• 3D complexity gap

    From MarkE@me22over7@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 13:52:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity",
    along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the
    Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create
    persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with
    the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and
    biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary
    and speculative OOL models."

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can
    support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-the-actualOrigins

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Vincent Maycock@maycock@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 10:00:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:52:40 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:

    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a >"qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity", >along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating >speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the >Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create >persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with
    the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and >biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing >causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning >through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary
    and speculative OOL models."

    Do you agree that this has been enabled?

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical >investigation, gained momentum during the mid?twentieth century and was >often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that lifeAs origin poses a multifaceted >scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and >empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of >science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves >exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can >support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural,

    Why do you believe that?

    and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    What supposedly supports that argument?

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    That may describe many of them, but ID is even worse.

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    I think this goes with "translation" #2. And are you suggesting that
    no progress has occurred since then?

    4. We don't know,

    That's right! We don't know; of course, that's not the same thing as
    "some unknown supernatural force did it".

    and don't know how we will

    Do you agree with them that it's the nature of science to have more
    questions than answers?

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    So they seem to.
    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual >https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-the-actualOrigins

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 08:40:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    Vincent Maycock wrote:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:52:40 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:

    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a
    "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity",
    along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating
    speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the
    Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create
    persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with
    the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and
    biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing
    causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning
    through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary
    and speculative OOL models."

    Do you agree that this has been enabled?

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the mid?twentieth century and was
    often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a multifaceted
    scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and
    empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of
    science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves
    exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can
    support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural,

    Why do you believe that?

    and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    What supposedly supports that argument?

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    That may describe many of them, but ID is even worse.

    That's right! We don't know; of course, that's not the same thing as
    "some unknown supernatural force did it".

    If we don't know, then ID is not "even worse". It is neither ruled out
    nor supported. You demonstrate your bias here. It doesn't appeal to you,
    I guess?
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 10:16:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/29/2026 9:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity", along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with
    the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary
    and speculative OOL models."

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/ article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-the- actualOrigins


    The gaps are not Biblical and if the ID perps had actually filled them
    you would not be an IDiotic supporter of the ID scam. The gaps tell you
    that if there was a supernatural creator of the universe it was not the designer described in the Bible. That is why the other IDiots quit
    supporting the ID scam when the ID perps put out their Top Six gap
    arguments in the order in which they must have occurred in this
    universe. The ID perp's designer is not the one that anti-evolution
    IDiotic creationists like yourself want to believe in.

    You even claim that you can keep wallowing in the origin of life denial
    until the gap is filled, but you know that, that is a lie because it is
    the existence of the gap that you can't deal with and means that the
    Bible is wrong about the creation. You depend on the gap never being
    filled so that you can keep lying to yourself about reality. If Baal or
    Shiva fills that gap it would just be more about reality that you have
    to deny.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 09:25:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    RonO wrote:
    On 10/29/2026 9:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a
    "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of
    complexity", along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational
    complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating
    speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of
    the Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency
    create persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks.
    Along with the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches,
    metaphors and biased narrative scenarios have played an important
    role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a more
    systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling a more
    rigorous evaluation of fragmentary and speculative OOL models."

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and
    was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a
    multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any
    meaningful progress requires navigating a diverse landscape of
    theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature
    of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first
    involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as
    Mars, Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical
    activity can support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on
    detecting biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation
    telescopes to identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may
    indicate biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual
    https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/
    article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-the-
    actualOrigins


    The gaps are not Biblical and if the ID perps had actually filled them
    you would not be an IDiotic supporter of the ID scam.-a The gaps tell you that if there was a supernatural creator of the universe it was not the designer described in the Bible.-a That is why the other IDiots quit supporting the ID scam when the ID perps put out their Top Six gap
    arguments in the order in which they must have occurred in this
    universe.-a The ID perp's designer is not the one that anti-evolution IDiotic creationists like yourself want to believe in.

    There's two problems with this.

    - I. The atheists 'disproving' the designer in the Bible intelligently designed the universe are notably lacking in Theological knowledge.

    - II. When people go out to disprove in this manner, they are very heavy-handed. Critical in a way people are not while holding general discourse. You could call it bias, or excessive lifting. It's very
    disgusting & trying to any reader possessed of Theological knowledge.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Vincent Maycock@maycock@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 11:45:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 08:40:01 -0600, Blaine <cactus_DAC@yahoo.com>
    wrote:

    Vincent Maycock wrote:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:52:40 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:

    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a
    "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity", >>> along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating
    speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the
    Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create
    persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with
    the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and
    biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing >>> causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning >>> through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary
    and speculative OOL models."

    Do you agree that this has been enabled?

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the mid?twentieth century and was
    often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that lifeAs origin poses a multifaceted
    scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and
    empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of >>> science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves >>> exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can
    support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural,

    Why do you believe that?

    and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    What supposedly supports that argument?

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    That may describe many of them, but ID is even worse.

    That's right! We don't know; of course, that's not the same thing as
    "some unknown supernatural force did it".

    If we don't know, then ID is not "even worse". It is neither ruled out
    nor supported. You demonstrate your bias here. It doesn't appeal to you,
    I guess?

    ID deals with the lack of knowledge in a worse way, epistemologically
    speaking, than does conventional abiogenesis research.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 10:15:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    Vincent Maycock wrote:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 08:40:01 -0600, Blaine <cactus_DAC@yahoo.com>
    wrote:

    Vincent Maycock wrote:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 13:52:40 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:

    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a
    "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of complexity", >>>> along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating
    speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of the >>>> Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency create
    persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks. Along with >>>> the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches, metaphors and >>>> biased narrative scenarios have played an important role. By formalizing >>>> causal assumptions, they propose a more systematic approach to reasoning >>>> through these gaps, enabling a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary >>>> and speculative OOL models."

    Do you agree that this has been enabled?

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the mid?twentieth century and was >>>> often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a multifaceted >>>> scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any meaningful progress
    requires navigating a diverse landscape of theoretical approaches and
    empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature of >>>> science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first involves >>>> exploring our solar system, particularly environments such as Mars,
    Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical activity can
    support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on detecting
    biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation telescopes to
    identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may indicate
    biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural,

    Why do you believe that?

    and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    What supposedly supports that argument?

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    That may describe many of them, but ID is even worse.

    That's right! We don't know; of course, that's not the same thing as
    "some unknown supernatural force did it".

    If we don't know, then ID is not "even worse". It is neither ruled out
    nor supported. You demonstrate your bias here. It doesn't appeal to you,
    I guess?

    ID deals with the lack of knowledge in a worse way, epistemologically speaking, than does conventional abiogenesis research.

    Ok, failing that,

    Do you agree there is some 'wisdom' to the universe? If not for over-population, you & I would have it made.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 12:31:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/30/2026 10:25 AM, Blaine wrote:
    RonO wrote:
    On 10/29/2026 9:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as a
    "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of
    complexity", along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational
    complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in evaluating
    speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the Science of
    the Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical contingency
    create persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual frameworks.
    Along with the limitations imposed by current empirical approaches,
    metaphors and biased narrative scenarios have played an important
    role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a more
    systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling a more
    rigorous evaluation of fragmentary and speculative OOL models."

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and
    was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a
    multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any
    meaningful progress requires navigating a diverse landscape of
    theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the nature
    of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first
    involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such
    as Mars, Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical
    activity can support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on
    detecting biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation
    telescopes to identify atmospheric gases or surface features that may
    indicate biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual
    https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/
    article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-
    the- actualOrigins


    The gaps are not Biblical and if the ID perps had actually filled them
    you would not be an IDiotic supporter of the ID scam.-a The gaps tell
    you that if there was a supernatural creator of the universe it was
    not the designer described in the Bible.-a That is why the other IDiots
    quit supporting the ID scam when the ID perps put out their Top Six
    gap arguments in the order in which they must have occurred in this
    universe.-a The ID perp's designer is not the one that anti-evolution
    IDiotic creationists like yourself want to believe in.

    There's two problems with this.

    -a- I. The atheists 'disproving' the designer in the Bible intelligently designed the universe are notably lacking in Theological knowledge.

    No one cares. Atheists do not have to disprove anything. Atheists do
    not drive science forward. Science is just the best means that we have developed to understand nature. Nature has been demonstrated to not be Biblical since before Christ was born. The Greeks had estimated the cirrcumference of the earth by physical measurements a couple of
    centuries before Christ was born. The Hebrew Bible was just wrong about
    the earth being flat. The Big Bang demonstrates that the universe was
    not created in six magic acts whether they are six days or six periods
    of time. Nature is just not Biblical.

    All this just means that the Bible can't be used to support anyones
    religious beliefs, and those that still want to believe that the Bible
    is correct about nature like MarkE have to wallow in the denial. They
    do not want the gaps to be filled by the atheists or theists. Any
    designer that fills the current origin of life gap is not the designer described in the Bible. MarkE fully understands this because he ran
    from demonstrating that his origin of life gap was not Biblical, and he
    moped around for a couple of months before he came up with the insane
    notion that as long as the gap remained a gap he could lie to himself
    about reality and wallow in the denial. He understands that no matter
    how the gap is filled he loses. He has always depended on the ID perps
    lying to him about having filled those gaps with their intelligent
    design science. If the ID perps had not been lying to him for decades
    MarkE would have never become an IDiotic supporter of the creationist ID
    scam. Any ID science filling the origin of life gap would just be more science for MarkE to deny, just as he is in denial of all the evidence
    that tells him that life has been evolving on this planet for billions
    of years.



    -a- II. When people go out to disprove in this manner, they are very heavy-handed. Critical in a way people are not while holding general discourse. You could call it bias, or excessive lifting. It's very disgusting & trying to any reader possessed of Theological knowledge.

    There is no reason to disprove anything. The existence of the origin of
    life gap that MarkE is lying to himself about demonstrates that the
    Bible is wrong about the creation. That is the end of the story. That
    does not disprove that the Biblical designer exists, but it does
    disprove that the Bible has an accurate description of reality.
    Creationists like MarkE have to wallow in the gap denial because they
    can't face the reality that the Bible is wrong about nature. The earth
    is not flat, the universe is not geocentric, there is no solid firmament
    that holds the sun and moon above the earth. The sun and moon were not created on the 4th day or period of time, but were created around the
    same time that the earth was created during the formation of our solar
    system. Life has been evolving on this planet for billions of years. Wallowing in the origin of life gap denial will never change reality.
    Life was not created on earth during the 3rd day or period of time with
    the creation of the crop plants described in the Bible. As MarkE
    acknowledges life originated on this planet over 3 billion years ago
    under conditions that are far different than exist on earth today, and
    that life existed as microbes for billions of years before multicellular
    life evolved. The Cambrian explosion of sea creatures occurred long
    before land plants existed. The ancestors of the angiosperm crop plants
    did not evolve until dinos ruled the landscape of the earth. The
    authors of the Bible just got the creation story wrong.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 11:51:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    RonO wrote:
    On 10/30/2026 10:25 AM, Blaine wrote:
    RonO wrote:
    On 10/29/2026 9:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as
    a "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of
    complexity", along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational
    complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in
    evaluating speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the
    Science of the Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical
    contingency create persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual
    frameworks. Along with the limitations imposed by current empirical
    approaches, metaphors and biased narrative scenarios have played an
    important role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a
    more systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling a
    more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary and speculative OOL models."

    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and >>>> was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a
    multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any
    meaningful progress requires navigating a diverse landscape of
    theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the
    nature of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first
    involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such
    as Mars, Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical
    activity can support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on
    detecting biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation
    telescopes to identify atmospheric gases or surface features that
    may indicate biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing >>>>
    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey >>>>
    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual
    https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/
    article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-
    the- actualOrigins


    The gaps are not Biblical and if the ID perps had actually filled
    them you would not be an IDiotic supporter of the ID scam.-a The gaps
    tell you that if there was a supernatural creator of the universe it
    was not the designer described in the Bible.-a That is why the other
    IDiots quit supporting the ID scam when the ID perps put out their
    Top Six gap arguments in the order in which they must have occurred
    in this universe.-a The ID perp's designer is not the one that
    anti-evolution IDiotic creationists like yourself want to believe in.

    There's two problems with this.

    -a-a- I. The atheists 'disproving' the designer in the Bible
    intelligently designed the universe are notably lacking in Theological
    knowledge.

    No one cares.-a Atheists do not have to disprove anything.-a Atheists do
    not drive science forward.-a Science is just the best means that we have developed to understand nature.-a Nature has been demonstrated to not be Biblical since before Christ was born.-a The Greeks had estimated the cirrcumference of the earth by physical measurements a couple of
    centuries before Christ was born.-a The Hebrew Bible was just wrong about the earth being flat.-a The Big Bang demonstrates that the universe was
    not created in six magic acts whether they are six days or six periods
    of time.-a Nature is just not Biblical.

    All this just means that the Bible can't be used to support anyones religious beliefs, and those that still want to believe that the Bible
    is correct about nature like MarkE have to wallow in the denial.-a They
    do not want the gaps to be filled by the atheists or theists.-a Any
    designer that fills the current origin of life gap is not the designer described in the Bible.-a MarkE fully understands this because he ran
    from demonstrating that his origin of life gap was not Biblical, and he moped around for a couple of months before he came up with the insane
    notion that as long as the gap remained a gap he could lie to himself
    about reality and wallow in the denial.-a He understands that no matter
    how the gap is filled he loses.-a He has always depended on the ID perps lying to him about having filled those gaps with their intelligent
    design science.-a If the ID perps had not been lying to him for decades MarkE would have never become an IDiotic supporter of the creationist ID scam.-a Any ID science filling the origin of life gap would just be more science for MarkE to deny, just as he is in denial of all the evidence
    that tells him that life has been evolving on this planet for billions
    of years.



    -a-a- II. When people go out to disprove in this manner, they are very
    heavy-handed. Critical in a way people are not while holding general
    discourse. You could call it bias, or excessive lifting. It's very
    disgusting & trying to any reader possessed of Theological knowledge.

    There is no reason to disprove anything.-a The existence of the origin of life gap that MarkE is lying to himself about demonstrates that the
    Bible is wrong about the creation.-a That is the end of the story.

    I'm not convinced. I recently mocked the story of the Tower of Babylon,
    but none of my peers joined me in mocking it. Why do you claim to have
    such grand information about the Beginning that you say there is
    something wrong with the Creation story? I think your case is that the
    days are in a different combination than as written in Genesis. Show me
    this crystal ball that tells you the order. Also, show me that 3 Billion
    years of time might not horribly confuse your prioritization &
    positioning of these days.
    --
    Sometimes I just feel like I need to get away
    A place where I can be by myself, all alone
    I kinda lay down in the back yard
    Watch the leaves fall down on my face

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Fri Oct 30 14:34:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/30/2026 12:51 PM, Blaine wrote:
    RonO wrote:
    On 10/30/2026 10:25 AM, Blaine wrote:
    RonO wrote:
    On 10/29/2026 9:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    This paper [1] has an interesting representation of OOL progress as >>>>> a "qualitative morphospace in which three distinct aspects of
    complexity", along the axes of spatial, metabolic and informational >>>>> complexity.

    1. "the authors have examined the difficulties inherent in
    evaluating speculative hypotheses about the OOL (what they call the >>>>> Science of the Gaps), emphasizing how complexity and historical
    contingency create persistent gaps in both knowledge and conceptual >>>>> frameworks. Along with the limitations imposed by current empirical >>>>> approaches, metaphors and biased narrative scenarios have played an >>>>> important role. By formalizing causal assumptions, they propose a
    more systematic approach to reasoning through these gaps, enabling
    a more rigorous evaluation of fragmentary and speculative OOL models." >>>>>
    2. "this transition, from philosophical speculation to empirical
    investigation, gained momentum during the midreAtwentieth century and >>>>> was often considered the golden age of OOL research."

    3. "Building on the recognition that liferCOs origin poses a
    multifaceted scientific challenge, it becomes clear that any
    meaningful progress requires navigating a diverse landscape of
    theoretical approaches and empirical domains."

    4. "We close with more questions than answers, but that is the
    nature of science."

    5. "two promising avenues are actively being pursued. The first
    involves exploring our solar system, particularly environments such >>>>> as Mars, Europa and Enceladus, where liquid water and geochemical
    activity can support microbial ecosystems. The second focuses on
    detecting biosignatures from exoplanets, using next-generation
    telescopes to identify atmospheric gases or surface features that
    may indicate biological activity."


    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing >>>>>
    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models" >>>>>
    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey >>>>>
    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    5. Keep it chipper, skipper

    _______

    [1] Origins of life: the possible and the actual
    https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstb/
    article/380/1936/20240281/235158/Origins-of-life-the-possible-and-
    the- actualOrigins


    The gaps are not Biblical and if the ID perps had actually filled
    them you would not be an IDiotic supporter of the ID scam.-a The gaps >>>> tell you that if there was a supernatural creator of the universe it
    was not the designer described in the Bible.-a That is why the other
    IDiots quit supporting the ID scam when the ID perps put out their
    Top Six gap arguments in the order in which they must have occurred
    in this universe.-a The ID perp's designer is not the one that anti-
    evolution IDiotic creationists like yourself want to believe in.

    There's two problems with this.

    -a-a- I. The atheists 'disproving' the designer in the Bible
    intelligently designed the universe are notably lacking in
    Theological knowledge.

    No one cares.-a Atheists do not have to disprove anything.-a Atheists do
    not drive science forward.-a Science is just the best means that we
    have developed to understand nature.-a Nature has been demonstrated to
    not be Biblical since before Christ was born.-a The Greeks had
    estimated the cirrcumference of the earth by physical measurements a
    couple of centuries before Christ was born.-a The Hebrew Bible was just
    wrong about the earth being flat.-a The Big Bang demonstrates that the
    universe was not created in six magic acts whether they are six days
    or six periods of time.-a Nature is just not Biblical.

    All this just means that the Bible can't be used to support anyones
    religious beliefs, and those that still want to believe that the Bible
    is correct about nature like MarkE have to wallow in the denial.-a They
    do not want the gaps to be filled by the atheists or theists.-a Any
    designer that fills the current origin of life gap is not the designer
    described in the Bible.-a MarkE fully understands this because he ran
    from demonstrating that his origin of life gap was not Biblical, and
    he moped around for a couple of months before he came up with the
    insane notion that as long as the gap remained a gap he could lie to
    himself about reality and wallow in the denial.-a He understands that
    no matter how the gap is filled he loses.-a He has always depended on
    the ID perps lying to him about having filled those gaps with their
    intelligent design science.-a If the ID perps had not been lying to him
    for decades MarkE would have never become an IDiotic supporter of the
    creationist ID scam.-a Any ID science filling the origin of life gap
    would just be more science for MarkE to deny, just as he is in denial
    of all the evidence that tells him that life has been evolving on this
    planet for billions of years.



    -a-a- II. When people go out to disprove in this manner, they are very
    heavy-handed. Critical in a way people are not while holding general
    discourse. You could call it bias, or excessive lifting. It's very
    disgusting & trying to any reader possessed of Theological knowledge.

    There is no reason to disprove anything.-a The existence of the origin
    of life gap that MarkE is lying to himself about demonstrates that the
    Bible is wrong about the creation.-a That is the end of the story.

    I'm not convinced. I recently mocked the story of the Tower of Babylon,
    but none of my peers joined me in mocking it. Why do you claim to have
    such grand information about the Beginning that you say there is
    something wrong with the Creation story? I think your case is that the
    days are in a different combination than as written in Genesis. Show me
    this crystal ball that tells you the order. Also, show me that 3 Billion years of time might not horribly confuse your prioritization &
    positioning of these days.

    Snipping and running from reality does not change reality. You were
    obviously convinced enough to remove what you could not deal with. No
    one has to disprove the existence of some god in order to demonstrate
    that the Bible got the story of creation wrong. Back in 2017 pretty
    much all the IDiots left supporting the ID scam on TO were
    anti-evolution Biblical creationists (Kalkidas had only been pretending
    to be a hindu). The ID perps shot themselves in the head by presenting
    their Top Six god-of-the-gaps arguments in the order in which they must
    have occurred in this Universe. That order was not Biblical, and Kalk
    and Bill quit supporting the ID scam. Bill claimed that he had never supported the ID scam, and Kalk just claimed that he was going to focus
    on other aspects of his religious beliefs. Pagano claimed that the Top
    Six were not the best evidence for ID and tried to put up junk that had
    not made the best of ID list before he quit posting. MarkE and Glenn
    ran from the Top Six and MarkE is still running and cannot address them
    in an honest and straightforward manner.

    The reality is that the IDiotic gap denial does not support Biblical creationism. MarkE understands this to be true, but lies to himself
    about reality in order to keep wallowing in the denial so that he can
    keep believing what he wants to believe. Most of the other IDiots
    posting on TO could not do that. Nature is not Biblical. Science is
    just the best means that we have for understanding nature. No science
    whether it includes the supernatural or not is going to change the fact
    that the Bible contains an incorrect description of the creation. The 9 billion years after the Big Bang (#1 of the Top Six) that it took to
    create the elements needed to support life in our star poor region of
    this galaxy is not mentioned in the Bible (fine tuning, #2 of the Top
    Six). The Sun and moon formed around the same time that the earth
    formed during the creation of our solar system from 9 billion years of
    dead star material, and this is not mentioned in the Bible. The Bible
    gets it wrong about the sun and moon being made and placed in the
    firmament during the 4th day or period of time. The sun and moon
    existed long before plants were created during the 3rd day or period of
    time. The origin of life (#3 of the Top Six) on this planet may have
    occurred over 4 billion years ago. Life existed for billions of years
    as microorganisms (the bacterial flagellum may have evolved over 3
    billion years ago among these microorganisms, #4 of the Top Six) before evolving multicellular life within the last billion years of the
    existence of life on earth and this origin of life and biological
    evolution is not mentioned in the Bible, but multicellular sea creatures
    (the Cambrian explosion) that were supposed to have been created on the
    5th day or period of time evolved long before land plants evolved on
    this planet. There are no bird fossils associated with the Cambrian sea creatures (#5 of the Top Six), and birds were supposed to have also been created on the 5th day. Birds would not evolve from dinosaurs until
    around 150 million years ago, and the ancestors of the grain plants (angiosperm grasses) claimed to have been created on the 3rd day would
    not evolve until around 80 million years ago, long after sea creatures,
    land animals and birds existed. The ID perp's gaps in the human fossil
    record scam argument requires the accurate dating so that the gaps can
    be identified that exist between existing transitional fossil forms
    within the last 10 million years. If we could not date the fossils accurately, how would they know that the gaps existed? The earth is a
    lot older than a few thousand years even using the most recent human
    fossil gap denial stupidity (#6 of the Top Six).

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mark Isaak@specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net to talk-origins on Thu Nov 5 17:54:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/29/26 7:52 PM, MarkE wrote:
    Translating:

    1. the gaps are real and structural, and as I argue elsewhere, growing

    Define "gap". By any reasonable definition, the gaps are shrinking.

    2. OOL has been characterised by "fragmentary and speculative models"

    As opposed to creationist models, which are vague and contradictory.

    3. OOL's "golden age" is long past, e.g. the false dawn of Miller-Urey

    4. We don't know, and don't know how we will

    Sounds like science in action. All of the above could have been written
    about the structure of atoms, too.
    --
    Mark Isaak
    "Wisdom begins when you discover the difference between 'That
    doesn't make sense' and 'I don't understand.'" - Mary Doria Russell

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2