I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model and we will
start calling them out by name and we will go after this using the depth
of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model and we will
start calling them out by name and we will go after this using the depth
of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying you
have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model and we
will start calling them out by name and we will go after this using
the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying you
have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model and we
will start calling them out by name and we will go after this using
the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to attack
and minimize before they present anything.
Did you and your acquaintances submit your response to Tour's 60 Day
origin of life challenge?-a You could have removed him from the debate entirely.-a Or, were you too scared then?
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics. One,
his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a
significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has enabled
him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee Cronin, who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., assembly theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient details like chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible seeds of doubt that will bear
fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is a much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from synthetic
organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his own field?
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow consideration
of supernatural agency as the best (or even possible) explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and reputation are on the line. Tour has no
such constraints.
All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to attack
and minimize before they present anything.
On 11/8/26 9:04 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to attack
and minimize before they present anything.
So, is either one of these folks competent in evolutionary biology?
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox
challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics.
One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a
significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has enabled
him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to the
origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't think so. But
I see no sign that he knows any more about evolutionary biology than I
know about synthetic chemistry.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have
effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee Cronin,
who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., assembly theory
is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient details like
chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible seeds of doubt
that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is a
much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from
synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his own
field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any other area
of evolutionary biology.
I've argued at length here against this category error which functionsAll the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even possible)
explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and reputation are on
the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly that any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What prevents consideration is that
the term just in practice means "incapable of being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything that was so capable has either been disposed of
long ago ("Zeus causes the lightning") or incorporated into a natural phenomenon (electricity).
All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
On 11/8/26 9:04 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to attack
and minimize before they present anything.
Looked them up. Rob Stadler is a biomedical engineer. No expertise in evolutionary biology. Sy Garte is apparently a biochemist. Again, no expertise in evolutionary biology. FYI.
On 11/8/26 9:04 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to attack
and minimize before they present anything.
So, is either one of these folks competent in evolutionary biology?
Did you and your acquaintances submit your response to Tour's 60 Day
origin of life challenge?-a You could have removed him from the debate
entirely.-a Or, were you too scared then?
Not my field, sorry. Nor is it the field of any of my acquantances.
Sounds like they are more literal than Bio Logos, most likely similar to Reason to Believe.
My guess is that he is only into the denial like Tour, and will not
tolerate any replacement of biological evolution with some deity that is
not Biblical.-a He needs to state how he expect to Biblical designer to
have designed life on earth over the last 3 billion years.
On 11/8/2026 5:57 PM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 9:04 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are >>>>> taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics >>>>> and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after
this using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology?
Ooh, I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to
attack and minimize before they present anything.
So, is either one of these folks competent in evolutionary biology?
I'm sure your search finger is not borked.-a But I'm glad you mockingly claim you're NOT scared, since then we can wait to see what kind of data they produce instead of simply dismissing them because of their job titles.-a That said, their combined expertise in molecular chemistry, cellular systems, and information engineering pretty much sums up what evolutionary theory relies on.-a You should be able to easily spot any errors.
Plus, I only suggested these people because Dr. Tour has worked with
them in the past.-a I have no idea who will be part of this project.-a You can dismiss them too once we find out.
On 11/8/2026 6:11 PM, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 9:04 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/8/2026 8:08 AM, John Harshman wrote:
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology?
Ooh, I'm so scared.
Probably Dr. Rob Stadler and Dr. Sy Garte.-a Now you know who to
attack and minimize before they present anything.
Looked them up. Rob Stadler is a biomedical engineer. No expertise in
evolutionary biology. Sy Garte is apparently a biochemist. Again, no
expertise in evolutionary biology. FYI.
OK, then.-a By your own logic, I anticipate future silence on your part
on anything that touches on prebiotic chemistry, molecular biology, or really anything outside mapping family trees of ducks, or feathers, or crocodilian DNA.-a Lead by example, John.
On 9/11/2026 11:04 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are >>>>> taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics >>>>> and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after
this using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology?
Ooh, I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox
challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics.
One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a
significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has
enabled him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to the
origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't think so.
But I see no sign that he knows any more about evolutionary biology
than I know about synthetic chemistry.
I'd rephrase that as "it's plainly demonstrable that his expertise has
been relevant to the origin of life, and experts in that field have gone noticeably quiet."
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have
effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee Cronin,
who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., assembly
theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient details like
chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible seeds of doubt
that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is a
much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from
synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his own
field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any other
area of evolutionary biology.
He did not start out claiming any understanding of OOL, but gained understanding using his adjacent knowledge and experience, and applied
that to explicate shortcomings and failures with OOL that were being downplayed or not acknowledged.
I expect a similar (if steeper) trajectory here.
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even possible)
explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and reputation are on
the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly that
any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any
evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does
materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What prevents
consideration is that the term just in practice means "incapable of
being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything that was so capable
has either been disposed of long ago ("Zeus causes the lightning") or
incorporated into a natural phenomenon (electricity).
I've argued at length here against this category error which functions
as a bottomless get-out-of-jail-free-card for philosophical naturalism.
As you know.
All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
I see a strong resemblance to Truthism. Clearly, we see the world differently.
On 11/8/26 4:45 PM, MarkE wrote:John, why would anyone want to invest in a conversation with you with an invitation like that?
On 9/11/2026 11:04 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We
are taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and
genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content
matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a
macroevolutionary model and we will start calling them out by name >>>>>> and we will go after this using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology?
Ooh, I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox
challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics.
One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a
significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has
enabled him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to the
origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't think so.
But I see no sign that he knows any more about evolutionary biology
than I know about synthetic chemistry.
I'd rephrase that as "it's plainly demonstrable that his expertise has
been relevant to the origin of life, and experts in that field have
gone noticeably quiet."
Rephrase all you like. Doesn't make it true.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have
effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee Cronin,
who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., assembly
theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient details like
chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible seeds of doubt
that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is a
much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from
synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his own
field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any other
area of evolutionary biology.
He did not start out claiming any understanding of OOL, but gained
understanding using his adjacent knowledge and experience, and applied
that to explicate shortcomings and failures with OOL that were being
downplayed or not acknowledged.
I expect a similar (if steeper) trajectory here.
Expect all you want. Doesn't make it true.
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even possible)
explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and reputation are on
the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly that
any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any
evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does
materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What prevents
consideration is that the term just in practice means "incapable of
being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything that was so capable
has either been disposed of long ago ("Zeus causes the lightning") or
incorporated into a natural phenomenon (electricity).
I've argued at length here against this category error which functions
as a bottomless get-out-of-jail-free-card for philosophical
naturalism. As you know.
Don't, really. I seldom pay attention to you. And I'm not sure what > category error you're claiming, or what it has to do with philosophical
naturalism. Explain if you think you must.
Plainly false. Clearly we both see the world with some intelligence,All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
I see a strong resemblance to Truthism. Clearly, we see the world
differently.
I'm wondering if you see the world at all.
On 9/11/2026 3:51 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 4:45 PM, MarkE wrote:John, why would anyone want to invest in a conversation with you with an invitation like that?
On 9/11/2026 11:04 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We >>>>>>> are taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and
genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content
matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a
macroevolutionary model and we will start calling them out by
name and we will go after this using the depth of their papers." >>>>>>>
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology?
Ooh, I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox
challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics. >>>>> One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a >>>>> significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has
enabled him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to the
origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't think so.
But I see no sign that he knows any more about evolutionary biology
than I know about synthetic chemistry.
I'd rephrase that as "it's plainly demonstrable that his expertise
has been relevant to the origin of life, and experts in that field
have gone noticeably quiet."
Rephrase all you like. Doesn't make it true.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have
effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee Cronin, >>>>> who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., assembly
theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient details
like chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible seeds of
doubt that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is a >>>>> much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from
synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his
own field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any other
area of evolutionary biology.
He did not start out claiming any understanding of OOL, but gained
understanding using his adjacent knowledge and experience, and
applied that to explicate shortcomings and failures with OOL that
were being downplayed or not acknowledged.
I expect a similar (if steeper) trajectory here.
Expect all you want. Doesn't make it true.
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even possible) >>>>> explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and reputation are
on the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly that
any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any
evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does
materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What prevents
consideration is that the term just in practice means "incapable of
being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything that was so capable
has either been disposed of long ago ("Zeus causes the lightning")
or incorporated into a natural phenomenon (electricity).
I've argued at length here against this category error which
functions as a bottomless get-out-of-jail-free-card for philosophical
naturalism. As you know.
Don't, really. I seldom pay attention to you. And I'm not sure what >
category error you're claiming, or what it has to do with philosophical
naturalism. Explain if you think you must.
Plainly false. Clearly we both see the world with some intelligence, interest, and thought-through interpretations, different though they are.All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
I see a strong resemblance to Truthism. Clearly, we see the world
differently.
I'm wondering if you see the world at all.
RonO wrote:
Sounds like they are more literal than Bio Logos, most likely similar
to Reason to Believe.
My guess is that he is only into the denial like Tour, and will not
tolerate any replacement of biological evolution with some deity that
is not Biblical.-a He needs to state how he expect to Biblical designer
to have designed life on earth over the last 3 billion years.
It has challenged my faith, a facebook meme. It was about prehistoric
man, saying how guys & gals from 10,000 yrs ago never heard of Jesus &
had no way to be saved.
On 11/8/26 9:45 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 3:51 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 4:45 PM, MarkE wrote:John, why would anyone want to invest in a conversation with you with
On 9/11/2026 11:04 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We >>>>>>>> are taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and >>>>>>>> genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content >>>>>>>> matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a
macroevolutionary model and we will start calling them out by >>>>>>>> name and we will go after this using the depth of their papers." >>>>>>>>
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? >>>>>>> Ooh, I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox >>>>>> challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are >>>>>> nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist
critics. One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has
gained him a significant platform in the age of online
influencers. Two, he has expertise that I would call adjacent but >>>>>> applicable, which has enabled him to drill into the prevailing
scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to
the origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't think >>>>> so. But I see no sign that he knows any more about evolutionary
biology than I know about synthetic chemistry.
I'd rephrase that as "it's plainly demonstrable that his expertise
has been relevant to the origin of life, and experts in that field
have gone noticeably quiet."
Rephrase all you like. Doesn't make it true.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have >>>>>> effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee
Cronin, who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g.,
assembly theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient
details like chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible
seeds of doubt that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is >>>>>> a much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from
synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his
own field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any other >>>>> area of evolutionary biology.
He did not start out claiming any understanding of OOL, but gained
understanding using his adjacent knowledge and experience, and
applied that to explicate shortcomings and failures with OOL that
were being downplayed or not acknowledged.
I expect a similar (if steeper) trajectory here.
Expect all you want. Doesn't make it true.
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even
possible) explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and
reputation are on the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly that >>>>> any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any
evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does
materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What
prevents consideration is that the term just in practice means
"incapable of being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything that >>>>> was so capable has either been disposed of long ago ("Zeus causes
the lightning") or incorporated into a natural phenomenon
(electricity).
I've argued at length here against this category error which
functions as a bottomless get-out-of-jail-free-card for
philosophical naturalism. As you know.
Don't, really. I seldom pay attention to you. And I'm not sure what >
category error you're claiming, or what it has to do with philosophical
naturalism. Explain if you think you must.
an invitation like that?
"If you think you must". Otherwise, don't.
Plainly false. Clearly we both see the world with some intelligence,All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
I see a strong resemblance to Truthism. Clearly, we see the world
differently.
I'm wondering if you see the world at all.
interest, and thought-through interpretations, different though they are.
I will admit that I'm not quite sure of that. I'm not fully acquainted
with your views on evolutionary biology, but the evidence from our
slight correspondence is that it isn't well thought through.
On 10/11/2026 3:28 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 9:45 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 3:51 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 4:45 PM, MarkE wrote:John, why would anyone want to invest in a conversation with you with
On 9/11/2026 11:04 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 2:37 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We >>>>>>>>> are taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and >>>>>>>>> genetics and we're going and we're using those as our content >>>>>>>>> matter saying you have suggested this is an example of a
macroevolutionary model and we will start calling them out by >>>>>>>>> name and we will go after this using the depth of their papers." >>>>>>>>>
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? >>>>>>>> Ooh, I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course,
heterodox challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other >>>>>>> spheres are nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist
critics. One, his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has >>>>>>> gained him a significant platform in the age of online
influencers. Two, he has expertise that I would call adjacent but >>>>>>> applicable, which has enabled him to drill into the prevailing
scientific claims.
It's vaguely conceivable that his expertise might be relevant to
the origin of life, though actual experts in that field don't
think so. But I see no sign that he knows any more about
evolutionary biology than I know about synthetic chemistry.
I'd rephrase that as "it's plainly demonstrable that his expertise
has been relevant to the origin of life, and experts in that field
have gone noticeably quiet."
Rephrase all you like. Doesn't make it true.
My read is that the OOL community, ostensibly ignoring Tour, have >>>>>>> effectively gone to ground. Except perhaps for poor old Lee
Cronin, who clearly has no answers to Tour's onslaught-a (e.g., >>>>>>> assembly theory is sufficiently abstract to deflect inconvenient >>>>>>> details like chemistry). I speculate that Tour has sewn credible >>>>>>> seeds of doubt that will bear fruit over time.
How will this translate to evolution? In comparison to OOL, it is >>>>>>> a much broader domain. Population genetics is some distance from >>>>>>> synthetic organic chemistry. Can he stretch that far outside his >>>>>>> own field?
Not that I can see. Nor can he claim any understanding of any
other area of evolutionary biology.
He did not start out claiming any understanding of OOL, but gained
understanding using his adjacent knowledge and experience, and
applied that to explicate shortcomings and failures with OOL that
were being downplayed or not acknowledged.
I expect a similar (if steeper) trajectory here.
Expect all you want. Doesn't make it true.
All the same, the blocker IMO is not ultimately expertise, but
worldview. The guardrails of materialism forever disallow
consideration of supernatural agency as the best (or even
possible) explanation of any scientific evidence. Tenure and
reputation are on the line. Tour has no such constraints.
Lots of hidden assumption and innuendo there. I doubt strongly
that any consideration of tenure or reputation is preventing any
evolutionary biologist from considering creationism. Nor does
materialism prevent consideration of the supernatural. What
prevents consideration is that the term just in practice means
"incapable of being made into a testable hypothesis". Anything
that was so capable has either been disposed of long ago ("Zeus
causes the lightning") or incorporated into a natural phenomenon
(electricity).
I've argued at length here against this category error which
functions as a bottomless get-out-of-jail-free-card for
philosophical naturalism. As you know.
Don't, really. I seldom pay attention to you. And I'm not sure what
category error you're claiming, or what it has to do withphilosophical
naturalism. Explain if you think you must.
an invitation like that?
"If you think you must". Otherwise, don't.
Plainly false. Clearly we both see the world with some intelligence,All power to you Jim. Pass the popcorn for round two.
I see a strong resemblance to Trumpism.
I see a strong resemblance to Truthism. Clearly, we see the world
differently.
I'm wondering if you see the world at all.
interest, and thought-through interpretations, different though they
are.
I will admit that I'm not quite sure of that. I'm not fully acquainted
with your views on evolutionary biology, but the evidence from our
slight correspondence is that it isn't well thought through.
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly our approaches are quite different.
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly our
approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency is
the best explanation.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 10/11/2026 05:47, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency
is the best explanation.
Intuition, especially untrained and motivated intuition, is a poor guide
to processes occurring on physical and temporal scales far removed from everyday experience.
To make an argument you need to be able to quantify the probability.
This can be done from observation or from a model. For spontaneous abiogenesis neither is available. Consequently all you have is an
argument from incredulity, combined with an appeal to a false dichotomy.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly our
approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency is
the best explanation.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency
is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
Exactly. As far as I can see, the answer is "never". Unless you have
some prediction of what observations a supernatural entity would produce that are different from what a natural phenomenon would produce, you
can't test this supernatural explanation. Otherwise all you can say is
that we don't so far know how this works.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
I want to figure out where you're coming from, see if you can be induced
to present a coherent hypothesis, and see if that hypothesis has
anything going for it. I will admit that my initial opinion is that this probably will not happen.
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we >>>>> agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency
is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not natural. This makes no claim as to what this might be, but God is generally thought of (the who/what of this entity is another question). It might also be argued to
be some other kind of process or source outside of spacetime with causal effect on the material world.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
Exactly. As far as I can see, the answer is "never". Unless you have
some prediction of what observations a supernatural entity would
produce that are different from what a natural phenomenon would
produce, you can't test this supernatural explanation. Otherwise all
you can say is that we don't so far know how this works.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
I want to figure out where you're coming from, see if you can be
induced to present a coherent hypothesis, and see if that hypothesis
has anything going for it. I will admit that my initial opinion is
that this probably will not happen.
Here's one hypothesis outline:
1. OOL needs a supply of nucleotides, peptides, lipids etc over most
likely millions of years
2. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) been shown to be destructive to added nucleotides and peptides
3. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) not been shown to produce nucleotides and peptides in any meaningful way at all
4. Extraterrestrial supply of these in the required form is implausible (arguably, so far)
5. This suggests naturalistic OOL to be so implausible that supernatural causation is a logical and legitimate explanation
Note: it is a category error to expect symmetrical structure bely in
the natural domain.
What science can do is lead is to the edge of what
is naturally plausible/possible, at which point consideration of the supernatural becomes reasonable.
Where this point is actually located is
unavoidably subjective to a degree (this relates to the 'so far'
qualifiers above), but at some stage the evidence may become
sufficiently compelling that a majority of people, including scientists, will consider the God hypothesis.
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly our
approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency is
the best explanation.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves into >abuse)
and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 11/10/26 3:08 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can
we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs
supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not natural.
This makes no claim as to what this might be, but God is generally
thought of (the who/what of this entity is another question). It might
also be argued to be some other kind of process or source outside of
spacetime with causal effect on the material world.
That's disguising the false dichotomy, not refuting it. The observation
is that we don't have a clear understanding of how life began. The conclusion from that would not be that there must have been a
supernatural cause. It's that we don't know.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
Exactly. As far as I can see, the answer is "never". Unless you have
some prediction of what observations a supernatural entity would
produce that are different from what a natural phenomenon would
produce, you can't test this supernatural explanation. Otherwise all
you can say is that we don't so far know how this works.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
I want to figure out where you're coming from, see if you can be
induced to present a coherent hypothesis, and see if that hypothesis
has anything going for it. I will admit that my initial opinion is
that this probably will not happen.
Here's one hypothesis outline:
1. OOL needs a supply of nucleotides, peptides, lipids etc over most
likely millions of years
2. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) been shown to be destructive to added
nucleotides and peptides
3. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) not been shown to produce nucleotides
and peptides in any meaningful way at all
4. Extraterrestrial supply of these in the required form is
implausible (arguably, so far)
5. This suggests naturalistic OOL to be so implausible that
supernatural causation is a logical and legitimate explanation
No, it suggests that, if we credit points 1-4, we don't know how life
began. It might, if you pushed it, suggest that there may be some
phenomenon we don't know about. But even so there would be no reason to
jump to the conclusion that that phenomenon is supernatural, whatever "supernatural" means.
Note: it is a category error to expect symmetrical structure bely in
the natural domain.
Nope. Science operates only in whatever domain can be studied. And we
still don't know what if anything you mean by "supernatural".
What science can do is lead is to the edge of what is naturally
plausible/possible, at which point consideration of the supernatural
becomes reasonable.
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Where this point is actually located is unavoidably subjective to a
degree (this relates to the 'so far' qualifiers above), but at some
stage the evidence may become sufficiently compelling that a majority
of people, including scientists, will consider the God hypothesis.
That point would be the one at which the God hypothesis becomes stated clearly enough that we would expect it to have observable consequences,
i.e. if and only if God exists, we should see X. So far, no X.
On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 16:47:52 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:And you?
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we
agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly our
approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is to
put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency is
the best explanation.
It's the "best explanation" because it (surprise!) has the exact
properties that you need it to have because you created it for that
exact purpose.
But two can play at that game: non-materialistic ideas about science
can be easily disproven with my latest hypothesis, namely that there's
some natural law that explains all the data.
Simple as that! That is, if you can just conjure up an unknown
supernatural cause that "explains" the data, so "materialists" can
conjure up an unknown *natural* law that explains the data.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and make
case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves into
abuse)
Oh, no, Mark, don't allow yourself to be abused. LOL!
and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 11/11/2026 11:22 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/10/26 3:08 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can >>>>>>> we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly >>>>>> our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is >>>>> to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs
supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not
natural. This makes no claim as to what this might be, but God is
generally thought of (the who/what of this entity is another
question). It might also be argued to be some other kind of process
or source outside of spacetime with causal effect on the material world.
That's disguising the false dichotomy, not refuting it. The
observation is that we don't have a clear understanding of how life
began. The conclusion from that would not be that there must have been
a supernatural cause. It's that we don't know.
The "we don't know" does not negate the dichotomy. In fact, we will
/never/ know, insofar as all science is provisional.
Rather, the "don't know" relates to the level of certainty we have as to which side of the dichotomy we believe the evidence best supports.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
Exactly. As far as I can see, the answer is "never". Unless you have
some prediction of what observations a supernatural entity would
produce that are different from what a natural phenomenon would
produce, you can't test this supernatural explanation. Otherwise all
you can say is that we don't so far know how this works.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
I want to figure out where you're coming from, see if you can be
induced to present a coherent hypothesis, and see if that hypothesis
has anything going for it. I will admit that my initial opinion is
that this probably will not happen.
Here's one hypothesis outline:
1. OOL needs a supply of nucleotides, peptides, lipids etc over most
likely millions of years
2. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) been shown to be destructive to added
nucleotides and peptides
3. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised early
earth OOL sites have (so far) not been shown to produce nucleotides
and peptides in any meaningful way at all
4. Extraterrestrial supply of these in the required form is
implausible (arguably, so far)
5. This suggests naturalistic OOL to be so implausible that
supernatural causation is a logical and legitimate explanation
No, it suggests that, if we credit points 1-4, we don't know how life
began. It might, if you pushed it, suggest that there may be some
phenomenon we don't know about. But even so there would be no reason
to jump to the conclusion that that phenomenon is supernatural,
whatever "supernatural" means.
Note: it is a category error to expect symmetrical structure bely in
the natural domain.
Nope. Science operates only in whatever domain can be studied. And we
still don't know what if anything you mean by "supernatural".
What science can do is lead is to the edge of what is naturally
plausible/possible, at which point consideration of the supernatural
becomes reasonable.
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it
means.
Where this point is actually located is unavoidably subjective to a
degree (this relates to the 'so far' qualifiers above), but at some
stage the evidence may become sufficiently compelling that a majority
of people, including scientists, will consider the God hypothesis.
That point would be the one at which the God hypothesis becomes stated
clearly enough that we would expect it to have observable
consequences, i.e. if and only if God exists, we should see X. So far,
no X.
Let's apply your requirement:
1. X = success of natural explanation of OOL, therefore this is not
evidence that God (or more generally, supernatural causation) exists.
2. X = uncertainty regarding natural explanation of OOL, therefore
uncertain this is evidence that God exists.
3. X = possible failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore
possibly evidence that God exists.
4. X = probable failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore
probable evidence that God exists.
5. X = failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore evidence that
God exists.
To reiterate, where science actually is on this scale is unavoidably subjective to a degree and a matter for individual assessment, but at
some stage the evidence may become sufficiently compelling that a
majority of people, including scientists, will consider the God hypothesis.
"We don't know" does not equate to "therefore materialism", and no
reason to consider God. It's not a get-out-of-ever-considering-God-free card. Rather, each of us will decide, actively or passively, what we
believe about reality.
On 11/10/26 10:41 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 11:22 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/10/26 3:08 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can >>>>>>>> we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But
certainly our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me
is to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability >>>>>> of materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural >>>>>> agency is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs
supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not
natural. This makes no claim as to what this might be, but God is
generally thought of (the who/what of this entity is another
question). It might also be argued to be some other kind of process
or source outside of spacetime with causal effect on the material
world.
That's disguising the false dichotomy, not refuting it. The
observation is that we don't have a clear understanding of how life
began. The conclusion from that would not be that there must have
been a supernatural cause. It's that we don't know.
The "we don't know" does not negate the dichotomy. In fact, we will /
never/ know, insofar as all science is provisional.
Rather, the "don't know" relates to the level of certainty we have as
to which side of the dichotomy we believe the evidence best supports.
A false dichotomy does indeed have two sides, but what part of "false"
is not clear here? There are more possibilities than "life arose by this process we have looked at" and "it was supernatural". To reject the one
is not to accept the other.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and >>>>>> make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
Exactly. As far as I can see, the answer is "never". Unless you
have some prediction of what observations a supernatural entity
would produce that are different from what a natural phenomenon
would produce, you can't test this supernatural explanation.
Otherwise all you can say is that we don't so far know how this works. >>>>>
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves >>>>>> into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
I want to figure out where you're coming from, see if you can be
induced to present a coherent hypothesis, and see if that
hypothesis has anything going for it. I will admit that my initial
opinion is that this probably will not happen.
Here's one hypothesis outline:
1. OOL needs a supply of nucleotides, peptides, lipids etc over most
likely millions of years
2. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised
early earth OOL sites have (so far) been shown to be destructive to
added nucleotides and peptides
3. Extant geological features that may approximate hypothesised
early earth OOL sites have (so far) not been shown to produce
nucleotides and peptides in any meaningful way at all
4. Extraterrestrial supply of these in the required form is
implausible (arguably, so far)
5. This suggests naturalistic OOL to be so implausible that
supernatural causation is a logical and legitimate explanation
No, it suggests that, if we credit points 1-4, we don't know how life
began. It might, if you pushed it, suggest that there may be some
phenomenon we don't know about. But even so there would be no reason
to jump to the conclusion that that phenomenon is supernatural,
whatever "supernatural" means.
Note: it is a category error to expect symmetrical structure bely in
the natural domain.
Nope. Science operates only in whatever domain can be studied. And we
still don't know what if anything you mean by "supernatural".
What science can do is lead is to the edge of what is naturally
plausible/possible, at which point consideration of the supernatural
becomes reasonable.
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it
means.
Where this point is actually located is unavoidably subjective to a
degree (this relates to the 'so far' qualifiers above), but at some
stage the evidence may become sufficiently compelling that a
majority of people, including scientists, will consider the God
hypothesis.
That point would be the one at which the God hypothesis becomes
stated clearly enough that we would expect it to have observable
consequences, i.e. if and only if God exists, we should see X. So
far, no X.
Let's apply your requirement:
....and then you go on to double down on the false dichotomy and present various Xs, none of which are things that we should see if and only if
God exists.
1. X = success of natural explanation of OOL, therefore this is not
evidence that God (or more generally, supernatural causation) exists.
2. X = uncertainty regarding natural explanation of OOL, therefore
uncertain this is evidence that God exists.
3. X = possible failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore
possibly evidence that God exists.
4. X = probable failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore
probable evidence that God exists.
5. X = failure of natural explanation of OOL, therefore evidence that
God exists.
Even #5 is just a restatement of your false dichotomy.
To reiterate, where science actually is on this scale is unavoidably
subjective to a degree and a matter for individual assessment, but at
some stage the evidence may become sufficiently compelling that a
majority of people, including scientists, will consider the God
hypothesis.
What God hypothesis? You have not presented such a hypothesis. There's
no way to evaluate such a nebulous claim against any sort of evidence.
"We don't know" does not equate to "therefore materialism", and no
reason to consider God. It's not a get-out-of-ever-considering-God-
free card. Rather, each of us will decide, actively or passively, what
we believe about reality.
"We don't know" equates to "we don't know". We could certainly consider
a God hypothesis if there were any such thing. But "Goddidit" is not a hypothesis, since there is nothing you could point to as evidence.
Evidence against one particular hypothesis is not evidence in favor of
any particular other hypothesis unless there are only two possible hypotheses. But there are more things in heaven and earth than are
dreamt of in your philosophy.
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed
phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest modification
if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an event
in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could not accomplish under the conditions in question.
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed
phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining "supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything that's
natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an event
in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could not
accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural
cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or as little.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared into
the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
One thing, though: you
should recall that all this is off-topic, since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
On 10/11/2026 10:38 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
On 10/11/2026 05:47, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we >>>>> agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency
is the best explanation.
Intuition, especially untrained and motivated intuition, is a poor
guide to processes occurring on physical and temporal scales far
removed from everyday experience.
You've made this point before and I think it's a good one. Even running
a computer evo simulation gives a glimpse of this effect, e.g.: https://groups.google.com/g/talk.origins/c/TmDpSRsjcok/m/9AqRFnTLAgAJ
To make an argument you need to be able to quantify the probability.
This can be done from observation or from a model. For spontaneous
abiogenesis neither is available. Consequently all you have is an
argument from incredulity, combined with an appeal to a false dichotomy.
Substitute 'plausibility' for 'probability' as follows, to mean 'realistically not possible' (acknowledging that this may be a somewhat semantic distinction).
For example, recently I've cited papers that empirically assess the plausibility of the survival and polymerisation of nucleotides added to modern thermal springs. From the examples I've found, they are quickly destroyed or rendered unusable. Indicatively, very high implausibility.
Alongside this, I've considered the plausibility of an environment able
to continuously supply nucleotides, peptides etc with sufficient composition, concentration, purity, chirality, activation, accessibility etc, for most likely millions of years. Again, very high implausibility.
Moreover, I am not aware of any realistic field demonstration of extant geological settings that can provide the above *at all*, let alone for millions of years. Very, very high implausibility.
I propose that there's a multiplier effect in combining these factors
that suggests OOL to be so implausible that it becomes logical to
consider supernatural agency as an explanation.
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 10/11/2026 12:44, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 10:38 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
On 10/11/2026 05:47, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can
we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
Intuition, especially untrained and motivated intuition, is a poor
guide to processes occurring on physical and temporal scales far
removed from everyday experience.
You've made this point before and I think it's a good one. Even
running a computer evo simulation gives a glimpse of this effect, e.g.:
https://groups.google.com/g/talk.origins/c/TmDpSRsjcok/m/9AqRFnTLAgAJ
To make an argument you need to be able to quantify the probability.
This can be done from observation or from a model. For spontaneous
abiogenesis neither is available. Consequently all you have is an
argument from incredulity, combined with an appeal to a false dichotomy.
Substitute 'plausibility' for 'probability' as follows, to mean
'realistically not possible' (acknowledging that this may be a
somewhat semantic distinction).
For example, recently I've cited papers that empirically assess the
plausibility of the survival and polymerisation of nucleotides added
to modern thermal springs. From the examples I've found, they are
quickly destroyed or rendered unusable. Indicatively, very high
implausibility.
Alongside this, I've considered the plausibility of an environment
able to continuously supply nucleotides, peptides etc with sufficient
composition, concentration, purity, chirality, activation,
accessibility etc, for most likely millions of years. Again, very high
implausibility.
Moreover, I am not aware of any realistic field demonstration of
extant geological settings that can provide the above *at all*, let
alone for millions of years. Very, very high implausibility.
I propose that there's a multiplier effect in combining these factors
that suggests OOL to be so implausible that it becomes logical to
consider supernatural agency as an explanation.
I've already pointed out to you that if supernatural explanations are possible there's nothing to stop you, or Behe, or Dembski, or Meyer, proposing a supernatural explanation and identifying and testing its implications. All that is necessary is that produce a proposal which is better than "I don't know".
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed
phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining
"supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything that's
natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an
event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could not
accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural
cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or as
little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect in
the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this context).
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as follows:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation)
{
-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural causation
}
else
{
-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not progressing*)
-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a }
-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared into
the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic, since
the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
On 12/11/2026 11:34 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
On 10/11/2026 12:44, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 10:38 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
On 10/11/2026 05:47, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can >>>>>>> we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly >>>>>> our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is >>>>> to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
Intuition, especially untrained and motivated intuition, is a poor
guide to processes occurring on physical and temporal scales far
removed from everyday experience.
You've made this point before and I think it's a good one. Even
running a computer evo simulation gives a glimpse of this effect, e.g.:
https://groups.google.com/g/talk.origins/c/TmDpSRsjcok/m/9AqRFnTLAgAJ
Substitute 'plausibility' for 'probability' as follows, to mean
To make an argument you need to be able to quantify the probability.
This can be done from observation or from a model. For spontaneous
abiogenesis neither is available. Consequently all you have is an
argument from incredulity, combined with an appeal to a false dichotomy. >>>
'realistically not possible' (acknowledging that this may be a
somewhat semantic distinction).
For example, recently I've cited papers that empirically assess the
plausibility of the survival and polymerisation of nucleotides added
to modern thermal springs. From the examples I've found, they are
quickly destroyed or rendered unusable. Indicatively, very high
implausibility.
Alongside this, I've considered the plausibility of an environment
able to continuously supply nucleotides, peptides etc with sufficient
composition, concentration, purity, chirality, activation,
accessibility etc, for most likely millions of years. Again, very high
implausibility.
Moreover, I am not aware of any realistic field demonstration of
extant geological settings that can provide the above *at all*, let
alone for millions of years. Very, very high implausibility.
I propose that there's a multiplier effect in combining these factors
that suggests OOL to be so implausible that it becomes logical to
consider supernatural agency as an explanation.
I've already pointed out to you that if supernatural explanations are
possible there's nothing to stop you, or Behe, or Dembski, or Meyer,
proposing a supernatural explanation and identifying and testing its
implications. All that is necessary is that produce a proposal which is
better than "I don't know".
When you say, "if supernatural explanations are possible", are you >suggesting that they may or may not be possible?
Supernatural causation is always possible in principle. The question is,
can we reasonably infer it?
If the relevant science is incomplete and still progressing, inferring >supernatural causation has higher risk of god-of-the-gaps.
If, however, the more the science is complete and not progressing, the
more the justification to consider supernatural causation.
As I've said elsewhere:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation)
{
the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural causation
}
else
{
if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not progressing*)
{
consider supernatural causation**
}
keep looking for natural explanation
}
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over time >science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
As first step, do you agree the logic of this framework?
I've noticed you will often make a comment but not follow up on my
response. Are you are interested in a conversation or not?
My approach is to refer to scientific papers and to interpret and
make case from them as best I'm able.
A critical related topic is if/when supernatural explanation of
scientific evidence is not god-of-the-gaps.
There's also intellectual sparring (which usually rapidly devolves
into abuse) and even occasional humour.
And you?
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all
observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature. >>>
"supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything that's
natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an
event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could not
accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural
cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or as
little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect in
the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly
physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as follows:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation)
{
-a-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural causation >> }
else
{
-a-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not progressing*) >> -a-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a-a }
-a-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over
time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared
into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic,
since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with.
On 13/11/2026 8:33 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all
observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of
nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining
"supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything that's
natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an
event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could not >>>>> accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural
cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or
as little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect in
the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly
physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this
context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do
you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as follows:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation)
{
-a-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural causation >>> }
else
{
-a-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not
progressing*)
-a-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a-a }
-a-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no
actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over
time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared
into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic,
since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this
discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with.
"What does 'not wholly physical' mean? How do you distinguish physical
from non-physical?"
We should not expect easy answers to such questions. They relate to the nature of reality and the principles for searching out knowledge and understanding of it.
One more thing. The multiverse hypothesis has relevant parallels with
the God hypothesis. In particular, the inference of a multiverse from,
guess what, the acknowledged challenges with OOL. For example: rCLEternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a finite universerCY*.
My point here is not to debate Koonin's conclusion, but rather to see it
as an affirmation of the principle of inferring "other" causation, if
and when the physical laws and resources of this universe are thought to
be possibly inadequate to account for observed phenomena. As an atheist,
he prefers the multiverse over God, but the process of inference is the same, and scientifically legitimate.
Your assertion that "'supernatural' has no actual meaning or referents"
is part of a common get-out-of-jail-free response on TO. You continue to make evasive/dismissive counter assertions rather than counter
arguments. This approach appeals because it offers a pre-emeptive
shutdown of any and all creationist claims. Sorry folks, the Koonin
example says that shortcut is not allowed.
* "The cosmological model of eternal inflation and the transition from chance to biological evolution in the history of life" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1892545/
On 11/12/26 5:57 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/11/2026 8:33 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all
observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of
nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining
"supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything
that's natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's
useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an
event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could
not accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural >>>>> cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or
as little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect
in the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly
physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this
context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do
you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as follows: >>>>
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation)
{
-a-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural
causation
}
else
{
-a-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not
progressing*)
-a-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a-a }
-a-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no
actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over
time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared
into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic,
since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this
discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with.
"What does 'not wholly physical' mean? How do you distinguish physical
from non-physical?"
We should not expect easy answers to such questions. They relate to
the nature of reality and the principles for searching out knowledge
and understanding of it.
Apparently we should not expect answers at all.
One more thing. The multiverse hypothesis has relevant parallels with
the God hypothesis. In particular, the inference of a multiverse from,
guess what, the acknowledged challenges with OOL. For example:
rCLEternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universerCY*.
Nobody infers a multiverse from challenges with OOL. Certainly Koonin doesn't. You have misread.
My point here is not to debate Koonin's conclusion, but rather to see
it as an affirmation of the principle of inferring "other" causation,
if and when the physical laws and resources of this universe are
thought to be possibly inadequate to account for observed phenomena.
As an atheist, he prefers the multiverse over God, but the process of
inference is the same, and scientifically legitimate.
In fact there is no such process of inference regarding a multiverse.
Again, you have mistaken Koonin's conclusion.
Your assertion that "'supernatural' has no actual meaning or
referents" is part of a common get-out-of-jail-free response on TO.
You continue to make evasive/dismissive counter assertions rather than
counter arguments. This approach appeals because it offers a pre-
emeptive shutdown of any and all creationist claims. Sorry folks, the
Koonin example says that shortcut is not allowed.
And yet you consistently fail to provide a meaning for the term. And
since you completely misunderstand the "Koonin example", your use of it
is fallacious.
* "The cosmological model of eternal inflation and the transition from
chance to biological evolution in the history of life"
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1892545/
Can we talk about macroevolution now?
On 14/11/2026 3:26 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/12/26 5:57 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/11/2026 8:33 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all
observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of >>>>>>> nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining >>>>>> "supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything
that's natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's >>>>>> useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an >>>>>>> event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could >>>>>>> not accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A
supernatural cause is a cause that's supernatural" would
communicate as much or as little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect
in the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly
physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this
context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do
you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as
follows:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation) >>>>> {
-a-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural
causation
}
else
{
-a-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not
progressing*)
-a-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a-a }
-a-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no
actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over >>>>> time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared >>>>>> into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic,
since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this
discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with.
"What does 'not wholly physical' mean? How do you distinguish
physical from non-physical?"
We should not expect easy answers to such questions. They relate to
the nature of reality and the principles for searching out knowledge
and understanding of it.
Apparently we should not expect answers at all.
Not the same thing. As you know.
One more thing. The multiverse hypothesis has relevant parallels with
the God hypothesis. In particular, the inference of a multiverse
from, guess what, the acknowledged challenges with OOL. For example:
rCLEternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a >>> finite universerCY*.
Nobody infers a multiverse from challenges with OOL. Certainly Koonin
doesn't. You have misread.
Assertion, not argument.
My point here is not to debate Koonin's conclusion, but rather to see
it as an affirmation of the principle of inferring "other" causation,
if and when the physical laws and resources of this universe are
thought to be possibly inadequate to account for observed phenomena.
As an atheist, he prefers the multiverse over God, but the process of
inference is the same, and scientifically legitimate.
In fact there is no such process of inference regarding a multiverse.
Again, you have mistaken Koonin's conclusion.
Assertion, not argument.
Koonin assesses OOL as "untenable* in a finite universe, i.e., that a coupled system of translation and replication emerged by chance."
This conclusion is of course debatable, but that's not at issue here.
I'm talking about a principle of inference.
To summarise and apply: if natural explanation of an observed phenomenon
is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic resources available
in our observable universe, then consideration of the involvement of additional resources located outside of it may provide an explanation.
Those "additional resources" could be more spacetime, or they could be supernatural agency, or neither.
* Koonin's "tenability" summary:
"Under the assumptions of this toy model (idealized to the extreme in
that an unrealistically high rate of abiogenic RNA production is
assumed), the emergence, by chance, of a ribozyme replicase in a finite universe consisting of a single O-region like ours, in principle, could
be considered. However, any significant increase in complexity would
call for a different cosmological model. In particular, the emergence of
a coupled replication-translation system is unlikely to the extent of
being, effectively, impossible. For such a complex system to be a viable candidate for the breakthrough stage, an infinite multiverse, such as
the one depicted by MWO or, in the very least, a universe with a vast
number of O-regions, is, indeed, a must."
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any (island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
Your assertion that "'supernatural' has no actual meaning or
referents" is part of a common get-out-of-jail-free response on TO.
You continue to make evasive/dismissive counter assertions rather
than counter arguments. This approach appeals because it offers a
pre- emeptive shutdown of any and all creationist claims. Sorry
folks, the Koonin example says that shortcut is not allowed.
And yet you consistently fail to provide a meaning for the term. And
since you completely misunderstand the "Koonin example", your use of
it is fallacious.
* "The cosmological model of eternal inflation and the transition
from chance to biological evolution in the history of life"
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1892545/
Can we talk about macroevolution now?
I gather you may have a head-start in that area. Can we talk about OOL?
But yes, I'm willing to discuss macroevolution with an exploratory posture.
On 14/11/2026 3:26 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/12/26 5:57 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/11/2026 8:33 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all
observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of >>>>>>> nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just defining >>>>>> "supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be a true
dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify everything
that's natural and everything that isn't by some other means, it's >>>>>> useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an >>>>>>> event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could >>>>>>> not accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A supernatural >>>>>> cause is a cause that's supernatural" would communicate as much or >>>>>> as little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect
in the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly
physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this
context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do
you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as follows: >>>>>
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation) >>>>> {
aaa the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural
causation
}
else
{
aaa if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not
progressing*)
aaa {
aaaaaa consider supernatural causation**
aaa }
aaa keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no
actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however over >>>>> time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared >>>>>> into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic,
since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this
discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with.
"What does 'not wholly physical' mean? How do you distinguish physical
from non-physical?"
We should not expect easy answers to such questions. They relate to
the nature of reality and the principles for searching out knowledge
and understanding of it.
Apparently we should not expect answers at all.
Not the same thing. As you know.
One more thing. The multiverse hypothesis has relevant parallels with
the God hypothesis. In particular, the inference of a multiverse from,
guess what, the acknowledged challenges with OOL. For example:
oEternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universeo*.
Nobody infers a multiverse from challenges with OOL. Certainly Koonin
doesn't. You have misread.
Assertion, not argument.
My point here is not to debate Koonin's conclusion, but rather to see
it as an affirmation of the principle of inferring "other" causation,
if and when the physical laws and resources of this universe are
thought to be possibly inadequate to account for observed phenomena.
As an atheist, he prefers the multiverse over God, but the process of
inference is the same, and scientifically legitimate.
In fact there is no such process of inference regarding a multiverse.
Again, you have mistaken Koonin's conclusion.
Assertion, not argument.
Koonin assesses OOL as "untenable* in a finite universe, i.e., that a >coupled system of translation and replication emerged by chance."
This conclusion is of course debatable, but that's not at issue here.
I'm talking about a principle of inference.
To summarise and apply: if natural explanation of an observed phenomenon
is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic resources available
in our observable universe, then consideration of the involvement of >additional resources located outside of it may provide an explanation.
Those "additional resources" could be more spacetime, or they could be >supernatural agency, or neither.
* Koonin's "tenability" summary:
"Under the assumptions of this toy model (idealized to the extreme in
that an unrealistically high rate of abiogenic RNA production is
assumed), the emergence, by chance, of a ribozyme replicase in a finite >universe consisting of a single O-region like ours, in principle, could
be considered. However, any significant increase in complexity would
call for a different cosmological model. In particular, the emergence of
a coupled replication-translation system is unlikely to the extent of
being, effectively, impossible. For such a complex system to be a viable >candidate for the breakthrough stage, an infinite multiverse, such as
the one depicted by MWO or, in the very least, a universe with a vast
number of O-regions, is, indeed, a must."
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any >(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal >inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation >producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a >universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
Your assertion that "'supernatural' has no actual meaning or
referents" is part of a common get-out-of-jail-free response on TO.
You continue to make evasive/dismissive counter assertions rather than
counter arguments. This approach appeals because it offers a pre-
emeptive shutdown of any and all creationist claims. Sorry folks, the
Koonin example says that shortcut is not allowed.
And yet you consistently fail to provide a meaning for the term. And
since you completely misunderstand the "Koonin example", your use of it
is fallacious.
* "The cosmological model of eternal inflation and the transition from
chance to biological evolution in the history of life"
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1892545/
Can we talk about macroevolution now?
I gather you may have a head-start in that area. Can we talk about OOL?
But yes, I'm willing to discuss macroevolution with an exploratory posture.
On 11/15/26 2:21 AM, MarkE wrote:
On 14/11/2026 3:26 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/12/26 5:57 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/11/2026 8:33 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 7:21 PM, MarkE wrote:"What does 'not wholly physical' mean? How do you distinguish
On 12/11/2026 1:27 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all >>>>>>>>> observed phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation >>>>>>>>Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of >>>>>>>> nature.
What does "beyond" mean here? It sounds as if you're just
defining "supernatural" as "whatever isn't natural. That would be >>>>>>> a true dichotomy by definition, but until we can identify
everything that's natural and everything that isn't by some other >>>>>>> means, it's useless.
A supernatural cause is an agent or power that contributes to an >>>>>>>> event in a way that the natural order, acting on its own, could >>>>>>>> not accomplish under the conditions in question.
Whatever that means. How is this definition useful? "A
supernatural cause is a cause that's supernatural" would
communicate as much or as little.
Alternative working definitions:
Natural order: the physical universe, including matter, fields,
spacetime, and the powers of physical systems, whether presently
understood or still undiscovered.
Supernatural causation: an agent or power bringing about an effect >>>>>> in the physical world by exercising a capacity that has no wholly >>>>>> physical basis. (This addresses what "beyond" signifies in this
context).
Still not very useful. What does "not wholly physical" mean? How do >>>>> you distinguish physical from non-physical?
These definitions are necessarily broad, but are functional as
follows:
if (an observed phenomenon has a well-supported natural explanation) >>>>>> {
-a-a-a the phenomenon alone gives no reason to infer supernatural >>>>>> causation
}
else
{
-a-a-a if (the relevant science is relatively complete and not
progressing*)
-a-a-a {
-a-a-a-a-a-a consider supernatural causation**
-a-a-a }
-a-a-a keep looking for natural explanation
}
This continues to suffer from the fact that "supernatural" has no
actual meaning or referents.
* the assessment of this condition is to a degree subjective and
individual (hence this discussion group, for example), however
over time science may reach a provisional consensus.
** one may consider supernatural causation at any point, but the
conditional shown provides a reason from science itself.
I posted a lengthy reply to the previous post, but it disappeared >>>>>>> into the ether and I'm not inclined to try it again.
Thanks for trying.
One thing, though: you should recall that all this is off-topic, >>>>>>> since the thread is supposedly about macroevolution, not OOL.
Noted; I'm okay with that.
I'm not. I would much prefer to talk about macroevolution, and this >>>>> discussion has run its course, assuming it had a course to begin with. >>>>
physical from non-physical?"
We should not expect easy answers to such questions. They relate to
the nature of reality and the principles for searching out knowledge
and understanding of it.
Apparently we should not expect answers at all.
Not the same thing. As you know.
One more thing. The multiverse hypothesis has relevant parallels
with the God hypothesis. In particular, the inference of a
multiverse from, guess what, the acknowledged challenges with OOL.
For example: rCLEternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is >>>> untenable in a finite universerCY*.
Nobody infers a multiverse from challenges with OOL. Certainly Koonin
doesn't. You have misread.
Assertion, not argument.
My point here is not to debate Koonin's conclusion, but rather to
see it as an affirmation of the principle of inferring "other"
causation, if and when the physical laws and resources of this
universe are thought to be possibly inadequate to account for
observed phenomena. As an atheist, he prefers the multiverse over
God, but the process of inference is the same, and scientifically
legitimate.
In fact there is no such process of inference regarding a multiverse.
Again, you have mistaken Koonin's conclusion.
Assertion, not argument.
Koonin assesses OOL as "untenable* in a finite universe, i.e., that a
coupled system of translation and replication emerged by chance."
This conclusion is of course debatable, but that's not at issue here.
I'm talking about a principle of inference.
To summarise and apply: if natural explanation of an observed
phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic
resources available in our observable universe, then consideration of
the involvement of additional resources located outside of it may
provide an explanation.
Those "additional resources" could be more spacetime, or they could be
supernatural agency, or neither.
* Koonin's "tenability" summary:
"Under the assumptions of this toy model (idealized to the extreme in
that an unrealistically high rate of abiogenic RNA production is
assumed), the emergence, by chance, of a ribozyme replicase in a
finite universe consisting of a single O-region like ours, in
principle, could be considered. However, any significant increase in
complexity would call for a different cosmological model. In
particular, the emergence of a coupled replication-translation system
is unlikely to the extent of being, effectively, impossible. For such
a complex system to be a viable candidate for the breakthrough stage,
an infinite multiverse, such as the one depicted by MWO or, in the
very least, a universe with a vast number of O-regions, is, indeed, a
must."
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any
(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
You mistake the nature of Koonin's reasoning. The creationist reasoning
is that a natural origin of life is too unlikely, therefore God must
have done it. Koonin's reasoning is that if there is a multiverse (or whatever), a natural origin of life is more likely. You present
perceived probability as evidence for God, while he presents the
multiverse as a hypothesis to increase probability. The analogy would be
if you said that the existence of God would increase the probability of life.
Your assertion that "'supernatural' has no actual meaning or
referents" is part of a common get-out-of-jail-free response on TO.
You continue to make evasive/dismissive counter assertions rather
than counter arguments. This approach appeals because it offers a
pre- emeptive shutdown of any and all creationist claims. Sorry
folks, the Koonin example says that shortcut is not allowed.
And yet you consistently fail to provide a meaning for the term. And
since you completely misunderstand the "Koonin example", your use of
it is fallacious.
* "The cosmological model of eternal inflation and the transition
from chance to biological evolution in the history of life"
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1892545/
Can we talk about macroevolution now?
I gather you may have a head-start in that area. Can we talk about OOL?
But yes, I'm willing to discuss macroevolution with an exploratory
posture.
I would be interested in discussing Tour's case, the supposed topic of
this thread.
On 11/15/2026 4:21 AM, MarkE wrote:
Check your clock Mark,-a You're a day ahead somehow
On 11/15/26 2:21 AM, MarkE wrote:
Koonin assesses OOL as "untenable* in a finite universe, i.e., that a
coupled system of translation and replication emerged by chance."
This conclusion is of course debatable, but that's not at issue here.
I'm talking about a principle of inference.
To summarise and apply: if natural explanation of an observed
phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic
resources available in our observable universe, then consideration of
the involvement of additional resources located outside of it may
provide an explanation.
Those "additional resources" could be more spacetime, or they could be
supernatural agency, or neither.
* Koonin's "tenability" summary:
"Under the assumptions of this toy model (idealized to the extreme in
that an unrealistically high rate of abiogenic RNA production is
assumed), the emergence, by chance, of a ribozyme replicase in a
finite universe consisting of a single O-region like ours, in
principle, could be considered. However, any significant increase in
complexity would call for a different cosmological model. In
particular, the emergence of a coupled replication-translation system
is unlikely to the extent of being, effectively, impossible. For such
a complex system to be a viable candidate for the breakthrough stage,
an infinite multiverse, such as the one depicted by MWO or, in the
very least, a universe with a vast number of O-regions, is, indeed, a
must."
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any
(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
You mistake the nature of Koonin's reasoning. The creationist reasoning
is that a natural origin of life is too unlikely, therefore God must
have done it. Koonin's reasoning is that if there is a multiverse (or whatever), a natural origin of life is more likely. You present
perceived probability as evidence for God, while he presents the
multiverse as a hypothesis to increase probability. The analogy would be
if you said that the existence of God would increase the probability of life.
I would be interested in discussing Tour's case, the supposed topic of
this thread.
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any
(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not a necessity. What do you make
of that?
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
The multiverse at least has it going for it that it's constrained by
the laws of physics and therefore could in principle be proven false.
God has no such constraint, so invoking him is not part of science.
On 15/11/2026 5:03 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
<...>
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any
(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not-a a necessity.-a What do you make
of that?
He includes a single "a spatially infinite universe" alongside a
multiverse. That's fine; the principle of inference is the same.
On 9/11/2026 1:08 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/8/26 1:45 AM, MarkE wrote:
I knew you'd appreciate a heads-up:
"We are going to be going after the macroevolutionary model. We are
taking their best papers in the fields of biochemistry and genetics
and we're going and we're using those as our content matter saying
you have suggested this is an example of a macroevolutionary model
and we will start calling them out by name and we will go after this
using the depth of their papers."
https://youtu.be/bRG0gQ7MBug?si=jgN2mUVZyldoLLQ6
Who are "we"? Are any of them competent in evolutionary biology? Ooh,
I'm so scared.
I find this an interesting social experiment. Of course, heterodox challenges to mainstream thinking in science and other spheres are
nothing new.
Tour is arguably different in two ways to many creationist critics. One,
his forthright (dogged? aggressive?) approach has gained him a
significant platform in the age of online influencers. Two, he has
expertise that I would call adjacent but applicable, which has enabled
him to drill into the prevailing scientific claims.
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can we >>>>> agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural agency
is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not natural.
On 11/10/26 3:08 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can
we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly
our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is
to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs
supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not natural.
Now you need to define "natural". Is gravity natural? Is consciousness natural? Is quantum tunneling natural? Why or why not?
Don't claim it's obvious, or is a pointless exercise. The definition of "natural" that is obvious to me makes your dichotomy disappear, because
it means the supernatural does not exist.
On 15/11/2026 5:03 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
<...>
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any
(island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not a necessity. What do you make
of that?
He includes a single "a spatially infinite universe" alongside a
multiverse. That's fine; the principle of inference is the same.
Suggest any corrections you think are necessary to this proposal:Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
The multiverse at least has it going for it that it's constrained by
the laws of physics and therefore could in principle be proven false.
God has no such constraint, so invoking him is not part of science.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be >untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable >universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of >additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other. >-------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
On Mon, 16 Nov 2026 06:58:35 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 5:03 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
<...>
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any >>>> (island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not a necessity. What do you make
of that?
He includes a single "a spatially infinite universe" alongside a
multiverse. That's fine; the principle of inference is the same.
So your problems with the multiverse are not necessarily relevant
here, are they?
Suggest any corrections you think are necessary to this proposal:Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
The multiverse at least has it going for it that it's constrained by
the laws of physics and therefore could in principle be proven false.
God has no such constraint, so invoking him is not part of science.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be
untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable
universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of
additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
I would say there was more to the natural world than probability. And
the multiverse is not necessarily "unobservable." Is the god in your hypothesis unobservable? Why or why not?
On 16/11/2026 8:17 am, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 11/10/26 3:08 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/11/2026 1:07 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 11/9/26 9:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/11/2026 2:33 pm, John Harshman wrote:
...
Our purposes and approach here seem to have limited overlap. Can >>>>>>> we agree on that?
I'm not sure about purposes. What are your purposes? But certainly >>>>>> our approaches are quite different.
Good question. I ask myself this more and more.
As a Christian with regard for science, a primary purpose for me is >>>>> to put up for debate scientific data for which the probability of
materialistic explanation is arguably so low that supernatural
agency is the best explanation.
So you are perpetuating a false dichotomy. Not good.
The dichotomy I'm referring to is definitional: natural vs
supernatural explanation. Supernatural as beyond natural, not natural.
Now you need to define "natural". Is gravity natural? Is consciousness
natural? Is quantum tunneling natural? Why or why not?
Don't claim it's obvious, or is a pointless exercise. The definition
of "natural" that is obvious to me makes your dichotomy disappear,
because it means the supernatural does not exist.
With reference to Koonin's paper https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/ PMC1892545/, suggest any corrections you think are necessary to this proposal:
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other. -------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
On 16/11/2026 8:35 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 16 Nov 2026 06:58:35 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 5:03 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>
<...>
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a >>>>> finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any >>>>> (island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal
inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not a necessity. What do you make
of that?
He includes a single "a spatially infinite universe" alongside a
multiverse. That's fine; the principle of inference is the same.
So your problems with the multiverse are not necessarily relevant
here, are they?
That statement suggests you don't understand the logic of my
proposition.
As I said, the principle of inference is the same.
Suggest any corrections you think are necessary to this proposal:Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the >>>>> need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation >>>>> producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a >>>>> universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
The multiverse at least has it going for it that it's constrained by
the laws of physics and therefore could in principle be proven false.
God has no such constraint, so invoking him is not part of science.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be
untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable >>> universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of >>> additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
I would say there was more to the natural world than probability. And
the multiverse is not necessarily "unobservable." Is the god in your
hypothesis unobservable? Why or why not?
On Mon, 16 Nov 2026 08:48:25 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 16/11/2026 8:35 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 16 Nov 2026 06:58:35 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 15/11/2026 5:03 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 15 Nov 2026 21:21:45 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
<...>
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a >>>>>> finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as any >>>>>> (island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to eternal >>>>>> inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
So his opinion is that a multiverse was involved with the origin of
life is not, according to him is not a necessity. What do you make >>>>> of that?
He includes a single "a spatially infinite universe" alongside a
multiverse. That's fine; the principle of inference is the same.
So your problems with the multiverse are not necessarily relevant
here, are they?
That statement suggests you don't understand the logic of my
proposition.
From one of your other posts, I would say you believe some problems
are so intractable that it becomes necessary to use an explanation
that has no observable consequences. When phrased like that, it should
be obvious that no, you shouldn't do that and in fact it's almost
impossible to do that without doing violence to the scientific method.
As I said, the principle of inference is the same.
Adapted from *The Design Inference*, I assume.
Suggest any corrections you think are necessary to this proposal:Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the >>>>>> need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and >>>>>> posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation >>>>>> producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a >>>>>> universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
The multiverse at least has it going for it that it's constrained by >>>>> the laws of physics and therefore could in principle be proven false. >>>>> God has no such constraint, so invoking him is not part of science.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be
untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable >>>> universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of >>>> additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
I would say there was more to the natural world than probability. And
the multiverse is not necessarily "unobservable." Is the god in your
hypothesis unobservable? Why or why not?
On 15/11/2026 1:12 am, John Harshman wrote:I suggest throwing the whole thing away. It is not repairable.
On 11/15/26 2:21 AM, MarkE wrote:
<...>
Koonin assesses OOL as "untenable* in a finite universe, i.e., that a
coupled system of translation and replication emerged by chance."
This conclusion is of course debatable, but that's not at issue here.
I'm talking about a principle of inference.
To summarise and apply: if natural explanation of an observed
phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic
resources available in our observable universe, then consideration of
the involvement of additional resources located outside of it may
provide an explanation.
Those "additional resources" could be more spacetime, or they could
be supernatural agency, or neither.
* Koonin's "tenability" summary:
"Under the assumptions of this toy model (idealized to the extreme in
that an unrealistically high rate of abiogenic RNA production is
assumed), the emergence, by chance, of a ribozyme replicase in a
finite universe consisting of a single O-region like ours, in
principle, could be considered. However, any significant increase in
complexity would call for a different cosmological model. In
particular, the emergence of a coupled replication-translation system
is unlikely to the extent of being, effectively, impossible. For such
a complex system to be a viable candidate for the breakthrough stage,
an infinite multiverse, such as the one depicted by MWO or, in the
very least, a universe with a vast number of O-regions, is, indeed, a
must."
"Eternal inflation offers a viable alternative that is untenable in a
finite universe", and also, "a spatially infinite universe such as
any (island) universe in MWO; the multiverse, while integral to
eternal inflation, is not actually required for my argument"
Koonin does allow for non-multiverse options. Strictly, he infers the
need for additional resources to explain OOL naturalistically, and
posits *the potential explanatory effectiveness* of eternal inflation
producing a spatially infinite universe or multiverse, or at least a
universe with a vast number of O-regions.
Show your working if you disagree.
You mistake the nature of Koonin's reasoning. The creationist
reasoning is that a natural origin of life is too unlikely, therefore
God must have done it. Koonin's reasoning is that if there is a
multiverse (or whatever), a natural origin of life is more likely. You
present perceived probability as evidence for God, while he presents
the multiverse as a hypothesis to increase probability. The analogy
would be if you said that the existence of God would increase the
probability of life.
Because this is foundational, it's worth persevering toward an agreed statement. I propose this:
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other. -------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
Suggest adjustments if you think necessary.
Too vague to address, notably the meaning of "body plan" as Tour viewsI would be interested in discussing Tour's case, the supposed topic of
this thread.
I'll wait until Tour presents a detailed critique before addressing his position. I expect it will include the origin of major biological innovations, especially new body plans and the regulatory systems that produce them. I think he has also signalled questioning the results of Lenski's LTEE, and possibly the Cambrian explosion, etc.
While we await this with keen anticipation, I find embryology
fascinating. For example:
"Arguably, the role of such biases in directing morphologyrCothough all
but neglected in previous accounts of both development and macroevolutionrCois critical to any substantive explanation for the origin of the archetypal vertebrate bauplan."
"Though speculative, the model addresses the poignant absence in the literature of any plausible account of the origin of vertebrate
morphology."
"The mechanism underlying the origin of radically new forms thus remains very much an open question (for a comprehensive pr|-cis of the history
and contemporary study of the origin of vertebrate form, see Onai and Kuratani, 2014; for a review of the problem of macroevolution, also see
Vrba and Eldredge, 2005)."
Reference:Quote-mining? Whatever do you think any of those quotes mean, and have
"Origin of the vertebrate body plan via mechanically biased conservation
of regular geometrical patterns in the structure of the blastula" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0079610716300542
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed
phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest modification
if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature.
On 12/11/2026 11:34 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
As first step, do you agree the logic of this framework?
I've noticed you will often make a comment but not follow up on my
response. Are you are interested in a conversation or not?
On 11/14/26 9:32 PM, MarkE wrote:
Because this is foundational, it's worth persevering toward an agreed statement. I propose this:
-------------------------------------------------------------------
If naturalistic explanation of an observed phenomenon is deemed to be untenable* given the probabilistic resources available in our observable universe, then it is reasonable to infer and consider the involvement of additional resources or causation located outside our observable
universe. This could be a multiverse, God, or other. -------------------------------------------------------------------
* to be defined separately
Suggest adjustments if you think necessary.I suggest throwing the whole thing away. It is not repairable.
Naturalistic explanation is not deemed to be untenable. "Probabilistic resources" is a nonsense buzzphrase. Equating Koonin's use of the
multiverse with Tour's use of God is ignoring what Koonin actually said.
On 11/11/26 1:43 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/11/2026 8:06 am, MarkE wrote:
2. Natural explanations are insufficient to account for all observed
phenomena, which implies some supernatural causation
Proposed working definition of supernatural. Again, suggest
modification if you disagree:
Supernatural phenomena or entities are those beyond the laws of nature.
Since we can never know all the laws of nature, the definition is unusable.-a And even worse, it will be used anyway.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:05:42 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |