• Freezing Winter

    From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 09:34:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's enthusiasm
    for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn into a verbal
    attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-victim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: rCLI hope you are pleased with yourself.rCY Urwin responded: rCLIrCOm pleased justice has been done,rCY before Winter replied: rCLWell, it wasnrCOt. You fucked it.rCY

    rCLCongratulations,rCY he added.

    unquote

    For more about Ian Winter KC, look at his profile on the website of his chambers.

    I don't think I have ever seen such a flurry of compliments about any barrister, underneath his photograph. A constant slideshow of
    sycophancy. Star of the criminal bar, great leader in this field,
    phenomenal attention to detail, a privilege to watch him, calm
    sophistication, intellectual stamina, brilliant in court.

    https://www.clothfairchambers.com/barrister-profile/ian-winter-kc/

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Handsome Jack@jack@handsome.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 10:01:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 09:34:26 +0000, The Todal wrote:

    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's enthusiasm
    for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn into a verbal
    attack on a journalist.


    Why not?

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-
    victim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: rCLI hope you are pleased with yourself.rCY Urwin responded: rCLIrCOm pleased justice has been done,rCY before Winter replied: rCLWell, it wasnrCOt. You fucked it.rCY

    rCLCongratulations,rCY he added.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 10:00:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    In message <nl5l93Fj7bdU1@mid.individual.net>, at 09:34:26 on Fri, 6 Nov
    2026, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> remarked:
    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's enthusiasm
    for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn into a verbal >attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-vict >im-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday Times >journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    I wonder if that was the journalist who was on TV this morning, telling
    how disappointed she was that being told her role to encourage
    whistle-blowers was unjust.
    --
    Roland Perry

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 10:15:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-06, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's enthusiasm
    for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn into a verbal attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-victim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: rCLI hope you are pleased with yourself.rCY Urwin responded: rCLIrCOm pleased justice has been done,rCY before Winter replied: rCLWell, it wasnrCOt. You fucked it.rCY

    rCLCongratulations,rCY he added.

    unquote

    For more about Ian Winter KC, look at his profile on the website of his chambers.

    I don't think I have ever seen such a flurry of compliments about any barrister, underneath his photograph. A constant slideshow of
    sycophancy. Star of the criminal bar, great leader in this field,
    phenomenal attention to detail, a privilege to watch him, calm sophistication, intellectual stamina, brilliant in court.

    https://www.clothfairchambers.com/barrister-profile/ian-winter-kc/

    Not sure why his chambers has to be in a meat market if he's so great.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 10:18:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:34:26 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's enthusiasm
    for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn into a verbal
    attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-victim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: rCLI hope you are pleased with yourself.rCY Urwin responded: rCLIrCOm pleased justice has been done,rCY before Winter replied: rCLWell, it wasnrCOt. You fucked it.rCY

    rCLCongratulations,rCY he added.


    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination
    of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence; but if
    Brand really believes he was so irresistible that women enjoyed being raped by him I suppose that may explain some of his crimes.






    unquote

    For more about Ian Winter KC, look at his profile on the website of his chambers.

    I don't think I have ever seen such a flurry of compliments about any barrister, underneath his photograph. A constant slideshow of
    sycophancy. Star of the criminal bar, great leader in this field,
    phenomenal attention to detail, a privilege to watch him, calm sophistication, intellectual stamina, brilliant in court.

    https://www.clothfairchambers.com/barrister-profile/ian-winter-kc/
    --
    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Spike@aero.spike@mail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 11:45:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
    On 2026-11-06, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    [rCa]

    For more about Ian Winter KC, look at his profile on the website of his
    chambers.

    I don't think I have ever seen such a flurry of compliments about any
    barrister, underneath his photograph. A constant slideshow of
    sycophancy. Star of the criminal bar, great leader in this field,
    phenomenal attention to detail, a privilege to watch him, calm
    sophistication, intellectual stamina, brilliant in court.

    https://www.clothfairchambers.com/barrister-profile/ian-winter-kc/

    Not sure why his chambers has to be in a meat market if he's so great.

    It might be a form of comment on the legal industry.
    --
    Spike

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Pamela@uklm@permabulator.33mail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 12:44:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 09:34 6 Nov 2026, The Todal said:

    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's
    enthusiasm for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn
    into a verbal attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-vi ctim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday
    Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: "I hope you are pleased with
    yourself." Urwin responded: "IAm pleased justice has been
    done," before Winter replied: "Well, it wasnAt. You fucked
    it."

    "Congratulations," he added.

    unquote

    Surely it's not considered a serious attack on a journalist to respond:
    "Well, it wasnAt. You fucked it" ?




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 14:56:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one
    person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of
    consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond
    reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of
    proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought
    that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie
    that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit
    like Sharia then but in reverse?


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Pamela@uklm@permabulator.33mail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 12:58:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 10:18 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter said:
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:34:26 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com>
    wrote:


    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's
    enthusiasm for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn
    into a verbal attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-
    lies-and-victim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday
    Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: "I hope you are pleased with
    yourself." Urwin responded: "IAm pleased justice has been done,"
    before Winter replied: "Well, it wasnAt. You fucked it."

    "Congratulations," he added.


    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they
    didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they
    must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no
    longer considered a valid defence; but if Brand really believes he
    was so irresistible that women enjoyed being raped by him I suppose
    that may explain some of his crimes.

    Russell Brand is almost certainly guilty at some time in his past of
    forced sex amounting to rape but the trial did not seem to present
    wholly convincing evidence to support the specific allegations. I
    suppose it will be useful to read more detailed accounts of the trial
    when they get published.

    As I currently understand it, despite the Met's 400 interviews the one
    upheld accusation of rape relied on people being present at certain
    times in certain locations and in particular on hearsay and unproven statements. It hardly makes for a reliable outcome.

    As mentioned, I am sure Brand is guilty of rape at times in the past
    but the Met's actions look as if they were taking unusually great pains
    and were out to get him. Ditto Channel 4.

    Such police time might have been better spent on further investigating Pakistani grooming and rape gangs, especially as their underage victims
    allege far greater abuse than do Brand's accusers.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 15:19:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-06, Pamela <uklm@permabulator.33mail.com> wrote:
    On 09:34 6 Nov 2026, The Todal said:
    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's
    enthusiasm for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn
    into a verbal attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-vi
    ctim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday
    Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: "I hope you are pleased with
    yourself." Urwin responded: "I-Am pleased justice has been
    done," before Winter replied: "Well, it wasn-At. You fucked
    it."

    "Congratulations," he added.

    unquote

    Surely it's not considered a serious attack on a journalist to respond: "Well, it wasn-At. You fucked it" ?

    It's not very appropriate from a barrister at their place of work.
    Nobody's saying it's any sort of crime or unlawful behaviour.

    But also: usually, it is wrong to identify a barrister with their
    client. They are doing a necessary job, and just because they might
    defend a rapist, a murderer, a terrorist, that does not mean they
    support those crimes. But here, the barrister has voluntarily chosen
    to publicly align himself with his convicted-rapist client. It is
    most peculiar and unwise.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 17:04:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination >> of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard >> enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the >> assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one
    person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of
    consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond
    reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of
    proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought
    that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie
    that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit
    like Sharia then but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she agreed is appropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate her refusal is appropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal rape because she didn't fight back or get injured is outrageous.





    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html
    --
    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From PJK@pjkvck@outlook.com to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 18:20:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 06/11/2026 17:04, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination
    of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard >>> enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the
    assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one
    person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of
    consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond
    reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of
    proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought
    that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie
    that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit
    like Sharia then but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she agreed is appropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate her refusal is appropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal rape because she didn't fight
    back or get injured is outrageous.





    ----Android NewsGroup Reader----
    https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html



    He's reported himself:

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/06/russell-brand-barrister-ian-winter-reports-himself-bar-watchdog-confronting-sunday-times-journalist


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 18:48:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she
    agreed isappropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate
    her refusal isappropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal
    rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is
    outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate'
    please?
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 19:49:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-06, Norman Wells <norman@myard.uk> wrote:
    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk>
    wrote:> Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they
    didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they
    must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no
    longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's
    word against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is
    it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what
    is true, ie the normal criminal standard of proof rather than just
    on the balance of probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental
    principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie
    that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit
    like Sharia then but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she
    agreed isappropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate
    her refusal isappropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal
    rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is
    outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate'
    please?

    What was your "legal point you actually raised"?

    "What evidence was there?" None of us were in court, we don't know.

    The jury were there, they heard all the evidence and argument from the prosecution and the defence, they were instructed as to the standard of
    proof, and they were sure that he committed one of the rapes and not
    sure that he committed two others. Despite not being there, I'm pretty
    sure that the prosecution didn't say anything resembling "you must
    believe anything any woman says". What actually is your point?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Fri Nov 6 19:38:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 6 Nov 2026 at 18:48:34 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger
    Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't >>>> fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been >>>> acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a >>>> valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word >>> against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can >>> make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the >>> normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of
    probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie that a >>> woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then >>> but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she
    agreed isappropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate
    her refusal isappropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal
    rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is
    outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate'
    please?

    (Note you were actually changing the subject from what I said, but anyway.) A large proportion of criminal cases are decided entirely on the word of one police officer against the defendant. The magistrate decides who to believe. And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity
    of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.
    --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 07:39:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Saying she must have agreed to anal> rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate' please?

    What was your "legal point you actually raised"?"What evidence was there?" None of us were in court, we don't know.

    And yet you appeared fully qualified to comment and condem.
    Strange that.

    The jury were there, they heard all the evidence and argument from the prosecution and the defence, they were instructed as to the standard of proof, and they were sure that he committed one of the rapes and not sure that he committed two others. Despite not being there, I'm pretty sure that the prosecution didn't say anything resembling "you mustbelieve anything any woman says". What actually is your point?

    'Pretty sure' of anything in a criminal case isn't good enough. We
    have long-established rules. For good reason.
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 07:46:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 18:48:34 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r>> On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger>> Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:> >>>> .>

    (Note you were actually changing the subject from what I said, but anyway.) A large proportion of criminal cases are decided entirely on the word of one police officer against the defendant. The magistrate decides who to believe.

    Cite please.

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensityof sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing ofseveral victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectivelycorroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.-- Roger Hayter

    Oh, I see. He's a thief (or whatever), therefore he did it.
    Fine, if that's how you think it should work.
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 07:44:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    In message <nl82tjFrqhU1@mid.individual.net>, at 07:39:29 on Sat, 7 Nov
    2026, Norman Wells <norman@myard.uk> remarked:
    The jury were there, they heard all the evidence and argument from the prosecution and the defence, they were instructed as to the standard
    of proof, and they were sure that he committed one of the rapes and not sure that he committed two others. Despite not being there, I'm pretty
    sure that the prosecution didn't say anything resembling "you mustbelieve anything any woman says". What actually is your point?

    'Pretty sure' of anything in a criminal case isn't good enough. We
    have long-established rules. For good reason.

    The jury has to be better than "Pretty sure", but there's no rule for
    mere bystanders.
    --
    Roland Perry

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RJH@patchmoney@gmx.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 07:55:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 6 Nov 2026 at 19:38:09 GMT, Roger Hayter wrote:

    On 6 Nov 2026 at 18:48:34 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger
    Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't >>>>> fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been >>>>> acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a >>>>> valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word >>>> against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can >>>> make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the >>>> normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of
    probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law. >>
    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie that a >>>> woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then >>>> but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she
    agreed isappropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate
    her refusal isappropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal
    rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is
    outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate'
    please?

    (Note you were actually changing the subject from what I said, but anyway.) A large proportion of criminal cases are decided entirely on the word of one police officer against the defendant.

    I'm surprised if that's the case. And in any event, in my limited expereince
    of seeing a few cases in local courts, police officers aren't the sharpest tools in the box, and what they say can be despatched into the 'reasonable doubt' (or complete nonsense) bin quite quickly. Amazed me that the
    prosecution hadn't briefed them before the cases, but there it is/was.

    The magistrate decides who to believe.
    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on
    patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.
    --
    Cheers, Rob
    Sheffield, UK

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 08:20:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    In message <11cmlgt$388ll$1@dont-email.me>, at 07:55:09 on Sat, 7 Nov
    2026, RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> remarked:

    in my limited expereince of seeing a few cases in local courts, police >officers aren't the sharpest tools in the box, and what they say can be >despatched into the 'reasonable doubt' (or complete nonsense) bin quite >quickly.

    Like all professionals (including lawyers), there's a spectrum of
    competence. I've met some incredibly thick barristers, and some very
    clever Detective Chief Superintendents.
    --
    Roland Perry

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 08:56:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court. It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Pancho@Pancho.Jones@protonmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 11:46:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 11/6/26 19:38, Roger Hayter wrote:
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 18:48:34 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:56:56 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:> Roger
    Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't >>>>> fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been >>>>> acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a >>>>> valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word >>>> against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can >>>> make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the >>>> normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of
    probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law. >>
    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie that a >>>> woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then >>>> but in reverse?

    Strongly suggesting she is lying is appropriate. Suggesting she
    agreed isappropriate. Suggesting that she failed to communicate
    her refusal isappropriate. Saying she must have agreed to anal
    rape because she didn't fightback or get injured is
    outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate'
    please?

    (Note you were actually changing the subject from what I said, but anyway.) A large proportion of criminal cases are decided entirely on the word of one police officer against the defendant. The magistrate decides who to believe. And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.


    In statistics, probability, there is always the question of statistical independence. Simply put, statistical independence affects how much
    multiple claims corroborate each other. AIUI, the problem with Brand and
    other celebrity cases is that the accusations are not independent, but
    are presented as if they were. In effect when a media story provides an opportunity to accuse someone, me too, or even to confess to something,
    some misguided people make false claims. Attention seekers, gold
    diggers, etc. This has always been well known, but isn't quantified, or appropriately considered in cases like Brand's.

    There is also the problem with historical trials, where social norms
    have changed. There are various ways for the legal system, and moral
    codes, to handle private sexual encounters. Encounters where it is
    impossible for external people to understand exactly what went on. In
    the past there was an understanding that if a woman consented to sex,
    she couldn't then claim she had been raped when a man took the
    initiative to perform a sex act she didn't like, but didn't strongly
    object to. So it seems reasonable to say that although Brand may be
    guilty of rape by today's standards, he probably wasn't by the standards
    of 20 years ago.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Pamela@uklm@permabulator.33mail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 12:39:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 15:19 6 Nov 2026, Jon Ribbens said:
    On 2026-11-06, Pamela <uklm@permabulator.33mail.com> wrote:
    On 09:34 6 Nov 2026, The Todal said:

    I hope a complaint is made to the Bar Council. A barrister's
    enthusiasm for his case and loyalty to his client should never turn
    into a verbal attack on a journalist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/05/flashbulbs-lies-and-
    vi ctim-blaming-how-russell-brands-trial-unfolded

    At the end of the trial, Winter [Ian Winter KC, Russell Brand's
    barrister] launched into an extraordinary tirade against a Sunday
    Times journalist, Rosamund Urwin, who worked on an investigation of
    allegations against Brand.

    Outside the courtroom, he said: "I hope you are pleased with
    yourself." Urwin responded: "I-Am pleased justice has been
    done," before Winter replied: "Well, it wasn-At. You fucked
    it."

    "Congratulations," he added.

    unquote

    Surely it's not considered a serious attack on a journalist to
    respond: "Well, it wasn-At. You fucked it" ?

    It's not very appropriate from a barrister at their place of work.
    Nobody's saying it's any sort of crime or unlawful behaviour.

    But also: usually, it is wrong to identify a barrister with their
    client. They are doing a necessary job, and just because they might
    defend a rapist, a murderer, a terrorist, that does not mean they
    support those crimes. But here, the barrister has voluntarily chosen
    to publicly align himself with his convicted-rapist client. It is
    most peculiar and unwise.

    I see he has now reported himself to the Bar Council, although I suspect that's largely a ruse to obtain leniency.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 13:20:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 06/11/2026 14:56, Norman Wells wrote:
    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one
    person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of
    consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond
    reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of
    proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought
    that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie
    that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit
    like Sharia then but in reverse?

    The jury heard all the evidence and made their decision. When you ask
    "what evidence was there, then?" you expect those of us who weren't in
    court to guide you towards whichever news reports summarise (usually inadequately) what was said in evidence. Don't be lazy. Do the spadework yourself.

    Don't you trust juries? In Anglo-Saxon times, you proved your innocence
    by finding as many friends as possible to speak up for you even if they weren't there at the time of the offence. Perhaps you think that is a
    better method than the one we have. Count up the number of witnesses for
    and against.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 13:22:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 07/11/2026 08:56, Norman Wells wrote:
    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court. It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?

    If the accused claims that he has no past criminal record and says that
    to the jury, it is permitted to introduce his past criminal record into evidence.

    Do you agree with s103 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 or not?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jon Ribbens@jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 14:16:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 2026-11-07, Norman Wells <norman@myard.uk> wrote:
    Saying she must have agreed to anal> rape because she didn't
    fightback or get injured is outrageous.

    Now would you like to address the legal points I actually raised
    rather than just what you regard as 'inappropriate' please?

    What was your "legal point you actually raised"?"What evidence was
    there?" None of us were in court, we don't know.

    And yet you appeared fully qualified to comment and condem.
    Strange that.

    What's strange is I don't remember doing that. Perhaps you could help
    by pointing out where I have made any comment on the trial or its
    outcome, let alone "condem" it.

    The jury were there, they heard all the evidence and argument from
    the prosecution and the defence, they were instructed as to the
    standard of proof, and they were sure that he committed one of the
    rapes and not sure that he committed two others. Despite not being
    there, I'm pretty sure that the prosecution didn't say anything
    resembling "you mustbelieve anything any woman says". What actually
    is your point?

    'Pretty sure' of anything in a criminal case isn't good enough. We
    have long-established rules. For good reason.

    So you didn't have a point. What a surprise.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 13:41:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:22:30 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    On 07/11/2026 08:56, Norman Wells wrote:
    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the
    propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the >>>> hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can >>>> effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on
    patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court. It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?

    If the accused claims that he has no past criminal record and says that
    to the jury, it is permitted to introduce his past criminal record into evidence.

    Do you agree with s103 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 or not?

    Doesn't that apply to any claims of "good character", not only specific claims of not having a criminal record?
    --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 14:50:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> Wrote in message:r
    On 06/11/2026 14:56, Norman Wells wrote:> Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie> that a woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then but in reverse?

    The jury heard all the evidence and made their decision. When you ask "what evidence was there, then?" you expect those of us who weren't in court to guide you towards whichever news reports summarise (usually inadequately) what was said in evidence. Don't be lazy. Do the spadework yourself.

    The question is what evidence could there be about something that
    happened or didn't happen in private behind closed doors? One
    person says there was consent, the other says there wasn't. How
    can anyone say with the certainty justifiably required in a
    criminal case that one of the parties was wrong or right beyond
    reasonable doubt?

    You may have your own view based on whatever prejudices you have,
    but you can't say it's based on actual evidence because there
    can't be any.

    Juries can be swayed, just as this group seems to be, by taking a
    dislike to someone, and then denying them a fair hearing. I
    think everyone is entitled to a fair trial based on the actual
    evidence. Don't you?


    Don't you trust juries?
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 15:09:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com

    Do you agree with s103 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 or not?

    Propensity to commit similar crimes depends on many things,
    Inc,using at least having a previous conviction for the same or
    similar offences.

    Generally, you'll find previous criminal records cannot be brought
    up in court except for sentencing purposes for the simple reason
    that the offence will not then be tried strictly according to the
    evidence but on prejudice. He's a thief therefore he
    dunnit.

    Some lawyers disagree with this sort of approach.
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roger Hayter@roger@hayter.org to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 15:54:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 7 Nov 2026 at 14:50:41 GMT, "Norman Wells" <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> Wrote in message:r
    On 06/11/2026 14:56, Norman Wells wrote:> Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org>
    Wrote in message:

    According to the BBC reports one of Winter's main lines of cross
    examination of the victims was the suggestion that because they didn't >>>> fight back hard enough or try hard enough to run away they must have been >>>> acquiescing in the assaults. I thought this was no longer considered a >>>> valid defence;

    What evidence was there then? If it comes down to just one person's word >>> against another's, as it does on the issue of consent, what is it that can >>> make anyone sure or certain beyond reasonable doubt what is true, ie the >>> normal criminal standard of proof rather than just on the balance of
    probabilities? I thought that was a fundamental principle of English law.

    Or are you suggesting that the woman should always be believed, ie> that a >>> woman's evidence is always worth more than a man's, a bit like Sharia then >>> but in reverse?

    The jury heard all the evidence and made their decision. When you ask "what >> evidence was there, then?" you expect those of us who weren't in court to
    guide you towards whichever news reports summarise (usually inadequately)
    what was said in evidence. Don't be lazy. Do the spadework yourself.

    The question is what evidence could there be about something that
    happened or didn't happen in private behind closed doors? One
    person says there was consent, the other says there wasn't. How
    can anyone say with the certainty justifiably required in a
    criminal case that one of the parties was wrong or right beyond
    reasonable doubt?

    You may have your own view based on whatever prejudices you have,
    but you can't say it's based on actual evidence because there
    can't be any.

    Juries can be swayed, just as this group seems to be, by taking a
    dislike to someone, and then denying them a fair hearing. I
    think everyone is entitled to a fair trial based on the actual
    evidence. Don't you?


    Testimony, by both complainant and defendant, *is* evidence.
    --

    Roger Hayter

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Norman Wells@norman@myard.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 17:41:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    Testimony, by both complainant and defendant, *is* evidence.

    Do you believe in only being found guilty beyond reasonable doubt,
    or is just a feeling enough?
    --


    ----Android NewsGroup Reader---- https://piaohong.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/usenet/index.html

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RJH@patchmoney@gmx.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 16:57:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 7 Nov 2026 at 08:56:07 GMT, Norman Wells wrote:

    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity
    of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of >>> several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively >>> corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on
    patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court. It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?

    Um. No. If there was a corroborated feature of the assault - a quite unique characteristic - and it was recalled by other victims, even for assaults many years apart, I would have thought such a finding would count when trying to establish the guilt of the defendant.

    --
    Cheers, Rob
    Sheffield, UK

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Todal@the_todal@icloud.com to uk.legal.moderated on Sat Nov 7 19:47:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On 07/11/2026 17:41, Norman Wells wrote:
    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> Wrote in message:r
    Testimony, by both complainant and defendant, *is* evidence.

    Do you believe in only being found guilty beyond reasonable doubt,
    or is just a feeling enough?



    Russell Brand was doing a lot of feeling up. Often without any semblance
    of consent. And sometimes witnessed by other people who were embarrassed
    and didn't know what to say or do, because he was Talent.

    Just a feeling can get you put in prison.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Owen Rees@orees@hotmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Mon Nov 9 11:08:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
    On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:22:30 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:

    On 07/11/2026 08:56, Norman Wells wrote:
    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the
    propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the >>>>> hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can >>>>> effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on >>>> patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court. It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?

    If the accused claims that he has no past criminal record and says that
    to the jury, it is permitted to introduce his past criminal record into
    evidence.

    Do you agree with s103 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 or not?

    Doesn't that apply to any claims of "good character", not only specific claims
    of not having a criminal record?

    Judge tells the jury that the delay in the arrival of the chief prosecution witness is not to be held against him as it is not in his control. He
    arrives later handcuffed to an escort who, it is revealed in later
    testimony, has brought him from a different court where he is on trial for violent assault.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Martin Harran@martinharran@gmail.com to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 12 11:50:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 08:56:07 +0000 (GMT), Norman Wells
    <norman@myard.uk> wrote:

    RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> Wrote in message:r

    And one of the best legal reforms in recent years, in view of the propensity of sexual offenders to do so more than once, was allowing the hearing of several victim's cases together so that their testimonies can effectively corroborate each other. The Brand case was an example.

    Yes, that was my understanding of how it works. Triangulation based on patterns established by independent victims and witnesses.

    Past activities have no bearing on current allegations. That's
    why it is not permitted to introduce the accused's past criminal
    record in court.

    Yes they can be brought up if there is a high degree of similarity
    between the previous crime and the one currently being tried. The
    first such case in the UK under Criminal Justice Act 2003 was under
    The Criminal Justice (Evidence) (Northern Ireland) Order 2004 which
    was the NI implementation of the Act and was the trial of the young
    man who abducted and murdered my sister-in-law, Attracta Harron. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/northern_ireland/4901098.stm

    The prosecution barrister explained to us that the new legislation
    allowed them to introduce a previous conviction where the similarity
    between the two crimes demonstrated a high probability that the same
    person committed both. Key aspects were that the first case involved
    Hamilton giving a lift to an older woman, a stranger, taking her back
    to the caravan at his home where the rape took place and his car
    having the handle and window winder removed from the passenger door.
    Those three elements were common to the Attracta case.

    This was argued out in the absence of the jury at the very start of
    the trial and the judge said he would reserve his decision which he
    finally made in the closing days of the trial, allowing the previous
    conviction to be presented to the jury. Hamilton had other previous
    convictions - he had been found guilty of exposing himself and
    masturbating before women drivers who were passing along country
    roads- but no attempt was made to introduce that though the judge did
    refer to it in his statement when passing sentence.

    https://attracta.martinharran.com/sentence.pdf Par 15.

    In allowing the previous rape to be introduced as evidence, Justice
    McLaughlin also acceded to the prosecution's request that the previous
    victim not be asked to appear in person but that her previous
    statement be read into evidence by a member of the PSNI; they said
    that she was still suffering emotional trauma from the rape and that
    was already intensified by Hamiton now being on trial for murder.

    The defence tried to fight this, Hamilton claiming that he was not in
    fact guilty of the previous rape, he had only pleaded guilty on the
    advice of his solicitor to get a reduced sentence and he wanted to
    challenge the previous victim's account. The judge rejected that
    argument. I can't remember his exact words but he said something along
    the lines that Hamilton's guilty plea made the previous crime an
    established fact in legal terms, it was not open to challenge in this
    case and he was not going to put "that poor woman" through the
    additional trauma of facing Hamilton in court again.

    Whilst I wanted to see the strongest case possible presented, I did
    have reservations about someone being tried on the basis of
    previous behaviour. In this case, however, I think it was justified,
    it wasn't used as evidence of Hamilton murdering Attracta, it was
    evidence of his *capability* to do so. Photos of Hamilton in the media
    after the trial show him as quite an evil-looking person but that is
    typical of the media - he was far from that in real-life. He was a pleasant-looking young man, almost cherubic in appearance, and if I
    had been on the jury, I would have found it hard to believe that such
    an innocent-looking young lad was capable of such evil behaviour.
    Watching the jury, I could almost see the wheels turning in their
    heads as they realised yes, this young man was capable of evil
    behaviour. It also brought into focus *why* he would have committed
    such evil; the sexual element had been mentioned in the case but more
    or less danced around as Attracta's body was too badly decomposed to
    determine if sexual assault or rape had taken place.


    It's not evidence, you see. Do you agree with
    that or not?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2