"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures that
are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat. The
second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow on free
energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's idea reframes
or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building on Ilya
Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the implications
of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency towards >energy-driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of a hurricane
is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through >complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are >constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >where Principia Darwinia meets its G%del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: >https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures that
are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat. The
second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow on free
energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's idea reframes
or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building on Ilya
Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the implications
of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency towards energy- driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of a hurricane is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle). Life
achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: https://youtu.be/ wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures that
are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat. The
second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow on free
energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's idea reframes
or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building on Ilya
Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the implications
of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency towards energy- driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of a hurricane is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle). Life
achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: https://youtu.be/ wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
On 11/1/2026 1:55 AM, MarkE wrote:
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures
that are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat.
The second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow on free
energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's idea reframes
or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building on Ilya
Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the
implications of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency
towards energy- driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of a
hurricane is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw
energy and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life
is arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle). Life
achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis
through complex and highly specific molecular machines, which
themselves are constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even
be where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: https://youtu.be/
wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
I wanted to scientifically test all this out, so knowing it was going to rain last night I decided to place a camera next to one of what I
believed was one of the smarter rocks in my garden I had placed over
some very intelligent clay.-a It hovered around 70F all night and I
figured that would be a good temperature so I turned on the recording.
I was hoping to see a full book of wonderful information on the rock in
the morning, at least a page or two of notes.-a Alas, nothing, all I
ended up with was a wet and dirty rock.-a I have got to find a more intelligent rock I guess.-a Or, maybe I needed a lightning strike to kick things off??
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures that
are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat. The
On 11/1/2026 8:51 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/1/2026 1:55 AM, MarkE wrote:
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it
for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures
that are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as heat.
The second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow on
free energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's idea
reframes or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building on
Ilya Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the
implications of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency
towards energy- driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of
a hurricane is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw
energy and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life
is arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle). Life
achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis
through complex and highly specific molecular machines, which
themselves are constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing,
but assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may
even be where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: https://youtu.be/
wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
I wanted to scientifically test all this out, so knowing it was going
to rain last night I decided to place a camera next to one of what I
believed was one of the smarter rocks in my garden I had placed over
some very intelligent clay.-a It hovered around 70F all night and I
figured that would be a good temperature so I turned on the recording.
I was hoping to see a full book of wonderful information on the rock
in the morning, at least a page or two of notes.-a Alas, nothing, all I
ended up with was a wet and dirty rock.-a I have got to find a more
intelligent rock I guess.-a Or, maybe I needed a lightning strike to
kick things off??
Ask MarkE if your stupid experiment is relevant.-a MarkE spent a lot of
time demonstrating that conditions that existed on earth were far
different billions of years ago when life originated on this planet.-a He demonstrated conclusively that the origin of life was not Biblical.-a Ask him why he ran from what he had done for months when he quit supporting
the origin of life gap denial.-a Try to get him to explain why he decided
to deny reality and wallow in the gap denial in spite of the fact that
the gap is not Biblical.-a He claims that he has always known that the ID perps have been lying to him about their ability to fill that gap, and
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine guidance?
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through >> complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be
where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of "spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis
through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging."-a It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical [9rCo11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]rCoit is the information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent causationrComediated by the onset of information controlrCothat is the key defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter. We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that
we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be
where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative)-a can happen if energy is added to the reaction.-a Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis
through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging."-a It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
MarkE wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis
through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging."-a It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps
the key property."
Okay, this is interesting, which you may find to be a change from my
usual arguments against you. What I read in this is that at some point,
life began leaning into the whole idea & process of evolution. That it's
not merely because 'those who adapt best survive because they adhere
better to principles of the planet', it's also because somehow life is embracing this natural selection beyond it simply being law of the
jungle or roll of the dice. That's not a point I've ever heard Darwin
make before. He was doing his best to align evolution with what would
cause it to appear believable and we might say he never had a chance in
his relatively short lifetime, considering the news is advising some retirees to plan on life until age 130 today, to go down this side path
or indicates he was even aware there was a path there.
RonO wrote:
On 11/1/2026 8:51 AM, sticks wrote:
On 11/1/2026 1:55 AM, MarkE wrote:
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on
it for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a
plant."
This is an intentionally provocative expression of "dissipative
adaptation", i.e. that matter naturally rearranges into structures
that are better at absorbing and dissipating incoming energy as
heat. The second law does not prohibit an open system with an inflow
on free energy from decreasing entropy locally. Jeremy England's
idea reframes or even flips the OOL thermodynamics problem, building
on Ilya Prigogine's dissipative structures.
Credit for this innovative line of thinking and pushing the
implications of physics. England offers a possible physical tendency
towards energy- driven organisation. The formation and sustaining of
a hurricane is an example of this principle.
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw
energy and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However,
life is arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred
Hoyle). Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium
homeostasis through complex and highly specific molecular machines,
which themselves are constructed from genetic and epigenetic
information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing,
but assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may
even be where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this: https://youtu.be/
wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
I wanted to scientifically test all this out, so knowing it was going
to rain last night I decided to place a camera next to one of what I
believed was one of the smarter rocks in my garden I had placed over
some very intelligent clay.-a It hovered around 70F all night and I
figured that would be a good temperature so I turned on the recording.
I was hoping to see a full book of wonderful information on the rock
in the morning, at least a page or two of notes.-a Alas, nothing, all
I ended up with was a wet and dirty rock.-a I have got to find a more
intelligent rock I guess.-a Or, maybe I needed a lightning strike to
kick things off??
Ask MarkE if your stupid experiment is relevant.-a MarkE spent a lot of
time demonstrating that conditions that existed on earth were far
different billions of years ago when life originated on this planet.
He demonstrated conclusively that the origin of life was not
Biblical.-a Ask him why he ran from what he had done for months when he
quit supporting the origin of life gap denial.-a Try to get him to
explain why he decided to deny reality and wallow in the gap denial in
spite of the fact that the gap is not Biblical.-a He claims that he has
always known that the ID perps have been lying to him about their
ability to fill that gap, and
I assure you I am not an 'ID perp'. I travel the Net & the 7 hallways. Wherever I go, people remark how 'different' I am from the average
poster. It's rare that I am clumped into a demographic with very many others.
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general >agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical [9u11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact
that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]uit is the information that determines the current state
and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent >causationumediated by the onset of information controluthat is the key >defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic >information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter.
We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that
we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be
where Principia Darwinia meets its G%del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:35:05 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
No, there's nothing tongue-in-cheek about it. This was an actual
argument put forward by Hoyle in his crackpot years.
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
Which is not the same thing as an "information problem."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical [9rCo11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact
that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]rCoit is the information that determines the current state >> and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent
causationrComediated by the onset of information controlrCothat is the key >> defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic
information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter.
Do you agree with that approach?
We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that
we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
Do you agree with what they said right after that?
"Digitization may have been a natural outcome of this process in
reaction networks that had once been primarily analogue. At this
point, information would have become separated from its physical representation, permitting information to become a causal influence in
its own right, and the language of Turing and von Neumann would have
begun to apply."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
So do you believe the emergence of "information control" is the only
problem abiogenesis research has in the context of "the information
problem"?
And do you agree with what they say here:
"While we have stressed that Darwinian evolution lacks a capacity to elucidate the physical mechanisms underlying the transition from
non-life to life or to distinguish non-living from living, evolution
of some sort must still drive this transition (even if it does not
define it). It is probable that non-trivial information processing
systems with delocalized information are more evolutionarily robust
given that information can be preserved in the face of changing
environmental conditions due the physical separation of information
and its material representation."
BTW, Paul Davies (one of the authors of your paper) isn't the best
starting point for questions like these. Here is some of the woo he's written about in other contexts:
https://grokipedia.com/page/the_mind_of_god
"Davies draws on the participatory anthropic principle, influenced by physicist John Wheeler, positing that conscious observation plays a constitutive role in actualizing quantum events and, by extension, the universe's historical unfolding. In this framework, the cosmos
retroactively influences its own origins through measurement acts by
later observers, fostering a feedback loop that culminates in self-knowledge.3 He highlights how fine-tuned physical constantsrCosuch
as the small scale of the cosmological constantrCofacilitate the
complexity required for life and cognition, suggesting these
parameters are calibrated for the production of minds that can decode
them.19 Empirical evidence from cosmology, including the cosmic
microwave background uniformity observed by COBE satellite data in
1992, underscores this observer-dependent coherence, though Davies
cautions that quantum interpretations remain interpretive rather than proven.3"
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 2/11/2026 10:28 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:35:05 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
No, there's nothing tongue-in-cheek about it. This was an actual
argument put forward by Hoyle in his crackpot years.
My reference to Hoyle was tongue-in-cheek.
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are >>>>> constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>> key property."
Which is not the same thing as an "information problem."
That's an introductory paragraph from the paper cited. You've jumped in
with your refutation before even reading the (short) selection of quotes
I provided.
an information problem with OOL?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
Hint: "A major unsolved problem" and "how information control emerges ab >initio"
Before we go any further, let's have your clear response. Would you
agree that this states an information problem with OOL?
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially >>> new or radical [9u11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact
that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]uit is the information that determines the current state >>> and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent
causationumediated by the onset of information controluthat is the key
defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition >>>from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic >>> information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter.
Do you agree with that approach?
We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that >>> we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
Do you agree with what they said right after that?
"Digitization may have been a natural outcome of this process in
reaction networks that had once been primarily analogue. At this
point, information would have become separated from its physical
representation, permitting information to become a causal influence in
its own right, and the language of Turing and von Neumann would have
begun to apply."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
So do you believe the emergence of "information control" is the only
problem abiogenesis research has in the context of "the information
problem"?
And do you agree with what they say here:
"While we have stressed that Darwinian evolution lacks a capacity to
elucidate the physical mechanisms underlying the transition from
non-life to life or to distinguish non-living from living, evolution
of some sort must still drive this transition (even if it does not
define it). It is probable that non-trivial information processing
systems with delocalized information are more evolutionarily robust
given that information can be preserved in the face of changing
environmental conditions due the physical separation of information
and its material representation."
BTW, Paul Davies (one of the authors of your paper) isn't the best
starting point for questions like these. Here is some of the woo he's
written about in other contexts:
https://grokipedia.com/page/the_mind_of_god
"Davies draws on the participatory anthropic principle, influenced by
physicist John Wheeler, positing that conscious observation plays a
constitutive role in actualizing quantum events and, by extension, the
universe's historical unfolding. In this framework, the cosmos
retroactively influences its own origins through measurement acts by
later observers, fostering a feedback loop that culminates in
self-knowledge.3 He highlights how fine-tuned physical constantsusuch
as the small scale of the cosmological constantufacilitate the
complexity required for life and cognition, suggesting these
parameters are calibrated for the production of minds that can decode
them.19 Empirical evidence from cosmology, including the cosmic
microwave background uniformity observed by COBE satellite data in
1992, underscores this observer-dependent coherence, though Davies
cautions that quantum interpretations remain interpretive rather than
proven.3"
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G%del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 11:51:38 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 10:28 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:35:05 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine >>>>> guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
No, there's nothing tongue-in-cheek about it. This was an actual
argument put forward by Hoyle in his crackpot years.
My reference to Hoyle was tongue-in-cheek.
In what sense?
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are >>>>>> constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what >>>> is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>>> key property."
Which is not the same thing as an "information problem."
That's an introductory paragraph from the paper cited. You've jumped in
with your refutation before even reading the (short) selection of quotes
I provided.
No, actually I refuted them in the order you listed them in your post.
Referring to the last portion I quoted, would you agree that thisstates
an information problem with OOL?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred." >>
Hint: "A major unsolved problem" and "how information control emerges ab
initio"
Did you see my question on what you understand "information control"
to mean?
Before we go any further, let's have your clear response. Would you
agree that this states an information problem with OOL?
Not in a way that would necessitate the use of the word "information."
It's like saying the information content of the sky is what causes its
blue color. I mean you *could* say that, but it's not necessary for understanding the phenomenon under consideration.
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially >>>> new or radical [9rCo11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact >>>> that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]rCoit is the information that determines the current state >>>> and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent >>>> causationrComediated by the onset of information controlrCothat is the key >>>> defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure >>>> of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic >>>> information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter.
Do you agree with that approach?
We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that >>>> we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >>>> kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >>>> become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
Do you agree with what they said right after that?
"Digitization may have been a natural outcome of this process in
reaction networks that had once been primarily analogue. At this
point, information would have become separated from its physical
representation, permitting information to become a causal influence in
its own right, and the language of Turing and von Neumann would have
begun to apply."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com >>>So do you believe the emergence of "information control" is the only
problem abiogenesis research has in the context of "the information
problem"?
And do you agree with what they say here:
"While we have stressed that Darwinian evolution lacks a capacity to
elucidate the physical mechanisms underlying the transition from
non-life to life or to distinguish non-living from living, evolution
of some sort must still drive this transition (even if it does not
define it). It is probable that non-trivial information processing
systems with delocalized information are more evolutionarily robust
given that information can be preserved in the face of changing
environmental conditions due the physical separation of information
and its material representation."
BTW, Paul Davies (one of the authors of your paper) isn't the best
starting point for questions like these. Here is some of the woo he's
written about in other contexts:
https://grokipedia.com/page/the_mind_of_god
"Davies draws on the participatory anthropic principle, influenced by
physicist John Wheeler, positing that conscious observation plays a
constitutive role in actualizing quantum events and, by extension, the
universe's historical unfolding. In this framework, the cosmos
retroactively influences its own origins through measurement acts by
later observers, fostering a feedback loop that culminates in
self-knowledge.3 He highlights how fine-tuned physical constantsrCosuch
as the small scale of the cosmological constantrCofacilitate the
complexity required for life and cognition, suggesting these
parameters are calibrated for the production of minds that can decode
them.19 Empirical evidence from cosmology, including the cosmic
microwave background uniformity observed by COBE satellite data in
1992, underscores this observer-dependent coherence, though Davies
cautions that quantum interpretations remain interpretive rather than
proven.3"
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G||del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 2/11/2026 2:06 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 11:51:38 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 10:28 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:35:05 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>>>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is >>>>>>> arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he >>>>>> (as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine >>>>>> guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
No, there's nothing tongue-in-cheek about it. This was an actual
argument put forward by Hoyle in his crackpot years.
My reference to Hoyle was tongue-in-cheek.
In what sense?
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis throughNo such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are >>>>>>> constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL. >>>>>>
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what >>>>> is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general >>>>> agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>>>> key property."
Which is not the same thing as an "information problem."
That's an introductory paragraph from the paper cited. You've jumped in
with your refutation before even reading the (short) selection of quotes >>> I provided.
No, actually I refuted them in the order you listed them in your post.
Referring to the last portion I quoted, would you agree that thisstates
an information problem with OOL?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
Hint: "A major unsolved problem" and "how information control emerges ab >>> initio"
Did you see my question on what you understand "information control"
to mean?
Before we go any further, let's have your clear response. Would you
agree that this states an information problem with OOL?
Not in a way that would necessitate the use of the word "information."
It's like saying the information content of the sky is what causes its
blue color. I mean you *could* say that, but it's not necessary for
understanding the phenomenon under consideration.
Let's recap:
1. You dismissed my claim of an OOL information problem, without
support, and with the gratuitous labelling of "just a creationist buzzword."
2. I quoted from a paper that straightforwardly disproved your
throw-away assertion: "A major unsolved problem is to determine how >information control emerges ab initio".
3. Did you concede? No. You ducked and deflected.
4. So I challenged you point-blank to give a straight answer to my
question, "Would you agree that the paper states an information problem
with OOL?"
5. But you chose to keep digging, even at the cost of this
self-discrediting absurdism: "Not in a way that would necessitate the
use of the word "information." It's like saying the information content
of the sky is what causes its blue color. I mean you *could* say that,
but it's not necessary for understanding the phenomenon under >consideration."
Vincent, why do you do this?
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially >>>>> new or radical [9u11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact >>>>> that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]uit is the information that determines the current state >>>>> and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In >>>>> this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent >>>>> causationumediated by the onset of information controluthat is the key >>>>> defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition >>>> >from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure >>>>> of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic >>>>> information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter.
Do you agree with that approach?
We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How didDo you agree with what they said right after that?
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that >>>>> we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >>>>> kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >>>>> become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred." >>>>
"Digitization may have been a natural outcome of this process in
reaction networks that had once been primarily analogue. At this
point, information would have become separated from its physical
representation, permitting information to become a causal influence in >>>> its own right, and the language of Turing and von Neumann would have
begun to apply."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com >>>>So do you believe the emergence of "information control" is the only
problem abiogenesis research has in the context of "the information
problem"?
And do you agree with what they say here:
"While we have stressed that Darwinian evolution lacks a capacity to
elucidate the physical mechanisms underlying the transition from
non-life to life or to distinguish non-living from living, evolution
of some sort must still drive this transition (even if it does not
define it). It is probable that non-trivial information processing
systems with delocalized information are more evolutionarily robust
given that information can be preserved in the face of changing
environmental conditions due the physical separation of information
and its material representation."
BTW, Paul Davies (one of the authors of your paper) isn't the best
starting point for questions like these. Here is some of the woo he's >>>> written about in other contexts:
https://grokipedia.com/page/the_mind_of_god
"Davies draws on the participatory anthropic principle, influenced by
physicist John Wheeler, positing that conscious observation plays a
constitutive role in actualizing quantum events and, by extension, the >>>> universe's historical unfolding. In this framework, the cosmos
retroactively influences its own origins through measurement acts by
later observers, fostering a feedback loop that culminates in
self-knowledge.3 He highlights how fine-tuned physical constantsusuch
as the small scale of the cosmological constantufacilitate the
complexity required for life and cognition, suggesting these
parameters are calibrated for the production of minds that can decode
them.19 Empirical evidence from cosmology, including the cosmic
microwave background uniformity observed by COBE satellite data in
1992, underscores this observer-dependent coherence, though Davies
cautions that quantum interpretations remain interpretive rather than
proven.3"
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>>>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>>>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G%del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is >>>>>> not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your >>>>>> video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of >>>>>> "spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 15:14:42 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 2:06 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 11:51:38 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 10:28 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 08:35:05 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is >>>>>>>> arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he >>>>>>> (as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine >>>>>>> guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between >>>>>> types of "dissipative structures".
No, there's nothing tongue-in-cheek about it. This was an actual
argument put forward by Hoyle in his crackpot years.
My reference to Hoyle was tongue-in-cheek.
In what sense?
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis throughNo such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is >>>>>>> "emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are >>>>>>>> constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL. >>>>>>>
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what >>>>>> is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general >>>>>> agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>>>>> key property."
Which is not the same thing as an "information problem."
That's an introductory paragraph from the paper cited. You've jumped in >>>> with your refutation before even reading the (short) selection of quotes >>>> I provided.
No, actually I refuted them in the order you listed them in your post.
Referring to the last portion I quoted, would you agree that thisstates
an information problem with OOL?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >>>> kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >>>> become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
Hint: "A major unsolved problem" and "how information control emerges ab >>>> initio"
Did you see my question on what you understand "information control"
to mean?
Before we go any further, let's have your clear response. Would you
agree that this states an information problem with OOL?
Not in a way that would necessitate the use of the word "information."
It's like saying the information content of the sky is what causes its
blue color. I mean you *could* say that, but it's not necessary for
understanding the phenomenon under consideration.
Let's recap:
1. You dismissed my claim of an OOL information problem, without
support, and with the gratuitous labelling of "just a creationist buzzword."
Support would be, tell me something in abiogenesis research that
*depends on* information for its elucidation in that research, and
I'll tell you how to phrase it so that the concept of information
isn't needed.
2. I quoted from a paper that straightforwardly disproved your
throw-away assertion: "A major unsolved problem is to determine how
information control emerges ab initio".
3. Did you concede? No. You ducked and deflected.
There was no concession necessary, although I suppose having your
ideas debunked might seem to involve ducking or deflection, from your
point of view.
4. So I challenged you point-blank to give a straight answer to my
question, "Would you agree that the paper states an information problem
with OOL?"
Right. And then...
5. But you chose to keep digging, even at the cost of this
self-discrediting absurdism: "Not in a way that would necessitate the
use of the word "information." It's like saying the information content
of the sky is what causes its blue color. I mean you *could* say that,
but it's not necessary for understanding the phenomenon under
consideration."
How is that an absurdism?
Vincent, why do you do this?
Do what?
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy
and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical [9???11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]???it is the information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent causation???mediated by the onset of information control???that is the key defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter. We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that
we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and become increasingly refined after ???algorithmic takeover??? has occurred."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but
assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be
where Principia Darwinia meets its G??del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 2026-11-01, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/11/2026 12:57 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:55:57 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
...
A universal characteristic of life is its ability to utilise raw energy >>>> and maintain a far-from-equilibrium homeostasis. However, life is
arguably the antithesis of a hurricane (just ask Fred Hoyle).
You mean Fred Hoyle of the "Tornado in a Junkyard Fallacy"? that he
(as an atheist) tried to use to prove panspermia, rather than divine
guidance?
Yes. A tongue-in-cheek reference, but a serious distinction between
types of "dissipative structures".
Life achieves its energy-harnessing far-from-equilibrium homeostasis through
complex and highly specific molecular machines, which themselves are
constructed from genetic and epigenetic information.
This points us again to the emerging "information problem" of OOL.
No such information problem (at least in abiogenesis research) is
"emerging." It's just a creationist buzzword.
*This* information problem:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical [9???11]. What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact
that in biological systems information is not merely a way to label
states, but a property of the system. To be explicit, biological
information is distinctive because it possesses a type of causal
efficacy [23,24]???it is the information that determines the current state >> and hence the dynamics (and therefore also the future state(s)).3 In
this paper, we postulate that it is the transition to context-dependent
causation???mediated by the onset of information control???that is the key >> defining characteristic of life. We therefore identify the transition
from non-life to life with a fundamental shift in the causal structure
of the system, specifically a transition to a state in which algorithmic
information gains direct, context-dependent, causal efficacy over
matter. We now turn to the question of how all this came about. How did
information first gain causal purchase over certain complex systems that
we now call living organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after ???algorithmic takeover??? has occurred." >>
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
And at the end check out end note 3 ...
"The question of whether a causal chain expressed in informational
language at the system level can ultimately be reduced, at least in principle, to a mechanistic causal chain at the molecular level, is the subject of a longstanding debate, complicated by the fact that
biological systems are always open. We make no attempt to engage this notorious philosophical topic here, because it is irrelevant for the
present discussion whether information is in fact a fundamental causal
agent (which would represent a radical departure from standard physics),
or may be treated merely phenomenologically as an effective causal
agent."
There is a lot of hand waving when discussing "information" in biological systems.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/
And at the end check out end note 3 ...
"The question of whether a causal chain expressed in informational
language at the system level can ultimately be reduced, at least in principle, to a mechanistic causal chain at the molecular level, is the subject of a longstanding debate, complicated by the fact that
biological systems are always open. We make no attempt to engage this notorious philosophical topic here, because it is irrelevant for the
present discussion whether information is in fact a fundamental causal
agent (which would represent a radical departure from standard physics),
or may be treated merely phenomenologically as an effective causal
agent."
There is a lot of hand waving when discussing "information" in biological systems.
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G??del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
On 3/11/2026 4:46 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/
And at the end check out end note 3 ...
"The question of whether a causal chain expressed in informational
language at the system level can ultimately be reduced, at least in
principle, to a mechanistic causal chain at the molecular level, is the
subject of a longstanding debate, complicated by the fact that
biological systems are always open. We make no attempt to engage this
notorious philosophical topic here, because it is irrelevant for the
present discussion whether information is in fact a fundamental causal
agent (which would represent a radical departure from standard physics),
or may be treated merely phenomenologically as an effective causal
agent."
There is a lot of hand waving when discussing "information" in biological
systems.
Possibly so, but don't throw the baby out, e.g.:
"Research investigating the origins of life usually either focuses on >exploring possible life-bearing chemistries in the pre-biotic Earth, or
else on synthetic approaches. Comparatively little work has explored >fundamental issues concerning the spontaneous emergence of life using
only concepts (such as information
and evolution) that are divorced from
any particular chemistry."
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26062909/
Interesting though that the end note you quoted references "present >discussion [as to] whether information is in fact a fundamental causal >agent", and parenthetically suggests that this "would represent a
radical departure from standard physics". Perhaps this is a more radical >idea than I've appreciated?
It seems fair to say that more work needs to be done in defining and >quantifying "information" in a biological context. Nevertheless,
information seems to be a brute reality in biology.
For example, a
recent phylogenetic reconciliation suggests that LUCA had a genome of at >least 2.5?Mb, encoding around 2,600 proteins*. That's real,
highly-specific data sequences (aka "information"), providing real and >essential causal control.
* https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02461-1
Obtaining suitable building blocks on an early Earth is one thing, but >>>>> assembling them is where the problem goes exponential. This may even be >>>>> where Principia Darwinia meets its G??del reckoning.
This new Long Story Story episode discusses this:
https://youtu.be/wO3h6oN6y9Q?si=mzvMb6fW6gCJ74vb
A reaction that's not spontaneous (i.e., its Gibbs energy change is
not negative) can happen if energy is added to the reaction. Your
video seems to equivocate between this and a popular definition of
"spontaneous," i.e., "will happen on its own."
For example, aSo you could just refer to it as "data sequence," not "information."
recent phylogenetic reconciliation suggests that LUCA had a genome of at
least 2.5?Mb, encoding around 2,600 proteins*. That's real,
highly-specific data sequences (aka "information"), providing real and
essential causal control.
*https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02461-1
And where did you get "highly specific" as part of information theory,
as well?
On 6/11/2026 1:20 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
For example, aSo you could just refer to it as "data sequence," not "information."
recent phylogenetic reconciliation suggests that LUCA had a genome of at >>> least 2.5?Mb, encoding around 2,600 proteins*. That's real,
highly-specific data sequences (aka "information"), providing real and
essential causal control.
*https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02461-1
And where did you get "highly specific" as part of information theory,
as well?
Why are you so bent on avoiding the 'i' word?
Let me answer that for you.
The proteins in LUCA
would average hundreds of units, and at this early
stage, necessarily with highly specific sequences to enable them to fold >efficiently and perform their enzymatic etc functions. All 2,600 of
them. That's a very large amount highly specific sequencing.
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
Here's your problem. Evolution (post-OOL) readily claims the
accumulation of information through the ratcheting mechanism of natural >section (cites below). Some significant portion of OOL is, by
definition, pre-Darwinian evolution.
Hence the OOL problem of
information production and accumulation. It's a bootstrapping conundrum.
I'm sorry to have to inform you that your semantic deflections will not
make the information problem of OOL go away.
_______
oSelection causes populations to accumulate information about the >environment.o >https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/jeb.12010?
oInformation gain by natural selection.o >https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10908337/
Etc etc.
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
As I've mentioned elsewhere, information is everywhere. You don't have
to rely on arcane physics theories to recognize this.
For example, let's say you assign 0 to a day without rain and 1 to a
day *with* rain, and then collect weather conditions for the month of November so far. And let's say that it rained on November 1, rained
on November 2, was clear on November 3, rained on November 4, and was
another sunny day on November 5. Then write down your results in
terms of the ones and zeroes mentioned above. You get:
11010
So right there we have a very small amount of information, but it's information nonetheless, and I'm sure you wouldn't wonder where that information "came from" or how it developed the way you do with
information in the genome.
On 6/11/2026 1:12 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
...
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
As I've mentioned elsewhere, information is everywhere. You don't have
to rely on arcane physics theories to recognize this.
For example, let's say you assign 0 to a day without rain and 1 to a
day *with* rain, and then collect weather conditions for the month of
November so far. And let's say that it rained on November 1, rained
on November 2, was clear on November 3, rained on November 4, and was
another sunny day on November 5. Then write down your results in
terms of the ones and zeroes mentioned above. You get:
11010
So right there we have a very small amount of information, but it's
information nonetheless, and I'm sure you wouldn't wonder where that
information "came from" or how it developed the way you do with
information in the genome.
No.
Information is increasingly recognised as a central characteristic
of life:
"What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological
systems information is not merely a way to label states, but a property
of the system. To be explicit, biological information is distinctive
because it possesses a type of causal efficacy"
Congratulations - you get a mention, as one of the "side-steppers". You
have been persistently unwilling or unable to acknowledge or understand >reality and role of information in this context.
The quote in expanded form, as provided earlier:
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general >agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical.
What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in
biological systems information is not merely a way to label states, but
a property of the system.
To be explicit, biological information is
distinctive because it possesses a type of causal efficacy u it is the >information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics
(and therefore also the future state(s)).
In this paper, we postulate
that it is the transition to context-dependent causationumediated by the >onset of information control u that is the key defining characteristic
of life.
We therefore identify the transition from non-life to life with
a fundamental shift in the causal structure of the system, specifically
a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct, >context-dependent, causal efficacy over matter.
We now turn to the
question of how all this came about. How did information first gain
causal purchase over certain complex systems that we now call living >organisms?"
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
...
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 14:00:42 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 1:12 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
...
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
As I've mentioned elsewhere, information is everywhere. You don't have
to rely on arcane physics theories to recognize this.
For example, let's say you assign 0 to a day without rain and 1 to a
day *with* rain, and then collect weather conditions for the month of
November so far. And let's say that it rained on November 1, rained
on November 2, was clear on November 3, rained on November 4, and was
another sunny day on November 5. Then write down your results in
terms of the ones and zeroes mentioned above. You get:
11010
So right there we have a very small amount of information, but it's
information nonetheless, and I'm sure you wouldn't wonder where that
information "came from" or how it developed the way you do with
information in the genome.
No.
Actually, yes.
Information is increasingly recognised as a central characteristic
of life:
"What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological
systems information is not merely a way to label states, but a property
of the system. To be explicit, biological information is distinctive
because it possesses a type of causal efficacy"
How about "instruction sets and results" instead of "biological
information"?
Congratulations - you get a mention, as one of the "side-steppers". You
have been persistently unwilling or unable to acknowledge or understand
reality and role of information in this context.
The quote in expanded form, as provided earlier:
Why do you have a quote in condensed and expanded form?
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the
key property."
Let's make sure you're not claiming that reliance on information is
something restricted to living things.
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially
new or radical.
Do you agree that your fascination with information in biology is not
"new or radical"?
What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in
biological systems information is not merely a way to label states, but
a property of the system.
It should be both, as they seem to imply.
To be explicit, biological information is
distinctive because it possesses a type of causal efficacy rCo it is the
information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics
(and therefore also the future state(s)).
Why not "genetic instructions and their results" rather than
"biological information"?
In this paper, we postulate
that it is the transition to context-dependent causationrComediated by the >> onset of information control rCo that is the key defining characteristic
of life.
The authors of the article may not be typical of mainstream science on
this claim.
We therefore identify the transition from non-life to life with
a fundamental shift in the causal structure of the system, specifically
a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct,
context-dependent, causal efficacy over matter.
"Evolutionary results" rather than "algorithmic information" might be
useful in this situation.
We now turn to the
question of how all this came about. How did information first gain
causal purchase over certain complex systems that we now call living
organisms?"
And what was wrong with their answer to this question?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
"Biological results" rather than "information control" might be a good alternative terminology use here.
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
What did I tell you about Paul Davies the last time you referred to
this article?
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
...
On 6/11/2026 9:35 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 14:00:42 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 1:12 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
...
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
As I've mentioned elsewhere, information is everywhere. You don't have >>>> to rely on arcane physics theories to recognize this.
For example, let's say you assign 0 to a day without rain and 1 to a
day *with* rain, and then collect weather conditions for the month of
November so far. And let's say that it rained on November 1, rained
on November 2, was clear on November 3, rained on November 4, and was
another sunny day on November 5. Then write down your results in
terms of the ones and zeroes mentioned above. You get:
11010
So right there we have a very small amount of information, but it's
information nonetheless, and I'm sure you wouldn't wonder where that
information "came from" or how it developed the way you do with
information in the genome.
No.
Actually, yes.
Monty Python Argument skit?
Information is increasingly recognised as a central characteristic
of life:
"What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological
systems information is not merely a way to label states, but a property
of the system. To be explicit, biological information is distinctive
because it possesses a type of causal efficacy"
How about "instruction sets and results" instead of "biological
information"?
Avoiding the i-word again.
Congratulations - you get a mention, as one of the "side-steppers". You
have been persistently unwilling or unable to acknowledge or understand
reality and role of information in this context.
The quote in expanded form, as provided earlier:
Why do you have a quote in condensed and expanded form?
To underline the direct rebuttal of your claim, and then put in context.
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what
is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>> key property."
Let's make sure you're not claiming that reliance on information is
something restricted to living things.
What do you mean?
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially >>> new or radical.
Do you agree that your fascination with information in biology is not
"new or radical"?
Not suggesting it was.
What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in
biological systems information is not merely a way to label states, but
a property of the system.
It should be both, as they seem to imply.
Why then your insistent avoidance of the latter?
To be explicit, biological information is
distinctive because it possesses a type of causal efficacy u it is the
information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics
(and therefore also the future state(s)).
Why not "genetic instructions and their results" rather than
"biological information"?
More i-word avoidance.
In this paper, we postulate
that it is the transition to context-dependent causationumediated by the >>> onset of information control u that is the key defining characteristic
of life.
The authors of the article may not be typical of mainstream science on
this claim.
We're living on the cutting edge here, Vincent.
We therefore identify the transition from non-life to life with
a fundamental shift in the causal structure of the system, specifically
a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct,
context-dependent, causal efficacy over matter.
"Evolutionary results" rather than "algorithmic information" might be
useful in this situation.
And...strike three for i-word avoidance.
We now turn to the
question of how all this came about. How did information first gain
causal purchase over certain complex systems that we now call living
organisms?"
And what was wrong with their answer to this question?
Que?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
"Biological results" rather than "information control" might be a good
alternative terminology use here.
4 x i-word avoidance - a PB?
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical
kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and
become increasingly refined after aalgorithmic takeoverA has occurred."
What did I tell you about Paul Davies the last time you referred to
this article?
Your opinion.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com >>>
...
Your one-line tit-for-tat
only fragments and derails discussion. I trust
my matching responses reinforce this lesson.
On Sun, 8 Nov 2026 19:09:19 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 9:35 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 14:00:42 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 1:12 pm, Vincent Maycock wrote:
...
Which is coded in LUCA's genome. And what does a genome
contain? *Information*.
As I've mentioned elsewhere, information is everywhere. You don't have >>>>> to rely on arcane physics theories to recognize this.
For example, let's say you assign 0 to a day without rain and 1 to a >>>>> day *with* rain, and then collect weather conditions for the month of >>>>> November so far. And let's say that it rained on November 1, rained >>>>> on November 2, was clear on November 3, rained on November 4, and was >>>>> another sunny day on November 5. Then write down your results in
terms of the ones and zeroes mentioned above. You get:
11010
So right there we have a very small amount of information, but it's
information nonetheless, and I'm sure you wouldn't wonder where that >>>>> information "came from" or how it developed the way you do with
information in the genome.
No.
Actually, yes.
Monty Python Argument skit?
You mean the skit two doors down! In any case, perhaps you should
explain what you mean by your cryptic statement of "No".
Information is increasingly recognised as a central characteristic
of life:
"What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in biological
systems information is not merely a way to label states, but a property >>>> of the system. To be explicit, biological information is distinctive
because it possesses a type of causal efficacy"
How about "instruction sets and results" instead of "biological
information"?
Avoiding the i-word again.
All I'm doing is backing up my claim that the word "information"
doesn't have to be used in order to be interested in or familiar with biology.
Congratulations - you get a mention, as one of the "side-steppers". You >>>> have been persistently unwilling or unable to acknowledge or understand >>>> reality and role of information in this context.
The quote in expanded form, as provided earlier:
Why do you have a quote in condensed and expanded form?
To underline the direct rebuttal of your claim, and then put in context.
So there was a context in which you were unable to rebut my claim!
"Although it has been notoriously difficult to pin down precisely what >>>> is it that makes life so distinctive and remarkable, there is general
agreement that its informational aspect is one key property, perhaps the >>>> key property."
Let's make sure you're not claiming that reliance on information is
something restricted to living things.
What do you mean?
Do you believe the concept of "information" is relevant to scientific
areas outside biology?
"The central position of information in biology is not itself especially >>>> new or radical.
Do you agree that your fascination with information in biology is not
"new or radical"?
Not suggesting it was.
Good.
What is often sidestepped, however, is the fact that in
biological systems information is not merely a way to label states, but >>>> a property of the system.
It should be both, as they seem to imply.
Why then your insistent avoidance of the latter?
Either one is useful. The point is, though, that ID proponents are
wrong to believe "information" per se is a problem for evolution and abiogenesis.
To be explicit, biological information is
distinctive because it possesses a type of causal efficacy rCo it is the >>>> information that determines the current state and hence the dynamics
(and therefore also the future state(s)).
Why not "genetic instructions and their results" rather than
"biological information"?
More i-word avoidance.
See above.
In this paper, we postulate
that it is the transition to context-dependent causationrComediated by the >>>> onset of information control rCo that is the key defining characteristic >>>> of life.
The authors of the article may not be typical of mainstream science on
this claim.
We're living on the cutting edge here, Vincent.
A * definition* is cutting edge?
We therefore identify the transition from non-life to life with
a fundamental shift in the causal structure of the system, specifically >>>> a transition to a state in which algorithmic information gains direct, >>>> context-dependent, causal efficacy over matter.
"Evolutionary results" rather than "algorithmic information" might be
useful in this situation.
And...strike three for i-word avoidance.
See above.
We now turn to the
question of how all this came about. How did information first gain
causal purchase over certain complex systems that we now call living
organisms?"
And what was wrong with their answer to this question?
Que?
Do you agree with them that the usage of "information" is a step
forward in abiogenesis research?
"A major unsolved problem is to determine how information control
"Biological results" rather than "information control" might be a good
alternative terminology use here.
4 x i-word avoidance - a PB?
See above.
emerges ab initio, for example, in an RNA world setting, from chemical >>>> kinetics, as well as how primitive control mechanisms might evolve and >>>> become increasingly refined after rCyalgorithmic takeoverrCO has occurred."
What did I tell you about Paul Davies the last time you referred to
this article?
Your opinion.
And how did my"opinion" relate to the link I posted there?
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3565706/?utm_source=chatgpt.com >>>>
...
Your one-line tit-for-tat
Which you seem to consume with gusto.
only fragments and derails discussion. I trust
my matching responses reinforce this lesson.
Well, it was you that was derailed, not me.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 58:21:33 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,989 |