• Re: Planning and Mental Health

    From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 5 17:06:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 06:44:11 +0000, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> wrote:

    In message <snlhel9re234b62tml0vvu32c7kc8gpgjl@4ax.com>, at 20:50:37 on
    Mon, 2 Nov 2026, Mark Goodge <usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk>
    remarked:

    This may sound like pedantry, but it's not. Like practically every >>profession and bureaucratic system, planning is chock full of jargon and >>buzzwords (although, unlike education, it's refreshingly free of TLAs). >>"Residential amenity" is one such term. It's not defined anywhere in >>legislation or the NPPF,

    presumably an FLA

    ETLA.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 5 17:23:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 08:35:39 -0000 (UTC), RJH <patchmoney@gmx.com> wrote:

    On 2 Nov 2026 at 20:50:37 GMT, Mark Goodge wrote:

    There's no such thing as "loss of residential amenity".

    It has now been established (partly by your good self) that there IS.

    There is no such *thing* as "residential amenity". It's just a catch-all
    term for a number of individual things which happen to fall into a
    convenient grouping.

    When does this 'loss of amenity' - amenity taken to mean useful feature - >become sufficiently substantial to affect the planners' decision?

    It depends on what the specific amenity is, and how strong the effect is.

    'Loss of view' was the one I remember as *not* sufficient. But blocked light >is?

    Yes. There's no entitlement to a particular view from your property. A lot
    of people who live on what is currently the edge of town will object to a
    new housing development which extends the built-up area on the basis that
    they will no longer have a view across open fields. But that's not a thing
    they have a right to in the first place. But loss of light via overshadowing
    is a material consideration, because people do have a right to have a reasonably expected amount of natural light on their premises.

    That said, although loss of view from a specific property is not a material consideration, a change in the view from the surrounding area as a whole is.
    If an online retailer wanted to build a warehouse near a town, individual householders within sight of the warehouse would not be able to object on
    the basis that they can now see a warehouse instead of beyond it to the
    woods and fields. But the fact that the warehouse is a significant change to overall appearance of the area would be a valid reason to object. That,
    though, wouldn't be filed under "residential amentity". It would go under "visual amenity", instead.

    I'd assume the decision rests on a combination of number of those affected, >and what the loss actually is. Seems incredibly vague and open to abuse . . .

    Determining planning applications is, essentially, a balancing act. You
    stack up all the reasons in favour of approval, and stack up all the reasons
    in favour of refusal, and the biggest pile wins. But reasons, both for and against, are not equal. An objection from the highway authority, or the fire authority, is a weightier objection than the parish council not being keen
    on it.

    Assessing the weight of various objections and supporting statements is a
    key part of the role of the planning officer when drafting their report.
    They have to ensure that they don't treat a minor objection as a major objection, and vice versa. Like a lawyer dealing with case law when drafting
    a claim or defence, a planning officer is expected to be familiar with
    relevant decisions by the planning inspectorate that shed light on the weighting assigned to different factors.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Goodge@usenet@listmail.good-stuff.co.uk to uk.legal.moderated on Thu Nov 5 17:30:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: uk.legal.moderated

    On Tue, 03 Nov 2026 11:52:10 +0000, JNugent <JNugent73@mail.com> wrote:

    On 02/11/2026 08:50 PM, Mark Goodge wrote:

    The number of times
    I've seen objections to planning applications based on "loss of residential >> amenity" which are then summarised in the planning officer's report as "A
    number of objectors referred to loss of residential amenity but without
    providing any evidence to support this claim". Without describing the actual >> effect that you are concerned about, an objection to "loss of residential
    amnity" is meaningless. But if you do describe an actual effect that you are >> objecting to, then you don't need to try to do the planning officer's work >> for them by categorising it as "loss of residential amenity" (especially
    given that it might actually come under some other general heading).


    People (eg, affected neighbours) put forward their objections in
    whatever format they feel comfortable with. No-one putting in an
    objection is expected to be an expert on planning and building control. >Assessment is for the officers to do. Or, eventually, a committee of >councillors.

    But people do object based on "loss of residential amenity", as if that statement alone has weight. It's a common theme in neighbour objections.
    People write things like "The proposed development will result in severe
    loss of residential amenity to me and my neighbours". But that's completely meaningless, and will be completely ignored. If, though, they said something like "The proposed development will cause the bottom of my garden to be in shade after 3pm", or "the proposed development will lead to a significant increase in noise" then that is a valid objection, and will be taken into account, because it relates directly to a relevant consideration. You have
    to say what the actual issue is, not use planning jargon as if it was an
    issue in itself.

    Mark

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2