• NDAs and minors ?

    From Jethro@jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 12:18:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    It seems there is som chatter in the Walliams furore that a young (i.e.
    under 18) person was made to sign an NDA.

    Just as a general question, how would courts view a document signed by a
    minor who cannot enter into contracts in their own name (except in very limited circumstances) ?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 12:37:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/11/2026 12:18, Jethro wrote:
    It seems there is som chatter in the Walliams furore that a young (i.e.
    under 18) person was made to sign an NDA.

    Just as a general question, how would courts view a document signed by a minor who cannot enter into contracts in their own name (except in very limited circumstances) ?



    I doubt if most NDAs are enforceable. I think if signed by a minor they
    would be worthless.

    There is a Sky interview with Lucy Beaumont who says that a person
    confided in her about Walliams' conduct. That person was not molested by Walliams but was expected to bring girls to Walliams. The girls were
    described as working class and unfamiliar with London and vulnerable.

    Beaumont says she hasn't witnessed anything. She contacted one girl and
    was worried about her. Beaumont says she offered to pay legal fees but "believes" that the girl had signed an NDA.

    I don't think we (or Beaumont) have seen any NDAs. I find it
    inconceivable that when inviting a girl into his dressing room Walliams
    would have presented her with an NDA. An NDA is sometimes used when
    settling a compensation claim. In employment cases it is intended to
    protect both sides of the dispute by keeping the allegations confidential.

    If, to take an example, a victim of Mohamed Al-Fayed had been paid compensation and had signed an NDA in order to secure a larger sum of compensation than she otherwise would have been given, if she had then
    told her story to the Press it is unlikely (but possible) that Al-Fayed
    might have sued her, thereby attracting even more odium.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jethro@jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 13:45:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    doubting something can or has happened is not legal explanation though.

    Are NDAs enforceable ? If not, why spend (a lot of) money to get them
    drafted and signed (and presumably hold back some mullah to set your
    attack briefs on any transgression ?)

    And if they are enforceable, then would a minor be bound by one ?

    And (for an edge case) could the same NDA signed when a person was a
    minor be considered legally valid when they are over 18 ?

    I'm quite comfortable with the idea that consenting adults can freely
    enter in to a contract that limits their right to expression. Company confidential and all that.

    I am less comfortable with the idea that people can be cowed (or feel
    they have been cowed) into silence over matters that could be considered criminal enough to be worthy of official action.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 14:49:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jethro wrote:
    doubting something can or has happened is not legal explanation though.

    Are NDAs enforceable ? If not, why spend (a lot of) money to get them drafted and signed (and presumably hold back some mullah to set your
    attack briefs on any transgression ?)

    They are sometimes enforceable and sometimes not. I hope this answers
    your questions.

    Go on, let us see the full text of the NDA that you have in mind. You
    don't have the text? Then this discussion is largely pointless.



    And if they are enforceable, then would a minor be bound by one ?

    And (for an edge case) could the same NDA signed when a person was a
    minor be considered legally valid when they are over 18 ?

    I'm quite comfortable with the idea that consenting adults can freely
    enter in to a contract that limits their right to expression. Company confidential and all that.

    I am less comfortable with the idea that people can be cowed (or feel
    they have been cowed) into silence over matters that could be considered criminal enough to be worthy of official action.


    You could find a specialist barrister who is fully conversant with the relevant law and dip into your life savings to pay him for his opinion.
    He would then ask whether you want advice about a specific NDA or
    general advice about how to draft an effective NDA.

    Or you could do your own research.

    You might perhaps include this leading case:

    https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2017/1194.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Pancho@Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 14:08:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/11/2026 12:37, The Todal wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 12:18, Jethro wrote:
    It seems there is som chatter in the Walliams furore that a young (i.e.
    under 18) person was made to sign an NDA.

    Just as a general question, how would courts view a document signed by a
    minor who cannot enter into contracts in their own name (except in very
    limited circumstances) ?



    I doubt if most NDAs are enforceable. I think if signed by a minor they would be worthless.

    There is a Sky interview with Lucy Beaumont who says that a person
    confided in her about Walliams' conduct. That person was not molested by Walliams but was expected to bring girls to Walliams. The girls were described as working class and unfamiliar with London and vulnerable.

    Beaumont says she hasn't witnessed anything. She contacted one girl and
    was worried about her. Beaumont says she offered to pay legal fees but "believes" that the girl had signed an NDA.

    I don't think we (or Beaumont) have seen any NDAs. I find it
    inconceivable that when inviting a girl into his dressing room Walliams would have presented her with an NDA. An NDA is sometimes used when
    settling a compensation claim. In employment cases it is intended to
    protect both sides of the dispute by keeping the allegations confidential.

    If, to take an example, a victim of Mohamed Al-Fayed had been paid compensation and had signed an NDA in order to secure a larger sum of compensation than she otherwise would have been given, if she had then
    told her story to the Press it is unlikely (but possible) that Al-Fayed might have sued her, thereby attracting even more odium.


    On technical point. Why aren't NDAs designed around a sequence of future structured payments. Each payment conditional upon no disclosure in the preceding period. As the contract is based upon ongoing mutual interest,
    as opposed to legal promises there is no need for legal enforcement,
    suing etc.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nicholas Collin Paul de =?UTF-8?Q?Glouce=C5=BFter?=@thanks-to@Taf.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 18:00:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    This is not really the same thing and it is from circa 40 years ago so
    things could be different . . . a boy wrote a successful computer game
    (namely "Manic Miner"). He made a contract with a publisher to sell
    it. He went to a different publisher and he simultaneously sold it
    through this different publisher. This 1st publisher wanted to sue to
    enforce a right to being the exclusive seller, but it never so sues
    because it got legal advice that it stands no chance against a minor
    in an open court.
    (S. HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/ fuer Kontaktdaten!)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jethro@jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 18:17:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 18:00:01 +0000, Nicholas Collin Paul de Glouce++ter
    wrote:

    This is not really the same thing and it is from circa 40 years ago so
    things could be different . . . a boy wrote a successful computer game (namely "Manic Miner"). He made a contract with a publisher to sell it.
    He went to a different publisher and he simultaneously sold it through
    this different publisher. This 1st publisher wanted to sue to enforce a
    right to being the exclusive seller, but it never so sues because it got legal advice that it stands no chance against a minor in an open court.
    (S. HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/ fuer Kontaktdaten!)

    Is it a case of the court would throw the claim out unheard ? Or would
    the claim be heard and then struck out ?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 19:13:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-12, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 18:00:01 +0000, Nicholas Collin Paul de Glouce++ter wrote:
    This is not really the same thing and it is from circa 40 years ago so
    things could be different . . . a boy wrote a successful computer game
    (namely "Manic Miner"). He made a contract with a publisher to sell it.
    He went to a different publisher and he simultaneously sold it through
    this different publisher. This 1st publisher wanted to sue to enforce a
    right to being the exclusive seller, but it never so sues because it got
    legal advice that it stands no chance against a minor in an open court.
    (S. HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/ fuer Kontaktdaten!)

    Is it a case of the court would throw the claim out unheard ? Or would
    the claim be heard and then struck out ?

    I imagine if you tried to sue a minor under contract, they would file
    an application to have the claim struck out due to the contract being unenforceable and the claim would be struck out at a preliminary
    hearing; or they would put their being a minor as part of their defence
    and judgment would be awarded against you at the main hearing.

    How much of their costs you would have to pay would depend on which
    route they took and whether it was a small claims track case. (If it
    was small claims you would want it to go to trial, which would be
    after allocation to the small claims track and hence costs would be
    limited; if it wasn't small then you would want it to be struck out
    at the earliest possible stage, when fewer costs would have accrued.)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jethro@jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 18:19:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 12:18:42 +0000, Jethro wrote:

    It seems there is som chatter in the Walliams furore that a young (i.e.
    under 18) person was made to sign an NDA.

    Just as a general question, how would courts view a document signed by a minor who cannot enter into contracts in their own name (except in very limited circumstances) ?

    Following on from this, by what law (if any ?) is a minor a minor and an
    adult an adult ?

    Given we have Gillick competence, and (I believe) minors are allowed to somehow enter into contracts for basic amenties ????

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 21:59:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-12, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 12:18:42 +0000, Jethro wrote:

    It seems there is som chatter in the Walliams furore that a young (i.e.
    under 18) person was made to sign an NDA.

    Just as a general question, how would courts view a document signed by a
    minor who cannot enter into contracts in their own name (except in very
    limited circumstances) ?

    Following on from this, by what law (if any ?) is a minor a minor and an adult an adult ?

    It depends on why you're asking (different age limits apply for
    different rules), but the most general provision is the Family Law
    Reform Act 1969 s1, which sets the age at 18 (reduced from 21) for
    laws made after that Act came into force, unless those laws specify
    a different age.

    Given we have Gillick competence, and (I believe) minors are allowed to somehow enter into contracts for basic amenties ????

    For "necessaries" at a reasonable price, yes, and certain other things
    such as employment, but with safeguards.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Martin Brown@'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 13 09:20:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/11/2026 14:49, The Todal wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jethro wrote:
    doubting something can or has happened is not legal explanation though.

    Are NDAs enforceable-a ? If not, why spend (a lot of) money to get them
    drafted and signed (and presumably hold back some mullah to set your
    attack briefs on any transgression ?)

    They are sometimes enforceable and sometimes not. I hope this answers
    your questions.

    But that is the problem with them. They are used as a weapon by powerful corporations and hyper rich people as lawfare to ensure the silence of
    people who know something that would be seriously embarrassing if it
    were made public. One side has essentially infinite capacity for legal
    fees and the very best advice so it is *not* a level playing field.

    Go on, let us see the full text of the NDA that you have in mind.-a You don't have the text? Then this discussion is largely pointless.

    In the instance that I have in mind even mentioning that it exists would potentially be a breach of the terms. Showing the wording to anyone
    other than my lawyer would certainly be a breach.

    I have signed plenty of normal NDA's for access to company secret data
    from clients in my time - promising not to disclose their trade secrets,
    pre publication patent disclosure or other restricted IP. They are a legitimate example of the good use of them.

    And if they are enforceable, then would a minor be bound by one ?

    And (for an edge case) could the same NDA signed when a person was a
    minor be considered legally valid when they are over 18 ?

    I'm quite comfortable with the idea that consenting adults can freely
    enter in to a contract that limits their right to expression. Company
    confidential and all that.

    I am less comfortable with the idea that people can be cowed (or feel
    they have been cowed) into silence over matters that could be considered
    criminal enough to be worthy of official action.


    You could find a specialist barrister who is fully conversant with the relevant law and dip into your life savings to pay him for his opinion.
    He would then ask whether you want advice about a specific NDA or
    general advice about how to draft an effective NDA.

    The legal advice I got was that for the four figure sum involved it was
    only worth going so far with it and in the end I signed an overly
    restricted NDA. I'm prepared to disclose this much since the company is
    no longer in business (and that doesn't narrow the field down much).

    If I had my time again I would go for maximum adverse publicity from the outset - I think that would have been a *lot* more effective at
    resolving the situation and would certainly have been quicker.

    Or you could do your own research.

    You might perhaps include this leading case:

    https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2017/1194.html


    Please can you summarise the crux of that judgement in layman's terms?
    I can read the words but I know from experience of legal documents that
    I do not know what some of the jargon used actually means. Notably:

    Tomlin Order

    If I have read it right that judgement seems to make my point that the
    hyper rich can bully ordinary reporters into not reporting criminal
    activities of the hyper rich. OK the leak was of a confidential document (Lagarde List) but once it is out in the open I reckon it is fair game
    to use that information for investigative journalism.

    https://www.lse.ac.uk/research/research-for-the-world/economics/sophisticated-tax-evasion-by-the-super-rich

    The phrase: Walks like a duck, quacks like a duck springs to mind.
    --
    Martin Brown


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nicholas Collin Paul de =?UTF-8?Q?Glouce=C5=BFter?=@thanks-to@Taf.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 13 11:43:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    I do not know. I read about it in a computers-games magazine. Legal technicalities are not what I read it for.
    (S. HTTP://Gloucester.Insomnia247.NL/ fuer Kontaktdaten!)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Handsome Jack@jack@handsome.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 13 17:49:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 13:45:14 -0000 (UTC), Jethro wrote:

    doubting something can or has happened is not legal explanation though.

    Are NDAs enforceable ? If not, why spend (a lot of) money to get them drafted and signed (and presumably hold back some mullah to set your
    attack briefs on any transgression ?)

    And if they are enforceable, then would a minor be bound by one ?

    And (for an edge case) could the same NDA signed when a person was a
    minor be considered legally valid when they are over 18 ?

    I'm quite comfortable with the idea that consenting adults can freely
    enter in to a contract that limits their right to expression. Company confidential and all that.

    I am less comfortable with the idea that people can be cowed (or feel
    they have been cowed) into silence over matters that could be considered criminal enough to be worthy of official action.

    An NDA is an *agreement*. If it is not voluntarily and competently agreed
    by both parties, it does not exist, or at least is not legally
    enforceable.

    It is possible to visualise situations in which a powerful person tries to impose an NDA on a weaker one by threats, but that's not the typical
    scenario. It is much more usual for money to change hands.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jethro@jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 13 18:53:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Fri, 13 Nov 2026 17:49:02 +0000, Handsome Jack wrote:

    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 13:45:14 -0000 (UTC), Jethro wrote:

    doubting something can or has happened is not legal explanation though.

    Are NDAs enforceable ? If not, why spend (a lot of) money to get them
    drafted and signed (and presumably hold back some mullah to set your
    attack briefs on any transgression ?)

    And if they are enforceable, then would a minor be bound by one ?

    And (for an edge case) could the same NDA signed when a person was a
    minor be considered legally valid when they are over 18 ?

    I'm quite comfortable with the idea that consenting adults can freely
    enter in to a contract that limits their right to expression. Company
    confidential and all that.

    I am less comfortable with the idea that people can be cowed (or feel
    they have been cowed) into silence over matters that could be
    considered criminal enough to be worthy of official action.

    An NDA is an *agreement*. If it is not voluntarily and competently
    agreed by both parties, it does not exist, or at least is not legally enforceable.

    It is possible to visualise situations in which a powerful person tries
    to impose an NDA on a weaker one by threats, but that's not the typical scenario. It is much more usual for money to change hands.

    Of course agreements can be deemed unfair and unenforceable by the
    courts ?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2