• Brand in Wandsworth Prison

    From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sun Nov 8 15:34:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member
    of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Sun Nov 8 19:37:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-08, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member
    of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    I would be quite surprised if he is not highly popular in prison.
    Obviously his first few days he would probably be "uncomfortable";
    I imagine anyone would be.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John@megane.06@gmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 12:25:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 08/11/2026 15:34, The Todal wrote:
    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member
    of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    It could also have been an inmate, or shock horror, the Mail simply
    making it up. There's enough external evidence to know the workings of
    prison life in general.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From jon@reading.mostly@crap.org to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 14:42:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member
    of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-
    fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 15:11:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:
    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of
    Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member
    of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-
    fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.


    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have
    quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    quotes from the Times

    Rape was 'momentary' failure, Brand's lawyer says

    Ian Winter KC, for the defence, has asked the judge to consider that the
    rape of a 21-year-old woman was a rCLshortrCY and rCLmomentaryrCY failure to respect her consent.

    He told the judge: rCLWe invite [you] to conclude that this was a fully consensual vaginal intercourse that [the victim] went to the defendantrCOs house to experience.

    rCLTherefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.rCY

    Winter said these areas were that consent was limited to vaginal sex and
    that it required the use of a condom.

    He invited the judge to sentence on that rCLlesser basisrCY.
    Ian Winter KC urged the judge to find that Brand did not humiliate or
    degrade the rape victim by forcing her to shower and brush her teeth
    before sex.

    He argued that Brand had made the requests for a good reason, as he is a recovering alcoholic.

    rCLWhilst plainly unattractive behaviour on the part of Mr Brand, it is
    not entirely surprising that an ex-alcoholic might prefer not to smell
    alcohol on an intimate partnerrCOs breath in circumstances where sexual activity was very much expected and intended to follow.rCY

    He urged the judge to find that Brand had been rCLinconsideraterCY by
    leaving quickly afterwards, to attend a stand-up show he was due to
    perform, rather than construing this as an aggravating factor intended
    to degrade the victim.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Peter Johnson@peter@parksidewood.nospam to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 16:24:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 15:11:05 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com>
    wrote:

    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:
    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of >>> Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member >>> of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-
    fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.


    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have
    quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    quotes from the Times

    Rape was 'momentary' failure, Brand's lawyer says

    Ian Winter KC, for the defence, has asked the judge to consider that the >rape of a 21-year-old woman was a oshorto and omomentaryo failure to
    respect her consent.

    He told the judge: oWe invite [you] to conclude that this was a fully >consensual vaginal intercourse that [the victim] went to the defendantAs >house to experience.

    oTherefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a >short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.o

    Winter said these areas were that consent was limited to vaginal sex and >that it required the use of a condom.

    He invited the judge to sentence on that olesser basiso.
    Ian Winter KC urged the judge to find that Brand did not humiliate or >degrade the rape victim by forcing her to shower and brush her teeth
    before sex.

    He argued that Brand had made the requests for a good reason, as he is a >recovering alcoholic.

    oWhilst plainly unattractive behaviour on the part of Mr Brand, it is
    not entirely surprising that an ex-alcoholic might prefer not to smell >alcohol on an intimate partnerAs breath in circumstances where sexual >activity was very much expected and intended to follow.o

    He urged the judge to find that Brand had been oinconsiderateo by
    leaving quickly afterwards, to attend a stand-up show he was due to
    perform, rather than construing this as an aggravating factor intended
    to degrade the victim.

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who
    normally does property work. Also, the journalists realised what the
    outcome was likely to be when they were given the list of 20+
    witnesses who were to give evidence corroborating the rape victim.
    The hearing also took much less time than expected because
    Brand/Winter didn't have much evidence to offer in defence.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 16:27:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-09, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:
    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:
    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of >>> Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member >>> of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-
    fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.

    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have
    quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    He doesn't seem to quite have the skill-set for mitigation full stop.

    quotes from the Times

    Rape was 'momentary' failure, Brand's lawyer says

    Ian Winter KC, for the defence, has asked the judge to consider that the rape of a 21-year-old woman was a rCLshortrCY and rCLmomentaryrCY failure to respect her consent.

    It seems a bit unwise to call the wrongdoing "short" and "momentary"
    when the defendant has been convicted of multiple offences on different occasions.

    He told the judge: rCLWe invite [you] to conclude that this was a fully consensual vaginal intercourse that [the victim] went to the defendantrCOs house to experience.

    I was going to criticise this phrasing, but then I thought actually
    I could well imagine Russell Brand pulling by saying "Would you like
    come back to my house to experience consensual vaginal intercourse?"

    rCLTherefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.rCY

    Winter said these areas were that consent was limited to vaginal sex and that it required the use of a condom.

    Those are two PRETTY FUCKING SIGNIFICANT AREAS.

    This guy sucks.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 21:26:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 15:11:05 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:
    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of >>> Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on
    how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility
    of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member >>> of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering-
    fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.


    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have
    quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    One of the comments he reportedly made when presenting the defence case made
    me wonder if he really had any idea how it would come across. According to
    The Guardian, he said:

    "The question for you is, can you possibly be sure in this case that out
    the many, many women who voluntarily had sex with Mr Brand between 1999
    and 2009, he raped just three of them?"

    To which the obvious answer is that he probably raped far more of them, it's just that only three of them came forward to report it afterwards.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 21:45:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-09, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 15:11:05 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:
    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:34:30 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    As you would probably expect, the Daily Mail is making more money out of >>>> Russell Brand, the gift that keeps on giving, by gleefully reporting on >>>> how uncomfortable he is in prison awaiting sentence and the possibility >>>> of him being attacked by other prisoners.

    I assume this was leaked to them by a member of the prison staff,
    possibly someone quite senior. Someone who knew what the Assistant
    Governor said to Mr Brand.

    I think there ought to be efforts to identify and discipline that member >>>> of staff. I don't suppose anyone cares, though.

    And I reckon that actually he might have the skill and money to charm
    other convicts and bring them under his spell. We will see.

    https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16274951/Russell-Brand-cowering- >>> fear-cell-prisoners-chant.html

    Ten years and six months.


    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have >>quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    One of the comments he reportedly made when presenting the defence
    case made me wonder if he really had any idea how it would come
    across. According to The Guardian, he said:

    "The question for you is, can you possibly be sure in this case that
    out the many, many women who voluntarily had sex with Mr Brand
    between 1999 and 2009, he raped just three of them?"

    To which the obvious answer is that he probably raped far more of
    them, it's just that only three of them came forward to report it
    afterwards.

    That's one obvious answer; the other obvious answer, which perhaps the
    judge should have interrupted to provide, was that the jury don't have
    to be "sure" he only raped three women out of thousands, they just have
    to be sure he raped each of these three specific women. I would have
    hoped a bloody pet groomer could understand that, let alone a KC.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 21:36:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who >normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His
    CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Tue Nov 10 03:33:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    In message <6ue4fl92sotpadrtppf017r3kq5s6sge76@4ax.com>, at 21:36:52 on
    Mon, 9 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
    remarked:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who >>normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His >CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile >sexual offences case.

    It's bit of a niche, so perhaps the accused has to make do with
    someone well known in a more mainstream role. And hope the skills
    are transferable.

    Mark
    --
    Roland Perry

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Tue Nov 10 09:22:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 10/11/2026 03:33, Roland Perry wrote:
    In message <6ue4fl92sotpadrtppf017r3kq5s6sge76@4ax.com>, at 21:36:52 on
    Mon, 9 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> remarked:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who
    normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial
    crime. His
    CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no
    reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    It's bit of a niche, so perhaps the accused has to make do with
    someone well known in a more mainstream role. And hope the skills
    are transferable.

    It may be a bit of a niche but there are lots of barristers with
    expertise in this area because it's the bread and butter of criminal
    practice at the bar. It isn't particularly well paid, so if as a client
    your priority is to spend as much as possible on your lawyers you'd
    probably shun the barristers who drive a Skoda and choose one who has a Porsche.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Tue Nov 10 21:30:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 09:22:53 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    On 10/11/2026 03:33, Roland Perry wrote:
    In message <6ue4fl92sotpadrtppf017r3kq5s6sge76@4ax.com>, at 21:36:52 on
    Mon, 9 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> remarked: >>> On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who >>>> normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial
    crime. His
    CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no
    reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest >>> that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    It's bit of a niche, so perhaps the accused has to make do with
    someone well known in a more mainstream role. And hope the skills
    are transferable.

    It may be a bit of a niche but there are lots of barristers with
    expertise in this area because it's the bread and butter of criminal >practice at the bar. It isn't particularly well paid, so if as a client
    your priority is to spend as much as possible on your lawyers you'd
    probably shun the barristers who drive a Skoda and choose one who has a >Porsche.

    Even if the ones who drive a Skoda have more experience in this particular
    type of case.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Handsome Jack@jack@handsome.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 14:22:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 16:27:45 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens wrote:

    On 2026-11-09, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote

    Ian Winter KC, for the defence, has asked the judge to consider that
    the rape of a 21-year-old woman was a rCLshortrCY and rCLmomentaryrCY failure
    to respect her consent.

    It seems a bit unwise to call the wrongdoing "short" and "momentary"
    when the defendant has been convicted of multiple offences on different occasions.

    Winter was commenting solely on the rape charge, not the other offences,
    and Brand was convicted of *one* count of rape on *one* occasion AIUI.


    He told the judge: rCLWe invite [you] to conclude that this was a fully
    consensual vaginal intercourse that [the victim] went to the
    defendantrCOs house to experience.

    I was going to criticise this phrasing, but then I thought actually I
    could well imagine Russell Brand pulling by saying "Would you like come
    back to my house to experience consensual vaginal intercourse?"

    rCLTherefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a
    short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.rCY

    Winter said these areas were that consent was limited to vaginal sex
    and that it required the use of a condom.

    Those are two PRETTY FUCKING SIGNIFICANT AREAS.


    There must be millions of men alive today who had sex with a girl who did
    not explicitly insist on the use of a condom.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Handsome Jack@jack@handsome.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 14:32:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson wrote:


    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who normally
    does property work. Also, the journalists realised what the outcome was likely to be when they were given the list of 20+ witnesses who were to
    give evidence corroborating the rape victim. The hearing also took much
    less time than expected because Brand/Winter didn't have much evidence
    to offer in defence.


    It's hard to know what you could say in such a position. Some variation of "Actually yes she did consent", which wouldn't take long.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 14:59:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/11/2026 14:32, Handsome Jack wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson wrote:


    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review yesterday,
    expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who normally
    does property work. Also, the journalists realised what the outcome was
    likely to be when they were given the list of 20+ witnesses who were to
    give evidence corroborating the rape victim. The hearing also took much
    less time than expected because Brand/Winter didn't have much evidence
    to offer in defence.


    It's hard to know what you could say in such a position. Some variation of "Actually yes she did consent", which wouldn't take long.


    It isn't quite as simple as that.

    It would be a valid defence to say that Brand had a genuine and
    reasonable belief that the woman was consenting - regardless of whether
    she actually did consent.

    The jury would consider all the circumstances and assess whether he had
    a reasonable belief in consent when he flipped her over and inserted his
    penis into her rectum. Perhaps she did not protest. Or else, perhaps he
    was deaf.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 16:38:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-11, Handsome Jack <jack@handsome.com> wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 16:27:45 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens wrote:
    On 2026-11-09, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote
    Ian Winter KC, for the defence, has asked the judge to consider that
    the rape of a 21-year-old woman was a rCLshortrCY and rCLmomentaryrCY failure
    to respect her consent.

    It seems a bit unwise to call the wrongdoing "short" and "momentary"
    when the defendant has been convicted of multiple offences on different
    occasions.

    Winter was commenting solely on the rape charge, not the other offences,
    and Brand was convicted of *one* count of rape on *one* occasion AIUI.

    Yes. Why do you think I said "multiple offences" and not "multiple rapes"?
    The judge was aware of all the convictions, because they were all in one
    trial. They all involved failure to respect consent. Hence my comment
    that the claim that Brand mostly respected consent and had just had one
    brief little lapse must have rung pretty hollow.

    He told the judge: rCLWe invite [you] to conclude that this was a fully
    consensual vaginal intercourse that [the victim] went to the
    defendantrCOs house to experience.

    I was going to criticise this phrasing, but then I thought actually I
    could well imagine Russell Brand pulling by saying "Would you like come
    back to my house to experience consensual vaginal intercourse?"

    rCLTherefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a >>> short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.rCY

    Winter said these areas were that consent was limited to vaginal sex
    and that it required the use of a condom.

    Those are two PRETTY FUCKING SIGNIFICANT AREAS.

    There must be millions of men alive today who had sex with a girl who
    did not explicitly insist on the use of a condom.

    The implication of Winter's mitigation is that she *did* insist on the
    use of a condom, and he went ahead without one regardless. Sure, there
    are a very great many men who have done the same. Perhaps they should
    all be in prison.

    (Also you forgot about the "anal rape" bit. There are probably not quite
    so many men who have done that.)

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 22:16:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 21:45:47 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-09, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 15:11:05 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>
    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:

    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have >>>quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    One of the comments he reportedly made when presenting the defence
    case made me wonder if he really had any idea how it would come
    across. According to The Guardian, he said:

    "The question for you is, can you possibly be sure in this case that
    out the many, many women who voluntarily had sex with Mr Brand
    between 1999 and 2009, he raped just three of them?"

    To which the obvious answer is that he probably raped far more of
    them, it's just that only three of them came forward to report it
    afterwards.

    That's one obvious answer; the other obvious answer, which perhaps the
    judge should have interrupted to provide, was that the jury don't have
    to be "sure" he only raped three women out of thousands, they just have
    to be sure he raped each of these three specific women. I would have
    hoped a bloody pet groomer could understand that, let alone a KC.

    Looking back over some of those comments, I think he was treating it in the same way that he would a fraud trial. Because in that context, the tone of
    his comments would actually make sense. Consider something like this:

    My client has been involved in multiple high value contracts over very
    many years. In all that time, only three of those very many contracts have
    raised allegations of financial wrongdoing. I put it to you that this is
    not evidence of carefully planned fraud, but, rather, three, and only
    three, occasions where my client's normally fastidious record-keeping has
    fallen short of the extremely high standards to which he aspires and
    normally achieves.

    That would work as both an argument in defence (the "cock-up ather than conspiracy" argument), or, if convicted, an argument in mitigation ("just
    three errors in an otherwise unblemished career"). But if you apply exactly
    the same style of argument to rape it's completely different:

    My client has had sex with very many women over very many years. In all
    that time, only three of those very many encounters have raised
    allegations of rape. I put it to you that this is not evidence of
    carefully planned sexual abuse, but, rather, three, and only three,
    occasions where my client's normally fastidious approach to gaining
    consent has fallen short of the extremely high standards to which he
    aspires and normally achieves.

    In this context, that argument doesn't work in either defence or mitigation.
    It is true that financial law often makes allowances for errors,
    particularly if they are rare, and does not unduly penalise people for the occasional alip-up. But the only acceptable number of rapes is zero. Arguing that "it's just the one" is neither defence nor mitigation. Most rapes are "just the one".

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Wed Nov 11 23:37:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-11, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 21:45:47 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
    <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-09, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 15:11:05 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>
    On 09/11/2026 14:42, jon wrote:

    The defence barrister did his best, but some would say he didn't have >>>>quite the skill-set for sexual offences.

    One of the comments he reportedly made when presenting the defence
    case made me wonder if he really had any idea how it would come
    across. According to The Guardian, he said:

    "The question for you is, can you possibly be sure in this case that
    out the many, many women who voluntarily had sex with Mr Brand
    between 1999 and 2009, he raped just three of them?"

    To which the obvious answer is that he probably raped far more of
    them, it's just that only three of them came forward to report it
    afterwards.

    That's one obvious answer; the other obvious answer, which perhaps the >>judge should have interrupted to provide, was that the jury don't have
    to be "sure" he only raped three women out of thousands, they just have
    to be sure he raped each of these three specific women. I would have
    hoped a bloody pet groomer could understand that, let alone a KC.

    Looking back over some of those comments, I think he was treating it in the same way that he would a fraud trial. Because in that context, the tone of his comments would actually make sense. Consider something like this:

    My client has been involved in multiple high value contracts over very
    many years. In all that time, only three of those very many contracts have
    raised allegations of financial wrongdoing. I put it to you that this is
    not evidence of carefully planned fraud, but, rather, three, and only
    three, occasions where my client's normally fastidious record-keeping has
    fallen short of the extremely high standards to which he aspires and
    normally achieves.

    That would work as both an argument in defence (the "cock-up ather than conspiracy" argument), or, if convicted, an argument in mitigation ("just three errors in an otherwise unblemished career"). But if you apply exactly the same style of argument to rape it's completely different:

    My client has had sex with very many women over very many years. In all
    that time, only three of those very many encounters have raised
    allegations of rape. I put it to you that this is not evidence of
    carefully planned sexual abuse, but, rather, three, and only three,
    occasions where my client's normally fastidious approach to gaining
    consent has fallen short of the extremely high standards to which he
    aspires and normally achieves.

    In this context, that argument doesn't work in either defence or mitigation. It is true that financial law often makes allowances for errors,
    particularly if they are rare, and does not unduly penalise people for the occasional alip-up. But the only acceptable number of rapes is zero. Arguing that "it's just the one" is neither defence nor mitigation. Most rapes are "just the one".

    I mean you make an excellent point, but it still boils down to
    "this KC is a complete idiot" which seems a bit hard to credit
    in the case of KCs who got their qualifications other than by
    being appointed to be Attorney General.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Owen Rees@orees@hotmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 02:10:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who
    normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile sexual offences case.

    The Secret Barrister has a new blog post about the case and the behaviour
    of BrandrCOs barrister.

    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist knowledge makes it even more interesting.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 10:39:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 02:10:53 -0000 (UTC), Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com>
    wrote:

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who
    normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His >> CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason >> to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    The Secret Barrister has a new blog post about the case and the behaviour
    of BrandAs barrister.

    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBAs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual >offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist >knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    That is, indeed, a very good post.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 11:11:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 23:37:56 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-11, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:

    In this context, that argument doesn't work in either defence or mitigation. >> It is true that financial law often makes allowances for errors,
    particularly if they are rare, and does not unduly penalise people for the >> occasional alip-up. But the only acceptable number of rapes is zero. Arguing >> that "it's just the one" is neither defence nor mitigation. Most rapes are >> "just the one".

    I mean you make an excellent point, but it still boils down to
    "this KC is a complete idiot" which seems a bit hard to credit
    in the case of KCs who got their qualifications other than by
    being appointed to be Attorney General.

    I don't think he's an idiot. I think that this is an excellent example of
    the fact that, even within a profession, expertise is not fungible. You can
    be good at something - even very, very good at something - and still not be good at something different, even if the different thing is still fairly closely related to what you are good at.

    Law is no different to music, or art, or programming. A brilliant guitarist
    may be useless on the piano. A great painter may be unable to produce a
    decent sculpture. Someone who can code perfectly in C++ may struggle with Python. And a lawyer sho specialises in fraud may not have the skills
    required for rape and sexual offences.

    That doesn't mean they couldn't learn those skills if they wanted to and
    were prepared to put the time and effort in. In many cases, having an
    adjacent skillset is a useful starting point - it is easier to learn a new musical instrument once you've already mastered one, for example, and the
    basic principles of coding apply to almost all languages. But the additional skill still needs to be learned. It doesn't come automatically just because you're already good at something similar.

    Hiring Ian Winter KC to defend a rape and sexual assault case seems to me to
    be like hiring Eric Clapton to play piano at your wedding reception, or
    hiring Damien Hirst to design a logo for your window cleaning business. the fact that they are very good what what they normally do does not mean that
    they are a good choice for what you want them to do.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 11:15:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who
    normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His >> CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason >> to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    The Secret Barrister has a new blog post about the case and the behaviour
    of BrandrCOs barrister.

    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the judge meant the victim
    was not in the cagegory of exceptionally vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding. --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 11:30:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12/11/2026 11:11, Mark Goodge wrote:
    On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 23:37:56 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-11, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:

    In this context, that argument doesn't work in either defence or mitigation.
    It is true that financial law often makes allowances for errors,
    particularly if they are rare, and does not unduly penalise people for the >>> occasional alip-up. But the only acceptable number of rapes is zero. Arguing
    that "it's just the one" is neither defence nor mitigation. Most rapes are >>> "just the one".

    I mean you make an excellent point, but it still boils down to
    "this KC is a complete idiot" which seems a bit hard to credit
    in the case of KCs who got their qualifications other than by
    being appointed to be Attorney General.

    I don't think he's an idiot. I think that this is an excellent example of
    the fact that, even within a profession, expertise is not fungible. You can be good at something - even very, very good at something - and still not be good at something different, even if the different thing is still fairly closely related to what you are good at.

    Law is no different to music, or art, or programming. A brilliant guitarist may be useless on the piano. A great painter may be unable to produce a decent sculpture. Someone who can code perfectly in C++ may struggle with Python. And a lawyer sho specialises in fraud may not have the skills required for rape and sexual offences.

    That doesn't mean they couldn't learn those skills if they wanted to and
    were prepared to put the time and effort in. In many cases, having an adjacent skillset is a useful starting point - it is easier to learn a new musical instrument once you've already mastered one, for example, and the basic principles of coding apply to almost all languages. But the additional skill still needs to be learned. It doesn't come automatically just because you're already good at something similar.

    Hiring Ian Winter KC to defend a rape and sexual assault case seems to me to be like hiring Eric Clapton to play piano at your wedding reception, or hiring Damien Hirst to design a logo for your window cleaning business. the fact that they are very good what what they normally do does not mean that they are a good choice for what you want them to do.

    Mark


    Valid points. As I said on 9th November, "The defence barrister did his
    best, but some would say he didn't have quite the skill-set for sexual offences".

    It is reported that Russell Brand is angry about the performance of his barrister, and feels aggrieved about the way he was represented.

    I suppose this must reflect on his solicitor who would have chosen the barrister and whose expertise Brand had to rely on.

    As I said, if your priority is to spend as much money as possible on
    your legal representation, you choose the barrister who drives a Porsche
    and shun the one who drives a Skoda. Perhaps members of the public
    believe that a rich barrister must be very good at his job to be so
    rich. And that a rich barrister who specialises in crime must be good at
    all criminal work including assaults, rapes, burglaries. That has never
    been how it works. It's all about choosing the genre of work that you
    enjoy and that pays well, and sometimes you can only get into that line
    of work through knowing the right people and going to the right public
    school.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jeff Layman@Jeff@invalid.invalid to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 11:45:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12/11/2026 11:15, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who >>>> normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial crime. His >>> CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no reason >>> to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to suggest >>> that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile
    sexual offences case.

    The Secret Barrister has a new blog post about the case and the behaviour
    of BrandrCOs barrister.

    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >> specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist
    knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the judge meant the victim was not in the cagegory of exceptionally vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    Meiosis or litotes, perhaps.
    (many more example at <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_device>)
    --
    Jeff

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 12:17:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:45:36 +0000, Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid>
    wrote:

    On 12/11/2026 11:15, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist
    knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly vulnerable" in >> the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the judge meant the victim >> was not in the cagegory of exceptionally vulnerable people. But colloquially >> "not particularly" is used (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean
    "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press
    apparently made much of this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    Meiosis or litotes, perhaps.
    (many more example at <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_device>)

    It's very common in British colloquial English to use a construction in the form of "not [superlative] [thing]" to mean the opposite of [thing]. For example:

    not very clever -> stupid
    not very long -> short
    not massively important -> unimportant
    not particularly big -> small
    not very tasty -> unpleasant taste

    But, as the Secret Barrister points out, this can cause confusion when a technical term follows that construction and is intended to be interpreted literally rather than colloquially. So "not particularly vulnerable" means
    "not more vulnerable than normal", but is likely to be perceived as "not at
    all vulnerable".

    I think their point that official documentation, such as sentencing
    guidelines, should try to avoid phrasing that has different literal and colloquial meanings is well made. I agree that "not additionally vulnerable" would be a more unambiguous phrasing here.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 12:22:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:30:57 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    It is reported that Russell Brand is angry about the performance of his >barrister, and feels aggrieved about the way he was represented.

    I'm not sure he'd have got a better result with a more skilled barrister, to
    be honest.

    I suppose this must reflect on his solicitor who would have chosen the >barrister and whose expertise Brand had to rely on.

    As I said, if your priority is to spend as much money as possible on
    your legal representation, you choose the barrister who drives a Porsche
    and shun the one who drives a Skoda. Perhaps members of the public
    believe that a rich barrister must be very good at his job to be so
    rich. And that a rich barrister who specialises in crime must be good at
    all criminal work including assaults, rapes, burglaries. That has never >been how it works. It's all about choosing the genre of work that you
    enjoy and that pays well, and sometimes you can only get into that line
    of work through knowing the right people and going to the right public >school.

    I'm aware that the cab rank rule doesn't generally allow barristers to pick
    and choose their clients and cases. But would it have been open to Mr Winter
    to say something like "Given the circumstances of this case, I really think
    you should be looking elsewhere for your representation"?

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 12:42:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >> specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist
    knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly
    vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the
    judge meant the victim was not in the cagegory of exceptionally
    vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used
    (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of
    this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    It's an interesting unintended consequence - the Sentencing Council's guidelines use the phrase "particularly vulnerable", which is pretty straightforward to understand. But they (and Winter) didn't think about
    what that phrase means when you put "not" in front of it, because,
    as you say, it doesn't mean that the person is not in the set of
    particularly vulnerable people, it means they are particularly
    not-vulnerable!

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jeff Layman@Jeff@invalid.invalid to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 13:49:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12/11/2026 12:17, Mark Goodge wrote:
    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:45:36 +0000, Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid>
    wrote:

    On 12/11/2026 11:15, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote: >>>
    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist >>>> knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly vulnerable" in
    the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the judge meant the victim >>> was not in the cagegory of exceptionally vulnerable people. But colloquially
    "not particularly" is used (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean
    "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press >>> apparently made much of this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    Meiosis or litotes, perhaps.
    (many more example at <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_device>)

    It's very common in British colloquial English to use a construction in the form of "not [superlative] [thing]" to mean the opposite of [thing]. For example:

    not very clever -> stupid
    not very long -> short
    not massively important -> unimportant
    not particularly big -> small
    not very tasty -> unpleasant taste

    But, as the Secret Barrister points out, this can cause confusion when a technical term follows that construction and is intended to be interpreted literally rather than colloquially. So "not particularly vulnerable" means "not more vulnerable than normal", but is likely to be perceived as "not at all vulnerable".

    I think their point that official documentation, such as sentencing guidelines, should try to avoid phrasing that has different literal and colloquial meanings is well made. I agree that "not additionally vulnerable" would be a more unambiguous phrasing here.

    It's an improvement, but not that much better for /public/
    understanding. I would have thought that "unusually" would have been a
    better choice. Both "particularly" and "additionally" suggest some sort
    of comparative, but to what? "Unusually", however, suggests a difference
    which could also include something unexpected to that normally found.
    --
    Jeff

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 14:19:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12 Nov 2026 at 12:42:27 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >>> specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist
    knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly
    vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the
    judge meant the victim was not in the cagegory of exceptionally
    vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used
    (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not
    particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of
    this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    It's an interesting unintended consequence - the Sentencing Council's guidelines use the phrase "particularly vulnerable", which is pretty straightforward to understand. But they (and Winter) didn't think about
    what that phrase means when you put "not" in front of it, because,
    as you say, it doesn't mean that the person is not in the set of
    particularly vulnerable people, it means they are particularly not-vulnerable!

    I think it was the judge in his sentencing remarks, not Winter alone, who used the phrase.
    --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 16:44:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 12:42:27 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote: >>>> https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >>>> specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist >>>> knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly
    vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the
    judge meant the victim was not in the cagegory of exceptionally
    vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used
    (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not
    particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of
    this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    It's an interesting unintended consequence - the Sentencing Council's
    guidelines use the phrase "particularly vulnerable", which is pretty
    straightforward to understand. But they (and Winter) didn't think about
    what that phrase means when you put "not" in front of it, because,
    as you say, it doesn't mean that the person is not in the set of
    particularly vulnerable people, it means they are particularly
    not-vulnerable!

    I think it was the judge in his sentencing remarks, not Winter alone,
    who used the phrase.

    No, it was only Winter. The judge carefully avoided the trap of
    prefixing the phrase with "not" (perhaps due to greater experience)
    and said she was "no more or less vulnerable than any adult woman
    making those choices".

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 20:44:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12 Nov 2026 at 16:44:19 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:

    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 12:42:27 GMT+0, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >> wrote:
    On 2026-11-12, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote: >>>>> https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who
    specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual >>>>> offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist >>>>> knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly
    vulnerable" in the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the
    judge meant the victim was not in the cagegory of exceptionally
    vulnerable people. But colloquially "not particularly" is used
    (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean "especially not", like "not
    particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press apparently made much of
    this deliberate (or perhaps stupid) misunderstanding.

    It's an interesting unintended consequence - the Sentencing Council's
    guidelines use the phrase "particularly vulnerable", which is pretty
    straightforward to understand. But they (and Winter) didn't think about
    what that phrase means when you put "not" in front of it, because,
    as you say, it doesn't mean that the person is not in the set of
    particularly vulnerable people, it means they are particularly
    not-vulnerable!

    I think it was the judge in his sentencing remarks, not Winter alone,
    who used the phrase.

    No, it was only Winter. The judge carefully avoided the trap of
    prefixing the phrase with "not" (perhaps due to greater experience)
    and said she was "no more or less vulnerable than any adult woman
    making those choices".

    Sorry, a false recollection obviously!
    --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 23:14:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12/11/2026 12:22, Mark Goodge wrote:
    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:30:57 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    It is reported that Russell Brand is angry about the performance of his
    barrister, and feels aggrieved about the way he was represented.

    I'm not sure he'd have got a better result with a more skilled barrister, to be honest.

    Quote from the sentencing remarks:

    "...but all those women had to face being confronted and being told they
    had lied, or twisted the truth and, or, they had agreed to your sexual demands: that was all done because of you, on your instructions".

    Brand's barrister chose an aggressive and unpleasant form of
    cross-examination and Russell Brand is deemed to have instructed him to
    do it. A better option - at least, to make Brand seem more compassionate
    and remorseful - would have been to concede that he behaved badly and to simply concentrate on the only argument that could have stood a chance
    of success, to say that he believed at the time that the women were
    consenting and that in retrospect he can see that he was wrong, but he
    did believe it at the time.



    I suppose this must reflect on his solicitor who would have chosen the
    barrister and whose expertise Brand had to rely on.

    As I said, if your priority is to spend as much money as possible on
    your legal representation, you choose the barrister who drives a Porsche
    and shun the one who drives a Skoda. Perhaps members of the public
    believe that a rich barrister must be very good at his job to be so
    rich. And that a rich barrister who specialises in crime must be good at
    all criminal work including assaults, rapes, burglaries. That has never
    been how it works. It's all about choosing the genre of work that you
    enjoy and that pays well, and sometimes you can only get into that line
    of work through knowing the right people and going to the right public
    school.

    I'm aware that the cab rank rule doesn't generally allow barristers to pick and choose their clients and cases. But would it have been open to Mr Winter to say something like "Given the circumstances of this case, I really think you should be looking elsewhere for your representation"?

    Of course. The normal way would be for the barrister's clerk to ring the solicitor and to tell him which barristers are most expert in this line
    of work. However, it may be that the lure of hefty fees overcame those scruples.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Owen Rees@orees@hotmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 22:02:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:30:57 +0000, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    It is reported that Russell Brand is angry about the performance of his
    barrister, and feels aggrieved about the way he was represented.

    I'm not sure he'd have got a better result with a more skilled barrister, to be honest.

    I suppose this must reflect on his solicitor who would have chosen the
    barrister and whose expertise Brand had to rely on.

    As I said, if your priority is to spend as much money as possible on
    your legal representation, you choose the barrister who drives a Porsche
    and shun the one who drives a Skoda. Perhaps members of the public
    believe that a rich barrister must be very good at his job to be so
    rich. And that a rich barrister who specialises in crime must be good at
    all criminal work including assaults, rapes, burglaries. That has never
    been how it works. It's all about choosing the genre of work that you
    enjoy and that pays well, and sometimes you can only get into that line
    of work through knowing the right people and going to the right public
    school.

    I'm aware that the cab rank rule doesn't generally allow barristers to pick and choose their clients and cases. But would it have been open to Mr Winter to say something like "Given the circumstances of this case, I really think you should be looking elsewhere for your representation"?

    As I understand it, the cab rank rule applies only to cases where the
    barrister has the relevant qualification, skill or experience. Declining a
    case due to lack of the specific expertise needed is not just allowed but
    is expected in order to uphold professional standards. Perhaps those with
    more direct knowledge can say whether or not my understanding is correct.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From JNugent@jnugent73@mail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 13 09:46:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 12/11/2026 05:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
    On 12/11/2026 11:15, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 12 Nov 2026 at 02:10:53 GMT+0, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:

    Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
    On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:24:24 +0000, Peter Johnson
    <peter@parksidewood.nospam> wrote:

    Interesting article on the case in the Observer's New Review
    yesterday, expressing surprise at the choice of Brand's barrister, who >>>>> normally does property work.

    According to his chambers, he specialises in fraud and financial
    crime. His
    CV lists several high profile fraud and corruption cases. I have no
    reason
    to doubt his ability in that field. But there's nothing there to
    suggest
    that he would be the most suitable choice to instruct in a high profile >>>> sexual offences case.

    The Secret Barrister has a new blog post about the case and the
    behaviour
    of BrandrCOs barrister.

    https://thesecretbarrister.com/2026/11/11/how-can-russell-brands-
    barrister-suggest-that-a-victim-of-sexual-assault-is-not-
    particularly-vulnerable/

    In that blog post SBrCOs self description is: a lowly junior barrister who >>> specialises in the prosecution and defence of rape and serious sexual
    offending (RASSO).

    SB writes well and is always worth reading. In this case the specialist
    knowledge makes it even more interesting.

    He makes a very good point about the phrase "not particularly
    vulnerable" in
    the judge's sentencing remarks; it is clear that the judge meant the
    victim
    was not in the cagegory of exceptionally vulnerable people. But
    colloquially
    "not particularly" is used (forgotten the figure of speech!) to mean
    "especially not", like "not particulary clever" to mean stupid. The press
    apparently made much of this deliberate (or perhaps stupid)
    misunderstanding.

    Meiosis or litotes, perhaps.
    (many more example at <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_device>)

    Very informative! Thank you.

    I was particularly intrigued with "Gish Gallop" (coined 1994). I
    remember that at about that time, I would frequently encounter opponents
    who used that device.>
    --
    This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.
    www.avg.com

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2