• Explainging the Great Unconformity

    From Pro Plyd@invalide@invalid.invalid to talk-origins on Sun Nov 8 20:37:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins


    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11156-5
    Published: 04 November 2026


    Abstract
    The Great Unconformity marks a globally
    extensive erosive surface linked to climatic
    shifts and environmental transitions that
    preceded the Cambrian explosion of life. The
    processes proposed to explain the formation
    of the Great Unconformity include glacial
    erosion during the Snowball Earth, rifting
    and plume activity, sea-level fall and
    mantle-driven dynamic topography. However,
    the dynamics of these processes have not
    been tested. Here we show that
    continental-scale uplift and subsidence
    associated with long-wavelength dynamic
    topography due to mantle convection drove
    the formation and preservation of the Great
    Unconformity. Our models predict prolonged
    continental-scale Neoproterozoic uplift and
    long-term Phanerozoic subsidence for Laurentia,
    Baltica and North China. This vertical motion
    scenario is ideal for the formation and
    preservation of the Great Unconformity, which
    is a first-order surface expression of deep
    Earth processes. The predicted prolonged
    continental uplift throughout Cryogenian
    times would have resulted in marked erosion
    due to the action of glaciers. The large area
    of Laurentia and limited deformation at its
    margins explain why the Great Unconformity is
    best preserved and documented there. Our
    models predict cycles of dynamic topography
    that are broadly reflected in preserved
    sediment volume across continents, and
    open new avenues for understanding the
    environments of Cambrian animal
    diversification.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From sticks@wolverine01@charter.net to talk-origins on Mon Nov 9 20:28:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 11/8/2026 9:37 PM, Pro Plyd wrote:

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11156-5
    Published: 04 November 2026


    Abstract
    The Great Unconformity marks a globally
    extensive erosive surface linked to climatic
    shifts and environmental transitions that
    preceded the Cambrian explosion of life. The
    processes proposed to explain the formation
    of the Great Unconformity include glacial
    erosion during the Snowball Earth, rifting
    and plume activity, sea-level fall and
    mantle-driven dynamic topography. However,
    the dynamics of these processes have not
    been tested. Here we show that
    continental-scale uplift and subsidence
    associated with long-wavelength dynamic
    topography due to mantle convection drove
    the formation and preservation of the Great
    Unconformity. Our models predict prolonged
    continental-scale Neoproterozoic uplift and
    long-term Phanerozoic subsidence for Laurentia,
    Baltica and North China. This vertical motion
    scenario is ideal for the formation and
    preservation of the Great Unconformity, which
    is a first-order surface expression of deep
    Earth processes. The predicted prolonged
    continental uplift throughout Cryogenian
    times would have resulted in marked erosion
    due to the action of glaciers. The large area
    of Laurentia and limited deformation at its
    margins explain why the Great Unconformity is
    best preserved and documented there. Our
    models predict cycles of dynamic topography
    that are broadly reflected in preserved
    sediment volume across continents, and
    open new avenues for understanding the
    environments of Cambrian animal
    diversification.

    The biggest problem with this theory is its total dependence on
    "Snowball Earth." While the paper frames the Great Unconformity as a
    "surface expression of deep Earth processes," the authors admit that
    mantle uplift alone could not cause enough water erosion to flatten the continents. Therefore, the entire deep-earth mantle model completely
    falls apart if the highly debated Snowball Earth theory is wrong. From
    what I have been able to find, if Snowball Earth actually did exist, it
    would have killed off the very life forms necessary to bring forth the Cambrian explosion. The Snowball theory is not something I would wager
    much on, and it is a topic where the secular scientists themselves
    remain deeply divided. Ultimately, we are right back to where we
    started. Still unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity materialistically.
    --
    Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kerr-Mudd, John@admin@127.0.0.1 to talk-origins on Tue Nov 10 20:37:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 20:28:08 -0600
    sticks <wolverine01@charter.net> wrote:

    On 11/8/2026 9:37 PM, Pro Plyd wrote:

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11156-5
    Published: 04 November 2026


    Abstract
    The Great Unconformity marks a globally
    extensive erosive surface linked to climatic
    shifts and environmental transitions that
    preceded the Cambrian explosion of life. The
    processes proposed to explain the formation
    of the Great Unconformity include glacial
    erosion during the Snowball Earth, rifting
    and plume activity, sea-level fall and
    mantle-driven dynamic topography. However,
    the dynamics of these processes have not
    been tested. Here we show that
    continental-scale uplift and subsidence
    associated with long-wavelength dynamic
    topography due to mantle convection drove
    the formation and preservation of the Great
    Unconformity. Our models predict prolonged
    continental-scale Neoproterozoic uplift and
    long-term Phanerozoic subsidence for Laurentia,
    Baltica and North China. This vertical motion
    scenario is ideal for the formation and
    preservation of the Great Unconformity, which
    is a first-order surface expression of deep
    Earth processes. The predicted prolonged
    continental uplift throughout Cryogenian
    times would have resulted in marked erosion
    due to the action of glaciers. The large area
    of Laurentia and limited deformation at its
    margins explain why the Great Unconformity is
    best preserved and documented there. Our
    models predict cycles of dynamic topography
    that are broadly reflected in preserved
    sediment volume across continents, and
    open new avenues for understanding the
    environments of Cambrian animal
    diversification.

    The biggest problem with this theory is its total dependence on
    "Snowball Earth." While the paper frames the Great Unconformity as a "surface expression of deep Earth processes," the authors admit that
    mantle uplift alone could not cause enough water erosion to flatten the continents. Therefore, the entire deep-earth mantle model completely
    falls apart if the highly debated Snowball Earth theory is wrong. From
    what I have been able to find, if Snowball Earth actually did exist, it would have killed off the very life forms necessary to bring forth the Cambrian explosion. The Snowball theory is not something I would wager
    much on, and it is a topic where the secular scientists themselves
    remain deeply divided. Ultimately, we are right back to where we
    started. Still unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity materialistically.


    Ok then, you explain it. Why did your God need to do it? and why then?



    --
    Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do

    --
    Bah, and indeed Humbug.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From sticks@wolverine01@charter.net to talk-origins on Tue Nov 10 17:40:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 11/10/2026 2:37 PM, Kerr-Mudd, John wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 20:28:08 -0600
    sticks <wolverine01@charter.net> wrote:

    On 11/8/2026 9:37 PM, Pro Plyd wrote:

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11156-5
    Published: 04 November 2026


    Abstract
    The Great Unconformity marks a globally
    extensive erosive surface linked to climatic
    shifts and environmental transitions that
    preceded the Cambrian explosion of life. The
    processes proposed to explain the formation
    of the Great Unconformity include glacial
    erosion during the Snowball Earth, rifting
    and plume activity, sea-level fall and
    mantle-driven dynamic topography. However,
    the dynamics of these processes have not
    been tested. Here we show that
    continental-scale uplift and subsidence
    associated with long-wavelength dynamic
    topography due to mantle convection drove
    the formation and preservation of the Great
    Unconformity. Our models predict prolonged
    continental-scale Neoproterozoic uplift and
    long-term Phanerozoic subsidence for Laurentia,
    Baltica and North China. This vertical motion
    scenario is ideal for the formation and
    preservation of the Great Unconformity, which
    is a first-order surface expression of deep
    Earth processes. The predicted prolonged
    continental uplift throughout Cryogenian
    times would have resulted in marked erosion
    due to the action of glaciers. The large area
    of Laurentia and limited deformation at its
    margins explain why the Great Unconformity is
    best preserved and documented there. Our
    models predict cycles of dynamic topography
    that are broadly reflected in preserved
    sediment volume across continents, and
    open new avenues for understanding the
    environments of Cambrian animal
    diversification.

    The biggest problem with this theory is its total dependence on
    "Snowball Earth." While the paper frames the Great Unconformity as a
    "surface expression of deep Earth processes," the authors admit that
    mantle uplift alone could not cause enough water erosion to flatten the
    continents. Therefore, the entire deep-earth mantle model completely
    falls apart if the highly debated Snowball Earth theory is wrong. From
    what I have been able to find, if Snowball Earth actually did exist, it
    would have killed off the very life forms necessary to bring forth the
    Cambrian explosion. The Snowball theory is not something I would wager
    much on, and it is a topic where the secular scientists themselves
    remain deeply divided. Ultimately, we are right back to where we
    started. Still unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity
    materialistically.


    Ok then, you explain it. Why did your God need to do it? and why then?


    Does this mean you disagree with my assessment? Why don't you just go
    ahead and tell us where I'm in error then?
    --
    Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Vincent Maycock@maycock@gmail.com to talk-origins on Tue Nov 10 20:45:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 17:40:52 -0600, sticks <wolverine01@charter.net>
    wrote:

    On 11/10/2026 2:37 PM, Kerr-Mudd, John wrote:
    On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 20:28:08 -0600
    sticks <wolverine01@charter.net> wrote:

    On 11/8/2026 9:37 PM, Pro Plyd wrote:

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11156-5
    Published: 04 November 2026


    Abstract
    The Great Unconformity marks a globally
    extensive erosive surface linked to climatic
    shifts and environmental transitions that
    preceded the Cambrian explosion of life. The
    processes proposed to explain the formation
    of the Great Unconformity include glacial
    erosion during the Snowball Earth, rifting
    and plume activity, sea-level fall and
    mantle-driven dynamic topography. However,
    the dynamics of these processes have not
    been tested. Here we show that
    continental-scale uplift and subsidence
    associated with long-wavelength dynamic
    topography due to mantle convection drove
    the formation and preservation of the Great
    Unconformity. Our models predict prolonged
    continental-scale Neoproterozoic uplift and
    long-term Phanerozoic subsidence for Laurentia,
    Baltica and North China. This vertical motion
    scenario is ideal for the formation and
    preservation of the Great Unconformity, which
    is a first-order surface expression of deep
    Earth processes. The predicted prolonged
    continental uplift throughout Cryogenian
    times would have resulted in marked erosion
    due to the action of glaciers. The large area
    of Laurentia and limited deformation at its
    margins explain why the Great Unconformity is
    best preserved and documented there. Our
    models predict cycles of dynamic topography
    that are broadly reflected in preserved
    sediment volume across continents, and
    open new avenues for understanding the
    environments of Cambrian animal
    diversification.

    The biggest problem with this theory is its total dependence on
    "Snowball Earth." While the paper frames the Great Unconformity as a
    "surface expression of deep Earth processes," the authors admit that
    mantle uplift alone could not cause enough water erosion to flatten the
    continents. Therefore, the entire deep-earth mantle model completely
    falls apart if the highly debated Snowball Earth theory is wrong. From
    what I have been able to find, if Snowball Earth actually did exist, it
    would have killed off the very life forms necessary to bring forth the
    Cambrian explosion. The Snowball theory is not something I would wager
    much on, and it is a topic where the secular scientists themselves
    remain deeply divided. Ultimately, we are right back to where we
    started. Still unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity
    materialistically.


    Ok then, you explain it. Why did your God need to do it? and why then?


    Does this mean you disagree with my assessment?

    Yeah, your problem is the wild speculation about supernatural forces
    being responsible for the origin of this unconformity.

    Why don't you just go ahead and tell us where I'm in error then?

    From a more technical perspective, I don't think you need erosion to
    base level in order to have an unconformity. Also, the article cited
    lists some other possibilities that don't rely on a Snowball Earth as
    an explanation for the unconformity.

    Also, there are mechanisms for the preservation of life during the
    Snowball Earth, so that idea per se shouldn't be taken as a criticism
    of this research. Also, it's the crust that undergoes uplift, not the
    mantle.

    And no, you have not escaped from the mantle processes that are too
    slow to have happened over a few thousand years.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From William Hyde@wthyde1953@gmail.com to talk-origins on Wed Nov 11 17:00:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    Vincent Maycock wrote:


    Also, there are mechanisms for the preservation of life during the
    Snowball Earth,


    Observations (e.g. of sand wedges) have shown that there was always open
    water during the most recent snowball event, consistent with our
    modelling results published in 2001 in Nature.

    Whether earlier snowball events were complete is less clear, owing to a
    lack of observations (the situation may have changed in the past few
    years, I am out of touch with this), but an incomplete snowball is still consistent with the models.

    However, even in our late Precambrian simulation, the ice free area of
    the earth was mostly oceans, with a few islands being the only ice free
    land.

    In short, there was at least one and probably several incidents of
    "snowball earth", but at least one of these and possibly all were
    incomplete.

    How this ties in with the unconformity is for others to decide.


    William Hyde

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From sticks@wolverine01@charter.net to talk-origins on Sun Nov 15 16:29:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 11/11/2026 4:00 PM, William Hyde wrote:
    Vincent Maycock wrote:


    Also, there are mechanisms for the preservation of life during the
    Snowball Earth,


    Observations (e.g. of sand wedges) have shown that there was always open water during the most recent snowball event, consistent with our
    modelling results published in 2001 in Nature.

    Whether earlier snowball events were complete is less clear, owing to a
    lack of observations (the situation may have changed in the past few
    years, I am out of touch with this), but an incomplete snowball is still consistent with the models.

    However, even in our late Precambrian simulation, the ice free area of
    the earth was mostly oceans, with a few islands being the only ice free land.

    In short, there was at least one and probably several incidents of
    "snowball earth", but at least one of these and possibly all were incomplete.

    How this ties in with the unconformity is for others to decide.

    Of course Vinny walked right into the trap door I left open for him and
    even hilariously argues against the wording they used for uplift when
    the entire paper speaks of "mantle driven dynamic topography". His
    suggestion that my "problem is the wild speculation about supernatural
    forces being responsible for the origin of this unconformity" is pretty
    funny since I only gave thoughts on the failures of this article and
    offered not a single word on how I felt it happened. I will do the same
    about some further thoughts even though I might disagree.

    But getting back to the snowball earth, I believe what William Hyde is speaking of is what they call "slushball earth." Either way, the problem
    still exists if that is the method used to explain the great
    unconformity, not just any unconformity, with having enough time to
    explain the generation of all the new species fully developed in the
    Cambrian explosion. But that's really a side issue.

    I also left one door available to counter with my last sentence ("Still
    unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity materialistically"
    ), but no one has managed to open it. Dhungana and Flament's whole
    theory depends on snowball earth to perform the glacial grinding
    necessary to form the great unconformity. The reason their theory fails
    is actually hidden in their work and shows some actual deception on
    their part. Not very scientific if you ask me. If you read the article
    you note several references to the 2020 study titled "Diachronous
    development of Great Unconformities before Neoproterozoic Snowball
    Earth," led by geologist Rebecca M. Flowers and published in the
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Though this paper
    actually tries to use the findings of the Flowers work to support their theory, the Flowers study completely destroys it. Basically, Flowers
    gives their evidence that there was no need for the glaciers to scrape
    because the rock was already eroded prior to snowball earth. The Pikes
    Peak granite data seems even to me to prove that conclusively if you
    accept secular assumptions.

    So there is a secular consensus opinion on how the great conformity
    formed even though it is still debated. This paper simply is not one of
    the possibilities.
    --
    Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Vincent Maycock@maycock@gmail.com to talk-origins on Mon Nov 16 09:06:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 16:29:08 -0600, sticks <wolverine01@charter.net>
    wrote:

    On 11/11/2026 4:00 PM, William Hyde wrote:
    Vincent Maycock wrote:


    Also, there are mechanisms for the preservation of life during the
    Snowball Earth,


    Observations (e.g. of sand wedges) have shown that there was always open
    water during the most recent snowball event, consistent with our
    modelling results published in 2001 in Nature.

    Whether earlier snowball events were complete is less clear, owing to a
    lack of observations (the situation may have changed in the past few
    years, I am out of touch with this), but an incomplete snowball is still
    consistent with the models.

    However, even in our late Precambrian simulation, the ice free area of
    the earth was mostly oceans, with a few islands being the only ice free
    land.

    In short, there was at least one and probably several incidents of
    "snowball earth", but at least one of these and possibly all were
    incomplete.

    How this ties in with the unconformity is for others to decide.

    Of course Vinny walked right into the trap door I left open for him and
    even hilariously argues against the wording they used for uplift when
    the entire paper speaks of "mantle driven dynamic topography".

    Dynamic topography refers to the response of the crust to differences
    in the mantle. That's not uplift unless you try to do something weird
    like define mantle convection to be "uplift."

    His suggestion that my "problem is the wild speculation about supernatural >forces being responsible for the origin of this unconformity" is pretty >funny since I only gave thoughts on the failures of this article and
    offered not a single word on how I felt it happened.

    And why is that? Do you accept the teachings of Stephen Meyer's *The
    Return of the God Hypothesis*?

    I will do the same
    about some further thoughts even though I might disagree.

    Again, why is your god so poorly supported by the evidence that it has
    to be called "wild speculation" to refer to him?

    But getting back to the snowball earth, I believe what William Hyde is >speaking of is what they call "slushball earth." Either way, the problem >still exists if that is the method used to explain the great
    unconformity, not just any unconformity, with having enough time to
    explain the generation of all the new species fully developed in the >Cambrian explosion. But that's really a side issue.

    I also left one door available to counter with my last sentence ("Still >unable to genuinely explain the Great Unconformity materialistically"
    ),

    So you don't believe the Great Unconformity formed
    "materialistically." How is that not invoking the supernatural, i.e.,
    purely baseless speculation?

    but no one has managed to open it. Dhungana and Flament's whole
    theory depends on snowball earth to perform the glacial grinding
    necessary to form the great unconformity.

    Glacial erosion is just one of the mechanisms they use to explain the
    erosion in the Great Unconformity.

    The reason their theory fails
    is actually hidden in their work and shows some actual deception on
    their part. Not very scientific if you ask me. If you read the article
    you note several references to the 2020 study titled "Diachronous >development of Great Unconformities before Neoproterozoic Snowball
    Earth," led by geologist Rebecca M. Flowers and published in the
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Though this paper
    actually tries to use the findings of the Flowers work to support their >theory, the Flowers study completely destroys it. Basically, Flowers
    gives their evidence that there was no need for the glaciers to scrape

    There's more to glaciation than just "scraping." Dropstones,
    tillites, and terminal moraines also come to mind.

    because the rock was already eroded prior to snowball earth. The Pikes
    Peak granite data seems even to me to prove that conclusively if you
    accept secular assumptions. So there is a secular consensus opinion on
    how the great conformity formed even though it is still debated.
    This paper simply is not one of the possibilities.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2