• Cometary impacts may not have delivered life origin chemicals as first thought

    From Pro Plyd@invalide@invalid.invalid to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 21:36:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins


    Popular press article

    https://studyfinds.com/comets-didnt-deliver-life-earth/

    LiferCOs starter chemical may not have hitched a
    ride on a comet after all. In computer simulations
    of early EarthrCOs comet bombardment, more than half
    of 100,000 runs produced not one strike that
    delivered enough hydrogen cyanide, a molecule lab
    experiments use to build sugars, fats and genetic
    material, to get liferCOs chemistry going.
    ...


    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-74214-y
    Cometary impacts an unlikely pathway towards the
    origins of life on Earth

    Abstract
    An early period of cometary bombardment has long
    been speculated to provide an important source of
    prebiotic feedstock molecules, required for the
    origins of life on Earth. In support of this
    interpretation, comets boast a rich diversity of
    volatile organic molecules, with many thought to
    be limiting for prebiotic chemistry. Modelling
    studies suggest, however, that a significant
    proportion of these molecules will be destroyed
    during hypervelocity impact. Here, we revisit the
    ability of comets to deliver prebiotic feedstock
    molecules in the high concentrations required for
    prebiotic chemistry, leveraging recent advances
    in cometary impact simulations, comet-atmosphere
    interactions, and dynamical modelling of
    short-period cometsrCO origin and evolution. Taken
    together, the rapid decline in EarthrCOs cometary
    impact bombardment and the efficient destruction
    of fragile cometary organics indicate that the
    successful delivery of prebiotic feedstock
    molecules was an exceedingly rare event. Our
    results therefore challenge the long-held
    assumption that cometary impacts played an
    important role in the origins of life on Earth.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Sat Oct 31 09:50:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/30/2026 10:36 PM, Pro Plyd wrote:

    Popular press article

    https://studyfinds.com/comets-didnt-deliver-life-earth/

    LiferCOs starter chemical may not have hitched a
    ride on a comet after all. In computer simulations
    of early EarthrCOs comet bombardment, more than half
    of 100,000 runs produced not one strike that
    delivered enough hydrogen cyanide, a molecule lab
    experiments use to build sugars, fats and genetic
    material, to get liferCOs chemistry going.
    ...


    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-74214-y
    Cometary impacts an unlikely pathway towards the
    origins of life on Earth

    Abstract
    An early period of cometary bombardment has long
    been speculated to provide an important source of
    prebiotic feedstock molecules, required for the
    origins of life on Earth. In support of this
    interpretation, comets boast a rich diversity of
    volatile organic molecules, with many thought to
    be limiting for prebiotic chemistry. Modelling
    studies suggest, however, that a significant
    proportion of these molecules will be destroyed
    during hypervelocity impact. Here, we revisit the
    ability of comets to deliver prebiotic feedstock
    molecules in the high concentrations required for
    prebiotic chemistry, leveraging recent advances
    in cometary impact simulations, comet-atmosphere
    interactions, and dynamical modelling of
    short-period cometsrCO origin and evolution. Taken
    together, the rapid decline in EarthrCOs cometary
    impact bombardment and the efficient destruction
    of fragile cometary organics indicate that the
    successful delivery of prebiotic feedstock
    molecules was an exceedingly rare event. Our
    results therefore challenge the long-held
    assumption that cometary impacts played an
    important role in the origins of life on Earth.

    It doesn't matter. There was a PNAS commentary published earlier this
    year that demonstrated that hydrogen cyanide could be produce on earth
    using mineral catalysis without having methane present in the atmosphere.

    https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2608465123

    QUOTE:
    This commentary aims to provide context for the work by Yang et al. (1),
    who report the formation of hydrogen cyanide (HCN) from amino acids
    under geochemically plausible aqueous conditions. This discovery touches
    on a central question in origin-of-life research: How did the building
    blocks of life accumulate on the early Earth?
    END QUOTE:

    Yang et al., 2026
    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41871242/

    PubMed has a link to the open access article.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2