Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and antisemitic beliefs?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/families-clear-homes-of-david-walliams-books-after-sexual-offence-allegations
Families clear homes of David Walliams books after sexual offence
allegations
Parents take action while several independent bookshops say they had
already stopped stocking his titles
In SarahrCOs house, David Walliams has been a bedtime staple for years.
Her children, aged eight, six and four, have dressed up as his
characters for World Book Day rCo they love the over-the-top, unusual
names and illustrations.
Now, all the books are going. rCLIrCOll probably take them away and replace them with other authors,rCY says Sarah, a mother in west London. rCLSooner rather than later, so they donrCOt realise.rCY If any of her children ask why, she will tell them rCLthat his choices arenrCOt great and that I think we should be reading other booksrCY.
Some schools appear to be taking a harder line rCo several teachers told
the Guardian they were removing Walliams books from their classroom shelves.
For Sarah, the principle is simple: rCLKids need to understand that
actions have consequences. If somethingrCOs not right, then we need to act upon it.rCY
On 13 Nov 2026 at 21:23:08 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and
antisemitic beliefs?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/families-clear-homes-of-david-walliams-books-after-sexual-offence-allegations
Families clear homes of David Walliams books after sexual offence
allegations
Parents take action while several independent bookshops say they had
already stopped stocking his titles
In SarahrCOs house, David Walliams has been a bedtime staple for years.
Her children, aged eight, six and four, have dressed up as his
characters for World Book Day rCo they love the over-the-top, unusual
names and illustrations.
Now, all the books are going. rCLIrCOll probably take them away and replace >> them with other authors,rCY says Sarah, a mother in west London. rCLSooner >> rather than later, so they donrCOt realise.rCY If any of her children ask
why, she will tell them rCLthat his choices arenrCOt great and that I think >> we should be reading other booksrCY.
Some schools appear to be taking a harder line rCo several teachers told
the Guardian they were removing Walliams books from their classroom shelves. >>
For Sarah, the principle is simple: rCLKids need to understand that
actions have consequences. If somethingrCOs not right, then we need to act >> upon it.rCY
Personally I think given the kind of knowing nastiness that Roald Dahl's books
(at least the few I've seen) portrayed they would be no loss.
Some of said
that Walliam's books are similar. But I would only reject them on their content, not the reputation of their authors. And I wouldn't stop those who liked them from giving them to their children. In other news, Lewis Carroll's real life persona seems to have shown some somewhat dubious interest in young girls. FAOD I think the Alice books should definitely be kept in circulation.
Again, that's just on the merits of the books.
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 13 Nov 2026 at 21:23:08 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and
antisemitic beliefs?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/families-clear-homes-of-david-walliams-books-after-sexual-offence-allegations
Families clear homes of David Walliams books after sexual offence
allegations
Parents take action while several independent bookshops say they had
already stopped stocking his titles
In SarahrCOs house, David Walliams has been a bedtime staple for years.
Her children, aged eight, six and four, have dressed up as his
characters for World Book Day rCo they love the over-the-top, unusual
names and illustrations.
Now, all the books are going. rCLIrCOll probably take them away and replace >>> them with other authors,rCY says Sarah, a mother in west London. rCLSooner >>> rather than later, so they donrCOt realise.rCY If any of her children ask >>> why, she will tell them rCLthat his choices arenrCOt great and that I think >>> we should be reading other booksrCY.
Some schools appear to be taking a harder line rCo several teachers told >>> the Guardian they were removing Walliams books from their classroom shelves.
For Sarah, the principle is simple: rCLKids need to understand that
actions have consequences. If somethingrCOs not right, then we need to act >>> upon it.rCY
Personally I think given the kind of knowing nastiness that Roald Dahl's books
(at least the few I've seen) portrayed they would be no loss.
Cut the guy a little slack, he was probably suffering from untreated PTSD.
After a long stay in hospital following a crash landing due to being sent
to the wrong place, Dahl took part in the Battle of Athens:
rCLOn 20 April 1941, Dahl took part in an event he called the Battle of Athens, alongside the highest-scoring British Commonwealth ace of World War II, Pat Pattle, and Dahl's friend David Coke. Of 12 Hurricanes involved,
five were shot down and four of their pilots killed, including Pattle.
Greek observers on the ground counted 22 German aircraft downed, but
because of the confusion of the aerial engagement, none of the pilots knew which aircraft they had shot down. Dahl described it as "an endless blur of enemy fighters whizzing towards me from every side".[66] [from Wikipedia].
When Dahl returned to his base, he along with the surviving pilots were shaking so much they couldnrCOt even light a cigarette, yet the CO was shouting at them to tell him what had happened.
ItrCOs thought that the German force they attacked consisted of some 200 aircraft.
Again from Wikipedia:
rCLWhen he began to get severe headaches that caused him to black out, he was invalided home to Britain where he stayed with his mother in Buckinghamshire.[69]rCY
Thank goodness none of us suffered similarity. Who knows what books we
might have otherwise written.
In this region of England illegal immigrants live in hotels and are given pocket-money, while ex-service personnel with PTSD sleep in doorways. Funny old society we have, innit?
Some of said
that Walliam's books are similar. But I would only reject them on their
content, not the reputation of their authors. And I wouldn't stop those who >> liked them from giving them to their children. In other news, Lewis Carroll's
real life persona seems to have shown some somewhat dubious interest in young
girls. FAOD I think the Alice books should definitely be kept in circulation.
Again, that's just on the merits of the books.
They used to burn alleged witches, couldnrCOt we do the same to those whose newly-regarded misconduct years if not decades after the event is deemed unacceptable yet who have not been charged with any crime? Unperson them in Ministry of Truth fashion?
Do we need to tighten up on the law, such as to make the accusation the verdict? Or is the current system good enough for the job?
On 14 Nov 2026 at 09:43:39 GMT+0, "Spike" <aero.spike@mail.com> wrote:
They used to burn alleged witches, couldnrCOt we do the same to those whose >> newly-regarded misconduct years if not decades after the event is deemed
unacceptable yet who have not been charged with any crime? Unperson them in >> Ministry of Truth fashion?
Do we need to tighten up on the law, such as to make the accusation the
verdict? Or is the current system good enough for the job?
On the other hand, the idea that middle-aged men befriending vulnerable young girls and having sexual relationships with them after they reached sixteen was
not actually illegal was at least as important as any inverse racism in the initial failure to investigate and prosecute "grooming gangs" in Northern cities. Clearly after proper investigation things that were actually illegal were discovered. Especially when the girls' and women's testimony was believed.
On 14/11/2026 11:07, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 at 09:43:39 GMT+0, "Spike" <aero.spike@mail.com> wrote:
They used to burn alleged witches, couldnrCOt we do the same to those whose >>> newly-regarded misconduct years if not decades after the event is deemed >>> unacceptable yet who have not been charged with any crime? Unperson them in >>> Ministry of Truth fashion?
Do we need to tighten up on the law, such as to make the accusation the
verdict? Or is the current system good enough for the job?
On the other hand, the idea that middle-aged men befriending vulnerable young
girls and having sexual relationships with them after they reached sixteen was
not actually illegal was at least as important as any inverse racism in the >> initial failure to investigate and prosecute "grooming gangs" in Northern
cities. Clearly after proper investigation things that were actually illegal >> were discovered. Especially when the girls' and women's testimony was
believed.
I think the main feature of the grooming gangs (which operated in a
number of towns/cities/areas) was the fact that the girls were both
underage and very vulnerable - from dysfunctional families or childrens homes, beyond the control of any parent. That prejudiced the police
against them and instead of being seen as vulnerable children they were
seen as young prostitutes willingly having sex with older men who bought
them alcohol and cheap presents.
I am not aware that any of the girls or women befriended by Walliams can
be in that category, but perhaps all will become clear if any charges
follow.
On 14 Nov 2026 at 09:43:39 GMT+0, "Spike" <aero.spike@mail.com> wrote:
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 13 Nov 2026 at 21:23:08 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are >>>> they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and >>>> antisemitic beliefs?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/families-clear-homes-of-david-walliams-books-after-sexual-offence-allegations
Families clear homes of David Walliams books after sexual offence
allegations
Parents take action while several independent bookshops say they had
already stopped stocking his titles
In SarahrCOs house, David Walliams has been a bedtime staple for years. >>>> Her children, aged eight, six and four, have dressed up as his
characters for World Book Day rCo they love the over-the-top, unusual
names and illustrations.
Now, all the books are going. rCLIrCOll probably take them away and replace
them with other authors,rCY says Sarah, a mother in west London. rCLSooner >>>> rather than later, so they donrCOt realise.rCY If any of her children ask >>>> why, she will tell them rCLthat his choices arenrCOt great and that I think
we should be reading other booksrCY.
Some schools appear to be taking a harder line rCo several teachers told >>>> the Guardian they were removing Walliams books from their classroom shelves.
For Sarah, the principle is simple: rCLKids need to understand that
actions have consequences. If somethingrCOs not right, then we need to act >>>> upon it.rCY
Personally I think given the kind of knowing nastiness that Roald Dahl's books
(at least the few I've seen) portrayed they would be no loss.
Cut the guy a little slack, he was probably suffering from untreated PTSD. >>
After a long stay in hospital following a crash landing due to being sent
to the wrong place, Dahl took part in the Battle of Athens:
rCLOn 20 April 1941, Dahl took part in an event he called the Battle of
Athens, alongside the highest-scoring British Commonwealth ace of World War >> II, Pat Pattle, and Dahl's friend David Coke. Of 12 Hurricanes involved,
five were shot down and four of their pilots killed, including Pattle.
Greek observers on the ground counted 22 German aircraft downed, but
because of the confusion of the aerial engagement, none of the pilots knew >> which aircraft they had shot down. Dahl described it as "an endless blur of >> enemy fighters whizzing towards me from every side".[66] [from Wikipedia]. >>
When Dahl returned to his base, he along with the surviving pilots were
shaking so much they couldnrCOt even light a cigarette, yet the CO was
shouting at them to tell him what had happened.
ItrCOs thought that the German force they attacked consisted of some 200
aircraft.
Again from Wikipedia:
rCLWhen he began to get severe headaches that caused him to black out, he was
invalided home to Britain where he stayed with his mother in
Buckinghamshire.[69]rCY
Thank goodness none of us suffered similarity. Who knows what books we
might have otherwise written.
In this region of England illegal immigrants live in hotels and are given
pocket-money, while ex-service personnel with PTSD sleep in doorways. Funny >> old society we have, innit?
Some of said
that Walliam's books are similar. But I would only reject them on their
content, not the reputation of their authors. And I wouldn't stop those who >>> liked them from giving them to their children. In other news, Lewis Carroll's
real life persona seems to have shown some somewhat dubious interest in young
girls. FAOD I think the Alice books should definitely be kept in circulation.
Again, that's just on the merits of the books.
They used to burn alleged witches, couldnrCOt we do the same to those whose >> newly-regarded misconduct years if not decades after the event is deemed
unacceptable yet who have not been charged with any crime? Unperson them in >> Ministry of Truth fashion?
Do we need to tighten up on the law, such as to make the accusation the
verdict? Or is the current system good enough for the job?
On the other hand, the idea that middle-aged men befriending vulnerable young girls and having sexual relationships with them after they reached sixteen was
not actually illegal was at least as important as any inverse racism in the initial failure to investigate and prosecute "grooming gangs" in Northern cities. Clearly after proper investigation things that were actually illegal were discovered. Especially when the girls' and women's testimony was believed.
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race hatred, bullying of minorities?
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 at 09:43:39 GMT+0, "Spike" <aero.spike@mail.com> wrote:
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 13 Nov 2026 at 21:23:08 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com>
wrote:
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and
are they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, >>>>> race hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel
and antisemitic beliefs?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/13/families-clear- homes-of-david-walliams-books-after-sexual-offence-allegations
Families clear homes of David Walliams books after sexual offence
allegations
Parents take action while several independent bookshops say they had >>>>> already stopped stocking his titles
In SarahrCOs house, David Walliams has been a bedtime staple for
years.
Her children, aged eight, six and four, have dressed up as his
characters for World Book Day rCo they love the over-the-top, unusual >>>>> names and illustrations.
Now, all the books are going. rCLIrCOll probably take them away and
replace them with other authors,rCY says Sarah, a mother in west
London. rCLSooner rather than later, so they donrCOt realise.rCY If any of
her children ask why, she will tell them rCLthat his choices arenrCOt >>>>> great and that I think we should be reading other booksrCY.
Some schools appear to be taking a harder line rCo several teachers
told the Guardian they were removing Walliams books from their
classroom shelves.
For Sarah, the principle is simple: rCLKids need to understand that
actions have consequences. If somethingrCOs not right, then we need to >>>>> act upon it.rCY
Personally I think given the kind of knowing nastiness that Roald
Dahl's books (at least the few I've seen) portrayed they would be no
loss.
Cut the guy a little slack, he was probably suffering from untreated
PTSD.
After a long stay in hospital following a crash landing due to being
sent to the wrong place, Dahl took part in the Battle of Athens:
rCLOn 20 April 1941, Dahl took part in an event he called the Battle of
Athens, alongside the highest-scoring British Commonwealth ace of
World War II, Pat Pattle, and Dahl's friend David Coke. Of 12
Hurricanes involved, five were shot down and four of their pilots
killed, including Pattle.
Greek observers on the ground counted 22 German aircraft downed, but
because of the confusion of the aerial engagement, none of the pilots
knew which aircraft they had shot down. Dahl described it as "an
endless blur of enemy fighters whizzing towards me from every
side".[66] [from Wikipedia].
When Dahl returned to his base, he along with the surviving pilots
were shaking so much they couldnrCOt even light a cigarette, yet the CO
was shouting at them to tell him what had happened.
ItrCOs thought that the German force they attacked consisted of some 200 >>> aircraft.
Again from Wikipedia:
rCLWhen he began to get severe headaches that caused him to black out,
he was invalided home to Britain where he stayed with his mother in
Buckinghamshire.[69]rCY
Thank goodness none of us suffered similarity. Who knows what books we
might have otherwise written.
In this region of England illegal immigrants live in hotels and are
given pocket-money, while ex-service personnel with PTSD sleep in
doorways. Funny old society we have, innit?
Some of said that Walliam's books are similar. But I would only
reject them on their content, not the reputation of their authors.
And I wouldn't stop those who liked them from giving them to their
children. In other news, Lewis Carroll's real life persona seems to
have shown some somewhat dubious interest in young girls. FAOD I
think the Alice books should definitely be kept in circulation.
Again, that's just on the merits of the books.
They used to burn alleged witches, couldnrCOt we do the same to those
whose newly-regarded misconduct years if not decades after the event
is deemed unacceptable yet who have not been charged with any crime?
Unperson them in Ministry of Truth fashion?
Do we need to tighten up on the law, such as to make the accusation
the verdict? Or is the current system good enough for the job?
On the other hand, the idea that middle-aged men befriending vulnerable
young girls and having sexual relationships with them after they
reached sixteen was not actually illegal was at least as important as
any inverse racism in the initial failure to investigate and prosecute
"grooming gangs" in Northern cities. Clearly after proper investigation
things that were actually illegal were discovered. Especially when the
girls' and women's testimony was believed.
I see the Ministry of Truth has been busy.
This from Wikipedia:
rCLDuring his lifetime, Dahl had urged his publishers not to "so much as change a single comma in one of [his] books".[1]
On 19 February 2023 Puffin Books announced it had hired sensitivity
readers over the span of three years to assess Dahl's works, rereleasing
his work with multiple changes regarding Dahl's depiction of race, sex
and character.
A report from British newspaper The Telegraph determined that Puffin
Books altered hundreds of passages in Dahl's work, including in Charlie
and the Chocolate Factory, Matilda, James and the Giant Peach, Fantastic
Mr Fox and The Witches.
Facing backlash from readers and authors, on 23 February Puffin Books announced that Dahl's original publications would be released alongside
the expurgated versions as "The Roald Dahl Classic Collection", but did
not retract the revisions.
Various authors, politicians, and organisations have commented on the controversy. It was later announced that the works of Enid Blyton
(author of The Famous Five) and Ian Fleming (author of James Bond) would
be expurgated as well, and it was reported that R. L. Stine's Goosebumps
had already been expurgated without the author's knowledge.rCY
Around 1950, while in infant school, I won a prize. It was a book about
the jungle, and contains what would now be regarded as unacceptable depictions of people. Should I burn it? I doubt itrCOs subsequently been given Roald DahlrCOs Ministry of Truth treatment.
Parents buy books, not children. If the author of said books is reputed to >have an... unwholesome interest in children, would parents still want to
buy the books?
If you're a children's bookshop, your customers are parents. If many
parents have decided that seeing these books upsets them, why would you put >them on display?
If you're a library, your customers are parents even if those who see the >displays might be children. If your customers don't want the books to be
on display, why would you not listen to them?
Market forces.
They aren't banned - I'm sure you can still order them if you want them.
I see the Ministry of Truth has been busy.
This from Wikipedia:
rCLDuring his lifetime, Dahl had urged his publishers not to "so much as change a single comma in one of [his] books".[1]
On 19 February 2023 Puffin Books announced it had hired sensitivity readers over the span of three years to assess Dahl's works, rereleasing his work with multiple changes regarding Dahl's depiction of race, sex and
character.
A report from British newspaper The Telegraph determined that Puffin Books altered hundreds of passages in Dahl's work, including in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Matilda, James and the Giant Peach, Fantastic Mr Fox and The Witches.
Facing backlash from readers and authors, on 23 February Puffin Books announced that Dahl's original publications would be released alongside the expurgated versions as "The Roald Dahl Classic Collection", but did not retract the revisions.
The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
Extraordinary, the irrational behaviour that has resulted from the
Walliams press reports.
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
Parents buy books, not children. If the author of said books is reputed to have an... unwholesome interest in children, would parents still want to
buy the books?
If you're a children's bookshop, your customers are parents. If many
parents have decided that seeing these books upsets them, why would you put them on display?
If you're a library, your customers are parents even if those who see the displays might be children. If your customers don't want the books to be
on display, why would you not listen to them?
Market forces.
They aren't banned - I'm sure you can still order them if you want them.
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for
being attracted to 15 year olds. Obviously that is an inaccurate description.
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 20:12:58 +0000, The Todal wrote:
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for
being attracted to 15 year olds. Obviously that is an inaccurate
description.
And trying to correct people can be considered apologist ...
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and antisemitic beliefs?
On 14 Nov 2026 at 20:59:29 GMT+0, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 20:12:58 +0000, The Todal wrote:
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for
being attracted to 15 year olds. Obviously that is an inaccurate
description.
And trying to correct people can be considered apologist ...
In any case that ship has sailed. Despite the psychopathological difference the general population definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely to be met with deep suspicion.
On 11/14/26 21:40, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 at 20:59:29 GMT+0, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com>
wrote:
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 20:12:58 +0000, The Todal wrote:
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for
being attracted to 15 year olds.-a Obviously that is an inaccurate
description.
And trying to correct people can be considered apologist ...
In any case that ship has sailed. Despite the psychopathological
difference
the general population definitely regards sexual interest in the under
sixteens as paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct
this is
likely to be met with deep suspicion.
And yet a huge percentage of under 16s indulge in sexual behaviours.
I think the truth is that the general population believe it is wrong for much older people to have intimate relationships with very young people. Intimate relationship where the older person can use their greater experience to manipulate emotionally, to exert coercive control.
We should take the trouble to stop relationships between people of a few years difference being described a paedophilia. e.g. a 17 year old and a
15 year old.
On 15/11/2026 08:50, Pancho wrote:
On 11/14/26 21:40, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 at 20:59:29 GMT+0, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com>
wrote:
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 20:12:58 +0000, The Todal wrote:
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for >>>>> being attracted to 15 year olds.-a Obviously that is an inaccurate
description.
And trying to correct people can be considered apologist ...
In any case that ship has sailed. Despite the psychopathological
difference
the general population definitely regards sexual interest in the under
sixteens as paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct
this is
likely to be met with deep suspicion.
And yet a huge percentage of under 16s indulge in sexual behaviours.
I think the truth is that the general population believe it is wrong
for much older people to have intimate relationships with very young
people. Intimate relationship where the older person can use their
greater experience to manipulate emotionally, to exert coercive control.
We should take the trouble to stop relationships between people of a
few years difference being described a paedophilia. e.g. a 17 year old
and a 15 year old.
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/russell-brand-mia-latter-age- of-consent-3pwdcqjsc
quotes
Mia Latter never found out the results of her AS-level exams. As a 16- year-old in 2006, her teachers had considered her a talented student rCo until her education was derailed by an emotionally and sexually abusive relationship with Russell Brand, who was 30 when they met.
Now 37, Latter does not want other teenagers to suffer as she did.
Today, she is waiving her right to lifelong anonymity rCo afforded to all victims of alleged sexual offences in the UK rCo to campaign for a change
in the law that she hopes will help rCLprotect teenagers from being
groomed by older men or womenrCY as she was.
She is calling for the introduction of a rCLstaggeredrCY age of consent that would prohibit relationships between 16- and 17-year-olds and adults. rCLI donrCOt want to criminalise teenagers having sex with each other,rCY she said. rCLIf yourCOre between the ages of 16 and 18, it seems reasonable that you can have relationships with each other, and [teenagers] are always
going to. But rCa if yourCOre in your thirties, forties and fifties and yourCOre trying to have a relationship with someone under the age of 18,
it [should be] a criminal offence.rCY
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
On 15/11/2026 10:12, The Todal wrote:
On 15/11/2026 08:50, Pancho wrote:
On 11/14/26 21:40, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 at 20:59:29 GMT+0, "Jethro"
<jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 20:12:58 +0000, The Todal wrote:
On 14/11/2026 15:04, Theo wrote:
[quoted text muted]
It is fashionable among journalists to call someone a paedophile for >>>>>> being attracted to 15 year olds.-a Obviously that is an inaccurate >>>>>> description.
And trying to correct people can be considered apologist ...
In any case that ship has sailed. Despite the psychopathological
difference
the general population definitely regards sexual interest in the under >>>> sixteens as paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct
this is
likely to be met with deep suspicion.
And yet a huge percentage of under 16s indulge in sexual behaviours.
I think the truth is that the general population believe it is wrong
for much older people to have intimate relationships with very young
people. Intimate relationship where the older person can use their
greater experience to manipulate emotionally, to exert coercive control. >>>
We should take the trouble to stop relationships between people of a
few years difference being described a paedophilia. e.g. a 17 year
old and a 15 year old.
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a
"staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to
realise is an appalling vista.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/russell-brand-mia-latter-
age- of-consent-3pwdcqjsc
quotes
Mia Latter never found out the results of her AS-level exams. As a 16-
year-old in 2006, her teachers had considered her a talented student rCo
until her education was derailed by an emotionally and sexually
abusive relationship with Russell Brand, who was 30 when they met.
Now 37, Latter does not want other teenagers to suffer as she did.
Today, she is waiving her right to lifelong anonymity rCo afforded to
all victims of alleged sexual offences in the UK rCo to campaign for a
change in the law that she hopes will help rCLprotect teenagers from
being groomed by older men or womenrCY as she was.
She is calling for the introduction of a rCLstaggeredrCY age of consent
that would prohibit relationships between 16- and 17-year-olds and
adults. rCLI donrCOt want to criminalise teenagers having sex with each
other,rCY she said. rCLIf yourCOre between the ages of 16 and 18, it seems >> reasonable that you can have relationships with each other, and
[teenagers] are always going to. But rCa if yourCOre in your thirties,
forties and fifties and yourCOre trying to have a relationship with
someone under the age of 18, it [should be] a criminal offence.rCY
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age
of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
I think one flaw in "staggered age of consent" is that most young men of
18 to 25 mainly want to get their end away without any commitment to a longterm relationship, and thus there will still be heartbreak for young girls who (not all of them of course) are hoping for true love and
possible marriage or longterm commitment.
A staggered age of consent would infantilise all young women.
On 13 Nov 2026 at 21:23:08 GMT+0, The Todal wrote:
I haven't read the Walliams books - has anyone here read them, and are
they likely to deprave and corrupt? Do they incite misbehaviour, race
hatred, bullying of minorities?
And can we expect Roald Dahl's books to be banned next, as people
gradually realise (or are reminded) that he had strong anti-Israel and
antisemitic beliefs?
It's an ethical call - whether to separate the art from the artist.
I find Nick Cave's position persuasive:
https://www.theredhandfiles.com/kanye-art-artist/
(TL;DR - don't throw out babies with bathwater; itrCOs reasonable to
find real value in art, as long as you arenrCOt pretending the personrCOs conduct doesnrCOt matter.)
Legally proscribing art because of the views of the creator is (IMVHO)
the beginning of the end.
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/russell-brand-mia-latter-age-of-consent-3pwdcqjsc...
quotes
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age
of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a
"staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible
to me.
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a
"staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible
to me.
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/russell-brand-mia-latter-age-of-consent-3pwdcqjsc...
quotes
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age
of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
That seems pretty silly though. It means a relationship between, say,
a 17-year-old and a 23-year-old is legal, but becomes illegal when the 23-year-old turns 24, and then becomes legal again when the 17-year-old
turns 18. I would've thought "if they're between 16 and 21 then the age
gap must be under 5 years", or something like that, would be far more sensible.
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a
"staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible
to me.
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now. Russell Brand
has rightly been prosecuted and punished under the existing laws.
Walliams, so far, is accused only of using his wealth and fame to charm
young women into bed. The protections are already in place if the
seducer is in a "position of trust".
It is against the law for someone in a position of trust to engage in
sexual activity with a child in their care, even if that child is over
the age of consent. This means that even though the child may be over
the age of consent (16), it is illegal to engage in sexual activity with
any 16 or 17 year old if you hold a position of trust.
Examples include
rCo Teachers
rCo Care workers
rCo Youth justice workers
rCo Social workers
rCo Doctors
Should one add a new example "being on the telly?" Or, would the
lawmakers decide that every adult is in a position of trust regardless
of their actual role?
And presumably the older person can wine and dine the younger person,
can form a friendship, can prepare (groom?) that younger person so long
as no contact of a sexual nature takes place. And any hug or chaste kiss
can be interpreted by a spurned young person as a sexual contact.
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of trust is by >no means unreasonable.
And avoiding hugging or kissing seems a very tolerable burden.
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population
definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely
to be met with deep suspicion.
Should one add a new example "being on the telly?" Or, would the lawmakers decide that every adult is in a position of trust regardless of their actual role?
In message <5133218178.82a3300b@uninhabited.net>, at 14:02:12 on Sun, 15
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of trust is by
no means unreasonable.
I met my late wife when she was 25 and I was 35. I can't see any problem
with that. Her father's reaction was "Thank god for that, I don't have
to be her keeper any more".
And avoiding hugging or kissing seems a very tolerable burden.
Hugging and kissing are quite different activities. I've met numerous
ladies who quite enjoyed a hug, but would not have approved of a kiss.
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population
definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely
to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
In message <5133218178.82a3300b@uninhabited.net>, at 14:02:12 on Sun, 15
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of
trust is by
no means unreasonable.
I met my late wife when she was 25 and I was 35. I can't see any problem with that. Her father's reaction was "Thank god for that, I don't have
to be her keeper any more".
And avoiding hugging or kissing seems a very tolerable burden.
Hugging and kissing are quite different activities. I've met numerous
ladies who quite enjoyed a hug, but would not have approved of a kiss.
On 15 Nov 2026 at 13:53:16 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a >>>> "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise >>>> is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible >>> to me.
criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now. Russell Brand
has rightly been prosecuted and punished under the existing laws.
Walliams, so far, is accused only of using his wealth and fame to charm
young women into bed. The protections are already in place if the
seducer is in a "position of trust".
It is against the law for someone in a position of trust to engage in
sexual activity with a child in their care, even if that child is over
the age of consent. This means that even though the child may be over
the age of consent (16), it is illegal to engage in sexual activity with
any 16 or 17 year old if you hold a position of trust.
Examples include
rCo Teachers
rCo Care workers
rCo Youth justice workers
rCo Social workers
rCo Doctors
Should one add a new example "being on the telly?" Or, would the
lawmakers decide that every adult is in a position of trust regardless
of their actual role?
And presumably the older person can wine and dine the younger person,
can form a friendship, can prepare (groom?) that younger person so long
as no contact of a sexual nature takes place. And any hug or chaste kiss
can be interpreted by a spurned young person as a sexual contact.
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of trust is by no means unreasonable. And avoiding hugging or kissing seems a very tolerable burden.
Hugging and kissing are quite different activities. I've met numerous
ladies who quite enjoyed a hug, but would not have approved of a kiss.
I would not be likely to hug an unrelated 16 year old, but everyone's >different.
I met my late wife when she was 25 and I was 35. I can't see any
problem with that. Her father's reaction was "Thank god for that, I
don't have to be her keeper any more".
Did he back his words with a dowry? :)
I think I should say at this point that I do not regard young people,
under the age of 20, as sexually attractive nor have I formed
friendships with any of them.
I do work at a charity where the age range is vast, probably 16 to 80.
And there seems to be quite a lot of affectionate hugging, usually at
the instigation of young women. They hug men or women of their own age
or older.
And when I am offered a hug I pull away trying not to look embarrassed.
And sometimes older volunteers mentor the younger ones.
If society wants everyone to regard such friendships as rather indecent
and inappropriate, then I wonder whether that is the right direction.
A "chaste kiss" is the way I would describe a peck on the cheek, no >tonsil-tennis.
And I think such actvity ought to be strongly discouraged in an >employer/employee situation.
In message <5870459741.5989fcb2@uninhabited.net>, at 16:05:04 on Sun, 15
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Hugging and kissing are quite different activities. I've met numerous
ladies who quite enjoyed a hug, but would not have approved of a kiss.
I would not be likely to hug an unrelated 16 year old, but everyone's
different.
16yr olds aren't ladies, they are children.
In message <5870459741.5989fcb2@uninhabited.net>, at 16:05:04 on Sun, 15
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Hugging and kissing are quite different activities. I've met numerous
ladies who quite enjoyed a hug, but would not have approved of a kiss.
I would not be likely to hug an unrelated 16 year old, but everyone's
different.
16yr olds aren't ladies, they are children.
In message <nlu65fFj6tuU1@mid.individual.net>, at 16:49:51 on Sun, 15
Nov 2026, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:
I think I should say at this point that I do not regard young people,
under the age of 20, as sexually attractive nor have I formed
friendships with any of them.
Maybe not this decade, but when you were in your 20's?
I do work at a charity where the age range is vast, probably 16 to 80.
And there seems to be quite a lot of affectionate hugging, usually at
the instigation of young women. They hug men or women of their own age
or older.
In many Continental countries it's almost compulsory to air-kiss
colleagues, the only question being "twice or three times".
And when I am offered a hug I pull away trying not to look embarrassed.
And sometimes older volunteers mentor the younger ones.
If society wants everyone to regard such friendships as rather indecent
and inappropriate, then I wonder whether that is the right direction.
A "chaste kiss" is the way I would describe a peck on the cheek, no
tonsil-tennis.
And I think such actvity ought to be strongly discouraged in an
employer/employee situation.
It wasn't as strict in Ye Olden Days. In the 80's it was regarded as
normal for young single girls to seek pleasure (eg gifts and posh
dinners), and even career enhancement, by flirting with their bosses or colleagues.
The youngest I mixed with (a colleague not a direct report), I
specifically waited until they were 18 [thus 16+2], and I was 25.
Nobody thought this the slightest bit unusual, and in that instance the 'affair', if it was even as serious as that, only lasted a couple of
months, at which point she happened to get a job somewhere else, and we
lost touch.
Maybe a year later there was another lass, perhaps 19yrs old, whose
mother chastised her for not fully grabbing the opportunity while it was available. I always made it a point of asking father (or if separated
mother) if they gave permission for me to ask their daughter out.
Sometimes the banter was a bit OTT, and one of my employees (who I never dated, but was reportedly very sexually active) was dismissed by most--
male colleagues on the grounds that "don't even think about it, you'd be
like waving a sausage at the Dartford Tunnel".
50yrs ago. Russell Brand would have been in nappies.
In message <nlu65fFj6tuU1@mid.individual.net>, at 16:49:51 on Sun, 15I had quite a few offers but was too shy to make use of them - and then
Nov 2026, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:
I think I should say at this point that I do not regard young people,
under the age of 20, as sexually attractive nor have I formed
friendships with any of them.
Maybe not this decade, but when you were in your 20's?
On 15 Nov 2026 at 12:44:43 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
quotes...
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age
of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
That seems pretty silly though. It means a relationship between, say,
a 17-year-old and a 23-year-old is legal, but becomes illegal when the
23-year-old turns 24, and then becomes legal again when the 17-year-old
turns 18. I would've thought "if they're between 16 and 21 then the age
gap must be under 5 years", or something like that, would be far more
sensible.
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection
beyond adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable.
And the law would have to apply to boys as well as girls, for a number
of reasons.
Maybe a year later there was another lass, perhaps 19yrs old, whose
mother chastised her for not fully grabbing the opportunity while it was
available. I always made it a point of asking father (or if separated
mother) if they gave permission for me to ask their daughter out.
How progressive, to allow a woman the responsibility that should properly >belong to a man. Did none of them have fathers or brothers to supervise their >daughters?
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a
"staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise
is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible
to me.
Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now.
On 15 Nov 2026 at 12:44:43 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
Staggered consent is already the law in some US states including
Florida, where Brand was living before he was sent to prison. The age
of consent in the state is 18, but lowered to 16 if the partner is not
older than 23.
That seems pretty silly though. It means a relationship between, say,
a 17-year-old and a 23-year-old is legal, but becomes illegal when the
23-year-old turns 24, and then becomes legal again when the 17-year-old
turns 18. I would've thought "if they're between 16 and 21 then the age
gap must be under 5 years", or something like that, would be far more
sensible.
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection beyond >adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable. And the law would have to apply to >boys as well as girls, for a number of reasons.
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population >>definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely
to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
On 15 Nov 2026 at 15:16:09 GMT+0, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population
definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely
to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
I am not sure the criminal justice system (as opposed to perhaps the penal >system) actually uses the term "paedophile". But the criminal justice system >always seems to have been happy to prosecute people showing a sexual interest >in pictures of fifteen year olds (and now 17 year olds) under the same law as >appliess to pictures of infants and babies. Perhaps if the law recognised a >difference then people in general might.
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a >>>> "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise >>>> is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible >>> to me.
Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to
criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now.
But absolutely none of that is true. It isn't "hard cases", it isn't
"bad law", it isn't clumsy, it isn't "usually harmless", the people
aren't "fragile", it isn't "all because of David Walliams", and it
isn't true that it's never been an issue until now.
We're talking laws that already exist in over 20 countries. It's the
sort of thing that has been mooted before, but there hasn't been the political will previously. It seems a pretty reasonable and sensible
change, and provided they don't word it stupidly like the Florida one
you mentioned, I don't so far see any obvious downside.
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection beyond >>adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable. And the law would have to apply to >>boys as well as girls, for a number of reasons.
I think 18 would need to be the cut-off. At the moment, that's the point at >which pretty every definition of "adult" kicks in, I don't think it would be >easy to justify an exeception for sex.
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years >older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 15:16:09 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14 >>Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population >>>definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely >>>to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
The criminal justice system doesn't use the term at all.
It does, though, distinguish between children under 13 and children
from 13 to 16, which broadly approximates to the same principle.
On 15/11/2026 18:31, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a >>>>> "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise >>>>> is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible >>>> to me.
Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to
criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now.
But absolutely none of that is true. It isn't "hard cases", it isn't
"bad law", it isn't clumsy, it isn't "usually harmless", the people
aren't "fragile", it isn't "all because of David Walliams", and it
isn't true that it's never been an issue until now.
What research do you rely on?
Usually, when contemplating a major change in the law one expects to see
a Law Commission investigation, a careful consideration of the pros and >cons.
I hope our law-makers do see the downside before they rush to appease
the tabloid press.
In message <h26kfllg2m155nml9su0bfeu00m543ftfc@4ax.com>, at 20:40:08 on
Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 15:16:09 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14 >>>Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population >>>>definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as >>>>paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely >>>>to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that >>>description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
The criminal justice system doesn't use the term at all.
It may not use the word, but implies the context.
It does, though, distinguish between children under 13 and children
from 13 to 16, which broadly approximates to the same principle.
The problem with laws like that is the photos in question don't include
a thumbnail of the participant's birth certificate.
In message <q95kflhj5ndegr1a4vfsn93u67rod4e5ic@4ax.com>, at 20:30:00 on
Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection beyond >>> adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable. And the law would have to apply to
boys as well as girls, for a number of reasons.
I think 18 would need to be the cut-off. At the moment, that's the point at >> which pretty every definition of "adult" kicks in, I don't think it would be >> easy to justify an exeception for sex.
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years >> older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21)
ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
I'm reminded of when the law was changed early in the noughties, so that "Page 3" photos of uunder-18's were banned. Previously at least one of
their models embarked on that career as soon as she turned 16.
The question, to which I never got a satisfactory answer, was "does that
mean back-numbers of The Sun published for those two years, are now
classed as containing images of child abuse.
On 15 Nov 2026 16:10:51 GMT, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 15 Nov 2026 at 15:16:09 GMT+0, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14 >>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population
definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely >>>> to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
I am not sure the criminal justice system (as opposed to perhaps the penal >> system) actually uses the term "paedophile". But the criminal justice system >> always seems to have been happy to prosecute people showing a sexual interest
in pictures of fifteen year olds (and now 17 year olds) under the same law as
appliess to pictures of infants and babies. Perhaps if the law recognised a >> difference then people in general might.
The law does distinguish between children under 13 and children from 13 to 16. But it's not a distinction which often finds its way into media reporting.
Mark
In message <h26kfllg2m155nml9su0bfeu00m543ftfc@4ax.com>, at 20:40:08 on
Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 15:16:09 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14 >>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population
definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as
paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely >>>> to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that
description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
The criminal justice system doesn't use the term at all.
It may not use the word, but implies the context.
It does, though, distinguish between children under 13 and children
from 13 to 16, which broadly approximates to the same principle.
The problem with laws like that is the photos in question don't include
a thumbnail of the participant's birth certificate.
On 15/11/2026 18:31, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a >>>>> "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise >>>>> is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible >>>> to me.
Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to
criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now.
But absolutely none of that is true. It isn't "hard cases", it isn't
"bad law", it isn't clumsy, it isn't "usually harmless", the people
aren't "fragile", it isn't "all because of David Walliams", and it
isn't true that it's never been an issue until now.
What research do you rely on?
Usually, when contemplating a major change in the law one expects to
see a Law Commission investigation, a careful consideration of the
pros and cons.
And here it is - or may soon be: https://lawcom.gov.uk/project/consent-in-the-criminal-law/
So it is otiose to rush to legislate, based mainly on David Walliams -
or can you cite other relevant cases?
Is there any evidence that the underage victims of gangs in Rochdale and elsewhere would at the age of 18 have miraculously become strong enough, assertive enough, to resist the seduction of the middle aged Pakistani
men? Or would it be merely a token gesture to say that we'll protect the young people till they are 18?
On 15 Nov 2026 at 21:02:45 GMT+0, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <q95kflhj5ndegr1a4vfsn93u67rod4e5ic@4ax.com>, at 20:30:00 on
Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection beyond
adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable. And the law would have
to apply to
boys as well as girls, for a number of reasons.
I think 18 would need to be the cut-off. At the moment, that's the point at >>> which pretty every definition of "adult" kicks in, I don't think it would be
easy to justify an exeception for sex.
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >>> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
I'm reminded of when the law was changed early in the noughties, so that
"Page 3" photos of uunder-18's were banned. Previously at least one of
their models embarked on that career as soon as she turned 16.
The question, to which I never got a satisfactory answer, was "does that
mean back-numbers of The Sun published for those two years, are now
classed as containing images of child abuse.
Or the more relevant question, do they contain indecent pictures of children?
Insofar as there was child abuse in how they were employed it doesn't show up >in the pictures.--
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:05:02 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <h26kfllg2m155nml9su0bfeu00m543ftfc@4ax.com>, at 20:40:08 on >>Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 15:16:09 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>
In message <9241227454.4ace736b@uninhabited.net>, at 21:40:12 on Sat, 14 >>>>Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Despite the psychopathological difference the general population >>>>>definitely regards sexual interest in the under sixteens as >>>>>paedophilia. As you say, any pedantic attempt to correct this is likely >>>>>to be met with deep suspicion.
Until quite recently, the criminal justice system reserved that >>>>description for those interested in pre-pubescent youngsters.
The criminal justice system doesn't use the term at all.
It may not use the word, but implies the context.
It does, though, distinguish between children under 13 and children
from 13 to 16, which broadly approximates to the same principle.
The problem with laws like that is the photos in question don't include
a thumbnail of the participant's birth certificate.
When it comes to photos (or pseudo-photos), the law is duck-typed. An >indecent photo is unlawful if the subject is, or appears to be, below the >relevant age.
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with people in positions of trust does.
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of trust is by no means unreasonable. And avoiding hugging or kissing seems a very tolerable burden.
On 15/11/2026 14:02, Roger Hayter wrote:
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position of
trust is by no means unreasonable. And avoiding hugging or kissing
seems a very tolerable burden.
Rubbish. My late wife was five years older than me. Does that mean I
was "groomed"?
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or
17 can only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more
than five years older than them (or, if a single cut-off is
preferred, no older than 21) ought to be easy enough to legislate
for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on
sex with people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense
of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically.
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years >> older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21)
ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with >> people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense
of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically.
On 15/11/2026 14:02, Roger Hayter wrote:
I think making being five years older equivalent to a position ofRubbish. My late wife was five years older than me. Does that mean I
trust is by no means unreasonable. And avoiding hugging or kissing
seems a very tolerable burden.
was "groomed"?
On 15 Nov 2026 at 21:02:45 GMT+0, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <q95kflhj5ndegr1a4vfsn93u67rod4e5ic@4ax.com>, at 20:30:00 on
Sun, 15 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
While that does makes sense, I don't think extending such protection beyond
adulthood at age 18 might be unacceptable. And the law would have to apply to
boys as well as girls, for a number of reasons.
I think 18 would need to be the cut-off. At the moment, that's the point at >>> which pretty every definition of "adult" kicks in, I don't think it would be
easy to justify an exeception for sex.
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >>> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
I'm reminded of when the law was changed early in the noughties, so that
"Page 3" photos of uunder-18's were banned. Previously at least one of
their models embarked on that career as soon as she turned 16.
The question, to which I never got a satisfactory answer, was "does that
mean back-numbers of The Sun published for those two years, are now
classed as containing images of child abuse.
Or the more relevant question, do they contain indecent pictures of children? Insofar as there was child abuse in how they were employed it doesn't show up in the pictures.
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 18:31, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 12:44, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-15, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
There is now apparently some pressure on the government to introduce a >>>>>> "staggered age of consent" which a few pundits are beginning to realise >>>>>> is an appalling vista.
Why on earth would that be an "appalling vista"? It seems quite sensible >>>>> to me.
Hard cases make bad law. The appalling vista is the clumsy attempt to
criminalise conduct which is usually harmless, just to protect some
fragile 16-18 year olds from some older men. All because of David
Walliams. It has seemingly never been an issue until now.
But absolutely none of that is true. It isn't "hard cases", it isn't
"bad law", it isn't clumsy, it isn't "usually harmless", the people
aren't "fragile", it isn't "all because of David Walliams", and it
isn't true that it's never been an issue until now.
What research do you rely on?
What research did you rely on?
Usually, when contemplating a major change in the law one expects to
see a Law Commission investigation, a careful consideration of the
pros and cons.
And here it is - or may soon be:
https://lawcom.gov.uk/project/consent-in-the-criminal-law/
So it is otiose to rush to legislate, based mainly on David Walliams -
or can you cite other relevant cases?
Yes. I expect pretty much everybody can. I know personally of someone
who was groomed at age 17 by a 35-year-old, and arguably it has had
long-term deleterious effects on their life. If you mean "legal cases"
then the whole point is that it isn't currently illegal, so there can be
no such legal cases.
Is there any evidence that the underage victims of gangs in Rochdale and
elsewhere would at the age of 18 have miraculously become strong enough,
assertive enough, to resist the seduction of the middle aged Pakistani
men? Or would it be merely a token gesture to say that we'll protect the
young people till they are 18?
It would have meant the police couldn't just dismiss it as "no crime",
for a start.
On 16 Nov 2026 at 08:59:15 GMT+0, "Pancho" <Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com> wrote:
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >>> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with
people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense
of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically.
We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether seventeen year old boys need protecting from older women; but I am pretty sure they should be
protected from older men. If, however, we brought in a law that only restricted the behaviour of men then the men's rights activists would howl with rage and this might be socially divisive.
On 16/11/2026 09:49, Roger Hayter wrote:
We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether
seventeen year old boys need protecting from older women; but I am
pretty sure they should be protected from older men. If, however, we
brought in a law that only restricted the behaviour of men then the
men's rights activists would howl with rage and this might be
socially divisive.
And are you pretty sure that young gay men of 17 would never give valid consent to sexual activity with a 30 or 40 year old man who wants to
lavish them with gifts and money, the "sugar daddy" scenario?
On 16/11/2026 09:49, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 08:59:15 GMT+0, "Pancho" <Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can >>>> only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with
people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense
of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically.
We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether seventeen year >> old boys need protecting from older women; but I am pretty sure they should be
protected from older men. If, however, we brought in a law that only
restricted the behaviour of men then the men's rights activists would howl >> with rage and this might be socially divisive.
And are you pretty sure that young gay men of 17 would never give valid consent to sexual activity with a 30 or 40 year old man who wants to
lavish them with gifts and money, the "sugar daddy" scenario?
Is it just that you wouldn't want your own son or nephew doing that?
On 14 Nov 2026 15:04:46 +0000 (GMT), Theo
<theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
Parents buy books, not children. If the author of said books is reputed to >have an... unwholesome interest in children, would parents still want to >buy the books?
If you're a children's bookshop, your customers are parents. If many >parents have decided that seeing these books upsets them, why would you put >them on display?
If you're a library, your customers are parents even if those who see the >displays might be children. If your customers don't want the books to be >on display, why would you not listen to them?
Market forces.
They aren't banned - I'm sure you can still order them if you want them.
He's been dropped by his publisher, so there's only a finite supply of new books left and they're unlikely to be reprinted any time soon.
On 16 Nov 2026 at 10:55:20 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 16/11/2026 09:49, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 08:59:15 GMT+0, "Pancho" <Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com> >>> wrote:
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can
only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>>>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with
people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense >>>> of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically.
We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether seventeen year >>> old boys need protecting from older women; but I am pretty sure they should be
protected from older men. If, however, we brought in a law that only
restricted the behaviour of men then the men's rights activists would howl >>> with rage and this might be socially divisive.
And are you pretty sure that young gay men of 17 would never give valid
consent to sexual activity with a 30 or 40 year old man who wants to
lavish them with gifts and money, the "sugar daddy" scenario?
Is it just that you wouldn't want your own son or nephew doing that?
I don't think 17 year olds "would never" give valid consent, I just think a significant number would be harmed.
Yet the far more pressing danger to children is the fashion for
sexting. Indecent photos are exchanged with people of the same age who
then circulate them among other friends and cause distress and even
suicidal thoughts. Or the person who asks for the indecent photos
turns out to be a scammer who wants more photos, more revealing,
otherwise he promises to circulate the photos to everyone in your
address book and your parents. That is a far more important issue for
young people. And it probably can't be cured by the easy expedient of
"a new law".
On 16/11/2026 13:12, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 10:55:20 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>
On 16/11/2026 09:49, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 08:59:15 GMT+0, "Pancho" <Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com> >>>> wrote:
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether seventeen year
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16 or 17 can
only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older than 21) >>>>>> ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule on sex with
people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense >>>>> of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically. >>>>
old boys need protecting from older women; but I am pretty sure they should be
protected from older men. If, however, we brought in a law that only
restricted the behaviour of men then the men's rights activists would howl >>>> with rage and this might be socially divisive.
And are you pretty sure that young gay men of 17 would never give valid
consent to sexual activity with a 30 or 40 year old man who wants to
lavish them with gifts and money, the "sugar daddy" scenario?
Is it just that you wouldn't want your own son or nephew doing that?
I don't think 17 year olds "would never" give valid consent, I just think a >> significant number would be harmed.
But once they have turned 18 they acquire the necessary hard shell, life skills, ability to defend themselves against predators.
Or maybe the best thing would be to make homosexual relationships
illegal until the participants have turned 21.
Or, and maybe this is the best option, just leave well alone.
On 16/11/2026 13:12, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 10:55:20 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com>
wrote:
On 16/11/2026 09:49, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 16 Nov 2026 at 08:59:15 GMT+0, "Pancho"
<Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com>
wrote:
On 11/15/26 20:30, Mark Goodge wrote:We could argue (and this group sometimes does) about whether
But the principle seems sound to me. A rule that someone aged 16
or 17 can
only legally consent to sexual activity with someone no more than >>>>>> five years
older than them (or, if a single cut-off is preferred, no older
than 21)
ought to be easy enough to legislate for.
Obviously it would apply to both sexes, just as the current rule
on sex with
people in positions of trust does.
When you say "obviously" you appear to be using obviously in the sense >>>>> of something which is far from obvious, and hard to justify logically. >>>>
seventeen year
old boys need protecting from older women; but I am pretty sure they
should be
protected from older men. If, however, we brought in a law that only
restricted the behaviour of men then the men's rights activists
would howl
with rage and this might be socially divisive.
And are you pretty sure that young gay men of 17 would never give valid
consent to sexual activity with a 30 or 40 year old man who wants to
lavish them with gifts and money, the "sugar daddy" scenario?
Is it just that you wouldn't want your own son or nephew doing that?
I don't think 17 year olds "would never" give valid consent, I just
think a
significant number would be harmed.
But once they have turned 18 they acquire the necessary hard shell, life skills, ability to defend themselves against predators.
Or maybe the best thing would be to make homosexual relationships
illegal until the participants have turned 21.
Or, and maybe this is the best option, just leave well alone.
On 15/11/2026 17:54, Roland Perry wrote:
The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:>>
I think I should say at this point that I do not regard young people,
under the age of 20, as sexually attractive nor have I formed
friendships with any of them.
Maybe not this decade, but when you were in your 20's?
I had quite a few offers but was too shy to make use of them - and then
my first girlfriend was 15 years older than I.
So I suppose I could complain that I was a victim of a predatory woman
but it was very much consensual. If anything I broke her heart rather
than the other way round
On 16 Nov 2026 at 14:21:12 GMT+0, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
But once they have turned 18 they acquire the necessary hard shell, life
skills, ability to defend themselves against predators.
Or maybe the best thing would be to make homosexual relationships
illegal until the participants have turned 21.
Or, and maybe this is the best option, just leave well alone.
"Leaving well alone", to the point of laisser-faire was what the PIE proposed.
On 15/11/2026 17:54, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <nlu65fFj6tuU1@mid.individual.net>, at 16:49:51 on Sun, 15I had quite a few offers but was too shy to make use of them - and then
Nov 2026, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:
I think I should say at this point that I do not regard young people,
under the age of 20, as sexually attractive nor have I formed
friendships with any of them.
Maybe not this decade, but when you were in your 20's?
my first girlfriend was 15 years older than I.
So I suppose I could complain that I was a victim of a predatory woman
but it was very much consensual. If anything I broke her heart rather
than the other way round. Perhaps any new legislation ought to involve
full psychological assessments of both people involved in a
relationship. If one person is more vulnerable, a magistrate should
declare the relationship inappropriate and unlawful.
In message <nm05i1FspjcU1@mid.individual.net>, at 10:51:45 on Mon, 16
Nov 2026, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:
Yet the far more pressing danger to children is the fashion for
sexting. Indecent photos are exchanged with people of the same age who
then circulate them among other friends and cause distress and even
suicidal thoughts. Or the person who asks for the indecent photos
turns out to be a scammer who wants more photos, more revealing,
otherwise he promises to circulate the photos to everyone in your
address book and your parents. That is a far more important issue for
young people. And it probably can't be cured by the easy expedient of
"a new law".
There's already a law about this, sometimes known as "revenge porn"
after one of the subsets.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:54:14 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |