On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't
science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the
position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display
empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
ItrCOs not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
For example, I donrCOt think anyone can disagree that good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of individual psychological thing but I donrCOt think that explains it at societal level.
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I donrCOt expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original question rCo why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
On 10/11/26 2:33 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't >>> science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the
position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display >>> empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations" >>> are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing >>> a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
ItrCOs not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
Dark energy is a universal constant whose strength can be measured. Dark matter exerts gravitational force that can be measured, and its
distribution through the universe can be measured.
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
Perhaps, but your example is not good.
For example, I donrCOt think anyone can disagree that-a good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
If so, you need to make such a case, which unfortunately you don't do.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of
individual psychological thing but I donrCOt think that explains it at
societal level.
Why not? Some societies encourage altruism more than others, and even
more so focus the sort of altruism that is and isn't encouraged.
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil-a being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
How is this explained by opposing external forces? Why do they affect
people in different places in different ways, and also affect people in
the same place in different ways? And which one is God anyway, in your estimation? Does he encourage the Israelis, or is that Satan? Is God
making me hate Trump? I would suggest that his behavior is responsible.
THis makes no sense.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I donrCOt expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original
question rCo why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
Because these mysterious forces don't act in any ways that can be
studied. They're too vague to have meaning. You could explain any
pattern, or any lack of pattern, by appeal to them.
On 10/11/26 2:33 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't >>> science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the
position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display >>> empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations" >>> are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing >>> a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
It's not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
Dark energy is a universal constant whose strength can be measured.
Dark
matter exerts gravitational force that can be measured, and its
distribution through the universe can be measured.
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
Perhaps, but your example is not good.
For example, I don't think anyone can disagree that good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
If so, you need to make such a case, which unfortunately you don't do.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of
individual psychological thing but I don't think that explains it at
societal level.
Why not? Some societies encourage altruism more than others, and even
more so focus the sort of altruism that is and isn't encouraged.
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
How is this explained by opposing external forces? Why do they affect
people in different places in different ways, and also affect people in
the same place in different ways? And which one is God anyway, in your >estimation? Does he encourage the Israelis, or is that Satan? Is God
making me hate Trump? I would suggest that his behavior is responsible.
THis makes no sense.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I don't expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original
question - why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
Because these mysterious forces don't act in any ways that can be
studied. They're too vague to have meaning. You could explain any
pattern, or any lack of pattern, by appeal to them.
I should also say that I've always thought that the idea of an active
Satan was theologically weird. Why should God permit such a thing, which >results in much evil not attributable to the need for free will? If >anything, it would imply more of an Ormadz vs. Ahriman sort of
relationship, with two equal opposing forces.
On Sun, 11 Oct 2026 18:48:20 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/11/26 2:33 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however, >>>>> does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating. >>>>> The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion >>>>> to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their >>>>> acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion, >>>>> we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as >>>>> we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in >>>>> the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go >>>>> with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't >>>> science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the >>>> position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display >>>> empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations" >>>> are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing >>>> a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
It's not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
Dark energy is a universal constant whose strength can be measured.
We can measure the rate at which the Universe is expanding and
determine the rate at which that expansion is accelerating but that
tells us nothing about the nature of dark energy, where it comes from
or why it acts in the way it does.
Dark
matter exerts gravitational force that can be measured, and its
distribution through the universe can be measured.
Actually, all that we can determine is that gravitational effects seem
to be equally distributed so we assume that dark matter is evenly
distributed but there is an element of circular reasoning there - we
assume the existence of dark matter from gravitational effects and
then try to use dark matter to justify those gravitational effects.
Again, I probably need to emphasise that I am not disputing those
scientific conclusions, just highlighting how much assumption and
speculation they are based on.
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
Perhaps, but your example is not good.
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in
other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
For example, I don't think anyone can disagree that good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
If so, you need to make such a case, which unfortunately you don't do.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of
individual psychological thing but I don't think that explains it at
societal level.
Why not? Some societies encourage altruism more than others, and even
more so focus the sort of altruism that is and isn't encouraged.
So why do societies differ in that way?
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
How is this explained by opposing external forces? Why do they affect
people in different places in different ways, and also affect people in
the same place in different ways? And which one is God anyway, in your
estimation? Does he encourage the Israelis, or is that Satan? Is God
making me hate Trump? I would suggest that his behavior is responsible.
THis makes no sense.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I don't expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original
question - why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
Because these mysterious forces don't act in any ways that can be
studied. They're too vague to have meaning. You could explain any
pattern, or any lack of pattern, by appeal to them.
I should also say that I've always thought that the idea of an active
Satan was theologically weird. Why should God permit such a thing, which
results in much evil not attributable to the need for free will? If
anything, it would imply more of an Ormadz vs. Ahriman sort of
relationship, with two equal opposing forces.
There you go again, trying to turn my question about science into some
sort of theological debate. In a triumph of optimism over experience,
I keep hoping that someday you will try to stick with what I did say,
rather than trying to attack me for stuff I didn't say.
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
Why should anyone here take the time to fill in a
dinosaur like yourself?
On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 07:11:19 -0600, Blaine <cactus_DAC@yahoo.com>
wrote:
[...]
Why should anyone here take the time to fill in a
dinosaur like yourself?
Because not everyone here is a prick like you.
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/11/26 2:33 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however, >>>>> does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating. >>>>> The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion >>>>> to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their >>>>> acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion, >>>>> we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as >>>>> we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in >>>>> the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go >>>>> with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it
doesn't
science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the >>>> position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not
display
empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural
"explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you
proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
ItrCOs not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
Dark energy is a universal constant whose strength can be measured.
Dark matter exerts gravitational force that can be measured, and its
distribution through the universe can be measured.
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
Perhaps, but your example is not good.
For example, I donrCOt think anyone can disagree that-a good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
If so, you need to make such a case, which unfortunately you don't do.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of
individual psychological thing but I donrCOt think that explains it at
societal level.
Why not? Some societies encourage altruism more than others, and even
more so focus the sort of altruism that is and isn't encouraged.
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil-a being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
How is this explained by opposing external forces? Why do they affect
people in different places in different ways, and also affect people
in the same place in different ways? And which one is God anyway, in
your estimation? Does he encourage the Israelis, or is that Satan? Is
God making me hate Trump? I would suggest that his behavior is
responsible. THis makes no sense.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I donrCOt expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original >>> question rCo why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
Because these mysterious forces don't act in any ways that can be
studied. They're too vague to have meaning. You could explain any
pattern, or any lack of pattern, by appeal to them.
Perhaps you are trying to goad me into relaying my supernatural story.
This was way beyond human senses filling in the blanks. You might almost
say she glowed. And the audio was definitely, highly perceptible.
I think I looked away, but when I looked again, she had completely
vanished. Where a moment ago sat a young lady was emptiness.
What do you do next? Call me a liar?
I guess I'm debating your 'vague' description. This was not vague.
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't >science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the >position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display >empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
On Sun, 11 Oct 2026 18:48:20 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/11/26 2:33 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On 08/10/2026 14:50, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however, >>>>> does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating. >>>>> The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion >>>>> to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their >>>>> acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion, >>>>> we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as >>>>> we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in >>>>> the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go >>>>> with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't >>>> science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the >>>> position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display >>>> empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations" >>>> are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing >>>> a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
It's not clear to me what empirical regularities you see applying to
Dark Energy and Dark matter
Dark energy is a universal constant whose strength can be measured.
We can measure the rate at which the Universe is expanding and
determine the rate at which that expansion is accelerating but that
tells us nothing about the nature of dark energy, where it comes from
or why it acts in the way it does.
Dark
matter exerts gravitational force that can be measured, and its
distribution through the universe can be measured.
Actually, all that we can determine is that gravitational effects seem
to be equally distributed so we assume that dark matter is evenly
distributed but there is an element of circular reasoning there - we
assume the existence of dark matter from gravitational effects and
then try to use dark matter to justify those gravitational effects.
Again, I probably need to emphasise that I am not disputing those
scientific conclusions, just highlighting how much assumption and
speculation they are based on.
but in terms of regular observable
behaviour, I think that can be seen in relation to religious belief.
Perhaps, but your example is not good.
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in
other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
For example, I don't think anyone can disagree that good and evil
both exist in our world but I think there is a good case for regarding
them as driven by some sort of non-material force.
If so, you need to make such a case, which unfortunately you don't do.
We see it at
individual level where some people are highly altruistic to the extent
of devoting their lives to help other people; other people are
entirely selfish. Arguments have been made that that is some sort of
individual psychological thing but I don't think that explains it at
societal level.
Why not? Some societies encourage altruism more than others, and even
more so focus the sort of altruism that is and isn't encouraged.
So why do societies differ in that way?
How come most people outside Israel look on in horror
at what they see as the evil being perpetrated in Gaza but most
people in Israel (who I am sure are just as good and decent as those
watching on), regard the deliberate targeting of civilians including
children as an acceptable price for their own defence. Or look at your
own country where roughly half the population detest Trump and all he
does; the other half detest those who detest Trump.
How is this explained by opposing external forces? Why do they affect
people in different places in different ways, and also affect people in
the same place in different ways? And which one is God anyway, in your
estimation? Does he encourage the Israelis, or is that Satan? Is God
making me hate Trump? I would suggest that his behavior is responsible.
THis makes no sense.
I think a good argument can be made for the concept of two opposing
unseen forces, one attracting people to good, the other attracting
them to evil with most people hovering somewhere between those forces.
I don't expect you to agree with my conclusion but back to my original
question - why should it be rejected out of hand and not be accepted
as having potential explanatory value like Dark Energy and Dark Matter
have for other things going on in the universe?
Because these mysterious forces don't act in any ways that can be
studied. They're too vague to have meaning. You could explain any
pattern, or any lack of pattern, by appeal to them.
I should also say that I've always thought that the idea of an active
Satan was theologically weird. Why should God permit such a thing, which
results in much evil not attributable to the need for free will? If
anything, it would imply more of an Ormadz vs. Ahriman sort of
relationship, with two equal opposing forces.
There you go again, trying to turn my question about science into some
sort of theological debate. In a triumph of optimism over experience,
I keep hoping that someday you will try to stick with what I did say,
rather than trying to attack me for stuff I didn't say.
On Thu, 8 Oct 2026 14:50:32 +0100, Ernest Major
<{$to$}@meden.demon.co.uk> wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't
science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the
position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display
empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
I meant to respond to that last bit. I don't have any specific
research protocol but I can see ways in which some research could be
imitated in the example I gave about forces for good and evil. A lot
of research has gone into group motivation and behaviour. I'm out of
touch with what's going on nowadays but back in the 1970s/80s when I
was working as a management consultant in manufacturing industry, a
lot of work was carried out into employee motivation and performance
which led to a major swing away from conveyor-line type organisation
with specialist jobs to group working where a team would work
collaboratively to produce a complete product. Not sure how much of an
impact it had in the USA but it certainly had a major impact this side
of the Atlantic - I got a fair bit of consultancy work out of it :)
There has also been quite a lot of work on team working but I think
most of that has been focused on small teams working toward specific
goals whether those be related to work or to sports.
I would like to see a larger study done. Taking my earlier example of Americans being roughly divided into two groups regarding Trump, it
would be interesting to see an in-depth comparison of the two groups
across a range of factors such as social status, ethnicity, religious
belief, educational status and so on. I know that a lot of work has
been done along those lines but it seems to have been very focused on
likely voting intentions rather than what influences people to adopt
the standards and values that they do adopt.
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
Actually, all that we can determine is that gravitational effects seem
to be equally distributed so we assume that dark matter is evenly
distributed but there is an element of circular reasoning there - we
assume the existence of dark matter from gravitational effects and
then try to use dark matter to justify those gravitational effects.
Again, I probably need to emphasise that I am not disputing those
scientific conclusions, just highlighting how much assumption and
speculation they are based on.
Dark matter is not evenly distributed. Where did you get that idea?
On Mon, 12 Oct 2026 08:25:50 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[...]
Actually, all that we can determine is that gravitational effects seem
to be equally distributed so we assume that dark matter is evenly
distributed but there is an element of circular reasoning there - we
assume the existence of dark matter from gravitational effects and
then try to use dark matter to justify those gravitational effects.
Again, I probably need to emphasise that I am not disputing those
scientific conclusions, just highlighting how much assumption and
speculation they are based on.
Dark matter is not evenly distributed. Where did you get that idea?
Sorry, brain fart, it is dark energy that is evenly distributed. That
doesn't change my underlying point that we cannot measure either dark
matter or dark energy, we can only measure what we *think* are their
effects.
[...]
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural "explanations"
are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you proposing
a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in
other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
[...]
I would like to see a larger study done. Taking my earlier example of Americans being roughly divided into two groups regarding Trump, it
would be interesting to see an in-depth comparison of the two groups
across a range of factors such as social status, ethnicity, religious
belief, educational status and so on. I know that a lot of work has
been done along those lines but it seems to have been very focused on
likely voting intentions rather than what influences people to adopt
the standards and values that they do adopt.
On 10/8/26 1:38 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
The problem is with the definition of "supernatural". What makes you
think dark matter or dark energy -- or even gravity, for that matter --
are not supernatural? They can be if you want to look at them that way.
On 10/8/26 6:50 AM, Ernest Major wrote:
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out
of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the
planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other
gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real
supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they
consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it
doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take
the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not
display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural
"explanations" are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you
proposing a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
One must note that several purportedly supernatural phenomena, such as dousing, remote viewing, and faith healing, *do* claim empirical regularities and *have* been investigated scientifically. Of course, in
no such cases have the claims of empirical regularity been found to have merit.
Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/8/26 6:50 AM, Ernest Major wrote:No merit? Did you see my quote about not being able to take out a camera
On 08/10/2026 09:38, Martin Harran wrote:
One of the reasons most often given for rejecting the supernatural out >>>> of hand is that it cannot be observed and examined. Science, however,
does not apply the same criteria in other areas.
The universe is expanding and the rate of expansion is accelerating.
The laws of physics say that nothing can accelerate without an
external force acting on it so scientists have concluded that there
must be some unknown external force causing the universe's expansion
to accelerate; they call it Dark Energy. Whilst the universe is
expanding, the individual galaxies make up the universe are not
expanding, they are simply drifting apart; individual galaxies and the >>>> planets and stars within them are staying more or less static in
relation to each other. The known forces are not enough to explain
what holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other >>>> gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter.
Neither Dark Energy nor Dark Matter can be directly observed or
examined in any way - that is why they are described as "dark"; their
acceptance is based purely on their explanatory value without any real >>>> supporting evidence. I don't have any issue with either of these;
where we don't have evidence to directly underpin a firm conclusion,
we have to go with what seems the most logical explanation so long as
we recognise that our conclusions may change if we do get evidence in
the future. What does bother me is that science is quite happy to go
with such explanations but reject out of hand any other area that they >>>> consider as "supernatural". Seems like a bit of double standards at
work.
Science requires empirical regularities. If something supernatural
displays empirical regularities then science can study it; if it
doesn't science can't.
There is not to my knowledge a consensus on how one delimits the
boundary between the natural and the supernatural. Some people take
the position that the delimitation is that the supernatural does not
display empirical regularities; under that criterion supernatural
"explanations" are not scientific.
If you don't adopt that criterion there is nothing to stop you
proposing a research protocol to investigate the supernatural.
One must note that several purportedly supernatural phenomena, such as
dousing, remote viewing, and faith healing, *do* claim empirical
regularities and *have* been investigated scientifically. Of course,
in no such cases have the claims of empirical regularity been found to
have merit.
and film it, or did you just throw it under the bus like everything else here in talk.origins?
Yeah, you see the fakers, the posers, the impostors, They've got a sick empty area scenario at 0:00. Then some fag little guy alien walks around behind a ghetto neighbor n his hood fence. True supernatural? You don't
have the occasion to film. Okay?
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[snip context, since I'm pretty much changing the subject]
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in
other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
Is this a property of the universe, or is it an artifact of how our
minds like to divide things? I would argue the latter.
Dark matter and dark energy, for example, are not two opposing forces.
They are two very different phenomena, operating on different things at >different scales, which just happened to be given partially overlapping >names at about the same time.
Gravity is a single force that always
pulls on matter; momentum, as far as we know, is a different property of >matter. Quarks come in threes. Anything can be paired with its lack (for >example, light and shadow, negative and positive electrical charge), but >that's hardly opposing forces. The only actual dualism I can think of in >physics is matter and antimatter.
The good/evil dichotomy is probably a good example *against* opposing >forces.
Even a superficial study of human nature will show that behavior
is far, far more complicated than such a dichotomy can capture, and you
can easily find instances in which the same act is good to some and evil
to others.
On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 15:39:34 -0700, Mark Isaak <specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[snip context, since I'm pretty much changing the subject]
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in
other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
Is this a property of the universe, or is it an artifact of how our
minds like to divide things? I would argue the latter.
Dark matter and dark energy, for example, are not two opposing forces.
They are two very different phenomena, operating on different things at
different scales, which just happened to be given partially overlapping
names at about the same time.
Dark energy pulls things further apart. Dark matter negates that by preventing galaxies and their contents from moving apart. How is that
not the two forces working in opposition to each other?
Gravity is a single force that always
pulls on matter; momentum, as far as we know, is a different property of
matter. Quarks come in threes. Anything can be paired with its lack (for
example, light and shadow, negative and positive electrical charge), but
that's hardly opposing forces. The only actual dualism I can think of in
physics is matter and antimatter.
The good/evil dichotomy is probably a good example *against* opposing
forces.
You disagree that some people are drawn towards selfless behaviour,
others towards selfish behaviour?
Even a superficial study of human nature will show that behavior
is far, far more complicated than such a dichotomy can capture, and you
can easily find instances in which the same act is good to some and evil
to others.
Of course it's complex and whether a particular act is good or evil
depends on the circumstances and a person's particular set of ethics.
That's why I said in my original post, "with most people hovering
somewhere between those forces."
On 10/29/26 9:15 AM, Martin Harran wrote:I hope Martin realizes Isaak is so intent on dodging the obvious fact
On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 15:39:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[snip context, since I'm pretty much changing the subject]
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in >>>> other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
Is this a property of the universe, or is it an artifact of how our
minds like to divide things? I would argue the latter.
Dark matter and dark energy, for example, are not two opposing forces.
They are two very different phenomena, operating on different things at
different scales, which just happened to be given partially overlapping
names at about the same time.
Dark energy pulls things further apart. Dark matter negates that by
preventing galaxies and their contents from moving apart. How is that
not the two forces working in opposition to each other?
Dark matter works on the scale of galaxies, and perhaps on galaxy
clusters. (I have never heard of the latter, but it sounds plausible.)
Dark energy works on the scale of the entire cosmos.
On 10/29/26 9:15 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 15:39:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
On 10/12/26 4:35 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
[snip context, since I'm pretty much changing the subject]
I disagree. What I think is particularly relevant is that it
identifies two opposing forces which is something we see regularly in
nature. Dark energy and dark matter are one example with one force
pulling things apart and the other binding them together. We see it in >>>> other areas; for example, gravitation would cause the moon to crash
into the Earth if it wasn't counterbalanced by the momentum coming
from the moon's forward speed.
Is this a property of the universe, or is it an artifact of how our
minds like to divide things? I would argue the latter.
Dark matter and dark energy, for example, are not two opposing forces.
They are two very different phenomena, operating on different things at
different scales, which just happened to be given partially overlapping
names at about the same time.
Dark energy pulls things further apart. Dark matter negates that by
preventing galaxies and their contents from moving apart. How is that
not the two forces working in opposition to each other?
Dark matter works on the scale of galaxies, and perhaps on galaxy
clusters. (I have never heard of the latter, but it sounds plausible.)
Dark energy works on the scale of the entire cosmos.
Gravity is a single force that always
pulls on matter; momentum, as far as we know, is a different property of >>> matter. Quarks come in threes. Anything can be paired with its lack (for >>> example, light and shadow, negative and positive electrical charge), but >>> that's hardly opposing forces. The only actual dualism I can think of in >>> physics is matter and antimatter.
The good/evil dichotomy is probably a good example *against* opposing
forces.
You disagree that some people are drawn towards selfless behaviour,
others towards selfish behaviour?
Of course I disagree. I myself am often drawn towards selfless behavior,
and at other times towards selfish behavior. I believe the apostle Paul spoke of similar sentiments.
Even a superficial study of human nature will show that behavior
is far, far more complicated than such a dichotomy can capture, and you
can easily find instances in which the same act is good to some and evil >>> to others.
Of course it's complex and whether a particular act is good or evil
depends on the circumstances and a person's particular set of ethics.
That's why I said in my original post, "with most people hovering
somewhere between those forces."
Except they don't hover between, but waver back and forth.
And for Martin, dark matter isn't a force. The force involved is the
same gravity that we experience every day.
On Wed, 4 Nov 2026 12:53:41 +0000, Ernest Major
<{$to$}@meden.demon.co.uk> wrote:
[rCa]
And for Martin, dark matter isn't a force. The force involved is the
same gravity that we experience every day.
Fair enough, I was perhaps too concise in my last response to Mark but
in my OP I did say "The known forces are not enough to explain what
holds these galaxies and their contents together along with other gravitational effects, so scientists have come up with the idea of
unknown particles that they call Dark Matter."
I thought that made clear that I was aware that gravity is the force I
was referring to.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:29:16 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |