• Re: The state of OOL (2023 paper)

    From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Thu Oct 8 08:55:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science. The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and rCLbiology-backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap in complexity..."

    Yeah, guys. It only took 3 billion years which is relatively instantaneous.
    --
    Do you want a friendship with chaos?
    Wanna party with Perses?
    Consequences mean nothing to me
    Morning is your problem, I don't stick around
    The damage is done, itrCOs all you from here
    And donrCOt come a looking 'cause I simply do not care
    Like yourCOd even find me
    Well, maybe after a few pints
    And I only make an appearance when the time is right
    You see, I'm all about the here and now
    Live in the moment and all that, carpe diem

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Thu Oct 8 11:42:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/8/2026 6:18 AM, MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science. The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and rCLbiology-backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap in complexity..."

    "Today, the origin of life remains one of the biggest open questions in biology. How did life emerge and gain complexity?"

    "Yet, a vast gulf remains between rCLchemistry-forwardrCY approaches and derived biological processes."

    "The canonical rCLchicken-and-eggrCY paradox at the origins of life has led to a variety of proposed mechanisms for self-replication without
    coordinated enzymes."

    _______

    The eco-evolutionary origins of life https://academic.oup.com/evolut/article/78/1/1/7334978


    You have to start acknowledging that all your denial about the origin of
    life is just a "So what?" stupid argument. You only use it to lie to
    yourself because you have already acknowledged that the origin of life
    gap is not Biblical. No matter how the gap is filled you lose. You
    have been running from the Top Six for nearly 9 years because you can't
    deal with the reality of what the ID scam has always been. If the ID
    perps had actually had the science to fill the Top Six gaps you would
    not support that science, and it would just be more science for you to
    deny, just as you deny all the valid scientific evidence that tells you
    that life has been evolving on this planet for billions of years.

    The god that could fill the existing origin of life gap is not the god described in the Bible. End of that story. Did you read how the Reason
    to Believe ex IDiots tried and failed to put the actual origin of life
    into their Biblical model. They acknowledged that the actual origin of
    life is never mentioned in the Bible, and they still wanted plants to be created during the 3rd period of time, but that made the rest
    inconsistent with what the Bible claimed. They understood that the land masses existed after the earth cooled enough to have liquid water, and
    that life likely evolved on a planet that had dry land masses, but they
    wanted to claim that land masses did not form on this planet until
    plants evolved during the 3rd period of time. They were willing to deny
    the ice ball earth events that occurred after life existed on this
    planet when most of the water existed as ice at the poles. There is no
    doubt that land masses existed long before the Biblical 3rd period of
    time. Putting the origin of life into their model destroyed the
    Biblical claims. They even wanted to remain in denial of biological
    evolution even though they understood that life had been evolving for
    billions of years and that sea creatures and terrestrial animals had
    evolved long before the land plants described in the Bible evolved. The
    6 day creation is just inconsistent with reality even if you claim that
    they are 6 periods of time.

    Harran put up the Pope Francis quote about believing in the Big Bang and subsequent evolution of everything rather than the creation as 6 magic
    acts. In order to be a creationist that is compatible with the Top Six
    best IDiotic gap denial arguments you have to be like Denton or Behe.
    Those two are theistic evolutionists that have given up on the 6 day
    creation myth. Nelson was never such a creationists and he depended on
    the ID perps lying about having the ID science to fill their gaps Pope Francis could deal with the Top Six gaps, but the ex IDiots at Reason to Believe cannot, nor can anti-evolution creationists like you and Sticks.
    Running from reality is never going to change reality.

    Creationist like you just have to maintain the progression of giving up
    on Biblical interpretations that we can figure out for ourselves. Early Christians had already given up on the Biblical belief that the earth
    was flat. Kepler was likely the last creationist seriously messing with
    the existence of the firmament and he had to give it up and go with
    elliptical heliocentric orbits. The article by the orthodox Jewish
    author that I put up claimed that the firmament was believed to be a
    solid dome above the earth until geocentrism failed (around the same
    time Kepler gave up on the notion). Sticks claims to be a young earth creationist, but you are likely an old earth creationist, so Sticks and
    you likely are no longer flat earth geocentric creationists. Isn't it
    stupid that Sticks has not yet given up on the young earth Biblical
    belief?

    The Big Bang (#1 of the Top Six) occurred over 13 billion years ago.
    The fine tuning of the earth for life (#2 of the Top Six) took 8 billion
    years to accomplish in our star poor region of the galaxy, and the sun
    and moon were created around the same time as the earth, not during the
    4th period of time after plants had been created. The origin of life
    (#3 of the Top Six) on earth may have occurred 4 billion years ago under conditions vastly different than now exists on this planet. Life had
    been evolving as microbes for a billion years before the flagellum (#4
    of the Top Six) evolved among bacteria, and that flagellum has been
    evolving for 3 billion years into multiple different forms among extant bacteria. The Cambrian explosion (#5 of the Top Six) occurred during a
    25 million year period over half a billion years ago. This is long
    before land plants evolved on this planet. The gaps in the human fossil record (#6 of the Top Six) are well defined period of time within the
    last 10 million years, and these gaps exist due to the transitional
    fossil forms that we already have found.

    Kalk and Bill quit the ID scam when the ID perps committed suicide by
    putting the Top Six out in the order in which they must have occurred in
    this universe. Kalk and Bill were anti-evolution Biblical creationists
    like yourself. You and Glenn just ran and would not deal with the Top
    Six in any rational and honest manner. You are still running, but
    reality is never going to change.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Blaine@cactus_DAC@yahoo.com to talk-origins on Thu Oct 8 13:12:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    RonO wrote:
    On 10/8/2026 6:18 AM, MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science.
    The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular
    life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and
    rCLbiology-backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap
    in complexity..."

    "Today, the origin of life remains one of the biggest open questions
    in biology. How did life emerge and gain complexity?"

    "Yet, a vast gulf remains between rCLchemistry-forwardrCY approaches and
    derived biological processes."

    "The canonical rCLchicken-and-eggrCY paradox at the origins of life has
    led to a variety of proposed mechanisms for self-replication without
    coordinated enzymes."

    _______

    The eco-evolutionary origins of life
    https://academic.oup.com/evolut/article/78/1/1/7334978


    You have to start acknowledging that all your denial about the origin of life is just a "So what?" stupid argument.-a You only use it to lie to yourself because you have already acknowledged that the origin of life
    gap is not Biblical.-a No matter how the gap is filled you lose.-a You
    have been running from the Top Six for nearly 9 years because you can't
    deal with the reality of what the ID scam has always been.-a If the ID
    perps had actually had the science to fill the Top Six gaps you would
    not support that science, and it would just be more science for you to
    deny, just as you deny all the valid scientific evidence that tells you
    that life has been evolving on this planet for billions of years.

    The god that could fill the existing origin of life gap is not the god described in the Bible.-a End of that story.-a Did you read how the Reason to Believe ex IDiots tried and failed to put the actual origin of life
    into their Biblical model.-a They acknowledged that the actual origin of life is never mentioned in the Bible, and they still wanted plants to be created during the 3rd period of time, but that made the rest
    inconsistent with what the Bible claimed.-a They understood that the land masses existed after the earth cooled enough to have liquid water, and
    that life likely evolved on a planet that had dry land masses, but they wanted to claim that land masses did not form on this planet until
    plants evolved during the 3rd period of time.-a They were willing to deny the ice ball earth events that occurred after life existed on this
    planet when most of the water existed as ice at the poles.-a There is no doubt that land masses existed long before the Biblical 3rd period of time.-a Putting the origin of life into their model destroyed the
    Biblical claims.-a They even wanted to remain in denial of biological evolution even though they understood that life had been evolving for billions of years and that sea creatures and terrestrial animals had
    evolved long before the land plants described in the Bible evolved.-a The
    6 day creation is just inconsistent with reality even if you claim that
    they are 6 periods of time.

    Harran put up the Pope Francis quote about believing in the Big Bang and subsequent evolution of everything rather than the creation as 6 magic acts.-a In order to be a creationist that is compatible with the Top Six best IDiotic gap denial arguments you have to be like Denton or Behe.
    Those two are theistic evolutionists that have given up on the 6 day creation myth.-a Nelson was never such a creationists and he depended on
    the ID perps lying about having the ID science to fill their gaps-a Pope Francis could deal with the Top Six gaps, but the ex IDiots at Reason to Believe cannot, nor can anti-evolution creationists like you and Sticks.
    -aRunning from reality is never going to change reality.

    That's not true at all. If they continue to run from reality, Earth will descend into the dark ages again where Zealots & Fanatics reign in
    basements perfecting the light bulb. If they continue to run from
    reality, The Crusades will be taken up again soon. For most, The
    Crusades is the bitter pill they have to swallow as Christians. If they continue to run from reality, these Crusades hating Christians will fall
    from the Christian vine like little undeveloped grapes. If they continue
    to run from reality, they will all burn in Hell for fracturing their
    religion. I understand you were on auto-pilot by the time you got to
    this, but you should recognize MarkE is not the only one reading.

    Creationist like you just have to maintain the progression of giving up
    on Biblical interpretations that we can figure out for ourselves.-a Early Christians had already given up on the Biblical belief that the earth
    was flat.-a Kepler was likely the last creationist seriously messing with the existence of the firmament and he had to give it up and go with elliptical heliocentric orbits.-a The article by the orthodox Jewish
    author that I put up claimed that the firmament was believed to be a
    solid dome above the earth until geocentrism failed (around the same
    time Kepler gave up on the notion).-a Sticks claims to be a young earth creationist, but you are likely an old earth creationist, so Sticks and
    you likely are no longer flat earth geocentric creationists.-a Isn't it stupid that Sticks has not yet given up on the young earth Biblical belief?

    People don't live in the sky. I'm not convinced as you about what
    exactly is up there. It's not every day I can hike to the top of Pike's
    Peak and look out over the cloud cover.

    -a The origin of life
    (#3 of the Top Six) on earth may have occurred 4 billion years ago under conditions vastly different than now exists on this planet.

    I wanted to showcase this. It expresses something that's been on my mind
    with the way MarkE goes on about "information" and liquid solutions.

    Kalk and Bill quit the ID scam when the ID perps committed suicide by putting the Top Six out in the order in which they must have occurred in this universe.-a Kalk and Bill were anti-evolution Biblical creationists like yourself.-a You and Glenn just ran and would not deal with the Top
    Six in any rational and honest manner.-a You are still running, but
    reality is never going to change.

    Reality changes just as much from ignorance as it does from wisdom. I
    don't understand why you think differently. Cause & Effect... If I go
    over and throw that chair over the rail, dropping it five floors, the
    reality is that I won't be enjoying the library anymore, yet where was
    there any wisdom in what I done?
    --
    Do you want a friendship with chaos?
    Wanna party with Perses?
    Consequences mean nothing to me
    Morning is your problem, I don't stick around
    The damage is done, itrCOs all you from here
    And donrCOt come a looking 'cause I simply do not care
    Like yourCOd even find me
    Well, maybe after a few pints
    And I only make an appearance when the time is right
    You see, I'm all about the here and now
    Live in the moment and all that, carpe diem

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ernest Major@{$to$}@meden.demon.co.uk to talk-origins on Thu Oct 8 21:12:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 08/10/2026 15:55, Blaine wrote:
    MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science.
    The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular
    life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and rCLbiology-
    backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap in
    complexity..."

    Yeah, guys. It only took 3 billion years which is relatively instantaneous.


    It took the earth around 1 billion years to get to the presence of stromatolites. There are chemical signals interpreted as evidence of
    life that are considerably older.
    --
    alias Ernest Major

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RonO@rokimoto557@gmail.com to talk-origins on Thu Oct 8 19:21:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On 10/8/2026 2:12 PM, Blaine wrote:
    RonO wrote:
    On 10/8/2026 6:18 AM, MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science.
    The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular
    life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and rCLbiology-
    backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap in
    complexity..."

    "Today, the origin of life remains one of the biggest open questions
    in biology. How did life emerge and gain complexity?"

    "Yet, a vast gulf remains between rCLchemistry-forwardrCY approaches and >>> derived biological processes."

    "The canonical rCLchicken-and-eggrCY paradox at the origins of life has >>> led to a variety of proposed mechanisms for self-replication without
    coordinated enzymes."

    _______

    The eco-evolutionary origins of life
    https://academic.oup.com/evolut/article/78/1/1/7334978


    You have to start acknowledging that all your denial about the origin
    of life is just a "So what?" stupid argument.-a You only use it to lie
    to yourself because you have already acknowledged that the origin of
    life gap is not Biblical.-a No matter how the gap is filled you lose.
    You have been running from the Top Six for nearly 9 years because you
    can't deal with the reality of what the ID scam has always been.-a If
    the ID perps had actually had the science to fill the Top Six gaps you
    would not support that science, and it would just be more science for
    you to deny, just as you deny all the valid scientific evidence that
    tells you that life has been evolving on this planet for billions of
    years.

    The god that could fill the existing origin of life gap is not the god
    described in the Bible.-a End of that story.-a Did you read how the
    Reason to Believe ex IDiots tried and failed to put the actual origin
    of life into their Biblical model.-a They acknowledged that the actual
    origin of life is never mentioned in the Bible, and they still wanted
    plants to be created during the 3rd period of time, but that made the
    rest inconsistent with what the Bible claimed.-a They understood that
    the land masses existed after the earth cooled enough to have liquid
    water, and that life likely evolved on a planet that had dry land
    masses, but they wanted to claim that land masses did not form on this
    planet until plants evolved during the 3rd period of time.-a They were
    willing to deny the ice ball earth events that occurred after life
    existed on this planet when most of the water existed as ice at the
    poles.-a There is no doubt that land masses existed long before the
    Biblical 3rd period of time.-a Putting the origin of life into their
    model destroyed the Biblical claims.-a They even wanted to remain in
    denial of biological evolution even though they understood that life
    had been evolving for billions of years and that sea creatures and
    terrestrial animals had evolved long before the land plants described
    in the Bible evolved.-a The 6 day creation is just inconsistent with
    reality even if you claim that they are 6 periods of time.

    Harran put up the Pope Francis quote about believing in the Big Bang
    and subsequent evolution of everything rather than the creation as 6
    magic acts.-a In order to be a creationist that is compatible with the
    Top Six best IDiotic gap denial arguments you have to be like Denton
    or Behe. Those two are theistic evolutionists that have given up on
    the 6 day creation myth.-a Nelson was never such a creationists and he
    depended on the ID perps lying about having the ID science to fill
    their gaps-a Pope Francis could deal with the Top Six gaps, but the ex
    IDiots at Reason to Believe cannot, nor can anti-evolution
    creationists like you and Sticks. -a-aRunning from reality is never
    going to change reality.

    That's not true at all. If they continue to run from reality, Earth will descend into the dark ages again where Zealots & Fanatics reign in
    basements perfecting the light bulb. If they continue to run from
    reality, The Crusades will be taken up again soon. For most, The
    Crusades is the bitter pill they have to swallow as Christians.-a If they continue to run from reality, these Crusades hating Christians will fall from the Christian vine like little undeveloped grapes. If they continue
    to run from reality, they will all burn in Hell for fracturing their religion. I understand you were on auto-pilot by the time you got to
    this, but you should recognize MarkE is not the only one reading.

    A return to the dark ages is about the only thing that Biblical
    creationist like MarkE can hope for at this time. The original mission statement and the Wedge document claimed that the ID perps wanted to
    recreate a theocracy that likely never existed in the US. The Founding Fathers did not want a repeat of the sad situation that Europe had gone through and was currently going through at that time. A lot of
    colonists had come to America in order to leave that type of religious stupidity behind. It is true that these colonists were by and large
    just as stupid about religious beliefs that they did not agree with, but
    the sensible ones ended up agreeing that we could not found this country
    under the rule of any single religious belief. The Puritans were
    already trying to ban other religions in their colonies, and that just
    was not going to work for all the colonies that did not agree with the Puritans.

    Behe even admitted that ID was science equivalent to astrology of the
    dark ages when some astronomers were making a buck being court
    astrologers, but that did not make astrology scientific.

    ID was supposed to be the Wedge to break science's strangle hold on
    reality. They really wanted their Biblical beliefs to return to being preeminent, in the US. They even named the ID scam unit The Center for Renewal of Science and Culture.

    It turned out that the ID science had never existed, so they had to
    start running the bait and switch on the hapless creationist rubes that believed that they actually had something that could be used to make the political changes that they desired. IDiots like MarkE rolled over for
    the bait and switch scam as the only means left to support their
    Biblical beilefs. It turned out that MarkE never had wanted the ID
    science to exist, and was only into the scam for the gap denial. It
    really is his only means to keep believing what he wants to believe.
    The only way for MarkE to get what he wants is for society to go back to
    the dark ages, but nearly all the creationist rubes that have fallen for
    the ID bait have dropped the issue instead of bend over for the
    obfuscation and denial switch scam. Many more rubes would need to roll
    over for the switch scam in order for that to happen. So far the only creationist rubes that have bent over for the switch scam have wanted to dishonestly use the scam to teach creationism in the public schools, but
    the ID perps always tell them not to do that. All the ID perps want to
    happen is for the students to be lied to about reality enough so that
    they can keep falling for the ID scam as bait. The problem is that none
    of the creationist rubes want to teach their kids enough science for
    them to understand what it is that they have to deny, if they can't tell
    them why they are lying to the kids. All the kids would be left with is
    the question as to why they were being taught a load of crap.


    Creationist like you just have to maintain the progression of giving
    up on Biblical interpretations that we can figure out for ourselves.
    Early Christians had already given up on the Biblical belief that the
    earth was flat.-a Kepler was likely the last creationist seriously
    messing with the existence of the firmament and he had to give it up
    and go with elliptical heliocentric orbits.-a The article by the
    orthodox Jewish author that I put up claimed that the firmament was
    believed to be a solid dome above the earth until geocentrism failed
    (around the same time Kepler gave up on the notion).-a Sticks claims to
    be a young earth creationist, but you are likely an old earth
    creationist, so Sticks and you likely are no longer flat earth
    geocentric creationists.-a Isn't it stupid that Sticks has not yet
    given up on the young earth Biblical belief?

    People don't live in the sky. I'm not convinced as you about what
    exactly is up there. It's not every day I can hike to the top of Pike's
    Peak and look out over the cloud cover.

    No one has ever been able to detect any firmament above the earth, even
    the ancients. They just believed that it had to exist or everything
    would fall to earth. The actual orbits of the moon and our orbit around
    the sun destroyed the concept of the the sun and moon being created on
    the 4th day and placed in the firmament. We've been to the moon, and
    sent space probes to the outer planets, and no firmament was ever
    detected. Really, Kepler tried to make his crystal spheres work, but he
    had to give them up for elliptical orbits. Once heliocentrism was
    established no one seriously considered the firmament as actually existing.


    -a The origin of life
    (#3 of the Top Six) on earth may have occurred 4 billion years ago
    under conditions vastly different than now exists on this planet.

    I wanted to showcase this. It expresses something that's been on my mind with the way MarkE goes on about "information" and liquid solutions.

    After running from the Top Six MarkE started to spend a lot of time
    developing the conditions that would have existed on an earth that had
    cooled enough to have liquid water on the surface of the planet. He was
    doing this in order to claim that life could never have arisen by
    natural processes under those conditions. He developed a detailed
    description of the origin of life gap that the ID perps were claiming
    could not be filled by natural processes, but he had to use the natural processes that had created the environment needed to create the gap. I pointed out that MarkE had just demonstrated that the origin of life gap
    was inconsistent with his Biblical beliefs. MarkE is an anti-evolution Biblical creationists, and the actual origin of life on this planet is
    not Biblical. It is just as non Biblical as biological evolution.
    MarkE quit posting the origin of life gap denial and ran from what he
    had done for months. He eventually came back to use the gap denial
    stupidity, admitted that the gap was not Biblical, but that he did not
    have to deal with that fact until the gap was filled. He literally
    admitted that he was only using the gap for denial purposes, and never
    wanted the gap filled by any valid ID science. If the ID perps had not
    been lying to MarkE for years about the gap he would never have become
    an IDiot. MarkE depends on valid ID science not existing in order to
    keep using the gap denial to support his religious beliefs.

    Kalk and Bill quit the ID scam when the ID perps committed suicide by
    putting the Top Six out in the order in which they must have occurred
    in this universe.-a Kalk and Bill were anti-evolution Biblical
    creationists like yourself.-a You and Glenn just ran and would not deal
    with the Top Six in any rational and honest manner.-a You are still
    running, but reality is never going to change.

    Reality changes just as much from ignorance as it does from wisdom. I
    don't understand why you think differently. Cause & Effect... If I go
    over and throw that chair over the rail, dropping it five floors, the reality is that I won't be enjoying the library anymore, yet where was
    there any wisdom in what I done?


    You sound like Bill. Before Bill quit supporting the ID scam he
    realized that the reality that actually existed did not support his
    Biblical beliefs. Bill started claiming that reality did not exist, and
    that his willful ignorance could support a reality just as substantial
    as the one science has to deal with every day. Science would not work
    if Bill was right.

    Ron Okimoto

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kerr-Mudd, John@admin@127.0.0.1 to talk-origins on Fri Oct 9 20:08:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: talk.origins

    On Thu, 8 Oct 2026 21:12:43 +0100
    Ernest Major <{$to$}@meden.demon.co.uk> wrote:

    On 08/10/2026 15:55, Blaine wrote:
    MarkE wrote:
    "The origin of life remains one of the greatest enigmas in science.
    The immense leap in complexity between prebiotic soup and cellular
    life challenges historically rCLchemistry-forwardrCY and rCLbiology-
    backwardsrCY approaches. Evolution must have bridged this gap in
    complexity..."

    Yeah, guys. It only took 3 billion years which is relatively instantaneous.


    It took the earth around 1 billion years to get to the presence of stromatolites. There are chemical signals interpreted as evidence of
    life that are considerably older.

    God was happier to let things run along quietly back then. 3 billion-
    odd years later he had a wakeup call and decided he'd better get some
    humans made, so they could worry about Sin.
    --
    Bah, and indeed Humbug.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2