"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids + carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and coordinating the integration and development of information, compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids + carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and coordinating the integration and development of information, compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
This seems a very gleefull summary - presumably because you WANT the
search for material OOL to fail. But if that makes you content then
fine. I'm all for persoanl happiness. I sense this is about the
worry that if breakthroughs do come then that would make you unhappy.
If a similar attitude had prevailed in the past we might never have left
the caves.
My own wish is that people will read and feel that here is a real
problem to tackle - people with a real yearning for expanding our
scientific knowledge.
Sorry to intrude on your crusade.
On 2026-10-10, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids +
carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes
vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and
coordinating the integration and development of information,
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of
ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical
constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic
geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose
explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
This seems a very gleefull summary - presumably because you WANT the
search for material OOL to fail. But if that makes you content then
fine. I'm all for persoanl happiness. I sense this is about the
worry that if breakthroughs do come then that would make you unhappy.
If a similar attitude had prevailed in the past we might never have left
the caves.
My own wish is that people will read and feel that here is a real
problem to tackle - people with a real yearning for expanding our
scientific knowledge.
Sorry to intrude on your crusade.
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in >naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is >willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids + >carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes >vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and >coordinating the integration and development of information,
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of >ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical >constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic >geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem.
For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose >explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
On Sat, 10 Oct 2026 18:26:18 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
So you're saying you don't believe in integrated chemical networks?
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
From the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids +
carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes
vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and
coordinating the integration and development of information,
"Development of information" is only a problem in the minds of
buzz-word using ID proponents.
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
Of course, no one is suggesting that those problems have been solved,
but neither have you shown that the difficulties they've encountered
mean that it's time to abandon research into them and consider more Christ-centric models of earth's history.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of
ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Are you sure the geochemical setting would have to be a "maelstrom"?
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical
constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic
geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I don't think your "translation" conveys the optimistic tone and
outlook of the article in question.
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem.
There are problems similar to that in all of science and math, but no
one considers invoking the supernatural in those areas.
For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose
explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
Why do you think there's so much interest in "materialistic belief" in
the scientific community, as opposed to "supernaturalistic belief"?
This seems a very gleefull summary - presumably because you WANT the
search for material OOL to fail. But if that makes you content then
fine. I'm all for persoanl happiness. I sense this is about the
worry that if breakthroughs do come then that would make you unhappy.
If a similar attitude had prevailed in the past we might never have left
the caves.
My own wish is that people will read and feel that here is a real
problem to tackle - people with a real yearning for expanding our
scientific knowledge.
Sorry to intrude on your crusade.
On 2026-10-10, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids +
carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes
vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and
coordinating the integration and development of information,
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of
ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than
may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical
constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable
to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic
geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose
explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
From the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
On 11/10/2026 9:07 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
From the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
The findings of lab experiments are an important and necessary part of
this research, but do not mistake "simulated prebiotic conditions" for >problem solved. Leading OOL researcher Bruce Damer highlights this issue >[1]:
oYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and >things like that...o
"[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry >experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial >progress.
So, these are the four points we've come up with to make
substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and >informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
build experiments that will move away from equilibriumo
Cite the papers that have gone into "the field...to hot springs", or "in
an environment that would say be like an analog of the early Earth,
build a complex experiment...that will move away from equilibrium", and
not just "the ethereal world of pure reactants" and "laboratory
glassware", to demonstrate:
- natural production of nucleotides
- natural production of amino acids
- natural production of lipids
- natural production of carbohydrates
- with required composition and purity
- with sufficient concentration
- with required chirality
- with spatial accessibility, energy activation, etc
- with feedstock delivery sustained over thousands/millions of years
No-one has taken up Damer and Deamer's appeal in over ten years, because >this just doesn't happen in nature.
_____
[1] oA new model for the origin of life: Coupled phases and
combinatorial selection in fluctuating hydrothermal pools.o >https://youtu.be/nk_R55O24t4?feature=shared
Bruce Damer
On 10/10/2026 11:58 pm, Jim Jackson wrote:
Your response illustrates the problem. You ignore my engagement with
science and revert to the familiar get-out-of-jail-free dismissal of any interpretation of the scientific evidence which deduces that materialism
may be an inadequate explanation.
Ironically, materialism is actually more susceptible to WANT its
worldview to be true. It has nowhere else to go. On the other hand, for example, Biologos offers an accommodation of current scientific view
within theism. I just don't think the science requires that.
On this occasion, I did spice it with rhetoric, to amuse myself (if no
one else) while we wait for scientific orthodoxy to catch up and concede
the data.
This seems a very gleefull summary - presumably because you WANT the
search for material OOL to fail. But if that makes you content then
fine. I'm all for persoanl happiness. I sense this is about the
worry that if breakthroughs do come then that would make you unhappy.
If a similar attitude had prevailed in the past we might never have left
the caves.
My own wish is that people will read and feel that here is a real
problem to tackle - people with a real yearning for expanding our
scientific knowledge.
Sorry to intrude on your crusade.
On 2026-10-10, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints
with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids +
carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes
vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and
coordinating the integration and development of information,
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of >>> ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than >>> may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical
constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable >>> to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic
geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now,
it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose
explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief.
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk
past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so
many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
On 2026-10-10, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/10/2026 11:58 pm, Jim Jackson wrote:
Your response illustrates the problem. You ignore my engagement with
science and revert to the familiar get-out-of-jail-free dismissal of any
interpretation of the scientific evidence which deduces that materialism
may be an inadequate explanation.
Ironically, materialism is actually more susceptible to WANT its
worldview to be true. It has nowhere else to go. On the other hand, for
example, Biologos offers an accommodation of current scientific view
within theism. I just don't think the science requires that.
On this occasion, I did spice it with rhetoric, to amuse myself (if no
one else) while we wait for scientific orthodoxy to catch up and concede
the data.
This seems a very gleefull summary - presumably because you WANT the
search for material OOL to fail. But if that makes you content then
fine. I'm all for persoanl happiness. I sense this is about the
worry that if breakthroughs do come then that would make you unhappy.
If a similar attitude had prevailed in the past we might never have left >>> the caves.
My own wish is that people will read and feel that here is a real
problem to tackle - people with a real yearning for expanding our
scientific knowledge.
Sorry to intrude on your crusade.
On 2026-10-10, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
Actually, just reading the lines. I'm entertained by the unflagging
optimism of OOL papers. Here's (yet another) example.
This paper [1] opens with a typical euphemism for stalled progress:
"The origin of life remains one of the most challenging questions in
Earth and planetary sciences"
Even the conclusions are becoming less hopeful these days:
"Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical constraints >>>> with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not isolated
reactions but integrated chemical networks."
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
2. Prebiotic assembly of building blocks into RNA + peptides + lipids + >>>> carbs (extremely difficult--cliff approaching; not demonstrated in
realistic prebiotic environments)
3. Bringing these together for supposed "co-evolution" (the cliff goes >>>> vertical here). This is the integration problem, i.e. co-locating and
coordinating the integration and development of information,
compartmentalisation, metabolism, reproduction, etc.
And all the while, the environment of early Earth is in the direction of >>>> ripping apart any delicate, complex, far-from-equilibrium snowflake than >>>> may happen to momentarily shimmer in the chemical maelstrom.
Here is the paper's conclusion again, in view of the cliff just
described: "Future progress depends on coupling realistic geochemical
constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that test not
isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
I'll translate this for you: "Progress has stalled because we are unable >>>> to even imagine, let alone empirically demonstrate, coupling realistic >>>> geochemical constraints with systems-level prebiotic experiments that
test not isolated reactions but integrated chemical networks."
It seems we have a way to go before the OOL community is willing to
begin to acknowledge that maybe we have a fundamental problem. For now, >>>> it's more and more shooting-fish-in-a-barrel for commentators whose
explanatory scope is not arbitrarily truncated by materialistic belief. >>>>
_____
[1] "Progress and persistent questions in understanding the origin of
life on Earth"
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11084-026-09753-5
On Sun, 11 Oct 2026 16:04:28 +1100, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/10/2026 9:07 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
From the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
The findings of lab experiments are an important and necessary part of
this research, but do not mistake "simulated prebiotic conditions" for
problem solved. Leading OOL researcher Bruce Damer highlights this issue
[1]:
rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and
things like that...rCY
"[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry
experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial
progress.
Do you agree that there has been progress, albeit "incremental"?
So, these are the four points we've come up with to make
substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and
informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY
Do you agree with your quote that the origin of life involved nature
as a ratchet?
Cite the papers that have gone into "the field...to hot springs", or "in
an environment that would say be like an analog of the early Earth,
build a complex experiment...that will move away from equilibrium", and
not just "the ethereal world of pure reactants" and "laboratory
glassware", to demonstrate:
- natural production of nucleotides
- natural production of amino acids
- natural production of lipids
- natural production of carbohydrates
- with required composition and purity
- with sufficient concentration
- with required chirality
- with spatial accessibility, energy activation, etc
- with feedstock delivery sustained over thousands/millions of years
No-one has taken up Damer and Deamer's appeal in over ten years, because
this just doesn't happen in nature.
I would encourage abiogenesis researchers to go out into the field as
well, but as the saying goes, "Don't let the perfect be the enemy of
the good." So *simulated prebiotic conditions* has got to count for something!
Also, I wonder why your ID god can only be supported by the supposed
absence of evolution. Does he not leave any traces of his own?
_____
[1] rCLA new model for the origin of life: Coupled phases and
combinatorial selection in fluctuating hydrothermal pools.rCY
https://youtu.be/nk_R55O24t4?feature=shared
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable. This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of reasons.
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias toward interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think though this applies to us all. A category error is to equate materialism with
science and rationality, and to consider belief in God as inherently
less rational or less regarding of science.
On 11/10/2026 9:07 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
-aFrom the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
The findings of lab experiments are an important and necessary part of
this research, but do not mistake "simulated prebiotic conditions" for problem solved. Leading OOL researcher Bruce Damer highlights this issue [1]:
rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural environment
is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure reactants and things like that...rCY
"[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over here, or they
want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and I believe that
it's time for the field to go from incremental progress to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've come up with to make substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first one is to
employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient complexity
so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you have an
experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example, and informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment that
would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium. And
what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started that
way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and building
upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to
build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY
Cite the papers that have gone into "the field...to hot springs", or "in
an environment that would say be like an analog of the early Earth,
build a complex experiment...that will move away from equilibrium", [...]
No-one has taken up Damer and Deamer's appeal in over ten years, because this just doesn't happen in nature.
On 10/10/26 10:04 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/10/2026 9:07 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is
willing to admit)
-aFrom the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
The findings of lab experiments are an important and necessary part of
this research, but do not mistake "simulated prebiotic conditions" for
problem solved. Leading OOL researcher Bruce Damer highlights this
issue [1]:
rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go to
the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural
environment is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure
reactants and things like that...rCY
"[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution
chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over
here, or they want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer] and
I believe that it's time for the field to go from incremental progress
to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've come up
with to make substantial progress in the origin of life, and the first
one is to employ something called system chemistry, having sufficient
complexity so instead of one experiment say about proteins, now you
have an experiment about the encapsulation of proteins for example,
and informational molecules built from nucleotides in an environment
that would say be like an analog of the early Earth, build a complex
experiment. Something we're calling sufficient complexity, and all of
these experiments have to move the reactions away from equilibrium.
And what do we mean by that? Well, in in your high school chemistry
experiments, something starts foaming something changes color and then
the experiment winds down and stops. Well, life didn't get started
that way. Life got started by a continuous run-up of complexity and
building upon in a sense nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out
how to build experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY
Cite the papers that have gone into "the field...to hot springs", or
"in an environment that would say be like an analog of the early
Earth, build a complex experiment...that will move away from
equilibrium", [...]
No-one has taken up Damer and Deamer's appeal in over ten years,
because this just doesn't happen in nature.
Has it ever occurred to you that perhaps the reason why those
experiments remain undone is because they would be arduous and horribly expensive?
And if they haven't been done, then you don't know whether or not "this" happens in nature, and your statement that it doesn't is just you making
up shit.
On 18/10/2026 1:17 pm, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/10/26 10:04 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 11/10/2026 9:07 am, Vincent Maycock wrote:
Here's the thing. There is exponentially increasing difficulty in
naturalistic formation of life from non-living matter:
1. Prebiotic synthesis of building blocks, i.e. amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids (very difficult; much more so than OOL is >>>>> willing to admit)
-aFrom the article you posted:
"Complementing these natural observations, laboratory-based
experimental studies have demonstrated the abiotic synthesis of
numerous biologically relevant molecules, including amino acids,
nucleotides, sugars, lipids, and metabolic intermediates under
simulated prebiotic conditions [162, 167, 169, 170,
172,173,174,175,176]."
The findings of lab experiments are an important and necessary part
of this research, but do not mistake "simulated prebiotic conditions"
for problem solved. Leading OOL researcher Bruce Damer highlights
this issue [1]:
rCLYou can't sit in a laboratory just using glassware. You have to go
to the field. You have to go to hot springs, you have to go to [...]
Iceland and come check and sit down and see what the natural
environment is like, rather than being in the ethereal world of pure
reactants and things like that...rCY
"[OOL research has] been mainly focused on individual solution
chemistry experiments where they want to show polymerization over
here, or they want to show metabolism over here, and Dave [Deamer]
and I believe that it's time for the field to go from incremental
progress to substantial progress. So, these are the four points we've
come up with to make substantial progress in the origin of life, and
the first one is to employ something called system chemistry, having
sufficient complexity so instead of one experiment say about
proteins, now you have an experiment about the encapsulation of
proteins for example, and informational molecules built from
nucleotides in an environment that would say be like an analog of the
early Earth, build a complex experiment. Something we're calling
sufficient complexity, and all of these experiments have to move the
reactions away from equilibrium. And what do we mean by that? Well,
in in your high school chemistry experiments, something starts
foaming something changes color and then the experiment winds down
and stops. Well, life didn't get started that way. Life got started
by a continuous run-up of complexity and building upon in a sense
nature as a ratchet. So we have to figure out how to build
experiments that will move away from equilibriumrCY
Cite the papers that have gone into "the field...to hot springs", or
"in an environment that would say be like an analog of the early
Earth, build a complex experiment...that will move away from
equilibrium", [...]
No-one has taken up Damer and Deamer's appeal in over ten years,
because this just doesn't happen in nature.
Has it ever occurred to you that perhaps the reason why those
experiments remain undone is because they would be arduous and
horribly expensive?
And if they haven't been done, then you don't know whether or not
"this" happens in nature, and your statement that it doesn't is just
you making up shit.
Feel free to respond to the science in my post "Hats off to DD (2026)".
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable. This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of reasons.
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias toward interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think though this applies to us all. A category error is to equate materialism with
science and rationality, and to consider belief in God as inherently
less rational or less regarding of science.
With that caveat in place, FWIW I do find the science around origin of
the universe and origin of life compelling in showing naturalistic explanations to be inadequate. Hence my strenuously arguing the case
here, and on the basis of science as much as I'm able, and no doubt
being selective at times.
This does put me in an interesting position. For example, I've advocated strongly for vaccination and accepting anthropogenic climate change, on
the basis of science and confidence in the very high consensus among scientists on these issues. Yet, with origin of life, I find myself on
the other side. That's not something I take lightly, or brush off as
simply the bias of materialism perpetuating wrong conclusions. I do
think that is at play, but the picture is surely complex, nuanced, and multi-factorial.
And so here we are. How about you?
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk
past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so
many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
On 12/10/2026 5:11 pm, MarkE wrote:
Jim, bumping this for your consideration:
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career
background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is
not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and
those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in
reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable.
This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of
reasons.
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias
toward interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think
though this applies to us all. A category error is to equate
materialism with science and rationality, and to consider belief in
God as inherently less rational or less regarding of science.
With that caveat in place, FWIW I do find the science around origin of
the universe and origin of life compelling in showing naturalistic
explanations to be inadequate. Hence my strenuously arguing the case
here, and on the basis of science as much as I'm able, and no doubt
being selective at times.
This does put me in an interesting position. For example, I've
advocated strongly for vaccination and accepting anthropogenic climate
change, on the basis of science and confidence in the very high
consensus among scientists on these issues. Yet, with origin of life,
I find myself on the other side. That's not something I take lightly,
or brush off as simply the bias of materialism perpetuating wrong
conclusions. I do think that is at play, but the picture is surely
complex, nuanced, and multi-factorial.
And so here we are. How about you?
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk
past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so
many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
Just wanted to say the quoting attributes are not good on this post.
Mark is referring to a post HE wrote, but it looks like JJ did in this post.-a I know because tomorrow I will respond to it hopefully, but I
will use Mark's original.
On 11/2/2026 3:17 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 12/10/2026 5:11 pm, MarkE wrote:
Weird too, I have this post coming in at 1:11 AM.
Jim, bumping this for your consideration:
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Below here, is what MarkE wrote, not JJ.
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career
background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is
not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and
those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in
reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable.
This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of
reasons.
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias
toward interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think
though this applies to us all. A category error is to equate
materialism with science and rationality, and to consider belief in
God as inherently less rational or less regarding of science.
With that caveat in place, FWIW I do find the science around origin
of the universe and origin of life compelling in showing naturalistic
explanations to be inadequate. Hence my strenuously arguing the case
here, and on the basis of science as much as I'm able, and no doubt
being selective at times.
This does put me in an interesting position. For example, I've
advocated strongly for vaccination and accepting anthropogenic
climate change, on the basis of science and confidence in the very
high consensus among scientists on these issues. Yet, with origin of
life, I find myself on the other side. That's not something I take
lightly, or brush off as simply the bias of materialism perpetuating
wrong conclusions. I do think that is at play, but the picture is
surely complex, nuanced, and multi-factorial.
And so here we are. How about you?
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk >>>> past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so >>>> many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
On 12/10/2026 5:11 pm, MarkE wrote:
Jim, bumping this for your consideration:
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias toward
interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think though this
applies to us all.
A category error is to equate materialism with
science and rationality, and to consider belief in God as inherently
less rational or less regarding of science.
With that caveat in place, FWIW I do find the science around origin of
the universe and origin of life compelling in showing naturalistic
explanations to be inadequate. Hence my strenuously arguing the case
here, and on the basis of science as much as I'm able, and no doubt
being selective at times.
This does put me in an interesting position. For example, I've advocated
strongly for vaccination and accepting anthropogenic climate change, on
the basis of science and confidence in the very high consensus among
scientists on these issues. Yet, with origin of life, I find myself on
the other side. That's not something I take lightly, or brush off as
simply the bias of materialism perpetuating wrong conclusions. I do
think that is at play, but the picture is surely complex, nuanced, and
multi-factorial.
And so here we are. How about you?
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk
past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so
many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable. This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of reasons.
On 2026-11-02, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 12/10/2026 5:11 pm, MarkE wrote:
Jim, bumping this for your consideration:
On 12/10/2026 7:05 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
Certainly people can try :-)
....snip...
I maintain that everyone has a belief system/worldview, which
consciously and unconsciously shapes our preferences and
presuppositions. Which is to say, I assume that I have some bias toward
interpreting evidence as disconfirming materialism. I think though this
applies to us all.
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A category error is to equate materialism with
science and rationality, and to consider belief in God as inherently
less rational or less regarding of science.
With that caveat in place, FWIW I do find the science around origin of
the universe and origin of life compelling in showing naturalistic
explanations to be inadequate. Hence my strenuously arguing the case
here, and on the basis of science as much as I'm able, and no doubt
being selective at times.
At one time explaining anything of the natural world as "science" was difficult. Each generation/society grows up and "knows" what is right -
if you explain things differently you are dismissed as an idiot or worse
a wizard/witch. But measured exploration of the material world has
indeed gradually shown that more and more of nature and the world is not fickle or capricious - it follows rules/laws. My own faith is that that process will continue. That for instance not currently understanding
origins is just our ignorance, as previously our not-understanding-
things "scientifically" was just our ignorance. The history of science
is a fascinating subject, and not yet played out.
This does put me in an interesting position. For example, I've advocated >>> strongly for vaccination and accepting anthropogenic climate change, on
the basis of science and confidence in the very high consensus among
scientists on these issues. Yet, with origin of life, I find myself on
the other side. That's not something I take lightly, or brush off as
simply the bias of materialism perpetuating wrong conclusions. I do
think that is at play, but the picture is surely complex, nuanced, and
multi-factorial.
And so here we are. How about you?
Which takes me back to a previous comment I made, about how people talk >>>> past each other, because the basic fundamental positions are SO
different that we each don'tr make sense to each other. I've seen it so >>>> many times.
I feel your rhetoric was very revealing.
[...]
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without God,
there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The--
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
On 11/3/26 9:50 AM, sticks wrote:
[...]
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of
the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without
God, there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and
history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.
Did you ever wonder how the idea of an old earth came into being in the first place?-a Hint: evidence, looked at by young-earthers.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
On 11/4/2026 10:30 AM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 11/3/26 9:50 AM, sticks wrote:
[...]
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of
the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without
God, there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and
history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.
Did you ever wonder how the idea of an old earth came into being in
the first place?-a Hint: evidence, looked at by young-earthers.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Hint: Read the book.-a I agree with its analysis.
BTW, I forgot to add in my initial post the authors are not exactly kind
to some of the ID people, and though I understand their reasoning, they
do ID a bit of an injustice in defining them in the way they do.-a Once
you read the book you'll be able to make your own decision.
On 10/12/2026 1:11 AM, MarkE wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I would say not here on talk.origins, but the conversations are not
without value as they expose just how little evolutionists have other
than philosophical rejection, which ultimately ends with mockery.
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career
background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is
not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and
those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in
reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable.
This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of
reasons.
And this is the reason I wanted to offer a reading suggestion for you.
I'm sure like myself, you have read the arguments many times from
various authors in the old vs. young earth debate.-a I have many times
read things that helped me grow in feeling confident of a young earth perspective.-a This book actually strengthened that belief and has
convinced me I am on the right path as a YEC.
It is probably the most thorough I have ever read regarding actual
scripture and the beliefs of Jesus and the apostles. It focuses entirely
on Scripture instead of trying to fit the Bible into a specific
scientific model.-a Things like the character of God, the doctrine of
death, authority of scripture, even the biblical definition of life itself.
It is broken into 14 heavily researched essays from theologians, Hebrew scholars, and church historians.-a I will admit, though I read every
word, some of the essays are so thorough in their examination of
specific word usage and the likes it can be hard to keep reading, but
that is not the fault of the authors and it is obvious if you get the
point you could skip ahead if desired.
It does delve into compromise views like Gap Theory, Day-Age Theory and
the Framework Hypothesis.-a It also refers to several of the Christian authors who have been mentioned around TO lately and critiques their positions.
It is not the end of the world if someone believes in old or young
earth, but the book does lay out some of the consequences of taking an
old earth position.-a I am not interested in debating this topic with
Martin or any other old earth believers, I simply want to point out this resource to you MarkE and any others like you who have not decided and
have an honest approach to things like you do.-a But I do hope you read
this book.
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without God,
there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.-a The book highlights many of these.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Here's a $5.89 pdf download: <https://www.christianbook.com/coming-grips-genesis-biblical-authority- earth/9781614580362/pd/34255DF>
Here's a $5.99 Kindle download:
<https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00FR0SW3U?>
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Here's a $5.89 pdf download:
<https://www.christianbook.com/coming-grips-genesis-biblical-authority-
earth/9781614580362/pd/34255DF>
Here's a $5.99 Kindle download:
<https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00FR0SW3U?>
Thanks for the suggestion. A YEC framework appears to be the most straightforward theologically. As I've indicated, to me the YEC position seems incompatible with scientific data, as well as intuition (e.g.,
I've stood on the edge of the Grand Canyon and found it difficult to see
how run-off from a global flood - and other erosion in under 10,000
years - could have formed it).
Having said that, intuition is obviously fallible, and I'm interested to
see where current thinking is at across the range of perspectives. Have purchased a copy.
On 2026-11-04, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Here's a $5.89 pdf download:
<https://www.christianbook.com/coming-grips-genesis-biblical-authority-
earth/9781614580362/pd/34255DF>
Here's a $5.99 Kindle download:
<https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00FR0SW3U?>
Thanks for the suggestion. A YEC framework appears to be the most
straightforward theologically. As I've indicated, to me the YEC position
seems incompatible with scientific data, as well as intuition (e.g.,
I've stood on the edge of the Grand Canyon and found it difficult to see
how run-off from a global flood - and other erosion in under 10,000
years - could have formed it).
Having said that, intuition is obviously fallible, and I'm interested to
see where current thinking is at across the range of perspectives. Have
purchased a copy.
Honestly? Some positions are just weird - it is as bad as flatearthism, or covid denial etc.
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
If not, I think that would qualify you as a "philosophical materialist", which is a faith position and not a deduction from that scientific data.
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of
concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
If not, I think that would qualify you as a "philosophical materialist",
which is a faith position and not a deduction from that scientific data.
On 4/11/2026 4:50 am, sticks wrote:
On 10/12/2026 1:11 AM, MarkE wrote:
Agreed, talking past one another is a TO pastime. Which raises the
question, Can people with such fundamentally different positions
overcome this? I'm always willing to try:
I would say not here on talk.origins, but the conversations are not
without value as they expose just how little evolutionists have other
than philosophical rejection, which ultimately ends with mockery.
I'm a Reformed/Evangelical Christian, with a love of science (career
background electrical engineer and software developer). My faith is
not because of science, but I do care about its implications (and
those of history, etc) in relation to the Bible.
This has lead me to a tentative OEC position, with an interest in
reconciling science, history etc with the Bible, where applicable.
This reconciliation is incomplete, at least for me, for any number of
reasons.
And this is the reason I wanted to offer a reading suggestion for you.
I'm sure like myself, you have read the arguments many times from
various authors in the old vs. young earth debate.-a I have many times
read things that helped me grow in feeling confident of a young earth
perspective.-a This book actually strengthened that belief and has
convinced me I am on the right path as a YEC.
It is probably the most thorough I have ever read regarding actual
scripture and the beliefs of Jesus and the apostles. It focuses
entirely on Scripture instead of trying to fit the Bible into a
specific scientific model.-a Things like the character of God, the
doctrine of death, authority of scripture, even the biblical
definition of life itself.
It is broken into 14 heavily researched essays from theologians,
Hebrew scholars, and church historians.-a I will admit, though I read
every word, some of the essays are so thorough in their examination of
specific word usage and the likes it can be hard to keep reading, but
that is not the fault of the authors and it is obvious if you get the
point you could skip ahead if desired.
It does delve into compromise views like Gap Theory, Day-Age Theory
and the Framework Hypothesis.-a It also refers to several of the
Christian authors who have been mentioned around TO lately and
critiques their positions.
It is not the end of the world if someone believes in old or young
earth, but the book does lay out some of the consequences of taking an
old earth position.-a I am not interested in debating this topic with
Martin or any other old earth believers, I simply want to point out
this resource to you MarkE and any others like you who have not
decided and have an honest approach to things like you do.-a But I do
hope you read this book.
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of
the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without
God, there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and
history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.-a The
book highlights many of these.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Here's a $5.89 pdf download:
<https://www.christianbook.com/coming-grips-genesis-biblical-
authority- earth/9781614580362/pd/34255DF>
Here's a $5.99 Kindle download:
<https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00FR0SW3U?>
Thanks for the suggestion. A YEC framework appears to be the most straightforward theologically. As I've indicated, to me the YEC position seems incompatible with scientific data, as well as intuition (e.g.,
I've stood on the edge of the Grand Canyon and found it difficult to see
how run-off from a global flood - and other erosion in under 10,000
years - could have formed it).
Having said that, intuition is obviously fallible, and I'm interested to
see where current thinking is at across the range of perspectives. Have purchased a copy.
I'm curious to know how the arguments for these positions have evolved,
and why their proponents find them convincing. In doing so, attempting
to remain open-minded (I could always be wrong), but also critical and discerning.
I have friends who are of a YEC persuasion, for example, so
understanding this perspective is more than academic - not to win an argument for the sake of it, but to appreciate and challenge their
thinking where that is warranted. I'd hope they'd do the same for me.
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of
concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
If not, I think that would qualify you as a "philosophical materialist",
which is a faith position and not a deduction from that scientific data.
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of
concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
I have no response to this what-if question. I'll let my descendants
answer it in one thousand years time if it is necessary.
On 11/5/2026 2:12 PM, Jim Jackson wrote:
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ... >>>>> now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT
needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of
concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
I have no response to this what-if question. I'll let my descendants
answer it in one thousand years time if it is necessary.
Well there you go MarkE.-a This completely solves the talking past each
each other problem he earlier complained of.-a Just don't talk.
On 6/11/2026 7:23 am, sticks wrote:
On 11/5/2026 2:12 PM, Jim Jackson wrote:
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ... >>>>>> now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT >>>>>> needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of >>>>> concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known
natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
I have no response to this what-if question. I'll let my descendants
answer it in one thousand years time if it is necessary.
Well there you go MarkE.?? This completely solves the talking past each
each other problem he earlier complained of.?? Just don't talk.
Absolutely and indeed. Jim, you've just been hoisted on your own petard.
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 7:23 am, sticks wrote:
On 11/5/2026 2:12 PM, Jim Jackson wrote:
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as confirming ... >>>>>>> now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT >>>>>>> needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000 years of >>>>>> concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known >>>>>> natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
I have no response to this what-if question. I'll let my descendants
answer it in one thousand years time if it is necessary.
Well there you go MarkE.?? This completely solves the talking past each
each other problem he earlier complained of.?? Just don't talk.
Absolutely and indeed. Jim, you've just been hoisted on your own petard.
:-) Maybe I was just being polite
On 11/5/2026 5:36 AM, MarkE wrote:
I'm curious to know how the arguments for these positions have evolved, and why their proponents find them convincing. In doing so, attempting
to remain open-minded (I could always be wrong), but also critical and discerning.
I have friends who are of a YEC persuasion, for example, so
understanding this perspective is more than academic - not to win an argument for the sake of it, but to appreciate and challenge their thinking where that is warranted. I'd hope they'd do the same for me.
I had to smile when I read this considering the history of this group.
I believe even though I no longer see posts from the Emperor unless it
get quoted, I could answer for him in an equally offensive way using his style. Obviously, we all know you want to be lied to....Ha!
YEC types just need pointing at a fossil shell up a mountain; any geology primer would help them.<yawn>
sticks <wolverine01@charter.net> wrote:
On 11/5/2026 5:36 AM, MarkE wrote:
I'm curious to know how the arguments for these positions have evolved, and why their proponents find them convincing. In doing so, attempting to remain open-minded (I could always be wrong), but also critical and discerning.
I have friends who are of a YEC persuasion, for example, so understanding this perspective is more than academic - not to win an argument for the sake of it, but to appreciate and challenge their thinking where that is warranted. I'd hope they'd do the same for me.
YEC types just need pointing at a fossil shell up a mountain; any geology primer would help them.
On 6/11/2026 9:15 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 6/11/2026 7:23 am, sticks wrote:
On 11/5/2026 2:12 PM, Jim Jackson wrote:
On 2026-11-05, MarkE <me22over7@gmail.com> wrote:
On 4/11/2026 11:06 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 4/11/2026 2:37 am, Jim Jackson wrote:
I agree, and I have a bias to interpreting evidence as
confirming ...
now there you have me - materialism(?) is but a short hand, for NOT >>>>>>>> needing anything "supernatural".
A question I've posed previously is this: if, after say 1000
years of
concerted OOL research, the scientific consensus was that all known >>>>>>> natural hypotheses had been disconfirmed, would you give any
consideration to the possibility of supernatural action?
Jim, what is your response to this?
I have no response to this what-if question. I'll let my descendants >>>>> answer it in one thousand years time if it is necessary.
Well there you go MarkE.?? This completely solves the talking past each >>>> each other problem he earlier complained of.?? Just don't talk.
Absolutely and indeed. Jim, you've just been hoisted on your own petard.
:-) Maybe I was just being polite
You can be polite and express strong disagreement. Please do.
On 11/4/2026 10:30 AM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 11/3/26 9:50 AM, sticks wrote:
[...]
Just as interpreting evidence changes once you decide the origin of
the universe and the origin of life could not have happened without
God, there is also a massive shift in how you interpret scripture and
history when looking through an old earth vs. a young earth lens.
Did you ever wonder how the idea of an old earth came into being in
the first place?-a Hint: evidence, looked at by young-earthers.
"Coming To Grips With Genesis - Biblical Authority and the Age of The
Earth"
Editors Terry Mortenson, Ph.D. and Thane H. Ury, Ph.D.
Hint: Read the book.-a I agree with its analysis.
On 11/6/2026 4:29 PM, Kerr-Mudd, John wrote:
YEC types just need pointing at a fossil shell up a mountain; any geology primer would help them.<yawn>
--
Science DoesnrCOt Support Darwin. Scientists Do
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:05:37 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |