• Evolutionary transition to multicellularity

    From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Sun Oct 11 19:24:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11038-w

    Abstract
    Dozens of independent origins of multicellularity have profoundly shaped EarthrCOs evolutionary and ecological history. These transitions have
    given rise to massive radiations encompassing thousands to millions of
    species and the evolution of increasingly complex bodies. Multicellular
    taxa now constitute the majority of EarthrCOs biomass and have
    fundamentally transformed global ecosystems, underpinning diverse biomes
    from forests and grasslands to coral reefs. While these
    macroevolutionary patterns have long been recognized, the
    microevolutionary processes driving the transition to multicellularity
    have remained unclear. Questions remain on how solitary cells form
    cohesive groups, how these groups become evolutionary units capable of adaptation at the multicellular level, and how novel cell types and developmental patterns emerge. Recent discoveries of previously unknown multicellular species and the development of experimental models have
    provided important insights into these questions. This work reveals that seemingly insurmountable evolutionary hurdles are often readily overcome either through the repurposing of ancestral unicellular traits or
    through emergent properties of multicellular collectives that arise spontaneously. Here we review key breakthroughs in our understanding of
    the microevolutionary processes that underpin the evolution of
    increasingly complex multicellularity, focusing on mechanisms through
    which single cells can evolve into functionally integrated multicellular organisms.

    You can use the link to read the article, but you need a subscription to download the pdf. MarkE put up a paper and claimed that too many genes
    had to evolve in eukaryotes during the evolution of multicellular
    animals. The paper had a figure noting the number of novel genes that
    evolved at each node of the phylogeny of metazoa. The data was likely
    used to make the inferences in the above paper. It was noted that most
    of the novel genes that had to evolve, had evolved by gene duplication.
    This just meant that the genes had already existed in the single celled ancestors, but had been modified enough to be called a new gene that did something different than the progenitor gene. It should also be noted
    that gene loss was common. Behe is the one that noted that gene loss
    would be expected to occur by Darwinian mechanisms over macro
    evolutionary time periods if that loss had some evolutionary advantage.
    It looks like that routinely happens, but the data indicates that Behe
    is wrong about that having a negative impact on future evolution because
    new genes constantly are being created in higher numbers than the genes
    that have been lost. This gene evolution paper is consistent with the
    above paper's claims that multicellularity evolved by recycling genes
    and pathways that existed in the single celled animals.

    Ancestral gene paper:
    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04136-5

    Ron Okimoto




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Mon Oct 12 17:19:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/11/2026 7:24 PM, RonO wrote:
    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11038-w

    Abstract
    Dozens of independent origins of multicellularity have profoundly shaped EarthrCOs evolutionary and ecological history. These transitions have
    given rise to massive radiations encompassing thousands to millions of species and the evolution of increasingly complex bodies. Multicellular
    taxa now constitute the majority of EarthrCOs biomass and have
    fundamentally transformed global ecosystems, underpinning diverse biomes from forests and grasslands to coral reefs. While these
    macroevolutionary patterns have long been recognized, the
    microevolutionary processes driving the transition to multicellularity
    have remained unclear. Questions remain on how solitary cells form
    cohesive groups, how these groups become evolutionary units capable of adaptation at the multicellular level, and how novel cell types and developmental patterns emerge. Recent discoveries of previously unknown multicellular species and the development of experimental models have provided important insights into these questions. This work reveals that seemingly insurmountable evolutionary hurdles are often readily overcome either through the repurposing of ancestral unicellular traits or
    through emergent properties of multicellular collectives that arise spontaneously. Here we review key breakthroughs in our understanding of
    the microevolutionary processes that underpin the evolution of
    increasingly complex multicellularity, focusing on mechanisms through
    which single cells can evolve into functionally integrated multicellular organisms.

    You can use the link to read the article, but you need a subscription to download the pdf.-a MarkE put up a paper and claimed that too many genes
    had to evolve in eukaryotes during the evolution of multicellular
    animals.-a The paper had a figure noting the number of novel genes that evolved at each node of the phylogeny of metazoa.-a The data was likely
    used to make the inferences in the above paper.-a It was noted that most
    of the novel genes that had to evolve, had evolved by gene duplication.
    This just meant that the genes had already existed in the single celled ancestors, but had been modified enough to be called a new gene that did something different than the progenitor gene.-a It should also be noted
    that gene loss was common.-a Behe is the one that noted that gene loss
    would be expected to occur by Darwinian mechanisms over macro
    evolutionary time periods if that loss had some evolutionary advantage.
    It looks like that routinely happens, but the data indicates that Behe
    is wrong about that having a negative impact on future evolution because
    new genes constantly are being created in higher numbers than the genes
    that have been lost.-a This gene evolution paper is consistent with the above paper's claims that multicellularity evolved by recycling genes
    and pathways that existed in the single celled animals.

    Ancestral gene paper:
    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04136-5

    Ron Okimoto
    MarkE should also note that the ancestral gene paper has what they call "Novel" genes listed at each known branch point involved in evolving
    metazoa (multicellular animals). Novel genes have new functions and
    evolve their own gene families, but they evolve from a gene that already existed. The gene families that already existed in single celled
    animals are called "Core" genes and the genes that evolved from them are called "Novel". Only 42 new Core genes evolved during the billion years
    that metazoa was evolving and are used by Bilateria (bilateral animals)
    and these new Core genes diversified by gene duplication during the
    evolution of metazoa.

    MarkE claimed at the time that over 5,000 Novel genes could not have
    evolved in the billion year period represented in their figure 1, but
    genes that evolve by gene duplication or gene fusion have been claimed
    by Dembski to not be his type of complex specified information (CSI).
    Dembski understands that such changes in function can evolve by natural mechanisms, so he started calling it lesser specified complexity. What Dembski considers to be CSI is the evolution of the Core genes. It is
    obvious that such evolution is rare, but it doesn't look impossible to
    have evolved. No new Core genes had to evolve during the
    diversification of Bilateria. From the likely worm-like common ancestor
    of deuterostomes and protostomes everything evolved from nematodes to
    humans, without new core genes needing to evolve. This is the main
    reason that this gene paper supports the findings of the study that I
    started this thread with.

    There have been lineage specific new genes that may have evolved from
    random sequence, and some of them are still in the phase where they are evolving more stable and reproducible folding structures. I do not
    think that we have figured out what any of these new genes do in our own lineage and those of research animals like Drosophila, but we can tell
    that they do make a protein product in those lineages. We just haven't figured out what the new genes do. What the study that started this
    thread found was that multicellular animals recycled existing
    developmental pathways, or changed them a little to do new things to
    evolve new cell lineages that evolved in the various species of metazoa.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2