On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote: >>>>
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income,
*all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300
prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing
at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private companies in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That would be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular
"overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or
anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that
may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads.
Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the
situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different >> from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead
cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full
except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's
-u1,000 a week.
Or on the other hand you could simply execute "all" criminals,It's a bit draconian, but I'm guessing that it would drastically reduce
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>> enough. ************************************************************************
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
Why not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong".
The notions of "right" and "wrong", and to what degree they
should be "rewarded" or "punished" are soleley the preserve
of "Politics"; as informed by "Ethics".
While you are a nothing but a "Clown" and a "Bluffer"
But clearly not very successful at that; once things start
to get a bit "complicated".
Although nothing that a 20 post sub-thred can't remedy;
if you can manage to string it out that long.
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income,
*all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300
prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing
at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private companies in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That would be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular
"overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads.
Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the
situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different >>> from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead
cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few
prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full
except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's
-u1,000 a week.
My point of course is that we are not in a position where we have a longstanding stable prison estate where the cost of the marginal prisoner is negligible.
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...************************************************************************
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>>> enough.
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
Why not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong".
The context here (which you have obviously forgotten) was that of criminals being punished (if at all) and whether adequately or otherwise. It's still there, above (and now highlighted).
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...************************************************************************
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>>> enough.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************ >>>>>> I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>>>> enough.
************************************************************************
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
Why not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong".
The context here (which you have obviously forgotten) was that of criminals >> being punished (if at all) and whether adequately or otherwise. It's still >> there, above (and now highlighted).
Which isn't a question which is decided by economists.
On 24/08/2026 02:39 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************ >>>>>>> I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>>>>> enough.
************************************************************************ >>>
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
Why not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong".
The context here (which you have obviously forgotten) was that of criminals >>> being punished (if at all) and whether adequately or otherwise. It's still >>> there, above (and now highlighted).
Which isn't a question which is decided by economists.
What on Earth are you talking about?
Has someone argued that economists instead of magistrates and/or judges should
decide criminal trials?
Or has somebody pointed out that there is such a thing as an economic view on
the subject of penal policy?
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, >>>>>>> which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income,
*all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300
prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing
at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing >>>>> new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private companies
in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each >>>>> new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That would
be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular
"overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads.
Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the
situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different >>> from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead
cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few
prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full
except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's
u1,000 a week.
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, >>>>>>>> which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income,
*all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300
prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing
at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing >>>>>> new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private companies
in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each >>>>>> new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That would
be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular
"overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads.
Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the >>>> situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different >>>> from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead
cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few
prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first
prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full
except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's
u1,000 a week.
More total nonsense.
There are no such things as "marginal prisoners".
Depending on sentencing policy, long term and short term, prisons
overall will want to maintain an element of *temporary *spare capacity
Which is already costed in. And then averaged out over the prison
population thus contributing to the u1000 a week cost
On induction a new prisoner may well be housed in that spare
capacity, until another prisoner is released.
*but he isn't going to stay there permanently*
Because if he did, then to maintain the same level of spare capacity
within the system, they would need to build another half cell and install another new bunk somewhere in the system.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message news:nf3449Ftk4rU2@mid.individual.net...
On 24/08/2026 02:39 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************ >>>>>>>> I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished >>>>>>>> enough.
************************************************************************ >>>>
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
Why not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong".
The context here (which you have obviously forgotten) was that of criminals
being punished (if at all) and whether adequately or otherwise. It's still >>>> there, above (and now highlighted).
Which isn't a question which is decided by economists.
What on Earth are you talking about?
Has someone argued that economists instead of magistrates and/or judges should
decide criminal trials?
Economists don't have "a view" as you claim above *****in asteriscs*****
They calculate the cost implications of various sentencing policies,
one of which may be adopted, depending on Parliament's "view"
Or has somebody pointed out that there is such a thing as an economic view on
the subject of penal policy?
Well.if they have, they are simply as stupid as you are.
On 23/08/2026 20:34, billy bookcase wrote:
Or on the other hand you could simply execute "all" criminals,It's a bit draconian, but I'm guessing that it would drastically reduce
the incidence of double-parking or littering.
On 24/08/2026 07:17 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the >>>>> situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> >>>>>>> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, >>>>>>>>> which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income, >>>>>>>> *all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300
prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing >>>>>>>> at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing
new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private >>>>>>> companies
in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each >>>>>>> new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That >>>>>>> would
be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular
"overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads. >>>>>
from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead
cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few
prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first >>> prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full
except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's
u1,000 a week.
More total nonsense.
There are no such things as "marginal prisoners".
You... er... don't have a feel for English used in technical discourse, do you?
Are there any night classes starting in September round your way?
Depending on sentencing policy, long term and short term, prisons
overall will want to maintain an element of *temporary *spare capacity
Which is already costed in. And then averaged out over the prison
population thus contributing to the u1000 a week cost
On induction a new prisoner may well be housed in that spare
capacity, until another prisoner is released.
None of that negates the concept of the "marginal prisoner".
Your thinking that it does (or might) simply highlights your lack of grasp of English as used in technical description.
*but he isn't going to stay there permanently*
Because if he did, then to maintain the same level of spare capacity
within the system, they would need to build another half cell and install
another new bunk somewhere in the system.
Go on... try a few more sentences filled with random words.
On 24/08/2026 06:27 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:nf3449Ftk4rU2@mid.individual.net...
On 24/08/2026 02:39 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
On 24/08/2026 09:12 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:...
On 23/08/2026 08:34 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
************************************************************************ >>>>>>>>> I said that the economist's view would that criminals are not punished
************************************************************************ >>>>>enough.
"Punishment" is simply not a "concept" in economics.
The context here (which you have obviously forgotten) was that ofWhy not?
Because people sre normally "punished" for doing something "wrong". >>>>>
criminals
being punished (if at all) and whether adequately or otherwise. It's still
there, above (and now highlighted).
Which isn't a question which is decided by economists.
What on Earth are you talking about?
Has someone argued that economists instead of magistrates and/or judges >>> should
decide criminal trials?
Economists don't have "a view" as you claim above *****in asteriscs*****
I didn't say that they did.
But some of them will.
Either way, though, has someone argued that economists instead of magistrates
and/or judges should decide criminal trials?
You seem to have forgotten to address that question.
They calculate the cost implications of various sentencing policies,
one of which may be adopted, depending on Parliament's "view"
Yes, I expect that Parliament might well employ some economists within various
government departments.
Or has somebody pointed out that there is such a thing as an economic view >>> on
the subject of penal policy?
Well.if they have, they are simply as stupid as you are.
Well done. More personal abuse.
Wouldn't it be a terrible shock if you ever managed to debate anything at all
on a civilised basis?
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message news:nf41k8F3n6vU1@mid.individual.net...
On 24/08/2026 07:17 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the >>>>>> situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally different
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> >>>>>>>> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, >>>>>>>>>> which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income, >>>>>>>>> *all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300 >>>>>>>>> prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing >>>>>>>>> at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and staffing
new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private >>>>>>>> companies
in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of each
new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That >>>>>>>> would
be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular >>>>>>> "overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>>>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>>>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads. >>>>>>
from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead >>>>> cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few >>>>> prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first >>>> prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full >>>>> except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's >>>>> u1,000 a week.
More total nonsense.
There are no such things as "marginal prisoners".
You... er... don't have a feel for English used in technical discourse, do >> you?
Precisely what has any of this got do with "technical discourse" ?
"Discourse" apparently being this week's new word.
"Marginal" being last week's.
In terns of prison administration and admissions there are no such
things as "marginal" prisoners. The system accommodates additional
prisoners every day.
Just because you learned a new word "marginal" last week, doesn't
mean you can simply apply it in all situations where something is
added to something else.
It only applies in the "technical" sense when this generates
marginal costs.
Are there any night classes starting in September round your way?
This u1000 a week cost per prisoner, has really hit you hard hasn't it ?
Clearly it's had a really big impact on all these fly-blown theories
of yours, you've possibly been touting for the past 50 odds years,
about the need to really punish people.
So that a recidivist shop lifter with a drug problem appears before
the Court; Their 5th offence this year. Total value of goods stolen from supermarkets u 645. Social cost in terms of impact on byestanders
assistants as surveyed by sociologists, and psychologists, and
quantified u355.
Total cost to Society u1000
Sentence: 1 year in prison at a cost of u52, 000.
And then when they come out its straight back on the drugs and the shoplifting
But at least they're been "punished".
Depending on sentencing policy, long term and short term, prisons
overall will want to maintain an element of *temporary *spare capacity
Which is already costed in. And then averaged out over the prison
population thus contributing to the u1000 a week cost
On induction a new prisoner may well be housed in that spare
capacity, until another prisoner is released.
None of that negates the concept of the "marginal prisoner".
Yes it does.
Oh and another new word there "concept" ? You're really picking this
stuff up quite quickly aren't you ?
Prisoners can be "marginal" in any of the ways it is possible to
measure prisoners. Height intelligence etc etc But those meaurements
apply to everyone and not just prisoners.
But none of these generate marginal costs.
Your thinking that it does (or might) simply highlights your lack of grasp of
English as used in technical description.
*but he isn't going to stay there permanently*
Because if he did, then to maintain the same level of spare capacity
within the system, they would need to build another half cell and install >>> another new bunk somewhere in the system.
Go on... try a few more sentences filled with random words.
I much prefer non random words myself.
Such as "It costs u1000 a week to lock someone up in prison"
bb
On 25/08/2026 08:54 AM, billy bookcase wrote:
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:nf41k8F3n6vU1@mid.individual.net...
On 24/08/2026 07:17 PM, billy bookcase wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 23:43:06 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 23/08/2026 03:40 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 23 Aug 2026 at 14:59:29 BST, "JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
On 23/08/2026 12:11 PM, Roger Hayter wrote:Fair enough but there are very major running costs of a prison, and the >>>>>>> situation when you add a person to nearly full prison is totally >>>>>>> different
On 23 Aug 2026 at 10:33:14 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> >>>>>>>>> wrote:
I'm not sure you've totally understood his point.
"JNugent" <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote in message
news:neu3riF5dmbU1@mid.individual.net...
We do not spend that for each prisoner. You cannot count overheads, >>>>>>>>>>> which need
to be met even if the prison is empty.
As locking up prisoners doesn't generate any wealth or income, >>>>>>>>>> *all"* expenditure on prisons consiste of overheads. Economics 101 >>>>>>>>>>
So that according to your calculations locking up the 87,300 >>>>>>>>>> prisoners currently in Engiah and Welsh prisons, costs nothing >>>>>>>>>> at all !
Thanks for pointing that out.
However, to talk about the a
low marginal cost of an extra prisoner when we are building and >>>>>>>>> staffing
new
prisons as fast as we can (and providing huge profits to private >>>>>>>>> companies
in
doing so) is frankly misleading. We should be dividing the cost of >>>>>>>>> each
new
prison by one two thousand and using that as the marginal cost. That >>>>>>>>> would
be
quite high.
Capital costs are overheads (or, in USA-speak, just the singular >>>>>>>> "overhead"), whether the new prison is directly built, rented, PFId or >>>>>>>> anything else by way of acquisition.
Capital costs are overheads (that included staff salaries, though that >>>>>>>> may, of coiurse, vary).
Running costs are distinct from capital costs and are not overheads. >>>>>>>
from having to open a new prison for the next 1000 inmates.
Indeed.
But no-one would be foolish enough to try to load the entire overhead >>>>>> cost of a new-build prison onto the first prisoner (or the first few >>>>>> prisoners) housed there, for very obvious reasons.
Of course not. But it would be reasonable to divide it between the first >>>>> prison-full.
And in the oppsite case, housing a marginal prisoner i na prison full >>>>>> except for one upper bunk would not increase the unit's costs by BB's >>>>>> u1,000 a week.
More total nonsense.
There are no such things as "marginal prisoners".
You... er... don't have a feel for English used in technical discourse, do >>> you?
Precisely what has any of this got do with "technical discourse" ?
Don't misinterpret the word "technical".
You have managed to remind me of a conversation I took part in over fifty years ago in a Liverpool jazz club. Two people attending clearly weren't jazz
fans and understood nothing of the genre. They dismissed the skills of the drummer in a post-bebop band because he didn't sound like Keith Moon or someone. When I pointed out that he was an excellent drummer and a great technician, they asked what his engineering day job had to do with it.
And you've managed to make the same mistake.
"Discourse" apparently being this week's new word.
"Marginal" being last week's.
In terns of prison administration and admissions there are no such
things as "marginal" prisoners. The system accommodates additional
prisoners every day.
And each of them is added at the margin.
Now come on... if you can't understand that, you need to get some remedial English lessons.
Just because you learned a new word "marginal" last week, doesn't
mean you can simply apply it in all situations where something is
added to something else.
It only applies in the "technical" sense when this generates
marginal costs.
A new prisoner, additional to the nmber already in the prison, will always mean that additional costs arise. His first breakfast is an obvious example. Glad to see that you are starting to recoignise that, and to understand what "marginal" (a term from economics) means.
Well done.
Are there any night classes starting in September round your way?
This u1000 a week cost per prisoner, has really hit you hard hasn't it ?
Why don't you add on the cost of the police, the courts, legal aid and car-parking for the judges and make the amount even bigger?
Clearly it's had a really big impact on all these fly-blown theories
of yours, you've possibly been touting for the past 50 odds years,
about the need to really punish people.
So that a recidivist shop lifter with a drug problem appears before
the Court; Their 5th offence this year. Total value of goods stolen from
supermarkets u 645. Social cost in terms of impact on byestanders
assistants as surveyed by sociologists, and psychologists, and
quantified u355.
Total cost to Society u1000
Perhaps you'll be able to make sense of that word salad and explain it properly.
Perhaps not.
Sentence: 1 year in prison at a cost of u52, 000.
And then when they come out its straight back on the drugs and the
shoplifting
But at least they're been "punished".
Depending on sentencing policy, long term and short term, prisons
overall will want to maintain an element of *temporary *spare capacity >>>> Which is already costed in. And then averaged out over the prison
population thus contributing to the u1000 a week cost
On induction a new prisoner may well be housed in that spare
capacity, until another prisoner is released.
None of that negates the concept of the "marginal prisoner".
Yes it does.
Are you booked for panto this year, yet?
Oh and another new word there "concept" ? You're really picking this
stuff up quite quickly aren't you ?
Prisoners can be "marginal" in any of the ways it is possible to
measure prisoners. Height intelligence etc etc But those meaurements
apply to everyone and not just prisoners.
But none of these generate marginal costs.
:-)
Your thinking that it does (or might) simply highlights your lack of grasp >>> of
English as used in technical description.
*but he isn't going to stay there permanently*
Because if he did, then to maintain the same level of spare capacity
within the system, they would need to build another half cell and install >>>> another new bunk somewhere in the system.
Go on... try a few more sentences filled with random words.
I much prefer non random words myself.
...but can't manage it as a technique.
Such as "It costs u1000 a week to lock someone up in prison"
bb
"Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote in message news:9226514543.337dd8ab@uninhabited.net...
On 18 Aug 2026 at 23:26:22 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote: >>
Jason Arday's PhD thesis of 2015 can be found on here
https://researchonline.ljmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/4552/1/158222_Jason%20Arday_%20Final%20PhD%20Thesis%20Vesrion%20Final%20Draft%20Oct%202015.pdf
While the 2009 thesis of Paula Zwozdiak-Myers, which he is claimed
to have plundered is here
https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/4316/1/FulltextThesis.pdf
Both are straightforward PDF's
While here is the "crib sheet" of claimed plagiarised passages, as
discovered by the racist Nathan Cofnas
https://ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
The yellow text represents what Cofnas claims, was copied.
As its impossible to copy text direct from his page, its necessary to
copy key passages manually. Starting maybe with
"student teachers are unique individuals"
which is at the start of a long if somewhat convoluted
paragraph in both.
And it really doesn't look too good,
As with the one exception of the passage concerning Dewey's
conceptualisation, which I can't find in Zwozdiak-Myers,
picking out key words especially attributions from Cofna's
selected yellow text, brings up lengthy identical/copied/stolen
passages in both theses.
And the copying/stealing of references is even worse IMO. As while
a person may be honestly mistaken in recognising a nicely turned
out paragraph as being one of their own, they're hardly likely to
mistake attributions and references to works they'd possibly
never even heard of.
All of which should have been spotted years ago.
bb
I can't speak to other subjects, but in medical publishing wholesale copying >> of references, either from other peoples' papers or your own is inevitable. On
any given topic there are strings of standard references that go in every
paper, which might have been read a decade or two ago.
That's not to detract from the seriousness of the plagiarisation of text that
you identify.
He isn't even copying them accurately
Try feeding "Price (2001: 44)" into both
Identical to start with but with paraphrasing towards the end
There's a reference to (Gray, 2004: 377) in the original;
while Arday's version is (Gray, 2010: 347)
I actually feel sorry for the bloke. He was presumably just trying
his luck and expecting to get caught out eventually. But people
just kept on believing him.
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
"Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote in message
news:9226514543.337dd8ab@uninhabited.net...
On 18 Aug 2026 at 23:26:22 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote: >>>
Jason Arday's PhD thesis of 2015 can be found on here
https://researchonline.ljmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/4552/1/158222_Jason%20Arday_%20Final%20PhD%20Thesis%20Vesrion%20Final%20Draft%20Oct%202015.pdf
While the 2009 thesis of Paula Zwozdiak-Myers, which he is claimed
to have plundered is here
https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/4316/1/FulltextThesis.pdf
Both are straightforward PDF's
While here is the "crib sheet" of claimed plagiarised passages, as
discovered by the racist Nathan Cofnas
https://ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
The yellow text represents what Cofnas claims, was copied.
As its impossible to copy text direct from his page, its necessary to
copy key passages manually. Starting maybe with
"student teachers are unique individuals"
which is at the start of a long if somewhat convoluted
paragraph in both.
And it really doesn't look too good,
As with the one exception of the passage concerning Dewey's
conceptualisation, which I can't find in Zwozdiak-Myers,
picking out key words especially attributions from Cofna's
selected yellow text, brings up lengthy identical/copied/stolen
passages in both theses.
And the copying/stealing of references is even worse IMO. As while
a person may be honestly mistaken in recognising a nicely turned
out paragraph as being one of their own, they're hardly likely to
mistake attributions and references to works they'd possibly
never even heard of.
All of which should have been spotted years ago.
bb
I can't speak to other subjects, but in medical publishing wholesale copying
of references, either from other peoples' papers or your own is inevitable. On
any given topic there are strings of standard references that go in every >>> paper, which might have been read a decade or two ago.
That's not to detract from the seriousness of the plagiarisation of text that
you identify.
He isn't even copying them accurately
Try feeding "Price (2001: 44)" into both
Identical to start with but with paraphrasing towards the end
There's a reference to (Gray, 2004: 377) in the original;
while Arday's version is (Gray, 2010: 347)
I actually feel sorry for the bloke. He was presumably just trying
his luck and expecting to get caught out eventually. But people
just kept on believing him.
I have no sympathy for him.
It has come to light his claims re being rCynon-verbalrCO etc were also bogus.
He was a conman who exploited the madness of DEI, assisted by DEI advocates who failed to check his claims.
His behaviour is no different to those who fake disability to claim
benefits or exploit other systems put in place to assist those with genuine issues.
billy bookcase <billy@anon.com> wrote:
"Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote in message
news:9226514543.337dd8ab@uninhabited.net...
On 18 Aug 2026 at 23:26:22 BST, ""billy bookcase"" <billy@anon.com> wrote: >>>
Jason Arday's PhD thesis of 2015 can be found on here
https://researchonline.ljmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/4552/1/158222_Jason%20Arday_%20Final%20PhD%20Thesis%20Vesrion%20Final%20Draft%20Oct%202015.pdf
While the 2009 thesis of Paula Zwozdiak-Myers, which he is claimed
to have plundered is here
https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/4316/1/FulltextThesis.pdf
Both are straightforward PDF's
While here is the "crib sheet" of claimed plagiarised passages, as
discovered by the racist Nathan Cofnas
https://ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
The yellow text represents what Cofnas claims, was copied.
As its impossible to copy text direct from his page, its necessary to
copy key passages manually. Starting maybe with
"student teachers are unique individuals"
which is at the start of a long if somewhat convoluted
paragraph in both.
And it really doesn't look too good,
As with the one exception of the passage concerning Dewey's
conceptualisation, which I can't find in Zwozdiak-Myers,
picking out key words especially attributions from Cofna's
selected yellow text, brings up lengthy identical/copied/stolen
passages in both theses.
And the copying/stealing of references is even worse IMO. As while
a person may be honestly mistaken in recognising a nicely turned
out paragraph as being one of their own, they're hardly likely to
mistake attributions and references to works they'd possibly
never even heard of.
All of which should have been spotted years ago.
bb
I can't speak to other subjects, but in medical publishing wholesale copying
of references, either from other peoples' papers or your own is inevitable.
On
any given topic there are strings of standard references that go in every >>> paper, which might have been read a decade or two ago.
That's not to detract from the seriousness of the plagiarisation of text >>> that
you identify.
He isn't even copying them accurately
Try feeding "Price (2001: 44)" into both
Identical to start with but with paraphrasing towards the end
There's a reference to (Gray, 2004: 377) in the original;
while Arday's version is (Gray, 2010: 347)
I actually feel sorry for the bloke. He was presumably just trying
his luck and expecting to get caught out eventually. But people
just kept on believing him.
I have no sympathy for him.
It has come to light his claims re being 'non-verbal' etc were also bogus.
He was a conman who exploited the madness of DEI, assisted by DEI advocates who failed to check his claims.
His behaviour is no different to those who fake disability to claim
benefits or exploit other systems put in place to assist those with genuine issues.
On 19/08/2026 15:37, Martin Harran wrote:
On 18 Aug 2026 22:31:05 GMT, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
[...]
I can't speak to other subjects, but in medical publishing wholesale
copying
of references, either from other peoples' papers or your own is
inevitable.
On any given topic there are strings of standard references that go
in every
paper, which might have been read a decade or two ago.
rCLif you copy from one author, itrCOs plagiarism, but if you copy from
many, itrCOs research.rCY
- Wilson Mizner
Can someone help me out here, because I really don't understand the
problem, but maybe that's because I've never written a thesis, let alone
a PhD.
What strikes me is that Mr Arjay's thesis is 400 pages long, and the
material that Nathan Cofnas claims has has been 'borrowed' probably
amounts to no more than 10-20 pages. (It is hard to tell, because it has
been presented in very narrow columns by Cofnas, but I'm guessing 10-20
pages worth.)
So, does that mean the Arjay thesis is well over 95% original?
Furthermore, it is necessary to read around the subject before writing
one's own thesis, and of course it's necessary to summarise the views of others. Arjay's thesis is not meant to be 100% original. It's meant to include others' work.
So, is the main issue here that Arjay simply didn't attribute around
10-20 pages of work correctly? If he had done so, he'd still have got
his PhD for the rest of his thesis, presumably.
The lack of attribution is serious, but it depends how central the
borrowed part of the thesis was to the central arguments, and I don't
think anyone has explained that. It may be that this was all background material. Even a small amount of unattributed copying can be fatal to
the PhD if it concerns original argumentation. But, did it?
A proper analysis would require some pretty hard work to understand the
full 400 pages as well as all the background material. Who has bothered
to do that? I note that a previous enquiry did look at the thesis, and
Arjay was exonerated. That enquiry would take into account things like
the supervision Arjay got. Maybe, his supervisor should be sacked?
So, what's going on here? Was the previous enquiry biased, as alleged?
Is there any evidence for that?
Oh, and I doubt that Arjay's athletic claims are true, but that's surely
got nothing to with his academic post?
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (1 / 5) |
| Uptime: | 35:15:53 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (6,742K bytes) |
| Messages: | 284,775 |