The full judgment here (if the link works) https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6ae882638eaebb6a839ff56b/Sandie_Peggie_v_Royal_College_of_Nursing_-_8001209.2025_-_Final_-_02.11.26_-_PR.pdf
quote from the BBC report:
Peggie (a nurse) objected to sharing a changing room with Dr Upton (a
trans female doctor) at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy and a number
of disagreements over the subject came to a head in December 2023.
The nurse was suspended in January 2024 and took both Dr Upton - who has since left the NHS - and the health board to a long-running and
high-profile tribunal. Peggie partially won a claim for harassment
against NHS Fife last December, but her other allegations of
discrimination and victimisation, including those against Dr Upton, were dismissed.
Peggie holds what are described as "gender critical" or "sex realist"
beliefs that people are born male or female and cannot change sex.
unquote
And quotes from the latest judgment (2nd November):
A substantial amount of evidence was led by the claimant to seek to demonstrate that the respondent had, as an institution, adopted what was described as rCygender identity beliefrCO or rCygender ideologyrCO, and that this institutional position should lead the Tribunal to conclude that
the relevant decision makers were influenced, subconsciously, by that.
The issue is whether the treatment complained of occurred because of the claimant's protected belief. The Tribunal concluded that it was not necessary, in order to determine the issues before it, to make a finding
on whether the respondent, as an organisation,held the asserted
institutional belief. Even if the claimantrCOs contention were
established, that would not, of itself, establish that the relevant
decision makers acted because of the claimant's protected belief.
The Tribunal concluded that SFrCOs actions were not, consciously or subconsciously, influenced by the claimantrCOs protected belief. SF did
not know that the claimant had a protected gender critical/sex realist belief, and did not understand or believe that the respondent had
adopted a position in line with gender ideology.
The full judgment here (if the link works) https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6ae882638eaebb6a839ff56b/Sandie_Peggie_v_Royal_College_of_Nursing_-_8001209.2025_-_Final_-_02.11.26_-_PR.pdf
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's
differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't,
and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions.
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's
differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't,
and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions.
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with
their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their
delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body. Not so much
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
<xxxx>
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's
differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't,
and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion, >one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too.
So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible,
so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to
HR about me?
On 5 Nov 2026 at 20:51:15 GMT, "GB" <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's >>>> differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't,
and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions. >>>
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be
friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion, one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible,
so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to
HR about me?
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion, one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's
name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the
name and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane
(she/her).
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>compulsion,My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns. >>
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
Funny in the sense that the two words can have very different meanings beyond >their literal definitions in practice.
For some people, 'wife' carries connotations of being owned and tasked with >mundane and unskilled aspects of the relationship. Connotations not usually >levelled at men. And some women don't like that.
That said, context is all.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
On 05/11/2026 22:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 20:51:15 GMT, "GB" <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote: >>> On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's >>>>> differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their
rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't, >>>> and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions. >>>
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be >>> friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion, one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own
preferred pronouns.
Same here.
And I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the name
and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane (she/her).
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
<xxxx>
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they
regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible,
so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going >> around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to
HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying
"but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
On 5 Nov 2026 at 23:50:10 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
There is an argument that affirming a desire to change sex, even in
children too young to have any understanding of what it means, has
become too much the norm, rather than counselling alternatives.
Indeed, it is being proposed that it should become illegal to even
suggest alternatives.
There is a difference between sexual orientation (which is a human preference) for which oppressive conversion therapy is rightly
condemned, and choice of bodily sex, which is actually impossible to
change in any satisfactory way.
On 2026-11-06, The Todal <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 22:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 20:51:15 GMT, "GB" <NOTsomeone@microsoft.invalid> wrote: >>>> On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other people's >>>>>> differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with their >>>>>> rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they aren't, >>>>> and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their delusions. >>>>
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be >>>> friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to >>>> put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion, one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own
preferred pronouns.
Same here.
And I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's
name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the name
and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane (she/her).
You do understand that the reason people do that is normalisation, right?
So that someone who *does* need to put their preferred pronouns because
they are perhaps not so obvious isn't immediately marked out (even via
email) as being weird and different?
(I'm not saying you have to do it yourself. I'm just saying that gender-conforming cis people doing it is not pointless.)
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they >>> regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible, >>> so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going >>> around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to >>> HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying
"but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they >>>> regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible, >>>> so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going >>>> around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to >>>> HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying
"but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone
using them in real life is approximately zero.
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they >>>> regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible, >>>> so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going >>>> around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to >>>> HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying
"but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone
using them in real life is approximately zero.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>compulsion,My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns. >>
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, which people >have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the third >person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put
up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a
big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like
"misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying
"but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone
using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
On 05/11/2026 22:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns.
Same here.
And I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the name
and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane (she/her).
In message <11ck6mm$2d1ll$1@dont-email.me>, at 09:29:59 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
Funny in the sense that the two words can have very different meanings
beyond
their literal definitions in practice.
For some people, 'wife' carries connotations of being owned and tasked
with
mundane and unskilled aspects of the relationship. Connotations not
usually
levelled at men. And some women don't like that.
That said, context is all.
In my case it's down to recognition in the public realm.
There's a lady currently featuring in every news broadcast today as
"Russell Brand's wife", for example. But she must have her own name.
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, 6
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, which
people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In other news, my late wife subscribed to the view: "She, who is 'she',
the cat's grandmother?"
And I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the name
and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane (she/her).
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 5 Nov 2026 at 23:50:10 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu>
wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
There is an argument that affirming a desire to change sex, even in
children too young to have any understanding of what it means, has
become too much the norm, rather than counselling alternatives.
"An argument", sure, but not a good one.
Indeed, it is being proposed that it should become illegal to even
suggest alternatives.
No it isn't.
There is a difference between sexual orientation (which is a human
preference) for which oppressive conversion therapy is rightly
condemned, and choice of bodily sex, which is actually impossible to
change in any satisfactory way.
That is simply false, given the large number of people who have done
this "impossible" thing and been satisfied with the results.
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu>
wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>>>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put
up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone
using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
On 06/11/2026 09:20, The Todal wrote:
And I am mildly irritated when I see an email signed off with a person's
name followed by their preferred pronouns. Especially when both the name
and the preferred pronouns are plainly as expected, eg Jane (she/her).
Charles (we/us)?
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:There is a someone in the public entertainment sector who went through a
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have
to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to
someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
Quite so. And if the trans person is friendly, competent and hardworking
it is very mean spirited to follow them to the toilets and loudly berate them for using what you firmly believe is the "wrong" toilet.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 08:18:58 GMT, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too.
No, it doesn't. It's a bit like saying 'why isn't there Straight Pride'.
So if I refer to a
transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but what they
regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put up with my foible,
so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big deal about it by going >> around using stupid invented words like "misgendering" and complaining to
HR about me?
I think your colleagues might find you to be a rude and ignorant member of staff. At best.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:55:35 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put >>>>>>> up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice. >>>>>>
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the >>>>>> other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having >>>>> to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so >>>>> if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone >>>> using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
I think you are a little confused. I think of the essence of gender
critical beliefs is that men or women (or indeed boys or girls) should
be allowed to adopt any dress or cultural behaviours of the opposite
sex without having to change sex in order to do so.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:55:35 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put >>>>>>> up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice. >>>>>>
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the >>>>>> other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having >>>>> to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so >>>>> if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone >>>> using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
I think you are a little confused. I think of the essence of gender critical beliefs is that men or women (or indeed boys or girls) should be allowed to adopt any dress or cultural behaviours of the opposite sex without having to change sex in order to do so. But obviously this does not include things that are only possible for one sex, and does not include oppressive or harassing behaviour toward other people.
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:55:35 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu>
wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but >>>>>>>> what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put >>>>>>>> up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice. >>>>>>>
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the >>>>>>> other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having >>>>>> to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so >>>>>> if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem >>>>> to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone >>>>> using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
I think you are a little confused. I think of the essence of gender
critical beliefs is that men or women (or indeed boys or girls) should
be allowed to adopt any dress or cultural behaviours of the opposite
sex without having to change sex in order to do so.
I think you are greatly confused, if you think that's what "gender
critical" people believe.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 14:57:39 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:55:35 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having >>>>>>> to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so >>>>>>> if that is what they wanted.
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but >>>>>>>>> what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put >>>>>>>>> up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice. >>>>>>>>
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the >>>>>>>> other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?" >>>>>>>
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because >>>>>> I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem >>>>>> to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone >>>>>> using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be >>>>> allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
I think you are a little confused. I think of the essence of gender
critical beliefs is that men or women (or indeed boys or girls) should
be allowed to adopt any dress or cultural behaviours of the opposite
sex without having to change sex in order to do so.
I think you are greatly confused, if you think that's what "gender
critical" people believe.
It is certainly what the most famous billionaire litigious author I
can think of is on record as saying.
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned with
their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour their
delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone
with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big
deal about it?
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu>
wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically >>>>>>> small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put
up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice.
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the
other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having
to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so
if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone
using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
<xxxx>
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending.
It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
On 05/11/2026 23:50, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
Well, I would genuinely like to be taller, always have. But I'm not.
Jon Ribbens <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 11:01:03 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> >>> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 09:22:32 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>> On 06/11/2026 08:18, Handsome Jack wrote:
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 20:51:15 +0000, GB wrote:
But at work you mostly just have to
put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to someone >>>>>>>> with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a microscopically
small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a big >>>>>>>> deal about it?
Presumably this works the other way around too. So if I refer to a >>>>>>> transgender person with what I regard as the right pronoun, but
what they regard as the wrong pronoun, then they should just put >>>>>>> up with my foible, so as to preserve a happy workplace. Why make a >>>>>>> big deal about it by going around using stupid invented words like >>>>>>> "misgendering" and complaining to HR about me?
If the misgendering is inadvertent an apology would surely suffice. >>>>>>
If it is part of a deliberate strategy to belittle or humiliate the >>>>>> other person, it would be rather like calling you "fatty" and saying >>>>>> "but he is fat, so why make a fuss about my friendly nickname?"
I agree that is pretty straightforward. It is less convincing having >>>>> to adopt non-binary pronouns. Though in practice I would try to do so >>>>> if that is what they wanted.
Do you mean just saying "they", or neopronouns like "xie"? Because
I don't think you need to worry too much about the latter - they seem
to exist exclusively on Tumblr, and the chances of bumping into someone >>>> using them in real life is approximately zero.
The idea that you need to belong to a special, esoteric gender to be
allowed to dress or behave in a certain way seems ultimately very
conformist and restrictive of the rest of us.
Be careful, such "gender critical" beliefs that you are criticising
here have been adjudged "worthy of respect in a democratic society".
You wouldn't want to get sued by a billionaire.
How Marxist of them.
On 2026-11-06, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 23:50, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
Well, I would genuinely like to be taller, always have. But I'm not.
Quite apart from the fact that you could in fact get surgery to make you taller if you really wanted, thinking that there's any comparison between gender dysphoria and "it might be nice to be taller" simply betrays an
almost total lack of understanding of the subject.
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri,
6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5 >>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", >>>> although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone,
which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the
third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
On 2026-11-06, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 23:50, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
Well, I would genuinely like to be taller, always have. But I'm not.
Quite apart from the fact that you could in fact get surgery to make you taller if you really wanted, thinking that there's any comparison between gender dysphoria and "it might be nice to be taller" simply betrays an
almost total lack of understanding of the subject.
On 6 Nov 2026 at 16:34:13 GMT, "Jon Ribbens" <jon+usenet@unequivocal.eu> wrote:
On 2026-11-06, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 23:50, Jon Ribbens wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Simon Simple <nothanks@nottoday.co.uk> wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just pretending. >>>>>> It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Yes. Maybe the mind needs changing rather than the body.
Oh, if only someone had thought of that before! You may just have
completely changed the lives of millions of people! Amazing! And
to think, we were all here to witness this historical moment.
Well, I would genuinely like to be taller, always have. But I'm not.
Quite apart from the fact that you could in fact get surgery to make you
taller if you really wanted, thinking that there's any comparison between
gender dysphoria and "it might be nice to be taller" simply betrays an
almost total lack of understanding of the subject.
Whether it is comparable is actually a matter of opinion.
And surgery to make you taller takes years, makes you disabled for a substantial fraction of the time, doesn't actually make you bigger or stronger or a different person, and has serious short term and long
term risks of complications.
There's a lady currently featuring in every news broadcast today as >>"Russell Brand's wife", for example. But she must have her own name.
She's "Mrs Russell Brand".
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
Not if the sex of the individual is known.
In message <11ckln6$2ilc0$1@dont-email.me>, at 13:46:14 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Max Demian <max_demian@bigfoot.com> remarked:
-aThere's a lady currently featuring in every news broadcast today as
"Russell Brand's wife", for example. But she must have her own name.
She's "Mrs Russell Brand".
That's an archaic nomenclature, which many would object to.
Calling me "Mr Jenifer Perry" would be bizarre.
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri,
6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5 >>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", >>>> although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone,
which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the
third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
On 05/11/2026 21:05, The Todal wrote:I absolutely agree.
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
There is a someone in the public entertainment sector who went through aTrans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just
have to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring
to someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
Quite so. And if the trans person is friendly, competent and
hardworking it is very mean spirited to follow them to the toilets and
loudly berate them for using what you firmly believe is the "wrong"
toilet.
sex change a few years ago and now lives as a woman. Unless you already
knew she is transgender, you wouldn't know.-a Does she now have to use
male toilets to assign with her male birth sex?-a Strictly speaking yes,
but she would be an idiot if she did.-a Half the men would be swooning
over her.
She's doing no harm, living out her life as she wants to, and is a
danger to no one.
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned
with their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour
their delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Lots of people have a hard time. Some spend their lives in gaol, as they don't conform to society's norms.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have
to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to
someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
And if he claims to be Napoleon, I have to address him as "your imperial majesty"?
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. IFair enough, but as I'm sure you're aware, it's not a new thing by many centuries, and is used by many authors. IOW, it's not incorrect.
prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem,
just in the interests of clarity.
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri,
6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5 >>>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:There is of course a difference between how you address someone,
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun
compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", >>>>> although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world. >>>>
which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the
third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they
were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't present".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I
prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem,
just in the interests of clarity.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri,
6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>>
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5 >>>>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:There is of course a difference between how you address someone,
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred
pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", >>>>>> although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world. >>>>>
which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the
third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they
were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't
present".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I
prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem,
just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>>>"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5 >>>>>>> Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:There is of course a difference between how you address someone,
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife", >>>>>>> although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world. >>>>>>
which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they
were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't
present".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I
prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem,
just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but the singular is also ambiguous.
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>>>>"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>> which people
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world. >>>>>>>
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't
present".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I
prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem,
just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but >> the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had
been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly
looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic
about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned
with their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour
their delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Lots of people have a hard time. Some spend their lives in gaol, as they don't conform to society's norms.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have
to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to
someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
And if he claims to be Napoleon, I have to address him as "your imperial majesty"?
On 06/11/2026 12:34, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned
with their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour
their delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Lots of people have a hard time. Some spend their lives in gaol, as they
don't conform to society's norms.
Well, it's good that you haven't challenged my main point, namely that
trans people are not just pretending.
Homosexuals used to be gaoled. Do you think that should be brought back?
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just have
to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring to
someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
And if he claims to be Napoleon, I have to address him as "your imperial
majesty"?
Can you explain why you'd refuse to call him that?
As a supplementary question, suppose that you are a long-standing
employee and the Napoleon person is a new recruit, who has been hired
with great difficulty because of his special expertise that is needed to
save the company from certain ruin. Would you put your personal
preferences above the needs of the company? Would you risk the jobs of
all your work colleagues by upsetting the new recruit, or would there be limits to your selfishness?
On 06/11/2026 12:34, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
On 05/11/2026 17:22, Max Demian wrote:
On 05/11/2026 09:31, GB wrote:
On 04/11/2026 23:56, JNugent wrote:
"gender ideology"?
Dear God...
Don't we need people just to grow up and be tolerant of other
people's differences? It seems that people are far too concerned
with their rights, rather than their obligations.
It would be better if people stopped pretending to be what they
aren't, and, in particular, stopped insisting that others honour
their delusions.
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
Lots of people have a hard time. Some spend their lives in gaol, as
they don't conform to society's norms.
Well, it's good that you haven't challenged my main point, namely that
trans people are not just pretending.
Homosexuals used to be gaoled. Do you think that should be brought back?
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose to
be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just
have to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring
to someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy workplace.
Why make a big deal about it?
And if he claims to be Napoleon, I have to address him as "your
imperial majesty"?
Can you explain why you'd refuse to call him that?
As a supplementary question, suppose that you are a long-standing
employee and the Napoleon person is a new recruit, who has been hired
with great difficulty because of his special expertise that is needed to save the company from certain ruin. Would you put your personal
preferences above the needs of the company? Would you risk the jobs of
all your work colleagues by upsetting the new recruit, or would there be limits to your selfishness?
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:49:56 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they >>>>> were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't >>>>> present".
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote: >>>>>>>>"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>>> which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I >>>>> prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem, >>>>> just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but >>> the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had
been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been
abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly
looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic
about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But
nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
And yet you don't regard wanting to be an approximation to the opposite sex to
the one you are born with, as opposed to preferring the cultural attributes normally linked to the opposite sex, is an affectation?
to identify with the traditional social roles of either sex is a perfectly reasonable aspiration, though I would not personally wish to tell anyone else about my preference.
I think there enough people around with deep psychological difficulties to make being non-binary a fairly weak indicator of poor employability.
On 07/11/2026 16:06, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:49:56 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote: >>>>
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they >>>>>> were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't >>>>>> present".
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>>>> which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I >>>>>> prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem, >>>>>> just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but
the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had
been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been >>> abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly
looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic
about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But
nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
And yet you don't regard wanting to be an approximation to the opposite sex to
the one you are born with, as opposed to preferring the cultural attributes >> normally linked to the opposite sex, is an affectation?
No, I don't regard that as an affectation. Arguably it could be
categorised as a mental illness but the mainstream specialists do not
think it should be regarded as such in the DSM handbook. As you
presumably know.
And transgender (or transsexual) people have the protection of our laws. Whereas those who claim to be nonbinary and to insist on gender-neutral pronouns have no protection under our laws.
I think not wanting
to identify with the traditional social roles of either sex is a perfectly >> reasonable aspiration, though I would not personally wish to tell anyone else
about my preference.
It is reasonable in the sense of not connoting insanity.
I think there enough people around with deep psychological difficulties to >> make being non-binary a fairly weak indicator of poor employability.
In a client-facing job, a tendency to keep correcting clients or indeed members of the public about mistakes you claim they have made about your pronouns, would generally make you a major pain in the arse and a
liability to the smooth running of your employer's business. If you can ignore the pronouns and become an efficient and hardworking employee,
that would of course count for a lot. But if I was interviewing a pronoun-obsessive, I would find a way of preferring a different candidate.
On 07/11/2026 16:06, Roger Hayter wrote:Persons undergoing gender reassignment are protected against discrimination
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:49:56 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote: >>>>
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they >>>>>> were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't >>>>>> present".
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to >>>>>>>>>> her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>>>> which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it
difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I >>>>>> prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem, >>>>>> just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but
the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had
been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been >>> abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly
looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic
about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But
nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
And yet you don't regard wanting to be an approximation to the opposite sex to
the one you are born with, as opposed to preferring the cultural attributes >> normally linked to the opposite sex, is an affectation?
No, I don't regard that as an affectation. Arguably it could be
categorised as a mental illness but the mainstream specialists do not
think it should be regarded as such in the DSM handbook. As you
presumably know.
And transgender (or transsexual) people have the protection of our laws. Whereas those who claim to be nonbinary and to insist on gender-neutral pronouns have no protection under our laws.
snip
On 7 Nov 2026 at 20:01:53 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 16:06, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:49:56 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote: >>>>>
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>>>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they >>>>>>> were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't >>>>>>> present".
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>>>>> which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it >>>>>>> difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I >>>>>>> prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem, >>>>>>> just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but
the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had >>>> been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been >>>> abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly >>>> looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic >>>> about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But >>>> nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
And yet you don't regard wanting to be an approximation to the opposite sex to
the one you are born with, as opposed to preferring the cultural attributes >>> normally linked to the opposite sex, is an affectation?
No, I don't regard that as an affectation. Arguably it could be
categorised as a mental illness but the mainstream specialists do not
think it should be regarded as such in the DSM handbook. As you
presumably know.
And transgender (or transsexual) people have the protection of our laws.
Whereas those who claim to be nonbinary and to insist on gender-neutral
pronouns have no protection under our laws.
I think not wanting
to identify with the traditional social roles of either sex is a perfectly >>> reasonable aspiration, though I would not personally wish to tell anyone else
about my preference.
It is reasonable in the sense of not connoting insanity.
I think there enough people around with deep psychological difficulties to >>> make being non-binary a fairly weak indicator of poor employability.
In a client-facing job, a tendency to keep correcting clients or indeed
members of the public about mistakes you claim they have made about your
pronouns, would generally make you a major pain in the arse and a
liability to the smooth running of your employer's business. If you can
ignore the pronouns and become an efficient and hardworking employee,
that would of course count for a lot. But if I was interviewing a
pronoun-obsessive, I would find a way of preferring a different candidate.
Since third party pronouns would normally only be used in the principal's absence it may not be as big a problem as we think; unless others' habitually tell tales.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 20:01:53 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote:
On 07/11/2026 16:06, Roger Hayter wrote:Persons undergoing gender reassignment are protected against discrimination in some circumstances, chiefly (that I can think of) in employment or the provision of services.
On 7 Nov 2026 at 15:49:56 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>
On 07/11/2026 13:39, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 7 Nov 2026 at 13:36:49 GMT, "Roger Hayter" <roger@hayter.org> wrote: >>>>>
On 7 Nov 2026 at 12:58:59 GMT, "The Todal" <the_todal@icloud.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 06/11/2026 13:22, Simon Simple wrote:
On 06/11/2026 11:29, Roland Perry wrote:But how about "the three siblings shared a house with their father. Tom >>>>>>> said they were regularly abused by them. The father denied that they >>>>>>> were abusing Tom but said that they might have been when they weren't >>>>>>> present".
In message <6125572633.b78470dd@uninhabited.net>, at 10:34:15 on Fri, >>>>>>>>> 6 Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:"They" is a perfectly acceptable gender-neutral pronoun.
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun >>>>>>>>>>>> compulsion,
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred >>>>>>>>>>>> pronouns.
My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, >>>>>>>>>> which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the >>>>>>>>>> third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about. >>>>>>>>>
Indeed we all do it.
"Mum, there's someone at the door for you!"
"OK, ask them what they want".
In other words, the scope for ambiguity and confusion can make it >>>>>>> difficult to make sense of an important set of events.
I am not willing to use they/them when referring to an individual. I >>>>>>> prefer to use the person's name, however cumbersome that might seem, >>>>>>> just in the interests of clarity.
Surely that is simply a result of using pronouns, not the particular pronouns
used! Certainly if all the relevant parties are of the same sex.
Ok, there's a further ambiguity as to the number of people referred to, but
the singular is also ambiguous.
You get closer to clarity if you avoid they/them. Tom said that he had >>>> been abused: that would mean Tom was abused. Tom said that they had been >>>> abused: that could be him, one of his siblings, all of them.
I am afraid that I actually have no sympathy for those who claim to
prefer nonbinary pronouns and claim to be offended if she, who plainly >>>> looks female, is described as she and not they.
It strikes me as an affectation. I don't think I would be enthusiastic >>>> about giving such a person a responsible job if I were an employer. But >>>> nevertheless I would always show the person respect by using their
preferred pronouns and preferably their name instead.
And yet you don't regard wanting to be an approximation to the opposite sex to
the one you are born with, as opposed to preferring the cultural attributes >>> normally linked to the opposite sex, is an affectation?
No, I don't regard that as an affectation. Arguably it could be
categorised as a mental illness but the mainstream specialists do not
think it should be regarded as such in the DSM handbook. As you
presumably know.
And transgender (or transsexual) people have the protection of our laws.
Whereas those who claim to be nonbinary and to insist on gender-neutral
pronouns have no protection under our laws.
snip
Misgendering is probably not discrimination if an employer or service provider
cannot influence it, but might, for instance, be harassment. I suspect non-binary persons are more or less equally protected from harassment.
On 06/11/2026 13:20, John wrote:m for using what you firmly believe is the
On 05/11/2026 21:05, The Todal wrote:
On 05/11/2026 20:51, GB wrote:
Trans people have a really hard time, and they are not just
pretending. It's a deep-set difference between mind and body.
You can choose your friends, and it seems that you wouldn't choose
to be friends with a transgender person. But at work you mostly just
have to put up with other peoples' foibles. If that means referring
to someone with (what you regard as) the wrong pronoun, it seems a
microscopically small concession so as to preserve a happy
workplace. Why make a big deal about it?
Quite so. And if the trans person is friendly, competent and
hardworking it is very mean spirited to follow them to the toilets
and loudly berate the
in the public entertainment sector who went through"wrong" toilet.
There is a someone
a sex change a few years ago and now lives as a woman. Unless you
already knew she is transgender, you wouldn't know.-a Does she now have
to use male toilets to assign with her male birth sex?-a Strictly
speaking yes, but she would be an idiot if she did.-a Half the men
would be swooning over her.
She's doing no harm, living out her life as she wants to, and is a
danger to no one.
I absolutely agree.
There's a separate issue in sports, where trans people may have an in-
built advantage.
Misgendering is probably not discrimination if an employer or
service provider cannot influence it, but might, for instance, be >>harassment. I suspect non-binary persons are more or less equally >>protected from harassment.
I think everyone is protected from harassment.
On 07/11/2026 08:35, Roland Perry wrote:
In message <11ckln6$2ilc0$1@dont-email.me>, at 13:46:14 on Fri, 6 Nov
2026, Max Demian <max_demian@bigfoot.com> remarked:
-aThere's a lady currently featuring in every news broadcast today as >>>> "Russell Brand's wife", for example. But she must have her own name.
She's "Mrs Russell Brand".
That's an archaic nomenclature, which many would object to.
Calling me "Mr Jenifer Perry" would be bizarre.
It would be inaccurate, as Mr is short for "master". Mrs (or, for that matter, Miss) is short for "mistress", so "Mrs Russell Brand" means "mistress of Russell Brand".
(I suppose "Mr Jenifer Perry" could mean "master of Jenifer Perry", but that's not an accepted usage.)
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion,My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns. >>
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, which people have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the third person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
On 2026-11-06, Roger Hayter wrote:
On 6 Nov 2026 at 03:18:22 GMT, "Roland Perry" <roland@perry.uk> wrote:
In message <1836425996.7b38cf47@uninhabited.net>, at 22:39:24 on Thu, 5
Nov 2026, Roger Hayter <roger@hayter.org> remarked:
Without prejudice to any opinion I may or may not have on pronoun compulsion,My late wife used to get very cross with people who (mainly wrote to
one thing I absolutely refuse to do is specify my own preferred pronouns. >>>
her) using "Ms", rather then "Mrs".
And even more cross with people who referred to her as "Roland's wife",
although I was very happy to be "Jennifer's husband". Funny old world.
There is of course a difference between how you address someone, which people
have legitimate preferences about, and how you refer to them in the third
person. Which is what current pronoun preferences seem to be about.
If we work together and I repeatedly refer to you using a nickname I
know you particularly dislike (without using it *to* you), would you
consider that acceptable behaviour? How about referring to you as
she/her when you want to be he/him?
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 61:53:24 |
| Calls: | 1,266 |
| Calls today: | 2 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
5 files (9,643K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,375 |