, Norman Wells <hex@unseen.ac.am> remarked:
On 16/10/2026 02:19, Roland Perry wrote:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>>>> does.
Why are you now writing about yourself in the third person?
To make it clear exactly who I'm talking about.
Do you mean who Roland is talking about?
Do you mean about whom Roland is talking?
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 Oct 2026, billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland does. >>> But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the seventh time >>> is
"not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >news:D8LLLjAQSH1qFA5Y@perry.uk...
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 Oct 2026, >> billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than
Roland does. But once you've expressed that five or six times >>>>already, the seventh time is "not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
That's simply not true.
Whereas with the Roland Perry theme
"Anything you can do, I can do better "
Performances daily. 1995 - 2026
In message <11b4jgs$1sfsm$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:14:16 on Mon, 19 Oct 2026, billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >>news:D8LLLjAQSH1qFA5Y@perry.uk...
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 Oct 2026,
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>>>> does. But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the >>>>> seventh time is "not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
That's simply not true.
Whereas with the Roland Perry theme
"Anything you can do, I can do better "
Performances daily. 1995 - 2026
That qualifies as stalking.
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >news:H8EK7YAgYH2qFAhx@perry.uk...
In message <11b4jgs$1sfsm$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:14:16 on Mon, 19 Oct 2026, >> billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >>>news:D8LLLjAQSH1qFA5Y@perry.uk...
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 >>>>Oct 2026,
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>>>>> does. But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the >>>>>> seventh time is "not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
That's simply not true.
Whereas with the Roland Perry theme
"Anything you can do, I can do better "
Performances daily. 1995 - 2026
That qualifies as stalking.
Are you really quite as stupid, as you are making out ?
It would only qualify as stalking had I, or anyone else
actually bothered to check.
But why would anyone bother ?
Leopards never change their spots.
However, thank you for the *confirmation* there; that had anyone
actually bothered to check, they would indeed, as suspected
have found you performing regularly if not daily ever since 1995;
or whenever it was that you first started posting.
IOW it was an educated guess; which you were more than happy to
confirm with your baseless accusation
In message <11bacva$3ui25$1@dont-email.me>, at 13:59:20 on Wed, 21 Oct 2026, billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >>news:H8EK7YAgYH2qFAhx@perry.uk...
In message <11b4jgs$1sfsm$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:14:16 on Mon, 19 Oct 2026,
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message >>>>news:D8LLLjAQSH1qFA5Y@perry.uk...
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 Oct >>>>> 2026,
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland >>>>>>> does. But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the >>>>>>> seventh time is "not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive* >>>>>>posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
That's simply not true.
Whereas with the Roland Perry theme
"Anything you can do, I can do better "
Performances daily. 1995 - 2026
That qualifies as stalking.
Are you really quite as stupid, as you are making out ?
It would only qualify as stalking had I, or anyone else
actually bothered to check.
But why would anyone bother ?
Leopards never change their spots.
However, thank you for the *confirmation* there; that had anyone
actually bothered to check, they would indeed, as suspected
have found you performing regularly if not daily ever since 1995;
or whenever it was that you first started posting.
IOW it was an educated guess; which you were more than happy to
confirm with your baseless accusation
Keep digging, send me a postcard from Australia.
"Roland Perry" <roland@perry.co.uk> wrote in message news:D8LLLjAQSH1qFA5Y@perry.uk...
In message <11aspah$355ov$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:04:14 on Fri, 16 Oct 2026,
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> remarked:
You may hold a different opinion about how auctions work, than Roland does.
But once you've expressed that five or six times already, the seventh time
is
"not new".
Which of course is totally untrue.
I asked a succession of *different* questions in *successive*
posts; none of which you addressed,
I'm afraid you simply repeated the same stuff over and over again.
That's simply not true.
Whereas with the Roland Perry theme
"Anything you can do, I can do better "
Performances daily. 1995 - 2026
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (1 / 5) |
| Uptime: | 35:15:55 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (6,742K bytes) |
| Messages: | 284,775 |