• Hats off to DD (2026)

    From MarkE@me22over7@gmail.com to talk-origins on Tue Oct 13 09:54:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    I commend David Deamer's follow-through on his own exhortation:

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and
    things like that...rCY [1]

    He and others did this:

    "At both the Kamchatka and the Mt Lassen sites, we added a defined set
    of primary molecular constituents of life to the hot springs. This
    included four amino acids (glycine, l-alanine, l-aspartic acid and
    l-valine, 1rCeg each), four nucleobases (adenine, cytosine, guanine and uracil, 1rCeg each) sodium phosphate (3rCeg), glycerol (2rCeg) and myristic acid (1.5rCeg). We expect that this mixture is a useful guide for
    monitoring degradation reactions, in addition to serving as a potential
    source of reactants for any synthetic reactions that might occur. The
    powdered mixture was first dissolved in approximately 1.0rCel hot water
    from the site and the resulting milky solution was poured into the
    boiling centre of the pond to start the experiment." [2]

    The results:

    "To summarize, the organic compounds required for the origin of life in
    a natural setting would have had a variety of possible fates other than
    those observed in a laboratory setting, where pure compounds react in
    glass containers. Our results show that self-assembly of boundary
    structures cannot occur under hot acidic conditions, at least with a
    simple amphiphile such as myristic acid. Furthermore, if di- and
    trivalent cations are present, as in the Kamchatka pool described here,
    the fatty acids will precipitate as insoluble soaps, which inhibits
    potential membrane formation. This limitation occurs not only for the
    boiling hot spring described here, but also for seawater, which has a relatively high content of calcium and magnesium ions (Monnard et al.
    2002)."

    The results cast major doubt on hydrothermal pools/vents:

    "From a biophysical perspective, these considerations suggest that the
    most plausible planetary environment for the origin of life would be an aqueous phase at moderate temperature ranges (less than 60-#C) and low
    ionic strength, having a pH value near neutrality with divalent cations
    at submillimolar concentrations. This suggestion is in marked contrast
    to the view that life most probably began in a geothermal or marine environment, perhaps even the extreme environment of a hydrothermal vent."

    Doubting the viability of marine environments turns attention to
    problems with fresh water alternatives:

    "One argument favouring a marine site for life's beginning is that fresh
    water would be rare on the early Earth. Even with today's extensive continental crust, fresh water represents only approximately 1% of the contemporary Earth's reservoir of liquid water. Another concern about a
    fresh water origin of life is that the lifetime of fresh water bodies
    tends to be short on a geological time-scale. On the other hand, if the temperature and ionic composition of a geothermal spring or seawater
    markedly inhibits self-assembly processes, we may need to reconsider the assumption that life inevitably began in such environments."

    Which leads them to:

    "A more plausible site for the origin of cellular life may be fresh
    water pools maintained by the rain falling on the earliest volcanic land masses and small continents."

    Indeed, you really cannot "sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You
    have to go to the field..."

    Well done Deamer and team - more of this please.

    _____


    [1] rCLA new model for the origin of life: Coupled phases and
    combinatorial selection in fluctuating hydrothermal pools.rCY https://youtu.be/nk_R55O24t4?feature=shared

    "[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
    want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
    it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've come up with to make
    substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
    employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
    so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
    experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and
    informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
    would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
    experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
    these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
    what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
    experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
    the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
    way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
    upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
    build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and
    things like that...rCY

    [2] "Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1664680

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From sticks@wolverine01@charter.net to talk-origins on Mon Oct 12 19:34:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/12/2026 5:54 PM, MarkE wrote:
    I commend David Deamer's follow-through on his own exhortation:

    Ditto.

    [2] "Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1664680

    I was interested in what kind of budget the group had to do this work
    and it was amazingly low. Total budget was $230,618. Using a real
    world environment instead of attempting to create one appears to have a financial benefit in this area of research.
    --
    Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From MarkE@me22over7@gmail.com to talk-origins on Tue Oct 13 15:30:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 13/10/2026 11:34 am, sticks wrote:
    On 10/12/2026 5:54 PM, MarkE wrote:
    I commend David Deamer's follow-through on his own exhortation:

    Ditto.

    [2] "Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment"
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1664680

    I was interested in what kind of budget the group had to do this work
    and it was amazingly low.-a Total budget was $230,618.-a Using a real
    world environment instead of attempting to create one appears to have a financial benefit in this area of research.


    Win-win.

    This work is where the rubber hits road - or where hypothesised
    prebiotic chemistry hits early-earth geology. It gives pause to OoL hand-waving and wishful speculation.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From MarkE@me22over7@gmail.com to talk-origins on Tue Oct 13 17:30:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 13/10/2026 9:54 am, MarkE wrote:

    Correction: title should read "2006"

    I commend David Deamer's follow-through on his own exhortation:

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and things like that...rCY [1]

    He and others did this:

    "At both the Kamchatka and the Mt Lassen sites, we added a defined set
    of primary molecular constituents of life to the hot springs. This
    included four amino acids (glycine, l-alanine, l-aspartic acid and l- valine, 1rCeg each), four nucleobases (adenine, cytosine, guanine and uracil, 1rCeg each) sodium phosphate (3rCeg), glycerol (2rCeg) and myristic acid (1.5rCeg). We expect that this mixture is a useful guide for
    monitoring degradation reactions, in addition to serving as a potential source of reactants for any synthetic reactions that might occur. The powdered mixture was first dissolved in approximately 1.0rCel hot water
    from the site and the resulting milky solution was poured into the
    boiling centre of the pond to start the experiment." [2]

    The results:

    "To summarize, the organic compounds required for the origin of life in
    a natural setting would have had a variety of possible fates other than those observed in a laboratory setting, where pure compounds react in
    glass containers. Our results show that self-assembly of boundary
    structures cannot occur under hot acidic conditions, at least with a
    simple amphiphile such as myristic acid. Furthermore, if di- and
    trivalent cations are present, as in the Kamchatka pool described here,
    the fatty acids will precipitate as insoluble soaps, which inhibits potential membrane formation. This limitation occurs not only for the boiling hot spring described here, but also for seawater, which has a relatively high content of calcium and magnesium ions (Monnard et al. 2002)."

    The results cast major doubt on hydrothermal pools/vents:

    "From a biophysical perspective, these considerations suggest that the
    most plausible planetary environment for the origin of life would be an aqueous phase at moderate temperature ranges (less than 60-#C) and low
    ionic strength, having a pH value near neutrality with divalent cations
    at submillimolar concentrations. This suggestion is in marked contrast
    to the view that life most probably began in a geothermal or marine environment, perhaps even the extreme environment of a hydrothermal vent."

    Doubting the viability of marine environments turns attention to
    problems with fresh water alternatives:

    "One argument favouring a marine site for life's beginning is that fresh water would be rare on the early Earth. Even with today's extensive continental crust, fresh water represents only approximately 1% of the contemporary Earth's reservoir of liquid water. Another concern about a fresh water origin of life is that the lifetime of fresh water bodies
    tends to be short on a geological time-scale. On the other hand, if the temperature and ionic composition of a geothermal spring or seawater markedly inhibits self-assembly processes, we may need to reconsider the assumption that life inevitably began in such environments."

    Which leads them to:

    "A more plausible site for the origin of cellular life may be fresh
    water pools maintained by the rain falling on the earliest volcanic land masses and small continents."

    Indeed, you really cannot "sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to the field..."

    Well done Deamer and team - more of this please.

    _____


    [1] rCLA new model for the origin of life: Coupled phases and
    combinatorial selection in fluctuating hydrothermal pools.rCY https://youtu.be/nk_R55O24t4?feature=shared

    "[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
    want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
    it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've come up with to make substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
    employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
    so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
    experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
    would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
    experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
    these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
    what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
    experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
    the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
    way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
    upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
    build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and things like that...rCY

    [2] "Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1664680

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Tue Oct 13 08:43:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/12/2026 5:54 PM, MarkE wrote:
    I commend David Deamer's follow-through on his own exhortation:

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and things like that...rCY [1]

    He and others did this:

    "At both the Kamchatka and the Mt Lassen sites, we added a defined set
    of primary molecular constituents of life to the hot springs. This
    included four amino acids (glycine, l-alanine, l-aspartic acid and l- valine, 1rCeg each), four nucleobases (adenine, cytosine, guanine and uracil, 1rCeg each) sodium phosphate (3rCeg), glycerol (2rCeg) and myristic acid (1.5rCeg). We expect that this mixture is a useful guide for
    monitoring degradation reactions, in addition to serving as a potential source of reactants for any synthetic reactions that might occur. The powdered mixture was first dissolved in approximately 1.0rCel hot water
    from the site and the resulting milky solution was poured into the
    boiling centre of the pond to start the experiment." [2]

    The results:

    "To summarize, the organic compounds required for the origin of life in
    a natural setting would have had a variety of possible fates other than those observed in a laboratory setting, where pure compounds react in
    glass containers. Our results show that self-assembly of boundary
    structures cannot occur under hot acidic conditions, at least with a
    simple amphiphile such as myristic acid. Furthermore, if di- and
    trivalent cations are present, as in the Kamchatka pool described here,
    the fatty acids will precipitate as insoluble soaps, which inhibits potential membrane formation. This limitation occurs not only for the boiling hot spring described here, but also for seawater, which has a relatively high content of calcium and magnesium ions (Monnard et al. 2002)."

    The results cast major doubt on hydrothermal pools/vents:

    "From a biophysical perspective, these considerations suggest that the
    most plausible planetary environment for the origin of life would be an aqueous phase at moderate temperature ranges (less than 60-#C) and low
    ionic strength, having a pH value near neutrality with divalent cations
    at submillimolar concentrations. This suggestion is in marked contrast
    to the view that life most probably began in a geothermal or marine environment, perhaps even the extreme environment of a hydrothermal vent."

    Doubting the viability of marine environments turns attention to
    problems with fresh water alternatives:

    "One argument favouring a marine site for life's beginning is that fresh water would be rare on the early Earth. Even with today's extensive continental crust, fresh water represents only approximately 1% of the contemporary Earth's reservoir of liquid water. Another concern about a fresh water origin of life is that the lifetime of fresh water bodies
    tends to be short on a geological time-scale. On the other hand, if the temperature and ionic composition of a geothermal spring or seawater markedly inhibits self-assembly processes, we may need to reconsider the assumption that life inevitably began in such environments."

    Which leads them to:

    "A more plausible site for the origin of cellular life may be fresh
    water pools maintained by the rain falling on the earliest volcanic land masses and small continents."

    Indeed, you really cannot "sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to the field..."

    Well done Deamer and team - more of this please.

    _____


    [1] rCLA new model for the origin of life: Coupled phases and
    combinatorial selection in fluctuating hydrothermal pools.rCY https://youtu.be/nk_R55O24t4?feature=shared

    "[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
    want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
    it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've come up with to make substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
    employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
    so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
    experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
    would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
    experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
    these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
    what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
    experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
    the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
    way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
    upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
    build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY

    rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
    the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
    Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
    is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and things like that...rCY

    [2] "Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1664680



    Lying to yourself about reality is never going to change reality. Just demonstrate that you can deal with any god that fills your perceived
    gaps. You know why the Reason to Believe and the other TO IDiots quit
    the ID scam, and you even admit that the origin of life gap is not
    Biblical, so what good does lying to yourself about that reality do for
    your religious beliefs? Your religious beliefs should not be based on lies.

    Try to demonstrate that you are not lying to yourself about reality.
    You already understand that you would not have fallen for the ID scam if
    they had actually filled the origin of life gap with a designer, so why
    keep pretending?

    Just try to put as much effort into trying to figure out if you can ever
    fill the origin of life gap with the designer that you have been lying
    to yourself about for decades. Really, what intelligent designer do you
    want to fill the gap, and is that possible? You have admitted that the
    gap is not Biblical, so what is the point of lying to yourself about
    that reality?

    The gap is the only thing that the ID perps have demonstrated to exist
    in this reality. You know that they have been lying to rubes like
    yourself for decades about the ID scam being a big tent for all
    creationists, but if they had actually been interested in the science
    they would have never made that claim because science is just the study
    of nature, and nature is known not to be Biblical. Most of the ID perps
    have already given up on young flat earth geocentric creationism, and
    yet they sucked in IDiots like Pagano who was a geocentric Biblical old
    earth creationist. Denton and Behe are theistic evolutionists, and yet
    you still fell for the scam. The ID scam was never a big tent, and it
    does not support your Biblical beliefs. Look at how they have fooled
    Sticks when he claims to be a young earth creationist. Meyer is an old
    earth creationist whose main argument (the Cambrian explosion) relies on
    the accurate dating of the event that places the event within a 25
    million year period of time over half a billion years ago. A time long
    before the first plants, described as being created on the third day,
    evolved on this planet. How can Sticks believe such a scam artist?
    Sewell (another ID perp) dropped the Cambrian explosion and the
    flagellum, that evolved over a billion years ago among bacteria, from
    his Top Six, and then he put the rest all out of temporal order so that
    he could keep fooling the rubes like Sticks and you with the junk.

    Just take the ID perp's Top Six gap denial arguments and demonstrate for yourself that the ID scam is not Biblical. Why do you think that the
    Reason to Believe old earth creationists quit supporting the ID scam
    after the Top Six came out? Why did Kalk, Bill, and Pagano quit
    supporting the ID scam? Pagano even claimed that the Top Six were not
    the best evidence for the ID scam before he quit posting. The origin of
    life gap is #3 of the Top Six, and you have already admitted that the
    origin of life gap is not Biblical.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2