[1] BT pun intended
From the DT:
David Blunkett
The Archers is losing the plot
This weekrCOs storm drama was squeezed together with little regard for practicalities
Spoiler alert: Fans of The Archers should be up to date with their
listening before reading.
IrCOve been a long-standing listener of The Archers. In fact, my mum got
me dancing to the music at the age of four, so I have been listening for
the full 75 years of this famous soap. I have always enjoyed the ups and downs, the sometimes infuriating narrative and presentation, and, for
the most part, the acting.
I have stuck with it all these years, and still, despite the arguments around the location of the production studio, I hope it wonrCOt end up, in the future, being one of the inexplicable cuts at the BBC.
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad. There was
quite a lot to take in, and it was a very mixed bag. MondayrCOs edition
was, in my view, well put together, well-acted and reasonably credible. TuesdayrCOs was a mess.
The drama began on Sunday, when Ambridge was hit by appalling weather (a weekend earlier than the rest of us, as it happens). The wind was strong enough to blow away EddierCOs turkey shed, which ended up blocking a road. As if that werenrCOt enough, a tree also came down, adding to the chaos. Quite a storm, you might think, although you wouldnrCOt necessarily have known it from listening. For all this destruction, only the rain (and
not the supposed raging wind) could be heard.
By Monday, the consequences were becoming more serious. Vince Casey was badly injured by the falling tree in attempting to clear the road,
whilst hairdresser Chelsea (whom he was giving a lift) was in a real
state, still dressed for Pip and StellarCOs wedding. Their reception was taking place at the PargettersrCO Mansion, Lower Loxley Hall. Listeners
will remember the iconic episode when Elizabeth ArcherrCOs late husband, Nigel, slipped to his death from the roof. I seem to remember that there
was a chimney embedded in that particular drama.
Amidst all this, Josh suddenly appeared back from South America rCo but a bit late for the wedding. Josh is PiprCOs brother and son of David and
Ruth rCo who had been incandescent at his absence from their daughterrCOs wedding. His appearance, walking along the fated road, carrying a
rucksack, and with it, a usable mobile phone, was entertaining rCo if implausible. This apart, the episode was believable and the acting convincing.
Birmingham, United Kingdom - JANUARY 13: (L-R) Donald McDonald, sound producer, Kim Greengrass, The Archers|e-|director and Nikita Berry, producer, while recording an episode of The Archers at the BBC 4 studio
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad Credit: Jose Sarmento Matos
Tuesday, however, was another matter. Out of the blue, a chimney came crashing down through the Orangery, taking out what remained of the
wedding buffet. Suddenly, everyone was searching for candles as the
lights went out and mayhem reigned (although it was only 6:30pm and the clocks hadnrCOt gone back). It was all hands to the pumps to clear up the glass. Another disaster to add to the growing list. We were then treated
to a creepy insert of police officer Harrison Burns, joking about what a mess had been made, rather than taking an incident with potential
fatalities seriously.
Yet the story wasnrCOt finished. In what could easily have been a separate episode, we then had the bizarre situation of David driving his sister Elizabeth, who is VincerCOs partner (and mother of the irritating Freddie and his sister, Lily), to the scene of the disaster that had befallen
Vince.
Except that, somehow, Pip and Stella had got there first. Having
travelled to their wedding by tractor, they apparently used that same tractor (with a front-loader) to reach the scene, arriving ahead of
David and Elizabeth. Not only that, but they managed to pull away the remaining obstruction from across the road, allowing the ambulance and
fire brigade to get through. As of Thursday evening, we had no idea
about VincerCOs condition, although clearly, being trapped under a tree might give us all a clue.
By this point, the sequence of events was becoming rather difficult to follow. Quite how everyone managed to be where they were, when they
were, is anyonerCOs guess. The problem wasnrCOt a shortage of drama, but rather the way it was all squeezed together, with little apparent regard
for the practicalities or the order in which things might reasonably
have happened.
If yourCOre lost by now, then just listen, once again, to the omnibus edition, where they might actually have sophisticated the storyline and
got their ducks (no pun intended) in order.
IrCOm still listening, and yet still bewildered. Continuity might be
helped by letting the writers have a longer run than the week, and
sometimes maximum two weeks, to rCLtell the storyrCY. Whilst I appreciate that sometimes the tale will be rCLwaggedrCY by the resources that dog the producers, not hearing from particular rCLfavouritesrCY for months at a time is increasingly causing dislocation of the narrative and the overuse of individuals in an unfortunate manner.
What I want from Jeremy Howe, the editor, is more space for storylines. Adherence to the reality of life in the countryside should never take
away the creative drama intended to entertain and hold the audience. But surely, after 75 years, The Archers can still tell a good story without losing the plot.
We were not told that Vince was immobile until we were told he will
never walk again. Something was obviously edited out along the line.
And do people really set up CatChat to help find a missing Ena?
On 24.10.26 14:59, BrritSki wrote:
[1] BT pun intended
From the DT:
David Blunkett
The Archers is losing the plot
This weekrCOs storm drama was squeezed together with little regard for
practicalities
Spoiler alert: Fans of The Archers should be up to date with their
listening before reading.
IrCOve been a long-standing listener of The Archers. In fact, my mum got
me dancing to the music at the age of four, so I have been listening for
the full 75 years of this famous soap. I have always enjoyed the ups and
downs, the sometimes infuriating narrative and presentation, and, for
the most part, the acting.
I have stuck with it all these years, and still, despite the arguments
around the location of the production studio, I hope it wonrCOt end up, in >> the future, being one of the inexplicable cuts at the BBC.
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad. There was
quite a lot to take in, and it was a very mixed bag. MondayrCOs edition
was, in my view, well put together, well-acted and reasonably credible.
TuesdayrCOs was a mess.
The drama began on Sunday, when Ambridge was hit by appalling weather (a
weekend earlier than the rest of us, as it happens). The wind was strong
enough to blow away EddierCOs turkey shed, which ended up blocking a road. >> As if that werenrCOt enough, a tree also came down, adding to the chaos.
Quite a storm, you might think, although you wouldnrCOt necessarily have
known it from listening. For all this destruction, only the rain (and
not the supposed raging wind) could be heard.
By Monday, the consequences were becoming more serious. Vince Casey was
badly injured by the falling tree in attempting to clear the road,
whilst hairdresser Chelsea (whom he was giving a lift) was in a real
state, still dressed for Pip and StellarCOs wedding. Their reception was
taking place at the PargettersrCO Mansion, Lower Loxley Hall. Listeners
will remember the iconic episode when Elizabeth ArcherrCOs late husband,
Nigel, slipped to his death from the roof. I seem to remember that there
was a chimney embedded in that particular drama.
Amidst all this, Josh suddenly appeared back from South America rCo but a >> bit late for the wedding. Josh is PiprCOs brother and son of David and
Ruth rCo who had been incandescent at his absence from their daughterrCOs >> wedding. His appearance, walking along the fated road, carrying a
rucksack, and with it, a usable mobile phone, was entertaining rCo if
implausible. This apart, the episode was believable and the acting
convincing.
Birmingham, United Kingdom - JANUARY 13: (L-R) Donald McDonald, sound
producer, Kim Greengrass, The Archers|e-|director and Nikita Berry,
producer, while recording an episode of The Archers at the BBC 4 studio
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad Credit: Jose
Sarmento Matos
Tuesday, however, was another matter. Out of the blue, a chimney came
crashing down through the Orangery, taking out what remained of the
wedding buffet. Suddenly, everyone was searching for candles as the
lights went out and mayhem reigned (although it was only 6:30pm and the
clocks hadnrCOt gone back). It was all hands to the pumps to clear up the >> glass. Another disaster to add to the growing list. We were then treated
to a creepy insert of police officer Harrison Burns, joking about what a
mess had been made, rather than taking an incident with potential
fatalities seriously.
Yet the story wasnrCOt finished. In what could easily have been a separate >> episode, we then had the bizarre situation of David driving his sister
Elizabeth, who is VincerCOs partner (and mother of the irritating Freddie >> and his sister, Lily), to the scene of the disaster that had befallen
Vince.
Except that, somehow, Pip and Stella had got there first. Having
travelled to their wedding by tractor, they apparently used that same
tractor (with a front-loader) to reach the scene, arriving ahead of
David and Elizabeth. Not only that, but they managed to pull away the
remaining obstruction from across the road, allowing the ambulance and
fire brigade to get through. As of Thursday evening, we had no idea
about VincerCOs condition, although clearly, being trapped under a tree
might give us all a clue.
By this point, the sequence of events was becoming rather difficult to
follow. Quite how everyone managed to be where they were, when they
were, is anyonerCOs guess. The problem wasnrCOt a shortage of drama, but
rather the way it was all squeezed together, with little apparent regard
for the practicalities or the order in which things might reasonably
have happened.
If yourCOre lost by now, then just listen, once again, to the omnibus
edition, where they might actually have sophisticated the storyline and
got their ducks (no pun intended) in order.
IrCOm still listening, and yet still bewildered. Continuity might be
helped by letting the writers have a longer run than the week, and
sometimes maximum two weeks, to rCLtell the storyrCY. Whilst I appreciate >> that sometimes the tale will be rCLwaggedrCY by the resources that dog the >> producers, not hearing from particular rCLfavouritesrCY for months at a time
is increasingly causing dislocation of the narrative and the overuse of
individuals in an unfortunate manner.
What I want from Jeremy Howe, the editor, is more space for storylines.
Adherence to the reality of life in the countryside should never take
away the creative drama intended to entertain and hold the audience. But
surely, after 75 years, The Archers can still tell a good story without
losing the plot.
In my view the week was far worse than recounted above. The silly witterings on Sunday of the married couple did not sound overly real to
me and Chelsea is no empty headed doll who (having had her hair dressing
kit stolen not so long ago) would accidentally leave it all in the Bungalow.
The chimney on top of LoLo hall would have largely fallen on through the house not the Orangery which we know is some distance from the main building.
Josh failed to reach his destination as his taxi could not get there -
which seems reasonable but the farce by which a tractor and a car can
both get there in a different order to leaving LoLo was an obvious nonsense.
We were not told that Vince was immobile until we were told he will
never walk again. Something was obviously edited out along the line.
By the time the cuts have been applied for the omnibus it will probably
make even less sense - why had Keira and Eddie nothing better to do than scrump the apples?
And do people really set up CatChat to help find a missing Ena?
On 24.10.26 14:59, BrritSki wrote:
[1] BT pun intended
-aFrom the DT:
David Blunkett
The Archers is losing the plot
This weekrCOs storm drama was squeezed together with little regard for
practicalities
Spoiler alert: Fans of The Archers should be up to date with their
listening before reading.
IrCOve been a long-standing listener of The Archers. In fact, my mum got
me dancing to the music at the age of four, so I have been listening
for the full 75 years of this famous soap. I have always enjoyed the
ups and downs, the sometimes infuriating narrative and presentation,
and, for the most part, the acting.
I have stuck with it all these years, and still, despite the arguments
around the location of the production studio, I hope it wonrCOt end up,
in the future, being one of the inexplicable cuts at the BBC.
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad. There was
quite a lot to take in, and it was a very mixed bag. MondayrCOs edition
was, in my view, well put together, well-acted and reasonably
credible. TuesdayrCOs was a mess.
The drama began on Sunday, when Ambridge was hit by appalling weather
(a weekend earlier than the rest of us, as it happens). The wind was
strong enough to blow away EddierCOs turkey shed, which ended up
blocking a road. As if that werenrCOt enough, a tree also came down,
adding to the chaos. Quite a storm, you might think, although you
wouldnrCOt necessarily have known it from listening. For all this
destruction, only the rain (and not the supposed raging wind) could be
heard.
By Monday, the consequences were becoming more serious. Vince Casey
was badly injured by the falling tree in attempting to clear the road,
whilst hairdresser Chelsea (whom he was giving a lift) was in a real
state, still dressed for Pip and StellarCOs wedding. Their reception was
taking place at the PargettersrCO Mansion, Lower Loxley Hall. Listeners
will remember the iconic episode when Elizabeth ArcherrCOs late husband,
Nigel, slipped to his death from the roof. I seem to remember that
there was a chimney embedded in that particular drama.
Amidst all this, Josh suddenly appeared back from South America rCo but
a bit late for the wedding. Josh is PiprCOs brother and son of David and
Ruth rCo who had been incandescent at his absence from their daughterrCOs >> wedding. His appearance, walking along the fated road, carrying a
rucksack, and with it, a usable mobile phone, was entertaining rCo if
implausible. This apart, the episode was believable and the acting
convincing.
Birmingham, United Kingdom - JANUARY 13: (L-R) Donald McDonald, sound
producer, Kim Greengrass, The Archers|e-|director and Nikita Berry,
producer, while recording an episode of The Archers at the BBC 4 studio
This weekrCOs episodes illustrate both the good and the bad Credit: Jose
Sarmento Matos
Tuesday, however, was another matter. Out of the blue, a chimney came
crashing down through the Orangery, taking out what remained of the
wedding buffet. Suddenly, everyone was searching for candles as the
lights went out and mayhem reigned (although it was only 6:30pm and
the clocks hadnrCOt gone back). It was all hands to the pumps to clear
up the glass. Another disaster to add to the growing list. We were
then treated to a creepy insert of police officer Harrison Burns,
joking about what a mess had been made, rather than taking an incident
with potential fatalities seriously.
Yet the story wasnrCOt finished. In what could easily have been a
separate episode, we then had the bizarre situation of David driving
his sister Elizabeth, who is VincerCOs partner (and mother of the
irritating Freddie and his sister, Lily), to the scene of the disaster
that had befallen Vince.
Except that, somehow, Pip and Stella had got there first. Having
travelled to their wedding by tractor, they apparently used that same
tractor (with a front-loader) to reach the scene, arriving ahead of
David and Elizabeth. Not only that, but they managed to pull away the
remaining obstruction from across the road, allowing the ambulance and
fire brigade to get through. As of Thursday evening, we had no idea
about VincerCOs condition, although clearly, being trapped under a tree
might give us all a clue.
By this point, the sequence of events was becoming rather difficult to
follow. Quite how everyone managed to be where they were, when they
were, is anyonerCOs guess. The problem wasnrCOt a shortage of drama, but
rather the way it was all squeezed together, with little apparent
regard for the practicalities or the order in which things might
reasonably have happened.
If yourCOre lost by now, then just listen, once again, to the omnibus
edition, where they might actually have sophisticated the storyline
and got their ducks (no pun intended) in order.
IrCOm still listening, and yet still bewildered. Continuity might be
helped by letting the writers have a longer run than the week, and
sometimes maximum two weeks, to rCLtell the storyrCY. Whilst I appreciate >> that sometimes the tale will be rCLwaggedrCY by the resources that dog the >> producers, not hearing from particular rCLfavouritesrCY for months at a
time is increasingly causing dislocation of the narrative and the
overuse of individuals in an unfortunate manner.
What I want from Jeremy Howe, the editor, is more space for
storylines. Adherence to the reality of life in the countryside should
never take away the creative drama intended to entertain and hold the
audience. But surely, after 75 years, The Archers can still tell a
good story without losing the plot.
In my view the week was far worse than recounted above.-a The silly witterings on Sunday of the married couple did not sound overly real to
me and Chelsea is no empty headed doll who (having had her hair dressing
kit stolen not so long ago) would accidentally leave it all in the
Bungalow.
The chimney on top of LoLo hall would have largely fallen on through the house not the Orangery which we know is some distance from the main building.
Josh failed to reach his destination as his taxi could not get there -
which seems reasonable but the farce by which a tractor and a car can
both get there in a different order to leaving LoLo was an obvious
nonsense.
We were not told that Vince was immobile until we were told he will
never walk again.-a Something was obviously edited out along the line.
By the time the cuts have been applied for the omnibus it will probably
make even less sense - why had Keira and Eddie nothing better to do than scrump the apples?
And do people really set up CatChat to help find a missing Ena?
I assumed that the newlyweds were removing the other tree, not the one
that Vince was under. I wouldn't think that they'd want to start moving Vince's tree as that might cause him further damage, much better to
leave it to the professionals.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 58:18:56 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,959 |