Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature. Ok,
this was in France. Shure la contingyont, silver plate, nespar, kesker say.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
Whatever, one punch in the face per donor might be an appropriate--
punishment.
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
On 04/11/2026 21:48, Simon Simple wrote:
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high
temperature.
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
Electricity is probably the UK's Achilles heal, NESO are barely able
to keep it stable under times of stress now. It wouldn't take much of
a hack of the first generation "smart" meters to take it over the
edge.
We have to hope that enough people have changed suppliers to render
most of them dumb again.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render
the donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
I guess it would fall under the computer misuse act, but you have to
catch them first. I seriously doubt Iran, North Korea, China or
Russia will extradite their geese that lay golden eggs.
In many ways the $6bn Binance hack is far more significant shot
across the bows. Image the consequences if a similarly sophisticated
hack was successful against a major banking organisation in the West.
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
I guess it would fall under the computer misuse act,
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone?
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to
the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to
the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to
the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops
working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and
no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com>
wrote:
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge
stops working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers
of protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example)
would catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single
action, and no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident,
as proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set
those limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would
be that it was air-gapped from the public Internet.
On 04/11/2026 21:48, Simon Simple wrote:
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature. Ok,
this was in France. Shure la contingyont, silver plate, nespar, kesker
say.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the
donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
There is no such offence in UK law.
Whatever, one punch in the face per donor might be an appropriate
punishment.
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of
protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would
catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and
no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as
proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it was air-gapped from the public Internet.
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to
the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops
working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and
no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies >>>>> being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things. >>>>>I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility >>>> but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more >>>> sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of >>> protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would >>> catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and >>> no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as >>> proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those >> limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Pop rCystuxnetrCO into your favourite search engine, and see how effective air-gapping was as a security measure when employed by IranrCOs nuclear enrichment program.
On 5 Nov 2026 at 17:04:17 GMT, "Spike" <aero.spike@mail.com> wrote:
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote: >>>
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies >>>>>> being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things. >>>>>>I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>>>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped >>>>> separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>>>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility >>>>> but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more >>>>> sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must >>>> have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of >>>> protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would >>>> catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and >>>> no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as >>>> proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those >>> limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Pop rCystuxnetrCO into your favourite search engine, and see how effective >> air-gapping was as a security measure when employed by IranrCOs nuclear
enrichment program.
I am aware of that. I do not imagine my system would be totally safe from interference, but I would have other design rules which would probably include
very basic logic and no complex software; and I would be pretty confident my house would not be a target of a personalised attack! A sense of proportion is
also necessary, extensive IT security does not prevent a brick through the window for instance.
But I think using a system with a central server on the Internet is just asking for problems.
On 05/11/2026 15:57, Jethro wrote:safecracker
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge
stops working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
It is usually that the systems have some really dumb default password
that is either easily guessed or is stated in the manual!
Worth reading Feynman and the super secure safe at Los Alomos story: https://www.ptlockandsafe.co.uk/blog/richard-feynman-physicist-and-
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers
of protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example)
would catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single
action, and no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
There was a time when routers all had the same password by default and advertised their make and model number in the SSID. How dumb is that?
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident,
as proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
I was amazed to find that my microwave had a wireless internet board
inside it a long time ago (seen when the service engineer changed the klystron on a still under warrantee machine). They never did issue a
firmware update to use it to find online cooking instructions.
On 2026-11-05, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to
the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops
working.
I imagine that temperature monitoring is most of the point of the remote access facility, and the feature to allow setting the temperature is
there because it was trivial to add.
For some of the supermarkets, alarms probably did go off, but it was overnight so there was nobody there to hear the alarms. For the blood
banks, the monitoring system did indeed successfully alert people, and
so the attack was foiled.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
Apparently for many of the supermarket fridges, the username was "admin"
and the password was the current date, and they were connected directly
to the Internet. So there was effectively no security at all.
Worth reading Feynman and the super secure safe at Los Alomos story:
I do wonder why it would have been deemed necessary to have a /freezer/ >temperature settable to 50#C! Rapid defrosting, perhaps:
"We're sending out the engineer. Meanwhile we'll be melting any ice
inside over the next hour or so." Cue pools of water next to the
freezer...
On 05/11/2026 13:34, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>> working.
I imagine that temperature monitoring is most of the point of the remote
access facility, and the feature to allow setting the temperature is
there because it was trivial to add.
I do wonder why it would have been deemed necessary to have a /freezer/ temperature settable to 50-#C! Rapid defrosting, perhaps:
"We're sending out the engineer. Meanwhile we'll be melting any ice
inside over the next hour or so." Cue pools of water next to the freezer...
For some of the supermarkets, alarms probably did go off, but it was
overnight so there was nobody there to hear the alarms. For the blood
banks, the monitoring system did indeed successfully alert people, and
so the attack was foiled.
If there was remote access, why was there no remote alarm warning? Or perhaps there was, and that had been disabled by the hack.
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like 70#C.
I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to
get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than
a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven
the wrong way and have it reach -200#C by mistake.
On 2026-11-06, Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 13:34, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies >>>>> being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things. >>>>I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>>> working.
I imagine that temperature monitoring is most of the point of the remote >>> access facility, and the feature to allow setting the temperature is
there because it was trivial to add.
I do wonder why it would have been deemed necessary to have a /freezer/
temperature settable to 50-#C! Rapid defrosting, perhaps:
"We're sending out the engineer. Meanwhile we'll be melting any ice
inside over the next hour or so." Cue pools of water next to the freezer...
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like 70-#C.
I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to
get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than
a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven
the wrong way and have it reach -200-#C by mistake.
--For some of the supermarkets, alarms probably did go off, but it was
overnight so there was nobody there to hear the alarms. For the blood
banks, the monitoring system did indeed successfully alert people, and
so the attack was foiled.
If there was remote access, why was there no remote alarm warning? Or
perhaps there was, and that had been disabled by the hack.
I was thinking of the physical sound alarm that presumably would go off,
and may well simply not be remotely hackable. As you say, a remote alarm
has to be configurable and so therefore could probably be turned off by
the "hacker".
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like 70#C.
I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to
get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than
a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven
the wrong way and have it reach -200#C by mistake.
Freezers have heaters for defrosting. Ovens rarely contain refrigerators.
In message <6181935031.3aa375a9@uninhabited.net>, at 10:43:39 on Fri, 6
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like 70-#C. >>> I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to
get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than >>> a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven >>> the wrong way and have it reach -200-#C by mistake.
Freezers have heaters for defrosting.-a Ovens rarely contain
refrigerators.
We have a peltier device fridge (for taking food to picnics in the car)
and it would be fairly easy to convert it into an oven.
It is usually that the systems have some really dumb default password that is either easily guessed or is stated in the manual!
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out instructions.
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility
but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more
sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of
protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would
catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and
no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as
proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote:
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies >>>>> being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things. >>>>>I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped
separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility >>>> but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more >>>> sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must
have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of >>> protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would >>> catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and >>> no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as >>> proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those >> limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation system.
The term rCyair-gappedrCO predates the current ubiquitous wireless connectivity
so we need to look beyond the label to the underlying concept. The idea is
to ensure that there is no way to establish any kind of connection between the separate compartments. Most people would not go to the trouble of
putting their refrigerator in a faraday cage to block wireless access and running it on a power supply protected against use as a connection.
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control
two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they would not be able to switch them on remotely.
Back in the day when I worked on a project studying the issues of
distributed computing, security was always the vitally important topic that never quite made the cut for getting more than minimal resources.
Over decades there have been people who have tried to address the issues
but have been dismissed by those who hold the purse strings. In some cases they have been dismissed as Cassandra without those doing so understanding just how ironic that is.
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
..
I guess it would fall under the computer misuse act,
Which has single-figure prosecutions annually.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers.
On 2026-11-06, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >> merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers.
Ok, but "googling the user manual and reading it to find the default
admin username and password" is well within the capabilities of even
the dullest of script kiddies.
Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov >>>> 2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI >>>>> agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >>> merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers.
Ok, but "googling the user manual and reading it to find the default
admin username and password" is well within the capabilities of even
the dullest of script kiddies.
It is now that you have described how to do it.
As far as I recall, the term comes from the idea that they are capable of running scripts created by other people but not much beyond that.
I think it is dangerous to dismiss AI agent attackers as no more of a
threat than script kiddies. They have already demonstrated the ability to perform previously unknown sophisticated attacks and a complete lack of any kind of moral compass. The sanctions that can be applied to human attackers such as sending them to prison do not work against AI agents.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 00:26:37 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 15:57:09 GMT, "Jethro" <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> wrote: >>>
On Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:51:13 +0000, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies >>>>>> being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things. >>>>>>I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to >>>>> the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read
temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped >>>>> separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops >>>>> working.
It has become a fad to add app connections to lots of household
appliances that really don't need it. Our dishwasher has that facility >>>>> but I really can't see the point.
Given that these appliances typically last 10-20 years, the
manufacturers need to commit to 20 years of security updates. Or, more >>>>> sensibly, remove the facility altogether.
What is more worrying (as a techie) is how many basic protections must >>>> have been left out (because profits) of these systems.
Or, to put it another way: my home automation setup has several layers of >>>> protection that took a few minutes to setup and which (for example) would >>>> catch any setpoint being moved by more than 2C in any single action, and >>>> no more than 30% in any 24 hour period.
(The reason I did this was after the news of the last fridge incident, as >>>> proof of how shit things were.)
This was in HomeAssistant - which is one of the clunkier suites out
there. I know SkySpark already has such protections built in as
wraparound templates.
Are you sure of the invulnerability of the software in which you set those >>> limits? If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation
system.
The term rCyair-gappedrCO predates the current ubiquitous wireless connectivity
so we need to look beyond the label to the underlying concept. The idea is >> to ensure that there is no way to establish any kind of connection between >> the separate compartments. Most people would not go to the trouble of
putting their refrigerator in a faraday cage to block wireless access and
running it on a power supply protected against use as a connection.
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control
two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when >> not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >> would not be able to switch them on remotely.
Back in the day when I worked on a project studying the issues of
distributed computing, security was always the vitally important topic that >> never quite made the cut for getting more than minimal resources.
Over decades there have been people who have tried to address the issues
but have been dismissed by those who hold the purse strings. In some cases >> they have been dismissed as Cassandra without those doing so understanding >> just how ironic that is.
WiFi is clearly vulnerable to a nearby spy, but no-one is going to pay for one
to hack my wifi, even an automated machine. I can set up a wifi network with no connection to the Internet.
On 06/11/2026 11:32, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <6181935031.3aa375a9@uninhabited.net>, at 10:43:39 on Fri,
6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like >>>>70#C.
I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to >>>> get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than >>>> a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven >>>> the wrong way and have it reach -200#C by mistake.
Freezers have heaters for defrosting.a Ovens rarely contain >>>refrigerators.
We have a peltier device fridge (for taking food to picnics in the
car) and it would be fairly easy to convert it into an oven.
But only by physically modifying it.
(And it would be a very poor oven, more of a 'warming box'.)
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people
working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management >thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from >home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not >in the office where the people work.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers. The >real threat has always been the people who understand how to exploit the >stupidity of the people who hold the purse strings.
Perhaps AI agents are a real new threat because they are less likely to be >impressed by politicians bluster and the arrogant assumption of superiority >by people who have gained positions of influence.
AI agents do not need to worry about keeping their job if they step
out of line or use unethical or even illegal methods.
I guess it would fall under the computer misuse act,
Which has single-figure prosecutions annually.
So those who feel the need to operate within the law are at a disadvantage.
Recent news suggests that AI agents do not consult corporate legal before >operating without permission on systems owned by people over whom they have >no authority.
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it
was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation >system.
The term rCyair-gappedrCO predates the current ubiquitous wireless connectivity
so we need to look beyond the label to the underlying concept. The idea is
to ensure that there is no way to establish any kind of connection between >the separate compartments. Most people would not go to the trouble of
putting their refrigerator in a faraday cage to block wireless access and >running it on a power supply protected against use as a connection.
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control
two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when >not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >would not be able to switch them on remotely.
In message <11clpdj$30hli$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:55:32 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people
working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management >> thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre -
triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from
home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not >> in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
In message <11clofo$3086a$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:39:36 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >> merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers. The >> real threat has always been the people who understand how to exploit the
stupidity of the people who hold the purse strings.
In opinion that analysis is deeply flawed.
Perhaps AI agents are a real new threat because they are less likely to be >> impressed by politicians bluster and the arrogant assumption of superiority >> by people who have gained positions of influence.
You do have an enormous chip on your shoulder.
AI agents do not need to worry about keeping their job if they step
out of line or use unethical or even illegal methods.
Nor do script kiddies.
I guess it would fall under the computer misuse act,
Which has single-figure prosecutions annually.
So those who feel the need to operate within the law are at a disadvantage.
One of the reasons there are so few prosecutions is because there are so many 'inadvertent' infringements it would overwhelm the criminal justice system.
...
Recent news suggests that AI agents do not consult corporate legal before
operating without permission on systems owned by people over whom they have >> no authority.
Neither do script kiddies.
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it
was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation
system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
The term rCyair-gappedrCO predates the current ubiquitous wireless connectivity
so we need to look beyond the label to the underlying concept. The idea is >> to ensure that there is no way to establish any kind of connection between >> the separate compartments. Most people would not go to the trouble of
putting their refrigerator in a faraday cage to block wireless access and
running it on a power supply protected against use as a connection.
Our dishwasher is bizarrely connected by wifi, and from time to time it downloads new software. Seems a bit of an overkill to me. I'm unaware whether it could be set up to start a cycle, remotely; but obviously it would only turn on if the door was shut.
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control
two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when >> not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >> would not be able to switch them on remotely.
There are several remote-controlled mains sockets available, often from
the same supplier as cctv cameras and doorbells. If I were to deploy
some, I wouldn't plug any heating appliances in, but perhaps the odd standard lamp (although a classic clockwork timer would probably be
almost as useful).
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done
by remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
Which might prompt the question "Why is the EU requiring all products
with a digital element to have a automated updates enabled by default".
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companies
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access?-a Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set to the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a remotely-read temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - an air-gapped separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the fridge stops working.
On 05/11/2026 11:51, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:41, Davey wrote:
Although I have no control over service and infrastructure companiesI'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need >>remote access?a Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
being hacked, I am glad that I never embraced the Internet of Things.
to the correct temperature and then left alone? Maybe, a
remotely-read temperature sensor that's not linked to the controls - >>gapped separate module - would be useful, to sound an alarm if the
fridge stops working.
People were saying, "Wouldn't it be a good idea for fridges to be
connected to the Internet," since before the Millennium. I never knew
why.
Our dishwasher is bizarrely connected by wifi, and from time to time it >downloads new software. Seems a bit of an overkill to me. I'm unaware >whether it could be set up to start a cycle, remotely; but obviously it >would only turn on if the door was shut.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it
was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation >>> system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and
days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be
fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router remotely. I think I saw an article once about attacks on routers but I do
not remember the details. As a former member of ACM I am still on the email list for ACM Queue and that is the sort of place where these things show up so it was probably there.
--
The term rCyair-gappedrCO predates the current ubiquitous wireless connectivity
so we need to look beyond the label to the underlying concept. The idea is >>> to ensure that there is no way to establish any kind of connection between >>> the separate compartments. Most people would not go to the trouble of
putting their refrigerator in a faraday cage to block wireless access and >>> running it on a power supply protected against use as a connection.
Our dishwasher is bizarrely connected by wifi, and from time to time it
downloads new software. Seems a bit of an overkill to me. I'm unaware
whether it could be set up to start a cycle, remotely; but obviously it
would only turn on if the door was shut.
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control >>> two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when >>> not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >>> would not be able to switch them on remotely.
There are several remote-controlled mains sockets available, often from
the same supplier as cctv cameras and doorbells. If I were to deploy
some, I wouldn't plug any heating appliances in, but perhaps the odd
standard lamp (although a classic clockwork timer would probably be
almost as useful).
My heaters have WiFi built in as well as simple remote controls. They are plugged in to ordinary sockets with physical switches when required.
The remote control sockets are used for various lamps and have their own remote controls rather than being on WiFi.
There's all sorts of problems with this
In message <e2Qs5ZDGxt7qFAK6@perry.uk>, at 08:07:34 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> remarked:
Our dishwasher is bizarrely connected by wifi, and from time to time
it downloads new software. Seems a bit of an overkill to me. I'm
unaware whether it could be set up to start a cycle, remotely; but >obviously it would only turn on if the door was shut.
I've made enquiries with her-indoors, and she says that other
functionality (which was never activated) allows for progress
reports to be sent to your phone.
However, since originally set up, the wifi passwords has changed, so
it's no longer on-line.
She reminded me there's a desktop fan in the bedroom, which can be
switched on/off remotely, without the bother of getting out of bed.
Although that is also probably suffering from the new-password issue
at the moment.
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
Which might prompt the question "Why is the EU requiring all products
with a digital element to have a automated updates enabled by default".
On 2026-11-07, Nick Finnigan <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
Which might prompt the question "Why is the EU requiring all products
with a digital element to have a automated updates enabled by default".
Do you have a specific law in mind?
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it
was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation >>>> system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and >>> days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be >>> fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router
remotely.
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral wifi service >would be a very bad choice for the access point of a local only wifi service.
On Sat, 07 Nov 2026 11:54:16 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
There's all sorts of problems with this
Stores being out of stock of items for a start.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 12:18:09 +0000
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <e2Qs5ZDGxt7qFAK6@perry.uk>, at 08:07:34 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> remarked:
Our dishwasher is bizarrely connected by wifi, and from time to time
it downloads new software. Seems a bit of an overkill to me. I'm
unaware whether it could be set up to start a cycle, remotely; but
obviously it would only turn on if the door was shut.
I've made enquiries with her-indoors, and she says that other
functionality (which was never activated) allows for progress
reports to be sent to your phone.
However, since originally set up, the wifi passwords has changed, so
it's no longer on-line.
She reminded me there's a desktop fan in the bedroom, which can be
switched on/off remotely, without the bother of getting out of bed.
Although that is also probably suffering from the new-password issue
at the moment.
I have a remote-control fan. It has a credit-card sized remote control,
which has never seen an internet.
In message <11clpdj$30hli$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:55:32 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access?-a Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people
working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of
management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre -
triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from
home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work
are not
in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
In message <5516401284.5059e9fb@uninhabited.net>, at 12:39:24 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>>>>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation >>>>> system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and >>>> days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be >>>> fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router
remotely.
That's a more complex attack, because they have to compromise your
router as well as compromising whichever appliance they are targeting.
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral wifi service
would be a very bad choice for the access point of a local only wifi service.
Not quite sure what you mean as "local only wifi service".
I've had ADSL routers which had two SSIDs, one for normal use, and
another for 'Guests' who had access only to the public Internet, not
anything inside the house.
In message <11cn96f$3gm5u$22@dont-email.me>, at 13:30:55 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sat, 07 Nov 2026 11:54:16 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
There's all sorts of problems with this
Stores being out of stock of items for a start.
If the fridge compiles a "shopping list" for you, and some of the items
are out of stock, then the worst that happens is they can't ship that
item to you. Depending on the store's shopping app, they might re-try
later.
[Many things seem to be often out of stock at our local Tesco delivery
service. Onions, for example!]
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis
for Burns Night.
In message <11cn96f$3gm5u$22@dont-email.me>, at 13:30:55 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sat, 07 Nov 2026 11:54:16 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
There's all sorts of problems with this
Stores being out of stock of items for a start.
If the fridge compiles a "shopping list" for you, and some of the items
are out of stock, then the worst that happens is they can't ship that
item to you. Depending on the store's shopping app, they might re-try
later.
[Many things seem to be often out of stock at our local Tesco delivery
service. Onions, for example!]
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis for Burns Night.
On 07/11/2026 14:19, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-07, Nick Finnigan <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
Which might prompt the question "Why is the EU requiring all products >>> with a digital element to have a automated updates enabled by default".
Do you have a specific law in mind?
The Cyber Resilience Act.
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11clpdj$30hli$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:55:32 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access?-a Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of
management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >>> triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from >>> home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work
are not
in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:44:02 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11cn96f$3gm5u$22@dont-email.me>, at 13:30:55 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sat, 07 Nov 2026 11:54:16 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
There's all sorts of problems with this
Stores being out of stock of items for a start.
If the fridge compiles a "shopping list" for you, and some of the items
are out of stock, then the worst that happens is they can't ship that
item to you. Depending on the store's shopping app, they might re-try
later.
[Many things seem to be often out of stock at our local Tesco delivery
service. Onions, for example!]
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to
re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis
for Burns Night.
I have a problem with the idea of keeping onions in a fridge.
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
In many ways the $6bn Binance hack is far more significant shot across
the bows. Image the consequences if a similarly sophisticated hack was >successful against a major banking organisation in the West.
There's all sorts of problems with this
Stores being out of stock of items for a start.
If the fridge compiles a "shopping list" for you, and some of the items
are out of stock, then the worst that happens is they can't ship that
item to you. Depending on the store's shopping app, they might re-try
later.
[Many things seem to be often out of stock at our local Tesco delivery
service. Onions, for example!]
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to
re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis for
Burns Night.
Who keeps onions in a fridge ?
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to
re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis
for Burns Night.
I have a problem with the idea of keeping onions in a fridge.
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access?a Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of >>>management thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data
centre - triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest >>>clue. The people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may
be working from home, it makes no real difference. The machines
doing the real work are not in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done
by remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:35:31 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <5516401284.5059e9fb@uninhabited.net>, at 12:39:24 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov >>>>> 2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>>>>>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation
system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and >>>>> days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be >>>>> fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router
remotely.
That's a more complex attack, because they have to compromise your
router as well as compromising whichever appliance they are targeting.
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral
wifi service would be a very bad choice for the access point of a
local only wifi service.
Not quite sure what you mean as "local only wifi service".
I've had ADSL routers which had two SSIDs, one for normal use, and
another for 'Guests' who had access only to the public Internet, not
anything inside the house.
I mean the converse of that, a wifi network none of whose members had any >connection to any other network. Obviously I would not use a router with >access to other networks as an access point for said network.
In message <7007745400.3ab4e8be@uninhabited.net>, at 16:47:57 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Not that this hypothetical fridge-stock-control-system would cope very
well with counting the number of onions you'd used, and hence when to
re-order. I'd have more serious issues with it attempting to re-order
things which were originally one-off purchases. For example a Haggis
for Burns Night.
I have a problem with the idea of keeping onions in a fridge.
Like other vegetables, such as carrots and potatoes, lettuce and bell-peppers, they do seem to last longer if kept in the drawer at the
bottom of the fridge.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:11:58 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI >>>agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
But AI hasn't.
Script kiddies don't discover vulnerabilities, or write the code to exploit >them. They merely use code written by those who do discover them.
AI can both discover the vulnerabilities and write the code to exploit them.
In message <6715756896.13a93f18@uninhabited.net>, at 15:59:17 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:35:31 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <5516401284.5059e9fb@uninhabited.net>, at 12:39:24 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov >>>>>> 2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>>>>>>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home automation
system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and >>>>>> days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be >>>>>> fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The
Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router >>>>> remotely.
That's a more complex attack, because they have to compromise your
router as well as compromising whichever appliance they are targeting.
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral
wifi service would be a very bad choice for the access point of a
local only wifi service.
Not quite sure what you mean as "local only wifi service".
I've had ADSL routers which had two SSIDs, one for normal use, and
another for 'Guests' who had access only to the public Internet, not
anything inside the house.
I mean the converse of that, a wifi network none of whose members had any
connection to any other network. Obviously I would not use a router with
access to other networks as an access point for said network.
So, essentially a local wifi network with only things like printers and
PCs attached to it. No email or web browsing on the PCs, no software
updates for the printers. That's a very niche market.
On 05/11/2026 09:20, Jeff Layman wrote:
On 04/11/2026 21:48, Simon Simple wrote:
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature. Ok, >>> this was in France. Shure la contingyont, silver plate, nespar, kesker
say.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the
donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
There is no such offence in UK law.
Fair enough. My point is that blood donors are told that each donation
"can save up to three lives". Obviously 'can' and 'up to' are doing a
lot of work there, and I would suppose that the average figure is a lot >lower. But if many donations are made useless, then it seems reasonable
to assume that some number of people will die as a result.
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need
*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user >interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly >trivial, so they did.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 15:15:15 +0000, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:20, Jeff Layman wrote:
On 04/11/2026 21:48, Simon Simple wrote:
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature. Ok, >>>> this was in France. Shure la contingyont, silver plate, nespar, kesker >>>> say.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the
donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
There is no such offence in UK law.
Fair enough. My point is that blood donors are told that each donation
"can save up to three lives". Obviously 'can' and 'up to' are doing a
lot of work there, and I would suppose that the average figure is a lot
lower. But if many donations are made useless, then it seems reasonable
to assume that some number of people will die as a result.
The point is that "attempted manslaughter" doesn't exist because it's an oxymoron. Manslaughter, by definition, is unintentional (but reckless or negligent) killing. But you can't intend to do something unintentionally. If you intend to kill, then it's murder, if successful, or attempted murder, if unsuccessful.
Deliberate tampering with medical equipment such that death is a significant probability would, I'm pretty sure, meet the threshold for murder or attempted murder.
Mark
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need
*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
Mark
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the >campaign against working from home.
You would need to ask the store management but intending to save money is >probably in there somewhere.
I have a problem with the idea of keeping onions in a fridge.
Like other vegetables, such as carrots and potatoes, lettuce and
bell-peppers, they do seem to last longer if kept in the drawer at the
bottom of the fridge.
And dairy products being tainted with onion smells is not a problem?
Onions generally last months, canonically on french handlebars for
instance.
I concur re potatoes.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 22:31:31 GMT, "Mark Goodge" ><usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
Mark
More so than a lockable lid over the control panel?
On 7 Nov 2026 at 17:50:54 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <6715756896.13a93f18@uninhabited.net>, at 15:59:17 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:35:31 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <5516401284.5059e9fb@uninhabited.net>, at 12:39:24 on Sat, 7 >>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov >>>>>>> 2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>>>>>>>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home >>>>>>>>automation system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and
days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be
fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The >>>>>>> Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router >>>>>> remotely.
That's a more complex attack, because they have to compromise your
router as well as compromising whichever appliance they are targeting. >>>>
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral
wifi service would be a very bad choice for the access point of a
local only wifi service.
Not quite sure what you mean as "local only wifi service".
I've had ADSL routers which had two SSIDs, one for normal use, and
another for 'Guests' who had access only to the public Internet, not
anything inside the house.
I mean the converse of that, a wifi network none of whose members had any >>> connection to any other network. Obviously I would not use a router with >>> access to other networks as an access point for said network.
So, essentially a local wifi network with only things like printers and
PCs attached to it. No email or web browsing on the PCs, no software
updates for the printers. That's a very niche market.
You can have more than one wifi network in the same physical space!!
They are quite clever at avoiding one another. And there is ample
bandwidth for any home available nowadays.
*If* I wanted home automation that is how I would do it. Any increased >equipment costs would be defrayed by not having to subscribe to a central >service.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clpdj$30hli$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:55:32 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management >>> thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >>> triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from >>> home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not >>> in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the >campaign against working from home.
You would need to ask the store management but intending to save money is >probably in there somewhere.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens ><jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need
*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user >>interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly >>trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of >salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls.
Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff
can alter the settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you
don't get hacked.
Mark
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control >>> two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when >>> not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >>> would not be able to switch them on remotely.
There are several remote-controlled mains sockets available, often from
the same supplier as cctv cameras and doorbells. If I were to deploy
some, I wouldn't plug any heating appliances in, but perhaps the odd
standard lamp (although a classic clockwork timer would probably be
almost as useful).
My heaters have WiFi built in as well as simple remote controls.
They are
plugged in to ordinary sockets with physical switches when required.
The remote control sockets are used for various lamps and have their own >remote controls rather than being on WiFi.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need
*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
Mark
On 7 Nov 2026 at 22:01:52 GMT, "Mark Goodge" <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 15:15:15 +0000, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk>
wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:20, Jeff Layman wrote:
On 04/11/2026 21:48, Simon Simple wrote:
Hackers, attempt to set blood bank fridges to some high temperature. Ok, >>>>> this was in France. Shure la contingyont, silver plate, nespar, kesker >>>>> say.
But if someone messed with our blood banks and managed to render the >>>>> donations useless, would this be attempted manslaughter?
There is no such offence in UK law.
Fair enough. My point is that blood donors are told that each donation
"can save up to three lives". Obviously 'can' and 'up to' are doing a
lot of work there, and I would suppose that the average figure is a lot
lower. But if many donations are made useless, then it seems reasonable >>> to assume that some number of people will die as a result.
The point is that "attempted manslaughter" doesn't exist because it's an
oxymoron. Manslaughter, by definition, is unintentional (but reckless or
negligent) killing. But you can't intend to do something unintentionally. If >> you intend to kill, then it's murder, if successful, or attempted murder, if >> unsuccessful.
Deliberate tampering with medical equipment such that death is a significant >> probability would, I'm pretty sure, meet the threshold for murder or
attempted murder.
Mark
But surely only a particular death, or a death specifically related to a given
act of tampering, could meet the criteria for attempted murder. Interfering with a blood transfusion centre fridge the contents of which had not been allocated urgently to any ill patients would be too remote. Possibly interfering with a unit of blood in an A & E department that had been crossmatched for an accident victim might be attempted murder of a patient even if the perpetrator did not know who they were, but not sabotage that could create a dangerous shortage of blood for patients yet to be identified.
In message <7845055963.84a063fa@uninhabited.net>, at 19:07:30 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 17:50:54 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <6715756896.13a93f18@uninhabited.net>, at 15:59:17 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:35:31 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>
In message <5516401284.5059e9fb@uninhabited.net>, at 12:39:24 on Sat, 7 >>>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 09:33:50 GMT, "Owen Rees" <orees@hotmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clr7s$314d3$1@dont-email.me>, at 00:26:37 on Sat, 7 Nov >>>>>>>> 2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
If I wanted a home automation system design rule 1 would be that it >>>>>>>>>> was air-gapped from the public Internet.
Unfortunately, that removes most of the value of having a home >>>>>>>>> automation system.
Home automation is more than remote-control.
My central heating has a classic 'controller', where I can set times and
days of operation. But it's not connected to The Internet.
If I installed a Hive (other brands are available) I suspect it would be
fairly easy to set the router up so that it was isolated from The >>>>>>>> Internet, on demand.
That works until someone finds out how to take control of your router >>>>>>> remotely.
That's a more complex attack, because they have to compromise your
router as well as compromising whichever appliance they are targeting. >>>>>
I think an appliance that consisted of a router with an integral
wifi service would be a very bad choice for the access point of a >>>>>> local only wifi service.
Not quite sure what you mean as "local only wifi service".
I've had ADSL routers which had two SSIDs, one for normal use, and
another for 'Guests' who had access only to the public Internet, not >>>>> anything inside the house.
I mean the converse of that, a wifi network none of whose members had any >>>> connection to any other network. Obviously I would not use a router with >>>> access to other networks as an access point for said network.
So, essentially a local wifi network with only things like printers and
PCs attached to it. No email or web browsing on the PCs, no software
updates for the printers. That's a very niche market.
You can have more than one wifi network in the same physical space!!
Yes, I know, having mentioned co-existing resident and guest networks in
an earlier posting.
They are quite clever at avoiding one another. And there is ample
bandwidth for any home available nowadays.
*If* I wanted home automation that is how I would do it. Any increased
equipment costs would be defrayed by not having to subscribe to a central
service.
Increasingly, now that it comes for a couple of cents per
microcontroller, in-house 'closed/private' comms like that are
Bluetooth, not wifi.
I spent far too long yesterday struggling to set up a gadget like that,
with an app designed by engineers whose IQ appeared to be lower than
their inside leg measurement.
And smart meters use Zigbee.
On 2026-11-07, Nick Finnigan <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 14:19, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-07, Nick Finnigan <nix@genie.co.uk> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 07:46, Roland Perry wrote:Do you have a specific law in mind?
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by >>>>> remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
Which might prompt the question "Why is the EU requiring all products >>>> with a digital element to have a automated updates enabled by default". >>>
The Cyber Resilience Act.
I don't think it says what you said it says.
Presumably you are referring to Annex I Part I paragraph (2)(c),
which says:
"ensure that vulnerabilities can be addressed through security
updates, including, where applicable, through automatic security
updates that are installed within an appropriate timeframe enabled
as a default setting"
If the product doesn't have remote access then it can't have remote vulnerabilities - and the automatic updates bit is only "where
applicable" anyway. For a product without remote access it's clearly
not applicable.
(And that's without even taking into account that the whole Regulation
only applies to "products with digital elements", which means "a software
or hardware product and its remote data processing solutions", and a
product without remote access clearly cannot have any "remote data processing".)
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202402847
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need
remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set
to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people
working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out
instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not in the office where the people work.
In message <appueltqgh9sgjf83b7iisjsiupi3f3hgn@4ax.com>, at 18:01:58 on
Sat, 7 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> remarked:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 13:11:58 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
But AI hasn't.
Script kiddies don't discover vulnerabilities, or write the code to
exploit
them. They merely use code written by those who do discover them.
AI can both discover the vulnerabilities and write the code to exploit
them.
And there was me thinking that AI was just parroting things it had been trained on (previous work).
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a >>safety-critical system in a public-facing situation (and
frozen/chilled food temperatures are a safety issue, you don't want
to give your customers a dose of salmonella), you do not want the
public to be able to access the controls. Remote control is the best
way to ensure that only staff can alter the settings on the units. At >>least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
MarkFair points, but why not just use a local LAN which connects to a
central computer in a secure office?
The nonsense sets in when the whole system is linked to the internet,
where everyone & his uncle can have a go at messing around with it.
Increasingly, now that it comes for a couple of cents per
microcontroller, in-house 'closed/private' comms like that are
Bluetooth, not wifi.
I spent far too long yesterday struggling to set up a gadget like that,
with an app designed by engineers whose IQ appeared to be lower than
their inside leg measurement.
And smart meters use Zigbee.
How useful are those protocols for linking a houseful of machines to a single >server?
The PHP issue recently was known to some humans for a couple of years
but not considered important enough to fix until an LLM found a way to >exploit it. Human error resulted in the fix being disclosed before the >loophole had been plugged and chaos ensued with government websites
forced off air for fear of being hacked by that disclosed vulnerability.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need
*any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left?
As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a >>safety-critical system in a public-facing situation (and
frozen/chilled food temperatures are a safety issue, you don't want
to give your customers a dose of salmonella), you do not want the
public to be able to access the controls. Remote control is the best
way to ensure that only staff can alter the settings on the units. At >>least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
"Remote" could mean a set of controls in a part of the store only
accessible to the staff. This could be a password protected computer
that also controls other things in the store, such as the air
conditioning. There's just no need for it to be remote from the store.
In message <11cpqoj$aeq2$1@dont-email.me>, at 12:42:59 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Max Demian <max_demian@bigfoot.com> remarked:
-aAnd, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-
critical-a system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled
food temperatures-a are a safety issue, you don't want to give your
customers a dose of-a salmonella), you do not want the public to be
able to access the controls.-a Remote control is the best way to
ensure that only staff can alter the-a settings on the units. At
least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
"Remote" could mean a set of controls in a part of the store only
accessible to the staff. This could be a password protected computer
that also controls other things in the store, such as the air
conditioning. There's just no need for it to be remote from the store.
Apologies for being repetitive, but that doesn't work for at least two reasons:
o Disaffected local staff still have access to the controls
o There are significant economies of scale in centralisation. My local
-a convenience store, which is at least 30% freezer, only has about two
-a staff on duty at any one time (and all staff would need to be trained
-a on something which happened maybe once a month), and there's nowhere
-a on the premises to put such a "locked room", it's like sardines.
None of the 8-bit computers I helped design in the 80's ever had any
patches, and almost no bugs. And we took forward and backwards
compatibility *very* seriously.
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 11:49:33 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
None of the 8-bit computers I helped design in the 80's ever had any
patches, and almost no bugs. And we took forward and backwards
compatibility *very* seriously.
I think you will find shareholder returns are taken more seriously ....
On 08/11/2026 12:53, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11cpqoj$aeq2$1@dont-email.me>, at 12:42:59 on Sun, 8 Nov >>2026, Max Demian <max_demian@bigfoot.com> remarked:
aAnd, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a
safety- criticala system in a public-facing situation (and >>>>frozen/chilled food temperaturesa are a safety issue, you don't
want to give your customers a dose ofa salmonella), you do not want >>>>the public to be able to access the controls.a Remote control is
the best way to ensure that only staff can alter thea settings on
the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
"Remote" could mean a set of controls in a part of the store only >>>accessible to the staff. This could be a password protected computer >>>that also controls other things in the store, such as the air >>>conditioning. There's just no need for it to be remote from the store.
Apologies for being repetitive, but that doesn't work for at least
two reasons:
o Disaffected local staff still have access to the controls
How about disaffected remote staff, though?
In message <11cpudd$3gm5u$28@dont-email.me>, at 13:45:17 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 11:49:33 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
None of the 8-bit computers I helped design in the 80's ever had any
patches, and almost no bugs. And we took forward and backwards
compatibility *very* seriously.
I think you will find shareholder returns are taken more seriously ....
They were of no interest to my team of engineers.
As I once said to the main shareholder "it doesn't cost you any more to manufacture a ROM with no bugs in, or a manual with no spelling
mistakes, than a flawed one".
"Remote" could mean a set of controls in a part of the store only
accessible to the staff. This could be a password protected computer that also controls other things in the store, such as the air conditioning.
There's just no need for it to be remote from the store.
In message <11cpudd$3gm5u$28@dont-email.me>, at 13:45:17 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
[quoted text muted]
They were of no interest to my team of engineers.
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:07:39 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11cpudd$3gm5u$28@dont-email.me>, at 13:45:17 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
[quoted text muted]
They were of no interest to my team of engineers.
Of course not. You were engineers. Not managers.
You did the best you could do with the budget you were given. Which
totally and utterly has no effect on my assertion that shareholder
returns are the sine no qua of any company that has shareholders.
On 08/11/2026 15:07, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11cpudd$3gm5u$28@dont-email.me>, at 13:45:17 on Sun, 8
Nov 2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 11:49:33 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
None of the 8-bit computers I helped design in the 80's ever had any
patches, and almost no bugs. And we took forward and backwards
compatibility *very* seriously.
I think you will find shareholder returns are taken more seriously ....
They were of no interest to my team of engineers.
As I once said to the main shareholder "it doesn't cost you any more
to manufacture a ROM with no bugs in, or a manual with no spelling >>mistakes, than a flawed one".
Indeed, and as a machinist once told me: "precision engineering is the >easiest thing in the world. It takes less time to drill a hole in the >correct spot, than the wrong one with correction then required."
In message <11cq6s6$3gm5u$29@dont-email.me>, at 16:09:42 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
On Sun, 08 Nov 2026 15:07:39 +0000, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11cpudd$3gm5u$28@dont-email.me>, at 13:45:17 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Jethro <jethro_UK@hotmailbin.com> remarked:
[quoted text muted]
They were of no interest to my team of engineers.
Of course not. You were engineers. Not managers.
Not true. Although an engineer by trade, my day to day work was at least
3/4 "managing".
You did the best you could do with the budget you were given. Which
totally and utterly has no effect on my assertion that shareholder
returns are the sine no qua of any company that has shareholders.
Se the reply I made a few minutes ago.
In message <6181935031.3aa375a9@uninhabited.net>, at 10:43:39 on Fri, 6
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Apparently one of the supermarket freezers reached something like 70-#C. >>> I just don't understand how it's physically *possible* for a freezer to
get so hot - you need a completely different mechanism for a heater than >>> a freezer. It's not like you can accidentally turn the dial on your oven >>> the wrong way and have it reach -200-#C by mistake.
Freezers have heaters for defrosting.-a Ovens rarely contain
refrigerators.
We have a peltier device fridge (for taking food to picnics in the car)
and it would be fairly easy to convert it into an oven.
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 09:02:52 -0000 (UTC), Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com>While I agree with you, I am conscious that monitoring can be separated
wrote:
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the
campaign against working from home.
You would need to ask the store management but intending to save money is
probably in there somewhere.
I also suspect that actually, security is a reason. It's just security from
a different attack vector.
If you need to manually switch a fridge or freezer into defrost mode, then the switch panel which controls that needs to be accessible. And if it's accessible to a member of staff walking past, then it's also accessible to a member of the public walking past. Or to a disgruntled member of staff walking past them having just been disciplined or sacked. Removing the
manual switches and replacing them with remote controlled switches removes the possibility of malicious tampering by malcontents within the store.
Also, the various regulations controlling the distribution and sale of chilled and frozen food require the temperature to be monitored and logged. It is hugely easier to do that by automatically transmitting the
termperature data to a central server than sending a member of staff round with a clipboard checking the temperature of every fridge and freezer.
Given that remote monitoring is pretty much essential for any significantly sized retail unit, and you don't want the controls to be amenable to tampering with by visitors, it makes commercial and practical sense to make the whole system - both monitoring and control - remotely operated. It's not significantly more complex to make the communication between fridge and server two-way rather than one-way.
What this does, of course, mean is that you're replacing one attack vector with a different one. But I suspect that, until now, the threat of malicious interference with the remote control system was considered to be low. Or, at least, lower than the risk of malicious interference with a human-accessible physical control panel on the unit itself. This may well be a risk which now needs to be reassessed. But the underlying reasons for having a remote control system are still valid.
Mark Goodge wrote:Isn't it more likely that it's just "a fridge" that the script kiddies
Deliberate tampering with medical equipment such that death is a significant >> probability would, I'm pretty sure, meet the threshold for murder or
attempted murder.
But surely only a particular death, or a death specifically related to a given
act of tampering, could meet the criteria for attempted murder. Interfering with a blood transfusion centre fridge the contents of which had not been allocated urgently to any ill patients would be too remote.
On 07/11/2026 22:31, Mark Goodge wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon RibbensFair points, but why not just use a local LAN which connects to a
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
central computer in a secure office? The nonsense sets in when the whole >system is linked to the internet, where everyone & his uncle can have a
go at messing around with it.
On 07/11/2026 22:31, Mark Goodge wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
"Remote" could mean a set of controls in a part of the store only
accessible to the staff. This could be a password protected computer
that also controls other things in the store, such as the air
conditioning. There's just no need for it to be remote from the store.
In message <11cpme0$8tbr$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:29:03 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
The PHP issue recently was known to some humans for a couple of years
but not considered important enough to fix until an LLM found a way to >>exploit it. Human error resulted in the fix being disclosed before the >>loophole had been plugged and chaos ensued with government websites
forced off air for fear of being hacked by that disclosed vulnerability.
As you may know, I've worked in the ISP and backbone Internet Industries >since the mid 90's, and both are awash with known vulnerabilities that >no-one has the time or energy to patch in a sufficiently rapid and
stealthy way. They just keep their fingers crossed. Works almost all the >time.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 22:31:31 GMT, "Mark Goodge" ><usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
More so than a lockable lid over the control panel?
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:49:33 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11cpme0$8tbr$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:29:03 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
The PHP issue recently was known to some humans for a couple of years
but not considered important enough to fix until an LLM found a way to >>>exploit it. Human error resulted in the fix being disclosed before the >>>loophole had been plugged and chaos ensued with government websites >>>forced off air for fear of being hacked by that disclosed vulnerability.
As you may know, I've worked in the ISP and backbone Internet Industries >>since the mid 90's, and both are awash with known vulnerabilities that >>no-one has the time or energy to patch in a sufficiently rapid and
stealthy way. They just keep their fingers crossed. Works almost all the >>time.
It used to work almost all of the time because discovering and exploiting >vulnerabilities was a high skill exercise. With the aid of AI, it isn't.
In message <11cmpfs$39gki$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:02:52 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clpdj$30hli$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:55:32 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chqji$1j3ee$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:51:13 on Thu, 5 Nov >>>>> 2026, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need >>>>>> remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out >>>>> instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >>>> triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The
people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from >>>> home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not
in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the
campaign against working from home.
"Working from home" is a complete red herring in this instance. The employees of the refrigeration outsourcing company could just as easily
be working in a portacabin on an industrial estate in India.
You would need to ask the store management but intending to save money is
probably in there somewhere.
You'd certainly save lots of money by not having to train sufficient personnel in all the shops, how/why to twiddle the knobs locally.
In message <9151285309.3d5992b0@uninhabited.net>, at 22:45:13 on Sat, 7
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 22:31:31 GMT, "Mark Goodge"
<usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk> wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon Ribbens
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature >>>> was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user >>>> interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly >>>> trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >>> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures >>> are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >>> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
Mark
More so than a lockable lid over the control panel?
Disaffected staff might have the key.
On 07/11/2026 22:31, Mark Goodge wrote:
On Sat, 7 Nov 2026 17:36:33 -0000 (UTC), Jon RibbensFair points, but why not just use a local LAN which connects to a
<jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-07, GB <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
I think that what I am actually asking is why supermarket freezers need >>>> *any* knobs twiddled? Surely, they are set to a temperature, then left? >>>As I said previously, my guess would be that the actual desired feature
was remote monitoring, and once they had put in the networking and user
interface for that, adding a way of setting the temperature was utterly
trivial, so they did.
And, as I've said elsewhere in this thread, when you have a safety-critical >> system in a public-facing situation (and frozen/chilled food temperatures
are a safety issue, you don't want to give your customers a dose of
salmonella), you do not want the public to be able to access the controls. >> Remote control is the best way to ensure that only staff can alter the
settings on the units. At least, it is so long as you don't get hacked.
Mark
central computer in a secure office? The nonsense sets in when the whole system is linked to the internet, where everyone & his uncle can have a
go at messing around with it.
In message <o8t1fl1uv51mtkbits02al12ird8e25vto@4ax.com>, at 22:21:37 on
Sun, 8 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
remarked:
[quoted text muted]
AI, like The Internet itself, simply accelerates things which were
happening anyway.
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 11:49:33 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11cpme0$8tbr$1@dont-email.me>, at 11:29:03 on Sun, 8 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
The PHP issue recently was known to some humans for a couple of years
but not considered important enough to fix until an LLM found a way to
exploit it. Human error resulted in the fix being disclosed before the
loophole had been plugged and chaos ensued with government websites
forced off air for fear of being hacked by that disclosed vulnerability.
As you may know, I've worked in the ISP and backbone Internet Industries
since the mid 90's, and both are awash with known vulnerabilities that
no-one has the time or energy to patch in a sufficiently rapid and
stealthy way. They just keep their fingers crossed. Works almost all the
time.
It used to work almost all of the time because discovering and exploiting vulnerabilities was a high skill exercise. With the aid of AI, it isn't.
In message <11cmr9u$3a52b$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:33:50 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
The little home automation I have is an app on my phone that can control >>>> two electric heaters. The heaters are switched off at the power socket when
not in use so even if someone was able to break in to my home network they >>>> would not be able to switch them on remotely.
There are several remote-controlled mains sockets available, often from
the same supplier as cctv cameras and doorbells. If I were to deploy
some, I wouldn't plug any heating appliances in, but perhaps the odd
standard lamp (although a classic clockwork timer would probably be
almost as useful).
My heaters have WiFi built in as well as simple remote controls.
I've not yet encountered any plug-in heaters with WiFi built in. Maybe
I'm just buying the cheaper brands.
They are
plugged in to ordinary sockets with physical switches when required.
The remote control sockets are used for various lamps and have their own
remote controls rather than being on WiFi.
The sockets I saw most recently are an add-on to an 'Alexa'
installation, and receive their commands by wifi.
The most recent addition to the mesh-of-things around here works on Bluetooth. And somewhere in the house is a fairly old Bluetooth
thermometer, but it's gone into hiding. From the data we can tell it's
not in the fridge/freezer or outdoors, but which room of the house is a mystery. Maybe fallen down the back of a sofa.
Oh, and one of the cars is hosting a tracker button we don't recognise
(and can't find), but as it sits on the drive 99.9% of the time, its location is hardly a secret. Tremendous fun, seeing as how the car's
owner filed the original patents for tracker buttons.
Round here the motto is "if it doesn't move - paint it; if it does move,
put a tracker button on it".
why not just use a local LAN which connects to a central computer in
a secure office? The nonsense sets in when the whole system is linked
to the internet, where everyone & his uncle can have a go at messing >>around with it.
Sufficiently well trained people are more expensive than most retail staff. >One per store is too expensive. 24 hour coverage requires more than one.
In message <11cs7it$157g0$2@dont-email.me>, at 10:34:05 on Mon, 9 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
why not just use a local LAN which connects to a central computer
in a secure office? The nonsense sets in when the whole system is
linked to the internet, where everyone & his uncle can have a go
at messing around with it.
Sufficiently well trained people are more expensive than most retail
staff. One per store is too expensive. 24 hour coverage requires
more than one.
There's 8760 hours in a year, and an employee on a 37hr week, 52-5.6
weeks of the year [so ignoring sickness and training] is 1717 hrs.
So you'd need 5.1 employees. But then there's lunch times, how do you
cover those?
I was brought down to earth with a bump, when in the late 70's I
thought I could run a Mon-Sat 9-5 retail shop, with a bit of
telesales and first line support, with myself and three staff.
But when one is on his day off, another is on vacation, another has
called in sick, and the remaining one declares "it's lunchtime"...
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need >>>>>>> remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out >>>>>> instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >>>>> triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The >>>>> people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from >>>>> home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not
in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by
remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the >>> campaign against working from home.
"Working from home" is a complete red herring in this instance. The
employees of the refrigeration outsourcing company could just as easily
be working in a portacabin on an industrial estate in India.
Perhaps you should have a word with Mr Roland Perry who introduced working >from home as if it were the key factor in deciding to use remote
management.
In message <11cs6mo$14ta8$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:19:04 on Mon, 9 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need >>>>>>>> remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>>>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out >>>>>>> instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data centre - >>>>>> triplicated if the people running it have even the smallest clue. The >>>>>> people keeping an overall view may be in an office or may be working from
home, it makes no real difference. The machines doing the real work are not
in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by >>>>> remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store".
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the >>>> campaign against working from home.
"Working from home" is a complete red herring in this instance. The
employees of the refrigeration outsourcing company could just as easily
be working in a portacabin on an industrial estate in India.
Perhaps you should have a word with Mr Roland Perry who introduced working >> from home as if it were the key factor in deciding to use remote
management.
It was a metaphor, to contrast with "working on the premises". But we
know you don't understand metaphors.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clofo$3086a$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:39:36 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov
2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI
agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >>> merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers. The >>> real threat has always been the people who understand how to exploit the >>> stupidity of the people who hold the purse strings.
In opinion that analysis is deeply flawed.
Perhaps AI agents are a real new threat because they are less likely to be >>> impressed by politicians bluster and the arrogant assumption of superiority >>> by people who have gained positions of influence.
You do have an enormous chip on your shoulder.
Decades of experience and a history of talking in person to real experts
and observing the stupidity of people in positions of authority.
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11cs6mo$14ta8$1@dont-email.me>, at 10:19:04 on Mon, 9 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
That is a much better question and avoids using the attack as part of the >>>>> campaign against working from home.I'm perplexed why supermarket fridges (which were also hacked) need >>>>>>>>> remote access? Let alone, blood bank freezers? Surely, these are set >>>>>>>>> to the correct temperature and then left alone?
Because the maintenance of such installations is outsourced, to people >>>>>>>> working-from-home, who need to be sent data, and in response send out >>>>>>>> instructions.
Introducing working from home as a factor ie exactly the kind of >>>>>>>management
thinking that creates the problem.
The control and monitoring will be done by systems in some data >>>>>>>centre - triplicated if the people running it have even the >>>>>>>smallest clue. The people keeping an overall view may be in an >>>>>>>office or may be working from home, it makes no real difference. >>>>>>>The machines doing the real work are not in the office where the people work.
False dichotomy. The question people are asking is "why is it done by >>>>>> remote access - rather than a person twiddling knobs in the store". >>>>>
"Working from home" is a complete red herring in this instance. The
employees of the refrigeration outsourcing company could just as easily >>>> be working in a portacabin on an industrial estate in India.
Perhaps you should have a word with Mr Roland Perry who introduced working >>> from home as if it were the key factor in deciding to use remote
management.
It was a metaphor, to contrast with "working on the premises". But we
know you don't understand metaphors.
I understand metaphors.
I also know when it is appropriate to use them and how to avoid making
them red herrings or dragging in a snide remark about an unrelated >controversial issue.
Literary devices have their place but can be problematic in technical >discussions, especially where security is concerned.
There are well known examples of the use of metaphor in security such
as rubber hose cryptanalysis or a steel door in a paper wall but
observe that they are unlikely to be taken literally.
In message <11cmr9v$3a52b$2@dont-email.me>, at 09:33:51 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clofo$3086a$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:39:36 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov >>>>> 2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI >>>>>> agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others - >>>> merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers. The >>>> real threat has always been the people who understand how to exploit the >>>> stupidity of the people who hold the purse strings.
In opinion that analysis is deeply flawed.
Perhaps AI agents are a real new threat because they are less likely to be >>>> impressed by politicians bluster and the arrogant assumption of superiority
by people who have gained positions of influence.
You do have an enormous chip on your shoulder.
Decades of experience and a history of talking in person to real experts
and observing the stupidity of people in positions of authority.
Rather than have that create a chip your shoulder, whose magnitude and visibility will mean almost everyone will completely disregard what you
have to say; why not use that experience to improve the world?
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11cmr9v$3a52b$2@dont-email.me>, at 09:33:51 on Sat, 7 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11clofo$3086a$1@dont-email.me>, at 23:39:36 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Owen Rees <orees@hotmail.com> remarked:
Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <11chig9$1efnj$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:32:55 on Thu, 5 Nov >>>>>> 2026, Martin Brown <'''newspam'''@nonad.co.uk> remarked:
Infrastructure attacks are likely to become commonplace now that AI >>>>>>> agents can be asked to make them and no real skill is required.
"Script kiddies" have been a thing for at least two decades.
They are irrelevant because they merely repeat attacks created by others -
merely copying is what distinguishes script kiddies from real hackers. The
real threat has always been the people who understand how to exploit the >>>>> stupidity of the people who hold the purse strings.
In opinion that analysis is deeply flawed.
Perhaps AI agents are a real new threat because they are less likely to be
impressed by politicians bluster and the arrogant assumption of >>>>>superiority
by people who have gained positions of influence.
You do have an enormous chip on your shoulder.
Decades of experience and a history of talking in person to real experts >>> and observing the stupidity of people in positions of authority.
Rather than have that create a chip your shoulder, whose magnitude and
visibility will mean almost everyone will completely disregard what you
have to say; why not use that experience to improve the world?
People who matter do not disregard what I write.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:53:45 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |