We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid future problems.
Richard
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid future problems.
Richard
On 11/11/2026 09:38, Tricky Dicky wrote:
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire
Water our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned
kitchen refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the
best approach, do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard
water areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after
looking at the crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern
and having to replace the shower controls for the same reason I
feel we need to do something to avoid future problems.
RichardWe've had various water softeners since we moved into this house 49
years ago. Certainly a worthwhile investment
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the >crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the >shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid >future problems.
Richard
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 09:38:02 -0000 (UTC), Tricky Dicky <tricky.dicky@sky.com> wrote:
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach, >> do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the
crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the >> shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid >> future problems.
Richard
'Hardness' is a result of dissolved salts, calcium and to a lesser
extent magnesium, in the water. A filter will achieve nothing. The
salts will just pass straight through. You need a proper water
softener system.
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid future problems.
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no
idea.
On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no idea.
I have seen toilets shower heads and taps almost completely blocked by scale
For me its a no brainer to install one
On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no
idea.
I have seen toilets shower heads and taps almost completely blocked by scale
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to replace the shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to avoid future problems.
Richard
On 11/11/2026 14:01, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no
idea.
I have seen toilets shower heads and taps almost completely blocked by scale
Then you've been unlucky. I've lived in 100mg/l+ calcium level water supplies for 50+years and never had a problem which wasn't resolved with
use of a weak acid and sometimes a bit of elbow grease.
> For me its a no brainer to install one
Sure, if you've got a spare -u500+ for the unit plus installation cost if it's not DIY, and around -u1/kg for the salt.
On 11/11/2026 14:01, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no
idea.
I have seen toilets shower heads and taps almost completely blocked by
scale
Then you've been unlucky. I've lived in 100mg/l+ calcium level water supplies for 50+years and never had a problem which wasn't resolved with
use of a weak acid and sometimes a bit of elbow grease.
For me its a no brainer to install one
Sure, if you've got a spare -u500+ for the unit plus installation cost if it's not DIY, and-a around -u1/kg for the salt.
On 11/11/2026 09:38, Tricky Dicky wrote:
We recently moved into a hard water area and according to Yorkshire Water
our water on average has 105.3mg/l of Calcium. With a planned kitchen
refurb in the Spring sometime I am looking into what is the best
approach,
do we go for filters or install a water softener?
I would be interested in any advice from members living in hard water
areas. There is no adverse taste to the water but after looking at the
crustiness that accumulated in the toilet cistern and having to
replace the
shower controls for the same reason I feel we need to do something to
avoid
future problems.
According to our water supplier, the hardness in our area is 116mg/l of calcium. Note that if you use other online hardness checkers you might
get slightly different figures.
<https://mytapwater.co.uk/>: 289.7 mg/l CaCOrea
<https://waterhard.uk/>: 250 ppm (not otherwise specified) <https://filterflair.co.uk/pages/uk-water-hardness-map>: 292 ppm calcium carbonate
<https://www.tapwater.uk/guides/water-hardness-map>: 276 mg of limescale minerals
(Note that 40% of calcium carbonate is calcium)
We've been here over 15 years and although the limescale is unsightly,
and, by the way, is unfortunately a much better substrate for mould than porcelain, I've never felt the need for a water softener. Fairly regular
use of a limescale remover is sufficient (citric acid crystals are
probably the cheapest and are very effective as a hot saturated
solution). We have never suffered any physical damage from limescale,
such as blocked pipes.
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost
of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no
idea.
On the plus side, the water supplied has a large artesian content, and
it contains trace elements like copper, zinc and magnesium alongside the chemicals that mytapwater identifies, so I am reluctant to use a
softener that might remove the health giving contents alongside the
hardness reduction.
Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 11/11/2026 14:01, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 11/11/2026 13:45, Jeff Layman wrote:
How much you'd save in soap and detergent, and possibly the cost of
power for heating washing machines and boilers against the capital cost >>>> of a water softener, and recurring cost for softening salts, I have no >>>> idea.
I have seen toilets shower heads and taps almost completely blocked by scale
Then you've been unlucky. I've lived in 100mg/l+ calcium level water
supplies for 50+years and never had a problem which wasn't resolved with
use of a weak acid and sometimes a bit of elbow grease.
> For me its a no brainer to install one
Sure, if you've got a spare -u500+ for the unit plus installation cost if
it's not DIY, and around -u1/kg for the salt.
I installed a deionising cartridge for my central heating. It was about -u20 for the filter housing and -u10 for the cartridge. No idea how long they last as the CH only rarely gets its water replaced.
Bulk DI resin is about -u3/litre. I can't seem to find any datasheet saying how much water a litre of resin will deionise.
https://finest-filters.co.uk/collections/di-resin
On 11/11/2026 15:33, Theo wrote:
I installed a deionising cartridge for my central heating. It was about -u20 for the filter housing and -u10 for the cartridge. No idea how long they last as the CH only rarely gets its water replaced.
As it's effectively a closed system, other than for the very occasional top-up, there would seem to be no advantage in using a deioniser. That's especially true as it usually runs at a lowish temperature (around
60-#C?) where the possibility of limescale formation is reduced. By the
way, trying to find information relating to temperature change and
limescale formation wasn't easy. I could only find one page which stated
"In hot-water systems, practically precipitation of calcium carbonate, CaCO3, starts to occur at approximately 35-#C to 40-#C (or as pressure drops), and progressively worsens as temperatures rise".
Bulk DI resin is about -u3/litre. I can't seem to find any datasheet saying
how much water a litre of resin will deionise.
https://finest-filters.co.uk/collections/di-resin
+1
Trying to find decent quantitative information in this area is a challenge.
On 11/11/2026 23:51, Indy Jess John wrote:
On the plus side, the water supplied has a large artesian content, and
it contains trace elements like copper, zinc and magnesium alongside
the chemicals that mytapwater identifies, so I am reluctant to use a
softener that might remove the health giving contents alongside the
hardness reduction.
You do not soften the kitchen tap
On 12/11/2026 08:02, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 11/11/2026 23:51, Indy Jess John wrote:
On the plus side, the water supplied has a large artesian content,
and it contains trace elements like copper, zinc and magnesium
alongside the chemicals that mytapwater identifies, so I am
reluctant to use a softener that might remove the health giving
contents alongside the hardness reduction.
You do not soften the kitchen tapFollowing the pipes from the stopcock onwards, there are branches off
the main, one going to washing machine in the utility room, one going
to the downstairs bathroom serving the bath and washbasin and then
through the wall to the outside tap in the garden, one going to the
upstairs toilet and washbasin and also the cold water tank and the
cistern to top up the central heating and then the incoming pipe goes
on to the kitchen sink tap and the dishwasher. Other than fitting
several softeners for each of the branch circuits, I can't see any
way of not softening the kitchen tap but softening everything else.
It is plumbed that way because of the geography of the house. The
water main comes in from the street, and the kitchen sink looks out
onto the back garden.
On 12/11/2026 08:02, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
On 11/11/2026 23:51, Indy Jess John wrote:Following the pipes from the stopcock onwards, there are branches off
On the plus side, the water supplied has a large artesian content,
and it contains trace elements like copper, zinc and magnesium
alongside the chemicals that mytapwater identifies, so I am reluctant
to use a softener that might remove the health giving contents
alongside the hardness reduction.
You do not soften the kitchen tap
the main, one going to washing machine in the utility room, one going to
the downstairs bathroom serving the bath and washbasin and then through
the wall to the outside tap in the garden, one going to the upstairs
toilet and washbasin and also the cold water tank and the cistern to top
up the central heating and then the incoming pipe goes on to the kitchen sink tap and the dishwasher.-a Other than fitting several softeners for
each of the branch circuits, I can't see any way of not softening the kitchen tap but softening everything else.
It is plumbed that way because of the geography of the house.-a The water main comes in from the street, and the kitchen sink looks out onto the
back garden.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:37:44 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |