On 08/10/2026 06:11, MarkE wrote:
On 7/10/2026 8:23 pm, Ernest Major wrote:
How do you address the tension between the claim that the universe is
fine-tuned for life, and that claim that natural causes cannot
account for the existence of life.
Fine-tuning is necessary but not sufficient.
A universe such as this which can sustain life as we know it is
necessary (and necessarily fined-tuned), but that, in and of itself,
is insufficient to assemble inanimate matter into life - that requires
a non-material intelligent agent.
I thought that this might be your response - that a universe that is fine-tuned to support life is not necessarily fine-tuned to produce
life. But that leaves a question unanswered - why did the putative
designer produce a universe putatively incapable of spontaneously
creating life.
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
"Recent developments (2020-2024) have:
1. Increased our understanding of the complexity involved
2. Revealed new layers of integrated systems
3. Highlighted the need for multiple, synchronized processes
4. Demonstrated the inadequacy of simple, linear explanations
5. Shown the requirement for precise, coordinated mechanisms"
"While new techniques provide deeper insights into prebiotic chemistry,
they also reveal additional layers of complexity that must be explained
in any naturalistic origin scenario."
1. *Introduction: The Origin of Life - A Journey into Complexity*
1.1. What is Life? Understanding the Origin Challenge
1.2. The Journey from Non-Life to Life: A Scientific Perspective from
Half a Century Ago
1.3. The Origin of Life: A Puzzle with Many Attempts to Solve It
1.3.1. Charles Darwin and the Origin of Life
1.3.2. Development of Origin of Life Hypotheses: A Theoretical Evolution 1.3.2.1 Recent Developments in Origin of Life Research (2020-2024)
1.3.2.2 Assembly Theory: Core Proposal and Framework
1.3.2.3 Critique of Assembly Theory
1.3.3. Primordial Soup and Pond Hypotheses
1.3.4. Hydrothermal Vent and Submarine Hypotheses
1.3.5. Volcano-Related Hypotheses
1.3.6. From Space Hypotheses (Panspermia, Meteorites, Solar Wind)
1.3.7. Clay and Mineral Surface Hypotheses
1.3.8. RNA, Peptide, and Protein Hypotheses
1.3.9.-a Quantum and Thermodynamic Hypotheses
1.4. Current Understanding
1.4.1. Broader Stages of Bottom-Up Development
1.5 LUCA and FUCA: Key Concepts in the Origin of Life
1.5.1 LUCA (Last Universal Common Ancestor)
1.5.2 FUCA (First Universal Common Ancestor)
1.5.3 From Chemical Networks to Early Life
1.5.4-a The Elusive Root: The Proposed Diverse Branches
1.6 Hypothesized Sites for the Origin of Life
1.7 Hypothesized Atmospheric Conditions for the Origin of Life
1.8 Concluding Remarks : The Journey into Complexity
2. *Fundamental difficulties in Prebiotic Chemistry*
2.1 Chemical synthesis of organic compounds
2.2 Simple organic molecules
2.2.1 The Role and difficulties of Key Prebiotic Molecules in the Origin
of Life
2.3 Origin of the organic compounds on the prebiotic earth
2.3.1 Historical Context: The Miller-Urey Experiment
2.3.2 Origin of Proteinogenic Amino Acids
2.3.3 Panspermia and Extraterrestrial Sources
2.3.4 Recent Discoveries in Meteorites
2.3.5 Hydrothermal Vents and Amino Acid Synthesis
2.4. Prebiotic Amino Acid Synthesis
2.4.1. Availability and challenges associated with major atoms required
to synthesize amino acids
2.4.2. Chemical Precursors: Availability and Selection Challenges
2.4.3. Availability of Chemical Precursors: Fundamental Obstacles
2.5. Quantity and Concentration: Barriers in Prebiotic Amino Acid Availability
2.5.1. Quantitative Challenges
2.5.2. Requirements for Natural Occurrence
2.6. Stability and Reactivity: The Prebiotic Amino Acid Paradox
2.6.1. Quantitative Challenges
2.6.2. Implications for Current Models
2.6.3. Requirements for Natural Occurrence
2.7 Selection of the 20 proteinogenic amino acids on early earth
2.7.1 The Mystery of the Twenty Amino Acids in the Genetic Code
2.7.2 The Exclusivity of Alpha-Amino Acids in Protein Synthesis
2.7.3 The Selection Problem: How Did Life Choose These Specific Amino
Acids?
2.7.4 The Limitless Possibility of Amino Acids
2.7.5 problems to Random Selection of the Amino Acid Set
2.7.6 Quantum Chemistry Hypotheses and Their Limitations
2.7.7 The Optimality of the Standard Amino Acid Alphabet
2.7.8 Studies Supporting the Optimality and Nonrandomness of the Amino
Acid Set
2.7.9 Implications and Conclusions
2.8 The Requirement of Chiral Amino Acids: Unraveling the Mystery of Homochirality
2.8.1 Hypothesized Prebiotic Mechanisms for the Emergence of Biological Homochirality
2.9 Amplification of Enantiomeric Excess
2.10 Explaining Homochirality through Natural Processes
2.11 Fundamental Barriers to Prebiotic Chemistry
2.11.1 Limitations of Autocatalytic and Amplification Models
2.12 From prebiotic to biotic chirality determination
2.12.1 Aspartate Aminotransferase: A Universal Requirement
2.13 The racemization of amino acids and polypeptides under natural conditions is inevitable
2.14 Problems of Prebiotic Peptide Bond Formation
2.14.1 Quantitative Findings Challenging Conventional Theories
2.14.2 Implications for Current Models
2.14.3 Natural Formation Requirements
2.14.4 Mutually Exclusive Conditions
2.14.5 Case Studies
2.15 Thermodynamic and Kinetic Barriers to Polymerization
2.15.1 Catalysis and Polymerization Challenges
2.16 Thermodynamic and Kinetic Barriers to Prebiotic Polypeptide Formation 2.16.1 Quantitative difficulties
2.16.2 Implications for Current Models
2.16.3 Requirements for Natural Occurrence
2.17-a Sequence and Structure Formation in Prebiotic Protein Emergence
2.17.1 Quantitative problems
2.17.2 Implications for Current Models
2.17.3 Requirements for Natural Protein Formation
2.18 Protein Folding and Chaperones
2.18.1 Quantitative Findings Challenging Conventional Theories
2.18.2 Implications for Current Scientific Models
2.18.3 Requirements and Conditions
2.18.4 Illustrative Examples
2.18.5 Critical Examination of Current Theories
2.18.6 Metabolic Integration
2.18.7 Quantitative Findings Challenging Conventional Theories
2.18.8 Requirements and Conditions
2.19 Proposed Environments and Conditions for Prebiotic Amino Acid
Synthesis
2.19.1 Terrestrial Surface Environments
2.19.2 Submarine Environments
2.19.3 Atmospheric Synthesis
2.19.4 Ice Environments
2.19.5 Extraterrestrial Delivery
2.19.6 Mineral Surface Environments
2.19.7 Formamide-based Synthesis
2.20 Summary: Prebiotic Chemistry and Early Molecular Synthesis
3. *Prebiotic Nucleotide Synthesis*
3.1 Formation of Simple Prebiotic Chemicals for Nucleotide Synthesis
3.1.1 Sources of carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus
3.1.2 Relevant atmospheric and aqueous chemistry
3.1.3 Energy sources for prebiotic reactions
3.2 Nucleobases: The Building Blocks of Genetic Information
3.3 Prebiotic Synthesis of Nucleobases
3.3.1 Purines (Adenine and Guanine)
3.3.2 Hydrogen Cyanide (HCN) Polymerization
3.3.3 Formamide-Based Synthesis
3.3.4 Pyrimidines (Cytosine and Uracil)
3.3.5 Cytosine Synthesis
3.3.6 Uracil Synthesis
3.3.7 Recent Advances in Pyrimidine Synthesis
3.3.8 Stability and Decomposition of Nucleobases
3.3.9 Selection of Nucleobases Used in Life
3.3.9.1 Nucleobase Fine-Tuning and Chemical Space
3.3.10 The Concept of Structure Space
3.3.11 Prebiotic Chemistry and Nucleobase Formation
3.3.12 The Challenge of Selection
3.3.13 Prebiotic Nucleobase Synthesis - Extraterrestrial Sources
3.4 Sugars, And The Prebiotic Origins of Ribose
3.4.1 Ribose - the best alternative
3.4.2 The difficulty to get ribose prebiotically
3.4.3 The Formose Reaction
3.4.4 Various possible ribose configurations
3.4.5 Selecting +#-nucleosides
3.5 Phosphorus
3.5.1 Sources of Prebiotic Phosphates
3.5.2 Activation of Phosphate
3.6 Nucleoside Formation
3.6.1 Glycosidic Bond Formation
3.6.1.1 Joining nucleobases and ribose
3.6.1.2 Regioselectivity obstacles
3.6.1.3 Potential catalysts and conditions
3.6.2 Prebiotic Nucleoside Analogues
3.6.3 Stability and Degradation of Nucleosides
3.7 Nucleotide Formation: Combining Nucleosides and Phosphates
3.7.1 Phosphorylation Mechanisms
3.7.1.1 Direct Phosphorylation of Nucleosides
3.7.1.2 Alternative Pathways
3.7.2 challenges in Selective Phosphorylation
3.7.3 Alternative Phosphorylation Mechanisms
3.7.4 Formation of Alternative Nucleotide Analogues
3.7.5 Prebiotic Phosphodiester Bond Formation
3.7.6 obstacles in Prebiotic Bond Formation
Unresolved barriers in Prebiotic Nucleotide Formation
3.8 Ribonucleotides to Deoxyribonucleotides
3.8.1 Reduction of Ribonucleotides
3.8.2 Difficulties in Selective Reduction
3.8.3 Prebiotic Availability of Reducing Agents
Unresolved obstacles in Prebiotic Reduction of Ribonucleotides
3.9 From Prebiotic Ribonucleotide and Deoxyribonucleotide Synthesis to Modern Synthesis in Cells: The Insurmountable Gulf
3.9.1 The Complexity of Modern Nucleotide Synthesis
3.9.2 The Chasm Between Prebiotic Synthesis and Modern Cellular Pathways 3.9.3 The Role of Metabolic Pathways and Regulation in Modern Cells
3.9.4 The Persistent obstacles in Prebiotic Synthesis
3.9.5 The Insurmountable Gulf: From Chemistry to Biology
3.10 Proposed Environments and Conditions for Prebiotic Nucleotide
Synthesis
3.10.1 Terrestrial Surface Environments
3.10.2 Submarine Environments
3.10.3 Atmospheric Synthesis
3.10.4 Ice Environments
3.10.5 Extraterrestrial Delivery
3.10.6 Mineral Surface Environments
3.10.7 Formamide-based Synthesis
3.11. Chapter 3 Summary Prebiotic Nucleotide Synthesis
4. *Prebiotic Carbohydrate Synthesis*
4.0.1 Fundamentals of Carbohydrate Chemistry
4.0.2 Prebiotic Carbohydrate Synthesis
4.0.3. Sources of Organic Molecules on Early Earth
4.0.4 Extraterrestrial Sources
4.0.5 Mineral-Catalyzed Synthesis
4.0.6 Recent Breakthroughs
4.0.7 Implications for Astrobiology
4.0.8 Future Research Directions
4.1 The Essential Role of Cell Membranes
4.2 Fundamental Properties of Cell Membranes
4.3 Structure and Composition of Phospholipids
4.4 Membrane Fluidity and Adaptation
4.5 The Challenge of Prebiotic Membrane Formation
4.6 Implications for Origin of Life Research
4.7 The Role of Glycerol in Membrane Formation
4.8 The Challenge of Phospholipid Homochirality
4.9 The Functional Significance of Membrane Homochirality
4.10 The Prebiotic Synthesis of Glycerol Phosphates
4.11 The Transition from Prebiotic to Biotic Synthesis
4.12 Prebiotic origin of phospholipids
4.13 Prebiotic synthesis of complete and incomplete phospholipids
4.14 Prebiotic phospholipid bond formation
4.15 No prebiotic explanation for the origin of complete lipids (CLs)
4.16. The degradation problem
4.17. Chapter 4 Summary Prebiotic Carbohydrate Synthesis
5. *Key Prebiotic Reactions and Processes*
5.1 Limitations Facing Prebiotic Chemical Reactions in the Origin of Life
5.2 Reactions Related to Amino Acids
5.2.1 Strecker Synthesis
5.2.2 Salt-Induced Peptide Formation
5.3 Reactions Related to Nucleotides
5.4 Reactions Related to Both Amino Acids and Nucleotides
5.4.1 Miller-Urey-type Reactions
5.4.2 HCN Polymerization
5.5 Reactions Involving Mineral Surfaces
5.6 HCN and UV Radiation Reactions
5.7 Concentration Mechanisms
5.7.1 Evaporation of Primordial Pools
5.7.2. Freeze-Thaw Cycles
5.7.3. Concentration in Micropores or Vesicles
5.7.4 Thermophoresis in Temperature Gradients
5.7.5 Salt-Induced Phase Separation
5.7.6 Concentration by Convection Cells in Hydrothermal Systems
5.8 Synthesis of Heterochiral Nucleotides
5.9 Synthesis of Non-Chiral PNA or ONA
5.9.1 Peptide Nucleic Acids (PNA)
5.9.2 Oligonucleotide Analogues (ONA)
5.10 Molecular Instability: obstacles in Explaining the Origin of Life
5.10.1 The Asphalt Paradox
5.10.2 The Water Paradox
5.10.3 The Information-Need Paradox
5.10.4 The Single Biopolymer Paradox
5.10.5 The Probability Paradox
5.11 Chapter 5 Summary: Key Prebiotic Reactions and Processes
6. *The RNA World Hypothesis: A Critical Examination*
6.1 Key Concepts and Proposed Mechanisms
6.1.1 Could RNA substitute proteins in an RNA world?
6.1.2 Limited catalytic possibilities of RNAs
6.1.3 Selecting ribozymes in the laboratory
6.1.4 Requirement of cofactors and coenzymes for ribozyme function
6.2 Problems in Prebiotic Synthesis: Linking Nucleotides and Forming Functional DNA
6.3 RNA Self-replication
6.3.1 Solving the chicken and egg problem?
6.3.1.1 Clarifying the Narrative: Gradual Emergence and Its Feasibility
6.3.2 Self-replication in the RNA world
6.3.3 The annealing problem
6.4 RNA Processing and Modification
6.5 RNA's Role in Protein Synthesis
6.6 RNA in Catalysis and Other Functions
6.6.1 DNA Prebiotic Synthesis
6.6.2 RNA and DNA Prebiotic Synthesis
6.7 RNA Protection and Degradation
6.8 Experimental Support and difficulties
6.9 Alternative Hypotheses and Criticisms
6.9.1 Current Research Directions
7. *The RNA-Peptide World*
7.0.1 Commentary on the Complexity of RNA-Peptides and Protein Folding
7.0.2 Commentary on the Complexity of Short RNA-Peptides and Ribosome Functionality
7.1 Integration of RNA and Peptides
7.2 Transition to Protein Synthesis
7.3 Experimental Support and Ongoing difficulties
7.4 The RNA-Peptide World Hypothesis rCo Concluding Remarks
8. *RNA Processing in Early Life: A multi-faceted System of
Interdependent Components*
8.1. RNA processing in the first life forms
8.1.1. RNA Synthesis and Maintenance
8.2. RNA's Role in Protein Synthesis
8.3. Ribosomal RNAs and the Origins of Life
8.3.1. Check Volume II, Chapter 11
8.3.2. RNA in Catalysis and Other Functions
8.3.3. RNA Protection and Degradation
8.4. Small RNA Pathways
8.5 Implications for Understanding the Origins of RNA Processing rCo Concluding Reflections
9. *Encapsulation in Vesicles*
9.1. Vesicle Formation and Stability
9.1.1. Related Problems and hurdles
9.2. First enzyme-mediated cells
9.3. Energetics and Transport: Early Methods of Energy Generation and Utilization in Proto-Cells
9.3.1. What came first: Lipid membranes, or membrane proteins?
9.3.2. The challenge to start harvesting energy
9.3.3. ATP - the Miracle molecule
9.3.4. Cell membranes, proton gradients, and the origin of life
9.3.5. Serpentinization and prebiotic chemistry
9.3.6. Nonsense remains nonsense, even when spoken by world-famous scientists
9.4 Summary: Proto-Cellular Structures and Early Metabolism: A Critical Examination
10. *Life's Emergence and First Life Forms*
10. 1. Abiotic Geochemistry and Biological Processes
10.1.1. Journey from Non-Life to Life
10.1.2. Was the First Life Form a Heterotroph or an Autotroph?
10.1.2.1. Heterotroph Hypothesis (Older Hypothesis)
10.1.2.2. Autotroph Hypothesis (More Modern Hypothesis)
10.1.2.3. RNA World and Metabolism-First hypotheses
10.2 The First Life Form is hypothesized to be a chemolithoautotroph
10.2.1. The Currently Closest Organism to Luca
10.2.2. problems of the Hydrothermal-Vent Theory in Life's Origins
10.2.3. High Temperatures Give Higher Reaction Rates, But There Is a
Price to Pay
10.2.4. A lot of origin-of-life reactions involve getting rid of water 10.2.5. From Raw Energy to ATP: Deciphering the Design within Cellular Mechanisms
10.2.6. Cellular Energy Systems: A elaborate Interplay of Components and Their Origins
10.2.7. The Limitations of Natural pH Gradients in Abiogenesis
10.2.8. Interwoven Complexity: Delving into Serpentinization and
Cellular Processes
10.3. The Metabolic Foundations of Primordial Life
10.3.1. The gas fixation mechanisms of the first life forms
10.3.2. Metabolism of Inorganic Substrates
10.3.3. Electron Transfer Processes
10.3.4. Synthesis and Degradation of Biomolecules
10.4. Can Evolution Explain the Diverse Metabolic Processes in
Hydrothermal Vent Organisms, Proposed as Life's Genesis?
10.4.1. Hydrothermal Vents: Deep-Sea Catalysts for Life
10.5. Metabolic Adaptations of Organisms in Deep-Sea Hydrothermal Vents 10.5.1. Metabolic Shift from Hydrogen to Sulfide Oxidation: challenges
and Implications
10.5.2. Evolutionary difficulties: Navigating Metabolic Shifts at Life's Origin
10.6. Decoding the Genetic Blueprint in LUCA: A Deep Dive into
Unresolved Complexities
10.7. The Gene Content of Earth's First Life-Forms
10.7.1. Nucleotide Synthesis and Recycling
10.7.2. DNA replication
10.7.3. Transcription (from DNA to RNA)
10.7.4. Translation (from RNA to Protein)
10.7.5. Protein Folding and Post-translational Modifications
10.7.6. Repair and Protection
10.7.7. Other Proteins and Complexes
10.8. Metabolic and Structural Transitions: From Deep-Sea Origins to Terrestrial Adaptation
10.8.1. From Deep-Sea Hydrothermal Vents to Ocean Surface
10.8.2. What Would Have Driven Life from the Ocean's Depths to its Surface? 10.8.3. From Vents to Surface: The Evolutionary Challenge of Oxygen and
ROS Management in Early Marine Life
10.8.4. Facing Dual Adversaries: Oxygen and UV Radiation in Early
Earth's Transitional Epoch
10.8.5. The Leap from Aquatic to Terrestrial Habitats: Requirement of Molecular and Metabolic Transformations
10.8.6. Membrane Emergence
10.8.7. Metabolic Reshuffling
10.8.8. DNA Protection and Repair
10.8.9. Emergence of Protective Structures
10.8.10. Sensory and Signaling Adaptation
10.8.11. Respiratory Adaptations
10.8.12. Reproductive Innovations
10.9 Ecology and Environment
10.9.1 Adaptation to Extreme Environments
10.9.2 Deep-sea Hydrothermal Vents Adaptations
10.9.3 Thermophilic Adaptations
10.10. Cellular Complexity
10.10.1 Cellular Structure and Complexity
10.11 Evolutionary Framework
Questions persist about LUCAs supposed exact form - whether a discrete organism or part of an interconnected biological network. How we
interpret LUCA's existence affects our grasp of early life's emergence
and development, particularly when examining its genomic and cellular features.
10.11.1 Community Over Singular Entity
10.11.2-a Implications
10.12 Community Dynamics
10.12.1 Genetically Fluid Community
10.12.2 Horizontal Gene Transfers
10.13 Summary: The First Life Forms and Proto-Cellular Structures: A Critical Examination
11. *Key problems in Prebiotic Chemistry*
11.1. General Key difficulties
11.2. Key problems in Prebiotic Amino Acid Synthesis
11.3 Key challenges in Prebiotic Nucleobase and Sugar Synthesis
11.4 Key challenges in Prebiotic Carbohydrate Synthesis and Early Protocellular Structures
11.6 Key difficulties in Carbohydrate Synthesis
"X-ray of life: Volume I: From Prebiotic Chemistry to Cells"
How do you address the tension between the claim that the universe is
fine-tuned for life, and that claim that natural causes cannot
account for the existence of life.
Fine-tuning is necessary but not sufficient.
A universe such as this which can sustain life as we know it is
necessary (and necessarily fined-tuned), but that, in and of itself,
is insufficient to assemble inanimate matter into life - that requires
a non-material intelligent agent.
I thought that this might be your response - that a universe that is fine-tuned to support life is not necessarily fine-tuned to produce
life. But that leaves a question unanswered - why did the putative
designer produce a universe putatively incapable of spontaneously
creating life.
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have
been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts "material"
with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and exhaust all
possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More
reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes the
best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-living matter have been discovered with power to produce large amounts of
specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
On 9/10/2026 12:28 am, Ernest Major wrote:
How do you address the tension between the claim that the universe
is fine-tuned for life, and that claim that natural causes cannot
account for the existence of life.
Fine-tuning is necessary but not sufficient.
A universe such as this which can sustain life as we know it is
necessary (and necessarily fined-tuned), but that, in and of itself,
is insufficient to assemble inanimate matter into life - that
requires a non-material intelligent agent.
I thought that this might be your response - that a universe that is
fine-tuned to support life is not necessarily fine-tuned to produce
life. But that leaves a question unanswered - why did the putative
designer produce a universe putatively incapable of spontaneously
creating life.
Let's follow the logic here. Using Meyer's premises for the moment, i.e.
the key characteristic of life is large amounts of information, and a non-material intelligence is the best, most causally adequate,
explanation for it--what then would "a universe that is fine-tuned to support life" entail?
It would entail front-loading of that information (a form of deism).
That's one model.
Interestingly, ID rejects this and proposes intelligent intervention in
time to create life; Biologos also rejects this, but for a different
reason, namely the belief that natural processes are sufficient to
generate the information for life.
Now, your point is, if we require fine-tuning of the universe to support life, why not allow additional fine-tuning to front-load the information
for life? Interesting question.
I'd add these follow-on questions: (i) is there any logical/physical prohibition on life information front-loading? and (ii) could we
distinguish between life information front-loading and ID's intelligent intervention to inset life information?
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have >>>> been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>> produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts "material"
with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and exhaust all
possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More
reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes the
best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while essentially
maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large amounts
of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Well John?
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
The structure of the argument seems to be that only X has been observed
to produce A, and therefore Y, not Z, is the best explanation for B.
On 10/11/2026 4:17 AM, Ernest Major wrote:
Well John?
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
The structure of the argument seems to be that only X has been
observed to produce A, and therefore Y, not Z, is the best explanation
for B.
I could have danced all night
I could have danced all night and still have begged for more
I could have spread my wings and done a thousand things
I've never done before
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have >>>> been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>> produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts "material"
with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and exhaust all
possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More
reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes the
best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while essentially
maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large amounts
of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
On 9/10/2026 9:18 am, MarkE wrote:
On 9/10/2026 12:28 am, Ernest Major wrote:
How do you address the tension between the claim that the universe
is fine-tuned for life, and that claim that natural causes cannot
account for the existence of life.
Fine-tuning is necessary but not sufficient.
A universe such as this which can sustain life as we know it is
necessary (and necessarily fined-tuned), but that, in and of itself,
is insufficient to assemble inanimate matter into life - that
requires a non-material intelligent agent.
I thought that this might be your response - that a universe that is
fine-tuned to support life is not necessarily fine-tuned to produce
life. But that leaves a question unanswered - why did the putative
designer produce a universe putatively incapable of spontaneously
creating life.
Let's follow the logic here. Using Meyer's premises for the moment,
i.e. the key characteristic of life is large amounts of information,
and a non-material intelligence is the best, most causally adequate,
explanation for it--what then would "a universe that is fine-tuned to
support life" entail?
It would entail front-loading of that information (a form of deism).
That's one model.
Interestingly, ID rejects this and proposes intelligent intervention
in time to create life; Biologos also rejects this, but for a
different reason, namely the belief that natural processes are
sufficient to generate the information for life.
Now, your point is, if we require fine-tuning of the universe to
support life, why not allow additional fine-tuning to front-load the
information for life? Interesting question.
I'd add these follow-on questions: (i) is there any logical/physical
prohibition on life information front-loading? and (ii) could we
distinguish between life information front-loading and ID's
intelligent intervention to inset life information?
Well, EM?
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have >>>>> been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>>> produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts "material"
with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and exhaust all
possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More
reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes the
best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>>>> produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and
exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More >>>>> reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes
the best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this instance,
the importation of God is performed by adding the word "immaterial" to
the conclusion, when premise two is talking about human beings.
On 13/10/2026 11:20 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power >>>>>>> to produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most >>>>>>> causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and
exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to.
More reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have >>>>>> demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes
the best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the >>>>>> specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-
living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best,
most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified >>>>> information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this
instance, the importation of God is performed by adding the word
"immaterial" to the conclusion, when premise two is talking about
human beings.
No, the logic is this:
If only material causes in non-living matter are available:
-a no production of large amounts of specified information is possible
else if an intelligent material cause in living matter is available
-a (humans):
-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a but not life itself
else if a non-material intelligent cause is available (God):
-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a including life
That is, if large amounts of specified information require intelligence,
and if life requires large amounts of specified information, then the
only source of life is a non-material intelligent cause (aka God).
You may disagree with either/both of the "ifs", but the logic stands regardless. That being the case, it shows there is no "sneaky attempt to import God".
On 10/12/26 6:23 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/10/2026 11:20 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power >>>>>>>> to produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most >>>>>>>> causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified >>>>>>>> information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and >>>>>>> exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to >>>>>>> import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to.
More reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings
have demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified >>>>>>> information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes >>>>>>> the best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of
the specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non- >>>>>> living matter have been discovered with power to produce large
amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best, >>>>>> most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this
instance, the importation of God is performed by adding the word
"immaterial" to the conclusion, when premise two is talking about
human beings.
No, the logic is this:
Not very good logic, you know.
If only material causes in non-living matter are available:
-a-a no production of large amounts of specified information is possible
Not shown, only asserted.
else if an intelligent material cause in living matter is available
-a-a (humans):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a but not life itself
Why not? Again, not shown, only asserted.
else if a non-material intelligent cause is available (God):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a including life
Sure, because God is by definition omnipotent and non-material and intelligent. But of course there could be other, unknown causes not equivalent to God, so defined. You have not shown that a cause of life
must be either non-material (whatever that means), or omnipotent, or intelligent, much less all three. And of course there's the problem of explaining God, assuming God is alive.
That is, if large amounts of specified information require
intelligence, and if life requires large amounts of specified
information, then the only source of life is a non-material
intelligent cause (aka God).
None of your ifs have been shown to be true or to lead to your conclusion.
You may disagree with either/both of the "ifs", but the logic stands
regardless. That being the case, it shows there is no "sneaky attempt
to import God".
The logic, unfortunately, never bothered to happen. Sorry.
On 13/10/2026 1:45 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 6:23 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/10/2026 11:20 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power >>>>>>>>> to produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most >>>>>>>>> causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified >>>>>>>>> information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and >>>>>>>> exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to >>>>>>>> import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. >>>>>>>> More reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings >>>>>>>> have demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of
specified information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design >>>>>>>> constitutes the best, most causally adequate explanation for the >>>>>>>> origin of the specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in
non- living matter have been discovered with power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the
best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the >>>>>>> specified information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this
instance, the importation of God is performed by adding the word
"immaterial" to the conclusion, when premise two is talking about
human beings.
No, the logic is this:
Not very good logic, you know.
If only material causes in non-living matter are available:
-a-a no production of large amounts of specified information is possible
Not shown, only asserted.
else if an intelligent material cause in living matter is available
-a-a (humans):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a but not life itself
Why not? Again, not shown, only asserted.
else if a non-material intelligent cause is available (God):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a including life
Sure, because God is by definition omnipotent and non-material and
intelligent. But of course there could be other, unknown causes not
equivalent to God, so defined. You have not shown that a cause of life
must be either non-material (whatever that means), or omnipotent, or
intelligent, much less all three. And of course there's the problem of
explaining God, assuming God is alive.
That is, if large amounts of specified information require
intelligence, and if life requires large amounts of specified
information, then the only source of life is a non-material
intelligent cause (aka God).
None of your ifs have been shown to be true or to lead to your
conclusion.
You may disagree with either/both of the "ifs", but the logic stands
regardless. That being the case, it shows there is no "sneaky attempt
to import God".
The logic, unfortunately, never bothered to happen. Sorry.
Your usual disingenuous merry-go-round.
On 13/10/2026 05:13, MarkE wrote:
On 13/10/2026 1:45 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 6:23 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/10/2026 11:20 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the >>>>>>>>>> power to produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation. >>>>>>>>>>
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most >>>>>>>>>> causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified >>>>>>>>>> information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and >>>>>>>>> exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt >>>>>>>>> to import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed >>>>>>>>> to. More reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human
beings have demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of >>>>>>>>> specified information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design >>>>>>>>> constitutes the best, most causally adequate explanation for >>>>>>>>> the origin of the specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in >>>>>>>> non- living matter have been discovered with power to produce >>>>>>>> large amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>>>>>> produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the
best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the >>>>>>>> specified information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this
instance, the importation of God is performed by adding the word
"immaterial" to the conclusion, when premise two is talking about
human beings.
No, the logic is this:
Not very good logic, you know.
If only material causes in non-living matter are available:Not shown, only asserted.
-a-a no production of large amounts of specified information is possible >>>
else if an intelligent material cause in living matter is available
-a-a (humans):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible, >>>> -a-a but not life itself
Why not? Again, not shown, only asserted.
else if a non-material intelligent cause is available (God):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible, >>>> -a-a including life
Sure, because God is by definition omnipotent and non-material and
intelligent. But of course there could be other, unknown causes not
equivalent to God, so defined. You have not shown that a cause of
life must be either non-material (whatever that means), or
omnipotent, or intelligent, much less all three. And of course
there's the problem of explaining God, assuming God is alive.
That is, if large amounts of specified information require
intelligence, and if life requires large amounts of specified
information, then the only source of life is a non-material
intelligent cause (aka God).
None of your ifs have been shown to be true or to lead to your
conclusion.
You may disagree with either/both of the "ifs", but the logic stands
regardless. That being the case, it shows there is no "sneaky
attempt to import God".
The logic, unfortunately, never bothered to happen. Sorry.
Your usual disingenuous merry-go-round.
Adding ad-hominem to the fallacies in play doesn't make your argument
any better.
To be clear, the point here is not the veracity of Premises One and Two (which are separate and obviously critical), but the validity of the argument structure and logic:
<selected quotes>
In this [opposing] view, intelligent design functions not as an
explanation, but as a placeholder for ignorance, one that proponents of intelligent design fill by postulating the activity of a creative intelligence, a 'God of the gaps.'
Argument from Ignorance:
-a-a Premise: Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E
-a-a Conclusion: Therefore, cause B produced or explains E
Arguments of this form commit an obvious logical error. They do not
include a premise providing affirmative support for the preferred conclusion.
In fact, the case for the intelligent design of life doesnrCOt rely on
such logic. Instead, the argument takes the following significantly different form:
-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have been discovered with power to produce large amounts of specified information.
-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified information in the cell.
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
To be clear, the point here is not the veracity of Premises One and
Two (which are separate and obviously critical), but the validity of
the argument structure and logic:
<selected quotes>
In this [opposing] view, intelligent design functions not as an
explanation, but as a placeholder for ignorance, one that proponents
of intelligent design fill by postulating the activity of a creative
intelligence, a 'God of the gaps.'
Argument from Ignorance:
-a-a-a Premise: Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E
-a-a-a Conclusion: Therefore, cause B produced or explains E
Arguments of this form commit an obvious logical error. They do not
include a premise providing affirmative support for the preferred
conclusion.
In fact, the case for the intelligent design of life doesnrCOt rely on
such logic. Instead, the argument takes the following significantly
different form:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have
been discovered with power to produce large amounts of specified
information.
In other words, Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most causally >> adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified information in
the cell.
Also, the premises are false. Specified information is produced by
copying. Life makes copies; therefore life produces specified
information, even without design.
And then there is the plain fact that life looks qualitatively different from what design looks like.
On 10/14/2026 10:14 AM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
To be clear, the point here is not the veracity of Premises One and
Two (which are separate and obviously critical), but the validity of
the argument structure and logic:
<selected quotes>
In this [opposing] view, intelligent design functions not as an
explanation, but as a placeholder for ignorance, one that proponents
of intelligent design fill by postulating the activity of a creative
intelligence, a 'God of the gaps.'
Argument from Ignorance:
aaa Premise: Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E
aaa Conclusion: Therefore, cause B produced or explains E
Arguments of this form commit an obvious logical error. They do not
include a premise providing affirmative support for the preferred
conclusion.
In fact, the case for the intelligent design of life doesnAt rely on
such logic. Instead, the argument takes the following significantly
different form:
aaa Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have
been discovered with power to produce large amounts of specified
information.
In other words, Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E.
aaa Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
aaa Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most causally
adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified information in
the cell.
Also, the premises are false. Specified information is produced by
copying. Life makes copies; therefore life produces specified
information, even without design.
And then there is the plain fact that life looks qualitatively different
from what design looks like.
I think this should give MarkE about all he needs to know in this >discussion. Neither of the two premises, no matter how you reword them
to satisfy, will ever be acknowledged by an evolutionist. Neither
premise is even close to being false. Can a single honest example be
shown of a material cause of specified information? Never! How can you >argue against the statement that Intelligent agents have been shown to
be able to produce specified information? Yet they seem to be doing
that. Here, Isaak makes the ridiculous argument that copying produces >specified information! This completely ignores the fact the information >being copied still demands an explanation of origin,
and the fact that
the copying itself could not have been done without requiring
pre-existing specified information to build the machinery needed to copy
the DNA in the first place.
You could argue all day about whether or not mutations and copying
errors should be considered as producing anything. All this does is >completely ignore the real issue about needing intelligence in the
equation to get the ball moving with the necessary information to build.
Isaak of course knows this, but that's all he has. There is simply no
other viable argument, so he resorts to moving the goal posts.
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to get
life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad design
argument. Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are easily
answered. But when you get down to the cell level, there is simply no >mistaking the perfection
and engineering like design involved. From the
living machines in the cell, to the code like and extremely complex >specified information of DNA, it certainly looks like something that was >designed. So when he says: "there is the plain fact that life looks >qualitatively different from what design looks like" the best answer is
So What.
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
"Recent developments (2020-2024) have:
1. Increased our understanding of the complexity involved
2. Revealed new layers of integrated systems
3. Highlighted the need for multiple, synchronized processes
4. Demonstrated the inadequacy of simple, linear explanations
5. Shown the requirement for precise, coordinated mechanisms"
"While new techniques provide deeper insights into prebiotic chemistry,
they also reveal additional layers of complexity that must be explained
in any naturalistic origin scenario."
1. *Introduction: The Origin of Life - A Journey into Complexity*
1.1. What is Life? Understanding the Origin Challenge
1.2. The Journey from Non-Life to Life: A Scientific Perspective from
Half a Century Ago
On 13/10/2026 1:45 pm, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 6:23 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 13/10/2026 11:20 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/12/26 1:47 PM, MarkE wrote:
On 10/10/2026 10:58 am, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:50 pm, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:Well John?
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes >>>>>>>>> have been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power >>>>>>>>> to produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most >>>>>>>>> causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified >>>>>>>>> information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts
"material" with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and >>>>>>>> exhaust all possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to >>>>>>>> import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. >>>>>>>> More reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings >>>>>>>> have demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of
specified information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design >>>>>>>> constitutes the best, most causally adequate explanation for the >>>>>>>> origin of the specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while
essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in
non- living matter have been discovered with power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the
best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the >>>>>>> specified information in the cell.
Thoughts, John?
The identical criticism applies. Nothing has changed. In this
instance, the importation of God is performed by adding the word
"immaterial" to the conclusion, when premise two is talking about
human beings.
No, the logic is this:
Not very good logic, you know.
If only material causes in non-living matter are available:
-a-a no production of large amounts of specified information is possible
Not shown, only asserted.
else if an intelligent material cause in living matter is available
-a-a (humans):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a but not life itself
Why not? Again, not shown, only asserted.
else if a non-material intelligent cause is available (God):
-a-a production of large amounts of specified information is possible,
-a-a including life
Sure, because God is by definition omnipotent and non-material and
intelligent. But of course there could be other, unknown causes not
equivalent to God, so defined. You have not shown that a cause of life
must be either non-material (whatever that means), or omnipotent, or
intelligent, much less all three. And of course there's the problem of
explaining God, assuming God is alive.
That is, if large amounts of specified information require
intelligence, and if life requires large amounts of specified
information, then the only source of life is a non-material
intelligent cause (aka God).
None of your ifs have been shown to be true or to lead to your
conclusion.
You may disagree with either/both of the "ifs", but the logic stands
regardless. That being the case, it shows there is no "sneaky attempt
to import God".
The logic, unfortunately, never bothered to happen. Sorry.
Your usual disingenuous merry-go-round.
On 8/10/2026 6:58 am, John Harshman wrote:
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have
been
discovered-awith-apower-ato-aproduce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce-alarge-aamounts-aof-aspecified-ainformation.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Several problems with that syllogism. First, it contrasts "material"
with "intelligent" as if those are both separate and exhaust all
possibilities.
Second, and more importantly, premise two is a sneaky attempt to
import God by blurring the nature of the evidence appealed to. More
reasonably, it should be stated like this: "Human beings have
demonstrated the power to produce large amounts of specified
information". And thus the conclusion: "Human design constitutes the
best, most causally adequate explanation for the origin of the
specified information in the cell."
I propose this modification to address your concerns while essentially maintaining the original meaning:
Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes in non-living matter have been discovered with power to produce large amounts of
specified information.
Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Conclusion: A non-material intelligent cause constitutes the best, most causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Of course you won't accept that, but it shows that premise two is
faulty and invalidates the argument.
And Biologos apparently didn't talk to any cosmologists before talking
about fine-tuning.
On 10/8/26 3:59 AM, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
Really? Do you accept that the _CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics_ contains large amounts of specified information? Do you accept that the
_CRC Handbook_ (at least in many editions) was printed on a press, i.e.,
was created by a material cause? (And don't give some excuse about a supernatural human mind being needed to write it. Even if true, that
applies only to the proof copy. All the subsequent copies that came off
the press have information specified by the proof copy, and require no
more human intervention than that the human refrains from turning off
the press.)
So yes, material causes have demonstrated the power to produce large
amounts of specified information. I have seen it happen myself.
On 10/14/2026 10:14 AM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
To be clear, the point here is not the veracity of Premises One and
Two (which are separate and obviously critical), but the validity of
the argument structure and logic:
<selected quotes>
In this [opposing] view, intelligent design functions not as an
explanation, but as a placeholder for ignorance, one that proponents
of intelligent design fill by postulating the activity of a creative
intelligence, a 'God of the gaps.'
Argument from Ignorance:
-a-a-a Premise: Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E
-a-a-a Conclusion: Therefore, cause B produced or explains E
Arguments of this form commit an obvious logical error. They do not
include a premise providing affirmative support for the preferred
conclusion.
In fact, the case for the intelligent design of life doesnrCOt rely on
such logic. Instead, the argument takes the following significantly
different form:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have
been discovered with power to produce large amounts of specified
information.
In other words, Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to
produce large amounts of specified information.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Also, the premises are false. Specified information is produced by
copying. Life makes copies; therefore life produces specified
information, even without design.
And then there is the plain fact that life looks qualitatively
different from what design looks like.
I think this should give MarkE about all he needs to know in this discussion.-a Neither of the two premises, no matter how you reword them
to satisfy, will ever be acknowledged by an evolutionist.-a Neither
premise is even close to being false.-a Can a single honest example be
shown of a material cause of specified information?-a Never!
-a How can you
argue against the statement that Intelligent agents have been shown to
be able to produce specified information?
-a Here, Isaak makes the ridiculous argument that copying produces
specified information!
This completely ignores the fact the information
being copied still demands an explanation of origin, and the fact that
the copying itself could not have been done without requiring pre-
existing specified information to build the machinery needed to copy the
DNA in the first place.
You could argue all day about whether or not mutations and copying
errors should be considered as producing anything.-a All this does is completely ignore the real issue about needing intelligence in the
equation to get the ball moving with the necessary information to build.
-aIsaak of course knows this, but that's all he has.-a There is simply no other viable argument, so he resorts to moving the goal posts.
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to get
life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad design argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are easily answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design involved.-a From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks like something that was designed.
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
On 10/14/2026 10:14 AM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/6/26 10:28 PM, MarkE wrote:
To be clear, the point here is not the veracity of Premises One and
Two (which are separate and obviously critical), but the validity of
the argument structure and logic:
<selected quotes>
In this [opposing] view, intelligent design functions not as an
explanation, but as a placeholder for ignorance, one that proponents
of intelligent design fill by postulating the activity of a creative
intelligence, a 'God of the gaps.'
Argument from Ignorance:
-a-a-a Premise: Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E
-a-a-a Conclusion: Therefore, cause B produced or explains E
Arguments of this form commit an obvious logical error. They do not
include a premise providing affirmative support for the preferred
conclusion.
In fact, the case for the intelligent design of life doesnrCOt rely on >>>> such logic. Instead, the argument takes the following significantly
different form:
-a-a-a Premise One: Despite a thorough search, no material causes have >>>> been discovered with power to produce large amounts of specified
information.
In other words, Cause A cannot produce or explain evidence E.
-a-a-a Premise Two: Intelligent causes have demonstrated the power to >>>> produce large amounts of specified information.
-a-a-a Conclusion: Intelligent design constitutes the best, most
causally adequate, explanation for the origin of the specified
information in the cell.
Also, the premises are false. Specified information is produced by
copying. Life makes copies; therefore life produces specified
information, even without design.
And then there is the plain fact that life looks qualitatively
different from what design looks like.
I think this should give MarkE about all he needs to know in this
discussion.-a Neither of the two premises, no matter how you reword
them to satisfy, will ever be acknowledged by an evolutionist.
Neither premise is even close to being false.-a Can a single honest
example be shown of a material cause of specified information?-a Never!
Actually, always. Watch the sky long enough, and you'll see cirrus
clouds form. QED, again.
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of *anything*?-a Anything at all?-a Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence.
-a How can you argue against the statement that Intelligent agents have
been shown to be able to produce specified information?
I don't. What agent A does is irrelevant to what agent B can or cannot do.
-a Here, Isaak makes the ridiculous argument that copying produces
specified information!
Well, of course. It follows directly from the definition of specified information. It's all in Dembski's book.
This completely ignores the fact the information being copied still
demands an explanation of origin, and the fact that the copying itself
could not have been done without requiring pre- existing specified
information to build the machinery needed to copy the DNA in the first
place.
Which completely ignores the original claim.
You could argue all day about whether or not mutations and copying
errors should be considered as producing anything.-a All this does is
completely ignore the real issue about needing intelligence in the
equation to get the ball moving with the necessary information to
build. -a-aIsaak of course knows this, but that's all he has.-a There is
simply no other viable argument, so he resorts to moving the goal posts.
Says someone who says "So What" to the fact that we have solid evidence
that life is *not* designed.-a Obviously, evidence is irrelevant to you.
But yes, we know pretty convincingly that conditions immediately after
the Big Bang produced what you call information and "got the ball
rolling". You might claim that intelligence was behind the Big Bang, and neither you nor I have any evidence to refute or confirm such a claim.
But the building started long before life appeared, and information has
been getting more and more informationy for about 14 billion years.
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to
get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad design
argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are easily
answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is simply no
mistaking the perfection and engineering like design involved.-a From
the living machines in the cell, to the code like and extremely
complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks like
something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If you
had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have learned
is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product less
expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get all
three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of life;
the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to
it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the rest.
But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which needs to have
the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to acquire raw materials
and process them itself into the energy to run the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else. You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't work
the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks evolved,
but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear that life is
not the product of design as we understand the term.
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to
get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad design
argument.a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are easily
answered.a But when you get down to the cell level, there is simply no
mistaking the perfection and engineering like design involved.a From
the living machines in the cell, to the code like and extremely
complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks like
something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If you
had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have learned
is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product less
expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get all
three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of life;
the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things makes it
worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same
fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to
it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the rest.
But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in factories
instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which needs to have
the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to acquire raw materials
and process them itself into the energy to run the watch and to produce
other watches. And I doubt anyone would want such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple as
possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else. You can
change your car's tires without needing to worry about transplant
rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by
Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't work
the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one single
precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks evolved,
but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear that life is
not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing. Isaak attempts to place the creationist Linnaeus
in the equation as a supporter of common descent. He naturally fails to >mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100 years later.
Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel that employs the >usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting focus to something
else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >evidence.
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak ><specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >original position.
There have been numerous "natural"explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak <specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*?-a Anything at all?-a Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny.-a There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the-a hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some mother-goddess?
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*?-a Anything at all?-a Lots of claims, not a single bit of
solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite
different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny.-a There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the-a hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to
believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some
mother-goddess?
'really want to believe'.
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak <specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]I read about this in the book by Michel-Yves Bollor|- and Olivier
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:17:11 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak >><specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>original position.
There have been numerous "natural"explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
What time would they have expected it?
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait"
until all other explanations are disproven?
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that
conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior
of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points
out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this
because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if
the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics
a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford
wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to
Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle
of the Sun-or any other miracles at F|itima or elsewhere-are lying or >hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to,
though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding
claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not
clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been
raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >believe?
I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >mother-goddess?
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of
solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite
different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to
believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some
mother-goddess?
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was >promised.
Many saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that
people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that
the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All
in all, it was a silly miracle.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite
different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>> that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to
believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some
mother-goddess?
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw
nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was
promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said
a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
Many saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun
left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that
people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that
the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All
in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 08:24:31 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite
different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to
believe?
Including those journalists who had viciously attacked the previous apparitions and were there that day with the express purpose of
showing the whole thing to be a load of nonsense?
I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some
mother-goddess?
I'm not making any claim other than showing Mark Isaak was wrong when
he said, "Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence."
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.
On 10/31/26 9:50 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>> *anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>> thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >>>>> different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a womanFaulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >>>>> believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>> that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>> cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>> around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >>>>> mother-goddess?
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >>> nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was
promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said
a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
According to Wikipedia, "The prophecy was that the Virgin Mary (referred
to as Our Lady of F|itima) would appear and perform miracles on that
date." Is that untrue?
Sure. It's only silly to those with any understanding of the solarMany saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >>> left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that
people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that
the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All
in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
system. The sun is not going to suddenly dart out, warm up a small spot
in Portugal, and return to its spot without anyone else noticing, and in >fact without causing system-wide disaster.
On 10/31/26 9:46 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 08:24:31 -0700, John HarshmanI suppose it all depends on how you define "solid evidence".
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite
different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to
believe?
Including those journalists who had viciously attacked the previous
apparitions and were there that day with the express purpose of
showing the whole thing to be a load of nonsense?
I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some
mother-goddess?
I'm not making any claim other than showing Mark Isaak was wrong when
he said, "Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence."
On 10/31/26 9:50 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>> *anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>> thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >>>>> different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a womanFaulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >>>>> believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>> that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>> cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>> around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>
non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >>>>> mother-goddess?
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >>> nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was
promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said
a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
According to Wikipedia, "The prophecy was that the Virgin Mary (referred
to as Our Lady of F|itima) would appear and perform miracles on that
date." Is that untrue?
Sure. It's only silly to those with any understanding of the solarMany saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >>> left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that
people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that
the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All
in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
system. The sun is not going to suddenly dart out, warm up a small spot
in Portugal, and return to its spot without anyone else noticing, and in >fact without causing system-wide disaster.
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
On 10/30/2026 5:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark IsaakI read about this in the book by Michel-Yves Bollor|- and Olivier >Bonnassies, "God - The Science, The Proof: The Dawn of a Revolution" and >found it to be quite an amazing event. They did a very long chapter on
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example.
it. Not like most of the miracles you hear about. So many reasons this
one is hard to claim a fake on. They certainly have tried, but it still >stands as an unexplainable phenomena witnessed by thousands of people.
Don't forget one of the big things was the fact it had been raining
heavily and the area was a rural, mountainous area of Portugal that was
very poor. The area turned to muck because over 70,000 people were
there. Yet, once the sun stopped moving their clothes and the muddy
ground were completely dry.
To those on here who will quickly dismiss Martin's example, just beware
even the biggest skeptical historians and scientists agree something >profound and collective happened to those 70,000 people who journeyed
there to witness the event that was predicted by these young girls for 6 >months after witnessing the virgin Mary on the 13th day of each month. >Little girls don't just make up shit like this.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:15:04 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 9:50 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>>> *anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>>> thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >>>>>> different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to
presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>>>>> surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would >>>>>>> reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>>> that all may believe."Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >>>>>> believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any >>>>>> non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >>>>>> mother-goddess?
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which >>>>>>> really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>>> cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>>> around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>>>>> experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>>
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >>>> nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was
promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said
a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
According to Wikipedia, "The prophecy was that the Virgin Mary (referred
to as Our Lady of F|itima) would appear and perform miracles on that
date." Is that untrue?
Sure. It's only silly to those with any understanding of the solarMany saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >>>> left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that
people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that >>>> the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All >>>> in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
system. The sun is not going to suddenly dart out, warm up a small spot
in Portugal, and return to its spot without anyone else noticing, and in
fact without causing system-wide disaster.
That people in Fatima experienced something that the rest of the world
didn't experience is what makes it supernatural. Perhaps that idea is
beyond your intellectual comprehension skills.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the
ToE.
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:01:14 -0400, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:17:11 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak >>><specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>>evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>original position.
There have been numerous "natural"explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
What time would they have expected it?
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone
who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have
you got a different understanding of it?
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait"
until all other explanations are disproven?
I wouldn't use the word "disproven"; it's a case of no natural
explanations on offer that stand up to even the gentlest scrutiny.
BTW, the principle of all natural explanations having to be ruled out
first is the way the Catholic Church goes about assessing all
potential miracles. Every possible natural explanation has to be
thoroughly examined and the Church makes extensive use of non-Catholic >scientists and doctors to do that examination.
Even when natural
explanations have all been ruled out, the Church only declares that
the event in question can be *considered* a miracle by Catholics but
that is not compulsory, it is entirely up to individuals whether or
not they treat it as a miracle.
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that >>conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior
of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points
out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this
because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if
the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics
a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford
wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >>pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to
Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle
of the Sun-or any other miracles at Fbtima or elsewhere-are lying or >>hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to,
though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding >>claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not
clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >>photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been >>raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
Can you show me where he deals with the shortcomings I highlighted in
my original post regarding a hoax and hallucination? How did the
hoaxers create the spectacular solar show? Why did people hallucinate
it at solar noon instead of the noon local time that they expected it?
How come the journalists who were vehemently opposed to the
apparitions also underwent this hallucination?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 16:42:37 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:01:14 -0400, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:17:11 +0000, Martin Harran >>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak >>>><specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>>>evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>>surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>original position.
There have been numerous "natural"explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>>experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>it at a different time from what they expected?
What time would they have expected it?
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone
who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have
you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the
same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >difference.
Let's say that 95% of the population at large believes that they're
the same thing. That means that 3500 people out of 70,000 would know
the difference, which leads to the question of why they didn't tell
anyone.
Also, this website
https://dqydj.com/solar-noon-calculator/
lists solar noon as being different from 1:20 p.m. on October 13,
1917 in Fatima, Portugal (that is, it says 11:31 a.m.). How do you
account for the difference?
Furthermore, what were the believers doing between 12:00 p.m. and 1:20
p.m.? Just keeping their hopes up by bootstrap force?
Furthermore, why would God choose such an obscure method of
demonstrating his supposedly great power?
And finally, is the Fatima "miracle" something that helps prop up your >beliefs, or are you secure enough in them that you don't care what
happened at Fatima that day?
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait"
until all other explanations are disproven?
I wouldn't use the word "disproven"; it's a case of no natural
explanations on offer that stand up to even the gentlest scrutiny.
So why don't you say, "We don't know what happened" rather than "a
miracle happened"?
It doesn't seem very scientific to determine how
something happened just by referring to your own personal preference.
BTW, the principle of all natural explanations having to be ruled out
first is the way the Catholic Church goes about assessing all
potential miracles. Every possible natural explanation has to be
thoroughly examined and the Church makes extensive use of non-Catholic >>scientists and doctors to do that examination.
Again, what's the point of that? Why couldn't it be determined that a >miracle happened without going to all that trouble?
For example, if
someone claimed they had seen the Jolly Green Giant towering over his
back yard lawn, would he then have to sit down and rule out all the
other explanations for the appearance, or could he just say "Look,
it's the Green Giant out back, and damn near ripping up the sod to
boot!"
Even when natural
explanations have all been ruled out, the Church only declares that
the event in question can be *considered* a miracle by Catholics but
that is not compulsory, it is entirely up to individuals whether or
not they treat it as a miracle.
See above.
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that >>>conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior
of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points
out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this
because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if
the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics
a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford
wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >>>pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to
Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle
of the Sun-or any other miracles at F|itima or elsewhere-are lying or >>>hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to, >>>though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding >>>claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not >>>clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >>>photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been >>>raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
Can you show me where he deals with the shortcomings I highlighted in
my original post regarding a hoax and hallucination? How did the
hoaxers create the spectacular solar show? Why did people hallucinate
it at solar noon instead of the noon local time that they expected it?
How come the journalists who were vehemently opposed to the
apparitions also underwent this hallucination?
If you read the quote closely, it's saying that something did happen,
but it was all inside their head. Not a hallucination, but something >addressed by the power of the human mind to deal with its own
suggestibility.
Here's more from the same Wiki site:
"In reference to the accounts of the Miracle of the Sun phenomena,
McClure writes that "the accounts of the miracle, of the dance of the
sun', are simply not consistent". McClure remarks that perception and
memory becoming uncertain during an incomprehensible event is not
surprising, but that the contradictions in the accounts must raise
some doubts towards the objective nature of what was seen.[59] While
McClure is often misquoted in purportedly stating that he had never
seen such a collection of contradictory accounts of a case in any of
the research that he had done in the previous ten years, he was
specifically referring to accounts of the alleged Marian apparitions
that the three children witnessed, not the accounts of the Miracle of
the Sun phenomena itself, when making such a claim.[60]"
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the
ToE.
was that unclear?
On 10/31/26 11:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:15:04 -0700, John HarshmanSure, they experienced something. But if we think that experience was >objectively true, why didn't the rest of the world experience it? Are
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 9:50 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>>>> *anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>>>> thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >>>>>>> different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to >>>>>>> presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>>>>>> surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would >>>>>>>> reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>>>> that all may believe."Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >>>>>>> believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any >>>>>>> non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >>>>>>> mother-goddess?
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>>>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>>>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>>>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which >>>>>>>> really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>>>> cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>>>> around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>>>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>>>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small >>>>>>>> cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>>>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>>>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>>>>>> experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>>>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>>>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>>>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>>>
'really want to believe'.
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >>>>> nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was
promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said >>>> a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
According to Wikipedia, "The prophecy was that the Virgin Mary (referred >>> to as Our Lady of F|itima) would appear and perform miracles on that
date." Is that untrue?
Sure. It's only silly to those with any understanding of the solarMany saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >>>>> left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that >>>>> people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you
think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that >>>>> the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All >>>>> in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
system. The sun is not going to suddenly dart out, warm up a small spot
in Portugal, and return to its spot without anyone else noticing, and in >>> fact without causing system-wide disaster.
That people in Fatima experienced something that the rest of the world
didn't experience is what makes it supernatural. Perhaps that idea is
beyond your intellectual comprehension skills.
you claiming that it was a local illusion?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:46:33 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:24 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:15:04 -0700, John HarshmanSure, they experienced something. But if we think that experience was
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 9:50 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 18:10:26 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 9:16 AM, Blaine wrote:
John Harshman wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:As he mentioned, there were reporters and others there who didn't >>>>>>> 'really want to believe'.
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>>>>> *anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of >>>>>>>>>> solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>>>>> thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
I hope you would agree that "no material explanation found" is quite >>>>>>>> different from "a non-material cause". To suppose otherwise is to >>>>>>>> presume a false dichotomy, i.e. "God of the gaps".
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>>>>> background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>>>>> children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>>>>>>> surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>>>>> In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would >>>>>>>>> reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>>>>> that all may believe."Faulty data based on anecdotal reports by people who really wanted to >>>>>>>> believe? I will point out that you have not explicitly proposed any >>>>>>>> non-material cause. Are you claiming this is a miracle caused by some >>>>>>>> mother-goddess?
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>>>>> at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which >>>>>>>>> really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>>>>> or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to >>>>>>>>> scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>>>>> cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>>>>> around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>>>>> event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>>>>> how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small >>>>>>>>> cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>>>>> addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>>>>> what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>>>>>>> experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>>>>> who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>>>>> of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>>>>> particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>>>>> hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>>>>> people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>>>>> it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>>>>
I will note that different observers saw different things, that many saw >>>>>> nothing, and that only a very few saw the virgin, which is what was >>>>>> promised.
No, that wasn't promised. The children only claimed that the lady said >>>>> a miracle would take place, no description was given of what the
miracle would be.
According to Wikipedia, "The prophecy was that the Virgin Mary (referred >>>> to as Our Lady of F|itima) would appear and perform miracles on that
date." Is that untrue?
Sure. It's only silly to those with any understanding of the solarMany saw the sun whirling around; but how would you do that,
since the sun is featureless to the unaided eye? Some claim that the sun >>>>>> left its usual position and approached the earth closely enough that >>>>>> people felt the heat and everything wet was dried instantly; do you >>>>>> think that nobody elsewhere in the world would have noticed it or that >>>>>> the sudden change in the sun's gravity wouldn't have major effects? All >>>>>> in all, it was a silly miracle.
Not particularly silly to the people who experienced it.
system. The sun is not going to suddenly dart out, warm up a small spot >>>> in Portugal, and return to its spot without anyone else noticing, and in >>>> fact without causing system-wide disaster.
That people in Fatima experienced something that the rest of the world
didn't experience is what makes it supernatural. Perhaps that idea is
beyond your intellectual comprehension skills.
objectively true, why didn't the rest of the world experience it? Are
you claiming that it was a local illusion?
I'm simply identifying it as something for which no natural
explanation stands up to scrutiny. The fact that the rest of the world
didn't experience it simply emphasises that.
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the
ToE.
was that unclear?
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the
Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the
oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The
Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to
even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do
you seriously think that such children would have understood the
concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades,
and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway,
are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this
devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 16:34:00 -0400, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 16:42:37 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:01:14 -0400, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 10:17:11 +0000, Martin Harran >>>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak >>>>><specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of >>>>>>*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>>>>evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been >>>>>thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The >>>>>background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young >>>>>children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman >>>>>surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary. >>>>>In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would >>>>>reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so >>>>>that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered >>>>>at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>>>the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>>>of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>>>original position.
There have been numerous "natural"explanations put forward which >>>>>really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax >>>>>or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to >>>>>scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised >>>>>cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area >>>>>around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>>>Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>>>explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this >>>>>event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to >>>>>how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small >>>>>cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In >>>>>addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>>>at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about >>>>>what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>>>the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who >>>>>experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those >>>>>who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature >>>>>of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>>>on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>>>noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not >>>>>particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>>>that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a >>>>>hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what >>>>>people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine >>>>>it at a different time from what they expected?
What time would they have expected it?
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone
who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have
you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the
same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up
solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time
instead of midday local time?
Let's say that 95% of the population at large believes that they're
the same thing. That means that 3500 people out of 70,000 would know
the difference, which leads to the question of why they didn't tell
anyone.
Pick a figure out of the air and build an argument based on it; not
quite what I would regard as a scientific approach.
Also, this website
https://dqydj.com/solar-noon-calculator/
lists solar noon as being different from 1:20 p.m. on October 13,
1917 in Fatima, Portugal (that is, it says 11:31 a.m.). How do you
account for the difference?
You can't type in the location, it only recognises the names in its
drop-down list; you have to put in the coordinates which are >39.63214963966405, -8.671796763644842 - that gives 1:21 p.m. for 13
Oct 1917
Furthermore, what were the believers doing between 12:00 p.m. and 1:20 >>p.m.? Just keeping their hopes up by bootstrap force?
I don't know but I'd guess that at least some of them were praying.
Do you think 80 mins an excessive time for people to wait for what they
expect to be a major event that might be running late? Does the fact
that it happened 80 mins later than they expected not weaken the case
for hallucination on their part?
Furthermore, why would God choose such an obscure method of
demonstrating his supposedly great power?
I don't know; you'd really have to ask him.
And finally, is the Fatima "miracle" something that helps prop up your >>beliefs, or are you secure enough in them that you don't care what
happened at Fatima that day?
I'm ambivalent about it as I generally am about calimed supernatural
events. It makes no difference whatsoever to my religious beliefs and
your asking that shows how little you understand religious belief.
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait"
until all other explanations are disproven?
I wouldn't use the word "disproven"; it's a case of no natural >>>explanations on offer that stand up to even the gentlest scrutiny.
So why don't you say, "We don't know what happened" rather than "a
miracle happened"?
I didn't claim anything about it being a miracle; as I said above, I'm >ambivalent about the matter. I was simply showing Mark Isaak was wrong
when he said, "Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence."
It doesn't seem very scientific to determine how
something happened just by referring to your own personal preference.
Where am I referring to my own personal preference?
BTW, the principle of all natural explanations having to be ruled out >>>first is the way the Catholic Church goes about assessing all
potential miracles. Every possible natural explanation has to be >>>thoroughly examined and the Church makes extensive use of non-Catholic >>>scientists and doctors to do that examination.
Again, what's the point of that? Why couldn't it be determined that a >>miracle happened without going to all that trouble?
Seems a fairly logical approach to me. I suspect you would have rather
a lot to say if they declared something a miracle without checking out >natural causes.
For example, if
someone claimed they had seen the Jolly Green Giant towering over his
back yard lawn, would he then have to sit down and rule out all the
other explanations for the appearance, or could he just say "Look,
it's the Green Giant out back, and damn near ripping up the sod to
boot!"
Now you're just being your usual disdainful self. It doesn't help your >arguments.
Even when natural
explanations have all been ruled out, the Church only declares that
the event in question can be *considered* a miracle by Catholics but
that is not compulsory, it is entirely up to individuals whether or
not they treat it as a miracle.
See above.
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations >>>>
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that >>>>conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior >>>>of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points >>>>out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this >>>>because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if
the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics >>>>a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford >>>>wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >>>>pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to >>>>Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle
of the Sun-or any other miracles at Fbtima or elsewhere-are lying or >>>>hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to, >>>>though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding >>>>claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not >>>>clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >>>>photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been >>>>raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
Can you show me where he deals with the shortcomings I highlighted in
my original post regarding a hoax and hallucination? How did the
hoaxers create the spectacular solar show? Why did people hallucinate
it at solar noon instead of the noon local time that they expected it? >>>How come the journalists who were vehemently opposed to the
apparitions also underwent this hallucination?
If you read the quote closely, it's saying that something did happen,
but it was all inside their head. Not a hallucination, but something >>addressed by the power of the human mind to deal with its own >>suggestibility.
Here's more from the same Wiki site:
"In reference to the accounts of the Miracle of the Sun phenomena,
McClure writes that "the accounts of the miracle, of the dance of the
sun', are simply not consistent". McClure remarks that perception and >>memory becoming uncertain during an incomprehensible event is not >>surprising, but that the contradictions in the accounts must raise
some doubts towards the objective nature of what was seen.[59] While >>McClure is often misquoted in purportedly stating that he had never
seen such a collection of contradictory accounts of a case in any of
the research that he had done in the previous ten years, he was >>specifically referring to accounts of the alleged Marian apparitions
that the three children witnessed, not the accounts of the Miracle of
the Sun phenomena itself, when making such a claim.[60]"
So you are using McClure's explanation to challenge what happened on
13 Oct even though he explicitly states that his explanation doesn't
apply to what happened on 13 Oct. You might want to go back to the
drawing board with that idea.
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 11:42:57 -0800, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the
ToE.
was that unclear?
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the
Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the
oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The
Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to
even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do
you seriously think that such children would have understood the
concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades,
and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway,
are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this
devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
The Irish are clever enough to understand the difference between
stupidity and lack of education. Apparently you are not that clever,
you think that somebody not understanding something means they are
stupid.
On 11/1/26 1:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 11:42:57 -0800, John HarshmanYou strike me as a quite bitter and generally unpleasant person.
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How >>>>> was that unclear?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others.
That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the >>>>>> ToE.
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the
Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the
oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The
Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to
even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do
you seriously think that such children would have understood the
concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades, >>> and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway,
are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this
devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
The Irish are clever enough to understand the difference between
stupidity and lack of education. Apparently you are not that clever,
you think that somebody not understanding something means they are
stupid.
But
doubtless that's just your internet persona. OK, so they're not stupid,
just very, very ignorant. But let's remember that the bit you claimed
they wouldn't understand was not mentioned until many years later, when >perhaps the ignorant girls had learned a thing or two.
Also, the girls were instructed to pray the rosary for an end to World
War I. Do you know how that worked out? I suppose that the Virgin wasn't
up to that useful a miracle.
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have
you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up
solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time
instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify
what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima
people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Let's say that 95% of the population at large believes that they're
the same thing. That means that 3500 people out of 70,000 would know
the difference, which leads to the question of why they didn't tell >>>anyone.
Pick a figure out of the air and build an argument based on it; not
quite what I would regard as a scientific approach.
It was based on your understanding of what I said, not something "out
of thin air." Are you suggesting that *no one* among the 70,000 knew
what time solar noon would be?
It's almost as if God (or the Virgin
Mary, whoever) was trying to trick them!
Also, this website
https://dqydj.com/solar-noon-calculator/
lists solar noon as being different from 1:20 p.m. on October 13,
1917 in Fatima, Portugal (that is, it says 11:31 a.m.). How do you >>>account for the difference?
You can't type in the location, it only recognises the names in its >>drop-down list; you have to put in the coordinates which are >>39.63214963966405, -8.671796763644842 - that gives 1:21 p.m. for 13
Oct 1917
Okay, that's sensible (although I suspect that the precision in your
numbers is not physically realizable).
Furthermore, what were the believers doing between 12:00 p.m. and 1:20 >>>p.m.? Just keeping their hopes up by bootstrap force?
I don't know but I'd guess that at least some of them were praying.
An 80-minute prayer would presumably more likely degenerate into
skepticism for at least some of them, don't you think?
Do you think 80 mins an excessive time for people to wait for what they >>expect to be a major event that might be running late? Does the fact
that it happened 80 mins later than they expected not weaken the case
for hallucination on their part?
Why would God be late?
Something keeping him, up there? LOL! Or did
God just not take into consideration the confusion that his little
game was causing?
Furthermore, why would God choose such an obscure method of
demonstrating his supposedly great power?
I don't know; you'd really have to ask him.
Why can't you ask him?
And finally, is the Fatima "miracle" something that helps prop up your >>>beliefs, or are you secure enough in them that you don't care what >>>happened at Fatima that day?
I'm ambivalent about it as I generally am about calimed supernatural >>events. It makes no difference whatsoever to my religious beliefs and
your asking that shows how little you understand religious belief.
What *does* make a difference to your religious beliefs?
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait" >>>>>until all other explanations are disproven?
I wouldn't use the word "disproven"; it's a case of no natural >>>>explanations on offer that stand up to even the gentlest scrutiny.
So why don't you say, "We don't know what happened" rather than "a >>>miracle happened"?
I didn't claim anything about it being a miracle; as I said above, I'm >>ambivalent about the matter. I was simply showing Mark Isaak was wrong
when he said, "Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence."
Are you ambivalent enough to lose interest in this supposed evidence
for a miracle?
It doesn't seem very scientific to determine how
something happened just by referring to your own personal preference.
Where am I referring to my own personal preference?
I said that because I thought you had chosen to believe that this was
a miracle. If that's not true about you, that makes two of us,
doesn't it?
BTW, the principle of all natural explanations having to be ruled out >>>>first is the way the Catholic Church goes about assessing all
potential miracles. Every possible natural explanation has to be >>>>thoroughly examined and the Church makes extensive use of non-Catholic >>>>scientists and doctors to do that examination.
Again, what's the point of that? Why couldn't it be determined that a >>>miracle happened without going to all that trouble?
Seems a fairly logical approach to me. I suspect you would have rather
a lot to say if they declared something a miracle without checking out >>natural causes.
No, not at all. My position is below, in what you labeled as
"disdainful."
For example, if
someone claimed they had seen the Jolly Green Giant towering over his >>>back yard lawn, would he then have to sit down and rule out all the
other explanations for the appearance, or could he just say "Look,
it's the Green Giant out back, and damn near ripping up the sod to
boot!"
Now you're just being your usual disdainful self. It doesn't help your >>arguments.
The point is, there are better ways of arriving at truth in science
than "checking out all natural causes."
Even when natural
explanations have all been ruled out, the Church only declares that
the event in question can be *considered* a miracle by Catholics but >>>>that is not compulsory, it is entirely up to individuals whether or
not they treat it as a miracle.
See above.
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations >>>>>
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that >>>>>conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior >>>>>of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points >>>>>out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this >>>>>because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if >>>>>the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics >>>>>a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford >>>>>wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >>>>>pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to >>>>>Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle >>>>>of the Sun-or any other miracles at F|itima or elsewhere-are lying or >>>>>hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to, >>>>>though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding >>>>>claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not >>>>>clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >>>>>photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been >>>>>raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
Can you show me where he deals with the shortcomings I highlighted in >>>>my original post regarding a hoax and hallucination? How did the >>>>hoaxers create the spectacular solar show? Why did people hallucinate >>>>it at solar noon instead of the noon local time that they expected it? >>>>How come the journalists who were vehemently opposed to the
apparitions also underwent this hallucination?
If you read the quote closely, it's saying that something did happen,
but it was all inside their head. Not a hallucination, but something >>>addressed by the power of the human mind to deal with its own >>>suggestibility.
Here's more from the same Wiki site:
"In reference to the accounts of the Miracle of the Sun phenomena, >>>McClure writes that "the accounts of the miracle, of the dance of the >>>sun', are simply not consistent". McClure remarks that perception and >>>memory becoming uncertain during an incomprehensible event is not >>>surprising, but that the contradictions in the accounts must raise
some doubts towards the objective nature of what was seen.[59] While >>>McClure is often misquoted in purportedly stating that he had never
seen such a collection of contradictory accounts of a case in any of
the research that he had done in the previous ten years, he was >>>specifically referring to accounts of the alleged Marian apparitions
that the three children witnessed, not the accounts of the Miracle of
the Sun phenomena itself, when making such a claim.[60]"
So you are using McClure's explanation to challenge what happened on
13 Oct even though he explicitly states that his explanation doesn't
apply to what happened on 13 Oct. You might want to go back to the
drawing board with that idea.
It was the girls' claims that were not contradictory, not the stories
about what happened on October 13. So do you see why he said there
were contradictions in the accounts of what happened on that day?
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:24:44 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have >>>>>you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up >>>solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time
instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify
what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima >>people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Who refused them the courtesy?
Let's say that 95% of the population at large believes that they're
the same thing. That means that 3500 people out of 70,000 would know >>>>the difference, which leads to the question of why they didn't tell >>>>anyone.
Pick a figure out of the air and build an argument based on it; not
quite what I would regard as a scientific approach.
It was based on your understanding of what I said, not something "out
of thin air." Are you suggesting that *no one* among the 70,000 knew
what time solar noon would be?
Knowing about solar noon does not mean taking it into account on every >occasion. I fully understand solar noon, but unlike you, if someone
said they would meet me at noon, I would automatically assume they
mean midday unless they gave me good reason to think it might be
something else. I would seriously doubt if anyone at Fatima expected
the miracle to take place at anything other than midday. I'll throw
your own question back at you, if something like 3500 people thought >beforehand that it might be solar noon, why do you think none of them >mentioned it?
It's almost as if God (or the Virgin
Mary, whoever) was trying to trick them!
Also, this website
https://dqydj.com/solar-noon-calculator/
lists solar noon as being different from 1:20 p.m. on October 13,
1917 in Fatima, Portugal (that is, it says 11:31 a.m.). How do you >>>>account for the difference?
You can't type in the location, it only recognises the names in its >>>drop-down list; you have to put in the coordinates which are >>>39.63214963966405, -8.671796763644842 - that gives 1:21 p.m. for 13
Oct 1917
Okay, that's sensible (although I suspect that the precision in your >>numbers is not physically realizable).
Which numbers do you mean? If you mean the time, it's not *my*
numbers; it's the numbers on the site *you* identified. If you mean
the Fatima coordinates, they come from Google Maps. Either way, why do
you think they are not physically realizable?
Furthermore, what were the believers doing between 12:00 p.m. and 1:20 >>>>p.m.? Just keeping their hopes up by bootstrap force?
I don't know but I'd guess that at least some of them were praying.
An 80-minute prayer would presumably more likely degenerate into
skepticism for at least some of them, don't you think?
Do you think 80 mins an excessive time for people to wait for what they >>>expect to be a major event that might be running late? Does the fact
that it happened 80 mins later than they expected not weaken the case
for hallucination on their part?
Why would God be late?
No reason to regard it as God being late; just the people
misunderstanding the time it was to happen.
Something keeping him, up there? LOL! Or did
God just not take into consideration the confusion that his little
game was causing?
Furthermore, why would God choose such an obscure method of >>>>demonstrating his supposedly great power?
I don't know; you'd really have to ask him.
Why can't you ask him?
I have rather more important things to talk to him about.
And finally, is the Fatima "miracle" something that helps prop up your >>>>beliefs, or are you secure enough in them that you don't care what >>>>happened at Fatima that day?
I'm ambivalent about it as I generally am about calimed supernatural >>>events. It makes no difference whatsoever to my religious beliefs and >>>your asking that shows how little you understand religious belief.
What *does* make a difference to your religious beliefs?
Nothing in particular.
If you are seriously interested (which I doubt)
you can find out more about the nature of my religious beliefs here;
TO even gets a passing reference!
https://www.derrydiocese.org/publications/the-net/the-net-march-2022.pdf#page=21
(Depending on your browser, you might have to scroll to Page 21)
It's not difficult to find out
when local noon is on any given day.
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other? >>>>>>Why would acceptance of a supernatural explanation need to "wait" >>>>>>until all other explanations are disproven?
I wouldn't use the word "disproven"; it's a case of no natural >>>>>explanations on offer that stand up to even the gentlest scrutiny.
So why don't you say, "We don't know what happened" rather than "a >>>>miracle happened"?
I didn't claim anything about it being a miracle; as I said above, I'm >>>ambivalent about the matter. I was simply showing Mark Isaak was wrong >>>when he said, "Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid evidence."
Are you ambivalent enough to lose interest in this supposed evidence
for a miracle?
It doesn't seem very scientific to determine how
something happened just by referring to your own personal preference.
Where am I referring to my own personal preference?
I said that because I thought you had chosen to believe that this was
a miracle. If that's not true about you, that makes two of us,
doesn't it?
I didn't say I don't believe, I said I am ambivalent. Is the
difference too subtle for you?
BTW, the principle of all natural explanations having to be ruled out >>>>>first is the way the Catholic Church goes about assessing all >>>>>potential miracles. Every possible natural explanation has to be >>>>>thoroughly examined and the Church makes extensive use of non-Catholic >>>>>scientists and doctors to do that examination.
Again, what's the point of that? Why couldn't it be determined that a >>>>miracle happened without going to all that trouble?
Seems a fairly logical approach to me. I suspect you would have rather
a lot to say if they declared something a miracle without checking out >>>natural causes.
No, not at all. My position is below, in what you labeled as
"disdainful."
For example, if
someone claimed they had seen the Jolly Green Giant towering over his >>>>back yard lawn, would he then have to sit down and rule out all the >>>>other explanations for the appearance, or could he just say "Look,
it's the Green Giant out back, and damn near ripping up the sod to >>>>boot!"
Now you're just being your usual disdainful self. It doesn't help your >>>arguments.
The point is, there are better ways of arriving at truth in science
than "checking out all natural causes."
Even when natural
explanations have all been ruled out, the Church only declares that >>>>>the event in question can be *considered* a miracle by Catholics but >>>>>that is not compulsory, it is entirely up to individuals whether or >>>>>not they treat it as a miracle.
See above.
But look at this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun#Skeptical_explanations >>>>>>
"Theologians, scientists and skeptics have responded to claims that >>>>>>conflict with established scientific knowledge regarding the behavior >>>>>>of the Sun.[7][8][10][55][56] Science writer Benjamin Radford points >>>>>>out that "The sun did not really dance in the sky. We know this >>>>>>because, of course, everyone on Earth is under the same sun, and if >>>>>>the closest lying star to us suddenly began doing celestial gymnastics >>>>>>a few billion other people would surely have reported it". Radford >>>>>>wrote that psychological factors such as the power of suggestion and >>>>>>pareidolia can better explain the reported events. According to >>>>>>Radford, "No one suggests that those who reported seeing the Miracle >>>>>>of the Sun-or any other miracles at Fbtima or elsewhere-are lying or >>>>>>hoaxing. Instead, they very likely experienced what they claimed to, >>>>>>though that experience took place mostly in their minds."[8] Regarding >>>>>>claims of miraculous drying up of rain water, Radford wrote "it's not >>>>>>clear precisely what the weather was at the time of the miracle", and >>>>>>photography from the time of the event does not show that it had been >>>>>>raining as much or as long as was reported.[55]"
Can you show me where he deals with the shortcomings I highlighted in >>>>>my original post regarding a hoax and hallucination? How did the >>>>>hoaxers create the spectacular solar show? Why did people hallucinate >>>>>it at solar noon instead of the noon local time that they expected it? >>>>>How come the journalists who were vehemently opposed to the >>>>>apparitions also underwent this hallucination?
If you read the quote closely, it's saying that something did happen, >>>>but it was all inside their head. Not a hallucination, but something >>>>addressed by the power of the human mind to deal with its own >>>>suggestibility.
Here's more from the same Wiki site:
"In reference to the accounts of the Miracle of the Sun phenomena, >>>>McClure writes that "the accounts of the miracle, of the dance of the >>>>sun', are simply not consistent". McClure remarks that perception and >>>>memory becoming uncertain during an incomprehensible event is not >>>>surprising, but that the contradictions in the accounts must raise
some doubts towards the objective nature of what was seen.[59] While >>>>McClure is often misquoted in purportedly stating that he had never >>>>seen such a collection of contradictory accounts of a case in any of >>>>the research that he had done in the previous ten years, he was >>>>specifically referring to accounts of the alleged Marian apparitions >>>>that the three children witnessed, not the accounts of the Miracle of >>>>the Sun phenomena itself, when making such a claim.[60]"
So you are using McClure's explanation to challenge what happened on
13 Oct even though he explicitly states that his explanation doesn't >>>apply to what happened on 13 Oct. You might want to go back to the >>>drawing board with that idea.
It was the girls' claims that were not contradictory, not the stories
about what happened on October 13. So do you see why he said there
were contradictions in the accounts of what happened on that day?
Either way, "must raise some doubts"
is not what I would regard as a
particularly conclusive opinion.
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 19:56:06 -0800, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 1:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 11:42:57 -0800, John HarshmanYou strike me as a quite bitter and generally unpleasant person.
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How >>>>>> was that unclear?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the >>>>>>> ToE.
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others. >>>>>>>
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the
Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the
oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The
Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to >>>>> even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do >>>>> you seriously think that such children would have understood the
concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades, >>>> and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway, >>>> are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this
devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
The Irish are clever enough to understand the difference between
stupidity and lack of education. Apparently you are not that clever,
you think that somebody not understanding something means they are
stupid.
So says the guy who disparaged the Irish people as devoted to class prejudice; then, when he realised I was right in what I had said,
instead of withdrawing the disparagement, decided to attack me with a personal insult. I think you would do well to invest in a good mirror.
But
doubtless that's just your internet persona. OK, so they're not stupid,
just very, very ignorant. But let's remember that the bit you claimed
they wouldn't understand was not mentioned until many years later, when
perhaps the ignorant girls had learned a thing or two.
Also, the girls were instructed to pray the rosary for an end to World
War I. Do you know how that worked out? I suppose that the Virgin wasn't
up to that useful a miracle.
On 11/2/26 6:49 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 19:56:06 -0800, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 1:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 11:42:57 -0800, John HarshmanYou strike me as a quite bitter and generally unpleasant person.
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How >>>>>>> was that unclear?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the >>>>>>>> ToE.
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others. >>>>>>>>
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the >>>>>> Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the >>>>>> oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The >>>>>> Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to >>>>>> even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do >>>>>> you seriously think that such children would have understood the
concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of
Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades, >>>>> and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway, >>>>> are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this
devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
The Irish are clever enough to understand the difference between
stupidity and lack of education. Apparently you are not that clever,
you think that somebody not understanding something means they are
stupid.
So says the guy who disparaged the Irish people as devoted to class
prejudice; then, when he realised I was right in what I had said,
instead of withdrawing the disparagement, decided to attack me with a
personal insult. I think you would do well to invest in a good mirror.
I'm willing to believe that this is just your internet persona and that
you aren't like this in person. You continue to ignore the substance of
the discussion; that's another unpleasant feature of your persona.
But
doubtless that's just your internet persona. OK, so they're not stupid,
just very, very ignorant. But let's remember that the bit you claimed
they wouldn't understand was not mentioned until many years later, when
perhaps the ignorant girls had learned a thing or two.
Also, the girls were instructed to pray the rosary for an end to World
War I. Do you know how that worked out? I suppose that the Virgin wasn't >>> up to that useful a miracle.
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:03:24 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:24:44 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran >>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have >>>>>>you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up >>>>solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time
instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify >>>what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima >>>people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Who refused them the courtesy?
Whoever told the girls what time the "miracle" was supposed to occur.
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 14:00:22 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:03:24 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:24:44 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran >>>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have >>>>>>>you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>>>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>>>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up >>>>>solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time >>>>>instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify >>>>what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima >>>>people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Who refused them the courtesy?
Whoever told the girls what time the "miracle" was supposed to occur.
I can never quite figure out whether you really believe the daft
arguments you put forward; or whether have a particular sense of
humour and are just trying to josh me; or whether you're taking on the
role of a Loki, putting forward arguments that you don't actually
believe but presenting them in such an extreme way that their
ridiculousness becomes self-evident.
Whichever it is, it serves a reasonably useful purpose in giving me a
vehicle to tease out further the original points I have made. The
usefulness, however, does reach a maximum point and I reckon we are
already beyond that point in this particular discussion.
[...]
On Tue, 03 Nov 2026 13:33:22 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 14:00:22 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:03:24 +0000, Martin Harran >>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:24:44 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran >>>>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>>>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have >>>>>>>>you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>>>>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>>>>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up >>>>>>solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time >>>>>>instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify >>>>>what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima >>>>>people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Who refused them the courtesy?
Whoever told the girls what time the "miracle" was supposed to occur.
I can never quite figure out whether you really believe the daft
arguments you put forward; or whether have a particular sense of
humour and are just trying to josh me; or whether you're taking on the
role of a Loki, putting forward arguments that you don't actually
believe but presenting them in such an extreme way that their >>ridiculousness becomes self-evident.
Whichever it is, it serves a reasonably useful purpose in giving me a >>vehicle to tease out further the original points I have made. The >>usefulness, however, does reach a maximum point and I reckon we are
already beyond that point in this particular discussion.
[...]
Are you or are you not claiming that there were girls who were
supernaturally told that there would be a miracle at noon on October
13, 1917?
On Tue, 03 Nov 2026 09:02:11 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Tue, 03 Nov 2026 13:33:22 +0000, Martin Harran
<martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 14:00:22 -0500, Vincent Maycock
<maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:03:24 +0000, Martin Harran >>>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 18:24:44 -0500, Vincent Maycock >>>>><maycock@gmail.com> wrote:
On Sun, 01 Nov 2026 17:37:57 +0000, Martin Harran >>>>>><martinharran@gmail.com> wrote:
[...]
What an incredibly weird question. I have never in my life met anyone >>>>>>>>>who thought noon was anything other than 12 midday local time. Have >>>>>>>>>you got a different understanding of it?
Yes, I've known that solar noon and local noon are not necessarily the >>>>>>>>same thing for many years, so at least some people are aware of the >>>>>>>>difference.
So, if I agreed to meet you next Thursday at noon, you would look up >>>>>>>solar noon at the place we are meeting and turn up at that time >>>>>>>instead of midday local time?
It would depend on the context. Probably I would ask you to clarify >>>>>>what you meant, if I thought I had to. Unfortunately for the Fatima >>>>>>people, they were evidently not granted that courtesy.
Who refused them the courtesy?
Whoever told the girls what time the "miracle" was supposed to occur.
I can never quite figure out whether you really believe the daft >>>arguments you put forward; or whether have a particular sense of
humour and are just trying to josh me; or whether you're taking on the >>>role of a Loki, putting forward arguments that you don't actually
believe but presenting them in such an extreme way that their >>>ridiculousness becomes self-evident.
Whichever it is, it serves a reasonably useful purpose in giving me a >>>vehicle to tease out further the original points I have made. The >>>usefulness, however, does reach a maximum point and I reckon we are >>>already beyond that point in this particular discussion.
[...]
Are you or are you not claiming that there were girls who were >>supernaturally told that there would be a miracle at noon on October
13, 1917?
I'm have not made *any* claims
and I really wish you would drop this
irritating habit of ignoring what I did say and trying to make out
that I said something else.
For clarity yet again, I simply pointed out in response to Mark Issak
that the children announced in advance that the Lady had told
something miraculous would occur in 13 October.
On that date, thousands of people experienced a solar event and noneof the natural
explanations that have been offered stand up to scrutiny.
You and Harshman seem to want to dismiss it as some sort of
hallucination but make no attempt to explain why the hallucination
happened at solar noon instead of the anticipated time of midday and
how it was experienced by journalists who were there with the express
purpose of showing the reported visions as total nonsense.
On Mon, 2 Nov 2026 13:47:29 -0800, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/2/26 6:49 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 19:56:06 -0800, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 1:45 PM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 1 Nov 2026 11:42:57 -0800, John HarshmanYou strike me as a quite bitter and generally unpleasant person.
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 11/1/26 10:42 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:48:55 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:37 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
It's evidence that little girls do indeed make up shit like this. How >>>>>>>> was that unclear?
On Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:17:48 -0700, John Harshman
<john.harshman@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/30/26 6:56 PM, sticks wrote:That's on a par with claiming that the Piltdown Man undermines the >>>>>>>>> ToE.
Little girls don't just make up shit like this.I suggest that you look up the Cottingsly fairies, among others. >>>>>>>>>
There are some rather significant differences. The children in the >>>>>>> Cottingsly fairies story were middle class, educated children, the >>>>>>> oldest of whom had the photographic skills to create the hoax. The >>>>>>> Fatima children were uneducated peasant children who were unlikely to >>>>>>> even understand the concepts of the messages they were passing on; do >>>>>>> you seriously think that such children would have understood the >>>>>>> concept of "the Consecration of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of >>>>>>> Mary"?
Note that this bit post-dated the actual revelations by several decades, >>>>>> and was recalled and communicated by one of the girls grown up. Anyway, >>>>>> are lower-class children supposed to be stupid? Are the Irish this >>>>>> devoted to class prejudice? I hadn't known.
The Irish are clever enough to understand the difference between
stupidity and lack of education. Apparently you are not that clever, >>>>> you think that somebody not understanding something means they are
stupid.
So says the guy who disparaged the Irish people as devoted to class
prejudice; then, when he realised I was right in what I had said,
instead of withdrawing the disparagement, decided to attack me with a
personal insult. I think you would do well to invest in a good mirror.
I'm willing to believe that this is just your internet persona and that
you aren't like this in person. You continue to ignore the substance of
the discussion; that's another unpleasant feature of your persona.
I don't see much point in trying to have a sensible discussion with
someone who reckons that disparaging not just me personally, but the
whole Irish nation is an acceptable form of debate. Keep going,
however, you are doing a fine job showing where the unpleasantness is
really coming from.
But
doubtless that's just your internet persona. OK, so they're not stupid, >>>> just very, very ignorant. But let's remember that the bit you claimed
they wouldn't understand was not mentioned until many years later, when >>>> perhaps the ignorant girls had learned a thing or two.
Also, the girls were instructed to pray the rosary for an end to World >>>> War I. Do you know how that worked out? I suppose that the Virgin wasn't >>>> up to that useful a miracle.
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak <specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid
evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to
get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad design
argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are easily
answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is simply
no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design involved.
From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and extremely
complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks like
something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If
you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have
learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product
less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get
all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of
life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things
makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same
fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to
it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the
rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run
the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want
such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple
as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else. You
can change your car's tires without needing to worry about transplant
rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by
Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't
work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one
single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks evolved,
but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear that life is
not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist Linnaeus
in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100 years later.
Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting focus to something
else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
On 10/27/26 7:42 AM, sticks wrote:
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to
get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad
design argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are
easily answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is
simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design
involved. From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and
extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks
like something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If
you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have
learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product
less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get
all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of
life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things
makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same
fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to
it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the
rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run
the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want
such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple
as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else.
You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about
transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by
Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't
work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one
single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks
evolved, but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear
that life is not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100
years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel
that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting
focus to something else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence for common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but someone who
had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out his supporting
his own biases, don't you think?
On 11/3/2026 5:18 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/27/26 7:42 AM, sticks wrote:
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to >>>>> get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad
design argument.a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are
easily answered.a But when you get down to the cell level, there is >>>>> simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design
involved. From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and >>>>> extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks
like something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If
you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have
learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product
less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get >>>> all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of
life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things >>>> makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same >>>> fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to >>>> it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the
rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run
the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want >>>> such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple >>>> as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else.
You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about
transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by
Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't
work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one
single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks
evolved, but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear
that life is not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100
years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel
that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting
focus to something else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence for
common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but someone who
had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out his supporting
his own biases, don't you think?
Hilarious. I hope MarkE notices he doubles down on this meaningless
drivel effectively ignoring the information problem which he refuses to >address other than saying copying is generating new information.
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just
basic common sense. ItAs exactly how any intelligent mind organizes a >complex system. A nested hierarchy fits a creation/design model just as >easily as it fits an evolution model. All it proves is that life is
highly organized.
Shifting the argument to Linnaeus's history is just the usual boring
tactic to avoid answering the actual question. He has no answer for the >origin of the information itself.
On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 17:48:40 -0600, sticks <wolverine01@charter.net>
wrote:
On 11/3/2026 5:18 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/27/26 7:42 AM, sticks wrote:
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to >>>>>> get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad
design argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are
easily answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is >>>>>> simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design
involved. From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and >>>>>> extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks >>>>>> like something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If
you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have
learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product >>>>> less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get >>>>> all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of
life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things >>>>> makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same >>>>> fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to >>>>> it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the
rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run >>>>> the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want >>>>> such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple >>>>> as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else.
You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about
transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by >>>>> Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't
work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one
single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks
evolved, but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear
that life is not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100
years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel
that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting
focus to something else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence for
common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but someone who
had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out his supporting
his own biases, don't you think?
Hilarious. I hope MarkE notices he doubles down on this meaningless
drivel effectively ignoring the information problem which he refuses to
address other than saying copying is generating new information.
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just
basic common sense. ItrCOs exactly how any intelligent mind organizes a
complex system. A nested hierarchy fits a creation/design model just as
easily as it fits an evolution model. All it proves is that life is
highly organized.
Shifting the argument to Linnaeus's history is just the usual boring
tactic to avoid answering the actual question. He has no answer for the
origin of the information itself.
Regarding the types of classification systems a Creator had available
to him (notice that it's not just a nested hierarchy!)
From:
https://www.studocu.com/en-za/messages/question/12144514/explain-different-types-of-classification-systems-25
Types of Classification Systems
On 11/3/2026 8:00 PM, Vincent Maycock wrote:Yes; telling.
On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 17:48:40 -0600, sticks <wolverine01@charter.net>
wrote:
On 11/3/2026 5:18 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/27/26 7:42 AM, sticks wrote:
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to >>>>>>> get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad
design argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are >>>>>>> easily answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is >>>>>>> simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design
involved. From the living machines in the cell, to the code like and >>>>>>> extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly looks >>>>>>> like something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad >>>>>> design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If >>>>>> you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have >>>>>> learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product >>>>>> less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can get >>>>>> all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true of >>>>>> life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some things >>>>>> makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the same >>>>>> fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make changes to >>>>>> it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw out the
rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run >>>>>> the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would want >>>>>> such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as simple >>>>>> as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything else. >>>>>> You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about
transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by >>>>>> Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't >>>>>> work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one >>>>>> single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks
evolved, but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear
that life is not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100 >>>>> years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel >>>>> that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting
focus to something else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence for >>>> common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but someone who >>>> had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out his supporting >>>> his own biases, don't you think?
Hilarious.-a I hope MarkE notices he doubles down on this meaningless
drivel effectively ignoring the information problem which he refuses to
address other than saying copying is generating new information.
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just
basic common sense.-a ItrCOs exactly how any intelligent mind organizes a >>> complex system. A nested hierarchy fits a creation/design model just as
easily as it fits an evolution model. All it proves is that life is
highly organized.
Shifting the argument to Linnaeus's history is just the usual boring
tactic to avoid answering the actual question. He has no answer for the
origin of the information itself.
Regarding the types of classification systems a Creator had available
to him (notice that it's not just a nested hierarchy!)
From:
https://www.studocu.com/en-za/messages/question/12144514/explain-
different-types-of-classification-systems-25
Types of Classification Systems
Sorry MarkE.-a Looks like nobody wants to address your actual question, preferring instead to focus on this incredibly important issue.-a Funny though.
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
In my childhood, I read a book on UFOs, and amid all the unexplained >sightings it talked about, it also told, in some detail, of a fairly >elaborate UFO hoax and how it was done. Fifteen or twenty years later, I >heard someone on the radio talking about a UFO encounter with many
witnesses that had "never been explained." He went on to describe the
hoaxed encounter I had read about.
So when you say, "numerous examples
that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation
found", my first thought is to wonder how many material explanations
have been found for them, but whose explanations are languishing on
unknown shelves or where people simply don't want to look. A sizeable >proportion, I would bet.
In regard to the Fatima miracle in particular: The phenomenon of a
steady light in the sky appearing to dance around is well known. I
believe it is a consequence of the eye's saccades and a featureless >background. There is nothing miraculous about it. I don't know about the >multicolored beams, but neither have I done research on the effects of >staring at the sun. It is also possible that that was a detail added for >one-upsmanship by people trying to make their story of the experience
more interesting than the last one. Obviously the sun did not actually
do anything unusual, or the event would have been reported around half
the world, not at a single location in Portugal.
Another possibility--and it is a possibility for virtually any
unexplained event--is that the entire story is fictional. No, I don't >believe that is the most plausible explanation for the Fatima miracle,
but I *do* believe it is not only plausible but likely that fictional >details have been added to the story in the century since the original >events took place. Folklore works that way.
And, of course, Hume's essay "On Miracles" is as relevant today as it
was when it was first published.
On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 15:02:13 -0800, Mark Isaak <specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced
the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams
of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its
original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the
Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no
explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal
at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban
the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle
on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at
noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM
that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
In my childhood, I read a book on UFOs, and amid all the unexplained
sightings it talked about, it also told, in some detail, of a fairly
elaborate UFO hoax and how it was done. Fifteen or twenty years later, I
heard someone on the radio talking about a UFO encounter with many
witnesses that had "never been explained." He went on to describe the
hoaxed encounter I had read about.
If the best you can come up with is a vaguely remembered childhood
story and an equally vague recollection of somebody some time talking
about a hoax, you would probably have been better to offer nothing at
all. Perhaps my own memory is faulty but I seem to recall you in the
past dismissing anecdotal evidence as having any particular value -
indeed, that is pretty much what you do below when you suggest
fictional details might have been added to the Fatima account.
So when you say, "numerous examples
that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation
found", my first thought is to wonder how many material explanations
have been found for them, but whose explanations are languishing on
unknown shelves or where people simply don't want to look. A sizeable
proportion, I would bet.
Bearing in mind the amount of investigation that has gone on to Fatima
and other claimed miracles both by believers and by sceptics, I would
be most surprised if there were explanations languishing on unknown
shelves. It sounds like wishful thinking on your part.
In regard to the Fatima miracle in particular: The phenomenon of a
steady light in the sky appearing to dance around is well known. I
believe it is a consequence of the eye's saccades and a featureless
background. There is nothing miraculous about it. I don't know about the
multicolored beams, but neither have I done research on the effects of
staring at the sun. It is also possible that that was a detail added for
one-upsmanship by people trying to make their story of the experience
more interesting than the last one. Obviously the sun did not actually
do anything unusual, or the event would have been reported around half
the world, not at a single location in Portugal.
Another possibility--and it is a possibility for virtually any
unexplained event--is that the entire story is fictional. No, I don't
believe that is the most plausible explanation for the Fatima miracle,
but I *do* believe it is not only plausible but likely that fictional
details have been added to the story in the century since the original
events took place. Folklore works that way.
What makes Fatima different is the fact that it was announced in
advance and the events of the day were documented at the time,
including documentation by trained reporters and journalists who were virulently opposed to religion and were at Fatima with the express
objective of showing the whole thing to be a load of nonsense. That is
about as far from folklore as you can get.
And, of course, Hume's essay "On Miracles" is as relevant today as it
was when it was first published.
It never fails to amuse me that people who insist on scientific
evidence are quite happy to turn to a philosopher when that
philosopher agrees with their own worldview.
On 11/3/2026 5:18 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/27/26 7:42 AM, sticks wrote:
On 10/25/2026 10:46 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
On 10/14/26 3:27 PM, sticks wrote:
Then he again appears to shift from considering the requirements to >>>>> get life from the first cell, to claiming the old worn out bad
design argument.-a Every one of those I've seen if you dig in are
easily answered.-a But when you get down to the cell level, there is >>>>> simply no mistaking the perfection and engineering like design
involved. From the living machines in the cell, to the code like
and extremely complex specified information of DNA, it certainly
looks like something that was designed.
I forgot to address this point. My argument is not that life is bad
design, but that it is qualitatively *different* design than that
produced by people.
Life does not produce perfection, and neither does human design. If
you had ever studied design, one of the first thing you would have
learned is that there are always trade-offs. Do you want the product
less expensive, better quality, or faster? There's no way you can
get all three, and often not even two out of three. The same is true
of life; the strategy that makes a plant or animal better at some
things makes it worse at other things.
Life looks designed in many ways because life and design use the
same fundamental process: evolution. Start with something, make
changes to it, test which changes work, keep those changes and throw
out the rest. But human design differs in three main ways.
First, we do away with sexual reproduction and make things in
factories instead. It's very expensive to make a wristwatch which
needs to have the abilities to periodically leave your wrist to
acquire raw materials and process them itself into the energy to run
the watch and to produce other watches. And I doubt anyone would
want such a watch.
Second, humans, being relatively stupid, try to keep things as
simple as possible, so we try to avoid parts that affect everything
else. You can change your car's tires without needing to worry about
transplant rejections.
Third, life arranges into a natural hierarchy, as first put forth by
Linnaeus. That's a consequence of common descent. Our designs don't
work the same way, because we make new designs not by modifying one
single precursor design, but by taking ideas from everywhere.
So yes, life *does* look designed to the extent that it looks
evolved, but it differs in fundamental aspects that make it clear
that life is not the product of design as we understand the term.
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over 100
years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up drivel
that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and shifting
focus to something else, even though he claims to be addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence for
common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but someone
who had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out his
supporting his own biases, don't you think?
Hilarious.-a I hope MarkE notices he doubles down on this meaningless
drivel effectively ignoring the information problem which he refuses to address other than saying copying is generating new information.
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just
basic common sense.
On 11/5/26 2:26 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
Bearing in mind the amount of investigation that has gone on to Fatima
and other claimed miracles both by believers and by sceptics, I would
be most surprised if there were explanations languishing on unknown
shelves. It sounds like wishful thinking on your part.
You yourself demonstrated the truth of my point. The most prominent part
of the miracle has an obvious (to me) mundane explanation: the
autokinetic effect. Yet you never mentioned it. Nor does the Wikipedia article on the Fatima miracle mention it. I have not looked further, but
I assume you have, and apparently you had not encountered that
explanation before.
The Wikipedia page says 50,000 to 70,000 people were gathered. You would
not get that sizeable a gathering unless thousands of people were eager
to see a miracle. If you tell 50,000 people that they will see something strange if they stare at the sun, I guarantee at least a couple dozen
will see strange things, especially since that is what most of them want
to see. And reporters make their living by reporting strange things.
Apparently, many of the accounts of the miracle were collected 15 to 33 years after the event. It takes less than a day for folkloric elements
to enter a story. In fact, I suspect your "virulently opposed to
religion" comments are a folkloric addition. Portugal has never been an atheistic country, and it is virtually certain that most of the
reporters of the miracle were Christians themselves.
And, of course, Hume's essay "On Miracles" is as relevant today as it
was when it was first published.
It never fails to amuse me that people who insist on scientific
evidence are quite happy to turn to a philosopher when that
philosopher agrees with their own worldview.
I note you give no reason to disagree with Hume.
On 11/5/26 2:26 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Tue, 3 Nov 2026 15:02:13 -0800, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
On 10/30/26 3:17 AM, Martin Harran wrote:
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 20:16:34 -0700, Mark Isaak
<specimenNOSPAM@curioustaxon.omy.net> wrote:
[...]
Can a single honest example be shown of a *non*-material cause of
*anything*? Anything at all? Lots of claims, not a single bit of solid >>>>> evidence.
There are numerous examples of individual happenings that have been
thoroughly investigated and no material explanation found.
The Miracle of the Sun at Fatima in Portugal is just one example. The
background to this was that between May and October 1917, three young
children in Fatima claimed to have had several visions of a woman
surrounded by light who identified herself as the Lady of the Rosary.
In one of the visions, they claimed the lady said that she would
reveal her identity and perform a miracle on 13 October that year "so
that all may believe."
On 13 October, a large crowd, generally estimated at 70,000, gathered
at the site in anticipation of the miracle where the crowd experienced >>>> the sun appearing to dance in the sky, sending out multicoloured beams >>>> of light and careering towards the earth before zigzagging back to its >>>> original position.
There have been numerous "natural" explanations put forward which
really fall into three categories - a localised cosmic event, a hoax
or mass hallucination. None of those explanations stand up to
scrutiny. There is no astronomical evidence to support a localised
cosmic and although the event was mostly localised to a small area
around Fatima, the Pope reported that he experienced it walking in the >>>> Vatican gardens just over a thousand miles away. Also, there are is no >>>> explanation offered as to how the children knew in advance that this
event, unknown to astronomers, would occur.
In regard to a hoax, nobody has been able to offer a suggestion as to
how the light effects were achieved.
In regard to mass hallucination, this is always found in small
cohesive groups of people, not among many thousands of strangers. In
addition to that, there was strong anti-religious feelings in Portugal >>>> at that time and there had been widespread attacks in the media about
what had been happening at Fatima with calls for the government to ban >>>> the assembly; there were many reporters present at the events who
experienced them so the hallucination suggestion has to embrace those
who were vehemently opposed to the whole idea.
All of these shortcomings, however, are overridden by another feature
of what happened. When the children announced there would be a miracle >>>> on 13th of October, they claimed that the lady said it would happen at >>>> noon. It actually happened at 1:20 PM. Initially this was seen as not
particularly significant until it was realised afterwards that 1:20 PM >>>> that day was the exact time of Solar Noon in Fatima. So, if it was a
hoax, why did the hoaxers arrange it for a different time from what
people were expecting? If it was hallucination, why do people imagine
it at a different time from what they expected?
None of these natural explanations work; can you suggest any other?
In my childhood, I read a book on UFOs, and amid all the unexplained
sightings it talked about, it also told, in some detail, of a fairly
elaborate UFO hoax and how it was done. Fifteen or twenty years later, I >>> heard someone on the radio talking about a UFO encounter with many
witnesses that had "never been explained." He went on to describe the
hoaxed encounter I had read about.
If the best you can come up with is a vaguely remembered childhood
story and an equally vague recollection of somebody some time talking
about a hoax, you would probably have been better to offer nothing at
all. Perhaps my own memory is faulty but I seem to recall you in the
past dismissing anecdotal evidence as having any particular value -
indeed, that is pretty much what you do below when you suggest
fictional details might have been added to the Fatima account.
So when you say, "numerous examples
that have been thoroughly investigated and no material explanation
found", my first thought is to wonder how many material explanations
have been found for them, but whose explanations are languishing on
unknown shelves or where people simply don't want to look. A sizeable
proportion, I would bet.
Bearing in mind the amount of investigation that has gone on to Fatima
and other claimed miracles both by believers and by sceptics, I would
be most surprised if there were explanations languishing on unknown
shelves. It sounds like wishful thinking on your part.
You yourself demonstrated the truth of my point. The most prominent part
of the miracle has an obvious (to me) mundane explanation: the
autokinetic effect. Yet you never mentioned it. Nor does the Wikipedia >article on the Fatima miracle mention it. I have not looked further, but
I assume you have, and apparently you had not encountered that
explanation before.
In regard to the Fatima miracle in particular: The phenomenon of a
steady light in the sky appearing to dance around is well known. I
believe it is a consequence of the eye's saccades and a featureless
background. There is nothing miraculous about it. I don't know about the >>> multicolored beams, but neither have I done research on the effects of
staring at the sun. It is also possible that that was a detail added for >>> one-upsmanship by people trying to make their story of the experience
more interesting than the last one. Obviously the sun did not actually
do anything unusual, or the event would have been reported around half
the world, not at a single location in Portugal.
Another possibility--and it is a possibility for virtually any
unexplained event--is that the entire story is fictional. No, I don't
believe that is the most plausible explanation for the Fatima miracle,
but I *do* believe it is not only plausible but likely that fictional
details have been added to the story in the century since the original
events took place. Folklore works that way.
What makes Fatima different is the fact that it was announced in
advance and the events of the day were documented at the time,
including documentation by trained reporters and journalists who were
virulently opposed to religion and were at Fatima with the express
objective of showing the whole thing to be a load of nonsense. That is
about as far from folklore as you can get.
The Wikipedia page says 50,000 to 70,000 people were gathered. You would
not get that sizeable a gathering unless thousands of people were eager
to see a miracle. If you tell 50,000 people that they will see something >strange if they stare at the sun, I guarantee at least a couple dozen
will see strange things, especially since that is what most of them want
to see. And reporters make their living by reporting strange things.
Apparently, many of the accounts of the miracle were collected 15 to 33 >years after the event. It takes less than a day for folkloric elements
to enter a story. In fact, I suspect your "virulently opposed to
religion" comments are a folkloric addition. Portugal has never been an >atheistic country, and it is virtually certain that most of the
reporters of the miracle were Christians themselves.
And, of course, Hume's essay "On Miracles" is as relevant today as it
was when it was first published.
It never fails to amuse me that people who insist on scientific
evidence are quite happy to turn to a philosopher when that
philosopher agrees with their own worldview.
I note you give no reason to disagree with Hume.
On 08/10/2026 11:59, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
Do you not understand the difference between a claim that spontaneous abiogenesis is impossible and a claim that material causes cannot
produce large amounts of specified information? If only abiogenesis qualifies as the production of large amounts of specified information Meyer's premise 2 would be false.
"X-ray of life: Volume I: From Prebiotic Chemistry to Cells"
On Thu, 8 Oct 2026 22:03:51 +0100
Ernest Major <{$to$}@meden.demon.co.uk> wrote:
On 08/10/2026 11:59, MarkE wrote:
On 8/10/2026 8:19 am, Ernest Major wrote:
Premise Two: Material causes have demonstrated the power to produce
large amounts of specified information.
Scientific evidence increasingly suggests otherwise:
Do you not understand the difference between a claim that spontaneous
abiogenesis is impossible and a claim that material causes cannot
produce large amounts of specified information? If only abiogenesis
qualifies as the production of large amounts of specified information
Meyer's premise 2 would be false.
"X-ray of life: Volume I: From Prebiotic Chemistry to Cells"
Otangelo Grasso is a Swiss-Italian author, apologist, and prominent
advocate for **Intelligent Design** and **Young Earth Creationism**
On 11/3/26 3:48 PM, sticks wrote:
On 11/3/2026 5:18 PM, Mark Isaak wrote:
This is quite amusing.-a Isaak attempts to place the creationist
Linnaeus in the equation as a supporter of common descent.-a He
naturally fails to mention that idea was put forth by Darwin over
100 years later. Basically, the whole post is simply more made up
drivel that employs the usual tactic of ignoring the question and
shifting focus to something else, even though he claims to be
addressing it.
In fact, I find it particularly significant that the best evidence
for common descent was supplied, and supplied voluminously, but
someone who had never heard of common descent. Pretty much rules out
his supporting his own biases, don't you think?
Hilarious.-a I hope MarkE notices he doubles down on this meaningless
drivel effectively ignoring the information problem which he refuses
to address other than saying copying is generating new information.
Copying does not generate new information to any significant degree. If
I have a ten gigabyte file, and I make a copy of it, I have created only
one bit of new information. What copying explains is where the
"specified" in "complex specified information" comes from.
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just
basic common sense.
That's not a fact; it is a lie. Before Linnaeus, what classification
there was was haphazard, organized mostly by geography and/or what the
plant was useful for. Yes, there were some broad categories (e.g.
"grass", "daisy"), but often these had little or no relationship with
common descent (e.g. "forb", "tree").
The fact that Linnaeus grouped life by structural categories is just basic common sense. ItrCOs exactly how any intelligent mind organizes a complex system. A nested hierarchy fits a creation/design model just as easily as it fits an evolution model. All it proves is that life is highly organized.--
Shifting the argument to Linnaeus's history is just the usual boring tactic to avoid answering the actual question. He has no answer for the origin of the information itself.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:34:23 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |